Attempt to formalize global warming debate, step 1
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by absolutely
here is a perfectly 'good' post by Deadly Ernest on the 'Global Warming' thread that inspired me to start these. He says that something or other is clearly evident, and it's fine to do so - elsewhere. My plan is that here, for now, we all hold ourselves to a higher standard, which I express as "Don't [i]tell[/i] me it is clearly evident; [i]show[/i] me. Make it as clear to me as it is to you. Above all, keep your [i]opinions[/i] to yourself. If I were swayed to share your opinion simply by your stating that you hold it as an opinion, I wouldn't be worth your effort to convince in the first place. I'm only interested in seeing you present the [i]facts[/i] on which you have based your opinion."
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=207065&messageID=2149606
I have to emphasize that no offense is meant to Deadly Ernest; as I said, his post is perfectly within the expectations of etiquette on TR, but I want to do something a little bit different this time.
by deepsand
We do not expect that you hold that there can be no doubt as to man's role, only that you accept that the current scientific evidence supports such a conclusion, and that there is presently no other good explanation.
Furthermore, if we are to anticipate our opponents' objections, we will most assuredly require our own loyal opposition, someone who will critically example our work with an honest scepticism.
claiming victory on obvious personal and aesthetic grounds before we even begin - I guess that's off limits?
$hit.
by absolutely
and then offer no apologies or recompense for your actions but insist on penalising me and others for wanting to plant only some of OUR seed stock and eat some as we have nothing else on hand. All this while insisting you take some of our seed stock to replant your own fields. now that's stupid, and you should have no recourse when we tell you to take a running jump off a tall cliff and leave us alone.
Now that's a bit closer to my point about the problems with Kyoto. You want to set things up so you don't pay for your past errors while punishing others trying to get things sorted.
by tonythetiger
by heml0ck
I feel that we have had an impact, but have we considered ALL the variables? I dunno....
That being said, we have hard data on carbon emissions, and the hole in the ozone layer, so I believe that we must take action to reduce greenhouse gasses. I truly believe it is irrelevant whether we are contributors or not; we need to protect/manage our climate and environment.
by tonythetiger
by heml0ck
Such as:
~a commitment to neutrality.
~a commitment to giving equal opportunity to all view points to state their cases.
~a commitment to ensuring that all participants understand and agree to the terms of engagement.
~a commitment to enforcing the rules of engages ment.
Note that this does not equate judging, rather refereeing.
I propose that once the debate is over, that a vote be taken to declare a winner based on predefined criteria like clarity of argument, cited references, sportsman-like conduct, what-have-you.
by heml0ck
I'm not very well educated on the subject. I'm looking forward to seeing all the viewpoints and data as it is presented. It should be good for everyone involved to increase their exposure to all issues and viewpoints.
I just hope that we can keep it civil ;)
by absolutely
by dr dij
by absolutely
by tig2
My rationale for not stepping into this debate is that I simply do not know enough about the subject. I don't believe that I am able to contribute to either side.
I do think that those of us who have the opportunity to read the debate should be able to clarify if they have materially changed their thinking and if so, what prompted that change.
What I know for certain today is that I will be following the discussion and seeking additional information on my own. I have a belief but at this time cannot back that belief with adequate facts.
by absolutely
Kidding. This is slightly less (in one sense) and slightly more (in another sense) than a 'debate team' exercise.
Less: none of us, apparently, are high school students, hoping to improve our college applications with extracurriculars.
More: several of us have established affections, animosities, and strident opinions on this topic.
My conclusion: I'm happy to stay with my plan of a separate thread, where interested but uninvolved TR members are invited to post about which arguments are convincing to them and why. The other option I somewhat like is allowing spectators to reply within the debate thread, with "[spectator]" or "[non-participant]" in the beginning of the titles of their posts.
by absolutely
...go to your respective 'corners' and prepare for the actual debate?
Thanks, whether you do or don't, you're both fun to argue with/against.
by absolutely
just yet.
I plan on taking 3 weeks or more to collect & interpret data, prepare arguments, etc. Please be patient. This will be grand.
Whether a success or a failure, this will be grand!
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
of my emotions, and there I agreed with you. I am quicker to anger than I would like to be, and you are right to take me to task for it when you see me speak before I think.
Here, you tell me to mind my own business when I point out that you have contradicted a previous statement - not your core values, just a previous statement, and I don't believe I was excessively harsh. And, I observe that you had declared yourself 'out', but returned to post an insult, not a dispute of fact. Finally, you posted on a public forum, not a private e-mail. I don't see where I have intruded into your business.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
by pat
by noelrd
Let them do whatever they want to "solve" whatever "problem" they'd like, whether that "problem" be real or perceived, and neither side should force the other to do, or not do, anything.
IF they are right, then THEY are failing to act on solving their own problem. IF they are right, there are SO MANY of them, they could have a huge impact on future technology -- IF they "just did it". But they don't, thus the proof that their real agenda is something other than what they claim.
by absolutely
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
Falsly accusing others of making outrageous claims does not garner credibility.
A hundred years ago, nobody knew anything about global warming!
by rob mekel
There is a certain writer who had some extreme ideas. One of his lesser extreme ideas was travelling around the world in 80 day's.
The more extreme ideas, fiction as it was claimed to be, were to be never taken serious, back then that is.
Nowadays it is said the man was a visionary. Maybe in future we will say the same of this swedish scientist.
Rob
[i]edited for some idiotic typos[/i]
by absolutely
"And as such, it's not even worthy of consideration for public debate."
What precedes seems to be your argument in favor of that assertion. It's well-constructed and welcome, and I have no interest in circumventing your right nor anybody else's rights to due process. Nor, by the way, is my motive to advance Al Gore's political agenda. The scientific evidence as I have reviewed it thus far was convincing to me, but I want to review the major components of that research at one go, thus this project.
by deepsand
by absolutely
Granted. There are data and numerical computer models that [i]claim[/i] predictive ability which itself is unproven, but [i]accepted by the public as proven[/i].
"As such, to expect them to act on it, is tantamount to blackmail and manipulation based on fear and ignorance. And as such, it's not even worthy of consideration for public debate."
Completely true, but it [i]is already[/i] a subject of public debate, and public [i]action[/i]. I think I'm in close agreement with you on the principle that the "package deal" is a logical fallacy, and always invalid. I started this debate precisely to de-couple these issues, which are illogially conflated within the premises of many "stakeholders". I do not expect it to be easy. I also doubt very much that the counter-argument of "package-dealing" will be made as competently without your participation as it would with it. What do you have to lose by participating? Will your taxes be raised any less if you abstain?
by deepsand
by deepsand
by deepsand
1) Pre-debate, take a TR wide poll re. the degree to which members agree/disagree with certain points.
2) Post debate, take a 2nd poll, on the same points, using the responses only from those who voted in the 1st.
by deepsand
And, how gracious of others to [b]not[/b] point out your equally trivial errors.
It must be ever so nice to be so perfect.
by absolutely
by deepsand
"[i]The comments re forest was pointing out that they have no right to tell people not to cut forests down, when they've already cleared most of theirs.[/i]"
To generalize, it states that "those who have made a mistake have no right to attempt to have others avoid making the same mistake, even when such would have adverse consequences for all."
I do not see that being an matter of politics, but of reason.
by deepsand
The postulate that man's combustion of fossil fuels would, by increasing atmospheric CO2, thus increasing the planet's temperature, was first presented in 1896, 110 years ago!
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
Even I did'nt realize how old this issue was until I discovered the American Institute of Physics' site.
I hope you're learning as much as I am; assuming, that is, that we each have the time for such.
Enjoy.
and a good thing to try to fix any errors you have made. But you have no right to try and put in place a system to force others to do as you want or put in place a system to punish others if they don't do as you want. And you definitely don't have the right to take the moral high ground on the issue, or demand that other people suffer hardships or difficulties because they wish to emulate part of what you've done. Especially when you refuse to accept any responsibility for what you've done and don't try to do any extensive corrections within your own resources.
The fact that the KP does things in that manner is evidence that it's more political than environmental - especially when those pushing constantly refuse to accept a stance that would make them responsible for fixing up what they did that they perceive as wrong.
by christy623
by deepsand
Try learning the physical sciences involved before putting your foot in it. For starters, see the American Institute of Physics site, at
http://www.aip.org/history/climate/summary.htm
&
by tonythetiger
will continue to go back and forth as their understanding changes, those who interpret this for the rest of us will continue to go back and forth depending on what they want us to do about it, and the climate will continue to shift from hot to cold. See the pattern?
:)
by deepsand
When it may very well go to my survival, I've every right to compel you, by force if need be, to not endanger me.
Your freedom to swing your fist ends at my nose.
in summary, you screwed up and placed both our lives at risk, and now insist on telling me how to save us both, while penalising me for wanting to ensure I manage well. Sorry, it is my choice if I share with you or not, and my choice how I use my resources to best suit me. If you wish to pay a fair price for some of my resources, then I'll sell some to you. But you have no right to demand I sell you some at the price and conditions you set out. If you try force, then expect me to defend myself. It is my right to defend myself, and my right to ensure I'll survive properly before worrying about if you'll survive.
------------
Anyway, we should leave this until after the GW debate - I've got a lot of work to do, as I had a lot of links etc and info ready when I had a system crash. During the long tiring recovery of data I made an error and copied some wrong files (easily done after 16 hour straight work) and lost all my email files and bookmarks etc. Now I have to reconstruct much of this environmental research stuff to prepare my case - do you have any idea how long it takes to try and remember and reconstruct a few years of bookmark links - yes I had a back up and lost that as well. grrr. I was tired.
by absolutely
Well, that [i]was[/i] my original hope, but I didn't want to keep pestering you, like a schoolmarm or whatever.
That said, I will provide another forum specifically for resuming this and other policy issues related to globabl warming, and possibly other environment issues. I am now planning on a separate 'therefore, what' thread, [i]after[/i] & separate from the 'yes vs. no' thread. I understand that many people view these (and other such) questions as 'intertwined' but I say there is value in 'disentangling' such issues, progressing systematically from the premise 'global warming is caused in significant part by humans', proving that premise to a satisfactory degree of certainty to influence consumers to opt for non-polluting solutions like battery-powered cars or else failing to prove that premise and continuing to burn petroleum 'like it is going out of style', and likewise for all other consequent and corollary propositions to that premise, (or the contrary premise, as the case may be).
by deepsand
by georgesr
by absolutely
by deepsand
Quote
1) I, through either ignorance or stupidity, eat up nearly all of the available seed stock of a grain that is critical to the long term survival of humanity.
2) I have an epiphany, and come to realize that, if our collective continued existent is to be realized, the remaining seed stock must not be eaten, but planted; and, we will need to eat something else until such time as there is once more enough grain for us to eat the desired amount while ensuring that the amount eaten will be replaced by new growth.
3) However, since I am the one who got us into this mess, I have no "right" to determine what is the best course for ensuring our survival; and, the rest should consume the little bit that remains?
unquote
Each farmer harvests his crops and splits it into feed stock and seed stock. You present the case, in point 1, that you've eaten all your feed stock and moved onto your seed stock. As an intelligent farmer, I wouldn't eat my seed stock, unless it was the last food source available, and then I'd stretch it out as I know I need it.
In point 2, you introduce unstated alternative food sources while stating you've woken up to your stupidity.
In point 3, you point out you have no RIGHT to determine what is the best course (which is correct, you can advise but you do NOT control my resources). You then make an assumption that we are going to eat the rest of the seed stock, i.e. you assume we're as silly as you are.
The reality that i point out, is that I will continue to consume my seed, the feed stock, while conserving my seed stock. I also pointed out that I might set aside more feed stock as seed stock for bargaining purposes later. I'll also utilise the unstated additional food sources you mention.
In all of this I have the right to decide what I'll do with my resources and how I'll sell any, if I do. You have no right to tell me what to do with my property, nor the right to penalise me if I ignore your advice and do as I think is best for me.
The likely situation is that you'll advice me to save all my feed stock as seed stock, to maximise the new planting when it's time to plant. But being smarter and knowing that I must have some of the feed stock in my daily diet to keep off certain illnesses, I refuse to do as you say and reduce my consumption of feed stock to the minimum needed for good health. Thus maximising my seed stock levels. You are angry that I'm still eating seed when you can't. Why should I risk my health to help you fix your mistakes?
You can admit your error and give advice, but you have no right to force your decisions on my and my resources.
by deepsand
"1) I, through either ignorance or stupidity, eat up nearly all of the available seed stock of a grain that is critical to the long term [b]survival of humanity[/b].
[i]Each farmer harvests his crops and splits it into feed stock and seed stock. You present the case, in point 1, that you've eaten all your feed stock and moved onto your seed stock. As an intelligent farmer, I wouldn't eat my seed stock, unless it was the last food source available, and then I'd stretch it out as I know I need it.[/i]
In fact, I said nothing regarding your vs my stock, be it feed or seed; rather, I said "nearly all of the available seed stock" necessary for the "survival of humanity."
"2) I have an epiphany, and come to realize that, if our collective continued existent is to be realized, the remaining seed stock must not be eaten, but planted; and, we will need to eat something else until such time as there is once more enough grain for us to eat the desired amount while ensuring that the amount eaten will be replaced by new growth."
"3) However, since I am the one who got us into this mess, I have no "right" to determine what is the best course for ensuring our survival; and, the rest should consume the little bit that remains?"
[i]In point 3, you point out you have no RIGHT to determine what is the best course (which is correct, you can advise but you do NOT control my resources). You then make an assumption that we are going to eat the rest of the seed stock, i.e. you assume we're as silly as you are.[/i]
I made no assertion re. my "right;" note the question mark at the end of that sentence. I was re-stating [i]your[/i] claim that I had no such "right" in the form of a question.
[i]In all of this I have the right to decide what I'll do with my resources and how I'll sell any, if I do. You have no right to tell me what to do with my property, nor the right to penalise me if I ignore your advice and do as I think is best for me.[/i]
Since your actions now affect the survival of [b]all[/b], as set forth in my example, [b]everyone[/b] has the natural right to compel you to not act in a manner which threatens the survival of the species.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending