Question Locked

8600gt 512mb or 8600gts 256mb

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok, since I am having great luck with the one question I've asked so far I thought I'd give this one a run here. I'm looking to upgrade my current video from the onboard to something for modern games, like Tabula Rasa.

I've doen some shopping and reading reviews, but I'm not tech savvy enough to crunch the numbers on which of these will do me the best. I'm between an EVGA 8600gt 512mb or an EVGA 8600gts 256mb. My system is an Athlon 64 3700+ 2.2ghz, 2.5gig pc3200 generic RAM. I'm upgrading to a 400w power supply to handle either card better, but I'm just not sure which one is better here.

Is this a case of more video memory is better, or am I better off with the faster processor and memory speed? Appreciate your thoughts and guidance

4 replies

by thumbsup2

More video ram will almost always give you better performance than less video ram. However, be sure to read the reviews for the cards to see if anyone is having difficulties with either of them, especially with games. And, go to the game web sites and check to see if anyone THERE is having difficulties with the cards. Not all video drivers work with all games or maybe there's a game patch specific to a particular card. You may save yourself a lot of trouble later if you check out the cards performance before you decide which one to buy.

---

by shady108

since ATI and AMD are now sleeping with each other, i would take a serious look at ATI cards....... ive always gone for AMD and ATI over INTEL and NVIDIA :-)

if your looking for peformance, a good thing to look at would be the core speed, ram speed and the number of pipelines. the more pipelines on the card the faster :)

before u decide read this -

http://enthusiast.hardocp.com/article.html?art=MTQxOSwxLCxoZW50aHVzaWFzdA==

look into Radeon HD 3870 XT now thats a graphics card! :)

by jamesrl

His website has tools to allow you to benchmark one against the other.

http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics_2007.html?modelx=33&model1=854&model2=855&chart=311

Personally as a gamer, I disagree with thumbs, more GPU (graphics processor) is preferable to more RAM in most situations.

But of course the devil is in the details. If the GTS is only very slightly faster, and you play the kind of games that can actually utilize 512 mb of VRAM, then you may be better off.

The benchmark I chose from Toms shows a pretty big gap between a GTS and GT with the same amount of RAM (1238 versus 1023 3D Marko6 score at 1600x1200 resolution). The gap between a GTS with 246 and a GTS with 512 is 1290 versus 1238). They didn't have a benchmark for a GT with 512.

And as a plug the new ATI 3850 (with 256) on the same benchmark scores 2173 and you can find them for $169 at newegg.com versus $149 for an 8600 GT with 512. That would be my recommendation in that price range.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.