Discussion Locked

[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]

0 helpful
1,352 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,352 replies

by pdarrough

Resistance is futile! Eventually we will all be assimilated by the Microsoft Vista- The best I can do is slow them down by refusing to upgrade for as long as possible. This does nothing to improve my opinion of Microsoft in general.

by techexec2

.
Some people will not be able to avoid Vista forever, but not me. I refuse to upgrade to Vista as my primary OS (maybe on a secondary system, if necessary). And since I cannot stay on Windows XP forever (it will eventually degrade), I am converting my personal workstations to Linux (1). I have been near the breaking point for a few years now. This capricious de-activation nonsense was the last straw.

It really can be done now and I am doing it. Today's Linux is a really strong alternative OS on x86 PC hardware. I've been running it on a secondary machine for a couple of years now. It gets better every year.

The only people who MUST stay with Windows are people who fall into a category like one of these:

- Their boss or users make them. Or, their spouse. :-)

- They want or need to run certain applications that are only available on Windows. Example: iTunes is only available for Windows and Macintosh.

- They are in the Windows business ecosystem: ISV, IHV, VAR, etc.

If you have any interest in exploring Linux as an alternative to Windows, I suggest you download and burn the PCLinuxOS live/install CD (2). You can boot your PC directly from the CD without affecting your hard drive at all. During boot, PCLinuxOS automatically detects all of your hardware and is fully functional (except for no hard drive, unless you mount it yourself from within Linux). Booting from the "Live" CD gives you a fully functional Linux operating system complete with many applications, including OpenOffice. You can also install from the same CD if you wish.

All the best to you!

--------------------------------

(1) The LEAVING WINDOWS Project
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=213495&messageID=2185615

(2) PCLinuxOS - "Linux heaven" for Windows users
http://www.pclinuxos.com

by tig2

That I know personally of one major corporation who is evaluating a Linux to replace the Windows platform.

They are considering this because early testing strongly indicates that their mission critical apps can be easily ported to a Linux based frame and their enterprise apps have suitable replacements that enable their production.

I will be watching this project closely. Mostly because the security value that they perceive from this move has been estimated in the ROI/TCO analysis. From the standpoint of the work I do, I will be watching for migration elements and also security- both inherent in the system and additional layering. The audit should be fascinating.

The company I am watching is publicly traded. Their transition will, no doubt, have others wondering if they wouldn't benefit from this move as well.

by jck

that allows Microsoft to remain dominant in the computer sector as an OS giant is that:

1) the general public remains complacent to be ignorant of anything they don't already know about

2) the general public remains unwilling to learn anything they don't have to even if it is more secure out of the box, runs faster, and costs far less per comparative unit than Microsoft.

3) the private sector tends to follow "trends", even if they are not the best option (both technically as well as fiscally)

Remember...resistance is not futile.

Even Hugh and the other Borg managed to live away from it without mass detrimental effects.

The public needs to be educated that hope is not lost in the computer world if they move away from MS juggernaut.

Linux is far and away an excellent alternative to Microsoft from a technical aspect, especially if you are running older hardware.

Just try and get Vista Premium to run on a PIII-733 with 256MB of RAM efficiently...then run something like Kubuntu/Ubuntu Desktop, Xandros, openSUSE or Mepis...you'll see the speed difference.

I will have to continue to use MS at my work as part of my job...I write Windows apps as my main function. However, I am converting my whole set of home PCs to Linux/dual-boot systems.

If I get my way, I'll try and push for my employer to migrate to Linux on the desktop. You figure, they can't argue with 600+ computer using employees getting new machines every 4 years maximum...at our purchase rate...ends up being more than $100k.

That is enough usually to get any bean counter to consider the option of Linux.

All hope is not lost...Linux can become accepted.

Use the force, Luke. :)

by rkuhn040172

A few things...

1) Pretty arrogant of you to think the general public is somehow dumber than you

2) Just how much faster does the general public need their PC's to run? The general public is buying 2.5-3.2 Ghz processors right now, many dual core just to read their email, surf the web and a few other light duties. Even if Linux were 10-20% faster on comparable systems, would it even matter?

3) OEM Windows cost very little when purchased with a new PC. What, maybe $50-$75? Use it for 3-5 years, that's not a lot of money for the general public.

4) I just installed Win XP on a PIII 450 Mhz laptop and it runs just fine. It took a lot of tweaking, but I was even surprised myself how fast it is running.

5) Why do all employees need a new PC at your company every 4 years max? MS currently offers 5 years of mainstream support. Are you really updating the OS or the hardware?

by tig2

I have some cost factoring analysis (open source, I wrote it- I define the copy left) of migrating a business from Windows to Linux. In this analysis, I did not cover every Linux but instead covered three that I could see as possibles- Enterprise RH, PC Linux OS, and Ubuntu (with some changes). I am working through adding Debian and SuSe to the list.

I haven't actually weighed the doc- I did some security analysis along with the ROI/TCO comparative analysis- but it is a monster that may help.

With very high level understanding of your business, I may even have some appropriate security compliance regs that are satisfied without additional tooling on the base install.

I would love to see more corps choosing Linux. It makes good sense.

by apotheon

1. Substitute "reasonably indisputable" for "indisputable" wherever you see it. Carry on, now. Obviously, if you want to be unreasonable, you can dispute anything.

2. "[i]Indisputable is a very strong word to use when much of your postings are of opinion and not fact as evidenced by so many people disagreeing with you.[/i]"

Fact: Certain things have been happening with Vista.

Fact: These issues can lead to real-world productivity losses, great inconvenience, and other annoyances.

Opinion: TechExec2 considers these things to be unacceptable.

Anyway, "so many people disagreeing with you" is a bit of an exaggeration. Off the top of my head, I can come up with two or three people who called TechExec2 a whiner or zealot, and one (you) who actually disagreed -- but since your disagreement tends to consist of insults, assumptions of bad faith before they're warranted, and unsubstantiated claims, I'm not sure you count.

by rkuhn040172

That's your problem right there.

You said, "Off the top of my head, I can come up with two or three people who called TechExec2 a whiner or zealot, and one (you) who actually disagreed."

That's the arrogance that I'm talking about. Just because only a handful of people on TR disagree with TechExec2 means nothing.

Think about the tens of millions of people that are content with Windows everyday that disagree with TechExec2 and yourself.

That is exactly what's wrong with TR nowadays. The minority have a larger voice than the numbers they represent in the real world. And you are in the minority when it comes to OS choice and many other of your opinions.

Their voice on TR is disproportionate to their real numbers. That's what I've been saying all along.

by apotheon

You read whatever you want to see into what other people have actually said, mentally putting words in their mouths. I'm not sure if it's because you are consciously creating straw-man arguments to knock down, or you're just so invested in your tiny little belief system that you're unwilling to read with an open enough mind to see that you might have overlooked something, but you clearly demonstrate time and time again that you are unable or unwilling to actually respond to the salient points others bring to the discussion.

"[i]You said, 'Off the top of my head, I can come up with two or three people who called TechExec2 a whiner or zealot, and one (you) who actually disagreed.'

That's the arrogance that I'm talking about. Just because only a handful of people on TR disagree with TechExec2 means nothing.[/i]"

I [b]never[/b] said that the number of people agreeing or disagreeing in [b]any way[/b] proved anything at all about the truth or accuracy of any statement. In fact, it was [b]you[/b] who implied that connection between popularity and correctness when [b]you[/b] said:

"[i]Indisputable is a very strong word to use when much of your postings are of opinion and not fact as evidenced by so many people disagreeing with you.[/i]"
I just pointed out that you were exaggerating to the point of absurdity on the subject of disagreement. I never validated your implied thesis that the number of people agreeing or disagreeing was germane to the question of whether or not the statement is truthful or accurate. That was what [b]you implied[/b]. It's not something I said at all.

"[i]That is exactly what's wrong with TR nowadays. The minority have a larger voice than the numbers they represent in the real world. And you are in the minority when it comes to OS choice and many other of your opinions.[/i]"

1. News flash: TR is for IT professionals. IT professionals are a minority in the world. Get over it.

2. Now you're claiming that a majority opinion is a correct opinion again. Self-contradiction is so very attractive, y'know.

"[i]Their voice on TR is disproportionate to their real numbers. That's what I've been saying all along.[/i]"
The fact that everybody agrees you're a childish, malicious little troll does not mean there's a conspiracy afoot.

by apotheon

1. He doesn't seem to be saying he thinks the general public is "dumber" than him. He just seems to be saying he thinks the general public is less well informed than him. Didn't you learn any reading comprehension in grade school? Maybe you haven't gotten that far yet.

2. The general public is buying computers through vendors like Wal-Mart in many cases -- and the largest segment of the "general public" computer consumer community is not buying a new computer at all, of any speed, because they figure their old computers are good enough. Most people aren't buying 2.5-3.2 GHz processor systems for any reason at all, because they're not buying new computers. Those who are, in many cases, are doing so for gaming -- not for "email, surf[ing] the web and a few other light duties."

3. Gee, for that much money I could have a much better video card.

4. "A lot of tweaking" isn't something your "general public" is going to do. Pick a demographic and stick with it. Anyway, I thought we were talking about Vista here.

5. Has it occurred to you that they might be working on tasks that require performance from their systems? Considering your OEM install statement, I'd think you'd recognize that updating hardware means updating the OS anyway, most of the time.

by w2ktechman

4. Many people are not computer savvy, so they will jest get what is sold to them as the popular OS.

by joergsattler

as a person that has English ( American variety) as a second language, though i no probably speak it better than my original mother tongue, it is distressing to me to see so many presumably educated people unable to express them self in their native tongue ( the written variety) properly without errors either spelling or grammatically

by w2ktechman

and I do not get paid to write, nor do I care if it is perfect.
I do think that I type better than some, but others are better than me. I am not a linguist, nor do I care. I know I run on sentences sometimes, and I do have typos often, but, are they really that bad? C'mon man, dont get bent about a little typo. Would it help if I apologise for jest instead of just?
Guess what, I Wont

by joergsattler

as a person that has English ( American variety) as a second language, though i no probably speak it better than my original mother tongue, it is distressing to me to see so many presumably educated people unable to express them self in their native tongue ( the written variety) properly without errors either spelling or grammatically

by hal 9000

After 4 attempts to get your point across couldn't you of at least added the w to no so that it reads the proper word NOW?

Now what where you complaining about people not typing properly and making mistakes?

Guess what my friend you are no better than the rest of us and we are not the ones complaining about this it's you so shouldn't you hold yourself to a higher standard that the rest of us [b]Plebes?[/b]

Col

by joergsattler

as a person that has English ( American variety) as a second language, though i no probably speak it better than my original mother tongue, it is distressing to me to see so many presumably educated people unable to express them self in their native tongue ( the written variety) properly without errors either spelling or grammatically

by joergsattler

as a person that has English ( American variety) as a second language, though i no probably speak it better than my original mother tongue, it is distressing to me to see so many presumably educated people unable to express them self in their native tongue ( the written variety) properly without errors either spelling or grammatically

by hal 9000

It's called the [b]Tax Cycle[/b] where hardware/Software is devalued to almost nothing over a 3 - 5 year period depending on the Tax Rules/Law wherever you are.

Any Bean Counter will tell the management to replace something because it is no longer profitable to have in the business and is actually costing the business [b]MONEY![/b] M$ accept this practise and is aiming with Vista to be on a 4 year turn around cycle for their new OS's. As stated elsewhere in this very thread M$ intends to have a major Service Pack available for Vista in a 2 year time frame from the Release of Vista and a New OS available in a 4 year time frame from the original Release of Vista. Depending at the time M$ may chose to call this new OS something different or maybe call it something like [b]Vista R2.[/b] M$ will be working this way for at least the next 10 years so you can expect to see 3 major Service Packs and 2 New Vista Released within that time frame.

You constantly claim to work business but don't understand the first thing about it so I personally wonder just what you are doing as it doesn't appear that you know the first thing about [b]Basic Business Practise's.[/b]

Just remember that if Business walks away from M$ the public will follow as they need to have on their home computers what is on their business computers so that they can continue to earn a living and maintain their job with out which the entire point is moot about anything relating to an OS.

Now to address the so called points that you brought up

[i]1) Pretty arrogant of you to think the general public is somehow dumber than you[/i]

Not really they are not Professionals in this industry and are sold what the retailer wants to push this week because they have a large stock of whatever. Most Home Users don't actually get what they need but what is sold to them.

[i]2) Just how much faster does the general public need their PC's to run? The general public is buying 2.5-3.2 Ghz processors right now, many dual core just to read their email, surf the web and a few other light duties. Even if Linux were 10-20% faster on comparable systems, would it even matter?[/i]

Well to you obviously not a drop but as you have said most people are buying Dual Core CPU's and supporting Hardware why do you think this is so? Because they know better or because that is what the salesperson who is working on a commission makes the most money from selling and then because the lower spec stuff is no longer being sold in enough numbers it gets removed from the shelves and the makers stop making it because no one wants to buy it. If you look at the same hardware running Vista Enterprise and SUSE the SUSE box beats Vista hands down in performance and even M$ accept this. They recently signed an agreement with Novel for Server Sales but Novel isn't only interested in flogging off SUSE for Servers they want to get it on the corporate Desktop as well where the real money is to be made.

[i]3) OEM Windows cost very little when purchased with a new PC. What, maybe $50-$75? Use it for 3-5 years, that's not a lot of money for the general public.[/i]

Maybe on a sub 1K desktop or NB with just Windows but then you need to buy more software so you can actually do some work Windows at best is only a platform to allow people to work and not the actual means of performing the work. In a case like this any software will do the job provided that it works and does what is required by the end user most don't even look at the OS as to them it isn't important till it breaks.

[i]4) I just installed Win XP on a PIII 450 Mhz laptop and it runs just fine. It took a lot of tweaking, but I was even surprised myself how fast it is running.[/i]

What's so surprising about this? After all M$ was starting to sell XP when the P2 450's where new on the desktop so it was commonly available when the P3 450 NB hit the shelves. More importantly why did you need to change the OS supplied with this NB it should have been the latest available at the time that this NB was sold.

[i]5) Why do all employees need a new PC at your company every 4 years max? MS currently offers 5 years of mainstream support. Are you really updating the OS or the hardware?[/i]

This is nothing to do with rubbish hardware but the Accounting Department who have devalued the Hardware/Software Package to nothing so to continue the Tax Benefits for Business they replace Hardware every 3 - 5 years or sooner. Generally speaking you will keep a computer for 4 years in most Business environments and Ink Jet Printers a shorter period of time unless there is some overriding factor involved like a NB Ink Jet printer is no longer being made and the replacement requires mains power and is the size of a desktop computer so it is no longer portable. Dot Matrix printers tend to last about as long and Laser printers tend to run the distance for the complete [b]Tax Cycle[/b] provided they where decent ones in the first place that don't cost $ per page to print with.

When you are involved in Business you will see that there are other considerations that need to be taken into account than just the Life Cycle of a M$ Offering which really is on no importance to the Business involved. They are only interested in something that they can work with till they are told to replace the things by the Accountants. This can be a 4 year cycle of it may be a 3 month cycle if there is a defective product in use which is costing the business more than it is worth so it gets junked and replaced when it makes Financial sense to the business. Surely you are not insisting that Business be run by M$ for all their Computer needs are you? This would be even more unpalatable to most business people that M$ currently are because of the extra costs involved in following M$ Gestapo Practises as they move hardware around within the business. If you are a Software House the Developers tend to keep getting the Latest & Greatest and their old machines which will be no more than 12 months old are given to a section of the business who has a less demanding role for the Computers that they use. But before this can happen the companies have to remove every bit of software that is going to be unused by the new user or run the risk of being raided by the M$ Gestapo in the guise of the Legal Department for failing to comply with the licensing agreements and it doesn't matter if a product is actually being used if it's installed you are a pirate and it doesn't matter if it's never been used for the last 3 years because it's sitting on the HDD taking up space and hogging resources which is costing the company money they are responsible for removing it and if just one computer slips through the net it will cost Hundreds of Thousands of $ and a massive amount of adverse publicity for the company involved. Have you any idea how hard it is to comply with this in a reasonably sized business where computers are being moved around on a routine basis? First you have to install the software that the particular person requires then get their old machine keep it on ice for a few weeks till you are sure that the new one is working properly and there is nothing that needs to be recovered off the old unit then you can remove any unnecessary software and data off the old machine and pass it onto the next department but generally when you come to do this you find the unit missing as someone has just walked in and grabbed the machine and then you need to go looking. With M$ Offering a reward for people to Dob in their Boss for this practise some unscrupulous people have been known to do this to get a % of the total fine that is eventually agreed upon between M$ and the business. I've seen at least 2 cases where this was arranged prior to M$ raiding the place to check compliance.

Even just loading a new machine with software that is currently being used is a breach of the User Agreement and M$ isn't overly concerned what is happening provided that they get their money in the form of massive fines they are happy. So they can quite legitimately hit a company who is commissioning new hardware for a department before it gets put into service because the same Retail License is on 2 computers when that isn't allowed. The proper way to commission new hardware is to first remove the old strip it out and then start to load the new unit it's only then that you can be completely sure that you are maintaining compliance with M$ stupid requirements.

The costs involved in lost production are of no concern to M$ as they are not interested in the facts only in stealing more Money.

As some idea of just how bad M$ Legal Department is one Computer Reseller here was selling off second hand Computers which where originally purchased with a Volume License and because that particular company was not supplying Install Disc's with every Computer that they sold [i]which M$ didn't even supply[/i] they where by M$'s definition of the EULA Pirating M$ Software. So the proper way to resell used computers that are perfectly good is to scrap the Volume License which can not be transfered from the original hardware and has been paid for at a lot more than $30.00 per machine and supply OEM install Product with every second hand computer which needs to have that particular OEM product Key on or again you are pirating the M$ product.

At the last M$ Partners meeting I was wondering why there where so fer faces that I recognised it's because most of those who where selling M$ 5 years ago are no longer involved in the industry and have moved on to greener pastures where they stand a chance of actually making money from new & second hand sales.

There is no money to be made in trading in second hand computers and reselling them unless you are a place like Dell, HP or the like who M$ just can not do without so they can continue to get away with murder while the rest of use have very strict Rules to follow and get jumped on if you don't do as we are told. For example if you buy a cheap HP Desktop you don't receive any Recovery Disc's but you can make your own from a hidden partition on the HDD if we did that with just 1 computer that we sold we would be facing a several Hundred Thousand $ Law Suit that M$ would quite happily settle out of court and put in the proviso that they can use the Companies & Principals Name & Address to show that the criminals who have breached the EULA to all their resellers in the monthly supplied [b]Enforcement Announcement.[/b] Which is supposed to show us just how much M$ is doing to help us stay in business but the big boys can do as they please and we just get jumped on as often as M$ please.

Just attempt to deal with M$ as a reseller for a year and you'll see exactly why there is such a massive dislike for M$ by so many people. They continually take your money offer you nothing then expect you to do as you are told, then they will send out members of their legal team to inspect your place of business every 6 months or so and charge you for the privilege of being audited.

M$ make the Mafia look like the people to do business with as they are far kinder and much more gentle to deal with.

Col
[i]Edited to add the blatantly obvious[/i] In case you are wondering how many times I've been fined by M$ for not following their Instructions the answer is [b]Zilch, Nada, Nil, Never.[/b] But now when a M$ Representative rings and begs to get a working unit under the cost of the software even in OEM form which my friend is much more than $50.00 I offer to sell them an OEM copy of Windows whatever and Install Open Office for free onto the computer that they just have to have that can read Excel. When you get a demand for a system that is below the price of the software it's easy to know where that is coming from.

But what I find totally amusing is the total lack of worry when you are being audited an after they find that you are doing nothing wrong you mention a company who is installing product from an Action Pack onto every computer that they sell the Auditor isn't interested as it's not their job to check the reports of Piracy their job is to audit who they are told to and they don't give a Rat's how much inconvenience they cause you just have to comply with their unreasonable demands and bring in all your staff from the field and allow them to inspect any NB's Tablets PDA or whatever the field techs may be caring and the customers who need immediate assistance are not considered as important. The last time that I had the Auditors here I had one customer ring up with an emergency that was costing about a Million $ per hour of Down time and all I could do was tell them to ring M$ and make a complaint there and send in a bill for the lost production because it was M$ Staff which was preventing me getting a tech out there to fix their problem.

by cruiser2000

It's good to see some of you have your eyes wide open. M$ has had it's run, but it wasn't the way OS were suppose to be..
Tax cycles, revenue streams.. not the langauge of true programmers. Who cares how much money Bill Gates contributes.. Who's money was it in the first place?

M$ has been found guilty of illegally protecting it's monopoly.. period, end of story.
It stole from the computer community. Now it want credit for being a responsible corporation. Give me a break.
If I fraudulently took money from you and then decided to give some back, should I be praised? I think not!
Open source software is the only answer for the long term!

by rkuhn040172

I don't feel like reading your book like post but I will say one thing here.

First off, I do have a business degree which I doubt many on TR who work in IT actually have. I also have 4 years management experience including project management.

Second, just because equipment on the books can no longer be depreciated doesn't mean it's costing the company money.

In order to get that depreciation you have to spend money. I disagree with your assertion. I can keep older equipment around and spend my money more wisely somewhere else that will give me a better return on my money.

by apotheon

"[i]I can keep older equipment around and spend my money more wisely somewhere else that will give me a better return on my money.[/i]"
That's especially true if you use an OS that doesn't demand a dual-core 64b processor and 4GB of RAM.

by hal 9000

Service Departments for the Mainframe side of IBM Wang Honeywell and the like are as useless as your so called Business Degree with 4 years experience in Management. You are a newbie and will remain such because you are too silly to look at real life so all I can add here is the blatantly obvious.

http://tinyurl.com/6wbv

Thanks for the link Max.

Col

by keith hailey

It only takes less than 3 minutes to reactivate. 3 Days, plenty of time.
And in 2 years time, you'll be using it and will have changed your tune, just like everyone did with XP. Now, everyone swears by XP (Windows fans, that is)

by hal 9000

But not to many who swear by it.

I need these units running 24/7 and after I went to bed last night for some reason best known to this computer which is on a UPS that will provide power for 36 hours if required it restarted and when I came in this mourning I was greeted by a screen saver at the Log In Screen.

I'll let you guess the first 2 words out of my mouth when I saw this and they had absolutely nothing to do with how great XP Pro isn't.

Then for the next 3 hours MSN Messenger wouldn't log on as the server at the other end was down. I got several phone calls where the people where swearing at XP again because it wasn't working. If Messenger isn't working it costs them money to ring me, instead of typing in a message for service and having it happen almost immediately. With at first a remote attempt to fix a problem and if it's then required a tech is dispatched to do the necessary work.

But the thing here is the problem of WGA shutting down a system when you push out software from a server. If this happens every time that you add a few pieces of software it takes far longer to reactivate every computer than just a few minutes. With 30 computers you'll be looking at several hours and that's if you can get straight to them as you need to ring M$ not do it on the Internet.

If WGA Kills off the OS like it's been known to do with XP you need to perform an In-place Install and that takes far longer than a couple of minutes more like 60 Minutes per machine then when Vista is concerned you need to activate and then apply any available updates. Now it will only be slightly over 1 hour per machine but when you have everyone screaming at you to [b]FIX IT NOW!!!![/b] However in a few years when there are several hundred MEG of Updates & a Service Pack involved it's going to take longer per machine.

Granted it's not a problem in a domestic situation all you need do is return it to the service department and wait two to three weeks to get it reactivated and returned but it's a major problem in an industrial situation and if there are any Medical Units involved it only gets worse.

Col

by rkuhn040172

1) What kind of UPS is that? Must be running diesel. 36 hours? For a PC? I'm lucky to get 20 minutes or so. Mine is consumer quality but even if I spent more and got a server type, I'd be lucky to get a few hours.

2) All your calculations assume WGA happens all the time. I have yet to have it happen a single time at my company of over 100 PC's in 2 years and only once in my after hours consulting gig.

by techexec2

.
The answer is that Microsoft has put a troublesome WGA "bomb" into Vista with the new aggressive trigger. Lots of normal events trigger it. Consider these questions:

- Will you always get at least 3 days? Not necessarily. How will you know? You really cannot be sure. What about bugs? Even if you do, what happens if the countdown starts on Friday after you leave for a 3-day weekend. When you return on Tuesday, the system is already in "reduced functionality mode"?

- What happens when you're on the road and without easy/good access to the Internet?

- Will online reactivation always work? No. Sometimes you'll have to call Microsoft.

- When you call Microsoft, will the human-to-computer system always enable you to reactivate? No. Sometimes you'll have to wait to talk to a real person.

- When you end up speaking to a real person, will that person always reactivate you? Not if they think you have a pirated copy, no.

- Will the de-activation only occur when it doesn't really matter to you? No. Odds are, it will typically happen when you are actively using your computer.

- Will malware trigger it? Probably. If application software doing normal things can trigger it, malware can trigger it. And, of course, malware will also advance the clock in order to provide for IMMEDIATE reduced functionality mode. Lovely! (...are you convinced this is complete lunacy by Microsoft yet? No? I'll continue...)

- Will Longhorn servers deactivate? I'm sure the answer is yes. This is all about Microsoft shutting down the pirates. So, how exactly are you going to be notified of that? Will it happen before or after the server outage causes you economic loss?

- When you roll out software updates to hundreds or thousands of Vista workstations, how many of them will be deactivated for whatever reason? How many times each year? How much time is the LAN administrator going to have to devote to these reactivations? How much staff productivity is going to be lost?

- Will TechExec2 ever sign up for this nonsense? No. I've got better things to do with my time than dance on Microsoft's string.

---

I think what Microsoft has chosen to do is completely unacceptable. It is a stunningly stupid and arrogant thing that they have done. Microsoft claims to have a piracy problem, yet they sold $44B and made $18B profit last year. Yup, the piracy is out of control. No. This is naked greed and Microsoft thinks they can force the entire world to submit to this.

I've been using Windows since 1992. I like Windows a lot (but it's not perfect). I beta tested Vista, liked it, and was going to upgrade in about 12 months when it is really ready. But, I'm not ever going to run Vista on my primary computers. I'm going to switch to a safe and sane operating system instead: Linux.

Nobody has to keep running Windows anymore unless they don't know any better. Today's Linux is good enough to replace Windows. And, it will be even better next year.

edit: clarifications

by tig2

So my tune will NOT change.

XP had it's fits and starts- but knowledgeable people let a lot of the problems go.

Sure, there was a lot of talk. Let's compare.

XP was "different" but you could still do all the same stuff. Vista? Not so much. The baseline Vista- OEM to many new machines- is so different to XP that many users can't install their MFD printers. Maybe because those drivers don't exist yet, and possibly never will.

... and the list can go on... but it is late.

I swear AT Windows. And I have been using Microsoft as long as TE2. Now I am finding sensible alternatives.

Edit- lack of sleep

by rkuhn040172

How is that MS's fault?

Driver issues have forever ever been a problem with Linux yet Linux supporters say it's the manufacturers problem.

So, I'll use that same argument here. It's the manufacturer's problem.

by rkuhn040172

Prepare to be flamed.

While I agree with you, you have to understand that everyday is the day that Linux is going to take over the world and bring down MS to these people even though they repeat this mantra day in and day out for 10 years.

by hal 9000

Times to make a point right? :D

Guess what Mate [i]joergsattler[/i] you are making a point but not the one that you think you are making. :^0

Col

by tig2

But that is just me.

And what I find more and more as I have the "Vista" conversation is that people are ready to move on.

Whether you like it or not, Microsoft made no friends with their architecture decisions this time round. End users are not stupid. They want functionality above all else.

by rkuhn040172

So, you hear about people ready to move on.

Just how many have done it? Start naming names. And don't even bring up Munich and other high publicity stunts.

Many people say one thing and do another, especially after looking at the migration costs, retraining costs, custom app dependencies, etc.

by hal 9000

I and most of the others here are [b]Professionals[/b] and it's not [b]Professional[/b] to use the names of companies without their permission or approval.

This is something that I don't think you have any knowledge about though.

Col

by tig2

Created ROI/TCO statements for? Several. Name names? Are you willing to provide my legal counsel? Are you willing to provide for me for the rest of my life because I provided secure information in a public forum and therefore demolished my professional reputation?

What are you? Bill Gates' love child?

Get over it. Vista is NOT the only game in town. With the Linices being considered, we can negate training issues.

Next invalid issue?

by tig2

In my experience, business refreshes the mission critical supportive technology every two years, the balance, every three.

4 years is a very old computer in the corp environment, considering that application architecture isn't what it used to be. But further, there may be environmental degradations that pertain- on airport computers are generally replaced more frequently than office computers due to environmental issues.

In my house, my personal system is the best and fastest money can buy. My test machines are not. On the average, the end user wants to have a stable online experience without having to re-educate themselves. As professionals, we therefore build in the best protections that we can.

The general public are people who are being quickly educated. They want value for their dollar. If OEM Vista "breaks" all their other peripherals, they will want something else. Linux provides that.

Edited because I walked 12 miles this week and I am tired!

by rkuhn040172

You apparently work for wealthier companies than I do.

Sure, most companies will replace mission critical technology faster than non-mission critical.

However, servers are one thing and PC's another. In addition, I know many, many companies that don't replace server hardware because they are scared to death to touch it.

On top of that, most companies I work with do keep PC's around for 4-5 years and even longer. I'd say the most "seen" PC's I come in contact with are Win 2000 on 1-2 Ghz processors and aren't scheduled for replacement anytime soon.

Lastly, as far as OS's, most companies don't upgrade immediately. They will stick with Win XP/Server 2003/2000 until the first service pack for Vista/Longhorn and then start converting. Too many issues to be worked out on top of legacy enterprise app compatiblity issues.

Consumers, they are a different case. They buy new whenever they get sick of the old, get a tax refund, or give their PC to a kid or friend.

Periphals are a non-issue with consumers. Most buy the bundled package PC meaning PC, monitor, printer and all will work with Vista as tested by the manufacturer prior to resale.

Only potential problems are older cameras, scanners, etc.

by tig2

And cannot say more than that as I manage privacy standards.

Larger corps want you to value hardware at a min= 5yr standard. In MS land, we have had to interject "islands" of min= 3yr.

You are very wrong on the consumer issue. I have no clue what your data set includes but I have gone bleary trying to fix "consumer" problems with their peripherals.

You, sir, need a grip, follow it with a clue. Please.

by techexec2

.
Thanks for mentioning that.

The current state of Linux and open source apps is excellent. The time is right for moves like this by U.S. corporations. I've read about a lot of such moves by non-U.S. companies and government offices (e.g. Munich, Germany). It appears that there is widespread refusal to submit to more Microsoft lock-in and high software cost, even by people who are still going to run Windows (e.g. OpenDocument vs. Office Open XML). It makes a lot of sense to strongly consider leaving Windows for Linux even without this Vista WGA nonsense.

by tig2

We cannot pass audit based on the "fact" that Microsoft is our EVERYTHING.

We are concerned about our mission critical systems. We are equally concerned about how we will connect with our legacy systems. We understand that we use emulators to do critical work.

We KNOW that Unix based systems will give us what we need. We KNOW that Linux based systems will give our end users what they need with little retraining.

WGA plays little part. Until the day that the Windows users (small group) are totally shut down.

The issue today- from here, anyway- is one of operability and long range functionality, combined with cost.

by apotheon

Use that argument if you like. Now that you have, though, you're stuck with it.

. . . except that with CUPS (the Common Unix Printing System), there are generic and manufacturer-specific drivers for a whole bunch of printers that were created by the open source community, mostly without any help from vendors. It seems to me that, considering the level of support from vendors (almost none), Linux and *BSD are ahead of the game. Imagine what driver support MS Windows would have without vendor support -- none, basically.

by rkuhn040172

I have yet to get a Linux distro to recognize my Lexmark printer. Tried 5 different distros to date.

Your statements are as hollow as political sound bites on the nightly news.

I don't have to "imagine" MS driver support without vendor support. Vendors provide drivers all the time for MS OS's. Vista is an exception because it is so new. Give it time.

I just installed Win XP Pro on a laptop that must be 5-7 years old (PIII 450 Mhz) and every single device was recognized on OS installation. That was impressive.

On the other hand, 75% of the time I have to "tweak" Linux using archaic command line statements just to get my monitor resolution higher than 800X600.

Ever try 800X600 on a laptop?

by apotheon

Lexmark actually goes out of its way to use anticompetitive practices to maintain its market share. It's like the Little Microsoft of printers. Lexmark actually goes out of its way to make its printers difficult to set up and configure unless you do it in Lexmark's specific, approved fashion. There were lawsuits related to this, about four or five years ago.

While I, too, find it annoying that some printers don't work so well with Linux (or other non-MS operating systems), I also find it even more annoying that Microsoft is way behind the power curve on support for quality printers. For instance, many Postscript laser printers (such as certain HP LaserJets) are positively a bear to set up for use with Windows, whereas two minutes with the CUPS web interface is all it takes to configure a Linux or FreeBSD system to use the same printer.

I lucked out with the HP 4050N that I recently picked up on the cheap. MS Windows XP actually has a driver for it, and since I'm not the only person using this printer there was actually a need for access to this Postscript laser printer with integrated print server. It only took me about ten minutes to get it working with MS Windows.

It only takes about forty-five seconds to configure CUPS at the command line to use the thing (if you know how to use the CLI configuration tools for CUPS).

I imagine things will be similar with the Postscript laser printer from Dell that I recently picked up. Postscript is the holy grail of network printing for almost every OS on the planet, and the bugbear of printing from MS Windows.

"[i]On the other hand, 75% of the time I have to 'tweak' Linux using archaic command line statements just to get my monitor resolution higher than 800X600.[/i]"
Archaic command line statements?

That pretty much sums up your ignorance of the state of the art of computer operating systems, right there.

"[i]Ever try 800X600 on a laptop?[/i]"
Yeah. I have an old laptop that isn't capable of 800x600. The screen finally went out on the thing. It worked fine. What's the problem?

by hal 9000

A reseller who is a [b]M$ Certified Small Business Specialist[/b] sells a Business a new server with 2003 64 Bit edition on it and a Lexmark Colour Laser printer to connect directly to this server which was brought specifically as a Print & File server.

Any ideas how long the person spent in attempting to set up that Lexmark Printer on that server? After using the supplied Drivers on the CD they posted a question on the Q&A Section here at TR I might add that you where very noticeable by your absence in helping the person who was asking the question as well but as Lexmark don't supply 64 Bit drivers that printer couldn't be installed to that Print Server.

I suppose things like that don't count when it comes to Windows Problems though do they? :^0

It isn't even a Manufacturer issue but a act of theft by the reseller isn't it?

Col

by rkuhn040172

Exactly which MS OS requires a dual core 64 bit processor and 4 GB RAM to run well?

Once again, stretching the facts here.

by nicknielsen

[i]I can also program Cisco routers from the command line.[/i]

This is called c o n f i g u r a t i o n. In my experience, it is the accepted method for setting up Cisco equipment. Any reasonably accomplished network tech can do it (and even a few less-accomplished techs).

by nicknielsen

[i]most of these post sound more like end users than network admins and support personal[/i]

So real tech professionals aren't also allowed to be end users and have computers of their own? They aren't allowed to have opinions about their home PCs?

by hal 9000

But as there where only 2,500 workstations involved and every one needed an [b]In Place Install[/b] to be able to be used again you might think that I'm more than a bit [b]Pissed Off[/b] with M$ and guess what you'd be right. :D

I've also had the same thing happen to every product supplied by M$ in one of their Action Packs so apparently M$ is opting for total coverage and control by selling Genuine and Pirate Software. If you want Total Control you need to Totally Control the market don't you?

As for your UPS's It's not my fault that you buy the cheap ones that are not good enough to be rated to a decent level it's your fault for spending your money more wisely isn't it? :^0

Col

by rkuhn040172

.2% failure rate (5 divided by 2,500). Sounds excellent to me!

If you read TR often enough, you'd think that WGA fails a lot more often than that.

by apotheon

You're not considering the metric very well. Yes, .2% failure rate isn't all [b]that[/b] bad -- if you're talking about .2% failure total, for everything. If it's just .2% failure rate of a single piece of software that can bring down an entire system, not even counting the failure rates attributable to other causes, that can add up.

Plus, y'know, that's a .2% failure rate [b]for unacceptable reasons[/b]. It's failing .2% more often simply because of something that is in no way, at all, necessary to your effective use of the software -- except that Microsoft decided you needed it. Screw that.

by hal 9000

100% Failure rate in one business supplied directly by M$ as a Government Volume License buyer. Not by a reseller but M$ directly and they still blacklisted this Product key 2 weeks after issuing a new one to allow SP2 to be installed onto the entire network. They also had to reissue the Product Key for SP1 to be applied as well perhaps you are seeing some king of trend developing here.

Col

by techexec2

.
I'm not speaking to our little [i]TR VILLAGE IDIOT[/i]. Until he's willing and able to behave like an adult instead of a 12-year old harassing the grown-ups, I'm going to try to ignore him. But, here's some help for you:

[b][i]THE IDIOT[/i] has personally witnessed about a 1% WGA failure rate[/b] (1)

According to this website (2), there have been 855 million Windows PCs sold between 2001 and 2006. Windows XP was the version of Windows being sold during this period.

[i]THE IDIOT'S[/i] personally observed WGA failure rate: About 1 in 100 = 1% x 855M = 8.55 MILLION legitimate customers affected by WGA failures.

This is not even close to an acceptable failure rate for a critical "feature" like WGA, one that can render the system unusable. WGA should be judged by the same criteria as any other critical Windows feature such as disk I/O. If Windows had a 1% disk I/O [u]software[/u] failure rate, Windows would be declared to be unreliable and people would seek more reliable solutions.

Even worse: This statistic is for Windows XP. Vista's WGA is much more aggressive.

Linux' WGA failure rate: 0%. Priceless. ;\

--------------------------------

(1) [i]THE IDIOT[/i] has personally observed about a 1% failure rate:
[i]"...I have yet to have it happen a single time at my company of over 100 PC's in 2 years and only once in my after hours consulting gig..."[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2193334

(2) 25-Year PC Anniversary Statistics
http://www.c-i-a.com/pr0806.htm

by hal 9000

But I just fell out of my chair laughing at his comment that it must be me who is at fault. :D

Lets see I didn't supply a Single Machine, 1 Single Bit of Software to this place but was recommended to go in there by M$ to sort out the problems that they had with the original Big LAN install on XP.

I didn't monitor the Install or upkeep it I and my staff only got called in by the Bureaucrats when they messed it up but I'm responsible for the Mess. :D :^0

Actually The poor fool is quoting M$ directly with the 1% problem with WGA as that is the Official Figure provided by M$ and last used at the Official Partners Meeting on 8 November 2006. Even the way that M$ arrived at this figure leaves a lot to be desired and the figure is heavily fudged and more like 5 - 8 % really with real problems created by WGA directly and it's much higher if you look at what happens if WGA is turned off.

Even Mark O Shea who is M$ Technical Head of Staff in AU admits this but the Village Idiot must have seen a Power Point Slide and just grasped on the 1% without any real knowledge of how that figure was arrived at and much more importantly what it really meant. :D

Now if just 1% of all airline travellers where killed in air crashes just how many people do you think would remain flying? :D

Actually I'm surprised that he hasn't complained about the link that I gave him to look at yet. I really expected some response much sooner, but as he only choses to look at what he likes I'm supposing that he's yet to actually see it. :^0

Just like so much of the other stuff that's been posted here that doesn't suit him to read as it frightens him too much. :D

Col

by tig2

Breaks your less than one year old peripherals, I have a few questions.

When I see people struggle to get their email because they have been given another MS F*ck job, I have an issue.

I have not had a problem with Linux (try checking the history of every problem I have ever posted here). Linux works with most hardware.

Possibly you have mistakenly shoved your head up your arse. Pity, really.

by apotheon

Trolling, I mean.

edit: On the other hand, it didn't look to me like she was losing her temper. She just seems to have lost a little of her (previously, apparently limitless) patience with you.

by tig2

I simply have found it helpful to point out when that particular mistake has been made.

So I shouldn't list psychic on your list of job skills?

by hal 9000

After all it has a Business Degree and 4 years of experience so it must know so much more than us mere plebes who have a much better education than it and also understand the Legal Consequences of our actions.

But I'm still trying to reconcile a previous statement by this one that the last 2 jobs that it's had over the past 7 years both employers have had no complaints about the quality of it's work.

The 2 statements from this clown seem to me at least to contradict each other but maybe thats just me seeing something that isn't really there right? :D

Col

by rkuhn040172

The fact that every Linux install I've done can't get my screen resolution correct out of the box without tweaking doesn't concern anyone? Typical of Linux!

If you are happy with 800X600, more power to you. I prefer at least 1024X768 or 1280X1024 depending on my monitor.

As far as Lexmark goes, again, typical open source, Linux speak. If something doesn't work, blame the manufacturer and not the OS. Funny thing is, Lexmarks work just fine on my Windows box.

by rkuhn040172

So, all your clients are so secretive about their switching from Windows to Linux that you can't name names. Sounds like BS to me.

by rkuhn040172

How many clients have you actually switched from Windows to Linux? And be as specific as possible.

I'm not asking for secret information.

And, switched OS's on more than a handful of equipment. How many have dumped MS 100%?

by rkuhn040172

First off, yes that business specialist shouldn't have sold them something unless it had been known to work.

Second, you are talking about 64 bit. Drivers are scarce at best. Yes, that is Lexmark's fault and not Windows.

Third, no I didn't attempt to help that person in their TR post as 1) I'm not skilled in the art of device driver writing and 2) I haven't been in the help section of TR lately.

by apotheon

I wouldn't tell you the names of corporations whose Windows networks I set up, without express permission, either -- and I'm not going to go around asking former employers and clients for such permission just to satisfy [b]your[/b] curiosity. Why don't you tell us the name of your employer and what the current OS deployment situation is for its network?

Clients whose networks have been substantially migrated to non-Windows OSes: 4.

100%? Only one.

Then again, I haven't been in the network migration business for a couple years. I'm considering getting into that sort of consulting again, since it's probably going to get lucrative enough in the near future to offset the annoyance factor. I'm inclined to stick to development for now, though, where I have greater control over my own work conditions.

by apotheon

"[i]The fact that every Linux install I've done can't get my screen resolution correct out of the box without tweaking doesn't concern anyone? Typical of Linux![/i]"
That should concern [b]you[/b]! My god, what are you doing wrong?

I'd be a lot more inclined to be helpful, by the way, if you weren't the poster boy for anti-Linux trolling. As things stand, however, I'm inclined to believe you're lying, or putting spin on the situation (100% of one time, for instance), or something like that. I'd be more credulous if Palmetto, or someone else reasonable about the whole thing, reported such statistics. You, though -- no friggin' way.

Anyway, it's not like I haven't had to "tweak" things to get resolution correct on MS Windows. I've had to install drivers just to get resolution on XP over 640x480 several times -- never had that problem with Linux. Even better, I "love" it when I change the resolution on MS Windows and it decides that it now has to alter the color depth to something like 8-bit color. That's always fun.

"[i]As far as Lexmark goes, again, typical open source, Linux speak. If something doesn't work, blame the manufacturer and not the OS. Funny thing is, Lexmarks work just fine on my Windows box.[/i]"
I can only assume that you are completely incapable of recognizing when a manufacturer has its head up its fourth point of contact. Did you miss the word "lawsuits" in my previous post?

Anyway, you're not allowed to make that argument any longer. You've accepted the "vendor's fault" argument for MS Windows. To reject it for anything else is just pure, blatant hypocrisy.

It didn't take long for that to happen.

by apotheon

"[i]Second, you are talking about 64 bit. Drivers are scarce at best.[/i]"
Funny . . . Linux drivers tend to handle 64 bit systems just fine. I guess that doesn't count, though, since only stuff MS Windows supports counts.

"[i]Yes, that is Lexmark's fault and not Windows.[/i]"
Hypocrisy again. Pick a side. Do you blame the manufacturer/vendor, or not?

by hal 9000

And print in a Public Forum the names of every place that you have worked for that uses Windows Exclusively, without their written authorisation and see exactly what happens to you. :D

I realise that you have no concept of [b]Legal Matters[/b] or the [b]Legal Consequences[/b] of your actions so you'll be perfectly happy to list those companies right? You also have absolutely no idea of [b]Compliencing Issues Either[/b] so please print here everyone that you work for and the [b]Companies that they deal with who are exclusively using Windows.[/b] Perhaps you would like to throw in the [b]Names & Addresses of the employees and their payments as well.[/b] :^0

Till you do all you are doing is sprouting off [b]BS.[/b]

Short enough for you this time? :p

Col

by nicknielsen

Evaluating PCLinux OS, Ubuntu, SUSE, and all three BSDs.

When I want a vista, I'll go drive the Blue Ridge Parkway.

by tig2

You do not get to demand protected information from a security analyst and not expect the answer I provided. I supplied you with all the open source information I had about projects that enjoy protection under GLBA and a host of other federal regulations. Don't like it? TOUGH. Write Congress and have those regulations repealed.

Good luck with all that.

by rkuhn040172

Ok, fair enough, I won't pussyfoot around like you.

I work for Arbor Homes and we are primarily a Windows shop.

Oh my, I guess I just exposed our secrets...well, not really considering 80-85% of the desktop market belongs to Microsoft and a huge chunk of the server market as well so that wasn't that hard of a guess now was it?

by rkuhn040172

How you are always the one that steps in the biggest piles of doggy doo.

I've never heard of anyone suffer from so many Windows problems as you and the scale of the problems either.

Makes me seriously question you and not the products.

by ontheropes

... I s'pose it would frickin' kill you to send me a frickin' email, woodentit, ya' frickin' TechExec2.

(bejeebus dood) :0

Note to you: (and Mr. Dawgit, and JD too) - See my godda... goldang profile for a stoopid email address.

Foo's.

Trust me.

I've already been down THAT frickin' "share-too-much-stuff-online at TR-with- who-knows-who" road!

I am now Mr. Total Discretion personified.

Ask anyone. :D

Trust moi!?!

Please.

Do I sound the least bit bitter?

-----

What was I saying?

Thanks for the avatar movie thing.

It keeps me out of the bars and off of the streets. Beats the hell out of jail.

OK. OK.

I'll say it...

I miss all y'all.

BTW-Mr. Mudd is on Star Trek.

Shoot me. Shoot me now.

Edited because HTML still kicks my butt.

by ambercroft

I want to make a coaster. I need a new source, AOL doesn't send them out anymore. The track has to be in good shape ( scratch free ), the print side doesn't matter since the felt will be glued to this side.

Once I have this built I will inform all if the 'bomb' ever goes off if I put unauthorized drinking cups on the coaster.

:)

by apotheon

NickNielsen -- let me know what you think of the various *BSD OSes in relation to each other. I'm a fan of FreeBSD. I like a lot about OpenBSD, though I haven't given it as thorough a going over as I'd like -- and there are apparently some limitations to it that don't appeal to me as much as FreeBSD. NetBSD, well, I haven't seen much reason to give it a try at all, yet. More information would be nice.

by apotheon

Now imagine what will happen if I contact them and ask questions about you, your work, and their network(s).

By the way, you didn't answer me completely.

by apotheon

You say that lots of people are willing to live with it. That's not really true. It's more the case that lots of people think that's just the way it is, and they pretty much [b]have to[/b] live with it. Only a few -- like you -- actually [b]choose[/b] to be treated like criminals without just cause, and to risk system shutdown because Microsoft doesn't give a hot damn about whether its customers are happy, with free will and all the facts within their grasp.

by rkuhn040172

Go ahead, contact all you want.

And I did answer the question. That was all I was asking from anyone else. No specifics, just what clients have you had that have made the switch from MS to Linux.

Now, in my case, how stupid was it? Considering that my 5 year daughter could of guessed we are primarily a Windows shop. Statitics are on her side.

by tony hopkinson

An open source developer could and would take it on. If you paid him or her.

They could even do it closed source and might as well if it was too specific to be useful to another business.

Of course you can't get a free open source product to manage the specifics of your business, can't get a free closed one either can you?

You are better off with an optimised solution anyway, the off the shelf suite type packages are a crap fit, full of bloat and a right pain to implement.

Been there, done that.

by jck

[i]A few things...[/i]

ok...

[i]1) Pretty arrogant of you to think the general public is somehow dumber than you[/i]

I said [b]ignorant[/b], not dumb or stupid. I never said dumb. I never said anything in comparison to me being smarter.

Get it right...learn the difference.

[i]2) Just how much faster does the general public need their PC's to run? The general public is buying 2.5-3.2 Ghz processors right now, many dual core just to read their email, surf the web and a few other light duties. Even if Linux were 10-20% faster on comparable systems, would it even matter?[/i]

I was arguing that Linux is better for [b]users who can't afford to go buy or don't yet have a new PC[/b]. That's why I said...go find someone with a PIII 733...and see which OS operates better on it.

But to answer your question about how fast they need to be?

I guess the fast, modern PCs have to be fast enough for anyone who wants to run Vista with AeroGlass running in full graphics mode, eh? Can you say...Crossfire? SLi? Neither of those options is cheap.

[i]3) OEM Windows cost very little when purchased with a new PC. What, maybe $50-$75? Use it for 3-5 years, that's not a lot of money for the general public.[/i]

Actually, Windows XP Pro x64 OEM cost me about $100.

However, you have to understand one thing: The general public needs [b]end-user support[/b] and OEM versions come with [b]NO SUPPORT[/b] from Microsoft and very little from the VAR other than installation and RMAs for defective disks.

Most end-users in the general public are not capable of troubleshooting their own problems like we technical people can most of the time for OS issues.

So, your OEM idea won't work for most of the general public who need that OS to be as "user/stupid friendly" as possible.

[i]4) I just installed Win XP on a PIII 450 Mhz laptop and it runs just fine. It took a lot of tweaking, but I was even surprised myself how fast it is running.[/i]

Again...most end-users in the general public don't know how to "tweak". They buy a PC, and are ignorant of the Linux option which really doesn't require a whole lot of "tweaking".

[i]5) Why do all employees need a new PC at your company every 4 years max? MS currently offers 5 years of mainstream support. Are you really updating the OS or the hardware? [/i]

I don't know. I don't determine hardware/software updating at the enterprise level. I write applications and make technology suggestions and administrate database and webservers.

But...if I had to make a guess...since they are buying new PCs, I would tend to think that means that they are upgrading hardware...not software.

Since our organization buys from Dell (no matter how much I wish they didn't...and would just hire techs to build them at $10-12 per hour and bulk order parts), we get whatever apps/OS come on the machine by default.

However, we are back-reversioning the systems now because they are shipping with Vista Premium under the licensing agreement with have with Microsoft. We are, upon arrival, wiping the disk and installing XP Professional and will continue to do so for some time to come (18-36 months).

Like I said before, I will try and move my organization to realise that for the greatest majority of users it does not matter if we run Linux or Windows. Most probably couldn't tell the difference between KDE-Redmond I mean Vista... and KDE 3.5 if you just changed the names on items in the menus and made a default load image to install on each new computer.

Most people here who use systems only use the Office suite to do their work, and interfaces for their proprietary software could be easily converted to Linux within a few months.

Anyways...Linux is more efficient...it's cheaper...you have more than one option of which Linux to run...and...Linux didn't remove OpenGL2 from their base OS structure.

Have a nice day :D

by rkuhn040172

3) OEM versions currently work for most of the people that buy them.

4) Linux doesn't require tweaking? That's the biggest load of crap I've ever seen on here.

If one doesn't know the CLI, forget it, Linux is the wrong choice. Try putting the newest version of Ubuntu on my PIII 450 Mhz laptop and not tweak Linux. BS.

5) If you are waiting 18-36 months before using a MS product, I'd bet you are also the type that complains when mainstream support ends too. After all, you are waiting for up to 3 years before you even use the product when support ends in 5 years. Nice.

Your points are all mute in my book.

by jck

Well...

if you want to run Vista optimally with the new features, including AeroGlass...you need a dual-core 64-bit machine with 4GB of memory.

I believe it was here that someone reported loading Vista on a 2GB dual-core machine, and that the Aero process was typing up 1GB of the memory because Vista saw the high-end video config he had and determined he wanted the top-level Aero.

See...even Microsoft is assuming these days...it's the in thing...

Hell, I'm running XP Pro x64 and I run SLi-ed dual 7900GT video cards and 4GB of RAM to keep XP Pro from sputtering on occassion.

I can't imagine what my machine would do with Vista Premium and Aero installed...

Well...can't imagine anything Vista would do...besides crash all my hardware drivers... hahahaha

by jck

Well, it's gonna be a year at least...but, I'm planting seeds right now.

One of the techs has Mepis loaded on an old Dell OptiPlex PC and is running it with 512MB of RAM and a 40GB disk...and it runs as fast as XP on a 1GB Dell GX6-series box.

I'd love to see more places switch to Linux as well. I can't see that we'd be able to migrate servers as quickly...but...if the "powers that be" here put their mind to it...we could migrate most of the 600+ PCs to Linux (end users who only use Office apps) within 2-3 months...and probably the majority of those left (some exceptions) by the end of 6 months.

Servers would probably take...oh...1-2 years...because of having to reimplement web technology, database migration and testing, etc...plus...all your people would be working on moving the client PCs too.

But yeah, it's silly to pay MS for Vista in the enterprise when all they want to do is documents, spreadsheets, photo-editing, presentations and email.

Linux = free (without support)
Linux = keeping hardware longer
Linux = choice (dozens of vers. of Linux vs 1 Microsoft)

cheaper...less updating hardware...choice of vendors.

in the immortal words of Mel Gibson in Braveheart...

FREEDOM!!!!!!! :D

by jck

Lemme premise this by saying I respect you as a techhead and a jokester and a TR member...as well as your education and experience.

However, Einstein had no PhD when he conceived all his famous works...and...it didn't make him any less the genius.

Not saying yours mean nothing...just that all the experience and education in the world doesn't make the man.

By the way I totally agree with you...rickk does seem quite naive...and...I would lay odds...he's a "yes man"...nods to his boss and does what he's told and takes his boss' word as gospel and follows the line.

I was that way once when I was a section head...

Then I found out that the procurements manager was hiding $1.1M of funds that were earmarked for purchasing "furniture and equipment". He probabaly was gonna refurnish his corner of the complex at the end of fiscal year.

Needless to say...my naiveity went away...and...I quickly had the Exec. Dir. sign my requisition for a new mainframe and network infrastructure.

Taught him to hide money from me, that old coot!! :D

by rkuhn040172

Thanks for speaking for me but really, I can do that myself.

1) I didn't quote the 1% number. You guys have a reading problem. I only quoted your .2% problem.

2) You seem to have a consultant attitude problem. That's not the first time you've mentioned "Bureaucrats" screwing things up. Do you really have that much disrespect for your clients?

3) I never said you sold or installed anything in your above example. Again, reading problem on your part.

4) I'd hardly equate people dying with a PC crashing

5) Can you prove your 5-8% number? Unlikely, doubtful and definitely more FUD.

by rkuhn040172

Exactly my point!

I could pay a developer to write it in open source or I could do what we are doing right now. Closed source, existing company, proven track record, many large clients, guarantees, and free support with a contract.

End of story.

So really, the argument boils down to this. For our company and our application, there is NO DIFFERENCE between open source and closed source.

by apotheon

Here's an example of how a company with intelligent people making the decisions might do things:

1. Choose an open source solution that's close.

2. Pay someone (outside consultant or employee) to customize it.

3. Enjoy the fact that in the end it probably cost considerably less than an end-to-end proprietary custom workup from scratch would cost, and still ended up being more customized to the company's needs than the proprietary solution would probably provide, in addition to which the open source solution has a proven track record of stability because it has been used by other companies for years.

by rkuhn040172

That is the most blatant, purely FUD, crap still yet. You're getting worse by the post.

Vista runs quite well including Aero without the need of a dual core 64 bit 4 Gb RAM PC.

Please, change your screen name to Elmer FUD.

If your PC is what you say it is and XP Pro is not running well, you have issues beyond MS and XP. Stop surfing porn, stop opening emails from Nigeria, install some AV and anti-malware, and most of all learn how to use a freaking PC.

No way in this universe you have a PC like that and are struggling to run XP Pro well. Your nose is growing.