Discussion Locked

[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]

0 helpful
1,352 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
Found by Ed Bott of ZDNet (1):

[b][i]"...Windows was deactivated due to a hardware change. You must activate Windows within 3 days or Windows will stop working. Click to start activation..."[/i][/b]

I just found out that if Vista does not like a change you make to your computer, [u]including merely installing software[/u] :0 , and requires reactivation, that it sometimes [u]will deactivate within only 3 days[/u], not 30 days.

I greatly dislike but might have accepted 30 days. If this nonsense ever happened, I would surely not lose access to [u]my computer[/u]. But, with only 3 days, it is very possible I might. What about 3-day weekends? What about being in a place without Internet access? Without telephone?

[b]This is totally unacceptable[/b]

This is completely and totally unacceptable. This is the kind of nonsense I would expect from a shareware program, not from my operating system provided by the world's largest software maker, that sells [u]$120 million in software EVERY SINGLE DAY[/u], clearing [u]$49 million in profit EVERY SINGLE DAY[/u]. I am (was) a paying customer. Microsoft does not need to willfully put my computer at risk in order to get more money from the cheaters. It's just pure greed and arrogance.

I will NEVER upgrade to Vista now. Absolutely, positively, NEVER, not even if Microsoft "fixes" this or calls it a bug. I don't care. It should never have been possible in the first place. This is the end of the line.

Hasta la Vista, baby!! It's Windows XP, Linux, and Mac now.

--------------------------

(1) References

Vista WGA problems confirmed
http://blogs.zdnet.com/Bott/?p=221

Sequence to Vista pulling the pin on the grenade
http://content.zdnet.com/2346-12354_22-56084.html

What does Windows Vista reduced functionality mode look like?
http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=286

Vista reduced functionality mode - Gallery
http://content.zdnet.com/2346-12554_22-56027-3.html

Windows Vista Validation Issues Forum (Microsoft)
http://forums.microsoft.com/Genuine/ShowForum.aspx?ForumID=1004&SiteID=25

edits:
3/6/2007: Added reference

1,352 replies

by tig2

I won't let anyone that I support use Vista. We are experimenting now with Unix/Linux in the hope that we find the right thing for all the competency levels in the family before it is too late.

This is the natural conclusion to a poorly played game. No one is fire proof. Not even MS.

by techexec2

.
I've been using Windows as my primary operating system since Windows 3.1 in 1992. I've used every version of Windows since then (except ME of course :-) ). I paid for every single one. This is very disappointing to see Microsoft self-destruct like this. They clearly just do not understand that this is so totally wrong of them. It's like if I miss a payment on my car and it stops running while I'm crossing the mountains during a snowstorm and says "Use OnStar to Reactivate. We accept VISA, Mastercard...".

On the other hand, it's been less than an hour and I am already feeling a sense of liberation while thinking about the possibilities of the good that will come out of this decision...

:-)

by alex.bailey

The car analogy isn't quite right...you already paid for your car in full and then you insert a metal CD and the car halts dead with a message on the dash "Are you sure you want to play this kind of music? Your CD player has been shutdown to prevent damage to your ears. Is it recommended you play Easy Listening whilst driving. Please contact your manufacturer to re-enable your CD player."
Vista is just one step too far in dumming-down (so-called "user-friendliness"). I am totally fed up with all the kid-oriented features they put into it now and the way MS think they have to wrap us all up in cotton-wool. Its just an operating system, damn it! I just want to do my work in the straight-forward way I always could do with previous versions of Windows.
MS, you haven't given us ANYTHING more useful, you have just tarted up the graphics (badly) and moved all the features around and changed their terminology so I can no longer find them.
What a waste of 5 years of development!

by w2ktechman

but yes, I agree that this is a big problem. Running a video game deactivates it and only 3 days??? And, does this count towards total reactivations? If the game was once again played, even on accident and it triggered yet another reactivation event, your Windows reactivations are running out.

WTF was MS thinking on this.

by insl8n

How about some info on other operating systems. What thay can and can't do. If MS/vista won't heed our complaints, lets move on.

by why me worry?

So now the legitimate owners of Vista are thrown into the same dirty pool of pirates that are using so called "non-genuine" copies of Vista according to Bill Gates and his dorks in charge.

I'm glad we don't have this re-activation nonsense with automobiles or other vehicles. Imagine having to apply for a new title everytime you change your worn out tires or replace the spark plugs. The idea is assinine and completely pointless.

by johnnysacks

I've been watching the ads recently for a replacement computer and it appears an individual consumer would have a tough time getting XP installed on a new computer.

Seems like I have the choice of any OS I want as long as it's Vista. Wow, what a way to propagate a new product, force your pool of manufacturers to install nothing else.

by rludwig

Do you mean that there is a limit on the number of times you can reactivate software you've already bought?? So every time I have to reactivate the OS because it found something it did not like on my PC, it reduces the number of heartbeats the thing has left? What's the limit? If it's like 10K then who cares? If it's 3 then there is a more serious problem.
I am planning on purchasing a new PC is the very near future. One of my requirements is that it have XP as the operating system. Vista does not provide any feature I need and it sucks up resouces from the PC that could be put to better us.
MS, go blow yourself.

by lightning joe

Whaaat? There are "limits" on reactivations? I change my machines around all the time; software, hardware, the gammut. Is MS saying that I can only put in a new card or install a game demo a pre-MS-approved number of times?

I'm sorry, but this defines them as NAZIS! (there, I win the "nazi-post" prize!)

Seriously, though, this is totally unacceptable. I would and will never pay for this sort of low-class treatment.

by hcarlson

My Espanio is not so good, as you can tell already. But let me say, Asta La Vesta to Vista! I've been with Gates since CPM and something called MSDOS circa 1982. Not goin a doit! notta notta!

by nicknielsen

I think MS has reached its point of no returns with Vista. Most of the people I know, even the hard-core "got to have the latest Windows OS" crowd are staying away from Vista. I'm not going there, either. My brand new built-for-games PC passes the Vista compatibility check, but it irritates no end that the most current versions I have of some M$ software "may have compatibility issues."

What a crock. Sticking with XP and investigating BSD, Suse, and Fedora.

by w2ktechman

a Linux distro called PC Linux OS,
I downloaded it and it seems to work pretty well so far, although I am more used to SUSE myself, I think that it has potential.

Might be another to look at.

by stress junkie

I've run about a dozen distributions of Linux in the last eleven years, and I've given a quick peek to about another dozen. I started using PCLinuxOS about six months ago. The first thing that really impressed me is how easy it is to configure wireless network cards. The next thing is that it already has all of the software to play MP3, WMV, and other styles of multimedia files. If you want to play commercial DVDs you can easily download the driver for that (libdvdcss) from the software installer (Synaptic).

PCLinuxOS is simply the most user friendly distribution of Linux that I've ever seen.

http://pclinuxos.org

Currently they are about to release a new version of their distribution. You can download the last test version but you will have to erase it and install the released version when that is available. Don't let that put you off though. The test version will work. It just can't use the software repository that is being created for the new release.

by technical

I use OpenBSD3.9, FreeBSD6.1 Suse9.3 and Windows 2000 ( all the Os's you mention)
BSD is Ultra stable. My Suse is better than Windows 2000 but its not quite as good as FreeBSD6.1 I do get some minor bugs with SuSE. BSD takes a day or two to understand all the details of the install if you have never done it before. Basically you have to read everything your asked, not keep pressing "Enter". Open BSD would not be a good idea for the desktop in my opinion. FreeBSD is better for that. Use FreBSD6.1+ and load Linux software onto it and you will have a serious machine. Other Linux distros are all OK in the end they feel similar. Bit like different Windows OSes 98,2000,XP etc. FreeBSD does seem to work very well as a server. I have one old box left on for something like a year, I forget it. The PSU fan will fill up with dust and overheat sometime in the next few years. This is all that seems to go wrong! Ubuntu is the favorite Desktop I happen to like Koppix because it writes well into Windows NTFS discs ( in my windows 2000).
All in All IF you havent done it before I would go with Ubuntu to get the hang of Linux then go FreeBSD if you need a serious machine. Keep the OpenBSD for Firewalls bridges and anything security under OpenBSD it will be OK (try not to alter the defaults and its "fairly" secure).
Theo would of course understand that by "fairly" I mean better than any other "operating system" in the world. The problem with security being people's behavior not the OS.

by apotheon

I avoid MS Windows when at all practical to do so. My favorite flavor of Linux is Debian. I stick with *BSD as much as I can.

Yeah, it looks like we tend to agree, overall.

by cactus pete

When did you install the OS, relative to installing/running the game?

Which version did you install?

by techexec2

.
Ed says that a dialog box popped up a few minutes after he began playing the game. He documents the sequence here (2).

--------------------------------

(1) Vista WGA problems confirmed
http://blogs.zdnet.com/Bott/?p=221

(2) Sequence to Vista pulling the pin on the grenade
http://content.zdnet.com/2346-12354_22-56084.html

(3) What does Windows Vista reduced functionality mode look like?
http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=286

(4) Vista reduced functionality mode - Gallery
http://content.zdnet.com/2346-12554_22-56027-3.html

by stress junkie

I actually thought that the prerelease warnings about this sort of thing would turn out to be wrong. The sequence of events in reference 2 are almost unbelievable. Does Microsoft think that people will remain loyal to their products with that kind of harassment? If you purchased that game and installed it you wouldn't be able to run it. That's a total waste of money, not to mention that the operating system isn't doing its job which is to run applications.

I think Microsoft has really gone too far and people will not tolerate it.

by why me worry?

From the time I played with the Vista Beta up until now, I won't let Vista within 500 feet of my systems.

by w2ktechman

Since the first beta I decided to start looking into Linux as an alternative. I had made up my mind to stick with XP until it is no longer a benefit, and move to another OS. At home I will not touch Vista.
At work however, I have too. Luckily (for now at least) it is limited. I told my manager that when it comes time that I need to support Vista in any way, I need to move on. Looks like an April-July timeframe for me to find a new job, cause thats when it starts rolling here.

by whatthe?

What is the rush to get Vista? We all know of Micro$oft's track record - they always release software LONG before it's actually ready. This OS will be full of anomolies and bugs and will take at least until Sp1 to be of any interest to me.

Try SUSE 10.2 - it's free, it works, it's yours to keep, your not renting from Gates.

by stress junkie

I wouldn't leave a job just because they are using Vista. We'll have to face it some time. I'm sure that I will eventually run into a client that is using Vista. Then another one. Then most of them. I won't turn down work just because I don't like the software that they are using. In one sense bad products mean more work for us. I understand if you are on salary and bad products mean more uncompensated late hours but we still have to make a living. Maybe when the business is interrupted too many times the managers will look into going back to XP or look into alternatives. You'll be prepared in either case. :)

by is

You would seriously move jobs just because your current employer is moving to Vista? In a corporate environment Vista will be so locked down by AD or local policy you wont be getting these ridiculous errors.

Instead of running scared, why not do some serious testing of your company's software products on Vista and maybe learn a thing or two about the OS.

I am not a Vista junkie, I wont be moving my hospitals PCs over to Vista until after SP1 is released, and then only after seeing what SP1 will do to the systems.

by w2ktechman

I am using 10.1
Also PCLinixOS
I couldnt get Mandriva to install on my system, and was warned off of Kubuntu by security issues brought up by the Linux Guru's here
Fedora 4 and 5 kept dying on my system when I setup dual screen mode

so SUSE and PCLinuxOS are the 2 currently fiddling with. No real issues with them either. SUSE had an install snafu, it tried to setup to my wireless instead of wired LAN. But this was probably due to the MB having the wireless adapter the first adapter. I noticed it and viola, the switch was made.

by techexec2

.
I just had a thought...

During the last year, Microsoft sold $44 BILLION and cleared $18 BILLION in profit. That is over $49 MILLION in profit, [u]every single day[/u]. That is like winning the lottery, [u]every day, of every week, of every month, of every year[/u].

Yet, Microsoft wants more! :0

And, they are willing to damage the experience of [u]paying Windows Vista customers[/u] in an effort to get it.

I just don't get it. What could be better than winning the lottery [u]every single day[/u]? I cannot imagine wanting more than that, and hurting innocent people to get it. Can you?

There is a word for that: Evil. ]:)

by stress junkie

I understand any business trying to recover lost revenue. The question is how do their efforts to recover the revenue affect legitimate customers. In this case it looks like Microsoft is willing to increase the pain to legitimate customers beyond what most people will accept. This is probably going to help Apple a lot. I expect that sales of Macintoshes will rise in the next 24 months.

by techexec2

.
You're absolutely right and I agree. There is nothing wrong with a business seeking to recover lost revenue and reduce piracy. Your words are better than mine in that they are more balanced. I agree with you.

I wasn't trying to be balanced. My words were addressing the extreme amounts of money involved. Most companies would KILL to have the revenues and profits that Microsoft does. Yet, they still whine and complain and demand more of what they think they deserve.

During the last year, Microsoft:

- Sold $44 BILLION in goods and services

- Cleared $18 BILLION in profits

- Had 71,000 employees

- Sold $619,700 [u]per employee[/u] :0

- Spent $366,000 [u]per employee[/u] :0

- Had $253,500 profit [u]per employee[/u] left over :0

Those numbers are far far above what other successful companies achieve. Those are numbers that only a monopoly can achieve, one that can raise and/or maintain high prices at will. Remember that Windows 95 $89.00 upgrade? What happened to that? There was competition back then. OS/2 was there and Microsoft had to win customers. Not any more! Since they are selling so many hundreds of millions of copies of Windows now vs. ten years ago, the price of Windows should have gone DOWN from $89 since then, not UP, if there were any competition at all.

Since they have a monopoly, and they are fabulously profitable, you would think they would not be so hurtful to their legitimate customers in their effort to make even MORE billions in the Far East and other places where piracy is such a problem for them.

Besides, I doubt it's really going to work very well. Those guys are not going to buy Windows at any price. They will either break WGA and steal Windows or use Linux. Do you really think the Chinese government is EVER going to use Windows? They don't trust it to not spy on them for the U.S. government. That is why they are promoting free "Red Flag Linux" over there.

So, yes, my words were unbalanced and I agree with yours.

And, Microsoft is evil. ]:)

by quasar kid

Ok - time to fess up. You're a socialist through and through. Where else would you like to dictate prices and profits?

Myself, I live in free country. It is really very simple - I can choose to use MS products or choose something else. I don't get it. If you don't like the product...don't buy it.

by techexec2

.
Hey Kid: You really need to read before you write. Listen before you speak. You're way off the mark here.

This post was just noting Microsoft's willingness to hurt their own customers to satisfy their greed to get more from pirates in certain markets. I used the extreme profits they make to drive the point home.

I don't advocate price controls on Microsoft at all. And, you cannot find a single place where I said so. You're just making that up.

As I said in my original post at the top of this thread, I'm just refusing to upgrade to Vista. I don't like the product and I am not going to buy it. I am going to choose the alternatives. Sounds like we're completely eye-to-eye here.

So...Do you feel a little foolish now? :^0 ;-)

by tig2

Have the fiance working with Open CD tools on his XP box- had to start somewhere and he's pretty resistant- and have Knoppix and Kubuntu burned to disc. Also have a SuSe distro. PC Linux is on the list as your description sounds like it is the perfect answer for the fiance's mom and brother. Neither of them really use the computer for much and really don't understand them at all so I am looking for the simplest and most closely aligned to what they know.

I started a thread on the subject some time ago located here: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212004

There are some great links in it to a wide variety of sites that I am finding very helpful.

I don't understand the machine that is Microsoft. I think they are making a major mistake this time.

by now left tr

Think it was around the time Windows XP was released.

Went somthing like - 2000 is fine, XP is 2000 with an updated UI. XP needs activation...moving to Linux....and so on....

by dfd98809

It's Deja Vu
When XP came online - I used to OS to learn how to "get-around" as many flaws as I could. Made a good living supporting folks who had use and develop under it.

Looks like I am on the learning curve again.

PCLinuxOS, VMWare with XP for personal use.

by techexec2

.
I have been using Windows since 1992. I have never sworn off Windows. I'm not swearing off Windows now. I'm just refusing to submit to the absurdity of capricious deactivation under Vista. That is an entirely new thing and I won't stand for being mistreated by a vendor like that.

So, it will be Windows XP for me. And, since Windows XP will likely start becoming a problem due to old age in a few years, I will be taking steps to leave Windows entirely down the road.

by severian

There are two separate companies/offices of customers that use our software in the process of planning a switchover to linux this year..because of Vista. I, personally, have never seen this happen anywhere, at least not for the desktop. Their IT contacted me, asking if we have a linux port; I suggested they try wine or crossover.

by slydder

Back then at least every 1 in 4 posts was pro MS defending XP. This is most certainly NOT the case with Vista.

What were the figures of lost MS customers because of XP? I figure with at least 4 times that many this time around.

chuck

by 17141714

I'm now an old fart of 66. I started computing in 1981 with CPM, then DOS 2 through to DOS 7 then played with MS first attempt to match Apple with Win286 then Win 386, MS 3.1 etc etc right up to Xp. The constant factor in this long painful experience is that every new release promised to be the answer to a world peace. Instead on each occasion it proved to be a load of BS! Since 1982,I have spent too much time under the bonnet trying to fix problems & BSODS. "It just doesn't work", next time it's Apple.

by now left tr

"Since 1982,I have spent too much time under the bonnet trying to fix problems & BSODS. "It just doesn't work", next time it's Apple."

So since 1982 you have never thought of changing OS to another vendor. Looks like you are just following the flock. Nothing has changed in the last 8 years...

by gstrickland

It doesn't always work that way TechMail.

Like the original poster, I too have been working with computers since the early 1970's (mainframes before you ask!).

I've done the the MAC thing, done the Unix thing, but MS is the most popular for office environments and therefore dominates. Companies do not like big changes - such as moving from MS to Apple or Unix.

The man appears to be in a stable job. Not his fault he hasn't been exposed to other OS's.

I'm sticking with XP - Vista is just a tarted up version and offers nothing. Ask me again in a couple of years what my next step will be. Maybe by then other vendors will jump on the big mistake MS have made and offer an alternative OS to us all.

by techexec2

.
[Updated 3/5/2007: There is updated information on the website referenced below that says this Vista activation breaker is a hoax. I'm not interested in piracy or cracking. I just found this amusing.]

In the high-tech version of Karma, people are so up-in-arms about Vista's [i]ACTIVATION WITH CAPRICIOUS DEACTIVATION[/i] "feature", that some of them are working very hard to rebel. Apparently, someone has found a way to defeat Vista activation by brute force (1).

Except for the fact that innocent Vista buyers are going to be hurt by this, I cannot honestly say I am not amused.

---------------------------------------

(1) Vista activation cracked by brute force
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37941

by noelrd

The same site now says that the "crack" doesn't work in any reasonable time.

by techexec2

I checked and right you are. I have no interest in cracking or piracy. I was just amused by the irony.

Thanks.

by rob miners

iv'e downloaded and installed PC Linux in a virtual environment and i have had a play. Different but not bad will be playing some more. Just noticed a new post that mentions that the corporate-oriented Vista Enterprise only supports a 3-day trial. This joker wasn't trying to play games on an Enterprise Build was he. I was a bit peed off that the games had been removed from the business edition.

by ffly

Well i have used windows from win 3.1 (which i hated, my commodore 64 was better)i also used DOS ,i was at a location which i had no phone, cell or land line and had been going to upgrade my hard drive to a larger one for some time but had not done so yet, but had the drive with me,my compaq laptop was giving me trouble and i decided to ghost the old drive to the new thinking it might solve my problem. Compaq has no SMART support in there BIOS, thinking drive might be failing i did so but XP would not let me do anything without activating again,which i had to quit where i was and lose time and return later to finish what i was doing and my HD did die shortly after .I have been trying to switch to Linux off and on for some time but should have learned it years ago while i was younger and had more time.as for Vista i ran the beta,sp1 and a version that came with my action pack subscription and it is a allow/deny nightmare as the Mac commercials show.when XP came out Microsoft had a promotion for myself and employers to buy a copy for $49.87 shipped(it came with a baseball bobble head doll bubble gum in a fancy box)that is a reasonabley price for a OS.Microsoft should just make the software price either more affordable or keep it at it's high price and let us only buy it once and get the updates forever or some idea like that...There is a saying about trusting but it is slipping mind at this time .But GREED does come to mind.

by stewart.smart

I was a die hard Mac User until the dark day that I switched to Wintel under pressure from my wife (bless!).

I have long categorized MS software under the "Almost Useful" heading but have become increagingly alienated. I thought PCs were suppose to be productivity aids? Hah! (LOL) I spend far too much time at work watching IE crash and ask me if I want to send an error report. Help used to be sourced from my copy of Office, now I'm directed online to the MS websit whether I like it or not!

IMHO MS have become a bunch of control freaks who want to 'squirrel; around on my hard disk checking anything and everything I do. If they are indeed now going to tell me what I can and can't do (or rather, exercise control secretively in the background) with my PC, I'm off to another OS. And to another 'office' solution.

My next PC will not be a Vista-based solution and there'll be some debate with my wife, but a return to my beloved MAC platform is looking increasingly likely!

Any suggestions on viable alternatives for 'office' solutions, ones that will allow me to work with existing Word, Excel and PowerPoint docs?

MS have finally pushed me over the edge. Hasta la Vista? They won't be seeing me again if I can help it.......

by glgruver

I have been using that for nearly a year now and it has worked fine. It can read and save in ms-office file extensions. I have used the spreadsheet, word processing, and slide show applications and they all worked quite well with ms-office xp. The spreadsheet needed a bit of tweaking to exactly match the ms-office 97 file, but overall, I am happy with the Open Office software.

KDE also has a free office suite that supposedly does much the same thing, but I have not worked with it enough to verify this. It is bundled with a Mepis distro that I am evaluating on my home system.

glgruver

by stewart.smart

Thanks - I'll check them out. Good to get some positive feedback on alternatives.

Given the dependency many people and organisations have on MS applications, I know it's pure wishful thinking that MS might crumble or eat some humble pie, but the anti-trust actions against MS in both the US and Europe offer a few rays of hope in the darkness....

by sheiba

Has anyone tried to take ownership of a folder in 'Documents and Settings' or tried to change permissions and security setting?
Say no more.
This OS is an Admins nightmare.
No compliments at this stage goes to Microsoft; but time will tell. I hope!

by tegal

Why do I feel so hard done by with MS? Do I really expect more from them? I just read through this entire post and was nodding agreement to almost anything. I intend to stick with XP for as long as I can enforce it at work.

I actually like XP, it's more stable than 98 and a bit prettier than 2k with a few more whiz-bangs added. My first thought about Vista and graphics shots I saw was 'what a waste of processing power'. XP still makes fairly heafty demands on the system resouces, specially on older machines, which being a charity most of our machines are, which I think are just over the edge of reasonable, but Vista ... ?!!! We'd have to buy a complete set of new PCs coz none of ours have the spec.

Home is another matter I like my games. Are there any alternative OS that will run PC (read Winows-based) games?

by apotheon

Linux provides excellent support for Windows games. Some games won't work (yet), but many do, and some even perform notably better on Linux than on Windows.

The most basic case is that of using Wine for running games. It's not all that easy to set up for someone new to it, however, so you may want to go with [url=http://www.transgaming.com]Cedega[/url]. For $5 a month, you can get regular updates to the software once it's installed, and run pretty much every major Windows game on the market shortly after it's released.

by howdougd

You can teach an old dog new tricks. I'll be 75
next birthday. Not too old to learn something new. Was fed up with MS long ago. Switchd to Ubuntu 13 months ago. Now use it on two home computers daily. Will never go back to MS products. Completely satisfied with Ubuntu. Come visit at:

http://www.imhdd.ms11.net/

by egpor95

Actually I decided a long time ago not to give Micro$oft any money for Vi$ta. The type of behavior exhibited by them will continue until it becomes too costly to do so. Basically, once you have paid for the product and it has been verified and activated, micro$oft has no right or authority to question anything you do with your computer. It is a blatent attempt at restraint of trade. I am hopeful that a large number of state attorneys will begin a large, expensive class action against them but I am not holding my breath. Too much money has already changed hands and it would not be a sufficiently popular "political" decision. Oh well, *nix is better, after all.

Gene Y.

by stalphonzo

At the risk of getting flamed here I think you people need to understand a thing or two about business.

First, I do not work at Microsoft. I do not know anyone who does. Second, I don't like product activation either. I find it offensive that Microsoft assumes guilt with a legitimate customer such as myself.

However, I also understand their desire to protect their intellectual property and right to profit as a business. Though casual copying is a problem which they acknowledge as a reason for product activation, the real problem is in places like China, Russia and other countries where they can give a hoot about Microsoft's rights as a company. Can you tell me how they're supposed to prevent the millions of users in these places from pirating their software? Without some sort of product activation mechanism in ALL of their software, how exactly are they supposed to prevent this? Just like you don't like the idea of someone stealing your friends car or CD's or whatever, neither should you like the idea that someone is stealing their software.

But this is the problem. Many think it's OK to steal software. It isn't. Just because MS makes 120 million a day on their products doesn't give ANYONE the right to rip them off. Period.

Microsoft's tactics aren't any different than any other Enterprise software and most home-based software products. Almost all vendors require some sort of activation. Because you're dealing with the OS it seems rather heavy handed that MS can disable your entire system, but what else are they supposed to do? Say please don't rip me off? Pretty please?

Frankly they should increase the grace period to 14 days and give the user a console to access their personal data in the event of a problem. Also, MS will, in just about every case, bend the rules if you call and explain the situation. I also think they should lighten up on what triggers reactivation. Perhaps not even minor hardware changes, but only upon a full re-install (hard drive change)?

There are 100's of alternatives to MS products, some of which are excellent. Apple (although you have similar issues with them) and of course Linux -- some really great choices like PC Linux and Ubuntu. If you don't like product activation then I encourage you to try these. For many they're a perfectly acceptable alternative.

Product activation sucks. No doubt, but it is Microsoft?s right. It's your right to choose not to use their products, which some have done and that's fine. But a little perspective is in order. Microsoft has the right to protect their property. If you can think of a better way I?m sure Microsoft is all ears.

by rdav99vfr

Sure, MS has the right to protect themselves, but the bottom line is that this latest garbage is going to drive a substantial chunk of their paying customer base away. In trying to protect their bottom line, they're causing what appears to be significant collateral damage that will likely hurt their bottom line more than help it. Will they fly the whole thing right into the ground trying to protect their bottom line? It's a slippery slope for sure.

I never thought I would consider a *nix OS, but they're only getting stronger every month while MS is becoming more obnoxious every month making me think more than twice now.

by techexec2

.
I strongly disagree with your rosy description of Microsoft. There is nothing normal about Microsoft. They are a deviant convicted monopoly that defies everyone including governments. I don't think you understand Microsoft at all. And, I don't think you understand the dastardly business tactics they use. Now, they are mistreating their own customers. They think they are invulnerable.

The one who needs perspective is Microsoft. They clearly have insufficient understanding and concern about their own customers.

[b][i]"...I also understand their desire to protect their intellectual property and right to profit as a business..."[/i][/b]

No argument with that. My point in mentioning the huge profits they are already making is that they are not starving. It isn't like they [u]need[/u] the money. So, I find it particularly offensive that in spite of huge profits that most COUNTRIES would kill to have, they are hurting legitimate customers in an effort to get more.

[b][i]"...Can you tell me how they're supposed to prevent the millions of users in these places from pirating their software? Without some sort of product activation mechanism in ALL of their software, how exactly are they supposed to prevent this?..."[/i][/b]

This is Microsoft's problem. And, how big of a problem can it really be if they make $18 BILLION in profit, on $44 BILLION sales, each year? This is the kind of piracy problem that most companies would LOVE to have.

I can live with product activation. It's the capricious product DE-activation that is the last straw for me.

[b][i]"...Because you're dealing with the OS it seems rather heavy handed that MS can disable your entire system, but what else are they supposed to do?..."[/i][/b]

It IS heavy handed. What should they do? They should not EVER deactivate a legitimate customer's system. Not even one time. The fact that they put that code in there, and that it can be triggered by merely installing software, or a bug, or a hacker (trust me, that is coming), is completely unacceptable.

[b][i]"...But this is the problem. Many think it's OK to steal software. It isn't. Just because MS makes 120 million a day on their products doesn't give ANYONE the right to rip them off. Period..."[/i][/b]

No disagreement about software piracy.

[b][i]"...Frankly they should increase the grace period to 14 days and give the user a console to access their personal data in the event of a problem. Also, MS will, in just about every case, bend the rules if you call and explain the situation. I also think they should lighten up on what triggers reactivation. Perhaps not even minor hardware changes, but only upon a full re-install (hard drive change)?..."[/i][/b]

These are all good suggestions. Any normal company would know not to hurt their own customers. Or threaten to sue them if they use Linux. Microsoft backing off now will not satisfy me. They are completely unpredictable and untrustable. And, Ballmer has disclosed that there is more restrictive WGA code sitting in wait that can be activated and has threatened to do so. They are out of control. Read: (1).

[b]Conclusion[/b]

There are lots of people like you who are willing to submit to Microsoft's nonsense while you make them richer and richer. I understand. You are free to submit. I am free to not submit. And, I'll try not to smile if your system is ever capriciously deactivated on you. :-)

Take care.

---------------------------

(1) Ballmer blames pirates for poor Vista sales. Will crank up WGA.
http://www.techspot.com/news/24405-ballmer-says-buffing-up-wga-will-improve-vista-sales.html
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37721
http://www.macnn.com/articles/07/02/19/ballmer.blames.piracy/

by Former member

History has shown that copy protection schemes are ultimately crackable. Those who wish to steal, will find a way to do so( Hey, the only cost to them is time, and time they have).

So, here's an idea, stop spending money developing copy protection schemes, which don't stop the pirates, which increase the total cost of the final product, and which frequently create productivity loss for legitimate users. Then reduce the store price of the product, thereby reducing the profit margin for commercial pirates, making it a less interesting target for them and therefore a less pirated product.

I suspect they could do that without even touching their profit margin (which obviously, as a publicly trafed company, they have to cater to the investors. Such is the nature of the beast).

by ms owns you.

"But, with only 3 days, it is very possible I might. What about 3-day weekends?"

Last i checked, your computer has to be turned on for the 3(30) day activation timer to countdown. Otherwise it sits in a sort of stasis. If you can not find internet in 3 days, then you probably shouldn't be using a copy of an OS that is not yours.

From reading your post and looking at your screenshot, I will take the intuitive leap and say you have never activated Vista to begin with.

So, let me ask you; Why should Microsoft allow you to do whatever you want with their software when you have not even purchased it, nor activated it? You are just pissed because you wanted a free OS and you are not getting one. QQ more, someone may care.

I have used Vista for a few months now (Business 1 month(beta), Ultimate 2 months)

All I ever hear is, "Woe is me!" "Down with Microsoft, up with (some obscure open source OS)!"

The reason a lot of open source OS' do not have security issues is the rest of the world doesnt care about them. Why try to pick a fight with a bunch of computer geeks locked in their rooms preparing for an attack that will never happen? It is much easier to pick off the mindless masses that use mainstream software.

I am not a MS fan, but I also know that no matter how much people QQ, they are here to stay.

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...Last i checked, your computer has to be turned on for the 3(30) day activation timer to countdown. Otherwise it sits in a sort of stasis. If you can not find internet in 3 days, then you probably shouldn't be using a copy of an OS that is not yours..."[/i][/b]

I don't care what it's supposed to do or if it has a bug or whatever. I think it is completely unacceptable for a legitimate customer's operating system to EVER self-deactivate. The code that does that should not be present in Vista. That is the only way to ensure it never happens. Microsoft surely knows this. So, they put that code in there, knowing that it would burn some legitimate customers, and they don't give a damn. They care more about trying to suck even MORE money from people in China, India, and Russia.

BTW: The malware that deactivates Vista will surely be around the corner. That will be LOTS of fun.

[b][i]"...From reading your post and looking at your screenshot, I will take the intuitive leap and say you have never activated Vista to begin with.

So, let me ask you; Why should Microsoft allow you to do whatever you want with their software when you have not even purchased it, nor activated it? You are just pissed because you wanted a free OS and you are not getting one. QQ more, someone may care..."[/i][/b]

You are way off the mark and misread my post. Ed Bott of ZDNet is the one who found this, not me. Check the links in my original post.

Furthermore, if I were you, I'd be embarassed about making a wild accusation like that without having made certain of my facts. I don't play computer games at all and never pirate software or music. Ever.

[b][i]"...I am not a MS fan, but I also know that no matter how much people QQ, they are here to stay..."[/i][/b]

I don't care if Microsoft stays or goes. What they do no longer matters to me.

[b]Conclusion[/b]

I can see you are someone who has chosen to keep using Windows and running Microsoft products. That's fine. And, you're right that there are a lot of flaming anti-Microsoft people out there. I am not one of them. I have been using Windows since 1992 (and still am as I type this). I, like you, have put up with Microsoft's nonsense up until now. I have simply had enough of it and am now going to take advantage of the alternatives that are now available. There has never been a better time to make a move like this.

I will try not to smile if your Vista system ever capriciously deactivates itself! :-)

Take care!

by joergsattler

For the worl of me i will never understand why people are so eager to embrace anything that comes from Redmond Washington.
The first tipoff should have been the exagerated hardware requirements to just run the basic version.
Now i keep seeing , and hearing from users about all kind of other nonsense ,deactivation when you install software other than that supplied or installed at the point of the initial activation, Hardware changes, or upgrades other than those present at original activation. Thats enough to make me look for alternatives to Windows Vista, period.
as much as i dislike Mac OS machines because of their proprietariness in hardware and software approach they seem less intrusive,
and as a consequence more acceptable then they have ever been prior to the arrival of Vista.
It's bizzare that the software engeniers at Microsoft are so ignorant to this problem that they keep designing software that's so user unfriendly. ill stick with XP and then seek alternatives when needed.

by chris.christenson

Mac has changed alot. Look at the Hardware specs. You would be supprised to see the same hardware as an Wintel box.

Same processor, HD's and RAM. It isn't as difficult to find parts like it was 8-10 years ago.

by now left tr

+ the post read as a personal opinion and not that of a company.

Perhaps you should post more often if you have things to say!!!

by gstrickland

"Perhaps you should post more often if you have things to say!!!"

With nice and friendly responses like that, perhaps I should. But wait ... .. maybe I have better things to do.

by codebubba

I played with Vista for awhile on a spare laptop I have here at the office. Unless and until the company mandates an upgrade to it I wouldn't touch it with a 10-foot-pole on a production machine.

As for my personal equipment - NADA! Nyet! No way Jose'. I have paid for all the XP licenses on my personal equipment and that's the last O/S software I plan to buy for some time.

This news about deactivation in 3 days is a pretty serious nail in that coffin.

-CB :)

by chris.christenson

I have been both a Mac user and a Wintel user since the early 80's and 90's (for the Mac) Steve Jobs can be arrogant but let me tell you he has been delivering what he promises. I run both Windows and the Mac operating system on my $500 Mac mini with no problems. Upgrading hardware or software is not an issue. Its time to stop being a slave to the great and wonderful "Gates." Lets face it Bill has brought alot of good to computing but this time his greed is too much.

by jrich2

I'm afraid to "upgrade" to Vista because I don't want a never-ending stream of problems... It looks like MS peaked at XP Pro. Pretty stable and doesn't require a lot of activating and authorizing.

by gemfly

Even if you refuse to use Vista, the day will come that Vista will be the only safe O/S supported with regular updates. Time will catch up to you. Oh, and enjoy your Mac.

by techexec2

Between now and then I will be using a much safer computer and won't have to deal with the 114,000 viruses and other malware that are attacking Windows anymore.

Touch? ]:)

P.S. My reason for switching has nothing to do with security or safety.

by noelrd

Go ahead and whine away. The rest of us will work out the problems. Use Ubuntu, it might work if you are lucky. Or use OpenOffice, but try not to fall asleep waiting for it to open. Call Microsoft bad names, just like everyone used to call IBM. Brag about how important you are - whiners really appreciate that. Oh, I forgot the main thing - give half truths about everything, like; linux is great, Vista is bad, etc.

Again, welcome

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...Go ahead and whine away..."[/i][/b]

If you noticed, I'm not whining. I'm leaving.

[b][i]"...The rest of us will work out the problems..."[/i][/b]

Only fools of the highest order would ever PAY their own money to help Microsoft work out Microsoft's own product problems. It is truly stunning that Microsoft can work for five (5) years, spending billions of dollars, and STILL release Vista in such poor condition and without great ISV and IHV support. The very short list of approved certified applications is pathetic.

[b][i]"...Or use OpenOffice, but try not to fall asleep waiting for it to open..."[/i][/b]

Get a faster computer. It's not a problem for me at all.

[b][i]"...Call Microsoft bad names..."[/i][/b]

No company I can think of has done more to deserve being disliked. Companies that run around threatening to sue their own customers are begging for it. And, that is but one example out of many.

[b][i]"...Brag about how important you are..."[/i][/b]

Where did I do that exactly?

[b][i]"...Oh, I forgot the main thing - give half truths about everything..."[/i][/b]

Name one half-truth I gave.

I think you are mischaracterizing me as a Linux Zealot. I'm really a disgruntled Microsoft Zealot who has just decided to refuse to upgrade to Vista. Of course, that means leaving Windows too. XP won't last forever.

[b]Suggestion for you[/b]

I can see that you have your personal identity and self-esteem intertwined with Microsoft's glowing orb of success. I used to be where you are, about 15 years ago, and I understand that. I can tell you from personal experience that it is a losing place to be. Microsoft is a winner to be sure. But, everyone outside a small elite within Microsoft are really kidding themselves. In fact, most of the 71,000 Microsoft employees are not ever going to come close to becoming one of the "Microsoft Millionaires". That party is O-V-E-R. Checked MSFT stock lately? Flat for over 5 years. People outside of Microsoft are just pawns in Microsoft's game and they will be sacrificed without a second thought whenever they choose. The long list of dead Microsoft "partners" is proof of that.

So, my advice is for you to make a serious review of yourself. Chart your own course and stop blindly following Microsoft. They are leading you astray.

Good luck.

by jmgarvin

See, IBM tried to do the same thing that MS is doing now...only this was back in the 80's. So guess what happened...IBM went bankrupt and had to rethink their whole strategy.

Perhaps, MS will learn from this fiasco, and actually build and OS that consumers want.

by techexec2

.
Exactamundo!

Microsoft is in that place where IBM was just before it began to fall. Overconfidence and arrogance. Making big plans to grow to a much larger size through business model extension. Lots of unhappy customers. And, most importantly, a nimble new competitor looming.

For IBM it was Microsoft.

For Microsoft it is Linux.

We'll see. Nothing is certain.

by noelrd

Another half truth. Its former CEO liked to brag about how he brought IBM from the brink of bankruptcy. Maybe, that's what you're thinking about.

by abhishek-itgeek

The information of Windows VISTA not working when certain changes are detected by it is purely devastating for people like me who are Microsoft fans. Really Bill should have some other way out to "Bill" the cheaters, not that way which could hurt normal and genuine users.

by rainmaker2112

While this article was interesting reading, the facts are:

1) a fix is out for this issue. Go here: http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;EN-US;931573

2) in the case of Ed Bott's game it was a game-protection piece of software nGameGuard that caused the issue. Contacting the game producer to update their version of this piece of software fixes the issue.

3) there aren't random or indiscriminate times when the "deactivation" occurs. Something triggers this event and some research will uncover it.

4) if something changes a system setting I'd want to know about it. In this case a setting changed that could cause many more problems than windows stopping. You can contact MS via phone to restart the system if it stopped working AND you don't lose your data.

5) The reality is that MS software is some of the most pirated in the world and activation while a bit painful isn't that big of deal when you consider the business side. Those who have the biggest gripes are those who can't install one copy on multiple computers like the "old days"

It's interesting that Ed Bott didn't include an update about the fixes and that his game triggered the event and that contacting the game producer to update the game guard would fix this. Alas, throw gas on the fire and then walk away I guess.

by freebird54

Strangely enough, when I read the article(s) about this issue, I also learned of the fixes, and how they work. Perhaps a re-read?

As to the piracy problem - it has grown very large, indeed - caused by the over-pricing of what SHOULD be a easy 'commodity' to afford. Win 3.1 was little pirated - but then again you could afford to buy it -even if you were a 'weenie pirate' type.

IF the big problem is in foreign markets, it should have been easy enough to put these restrictions (and de-activation possibilities) in the versions that use the language of the affected areas - without penalizing the millions who DO pay for the software.

It took me until '02 to move to XP, because of the ludicrous tying of an os to a particular machine - or even to a particular configuration of that machine. I moved only when it became clear that a) they fixed most of the worst problems with SP2 and b) that they were not going after people for motherboard changes after all.

Microsoft weathered all the complaints about this kind of thing last time, so naturally they are trying for even more - we seem to put up with it!

Yes, I made the switch to Linux recently, and if I see Vista it will be on a work machine that isn't on something sensible, like 2000, *nix, or even NT 4....

Why do the inadequate/inferior systems always seem to win out in the marketplace? VHS/Beta, Windows over Mac/Amiga, Intel vs Motorola....

by so.cal guy

As for me i will wait for vista sp1 to come out before upgrading but to say i will change jobs because i don't want nothing to do with windows vista give me a break as much as you love it or hate it windows vista is here to stay and all the whining and crying is not going to change that fact

I'm in school at this point learning the In's and outs of vista because as we replace our work stations they will have vista on them and if you work in the support Field you will need to know this OS because like it or not after the computers with xp installed are gone it's going to be hard to find them and you are going to have to support windows vista

change is all ways hard but it's here and we as IT professionals we have to change with it

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...a fix is out for this issue..."[/i][/b]

and

[b][i]"...Contacting the game producer to update their version of this piece of software fixes the issue..."[/i][/b]

Thanks for the link. I expected they would fix this quickly. Doesn't change anything for me though.

I don't care if this capricious deactivation occurred because of a bug or not. I don't care if Microsoft or a vendor "fixes" the bug or not. [u]The problem is that there is code in the operating system that can cause it to self-deactivate[/u]. That alone is unacceptable.

I'm simply not ever going to run an operating system that can capriciously self-deactivate, even if it is "not supposed to happen to legitimate customers and we're sorry it happened to you" or some such.

I wonder... Will servers powered by the coming Vista Server have self-deactivation code that is never supposed to deactivate too? Airline scheduling systems? Police 911 information systems? Hospital information systems? Just a thought... :^0 :^0 :^0 (although this really isn't funny)

[b][i]"...Something triggers this event and some research will uncover it..."[/i][/b]

You mean like some malware for instance? :^0

While Microsoft is researching it, and somebody else's computer is down, I'm going to be running Windows XP, MacOS, or Linux. I'll even let them borrow my computer to check their e-mail, [u]presuming the mail server is not also capriciously self-deactivated[/u]!! :^0 :^0 :^0

[b][i]"...You can contact MS via phone to restart the system if it stopped working..."[/i][/b]

I love how Microsoft is so generous with my time like that. No. I'm going to run Windows XP, Linux, and Macintosh and never have to call and wait on hold at any time. And, I can compute away from the Internet and telephones if I choose. I can compute on Christmas day if I choose. I can compute at 3:00 am if I choose. And, my operating system will never self-deactivate.

[b][i]"...The reality is that MS software is some of the most pirated in the world and activation while a bit painful isn't that big of deal when you consider the business side..."[/i][/b]

It's not activation that I object to. It's DE-activation.

This piracy problem is Microsoft's business problem. It is particularly offensive that they would try to make it my problem with this self-deactivation nonsense. And besides, it's not like they need the money. $44 BILLION in sales, $18 BILLION in profit last year. Poor Microsoft. They "only" cleared $18 BILLION last year because of those bad pirates in China, India, and Russia!! :^0 What they chose to do [i]TO ME[/i] because of that is unacceptable.

[b][i]"...Those who have the biggest gripes are those who can't install one copy on multiple computers like the "old days"..."[/i][/b]

Not me. I've been a paying Microsoft and Windows customer since 1992...and up until last week.

[b]Our conversation was had in Redmond[/b]

I'm quite sure there were a bunch of young Microsoft engineers in a conference room in Redmond designing this self-deactivation "feature". They had a conversation much like we just had here. In the end, they decided that this would be acceptable.

They were too young, too foolish, and wrong.

[b]Not an Over-reaction[/b]

As you can see, mine was not an over-reaction at all. The "brilliant" minds at Microsoft just did not think this all the way through.

And, I am [i]NEVER[/i] going to upgrade to Vista.

Take care...

by dfarrich9

More garbage from Microsoft. More control. More of nothing. XP was their first almost accepatable product - note almost. One would think they would have written a better release instead of changing everything - much the less changing it for the worse. They're nothing more than acres of over-educated underexperienced idiots clustered in Redmond WA.

by jbb1

MS has just cut the availability of tech suport on some versions of Vista from ten years to five. Their reasoning is obscure. At the same time, they are apparently extending support on Windows XP. Makes you wonder what they know that we don't.

Just another reason to avoid Vista.

by techexec2

.
I would not change jobs to avoid Vista either.

You are correct. Vista is the new Windows OS and many people and businesses will upgrade to it. Many will not. I will not and my company will not. The truth is, nobody has to upgrade to Vista. Nobody. It's strictly a matter of choice.

And, this is not about avoiding change. There is going to be a change alright. But, it will be to Linux and to Macintosh, not to Vista.

P.S. I can understand that you would have to accept running Vista in Vista, CA!! :^0

by wgs777

I agree with you 100%. Vista's WGA and DRM tie up your computers CPU not for your benefit, but instead are working against you. Also Vista's severe hardware, software, and driver incompatibility issues are reasons to never touch Vista. Anyone who uses a computer to do real work should never upgrade from XP Professional to Vista. The CIO at the US Department of Transportation has banned upgrades to Vista citing "No compelling business reason to upgrade and several reasons not to upgrade to Vista". See this Link: http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=197700789

by doctordawg

Who are these tards who think "free enterprise" means Microsoft is free to do whatever the hell they want, and you either pay or go somewhere else? Microsoft is changing the terms of the sale AFTER I buy the product (bugger off with your "you should have read the billion lines of disclaimers" nonsense). This isn't capitalism, this is fascism. This is corporo-nazism. Once I BUY the software, I have the right to be left the hell alone. But no.

I am in mid-process of migrating my entire network to Ubuntu now. So far so good.

Microsoft, or any corporation, should not own the ability to speak, the same as no one owns the english language. You can charge for lessons, or for books in english, but no one should own the language, and hence control the ability to speak. Microsoft's stranglehold on my computer's ability to speak must end. And Linux is the language to achieve this.

by apotheon

"[i]And Linux is the language to achieve this.[/i]"
That's not just Linux. There are other options as well. The various *BSD operating systems probably make up the only other practical alternatives in that vein, for most people at least. That's another entire family of operating systems, though, that most people neglect when they start talking about practical alternatives to MS Windows.

In fact, something like FreeBSD grants you even greater legal control over your computing environment, because you don't have to deal with the forced redistribution of code requirements of the GPL with regard to the BSD kernel and core utilities. That's the main reason I decided to finally give FreeBSD a try, though once I did so I found many more reasons to make it my primary OS of choice.

by lightning joe

How funny (and how Microsoft!) that a discussion on Windows Vista quickly morphs into a Linux promo!

by apotheon

For my part, I'm more of a fan of FreeBSD.

. . . but Linux Uber Microsoft is certainly something worth considering.

by apotheon

Maybe he's looking for jobs that don't involve up to date MS Windows use at all. If he moves on to an all open source shop, and has wanted to get out of the proprietary OS line of work for a while anyway, now is the [b]perfect[/b] time to "move on" from his current job.

I think we need more information to be able to determine whether the decision to leave a job because of Vista adoption is a good one, in this case.

by apotheon

"[i]Ask me again in a couple of years what my next step will be. Maybe by then other vendors will jump on the big mistake MS have made and offer an alternative OS to us all.[/i]"
Are you unaware that many alternatives already exist?

by tyler70006

There is more misinformation out there about Vista. If you don't want to use it fine but quit being such a lying cry baby. Grow up...

by techexec2

Can you support that assertion? I would love for you to be right about that.

This was found by Ed Bott of ZDNet. He documented it pretty well.

Please cite website references or other information to support what you have claimed about this.

Thank you.

by tyler70006

Of course I can't prove that he is wrong. Only that it din't happen to me on the 50 or so computer I've already set up with Vista. And yes I've made many changes to them software and hardware. If it did happen just call MS and get it re-activated. I'm just tired of all the bitching and complaining. Any resonable person could fix this problem with out giving up.

by boony

I know this is a thread re: Vista, and a had a bitter taste of the beta and have spit it out. After doing some research on Linux, my head is nearly spinning from the distros, (not that choice is a bad thing)and I'd like to know if you had any suggestions for a Windows only boy. PC Linux? Linspire? Ubuntu? Is there a best one to cut your teeth on? I'm building a new box soon, and I'd like to keep MS off of it, or possibly Linux+XP with VMware.

by techexec2

.
I understand your view of Vista. I agree with you. I ran the beta also without this problem. And, yes, there is a way to resolve the problem if it does occur. That is not the point.

The point is that it is completely unacceptable to me that there is code in Vista that can self-deactivate the operating system. I don't want to have to deal with this nonsense. Apparently, this time it was a bug. Next time it could be malware. Who knows? Who cares?

I will not stand for my workstations to be subject to capricious self-deactivation under any circumstances.

I don't want my Vista Servers (when released) to be subject to capricious self-deactivation. I won't stand for it.

It's OK if you want to sign up for that. I won't do it. I will not tolerate any more bullsh*t from Microsoft. How do you know this is the end of it? You don't and neither do I. Ballmer has already disclosed that there is more restrictive WGA code sitting in wait that can be activated and has threatened to do so. They are out of control. Read: (1).

There are good alternatives that don't self-deactivate and I am going to use them. Microsoft is not necessary anymore.

I hope you enjoy Vista and that it never self-deactivates on you and that you are happy with it.

I am also going to be happy and will never upgrade to Vista.

-----------------------------

(1) Ballmer blames pirates for poor Vista sales. Will crank up WGA.
http://www.techspot.com/news/24405-ballmer-says-buffing-up-wga-will-improve-vista-sales.html
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37721
http://www.macnn.com/articles/07/02/19/ballmer.blames.piracy/

P.S. And, if your workstation is deactivated and you need to check your e-mail, I'll let you use my workstation to check it, assuming the Vista e-mail server is not self-deactivated that is. :-)

by slydder

if more people were to avoid supporting MS products there would be a larger and faster move to real OS's. I for one do not support any MS OS. I have XP Home, XP Pro and 2000 running multi-boot on one box in house but only for those times when I need to check something. And that box is not booted very often. I have moved approximately 85% of my clients to Linux/BSD solutions and away from MS. They are happy and I am happy.

chuck