Discussion Locked

Am I the only Admin looking at blocking hotmail.com to stop SPAM? (edited)

0 helpful
177 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

EDIT NOTE: added details at end.

Half of the SPAM I get day in and day out is from a disposable Hotmail.com address.

They brag about SPAM protection for the USERS when you sign up for a hotmail account, but don't do anything about stopping their accounts from causing a lot of the SPAM out there.

On a prefessional basis, would anyone use a hotmail account for work? If they do, then what is that saying about their company and they way they do business?

What do you think? Would blocking hotmail.com be a bad thing? I get closer and closer everyday.

**** ADDED DETAIL **********************
Running Domino on Linux, so any products that run on the server would have to work with this. Sorry, not a M$ shop.

177 replies

by cactus pete

Most of the mail sent as spam is not actually FROM hotmail.com - it just appears to be.

Spammers fake the return address most of the time.

by fitzmark

you're really talking about filtering on the from header that includes the word hotmail, and not actually "blocking" hotmail. If you actually block the hotmail sending ips, you will probably find that it is not actually coming from there 99% of the time.

by tony hopkinson

for personal stuff, but I bet you wouldn't give a toss. Nor should you to be quite honest. I've worked at places where this is not allowed. If you are talking about just disallowing .hotmail.com and hotmail.co.uk on your business servers I can't see a problem at all. I do all business related work through the company email, if nothing else it's on record. I'd be very suspicious of anyone who told me they were doing company business thru hotmail.

by deepsand

a lot of small businesses DO use Hotmail, owing to the fact that it's FREE of any explicit cost.

They do, of course, overlook the implicit costs of reduced productivity, increased risk of having thier system(s) corrupted, etc..

by jdclyde

affect how seriously you take someone? If they are using a hotmail account for professional use, just how professional are they?

When you get internet access, your ISP gives you at least 5 addresses. If this is a small company the five is enough. If not, there are still many affordable ways to get e-mail that are much more reliable.

Or am I way off base with this line of thinking? I make a point of not looking down on non-techs for not knowing tech, otherwise they wouldn't need people like us, but I think this is different?

by tony hopkinson

Most people try to keep me well away from customers LOL

Tony's a great guy, but he can be somewhat blunt, was the reasoning.

by deepsand

MANY small businesses use Hotmail because it's free, easy to establish any number of anonymous accounts, & just as easy to walk away from.

Furthermore, most of the users are neither knowledgable of the risks inherent in e-mail, nor inclined to become both informed of such risks & proficient and diligent in avoiding such.

Add to the mix the dirty little secret that MSN shares it's subscriber base with "affiliates," and you have the perfect hunting ground for spammers.

Until such time as Hotmail becomes a provider of e-mail service first & foremost, as opposed to an advertising platform, it will continue to be a menace to us all.

I feel your pain.

by frank_s

One Hotmail address I've had for about 3 or 4 years never gets any spam. I give this address to very few people (friends and family only) and it has an unusual name with numbers and letters. When I set it up originally, I unchecked all the option boxes. So it seems to me that unless you tell them OK, Hotmail/MSN doesn't share addresses.

by ccassino

I had a hotmail acct a few years ago. I never gave the address to ANYONE. I went in a week later and my inbox was loaded with junkmail.

jd, you need to look at the headers of the message, then go from there.

by rononline

I used a Hotmail account for some time with Outlook Express, due to the fact that I travel a great deal spending a few months to a couple of years in each place, and with this arrangement I don't have to keep distributing change of address notices.
Hotmail are no longer supporting remote sending by OE etc.
I now use Gmail with OE and its working just fine.

by jaqui

I deny any @msn, @ microsoft, @ yahoo, or @ hotmail
email addy's.
bounce them back to originating server.

no more spam in my inbox.

by dafe2

We use Brightmail as well.....but just denying those you mention keeps a lot of garbage out of the inbox :-)

by jaqui

deny anything other than plain text formatted email.
no multipart alternative, no html.
no email with attachments.

that clears a huge amount of spam also.
most spam is multipart alternative, to enable colours and images.

for me, email should only be plain text.

what is brightmail?
an anti spam tool?

by cactus pete

I work for a law firm. many of the higher executives correspond with colleagues and they don't care from which account an email comes - personal or business. They don't differentiate between being at work and drafting an important meail, or being at home. So blocking certain domains may get you into a lot of hot water ith management.

We have two Tumbleweed.com products, MMS and Mailgate which remove most spam.

by jellimonsta

Our CEO, CFO and Owner all correspond with individuals who use hotmail or yahoo accounts. Regardless as to whether it is personal or business, if you disrupt this correspondence, you can land yourself in hot water. IMHO.

by jdclyde

Just trying to tie down the damn spam.

I have a spam filter that quarantines about 500 spam per day, but still get quite a few through.

Will have to just add another layer of anti-spam.

Thanks for the input all.

by cactus pete

The best thing to do is to keep the email address from getting into the spammers' handsin the first place.

Don't publish email address on web sites. Don't submit to websites. use throw-away addresses when possible. Etc, etc...

by jdclyde

where you could put your contact e-mail on your web site and it would open in their e-mail, but it wasn't in a form that bots could gleem them.

Anyone know what I am talking about?

We have a sales force, and they REQURE that all of their addresses are available to the public.

Any ideas?

by cactus pete

I haven't seen it in years, actually. I don't even remember which webdev guy showed that to me. But it IS possible. I'm sure it just involves burying the actual address in a database, and using a pointer.

Otherwise, you can put a pic of the text up, but not the actual text of the address.

However, this will only help prevent future users' addresses from being spammed as much. Once it's out there, you're screwed. It can be sold and resold until you're swimming in spam.

So we have that mailgate appliance in place. This way it's not outsourced [postini was a close second for us] and the users can control what is or isn't spam.

In front of that we do an sbl-xbl lookup. This cut out volume in half. The next filter reduces the leftovers by 75%.

So, what's that in math... we actually receive 1/8 of the mail that is sent to us...

by jaqui

is to use the no-spam format for addys on a website.

jaqui AT x-mail DOT net

remove spaces and translate the at to @...
then bots can't get email addys from it.

don't use mailto links, use email forms that call a script when submitted is a better option.

then the sales people can give thier addy out when they reply.

by grover99

That way, the form knows where to go but the sender doesn't know the email address. Prevents harvesting. Only drawback is if the user mistypes their return email address in the form.

by allmedia.jda

I see someone already posted a script that will "hide" the email address but I thought I'd share this one also. Seems slightly easier to use to me.

by av .

I already have yahoo, mindspring and MSN blacklisted. If any of the addresses from these sites are good, I whitelist those. It keeps lots of spam from getting to people's inboxes.

by philj2o

Hotmail is the single biggest source of spam and virus laden emails *trying* to enter our organization. Will MS ever wake up to this and take some positive action??

by christineeve

Hi,
I live overseas and hotmail is my preferred way to log on anywhere and contact my family back in the US. I've had the same email address and IM name for years. My family knows it by heart and it's easy for them to remember.

Also, of all the spam I've ever received, it was never from a valid email address, i.e., AOL, juno, hotmail, it was ALWAYS a spoofed address.

If you block the email address or domain, you're not really blocking the spammer, you're blocking the spoofed emailer/domain.

by jaqui

I did get from hotmail, yahoo, msn were all from valid email addresses.

use webmail service from less well known provider to avoid getting blocked.

my email that I hand out to most people for personal contact is:
jaqui@somethingorother.com
( provided by myownemail )
silly thing, with 5 active email addresses, in the last year I have only gotten 3 spam messages.
from a personals list from somewhere. bounce the messages and haven't seen one again.

by sacre

While your own staff may not have any legitimate reason for using a hotmail account, it is unreasonable to place any such restrictions on your clients, especially individuals. It would be bad for business if emails coming in to ask for support are bouncing.

I'd recommend using spamassassin or something similar.

by vilela70

If they dont do anything to stop those anoying spamers, I agree to BAN HOTMAIL from serious networks!

by graeme

as others have noted - along with all the other "free" addresses. We particularly note that Yahoo is the worst.

DO NOT bounce (as suggested elsewhere). It serves no purpose except to clog the Internet's overall bandwidth. The originating address was probably spoofed.

by maryvee21

Hotmail can be set up so that you will only receive mail from addresses in your contact list. Anything that is identified by Hotmail as "junk" will be put in junk email folder and you won't ever see it unless you go to that folder. You can even set it up to where junk mail is deleted immediately upon arrival in that folder or is kept for a short time. Where you see the tabs for "Today", "Mail", "Calendar" and "Contacts" you would click on "Mail" then choose "Options" to the right of those tabs.

by jdclyde

I am not worried about hotmail users getting spammed, it is the spam that comes FROM the header hotmail.com.

I am aware that almost all spam is spoofed, but I just see the majority of the spam that gets by our spam filter says from hotmail.

by maxsecdsl.pipex.com

the 'from' is usually spoofed anyway, and shouldn't be relied upon by you anti-spam system.

Same could be said for yahoo.com etc etc.

have a look at spamassassin for a nice cheap & very good solution to this, otherwise you'll be check ip-locations and blocking everything outside you continent like verizon do (bad idea btw).

by colinp

A great product we use is called Businessmail (www.netcplus.com) which has an amazing antispam system for not a lot of money. It is also a very versatile mail programme.

by colinp

A great product we use is called Businessmail (www.netcplus.com) which has an amazing antispam system for not a lot of money. It is also a very versatile mail programme.

by jdclyde

And because of the tonnage involved (cement products) we only do business with our state and the two or three that neighbor us, so outside the country really would not affect us on a business level.

But I am still not looking to block ANYTHING from ANYWHERE that could be legitamate.

by filip_declercq

Maybe I'm wrong, but I think my solution is the best and easiest way dealing with spam, but needs a worldwide change.

My proposal: only allow mails that contain a digital certificate, issued by a trusted certificate authority that certifies the identity of the mailer (so: not only certification of e-mail address). Unsigned mail can then be interpreted as possible spam.
Sounds easy, but needs a worldwide adoption to work good. But: adoption could go fast, if e.g. Microsoft would integrate this into their new release of Outlook (Express).

Identity verification doesn't have to be expensive: Thawte does it for free. Besides this, it could be a nice job for the government. The Belgian government for instance (where I live) has started the issue of digital identity cards, which makes digitaly signing possible. (more info: e.g. on http://www.microsoft.com/belux/nl/eid/ )

Final step in this process (for ultimate success) is changing legislation: spam has to be illegal and prosecuted. This would be the hardest step, I think.

Maybe I'm dreaming...

by th7711

Totally agree the concept. However, human like to cover themselves in Internet and a lot of shadow ISP is not regulated in some contries. It takes a lot of effort to enforce/implement. For example, HK has started to issue digital ID card with e-cerf and promoted the usage for two years. The penetration is still limited.

by jdclyde

It already is in most if not all of the US.

That doesn't stop some scumbag from setting up their server in another country that doesn't have laws to stop that and remotely control it.

They need to take it a step further and prosocute ANYONE involved with it at any level. From gleaming the addresses, to selling the lists, to using the lists. Jail time, not a fine. Give them a boy friend that will be a real friend in the end, if you know what I mean.

by myron_s

Should I get a flurry of junk from hotmail to my company network then I'll just block the lot from Hotmail. Simple as that.

by tony_c_nz

I am employed by a small business that now has very little spam (guess we are lucky!). The amount of spam reduced considerably when we installed Mailwasher (a FireTrust product). I tried it on my home pc, and was so impressed we now have it at work. It screens email on the server, allowing the receiver to view in part (or in full, with / without headers) BEFORE it is downloaded, and determine if the mail is spam / virus / just plain dodgy.

A reporting system allows you to add suspect addresses to a spam database, so that in future any further from that address, or domain, is automatically identified as spam (being in a database it helps all users of the programme, not just you). Programme is very adaptable to users requirements, and allows addresses to be black or white listed.

Features: options to delete (from server), bounce, or blacklist (or all three if you so wish). Bouncing the email gives the impression your addy is not an active one and hopefully helps keep it off spammers lists! Although this compounds the problem of unnecessary mail, I believe it is justified. Spoofed addresses are usually picked up immediately, so the message will not bounce.

As a customer, I will often use a Hotmail addy for an initial on-line inquiry until I am sure I can trust the site.

Have recently switched to g-mail, and found that brilliant, not only because I have 1GB storage, but if I should not be able to access my account for more than 30 days, I know they will not have closed it on me (they allow nine months). I have used it for a few weeks now, AND NOT ONE BIT OF SPAM :-D

www.mailwasher.com to look, to download for a free trial (30 days). I think it is about $UDS40 to buy.... well worth considering IMHO, though not sure how effective this will be where the email traffic is very heavy.
Cheers
Tony

by munezrhep

There are more reliable e-mail service providers out there. Change then.

I think I heard of Hotmail. But never tried because most of us use the famous 'y'....mail and others too!

Block Hotmail.com if:
- you can prove that they don't/can't do anything against spam.
- it's annoying (in the sense). if you can't take it anymore.

Else...I don't know why you chose Hotmail.com =)

by jdclyde

I am picking on hotmail because about 60% of EVERYTHING that gets by our spam filter has a hotmail header.

I do not need viagra or a mortgage or a date with a lonely housewife. Got enough problems with my own wife, let alone put up with someone elses wife.

by jdelasaux

Since Congress is totally in the dark about Spam, and the Internet gurus/governors refuse to install an address authentication system such as AMTP ... let's get with it.

I guess we will just have to start punishing some of the more outrageous ISP's ourselves.

If we all blacklisted Hotmail in our own email programs' Rules, the outcry might get someone's attention.

I, for one, am outraged at the condition that those in charge of the Internet policies have allowed the spammers to degrade the Internet to.

by techrepublic.com

I don't know what business you're in, but blocking other than plain text would mean us not missing over half of our customer emails.
I would guess this definitely is not an option in most businesses.

by jaqui

since email is meant for text messages, why do I need the multimedia crap in a text message?

I don't want advertising in email.
I don't want pictures or coloured text.

plaint old black and white text...well since my system is defaulted to cyan on black ...

I'm not going to pay for your data transfer wastage by sending html email.

yes those html formatted emails use more data transfer and cost you more money.

since my business email signature states that only plain text email accepted, anyone that can't read deserves to get undeliverable message.

by mr l

Clearly you do not administer email for a medium or parge business...else you would be told to rescind those text-only rules, and you would have to live with it.

Saying "I said plain text, if you can't read you don't deserve to send email to my Fortune 500 multi-billion business" will accomplish one thing and one thing only for the manager of that email environment...that being...to allow him the chance to update his resume.

Cheers

by cactus pete

And someone looking to be a client of the business sends mail to you when their IT department configured all the Outlook clients to send mail in HTML by default.... Now they think you can't receive mail, why would they want to do business with you?

We must work with the lowest common denominator, unfortuantely, and keep it as safe and steady as possible.

by jdclyde

I loath html e-mail.

If you want me to see your pretty advertising, include a link that I can click on IF I CHOSE.

Too many scripts can be run in html e-mail, so I NEVER accept as html for myself. Unfortunately I can't enforce this for the users as I am the Net/sys admin, not the e-mail admin. So instead I get the joy of going around the state to clean up the systems when they are so clogged with malware and viruses that you can't even run just e-mail.

Waa hoo!

M$, you are a bane on my existence with all your auto crap.

by cholmes

Hotmail.com & msn.com are already blocked in my domain, as well as the *.info, *.biz & *.tv

I haven't blocked AOl becuase we have several people that use AOL from home to send themselves reminders, etc....like me!

by jk91

I've been blocking hotmail for a while now. I've yet to look at a log and see that a legit email has been blocked from hotmail (whether actually from hotmail or spoofed). If a business is using hotmail accounts it probably isn't one we care to communicate with.

by mollenhourb9

If you are getting SPAMmed to death by hotmail then hey, block it. Just check one thing first. How many of your companies customers are using Hotmail? Does the CEO's wife email him using Hotmail (or does the CEO's husband...)? Are the hotmail accounts spoofed.

I was blocked from emailing my own mother (from my home account) by Earthlink, because somebody spoofed by Charter email address, even though I had firewalls, virus protection, and a few "trick" entries in my address book. Earthlink thought I was spamming them. The real tip off was when I spammed myself.

Once you've checked all those things, go for it. I suggest you also put something on your company web site telling potential customers that they will not be able to get in touch with you via Hotmail. You DO NOT want to the the "network admin who brought our customers to their knees".

by jdclyde

Thanks.

It does bring out all the main reasons NOT to block.

Anyone who has read my posts before will know that I am not a big advocate of the IT NAZI, and it isn't my intention here.

by mbaumli

I still have a single vendor who does have Hotmail.com as a domain. Yes there are people who do use free email services as their email provider.

Even so doing, I deal with a massive amount of spam and killing hotmail would probably make about a 5% or less dent of the overall total. After spending months tinkering with a Lotus Notes Filter, the only thing that I realize is that Spam is every evolving when it comes to being blocked. What may work flawlessly one way may not work at all the next day.

by doctordisk

Unfortunately, I didn't foresee spam in the early nineties when I put my company e-mail address on my company web-site.
I also opened doctordisk AT hotmail DOT com which I used while away from home until I set up web-mail access to my drdisk DOT com DOT hk server. Since then I mainly used it for occasional private stuff.
Also, in the early days, I naively entered my "real" e-mail address when downloading stuff.
When spam first exceeded 200 / day I bought MailWasher, which worked really well, except that I now think it was a mistake to turn on "bouncing".
The one trouble with MailWasher was that I still had to at least glance at the headers of the mails marked for deletion. After a while I was having to have a "quick look" at over 500 spam a day in case there was "real" mail therein.
I noticed that my "paid for" Hotmail account (not a "free" one) never got more than one or two spam in the Inbox any day and most days it got none.
Eventually, after four days in the same fortnight at over 1000 spam, for my own sanity, I made the decision to abandon my company address. I set up a "vacation" type system that answered the first e-mail from any given address and referred them to my web-site to get my new e-mail address. There on my web-site the new address was given using extra spaces and AT and DOT (as shown above). My old company account is set to forward the mail it answers to my hotmail address but to delete any susequent mail from the same sending address.
A filter in MailWasher sorts all mail forwarded to my hotmail address from my company address so that it is very easy to check before deleting.
The first day this was in operation it was forwarding over 500 per day, but the drop off was very rapid. Within a month it was less than 50 a day. Now there is only a trickle. Meanwhile every decent person who sends real mail looks at my website, follows the directions and sends again to my hotmail account.
Now, a few months later, I get lots of real mail to my hotmail account and one or two spam. One day last week, 5 spam arrived.
My plan is to leave this system working for about a year, and then to close down my company account altogether.
My e-mail checking time has now decreased from over three hours hours per day down to only 15 to 45 minutes depending on how many I actually need/decide to answer.
These days I like Hotmail!

by hdanielb

Not only because used as disposable to send spam: MS also use their msn messenger service as a hook to make people take a hotmail account. Users beleive by default that they can?t get messenger without hotmail. (using passport.com)
Once this account is known by messenger contacts it is used as a regular email address, and sometimes is difficult to enforce use of corporate email accounts, without depending of hotmail.
Also difficult to filter its access thru the web; it can be accessed thru several domains like login.passport.net, g.msn.com, etc.
Besides, if you try to enforce the use of a non-ms email client, sometimes you can?t get rid of emails thru hotmail. Some little "poppers" services (hotmail popper, frepops, etc. ) can help to hold email transactions exclusively inside your corporate, or favorite email client.
All this makes very difficult to block emails from hotmail, because great part of users contacts have an account. The only real approach to solution is blocking every email that is not in contact list, and taking them to a bulk email folder, which users should inspect periodically, with an extra training in order to take real emails from there.

by myers-j

I agree 100% and gone that route. I had to back off though because too many legitimate e-mails from hotmail were not getting through.

by hgordon

I'm surprised that you are even taking the time to "considerate" it. Just do it. It is a 100% positive for every one in your organization who receives e-mail.

by vegac

Most of my users use either Hotmail or Yahoo at work. They are both bad news when it comes to SPAM however at times they are needed in our daily work.

by deacon336

A more useful way to handle SPAM for us was to install Microsoft's Intelligent Message Filter. It has eliminated ~95% of our SPAM from all sources.

If you are running Exchange Server 2003 with Outlook XP or 2003 clients it is a great solution and the price is right (free). It is easy to discard true SPAM and put the "gray" items in the user's Junk-Mail folder for review. BUT, I strongly suggest that you read the documentation carefully so you do not throw away mail you want to keep.

FWIW, I now know that approximately 75% of all e-mail we receive is SPAM.

This link is to the download page at MS.
http://www.microsoft.com/exchange/downloads/2003/imf/default.mspx

by texasjetter

We were using McAfee's Spam Assasian which worked ok for a while. But it degraded to only catching ~65% of spam. I changed to the Intelligent Messaging Filter and it gets 92% of the spam with 0 false positive. I recently change the upper end of the filter to reject anthing above 5 and that has dropped over 10,000 spam messages in just 5 days. Considering I only have about 65 users I think that is significant. I have gone from getting 60-70 spam in my Inbox down to 6 or 7 a day!

by deathtoliberalism

The internet is still too new for a lot of people out there, and to them hotmail is a great convenience, and some even think it makes them look professional to be linked up with microsoft. They don't look at things the same way that you or I necessarily do.

I tried to block hotmail at work, and too many people complained of lost business correspondance, so for now, it stays.

by jdclyde

for taking the time to respond with the ideas.

Even if your not saying what I WANT you to say, it still helps keep the objective on track. Which is to provide my users with a valuable tool that helps them do their jobs better so the company can make lots of money so I can get a raise and some new toys.

I am not one to try to restrict what the company allows (think web radio, oh well)

by ole88

is to send a number of these UCE messages to the hotmail.com spam address and see if you can get them to change their policy. If they are spoofed messages, hotmail (and Microsoft) are large enough to try tracking the spammers down and go after them.

I am not saying that you want to send EVERY ONE of these messages back, just what you can afford to timewise. The more the better, but every little bit counts.

by jdclyde

Thanks!

It is just depressing.

I have a spam filter that blocks about 600 SPAMS a day, and I still get about 20 per users that still get through (120 users).

And of course I can't get them to STOP CLICKING ON THAT "REMOVE" LINK. GRRRRRRR.

by stillcatchingup

We have used hotmail and yahoo accounts in the past, because a company we did daily business with used a spam blocking company that black-listed our ISP. It took our ISP over 4 months to prove that the SPAM was not coming from their site and was able to get their name removed.

Just something to think about.

by jdclyde

done that.

Was black listed on a CBL list, and it was a beotch to stay off it for more than a day at a time for about a month.

It has been about two weeks since we have been listed.

by jdclyde

Just a hint, for this to be helpful you need to share the solution you found.

Thanks!

by jimy

We use a spam appliance called DoubleCheck that eliminated the problem completely. Also gives admins and mgmt the ability to report on usage, block viruses, etc.

by scminter

Try ASSP. It is FREE and it blocks spam at the SMTP level. That way spammers spammers smtp software might think the addresses are bad and remove them.

I've been using it for months here and it has been great. I only have 100 mailboxes though so I don't know how well it will scale.

by itdood

A spammer would never actually use a hotmail account to send SPAM FFS. I'm thinking if someone sent out a few million emails from their hotmail account it just might violate their TOS??

For our org, much of the recruiting we do is online, and many candidates use free email services to communicate with us, so blocking one of them would hurt business.

Blocking or black listing based on the Domain name itself is a very poor anti spam strategy. It's not a best practice in the least because given viruses and SPAM, up to 70% of all SMTP connctions have a spoofed FROM: address. You'll be chasing your tail and hurting users.

If you are running an email server and wish to implement anti-spam techniques you should look into DNSBL or RDNS at the edge. That will block about 75% of all spam at the connection which is very nice. The connection is 550-ed so there's no data exchanged.

From there, pass on what's left to a dictionary/isolation type filter.

With that approach, you'll achieve about 98% blocking of SPAM with very little false-positives.

There's surfcontrol, ironport, brighmail, postini to name a few vendors. You should isolate your mail exchanger anyway, you could use Symantec enterprise gateway at the edge which also uses DNSBL and does virus filtering before it even hits the local MTA and stores which offloads your local email and provides better services to your users.

by dbucyk

I'm with Telus and I hate it for what they say they can do.

They say they are also trying to eliminate spam or at least reduce it and I have had to use Outlook Express and configure some mail rules to just delete it, but I still have the odd one come in and yes, it's from either hotmail or some other person.

Blocking hotmail is actually a good idea. I have no use for them either. They do give you a chance to set up an email account with them, but, with all the viruses and spam that come from hotmail and MSN messenger, I wholeheartedly agree that hotmail is a nuisance and has to be dealt with accordingly.

by jcptech

I use a very cost effective service that is no sweat to setup and 98-99% effective. I work at an educational institution so my prices are a bit lower, I pay approx. $800 for 120 email accounts a year. AppRiver blocked 130,000 junk mail and additionally filtered out over 3000 virus infected emails. The time it saves me and everyone else it more then pays for itself. I looked into linux box filter which is free but I'd have constant work to do, I've looked at software that has definition updates like AV but it's more trouble and money then AppRiver. If you have your own email server it would be worth checking it out. http://www.appriver.com/

by industrial_controller

I use free email accounts for testing purposes and "off the record" communication. No one has questioned my professionalism as a result.

by jcbrooks_bs9

I use hotmail for work related purposes for two reasons. One i have bounced around the country quite a bit in the last ten years and got tired of changeing e-mail addresses to all my contacts evrytime I switched ISP's and secondly the price is right.

by deback2u

Everybody talks about spam but who really is doing anything about it. It's not Hotmail that is causing the emails, it's the spammer. Why not make the proliferaters suffer? I believe if bandwidth was reduced based upon IP addresses the email multipliers would be more selective in what they pass along and may even offer up the idiots who think volume is better than content. Why not look at the source instead of the result?

by mr l

Great idea...not new, but great nonetheless.

Now...please tell us all how to go about doing that.

by deback2u

The trick is finding the perpetrator. I figure working backward will force people to keep identifying where the originator is located.
My suggestion is to drop back one level at a time e.g. T3,T1, then drop baud until it reaches 110. You cannot stop someone from using the internet but you can surely slow them down.

by mr l

I manage 13,000+ desktops and the Notes environment that supports them as well. Try blocking the hotmail domain and then permitting on an explicit basis. You can do this for all major spam-factory domains (yes I know they are spoofing...just easier this way), yahoo, msn, aol, etc...

Great tool to implement this? Several, we use Trend, but any "Name" player in the space will handle this simple level of filtering for you.

Have someone who "needs" all the junk allowed through? With Trend or any other competent product for Domino you would be able to drop that internal user into an exceptions list the eliminates the spam filtering functions. (NOTE, make anyone who wants onto this list fight tooth and nail to get there...and make sure that they or the person insisting you put them there outranks you...else say NO, loudly)

by caleb38

I am the I.T. manager for a company of about 50 people. We have several Yahoo retail websites hosted by Yahoo! and were inundated with SPAM. Out of frustration and desperation, I installed a program called Qurb, a whitelist program, at the client level. This program is easy to use and manage and works great. We've been running it now for about two years and I've never looked back. More importantly, I still have a job!

by caleb38

I am the I.T. manager for a company of about 50 people. We have several Yahoo retail websites hosted by Yahoo! and were inundated with SPAM. Out of frustration and desperation, I installed a program called Qurb, a whitelist program, at the client level. This program is easy to use and manage and works great. We've been running it now for about two years and I've never looked back. More importantly, I still have a job!

by bakpkg

Way too many people are confused by spam. I have used hotmail since MS set it up and would be lost without it. It keeps my personal and business email accounts free from spam as I never give them out to the sites that request I register (ie the one your on now for example). I use a whitelist filter on the hotmail account which lets me delete junk in mass. Secondly 99% of the spam I get is spoofed so blocking the return address is a waste of time and blocking a domain like hotmail makes even less sense. For all you admins who only want you users using the business address to sign up with are just asking for the spam you get. The accounts are free and have generous sizes so use them to catch the spam. As for sending the spam to the hotmail support staff, I have done this but unless it is a phishing attack I don't as they are swamped and will only tell you the address is spoofed. As for blocking domains I guess we should block Paypal, Ebay, Citibank, Suntrust, Regions, etc as I have been spammed and hit with phishing attacks from all of the them also.

by simontew

My brother works for T-Mobile, the German-based cell phone carrier. More than a year ago they blocked all incoming mail from Hotmail accounts.

No doubt there were a few irritated friends of staff members who found they were no longer welcome. On the other hand, as you say, who uses Hotmail for business? And, if you've got a complaint, you can send it via their website so they won't have annoyed many customers.

Here where I work we have to quarantine all suspected spam for a few days in case it turns out to be real emails. The email team have had to pay for huge upgrades to the Exchange Server so they can store the spam during quarantine. If you can stop the spam hitting your firewall in the first place, by blocking Hotmail, you'll reduce the amount of storage you require.

Only problem I can foresee is Are any customers likely to try to contact you from Hotmail accounts? If so, you'll have to balance out the benefits of reducing your email storage space against the potential loss of goodwill from customers who get blocked.

-Si

by codejock

Yes, I have clients who use Hotmail accounts strictly to test inbound mail when it looks like the POP3 server is acting flaky.

I very aggressively filter spam for my own domains. I use Spamhaus' XBL and SBL to block connections from known spam IPs.

Hotmail is the bane of your existence. I've found the majority of spam spattering my domains comes from the Asia-Pacific and Latin America/Carribbean address blocks.

If the connection originates from either an APNIC or LACNIC IPv4 address, the server closes the connection with a status 550 "Connection attempt denied from banned IP. Use Web form at [domain's contact us Web page address]". We haven't found a spammer yet who will manually enter their message into a Web form.

Most spam we see have forged headers. We don't even bother sending a bounce message. The mail flows into a folder which gets reviewed before getting dumped to the bit bucket. If the mail is legitimate, it gets forwarded to the user.

Now before I get lectured about how one shouldn't just unequivocally ban whole IPv4 address blocks, let me remind detractors of the policy of the following:

1. We do no business with companies or customers in Asia, Australia, NZ, Latin America or the Caribbean.

2. We offer an alternate means that allows legitimate customers and businesses to contact us other than e-mail.

3. The Internet is an interconnection of thousands of *private* networks and systems. Your freedom of expression ends at my network boundary. I am under no obligation to accept your connection just because you want to make it. Your use of *my* resources is subject to *my* policies of acceptable use. My AUP excludes unsolicited bulk commercial e-mail. If APNIC and LACNIC ISPs continue to choose to host spammers on their systems, I'll continue to choose to deny connections on my SMTP port to them. Network closed. Go away.

Some customers follow anti-spamming advice and get disposible accounts from hotmail, gmail and other services like them for e-commerce purposes. We haven't cut off those domains yet. If we started swimming in spam from them, we'd ban the sender domain and explain that their customers need to vent their spleens at the provider.

by jdclyde

Could you post what ranges of IP's you deny?

I am in the same boat that we barely go out of the state, and Never out of the country accept Canada, and everyone knows they don't count (I hope you either have a sence of humor or are not from Canada or both).

Thanks!

by ndynamics

I am fighting the other side of the coin on a daily basis. As more and more IT admins block entire domains and implement spam filtering poorly, I have to answer more and more end user complaints about email not getting through to the recipient. Nobody bothers to check for false positives in their junk mail folders any more.

Blocking entire domains is NOT the answer. We have to fight the spammer's abilities to spoof addresses. The sender policy framework (SPF) looks like it might really address this problem. We need to get Microsoft, AOL, and a few other big guys on board with this standard. Once it gets support from over half of the ISP community, plus Exchange Server, it has the potential to nip this problem in the butt. You have to know what you are doing to properly configure SPF, so start reading up on it.

I use MailEssentials from GFI with Exchange Server. The 10.1 release has SPF filtering capabilities. Any domain who has bothered to implement SPF records in DNS is totally stopped at my filter if the address is spoofed. Virtually 100% of the time. Many of the big ISP's are already supporting SPF.

I'm sure SPF has limitations, the biggest one being admins who don't know what they are doing trying to configure it. I am not positive it's foolproof, but I haven't been able to think of a way around it yet.

by greyseal96

I've had to sign in numerous times lately at their little screen that they use to verify that you're a human and not a spam program. I got annoyed at this and wrote a message to MS about it. Basically, we'll just have to put up with it. If it works, that's cool, but I'd have to be extremely optimistic to believe that...Here's how they responded:

Thank you for writing to MSN Hotmail Technical Support.

This is Cris and I am writing in response to your issue on your account that seems to repeatedly require verification of your identity. I appreciate the feedback you sent us and I sincerely apologize for any inconvenience this has caused you.

The characters you are being asked to enter is part of the Human Interactive Proof (HIP) validation process we have implemented to verify valid users and to help stop both incoming and outgoing unsolicited mail (SPAM). This security measure helps make it very difficult for spammers to employ automated programs that use the Hotmail system to send unsolicited e-mail.

We're continually evaluating the process to ensure that we limit the number of customers receiving multiple challenges and are already taking measures to help improve this process in upcoming releases.

It is possible that you may receive challenges on a regular basis and we ask for your cooperation by filling out the text when prompted, as you will be helping us in our ongoing fight against SPAM.

Please allow me to share with you the facts and tips about the HIP validation process:

1. It is possible to receive multiple challenges within a day or every few days. This will be dependent on the amount and types of messages you're sending. However, this should diminish over time.
2. You need to correctly enter the text on the screen to be able to access your account. If you have any concern seeing the picture and your computer has speakers, please click the "I can't see this picture" link. This will bring up an audio file that will play the numbers and letters you are supposed to enter to ensure what you're entering is correct.
3. If you are writing a message that has an attachment, you will need to re-attach it to your original message.

Again, I want to thank you for your cooperation and we're confident that you will see the benefits that this process adds to your overall Hotmail experience.

If you have any other suggestions or concerns, please feel free to write back and we'll be happy to assist you.

Thank you for your continued support.

Sincerely,

Cris B. Jr.
MSN Hotmail Technical Support

by bhamm

Look at the hidden headers and block anything that comes from a cable system. You'll find that reduces your email way down.

by scooterb

I am constantly monitoring my mail server and see that many of the spams that come in do come from Hotmail accounts. And yes, I do use anti-spam software, but the fact that it actually hits the server causes it to have to use CPU time and effort. I don't think it's worth having to utilize my servers time and horsepower to decide if I really want it sent through. Why not just stop it at the firewall and be done with it. I have come very close to blocking it before, but haven't. As the days go by and more and more comes in, I get allot closer. I don't think I would apologize to anyone either.

by dr dij

I use plain text email but only at home.

Then you avoid any possibility of 'mouse-over' scripts activating or automatic scripts running off retarded windows / outlook flaws like buffer overflows.

I see real bizarre spam emails with ?UTF-8=.. and things like that, will never know what they are :)

While I use outlook at work, I've turned off scripting. Then I get the outlook window that states something like 'due to activex in email it may not display correctly'. This is in an ad email from Oracle who should know better, and an IM security firm (who especially should know better!). Try this yourself and you'll see that scripts are actually executing in these garbage emails. I tried viewing the source but it was so complicated the script could have been anywhere. Could have been a real penetration attempt.

BTW brightmail is an anti-spam SERVICE. Does more than a simple program could. There are several of these, they use multiple a/v filters plus have networks of spam responders & honeypots to say it is spam before it is sent to you.

by i_am_hellion

Not sure how effective this is but is something I always use when not wanting email addresses to be harvested from a web site.

I never get spammed from these sites with this on it.
The company I work for during my day life recently had concerns from a newly developed web site and once this was implemented it seemed to reduce the concerns.

Glad to help today and not stir anyone up .... LMAO

by unclejohnh

I have blacklisted several of the common spam domains. The few ligitimate clients that use any of these services I add to a white list to allow them through.

Might not be practical for a big shop with a lot of clients using these services. But works well for our small shop. Only had about a half dozen clients that I didn't catch from our address book that had problems.

by cactus pete

The robots.txt file is only good for stopping bots that play by the rules.

But it does keep your address from getting into a search engine and harvested off of yet another site.

by /usr

I just installed mine and I love it! It runs Linux and it prevents 97% of the crap out of our Exchange svr. It AV is better that Symantec, so I chucked that junk too. I'm very happy in the month I've run it so far and It's blocked only 8 or 9 ligitamit messages out of the 114,168 its blocked since Jan 20.

I had a couple of issues upon set up, but I'm very pleased now.

by jaqui

notice being plain text only.
html formatted email is not accepted.
second email html formatted gets your domain reported as a spamming domain.

any company that thinks costing people more to communicate with them is good is not a company that I'm worried about.
they STEAL from people by doing so.

by jaqui

is the newest encoding for plain text, and only windows doesn't support it completely.

utf-8 will also allow multilanguage support far better than the old ascii standard.

applications will translate utf-8 into ascii as well as from original language into your default language, if you have support enabled.

by cactus pete

So any spoofed mail coming in as a particular domain is reported as spam for that domain.

Bouncing mail back to spoofed messages is a waste, and typically scares the crap out of average users whose address was spoofed.

Another scenario:

Senior partner of the law firm representing your company writes to the CEO of your company. His mail, by default, is set to send as html. This guy doesn't read the bounced message before having sent out another message to your CFO.

Important information and questions are missed, filing deadline is not met, your company is either in contempt or out millions of dollars.

Sure, it's an exageration, but who do you think takes the blame when anything like this happens?