Discussion Locked

A Sad Day for Israel

0 helpful
201 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

201 replies

by Member 25348569

because we believe that our Imaginary Being tells us to (unless, of course, we're schizophrenic). Or because we believe in a different Imaginary Being to you. Or that we believe that OUR interpretation of the writings of our common Imaginary Being is the only correct version.

Trust me, Atheists don't kill BECAUSE they are atheists. They need to find another reason.

Being human, that's pretty easy, though.

:)

by charliespencer

But I think the number of atheists who kill over differing beliefs is far smaller than those who kill because they feel their religion doesn't tolerate differing beliefs.

by charliespencer

One group's sad day is another group's happy one. Another example of the equality of the Internet.

Disclaimer: I don't care about either side in this debate.

by sleepin'dawg

the drug induced delusional halucinations of a carpet merchant, especially one who was considered raving mad but then isn't Christianity based upon the teachings of a failed carpenter. At least he was an advocate of peace and love unlike Mohamed who advocates murder and mayhem. If you don't believe that, read the Queran or Koran.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by w2ktechman

"I made the point that serious Jewish immigration into the area started late in the 18th Century and that there was, relatively speaking, very few Jews in the are until then. I hold to that point."

Ok, lets look at some history now
http://www.palestinefacts.org/pf_early_palestine_israel_antiquity.php

What? Ancient Egypt laid waste to Israel in 1210 BC? I think that is a bit older than the 18th century

http://www.palestinefacts.org/pf_early_palestine_first_jews.php

Ok, Ok, so what you mean is they were kicked out, and in the 18th century started to return. However, there were more than a mere handful.

Also, I ran into this piece (link after) which I thought interesting, since often you bring up the land stealing, and evicting people. I wonder where those tactics came from?

" Zionism was further fueled by continuing episodes of anti-Semitism, which included the slaughter of Jews and confiscation of their property, and which rose in frequency and intensity in the 19th century."

http://www.palestinefacts.org/pf_early_palestine_zionism.php

by jdclyde

for option three to come along.

I don't see it in the post that started this thread, but a very biased and distorted view, intentionally leaving a lot out.

by jdclyde

Are you saying the arab nations can't out-spend the US in this case?

Are you saying that the nations in the middle east are anything BUT brutal?

by Member 25348569

has more money than they have any idea what to do with. They would represent the biggest danger to Israel if the general ideas about "all Muslims" is true but we hear little from SA and likely wont unless an anti-West regime takes over.

Throughout this thread, I've been searching for answers. I have some - I think - but there is loads of stuff about the US relationship with Israel that I don't know. I would be interested in what game you think that the US is playing when you consider that they have given as much military aid to Egypt as they have given to Israel. I didn't know this until about five minutes ago.

As far as I can make out, there has been a tacit understanding between Israel and the United States for at least the last decade that while the U.S. may supply the same planes, tanks, or ships to both Israel and its potential enemies, Israel was to preserve its edge by the weapons systems aboard those platforms - better missiles, electronic warfare capabilities and computers.

What game are you playing?

by jdclyde

Sorry, I don't recall Israel military rounding up and executing anyone that isn't a Jew.

If you are going to make a statement, stay away from intentionally inflammatory words that do not fit the situation, just to push your own agenda.

by jdclyde

No civilized nation should EVER "take it on the chin".

When there is a cease fire, who is it that breaks it?

Hezbollah intentionally puts the citizens at risk, but you blame Israel for shooting back. Hezbollah is not the innocent here, but the aggressor.

by jellimonsta

I spent the first 21 years of my life in lovely Wolverhampton. Believe me, I have never spoken English!! :p :D

by the 'g-man.'

Of a post on a Technical Website called Techrepublic? Besides I have other things to worry about than the state of another country and it's wars - like my own and it's!

by jdclyde

Was/is it concern for Palestine that feeds this still, or hate for Israel?

Always seemed like more of the later than the former....

by jdclyde

I remember reading how "we" played both sides of that. Both sides were helped, but only enough to ensure a stale-mate because "we" didn't want EITHER nation to take over the other.

Way to much "enemy of my enemy is my friend" crap through out the ages. Why I am to the point I don't give a ratsass about what happened 50 years ago, and who did what then. If everyone was wrong, frig it.

I care about NOW, and what can happen NOW.

I do question how Israel responding to attacks on citizens is Israel being the brutal one's here. Who is it INTENTIONALLY targeting citizens? Who is putting citizens in the crosshairs by intentionally and cowardly hiding among them, HOPING for civilian deaths to gain false sympathy?

Sorry, but it is clear to me who is "brutal" here.

by Member 25348569

is what I've been saying throughout the thread.

Israel goes after those it believes to be Palestinian and Hezbollah terrorists with complete disregard for potential or actual civilian casualties.

In the recent Lebanese "war", statements from Israeli government officials and military leaders suggested that the IDF blurred the distinction between civilians and combatants - or didn't care.

Their argument was that only people associated with Hezbollah remain in southern Lebanon, so all were legitimate targets of attack. What they totally ignored was that their immediate attacks totally trashed the infrastructure and that most Lebanese civilians were unable to get out because they were sick, wounded, did not have the means to leave or were providing essential civil services.

Every single human rights organization that visited the area issued reports stating that the Israeli government and its forces seem to target civilians and exhibit reckless disregard for human life. Not one human rights non-governmental organization agreed with Israeli government statements that they are careful not to kill civilians and that civilians killed are "accidental". In the two years 2006 to 2007 over 3700 Palestinian civilians were killed by Israeli forces including over 700 children.

http://64.226.129.19/pmw/manager/features/display_message.asp?mid=487

by jdclyde

First of all, for a reporter/writer, Mr. HEDGES seems to be a horrible speaker. And yes, it has seemed clear for a long time that the youth have been indoctrinated into a life of nothing but hate and death. This mindwashing of an overbreeding population is not something that will be controlled by anything but a greater force, like Saddam showed in Iraq. Being a nice guy does nothing but get you and yours killed.

Second, when a rocket is fired, what is Israel to do? Nothing?

by tony hopkinson

Given the murder and mayhem christianity has engendered, they can pat themselves on the back for not being total hypocrites.

by charliespencer

As I noted earlier, my personal opinion is that it's all rooted in religious beliefs. As an atheist, I'm unqualified to regard one set of beliefs as more valid than another. I view the basic positions of both sides as unsupportable. Geez, the damn land will barely support agriculture.

by jdclyde

As it has been shown over and over again, that once it gets down to just muslims, they will gleefully go about eradicating anyone that is the wrong flavor of islam...

Being Jewish is a greater crime than being the wrong flavor, and the Palestinians are disposable.

by john.a.wills

is the Zionist hate for the Palestinians. When the Zionists stop hating, there will be peace because when they stop hating there will be repatriation and restituion in accord with the Jewish mitzvah "lo tignov" (Dt 5:19).

by john.a.wills

There follows one very influential line of argument which makes many USAmericans pro-Zionist.
1. God gave the Holy Land to the Israelites.
2. The Israelites are a nation.
3. The Israelis are the national descendants of the Biblical Israelites.
4. The Israeli conquest is thus a divinely sanctioned reconquest.
5. When the Israeli(te)s are safe in their own land Jesus will come again.
Now, my comments.
#2 is contrary to Nm 23:9: Israel is a church, not a nation.
#3 is historical hogwash: the ancestors of the Israelis can trace their faith to various conversions. The nearest the Biblical Israelites have to a national descent is the Palestinian nation.
#5 is not known to me from the Bible.

by charliespencer

To me it's a word that's been tossed about in so many different connotations that I find it as jingoistic as 'Homeland'. I avoid using it because I find it doesn't mean the same thing to everyone that uses it (unlike 'red' or 'ocean').

by john.a.wills

I seem to be the one who has used the word most, so I'll make an attempt.

Zionism is the work planned by the World Zionist Organization and its supporting organizations such as Qeren Qayemeth leIsrael(also called Jewish National Fund) and the Jewish Agency for Israel(formerly called the Jewish Agency for Palestine).

That isn't very good, but it's probably good enough for most of this discussion so far. I give a better but longer one in a book I'm not supposed to mention.

by w2ktechman

"The Israelites are a nation."
"#2 is contrary to Nm 23:9: Israel is a church, not a nation."

Israelites are not a nation, they are/were a peoples.
As far as Israel being a chuch and thats it, may be a bad statement. Just because 1 source (not always accurate either) states it, does not mean it was always that way.

Quoted from the site here

http://www.palestinefacts.org/pf_early_palestine_original_people.php

"The Biblical account continues with the rise of an Israelite kingdom, first under Saul and then under David at about 1000 BC, the date of David's conquest of Jerusalem.

The biblical accounts have not been confirmed by archeology and the exact dividing line between myth, legend, and history remains unknown. Generally the historical record begins with the destruction of the northern Israelite capital at Samaria in 772 BC by Assyrians, and the conquering of Judah's (southern Israelites) capital at Jerusalem in 586 BC by Babylonians who destroyed the First Temple."

That tells me that Israel was a Nation/Kingdom that ruled the area over 1,000 years ago.
A couple of years ago I found a site that had maps and a timeline for many events in Palstine history, and it was very similar.

Even earlier than that there are records that Egypt anhialated Israel, which also suggests that they were a nation that threatened the mighty Egypt.

#3 -- Do you have any proof that the ancestors of Israel (Southern Israel was Jewish btw, at Jerusalem) is not the modern day Jews?

As for the rest, personally, it is not my history so I can care less. The actions of today and moving forward are where my attention is peaked. I dont care if their god gave them the land, or if temples are/were there, nor do I care if they believe that Jesus will return or how.

by john.a.wills

You are confusing nation and state. The Israelite states were ecclesial, not national. The Bible is pretty consistent in its use of the word "goy" (nation) in contrast to Israel, or for Israel when God is annoyed with it.
Any history of Russia should tell you about the conversion of the Khazars to Rabbinical Judaism and of their empire. Two letters of the Cyrillic alphabet are from the Hebrew alphabet, and the first Polish coins were inscribed in Hebrew as well as Roman letters. The Ashkenazim are basically descended from the Khazars and their subjects, which is why so many Israelis are blond: they are Slavs or Teutons. A brief history of the Khazar Empire is given in Koestler: The Thirteenth Tribe.
And you may not care about Jesus returning, but many U.S. Fundamentalists do, and that is important.

by sleepin'dawg

The idea is to maintain an equilibrium by preventing any one nation being able to overwhelm its neighbors. During the age of nuclear power this came to be known as MAD or [i]Mutually Assured Destruction[/i]. Don't you just love acronyms.

The Israelis are not totally reliant on the US for their technology, witness the co-operation between Israel and South Africa in the development of the Kfir fighter and other weaponry.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

who the aggressors are just about daily...

The only piece offered to the Israelis is that of the grave.

Yeah, back to "The Zionists" again, huh?

What is your agenda? You have weakly claimed you are not anti-Israel, yet your every post says otherwise.

by sleepin'dawg

If an "innocent civilian" population stands idly by and permits terrorist organizations to exist within their midst they can only expect and get what they deserve. As you just pointed out in another post there are many matters of which you were and are, unaware. I doubt you have ever been there but as someone who has I can only say your observations and opinions are warped to the extreme and are seriously in error. Israel isn't totally innocent but in comparison to Fatah, Hamas, and Hezbollah, they appear as choirboys. BTW choice locations for Hamas or Hezbollah are similar to the locations Fatah used to use and that is usually next to schools and hospitals.

I find it hard to believe that there still exists any sympathy for Islamic Palestinian terrorists in light of the recent terrorist attacks within the UK, whether or not they were Palestinian in origin or not. Your goverment permitted the import of Islamic cheap labour and is now having to pay the price of having them in your nation.

Wasn't it an Englishman who stated that people only get the type of government they deserve. I doubt he would have had organizations such as Hezbollah or Hamas in mind.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by tonythetiger

want Israel to remain where it is for as much of forever as possible. They surely prefer hating and killing a few Israeli, than hating and killing each other!

by jdclyde

Just like they continually try to paint the US as anti-muslim.

Many weak minded fools in the world believe it.

by Member 25348569

How do I get it through to you and just about everyone else here that I am NOT offering support for terrorist groups. What I AM doing is withholding my support from Israel.

I am criticising Israel. I used to be a supporter of the State but, over the past decade, their actions have made me feel increasingly queasy. They are the masters of the pre-emptive strike.

Regardless of the provocation, the response of Israel was and is always one of massive overreaction. This then obviously - why can none of you see it? - brings about a reaction from the Palestinians. As there is very little that the Palestinians can do, hemmed in as they are with all of their resources under Israel's control, they throw rocks at tanks and troops with guns and blow themselves up.

If you can't begin to grasp the circumstances that could bring someone to that level then I despair for my fellow humans. I don't ask you to agree with it, just try and see what it must take for someone to blow themselves to smithereens in the pursuit of a goal.

I truly do not understand the attitude of Israel and, even less, do I understand the blind support from the US. Unless, of course, the US is playing some deep game to keep the area unstable and that would be really nasty to contemplate given the number of dead. I hope there is some other reason, however difficult for me to fathom.

Dawg: If you insist on misreading my posts there isn't a lot that I can do. I have to let it go, I'm done.

Neil

by jdclyde

If you only criticize one side, you are seen to support the other. A simple idea.

I personally am in favor of NEVER having a "measured" response. It was one of the biggest flaws in the battle in Iraq, of not throwing everything we have at them to begin with and locking the place down. It was native for Bush to believe that the citizens would rise up to join us, especially after Bush Sr. let them think the same thing and then pulled back to let them be slaughtered.

You make the price higher than people are willing to pay.

Why is the birthrate three times the norm in the camps?
To intentionally over populate?
To intentionally make future human weapons?

Is is suspect, to say the least, that a parent "can't stop" the 12 year olds. [i] (providing the story is more than just a story)

by charliespencer

There's nothing more contemptible than interpreting the word of your god as justification to round up an army, invade a foreign land, slaughter every living soul you could find over some concept of 'holy land'. Christianity never did anything like that (recently).

by sleepin'dawg

[i][b][u]They are the masters of the pre-emptive strike.[/i][/b][/u]

They certainly are but in the case of Hezbollah and Hamas, their response has only been reactionary. An example of a pre-emptive strike was when Israel took out the French built Iraqi nuclear installation some years ago or perhaps you might include the Entebbe raid. So far Israels response [b][i]has not[/b][/i] been in any way pre-emptive. It has been reactionary in nature. If they were acting pre-emptively, Palestine, Lebannon and large sectors of Syria would be a total waste land by now, not that it's in much better shape now, thanks to the inability of the Muslim fanatics to live at peace and develop the area. The Palestinian people would only gain by peace with Israel but that is contrary to the desires of the Muslim fanatics. As I have said, repeatedly, I've been there and seen with my own eyes how the Israelis live and how their Islamic neighbours live. Both Jordan and Egypt have gained much more through peaceful co-existence with Israel than they ever did through war.

BTW more Palestinians are killed,daily, by their own kind than by anything the Israelis do. That's something that never, if ever, seems to make the papers.

[b][i]Why can't [u]you[/u] understand and see that!!![/b][/i]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

that I can't - won't - do "simple". None of this is "simple". Too many people are dead for it to deserve "simple".

Nowhere in my posts do I support those who commit terrorist acts against Israel or anyone else. Until my last post to Dawg, I don't believe that I attempt offer any reason as to why they might do what they do.

If you choose to see "the enemy of my friend is my enemy" or some other simplistic bollocks then that's the way you see it and there is little that I can do. Really, there is little that I care to do.

Neil :(

by sleepin'dawg

that Israel has had to contend with since 1948 and what every Jew has had to contend with since the Diaspora. Since they were rightly, or wrongly, given their "homeland" in 1948 most Jews have made it there motto: [b]Never again.[/b]

I can't say I blame them and having spent some time in every decade, in the Mid-East, since 1962,(I was last in Syria, Egypt and Libya in 2004) I've seen what the Israelis have built for themselves and keep asking why the other nations can't live in a similar fashion. I've done business all over the Mid-East, not just in Israel. I see how the people live and have seen the benefits of peace in Jordan and Egypt. Why is it that every other Arab nation will not tolerate a Palestinian presence beyond a certain size. Even Syria has forcibly deported many people of Palestinian origin, a fact conveniently ignored by the so called peace lovers of this world. Are you sure you aren't biased against Israel and the Jews???

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

P.S. BTW [b]I[/b] don't think you are biased but feel you are naively ill-informed. [b]D[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

US$30 billion reasons why Lebanon, population 4 million, invaded twice by Israel and by once by Syria and victim of major sectarian violence and, just when they were getting their sh:t together, trashed by Israel (three times. Count it, three) again...

You know, Dawg, I have no f*cking idea why they don't have the same standard of living in Lebanon as they do in Israel.

?:|

by maxwell edison

The two questions:

1. Does Israel have a right to exist in its current geographical location, and will you recognize and respect that right to exist, including no longer threatening that right or threatening to seek that State's destruction?

If the answer to question number one is yes (in both actions and words), then go to question number two.

2. How should the border disputes be settled, either amongst the neighboring parties themselves and/or with influence from the outside (U.S., U.K., U.N., etc.)

However, if the answer to question number one is no (all or in part), then any answer to question number two is a moot point. In such a case, Israel does, in my opinion, have every right to wage full and total war against those seeking their destruction, even taking it to the point of demanding full and unconditional surrender from those enemies, including taking whatever land conquest they deem appropriate.

An analogy: If terrorist factions from Mexico were hell-bent on taking back the Southwest United States, and the nation-state of Mexico publicly supported such actions, and their tactics included bombings, lobbing missiles into Texas, kidnapping and killing US citizens, etc, the U.S. would be justified to wage full and total war against Mexico, demanding unconditional surrender.

How are my two questions flawed?

How is my analogy flawed?

P.S. As a disclaimer. I firmly believe that the radical wing of Islam (I think you know who and what I mean) is on a mission to kill all Jews and Christians they consider infidel, and to spread their ideology across the globe by whatever means possible. Their agenda is not negotiable. I support any and all efforts to stop them. I further believe they have sleeper cells all across the globe, and if they're not dealt with now - however painful it might be - they'll have to be dealt with later, causing much more pain in the long run. And to exacerbate the problem, we see socialistic and political correct nonsense actually aiding their mission. France and Bridget Bardot are only one case in point. I also believe that this current threat, as I described, makes Adolph Hitler look like childs-play.

by jacksavage20

I do dread the day American policies turn against Israel. The Muslim population in Europe has overtaken and will be a minority not much longer. There will and is no room for negotiation Israel is the only ally we will have over there in 15 years.

by Member 25348569

The total population of Europe is around 750 million. The number of Muslims is estimated as 50 million and half of those are in Russia. Western Europe's population is around 300 million of whom 13 million are Muslim, half of those in France.

Personally, I think we'll hold back the rampaging Islamic hordes for the next year or two.

Neil :)

by jdclyde

because of all the politically correct BS, including what you have seen first hand, gives this minority a large voice.

We don't see hesitation to insult Christians, but people don't DARE offend the Muslims. It is fashionable to be pro-muslim and anti-Christian.

There is even serious consideration in many civilized parts of the world to allow sharia law, which has no place in any civilized nation.

by tony hopkinson

Lot's to do with the european one though.

Personally I'll be quite chuffed when the number of religous people of various flavours balances out, maybe they can mess with each other then and leave me alone...

by sleepin'dawg

to be visited every week for the forseeable future by Pentecostals, Seventh Day Adventists and the Jehovas Witnesses unless and/or until you enact a means of keeping Jd from tap dancing to show tunes. Failing that you will be visited by the Islamic Brotherhood and the Jews. They're demanding equal time. :^0

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

The sad truth, in 1962 it had the best standard of living in the whole Middle East. Beirut was known as the [i][b]"Paris of North Africa"[/i][/b] and was a centre of international banking and finance almost on a par with Zurich. Then the Palestinians arrived after being kicked out of Jordan and the downward spiral began. First it was Christians against Muslims and then Syria arrived. Syria used and uses the Palastinians in Lebannon as proxies in attacking Israel.

To answer your Irgun comment I would say the British Army.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

The State of Israel exists - that is a fact. whether it should have been created is now academic for those of us outside the region. It exists.

For those inside the region, the debate is so obviously not over.

Yes, Israel does have the right to protect its borders. No debate on the right. Whether it has the right to "protect" borders that were taken by force in a war the Israelis started IS a point for debate. The strategy that it uses to "protect" these borders IS a point for debate. Its actions outside of those borders ARE matters for debate.

"Destruction" in the way that some groups have proposed isn't an option as it just isn't going to happen. Israel is the world's fifth or sixth strongest nuclear power and may well have more nukes that the UK. Unlike the UK, they would almost certainly use them in extremis. Don't think that surrounding Arab governments don't know that and don't think, for a minute, that the Palestinian groups care what the Arab governments think.

I guess that "full and total war" is something that you do and I just don't. Personally, I prefer "measured response" and "measured response" does not involve dropping cluster bombs on civilians [b]under any circumstances[/b]. No matter how many f*cking rockets they fire at you.

We will just have to disagree about "Radical Islam", I have problems with global conspiracies. No doubt I'll be speaking Farsi unless the US bails us out.

Neil :)

p.s. Yet again I ask, "Why did the British government not send a Harrier jet down to Dublin to put a couple of rockets through the window of IRA headquarters?" back in the 1970s.

by maxwell edison

But sometimes attempting to see things in simple terms will, in the very least, point a person in the right direction so the more complicated details can be better addressed.

Regarding[i] full and total war[/i] versus a [i] measured response[/i], while both have their flaws (the understatement of the year), the former, in the very least, has some semblance of finality to it, while the latter seldom (if ever) solves the underlying problem. The former defeats an enemy, while the latter, at best, contains it. The notion, "[i]To the victor goes the spoils of war[/i]" not only can put finality to a conflict, but when faced with such an outcome, could indeed act as a very strong deterrent. The [i]measured responses[/i] in the middle-east have not only solved nothing, but have caused this problem to linger on for so long that most people have no idea what started it all in the first place. I prefer finality to a problem.

I also know that we disagree about "Radical Islam". Unfortunately, all too often, the only retort you appear to have is an attempt to discredit the opposing view by using terms like [i]global conspiracies[/i]. You don't like "simple", and I don't like to be pigeon-holed into believing in "global conspiracies".

I'll not comment on your obvious sarcasm, "[i]No doubt I'll be speaking Farsi unless the US bails us out.[/i]", except to suggest it belongs in the same category as your use of [i]global conspiracies[/i].

You asked, "[i]Why did the British government not send a Harrier jet down to Dublin to put a couple of rockets through the window of IRA headquarters back in the 1970s?"[/i] I have no idea - except perhaps it's because the Harrier jet wasn't commissioned into service until the 1980s!

by sleepin'dawg

Back in the bad old days of the [i]"Cold"[/i] War were you one of those who advocated peace at any price; even if any price meant unilateral disarmament??? I am not implying anything here but I am curious. You have grown up in an England that survived, barely, The Second World War. I would have thought you would have learned by now that policies of appeasement never work. They didn't work for Ethelred the Unready and they didn't work for Neville Chamberlain.
I think you are fortunate to have never had to live during any serious conflict wherein the matter of your daily existence would be threatened.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by w2ktechman

" Unlike the UK, they would almost certainly use them in extremis"

really? Then why have them at all? It is to show deterrent only? What would happen in an extreme, say France (lol), Spain, Norway, and Germany attacked your island, and y'all were being overrun. I think you'd let 'em fly

by Member 25348569

techman first as it's fairly straightforward. It has long been UK government policy that we would not use them as a first-strike weapon. They would have to be used against us first. I can't actually conceive of a scenario in the near or mid future - my lifetime - where they would be used against us and we would have a clear idea of where and against who to strike back.

I think the Israelis would adopt a much more "robust" approach.

Dawg, you still insist on putting things in black and white. I don't advocate appeasement for the Israelis but I DO advocate that they try and tone down the idea that its acceptable to take out an apartment block [b]in another country[/b] to kill one man who might not even be there. The idea that that attitude will deter the Palestinians is so obviously wrong that the next, inevitable step is to wall off the whole area and that is what they are doing. Where does THAT end?

Maxwell, total war? How total? More than they did to Lebanon a couple of years ago? did that work?

Neil :)

By the way, The Hawker Siddeley Harrier GR.1 first flew on 28 December 1967, and entered service with the RAF on 1 April 1969. If we'd have toasted the IRA's HQ and everyone in it, it would have been the early 70s the first time. 1982 was when the Harriers were first used in real combat in the Falklands War.

by sadidsahmai

I'm an student from Iran!
I know this name: Iran, dosn't remind you good things....Ahmadi Nejad, Nuc. Program. 5+1 , Holocost, ...
I know that most of bad thing have come together to make this background....(but I'm inviting you to search and know more...not just this devil stuff..)
OK! I think the problem which has discussed here has many deep and tiny factor that you don't cosider....
here is MiddleEast, a region with many different cultures,different nations, languages, and different religions in a half or 1/3 of U.S ..very close to each other..........but with very long history of ancient civilzation,religions, War, and Culture and also Dictatorship.....
DictatorShip and Religion has a long and deep roots here......
take a look at West Policy to this oily region of the world.................U.S blame Iran and some similar countries... for thier Totaliter goverments,... and call Saudi Arabia,Kuwait,Egypt,Jordan,even Turkey... as their great friends...........but all of them are same..........all of them have a totaliter goverment ............ almost all of Middle Eastern Countries has govern by a Dictator or sth similar..........
I don't want to write about the past..........and political issues....
I hate Dictator Ship..............I love Democracy and Humanity..........
but it's not fair................. you said sth...true/false..... but not all of the fact...............take a look at your comments.........some one say sth like those Exteremists say......Wipe,3rd War,Kill,Destroy,"The Hezbollah are murderers, liars and thieves and they should be treated as such"........nobody talk about......education......democracy......and communication.....
I hope for a day that both sides.......Iran,US.......Israil,Palestinians..........Turks,Kurds,,,,,,,,Sunnies,Shias....Minorities/Majorities.....to talk.

hope for listening ......... hope form more conversation between sides.........hope for more talk and less violance.....
currently neither Israil nor Palestain...neither Iran nor U.S....niether X nor Y.....listen to each other both side just say thier comments and both side let extremist and disform minds take the final desicion.
you must consider that most of Terrorist Ideas actully have Political root rather religious issues.........I'm a secular....but most of thier theoritical ideas hasn't related to Islam,... the Islam and similar things is just an excuse to implement thier ideas ang gathering some ignorant and stupid people.....take a look at them....Taliban.......Ben-Ladan........I don't know..you konw better.......Terrorists................what you see? I say Un-Educated and Un-Civilized persons.......They're not living in this age...........they belong to differnt time........many years ago.........why?

but the future is bright and hopefull..............we need education and it's improving faster and faster.............we need better networking infrastructure, going forward even improving by years.........better networking to communicate with other part of the world...to come to closer...................I am hopefull because of IT and new technologies and thier capabilty to give the chance to people to talk.........to listen to themselves...........to experience humanity and love.........people in this age has better and more chance to understand that "The Earth" is thier actual country/home and "The Universe" is thier land and .....
this and next generations has more power to govern the goverments to come closer....

sorry for long comment and poor english writing.............I hope to describe my oponion wihtout leading to misunderestanding bcz of my poor english.

by w2ktechman

Thank you for posting.
I do agree that more talks also need Listening on the other side.
It also sounds like you are all in dire need of more schools/education. However from my understanding, the erligious leaders for many clans/communities forbid this, and are taught only what they want to have taught.
Until this changes (not likely soon), there will always be widespread Un-education.

As for your opinion -- It came across just fine.

by sadidsahmai

The fact is in the most of regions in the Middle East there is an widespread education between new generations!! not like modern countries(Quality and Quantity) but there isn't very much difference also!! here in Iran, governments have a great problem to provide enough chance for high school students for going to university (more than 1 million student in a year for a 70 million's population country!) but the problem is in the democracy and pluralism or secularism ,... concepts and the disappointing fact is most of this educated people study less than a 20min a day!!! (without consider their professional fields) so they need democracy and freedom also and so education itself isn't enough.
but I believe The Controlled Education in a Ideological Government also better than nothing....bcz such an educated person won't become a extremist.....so education is just one of the factors......ME also need democracy, freedom, more Communication to the world, and less Dictator-growing by the West.

ps.I don't mean that the roots of dictators in the M.E. is in the west policy I mean just they usually help some of them and blame the others upon their situations.

by sadidsahmai

I'm an student from Iran!
I know this name: Iran, dosn't remind you good things....Ahmadi Nejad, Nuc. Program. 5+1 , Holocost, ...
I know that most of bad thing have come together to make this background....(but I'm inviting you to search and know more...not just this devil stuff..)
OK! I think the problem which has discussed here has many deep and tiny factor that you don't cosider....
here is MiddleEast, a region with many different cultures,different nations, languages, and different religions in a half or 1/3 of U.S ..very close to each other..........but with very long history of ancient civilzation,religions, War, and Culture and also Dictatorship.....
DictatorShip and Religion has a long and deep roots here......
take a look at West Policy to this oily region of the world.................U.S blame Iran and some similar countries... for thier Totaliter goverments,... and call Saudi Arabia,Kuwait,Egypt,Jordan,even Turkey... as their great friends...........but all of them are same..........all of them have a totaliter goverment ............ almost all of Middle Eastern Countries has govern by a Dictator or sth similar..........
I don't want to write about the past..........and political issues....
I hate Dictator Ship..............I love Democracy and Humanity..........
but it's not fair................. you said sth...true/false..... but not all of the fact...............take a look at your comments.........some one say sth like those Exteremists say......Wipe,3rd War,Kill,Destroy,"The Hezbollah are murderers, liars and thieves and they should be treated as such"........nobody talk about......education......democracy......and communication.....
I hope for a day that both sides.......Iran,US.......Israil,Palestinians..........Turks,Kurds,,,,,,,,Sunnies,Shias....
Minorities/Majorities.....to talk.

hope for listening ......... hope for more conversation between sides.........hope for more talk and less violence.....
currently neither Israel nor Palestain...neither Iran nor U.S....neither X nor Y.....listen to each other both side just say their comments and both side let extremist and disformed minds take the final decision.
you must consider that most of Terrorist Ideas actually have Political root rather religious issues.........I'm a secular....but most of their theoretical ideas hasn't related to Islam,... the Islam and similar things is just an excuse to implement their ideas and gathering some ignorant and stupid people.....take a look at them....Taliban.......Ben-Laden........I don't know..you know better.......Terrorists................what you see? I say Un-Educated and Un-Civilized persons.......They're not living in this age...........they belong to different time........many years ago.........why?

but the future is bright and hopeful..............we need education and it's improving faster and faster.............we need better networking infrastructure, going forward even improving by years.........better networking to communicate with other part of the world...to come to closer...................I am hopefull because of IT and new technologies and their capability to give the chance to people to talk.........to listen to themselves...........to experience humanity and love.........people in this age has better and more chance to understand that "The Earth" is their actual country/home and "The Universe" is their land and .....
this and next generations has more power to govern the governments to come closer....

sorry for long comment

by Member 25348569

I sit next to a Muslim convert and they are the worst! He has declared Jihad if I steal any more of his biscuits.

:p

by w2ktechman

Personal Jihad is the worst... He can 'get you' anytime he wants (and anyone around you). You really should offer to give some Gravy to him next time you snag dem biscuits :D

by Member 25348569

The biscuits that I'm talking about are what you Yanks would call "cookies" although I'm not sure that Chocolate Hobnobs translates into the American.

Doesn't really work with gravy...

Neil

by pip

well said -its about time we saw genocide for what it is, and stopped giving the likes of Arafat Nobel PEACE prizes.

by jdclyde

of why that award is meaningless.

Heck, if you make an intentionally inaccurate slide show, you might get one too! B-)

And yes, the stated goal to wipe out Israel is genocide. Don't know why that should bother anyone, right?

by jamesrl

You have no issue with Saddam who was once a hero of the US for fighting Iran becoming a goat for invading Kuwait, or any problem with George Wallace, a racist who repented, but Arafat can never be forgiven?

Arafat won the prize for his work with Yitsak Rabin and Shimon Peres in negotiating a peace agreement. He accepted the existence of Israel in 1988. He worked to try and establish peace since then.

I'm not claiming he was a saint, but compared to Hamas, he was at least interested and engaged in peaceful dialogue.

James

by tony hopkinson

Those societies where it is in place and they are 'happy' with it wouldn't agree with you.

So you wish to impose your (perhaps some our) ideas of what civilsiation should be. Worse still, What you are really talking about is a morality, very changeable subjective concept.

We have different morals, never mind us and Ali. I for instance have no time for child sacrifice and ritual canibalism...

I'm not pro-muslim never have been. I've always been anti-christian since that git in the frock with his collar on backwards tried to drown me for my own good.

Another imposition, why are people surprised when I go out of my way to upset those who think it was 'civilised' to do that....

If you want to smack them about so they'll do as they are told, fine, don't give me this crap about civilised though. Civilise is what Cortez did to the Aztec, and what our ancestors did to the indians. Smacked them about and then excused themselves with mealy mouthed justifications of civilsed behaviour.

by jdclyde

4:34 . . . If you fear highhandedness from your wives, remind them [of the teaching of God], then ignore them when you go to bed, then hit them. If they obey you, you have no right to act against them. God is most high and great. (MAS Abdel Haleem, the Qur'an, Oxford UP, 2004)

Sentences Imposed for Alleged Homosexual Conduct Violate Basic Rights
http://www.sodomylaws.org/world/saudi_arabia/saudinews040.htm

It was the barbaric sharia law that backed up the call for the death of Salman Rushdie.

Iran: Academic?s Death Sentence Condemned
http://hrw.org/press/2002/11/iranacademic.htm

You must never have actually read anything about sharia to even partially support it as anything but barbaric, and MY sense of morality has nothing to do with it. There is NOTHING civilized about it or it's followers.

by tony hopkinson

The Salem witch trials...

Jesus getting his feet washed in some bint's hair.....

As for homosexuality, don't even go there.

I give you Alan Turing.......

And there's no way the good and christian church ever offed someone for writing 'erm objectionable material is there?

If you want something western powers really get annoyed about Sharia law, here you go.

Hacking people's heads off isn't bad for business, this stuff though...

http://www.welfare.qmul.ac.uk/money/sharia.html

by jellimonsta

Don't let my wife see those chocolate hobnobs. She has long been a fan of chocolate digestives, but had chocolate hobnobs for the first time when we were over there in May.
She bought 4 packs and ate 1 pack a day! :0 Actually, to be fair, I think I had 2 from all of the packs collectively. ;\

by jdclyde

Do you have any idea how many times Elvis shows up in a grilled cheese sandwich? :0

by jdclyde

I am bummed out though, because the girl scouts USED to have their sale in time for hunting season in November, but now it isn't until December. No Thin Mints for dear camp!

And Neil, if you meant cookies, SAY cookies! :p

by jdclyde

You have gone into what is wrong with Israel and the support they get from the US.

You have not gone into what is wrong with the other side of the coin.

If you do not favor one side or the other, why only criticize the one side and the people that support it?

That is the point I was trying to make.

by Member 25348569

I was trying to find out WHY the support for Israel was so absolute. I still am. We all know - or believe we know - what the terrorist organisations do and how they do it. What we missed in this discussion were two things: What the Israelis do that could be considered terrorism and why the terrorists do what they do.

No-one in this thread or in previous threads on Iraq have ever considered that it might not be about religion, but about nationalism. You guys all understand about freedom and how you would feel if someone came in and gave away or took your land. That's what the partition and the subsequent Israeli conflicts did to the surrounding countries yet this is largely ignored with cries of "Muslim Terrorists!" and even some of "Global Muslim Conspiracy!".

Ah, well...

Neil :)

by the scummy one

however if you meant cookies, then why say biscuits???
Yes, those are the kinds of things that disappear without a trace..
Blame it on someone else :D

Or, at least, bring in something once in a while that he can snag (tis better than a Jihad)

by the scummy one

I was waiting to see if there would be a reply to that!

I have an excuse, I wrote it in the BC era (before caffeine). I was making the coffee when I typed it.

So, then when I got to work I went to edit, but alas, I am using Scummy's account and it wont let me edit :(

by Member 25348569

Just ask Jelli's missus if you don't believe me. Tip: They are even better if you keep them in the 'fridge.

I am not allowed to buy them as I will scoff an entire packet without pausing to breathe.

Neil :0

by jdclyde

Returning fire as an act of terrorism.

Many will always accept firing rockets at civilian targets terrorism.

Many will always accept blowing up buses and discos full of civilians as terrorism.

Between the two, it isn't a hard choice for me.

I, quite unlike you, so not believe is such a thing as "measured response". If someone came after me, I would not apply "reasonable force". I would apply all that I have to remove that threat. I will not fault Israel for doing the same.

We will not see eye-to-eye on this one, because I will never feel that Israel should as you said "take it on the chin".

The organizations providing the rockets needs to be tracked down and exterminated, instead of replying one at a time, dozens of times a day.

There will never be peace in the Middle East until either Israel is wiped out, or they take out the neighboring nations, sadly. The surrounding nations will only stop when they are dead.

by Member 25348569

at least for the moment.

Saudi Arabia doesn't seem to be majorly involved in financing or encouraging anti-Israeli activity. Saudi Arabia supports the position that Israel must withdraw from territory occupied in June 1967.

Jordan has signed a treaty with Israel and now has normal relations.

Egypt signed a peace treaty thirty years ago when Israel agreed to withdraw from Sinai, captured in the 1967 war. Unfortunately, though, the political climate in Egypt is changing and peace may not last.

Israel has normal diplomatic relations with quite a few Muslim countries outside of the Arab League.

it can be done.

by the scummy one

JD, you are in favor of invading Iran???
from what I have read, rockets and money has been coming from Iran to be used against Israel. However, we are not in a good enough position in the region to start this war.

I will also concede that some of the Israeli responses have baen a bit over-done, such as Lebanon. While I did not disagree with this battle, I did disagree with sending missiles to apartment buildings just because 1 or 2 Hezbollah were there. I also thought that they took the business buildings a bit too far. Did you see photos of downtown areas afterwards? Holy Cr@p, they were sent back to the stone age!

However, I disagree with most of Neil's assessment. If they are being fired upon, they should not just accept it, specially if it is happening often. The NEED to get to the root of the problem, and remove it. That is what the whole Lebanon thing was about. They let Lebanon militia build up for too long. Just like now, they have allowed Hamas to build up too long.
Personally, I would have no problem with an invasion of both, to root out these terrorist groups, and afterwards, to be able to work with the remainder f the populations for Peace.
However, I doubt it would happen, if they invaded, it would just cause More Hate.

This is the real problem there, how do they create a state of tolerance with each other, and remove the hatred. The hatred in the region runs deep in some, and others just dont care!

JD has may points right (in my mind at least), who breaks the cease fire(s)? Who has been promising one thing, and then sneaking to another attack?
Israel has no real recourse but to Defend Themselves against such open hostilities. And, unfortunately, it is not in Neils world where they can just say "lets be friends" and it is all good again.
As for giving back land, there have been attempts to let areas govern themselves. How does it turn out --More Hostilities! Israel looks weak whenever they pull back, and this emboldens the enemy/terrorists. Also, these groups will suddenly get a surge of finances because 'they defeated the Israeli war machine' .
So, what does Israel really give up if they pull out of an area? Not just some land, but security AND the increase in enemies that are better funded than they were.

What is the solution? I cannot say. But it is not to retreat or stand down!

by jdclyde

There will always be a group displeased until Israel is gone.

As in the link you provided Neil, when their own children are brainwashed and sent out knowing nothing but hate, things will only get worse.

The more land Israel gives "back", the closer the launching zones are to fire more rockets from. And that is all dependent about if we care about sorting out back dependent upon what time stream.

The generations that are intentionally over breeding, under destitute conditions, are not exactly doing anything to improve their position, now are they? If you are actively making your own situation worse, you lose a lot of the sympathy you might have once got.

by Member 25348569

when you posted "if they invaded, it would just cause More Hate", did you actually stop to think what you wrote? If MORE invasion would cause MORE hate, is it not obvious that previous invasions caused the hatred that now exists?

Don't take my word for it but it may interest you to know that Hezbollah DID NOT EXIST before Israel invaded South Lebanon in 1982. They continued terrorist acts against Israel after the Israelis withdrew. admittedly. Their justification is that there is still disputed territory that Israel captured from Syria in 1967 which Hezbollah says belongs to Lebanon which wasn't involved in the 1967 war.

Neil

If you invade Iran it will be the most stupid act since the invasion of Iraq. More to the point, WHAT THE F*CK HAS IT GOT TO DO WITH YOU? Just asking, mind.

Check out Iran's military capability. They represent no danger to Israel other than the aid that they give that enables the relative flea-bites of the terrorists.

by the scummy one

JD's comment. Yes, I agree, at this time it would be a horrific mistake, and very, very costly...

And yes, I understand my comment clearly. More incursions will spread more hate. However, they cannot just back away and constantly just 'take the hit', nor can they just give the land back, because it will not change anything except how well their missile strikes will hit their targets.

That is why I said that I do not have an answer to what should be done. Maybe an all out total war until only 1 side is victorious? (Did I just say that???)
But this would totally alienate Israel from the rest of the world, and would bring more and more money to the terrorists fighting them. And then what? nope, not the answer.
How about incursion squads to seek out and kill everyone associated with their enemies? Again, this would just promote more problems, especially internationally.

Israel is in a tough spot, with no clear path that does not look like genocide or over-reaction. Do you have a better plan that will work? Talks have not done anything previously! giving land back brings More not Less hostilities! Is there a solution here?

My only solution that has a chance of working would be an international peace keeping force in the region, which will actively take down organizations such as Hezbollah and Hamas. But even then, would this work? And how much would it cost?
This is a very tough situation to try to remedy, especially when all options seem to fall apart short of just blatantly killing everyone!

by jellimonsta

Neil, my wife can pack those things away too (actually she is like that with most sweets). She is only 125 lbs, but she can put stuff away alright.
I generally don't get a look in with sweets, as it is gone by the time I get home from work. :(

by tony hopkinson

I'll get them all to come round at the same time on the promise of converting me.

If I get real lucky I can invite that b'stard who keeps trying to sell me double glazing at the same time.

by w2ktechman

"A vet told the newspaper the words "defied scientific explanation". "

And we all know Nigerian Vets are the best Scientific resource available :^0

by boxfiddler Hot topic

of the creation story, but I do the Biblical.

Eve shared the blame with Adam and the serpent. God punished all three. Furthermore, Adam was an utter wuss. First thing, he caved in to Eve, second thing, as soon as God asked he blamed Eve in blatant attempt to shrug off his own responsibility in the matter.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Mormons. They hit my neighborhood once a month. You could set your watch by them.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I thought God didn't want to give them Judges because it was a first step in movement towards secularity.