Question Locked

about SATA, eSATA, and hard drives?

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking to buy an external drive, but I may just get a regular SATA and then put it in an enclosure.

What I've seen from various benchmarks however, is that eSATA seems to be around 150MB/s whereas its supposed to be equal to SATA II at 300MB/s.
Then I thought perhaps it was just the drives.

So my question;

for a SATA harddrive, what is the expected burst output? Is it enough to even saturate a SATA I connection?

Basically, I want to make sure if I run a drive in eSATA it will run just as fast as a internal SATA drive.

Also on that note, is there any major difference between external enclosures? I just want USB 2.0 and eSATA, but do they effect the ability of the drive you put in any, or is more appearance and software?

Thanks!

2 replies

by thechas

A near as I can tell, the terms SATA and eSATA are being used somewhat interchangeably. As for SATA 1 (150) and SATA 2 (300), that refers to the maximum sustained data transfer rates.

Therefore, you want a SATA 2 drive. Your enclosure should be USB 2.o compliant with full SATA 2 support.

I recommend enclosures that have as much metal in contact with the drive as possible. This helps the drive to run cooler which will lengthen it's life.

2 other thoughts:
Compare prices, you may find that there is no savings on buying a separate drive and enclosure. 1 plus for buying a complete solution is no support issues.
Second, if you go with a 2.5" SATA drive, you can run a USB port powered solution. Less cables and stuff to carry around.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.