Discussion Locked

[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]

0 helpful
1,352 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,352 replies

by techexec2

.
In my view, what you're doing is ethically wrong. I don't like Microsoft, but I don't steal from them. Two wrongs don't make a right.

That said, your choosing to steal from Microsoft has no direct affect on me. So, how you feel about what you choose to do is your business, not mine.

by neb

Hey that's cool, I asked for an opinion.

The point I was trying to make though was that I'm making MS a lot more money by having and knowing how to do thier stuff then they'd have made by me buying an OS, which I would not have done anyway. I make them money and they don't pay me anything. They also pay their employees way more than I make while I'm making them a quite a bit of money. ...that's the basic idea. I know you can always dispute what I've said, but define ethics. I'm pretty sure I have a valid point. And as long as I'm not shrink wrapping it and selling it to someone else they aren't hurt by it.

by apotheon

In my view, there's nothing ethically wrong with that behavior. In my view, copyright law -- basically, using government to force you to behave in a given manner with something you possess by putting a gun to your head -- is what's ethically wrong. Once Microsoft "sells" something, it should have zero say over how it's used by someone else. That's all there is to it.

Now, an explicit contractual agreement would change things. If Microsoft reps came to you with a contract and demanded that you sign it, allowing you to read it first of course, before they'd turn over a Microsoft Windows installation CD to you, you'd be ethically obligated to abide by the terms of the contract (as well as legally at risk if you didn't). Copyright law and end user license "agreements", however, do not do this at all -- they ensure that when something finds its way into your possession, perhaps without your consent or immediate knowledge, you are then [b]retroactively[/b] forced by law to comply with terms of use to which you [b]never agreed[/b]. That's not proprietary rights -- it's an end-run around anti-slavery laws.

By the way, TechExec2, even the law doesn't define violation of copyright law as "theft". Copyright infringement (the technical term) is not theft, because one does not deprive another person of possessions by infringing copyright. All one does is dilute a (nominally) limited monopoly power to control the disposition, duplication, and distribution of materials that fit a specific legally provable form. That's a huge step away from stealing. In fact, when you describe it accurately, it doesn't sound like a crime at all -- does it?

by hal 9000

It's not even a breach of Copyright as M$ expects and sells SA with this in mind to have your staff use the same thing at home as they use on their workstations.

Col

by techexec2

.
I have come to appreciate your point of view on the ethics of this as well. And, I admit my use of 'steal' was technically inaccurate (just being a little lazy).

Even a copyleft-based license like the GPL depends on copyright law for enforcement in the courts, and the software uses the same "click wrap" method of license consummation.

by neb

I like both of your opinions, not saying I agree or disagree. But I'd really like a comment directed at some of my particualar statments.

The legal and ethical argument is really for those who just buy and use the products. I know that it technically implies everybody. But using the products and in turn developing skills that result in making money for people like MS is really a different story, especially when they normally have to PAY employees. I know it's a stretch, but making me pay hundreds of dollars for a full version of Vista is indentured service. And actually MS does ALLOW the sort of thing I've said I'm doing, with it's products.

by jackie40d1

I am trying out several versions of Linux to see which one I want to use for this computer .

I have win 2 K Pro and the about 16 patches for it installed the reat are ignored as I do not have IE on this machine any more nor the other thing MS put out called Outlook . .

I am between Linux 2007, PClinuxOS, and Linspire 5.0 as the final contestants for this computer depends on which one I can get what working fastest . . The games are on Code Weavers ( got to have my 4 or 5 games ) to keep from going totally mad . . besides it exersize for my right arm ( got it out of a sling a few weeks ago ) I run them for 1 week and see what I got working and what does not work . . Winner will be posted hahahaha !

by jackie40d1

I got the story in a e-mail maybe a day ago and only glanced at it But its about time some one got on M$ about their BS they have been putting out and expecting people to put up with . . Like K.M.A. and we will give you a patch !

by n98b

XP has the same behavior as you mentioned in vista- only with the later WGA updates, so unless you plan to not update your XP system, then You can stay with XP. If not- then you should cry to Microsoft about the whole thing because it's been around for a while in both operating systems.

by hal 9000

Vista at the first Service Pack that is if M$ can keep to schedule and it would make it a first will be released in about 2 years time and then you are locked into only using Digitally Signed hardware on your Vista System. If you have any hardware not digitally signed Vista is going to shut down and not restart till it's removed which may prove a bit difficult if it's something built onto the M'Board.

Then at the next release of Vista which again if M$ can stick to their self announces schedule will also Incorporate Digital Signing of Software so if you have some software not Digitally Signed it's unable to be installed on Windows whatever it ends up being called either something like Vista R2 or if the marketing department finds that there is bulk resistance to the Vista name they'll come up with something different probably XP R2 just to trade on a product that while not great works sort of unlike Vista does at this point in time. This isn't to force the M$ Monopoly but to add security to the Windows Platform as any Digitally Signed Software will be incapable of doing any damage to the Windows Kernel and it will be much more secure. Actually I thought that was the current only valid reason to move to Vista now. :D

I've yet to see XP's WGA come up with anything like this but it's slated for Vista and is quite well known by every M$ Partner who bothers to attend the meetings and the M$ staff are boasting about this. Also Vista is the basis of all the M$ Windows Products for the next 10 years again if M$ can keep to their self imposed schedule so that will probably get stretched out to 15 or more years depending on just how far behind they run and if they are stupid enough to try to resurrect that Bloody Silly WFS again after all it was promised with NT something or other and is still as yet to eventuate.

Who knows at the end of the development cycle that has been announced for Vista it just might look like it was supposed to when Longhorn was announced but still without the WFS. :^0

Col

by jackie40d1

I have put the same copy of Win 2 K Pro on about 20 or 30 computers and not one has ever been shut down but then I put a good fire wall
on them so MS can't jack with them . . Its only been lately I have sold computers with Linux on them as the people heard about "PATCH TUESDAY" and were not wanting any part of it ! !
The Linux I put on their computers did all the stuff they wanted to do .. the Big Open Source OFFICE does most of their work and connecting to web is easy . . So they are happy and do not need much else . .

by parrotnut

OMG!!! I can`t stop laughing...can not type or see!!
This is a professional business?

by w2ktechman

pirating SW and selling systems to others in this way.
And especially bragging about it in an open forum. you should be ashamed.

by hal 9000

And Office 2007 now need activating and the free ride is over. :D

While I'm personally in two minds about this as I've seen companies buy 1 Action Pack and then proceed to install it on everything that they sell so it's impossible to compete with their prices as they don't charge the correct amount for any software.

However saying that the Last Action Pack that I purchased was full of Pirate M$ Product according to M$ and it's stupid WGA so I just suggested to the M$ tech Support Line that they where in total Control of the Market as they sold the Real Stuff and the Pirate Stuff as well so they could control everything that was sold and in what numbers it gets sold at.

Col

by parrotnut

As I type this, I am using a live cd and it is much faster than winxp! I am really impressed and am going to wipe a hdd and install!

by techexec2

.
If people who bought "Vista-capable" computers last year feel they were mislead by Microsoft, I suppose they SHOULD seek redress. After all, since most of the other important features were removed from Longhorn/Vista before release, not being able to run Aero Glass could easily be the "last straw" for many people. What?! No eye-candy?! :^0 :^0 :^0

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...I just make offsite backup copies of disks for work that have mass install capabilities or whatever you call them, making them valid and WGA compatible and I can install at home for testing things. (sometimes games, but...) I figure MS owes me that much for allowing them to make money off of the MS skill set I've developed over the years since I was an IBM programmer, via my employers..."[/i][/b]

This is a rationalization. It appears that what you're doing is a violation of the EULA. So long as copyright law is the law of the land, I intend to honor it.

by apotheon

"[i]So long as copyright law is the law of the land, I intend to honor it.[/i]"
I intend to do the same, to the best of my ability (within reason), so long as ethical pressures do not prompt me to do otherwise. It's just not smart to willfully violate copyright law with blatant disregard for the current legal circumstances, to say nothing of the fact that even using the software illegally for free provides support for perpetuating an unethical business model because it helps increase the popularity of the software. It also puts me, and anyone who depends on me, at legal risk -- so yeah, I don't tend to do that.

Instead, I try to support software with about as ethical a licensing scheme as I can manage to find and use to keep myself in Pepsi and Cheetos (or, these days, rooibos tea and buffalo burgers). The fact that it's not ethical to impose limits on my use of software in my possession via so-called "agreements" and authoritarian copyright law in no way changes the fact that it's smarter to use something else than to wantonly violate copyright law.

Nobody would take me seriously when I rail against copyright law if I was infringing Microsoft copyright by illegally using MS Windows, anyway. Few enough people take me seriously even when I demonstrate my principles by avoiding the software -- there's no reason to undermine my position and alienate the few who are left listening to what I have to say. Plus, y'know, MS software is technically sub-par anyway.

by jackie40d1

I made an OLD computer used OLD CD burners and
OLD software to be able to copy CD's with some of the old Software did not know it was not supposed to copy stuff
Its how I make copies of my Win 2 K CD's when it gets kinda worn and scratched up As the ones I drag around for fixing stuff is in and out of computers so it is always getting nicked or scratched some where !
Even When I put it in and take it out by putting my little finger in the hole in the center . .

by apotheon

1. I think the GPL is almost as bad as copyright law and proprietary software EULAs. It's just another EULA, in fact.

2. It's not the copyleft characteristics of it that make the GPL dependent on copyright law -- it's the fact that it imposes restrictions on how and when you are allowed to distribute GPLed software. All copyleft would do with a simple anti-copyright type license is make sure that copyright can't "reclaim" something.

3. The only time something like an end user license agreement is unethical as a binding "agreement" is when it actually obligates or restricts the recipient in some way. Both the GPL and Microsoft EULAs do this. Something like the BSD license or [url=http://ccd.apotheon.org]CCD CopyWrite[/url] do nothing more than create an explicitly "protected" license akin to the terms of the public domain. These are ethical licenses (or, at least, about the best you're going to get under current legal circumstances).

On a scale of one to ten, the amount of evil inherent in a given license is pretty much as follows:

CCD CopyWrite: 1
BSD License: 1.5
GPL: 7.5
MS EULA: 11

. . . so the GPL isn't a very effective counter to my arguments. Yes, it's dependent upon copyright law, and it blows chunks -- but that doesn't win you any points because it is in no way a good representation of an ethical treatment of the product of the intellect. As such, it's irrelevant to my argument.

by neb

You told me what you thought was right in the abstract sense. That's assuming the people who created the EULA were playing fair in the first place and they are not. It's still endentured service for those of us trying to make a living using thier stuff. Again, why should I have to pay $600.00 so I can continue to support thier products??

And you still haven't commented on the fact that what I'm talking about is Ok with them in certain contexts.

I mean if you want to get pissy that's fine I guess, but I was trying to have a friendly debate. You are making it kind of contentious. It's becoming similar in kind to a religious argument.

It's like if I asked you if you thought it was possible to walk on water in some way and you answer that your god says it is unholy to get wet. I mean are you saying that I'm going to go to jail for doing this? Cause I'm not.

by techexec2

.
I've answered your question as best I can. It's not about religion and I'm not intending to be "pissy". I cannot speak positively about what you're doing because I don't agree with it. Sorry.

As I see it, the key principles are:

- I believe in obeying the law.

- [u]Copyright law[/u] allows a company (MS) to establish restrictions on copying and use of their intellectual property. You may be violating the copyright restrictions defined in the MS EULA, or not. I don't know (but it appears you are). That's between you, your employer (he is directly involved in your activities and is responsible for them), and MS.

- [u]Contract law[/u] allows a company (MS) to create legally binding agreements with others. When you click "I agree" on the EULA before installing the software, you are entering a legally binding contract.

Based on your description of what you're doing, I think you're in violation of the MS EULA.

[b][i]"...Again, why should I have to pay $600.00 so I can continue to support thier products??..."[/i][/b]

In my view, if the EULA you agreed to (when you clicked "I agree") says you must, then you must. This is not about fair and unfair in my view. It's about legal and illegal.

[b][i]"...And you still haven't commented on the fact that what I'm talking about is Ok with them in certain contexts..."[/i][/b]

I don't know what more to say here. This is between you, and your employer, and Microsoft. If what you're doing is legal, all is good. If not, maybe you should reconsider. Further, if Microsoft allows something "similar" to what you are doing, but not "actually" what you're doing, I would say that you are violating the EULA. Just my opinion.

[b][i]"...I mean are you saying that I'm going to go to jail for doing this? Cause I'm not..."[/i][/b]

No jail time. But, in America, you and your company could be raided by law enforcement authorities based on an anonymous tip. Any disgruntled former employee can provide that. They will examine every single computer. Any copyright violations they find will result in restitution and fines. If you choose to fight it in court, you might also end up paying all of the plaintiff's (MS or BSA) legal fees. Here's an example (1). Laws in America work this way. It may be different in Norway.

[b]In closing[/b]

In closing, I'm not trying to be contentious. I'm just saying what I think. You might feel safer regarding this in Norway than I do in America based on what you have observed happen around you. Perhaps you have never known anyone who has been dragged into court over this. Perhaps you know that Norwegian authorities look the other way. Perhaps copyright laws are different in Norway. Whatever. But, I can tell you with completely certainty that it is a foolish risk to violate software copyright in America.

All the best to you.

BTW: I know a bunch of Norwegians and like Norway. The Lillehammer Olympics were pure magic.

-------------------------------------

(1) Example of a U.S. company that got caught unintentionally violating copyright law
http://news.com.com/2008-1082_3-5065859.html

by techexec2

.
I'll defer to you on ethical theory as that is one of your key interests. It's not something I have invested time in. Maybe someday.

Perhaps you would prefer that I not use the term "ethically wrong" regarding what he is doing and instead just use "illegal" (and it may not even be that). That's fine with me. On the other hand, it wasn't a philosophical ethic I was speaking of. It was just the simple ethic of obeying the law. That's all.

I wasn't really trying to counter your views about the ethics of existing copyright law. My comment about the GPL was only noting that it too is contrary to your views.

by apotheon

Hopefully I didn't come off too harshly in my previous post. I do respect your knowledge and opinion as I've seen it here at TR -- as far as I can tell, you're one of the "good'uns" here at TR, and I thought so before you got fed up with Microsoft as well. I certainly don't mean to cause you to cease sharing your opinions. If I was too harsh in my phrasing, it's probably just because the problems of copyright and patent law -- particularly as they intersect with ethicality -- are subjects of great importance to me, and I want to make sure that my thoughts on the matter are known when contrary (mainstream) opinions are voiced.

There's even a touch of disappointment at yet another MS Windows user with more than two brain cells to rub together switching to open source OSes, if only because it makes it more difficult for me to point out an example of someone I like who doesn't use a free unix OS when someone like rickk, George Ou, Steve Warren, or mindilator claims that I only respect people who agree with me.

In retrospect, I see that it appears your focus in mentioning the GPL was on the EULA-style enforcement of the GPL, and not necessarily on the "free software" claims associated with the GPL. I apologize for misunderstanding your intent, as you seem to be indicating that I did. My fault -- I normally don't make such hasty assumptions about someone's meaning as I did this time. I should have been more reasonably sure of my interpretation, or at least stated my operating assumption clearly, before proceeding as I did.

by apotheon

I thought TechExec2 was being perfectly reasonable -- and I don't even completely agree with him. I think perhaps you've "got your back up", so to speak, and are verging on taking offense where none was intended.

As TechExec2 points out, by willfully and with disregard for the consequences violating a Microsoft EULA (assuming it's a violation), you are exposing more than just yourself to the potential for litigation. The company whose licenses you are violating (again, assuming it's a violation) is now subject to increased exposure to legal action, which can do incredible damage to the company. Even an audit that completely exonerates a company can cost that company significantly both in resources during the audit and in lost productivity.

Regardless of the ethicality of the action, in and of itself, of violating Microsoft EULAs (I don't believe it's unethical -- TechExec2 evidently does, if only because it's a violation of law), exposing your employer to litigation due to license violation is unethical (barring extreme circumstances that probably don't need addressing here) as an IT professional. If you're going to violate Microsoft EULA terms, please do so on your own time and in such a manner that the only people put at risk are those who are similarly engaged in the willful act of infringing copyright.

. . . or, better yet, use an operating system other than MS Windows. If you believe (as I do) that Microsoft's entire business model is predicated upon unethical decisions and practices, you should not be supporting it even while you violate its "rules". As you rightly point out, chances are good that by using MS Windows illegally (assuming you would not have done so legally if illegal use wasn't possible) your actions are in fact resulting in a net benefit to Microsoft's bottom line. That should not be a justification of your action: it should be a reason to stop what you're doing and make a choice between on one hand supporting Microsoft legally and in the manner of Microsoft's choosing, and on the other hand ceasing to support Microsoft in such a manner altogether, using some other operating system instead.

Your behavior appears to be unethical, or at least amoral, even from your own point of view. Perhaps you should reconsider that behavior.

by neb

Thanks for all that, it's what I was looking for. Sorry if I appeared to take offense, I didn?t mean to and I don?t consider anything that was said as something to take offense to. I was just trying to illicit the kind of responses I was looking for, not agreement with what I?m saying either. You learn nothing if everybody agrees with you all the time. (?something I need to keep an eye on myself.) I just felt the blanket statement previously that I need to follow the EULA didn't really say much to me, other than you should always follow the rules, a concept that I am aware of.

I guess you are right about MS and their business practices. But to me that?s an excuse to ignore any promises I would supposedly make to them, flatly a good enough reason. Again, define ethical. Also, I doubt they will raid my house and believe me; my company isn't at much risk. It is at risk for things that are far worse than a MS attack anyway. But I understand where your opinion is coming from sort of.

Why have EULAs and software licenses become such the holy grail of our society today? It's all a bunch of marketing and sales hogwash. They are simply taking advantage of the legal system to send their profits through the roof. The little guy trying to sell shareware still gets stomped into the ground. They don?t have an SUV load of lawyers and soccer moms that can attack whenever they are called upon. And btw/I feel you should always pay shareware licenses or donate in whatever way there is to support people like that. I know what you are going to say though, that it?s no different for bigger companies, but I think it is. I?ve worked for them and know where they are coming from. Not that they are evil, just jerk offs.

Here?s the rub for me, I want to continue working with MS stuff because that?s where the jobs are. They own the market and dominate how businesses do their computing. This mom and pop guy is all well and good, but I can?t find a job making squat if I START learning Linux. Not many people like him hire software developers and maintainers. Also if I go that way I have to start over on a big learning curve and get an entry level job some place. I?ve done that too many times now. I actually started with MS in the DOS days and then had to convert my skills to the IBM mainframe to find work, starting from the entry level there. Gotta love JCL! Then I had to do it all again when Y2K happened and learn the new MS stuff, which is like Swedish compared to the old MS stuff. Again Linux (UNIX) is all well and good (?except that it?s like working on a mainframe, no JCL but?), but the few good jobs out there are for the gurus. I?m no MS guru either, but there are more jobs for people below guru status with MS technology. Once you have a level of knowledge in a particular technology, learning more is quicker and less dismally painful then jumping into a new arena. I know because I?ve done it a lot. I don?t want to change. Change should be feared. But maybe it?s just me and I should get a job at Starbucks or something. That aside it leads to the dilemma I have that in order to get up to speed on a particular new MS technology I have to shell out hundreds of Krone for it. No way will I ever do that. Because you don?t get to do it once, you have to keep doing it over and over and over. There is a new OS every few years a new visual DOT whatever that is completely different, etc., all too expensive. Employers no longer pay for training on this stuff like they did in IBM-land. They expect you train yourself. I know you have no pity for me because I?m unethical, but there?s no real light at the end of that tunnel. I may have to resort to stealing from the vegetable stands in my area for food if I don?t undermine a few EULAs.

by techexec2

.
No harm done.

It must be a difficult position for you to be in. You work in the computer and software industry. Yet, the legal foundation of the industry is based on copyright and patent law (1), something you find unethical. However you choose to work this out for yourself is completely fine. We all have to make our own way in a world we did not create.

Quite honestly, until I conversed with some people on TR about this and read some of your writings, I had really never questioned the ethics of copyright and patent law. It's the law of the land and is pervasive. I've mostly just tried to understand it well and work well within this structure defined by the government. I think most people are in the same boat with me on that (or worse...many do not even understand how copyright, patent, or even trademark law work). I'm sure you realize this, know that you have run ahead of the pack so to speak, and need to help us catch up with you.

At least I'm heading in the right direction. On your 1 to 10 "scale of evil", I've successfully jumped from a level 11 OS to a level 7.5 OS! :^0

--------------------------------

(1) I do have a major problem with the way patents are being used with software. There needs to be major reform there.

by apotheon

Obviously, my "scale of evil" was ad-hoc and meant to be taken with a grain of salt. It certainly wasn't created through any kind of systematic application of objective metrics. It's heuristic in the extreme, based on the "feel" I get from each of the different approaches to dealing with the proceeds of intellectual endeavor. Taking it as a working system, just for argument's sake, however:

I wouldn't say you're on a 7.5 OS. While it's true the kernel is GPLed, and much of the core utilities are GPLed as well -- accounting for more than 50% of the "evil quotient" of the OS as a whole, I'd say -- there are a great many other licenses involved. For instance, the LGPL is similarly pervasive, and there are parts of a complete, highly functional Linux distribution in default configuration that are licensed BSD, MIT, and Apache. Some GPLed software is also dual-licensed, such as Perl's status -- dual-licensed GPL and Perl Artistic License (the latter being probably about 3.5 on the scale) -- and in such cases I'd say that the "evil quotient" of that software would be that of the least evil license used. In general, Linux distributions probably end up settling in somewhere around the level of about 3.5 most of the time.

FreeBSD, meanwhile, uses the BSD license for its kernel and the majority of core utilities, but there is also a lot of otherwise-licensed software involved in a standard configuration of FreeBSD. For instance, it comes with GCC by default, which is distributed under the terms of the GPL, thus raising the "evil quotient" of FreeBSD. All told, I'd probably place FreeBSD at somewhere around 2.0 or 2.5 (give me time to figure this one out in more detail). OpenBSD is more rigorous about the "freeness" of its included software, which is better than FreeBSD in this regard, but considers the GPL to be acceptably free, and the format of the installer is under enforced copyright -- thus undoing any good to the more rigorous "freeness", making it probably no better or worse than FreeBSD on its evil quotient.

Now that I've gotten through all that nonsense of "evil quotients" and an "evil scale", which is silly but fun and vaguely useful in getting across how I feel about various licenses:

It's not just the IT industry that provides such a minefield of ethicality for me. I think more, and more deeply, about ethical issues than almost much anyone I've ever met. As a result, I have a very finely honed sense of ethicality within my own understanding of ethics -- which leads to the kinds of issues I have with licensing in the software industry being ubiquitous, distributed through all facets of life. Books, movies, and music all have a connection with copyright law, for instance. Military service and law enforcement provide ample conflict of principles because of the problems of unrighteous wars and unethical laws, respectively. Even formalized higher education (universities and the like) rubs several ethical concerns entirely the wrong way. I struggle with the problem of paying my taxes -- in many ways, I find paying taxes to be a concession to unethicality, but must in practice do so to survive as a part of society.

I cannot escape the issues I have with IT work without doing grunt work instead. I cannot avoid the issues of grunt work (for instance, retail sales involves taxation, while service industry stuff -- like basically all professional career paths -- does not) without doing something with many of the same issues as the IT industry. Ultimately, I try to do the least harm I can reasonably get away with doing while trying to contribute to reforming things as much as reasonably possible.

by aaron a baker

I just got this from some idiot named "deich".
Here is a copy of his "Note"
One of your fellow TechRepublic members has sent you a private message:

From: deich
Subject: micro screw nux convo
Message:
i just cant believe the three of you rick arron and hal 9000 could be so
childish in you comments to each other it is a disgrace to the it community

i have seen better conduct in hardware forums and pirate coves than i witnessed
here.

*******************************************

In Answer I would ask, this:
Have you actually read the posts?
Do you even know of what you speak?.
There are over 700 + posts in this thread and nowhere do I see Your name or have ever seen any participatiion on your part.
By what right of Divinity then, do you dare presume to pass judgement on Us???
I suggest you get with the program kid, actually read the posts,[ALL OF THEM] and then perhaps you might be in a better position to reach a conclusion regarding our personal characters.
Until then don't bother me again, I will not acknowledge you childish remarks.
As for your slurs, rest assured they are most unwelcome and will be disregarded.
The people of which you speak are fine people and the fact that there may be disagreements is precisely what makes TR and it's People what is.
The Bests in the Business
PS.
If you use the SHIFT while typing a letter, you'll note it come's up as a cap.I would also suggest the use of a spellchecker.
First learn how to read,write and then READ the entire post 'THEN and ONLY THEN" might you have a valid opinion.
Of which I will still have no interest.
Aaron

by hal 9000

I just replied to the person that if they would like to bother to inform me what it was they where actually talking about I would have a look see but I had absolutely no idea of what they where on about nor did I care.

They are perfectly entitled to be indignant if they so chose to be but it honestly doesn't affect me or any of the others mentioned one little bit.

Obviously we are all supposed to be [b]Mindless Zombies[/b] agreeing with each other no matter what, well unfortunately my attitude is [b]Tough deal with it and get a Life.[/b] :D

by techexec2

.
It has just come to my attention that normal use of USB devices can trigger Vista WGA de-activation as reported by this TR peer (1).

This new information reaffirms my decision to never upgrade to Vista, and to eventually leave Windows entirely. This proves just how effin' stupid those people in Redmond are. But, I am not surprised by this development at all.

-------------------------------------------

(1) Vista...A mess
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=218687&messageID=2215641

by jackie40d1

I love Windows for their WGA's and problems with it . . And when People get to buy windows a few times they will begin to look around for a different O/S and just maybe they might like some flavor of Linux like what from free to maybe $60.00 they have BUT the People of the different FLAVORS of LINUX have to step up to the plate and get the news out there I keep banging on people heads . . I have already proved to people they can run their favorite MS stuff on LINUX using Code Weavers Pro . . I just have some stuff which is not made by MS and will not yet run in Linux as soon as I get it to work there ( driver problems ) I am gone from windows ( I will put the windows Hard drive up on a shelf and leave it there ) Just incase I got to help a windows person whom comes in with their windows box and need some help with it ( oh yeah I have Win 2K on it ) So XP and Vista are out of luck go else where do not want the head aches . .

by tig2

BSD is BSD. Linux is Linux. Similar in many respects. Not same.

If I understand it all completely- and I may not- the major differentiation is in the EULA- specifically what one may do with the source and what restrictions pertain. Linux is bound to the GNU while BSD is not.

Another differentiating point is origination of the base. BSD is about my age. Linux is not.

Regardless, while I don't think that MS will successfully kill Linux- although I think they will try- I don't think there is a darned thing they can do to BSD.

Irrespective of the next play, if MS thinks that they can take Linux to court they may be mistaken. I do believe that they have maximally pissed off a sufficient user base to cause concern.

Just my opinion.

by apotheon

The first BSD Unix was distributed in '77, I think.

386BSD was released in 1992 -- an x86 platform BSD Unix created and released under the BSD license. It didn't last long, but it spawned FreeBSD and NetBSD. NetBSD later spawned OpenBSD, then NetBSD started withering.

Now, three derivatives of FreeBSD seem to be gaining real traction -- Dragonfly BSD, PC-BSD, and DesktopBSD. Dragonfly BSD was actually forked from FreeBSD because some believed that the way threading was being handled in the FreeBSD kernel would not perform well. The Dragonfly BSD codebase has continued to diverge from there somewhat, though Dragonfly BSD and FreeBSD share code back and forth liberally. PC-BSD and DesktopBSD are not forks, however: they're just repackaged versions of FreeBSD, designed with end-user accessibility with a friendly KDE GUI as their major goal.

All of these *BSDs use the BSD license. You're right about them differing from Linux in licensing -- the Linux kernel, as well as the main toolset for most Linux distributions, is licensed under the terms of the GPL. That, in fact, is one of the reasons I started looking into FreeBSD in the first place.

If Microsoft tries to sue the *BSDs or Linux and actually wins, I suspect they'll just go "underground". I don't think Microsoft wants to take the chance it'd lose such a lawsuit, however. It's more likely to go after major corporate users, and maybe individual users as well, following in the footsteps of the RIAA. That'd be a much more lucrative, and much less dangerous, approach. You're not going to get the whole Linux community, for instance, rallying around Joe Random if he gets sued and contributing millions of dollars to his defense fund, so chances are good Microsoft could really jam him up pretty badly. Microsoft would just need to figure out a way to justify a lawsuit for an individual user that amounts to more than a hill of beans -- unlike the RIAA lawsuits, there's no "for each song you owe this much money" sort of half-baked arithmetic to add up to hundreds of thousands of dollars. There's just one operating system, which may or may not infringe a bunch of patents.

Actually, now that I think about it, instead of end-users Microsoft would probably target small businesses. It would be dead easy to sink a little half-dozen employee business based on the use of a few Linux machines. The EFF might have something to say about that, though, and then Microsoft would have a fight on its hands that it might not win.

We really just need to get rid of software patents. Seriously.

by apotheon

PC-BSD does use KDE as its default desktop. A lot of the same software will run on both *BSD and Linux, so that's no surprise. The BSD family of Unix and the Linux family of unixlike OSes are two separate families that sprang from different sources -- *BSD actually evolved from the original AT&T Unix, and the Linux kernel was created years later by a Finnish college student, basically for fun. Both of them were made available on x86 architecture systems at about the same time, in the early '90s.

by apotheon

By the way, since PC-BSD is basically just FreeBSD with a pretty face (and FreeBSD is currently my favorite OS), I may have to give it a try soon. The things I've heard about PC-BSD make me think it might basically be the Ubuntu of the BSD world, but without the negatives attached to Ubuntu. Whereas Ubuntu is an actual fork of my favorite Linux distribution (Debian), with less stability, fewer packages in the archives, and a hosed-up security model, PC-BSD is still FreeBSD (my favorite *BSD), just packaged up differently.

Keep telling people about PC-BSD. I've noticed you like it -- and I'd like to see it get more attention, particularly as an alternative to Ubuntu.

by helpdesk dave

Anyone worth their IT salt never ever goes with bleeding edge technology, be it hardware or software, I will wait a year since Vista's initial release and install it and not have any substantial problems with it. Letting all the air heads out there get hit with the bugs that MS will eventually fix. If there wasn't such a loss of morals in this world, stealing and reselling everything that they can get their hands on there would be no need for anti-priacy laws. Hate to be such a hard a_s about this but seriusly folks, this is common practice, you jump into the water before it's tested, your gonna get bitten.

by techexec2

.
This is not about bugs. Of course it is wise to wait for SP1 or SP2. That goes without saying. But, even after all of the bugs and problems are fixed, Vista's WGA will *still* capriciously de-activate based on software events, by design. Erroneous de-activation has happened to millions of legitimate customers with XP, and it will be much worse with Vista.

Read the thread to find out more about this.

by jackie40d1

when they get the XP fully fixed and SP 4 is out then I might up grade to XP and "Vista" is not even on my radar to put on anything . . There are a lot of LINUX versions I like and Take maybe 40 minutes to install completely ( Linux 2007 6 CD's ) and its done .. . Not like Win 2 K Pro which takes over an hour to install and its only 1 CD plus the other fixes to install got to be 14 of them ( beyond SP 4 ) Plus adding anti virus and firewall and your up to almost 2 hours . .
plus there is real and quicktime and windows media . . and the memory watcher and the other items they want like Intervideo and Nero 7 and so on ( so your up to 3 hours now )

by ksnow-1

I had a problem with am MSI motherboard that took me 3 Mounts to find.In the device Manger
there were no Caution Signs showing and after Reloading XP 6 or 7 times and having to call MS every time for there 50 diget # and having to talk to ther rep. one Day I spent some time in the Device Manger & Opened every singel page. Then in the Mother board Support last page I found 5 Confilcks
with the sound board, video board even the HDD. After E mailing MSI and them telling me to take the Mobo out of the case and only conect the HDD Video Card and DVD if was still a problem to send it in to them. On a $75.00 board thats 2 yeas old I don't think so.That was the 3th Board 2 pryers went in under Warrenty. So I took the first SOYO board that I originly Bought and though I had alot of problems with (Sent 2 XP Home version back Because Hole programs would come up missing then got XP Pro)Worked Jest Fine With XP Pro SP2 But didn't work with SP1. It's been working good for 6 mounths now. But if I would of had a OEM version istead of a box version I would of had to buy eather a New Computer or another XP OS Which Sucks because of bad hardware. For me my next Computer I will be looking forwerd to checking out Festa Fone. XP has been the Worst OS I have ever owned compaired to 98SE & 2000 so VISTA is out of the Question for me

by jackie40d1

After 6 or 7 times I think I would have gone back to Win 2K Pro and sent the stuff back to MS for refund ! ! Or gone to Linux 2007 and installed it then added Code Weavers Pro and then you can run the windows stuff with out the problems of Windows . . At Linux speeds
Linux 2007 is like $15.00 delivered to your door and Code Weavers Pro is like $60.00 delivered to your door . . So for under what the XP cost you got everything !

by fredonesaid

these guys like rickk and teckmail live under microsucks dresses, how can anybody in thier right mind defend outfits like that, what a dreary life they must lead, nothing they say makes absolutly any sense, Mr. Baker, don't waste yout time.

by media-ted9

... in the Sea-Tac area. That's the only reason I can come up with to explain your "American" diatribe.

You may be enjoying the neo-dark-ages of the decline and fall of the almighty "dollar", but you must really work at ignoring the facts and history of "American Big Business".

Let's look at something called, "The Big Three", shall we? Or am I the only one old enough to remember that? Chevy (GM) Ford (FoMoCo) and Plymouth, Dogde, Desoto (Chrysler) of old pretty much ran the world around on wheels - or at least they thought so. Finally they became so big and powerful that they owned/controlled government(s).

Their arrogance grew with their profits and their power. Then people found that their products were not as well made as the "cheaper imports", their products exploded in light impact situations, ... and they ignored, and denied any wrong doing. They spent ever-increasing funds and energy on producing advertising (lying) and figured that quality in photos and copy and TV would surely make up for the shoddy products they insisted on continuing to produce.

Now - a few decades later - most cars on the roads - IN AMERICA - are imports; in fact, even the Fords, Chevy's, and Chryslers are running with imported engines and power trains. Junk Bonds is what best describes the "Big Three".

To justify belligerance and monopolistic hammering of the customer by linking it to some mythological "American Business Ideal" is just simple foolishness. I was born and raised in the Mid-West (Iowa), and I know better! The fact that I'm pushing 60 may account for my better memory of actual history over the rewritten versions casually forced upon us daily, but M$ is not learning from history, but like the greedy fools they have always been, are compelled to repeat it in devoted ignorance.

It is to our collective shame that the focus in "modern society and technology" is on the fear / growing concern that M$ could shut us down, rather than where the focus should always be: we buy a computer to use as a tool to do stuff and produce things; but we have degenerated to the point of blindly accepting that we should not expect M$ to actually work well, but dazzle us with pretty goodies until they are shut down because the arrogant rich don't think they have made enough off the fools who buy their crap - by choice, design, or force.

C/PM worked, but it was killed. M$ lives on, ... like a bloated cancer. Perhaps we should stop watching all the TV ads that hype the beauty of the cancerous lumps forming on the body politic and refocus on production and quality before those things are completely forgotten.

Sorry for the rant, but I'm tired of crap and force being justified as though it's American and that makes it Sacred.

by apotheon

Thanks for a thoughtful and well-reasoned bit of commentary. It's nice to see people pipe up now and then with such a practical understanding of the way things work.

by jackie40d1

Yeah I guess your right . . I am one of the people whom did not drink the MS water . . I have been leaning toward Linux of some version to get away from ever having to download updates EVERY TUESDAY . . I have Win 2000 Pro and will not add XP till SP 4 comes out and if I get the Linux going with all I want I will never touch MS again . .

by magpie_z

There is no discussion with delusional people who through committee become the arbiters of what is right and wrong, good or bad, or through their own prism and colored glasses decide that only their experiences have validity.

That is why I no longer respond to their closed mindedness. It doesn't matter to them if another viewpoint has validity and they make sure that they get their childish insults and demeaning statements in trying to insult anyone who does not stroke their egos.

Time to let them have this group and their excrement masticating ways to themselves. See you around.

by magpie_z

that a person cannot cut & paste repetive posts for replies. Either that or his system is stuck on stupid.

by ole man

The tide is turning and the times they are
a-changing. So get used to it and suck it
up.

Seems you wouldn't mind "thugs" so much
seeing as how you just looooove Microsoft.
(oh, that's right....you don't care)

No abusive corporation that antagonizes
their customers (or "end users" as Microsoft
calls them) can last forever.

by absolutely

There will be a move away from Microsoft, which will have to be accomplished in a number of ways, including adoption of different OSes for personal computers. In different environments, dumb terminals will be possible. I'm not sure a lot of the market for Microsoft products will be able to move into the Macintosh price range any time soon, but if such a move begins in businesses, Apple might work its way into homes the same way Microsoft did. Otherwise, I imagine Open Source operating systems making up a lot of the discrepancy in new computer sales.

Either way, I agree that the next 24 months will be substantially different than the previous 24 months for IT pros.

by absolutely

[i]You're not considering the metric very well. Yes, .2% failure rate isn't all that bad -- if you're talking about .2% failure total, for everything. If it's just .2% failure rate of a single piece of software that can bring down an entire system, not even counting the failure rates attributable to other causes, that can add up.

Plus, y'know, that's a .2% failure rate for unacceptable reasons. It's failing .2% more often simply because of something that is in no way, at all, necessary to your effective use of the software -- except that Microsoft decided [u]you needed it[/u]. Screw that.[/i]

Microsoft decided they needed it, because they haven't been able to secure their software from piracy without methods that are invasive to legitimate, paying customers. Enthusiastic agreement to all the rest of your post, especially the last 2 words of it.

by absolutely

Google is widely regarded as having the best algorithm for sorting Internet search strings, making it authoritative.

If it were "authoritarian" they might be able to tell China what to do, instead of the converse. Did you use MS Word? Cancel that, I'm going to check myself, but I bet it can't identify such a syntax error, as it is grammatically correct but nonsensical.

by absolutely

This will be presented in the style of a middle-school algebra story problem, so HAL9000 is assigned to assist rickk as needed. I apologize, but you are allowed to write a computer program to solve the problem, and if you deliver that before rickk admits he is stumped, that will be acceptable.

Let the variable 'x' be equal to the total number of licenses of Microsoft Windows Vista purchased. (Assume that the WGA program as implemented in Microsoft Windows Vista has [u]completely solved[/u] the problem of piracy, so the total number of users is exactly equal to the number of licenses sold.)

Let the variable 'y' be equal to the total number of problems reported by users of Microsoft Windows Vista.

Find the number of Windows Vista Users who have not had a problem. (yet)

(Hint: subtract)

by kevron

Everyone just now realizing they should never have upgraded to Vista are TOO late in figuring that out. Even if Vista was going to be a good OS, I realized before it was released that it would be a good year or two before I would want to upgrade. After all, now that it's out and I can read all the feedback, I'm not sure I'll ever upgrade. I'm more than willing to stay with XP, *nix, and Mac. Another thing that frustrates me as a tech support guy, is the fact that all these end users are buying new computer with vista or upgrading. That's okay though. As I've never used Vista, I now keep that Microsoft Technical Support number and all the Manufacturer's numbers that have anything to do with Vista right by my side. As soon as I hear they're using Vista, I just pop up the list and refer them. I didn't do this at first as it's my common practice to do everything I can to troubleshoot the problem. However, since Vista makes absolutely no sense, I love whipping out the list and getting rid of the sucker that has Vista.

by apotheon

I get the impression Microsoft can't really differentiate effectively between itself and its customer base on such issues. Thus, "you" and "it" are synonymous from Microsoft's point of view.

That's my working theory, anyhow.

by jackie40d1

It will be faster than that And the Versions of Linux are very fast making a dent in the Windows area's Since Dell is now going to begin adding Linux to its computers ( Which means it will BE CHEAPER to buy ) would cut the price of a Dell by what $70.00 or more and give them an advantage over others offering only Windows

by w2ktechman

many times before. Big businesses are not going to dump MS so quickly. Also, people fear change in things that they do not understand.
I recommend for most to stick with XP for now. Although many know I dislike Vista very much.
I keep a couple of Linux boxes running to show people, and sometimes someone will play with one for a bit. I will even show them some things on it as well. So far 2 people have wanted to learn more, while many others just want what they already know. I doubt that this will topple MS, or that it will be a huge failure. But, every day, as their WGA and other issues rise, more and more people will get pissed off enough to move on.

It will not be until the business community moves from MS, that MS will be toppled. But, this is the Best time for Linux. It is re-building itself for the home user and computer illiterate. Because of this, and the MS issues, I do think that Linux has a good chance to be in competition with MS. This may take a few years for the numbers to truly rise to this point, but it is a very interesting time for Linux.

by jackie40d1

From all the People whom I know who are not going to move to Vista . . And are looking VERY HARD at Linux I have a gob of CD's with ISO's on them and run them up as a test of the Version of Linux to see what it can do and whats in it . . I like 3 of them now as they are cheap and very food as to what they have to offer ( I got a new one Ubuntu 7.4 [Fawn ] I think it was and I got to tun a test of it ) See whats all on the CD was just under 700 megs of compressed stuff took about 1 hour to download

by techexec2

.
The "advantages" of the Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) are growing...

[b]Windows WGA Malware is here![/b] (1)

This insidious malware is a trojan that phishes for credit card numbers. Here's how it works:

[i]"...Revalidation is an increasingly familiar process for many end users and, for some, warnings of counterfeit software should the software fail validation. The counterfeit popup appears when the computer reboots or wakes from sleep. The Trojan plays off both behaviors and even Windows Vista's mechanism of essentially shutting down when product activation fails.

The Trojan launches a Windows Piracy Control Screen (2) on bootup following infection.

"You can choose only 'Yes' or 'No,'" Takashi Katsuki wrote on the Symantec security Weblog. "You can't run Task Manager or any other applications. If you choose 'No' your PC will be shut down immediately."

If the end user chooses "Yes," an "Activation of Windows" box opens (3), requesting personal information, including credit card number..."[/i] (1)

I especially love the part where it says "Important: your card will NOT be charged" (2). Outstanding! :^0

Anyone with half a brain could have anticipated this move by the criminals. They have lots of university degrees in Redmond, but no friggin' common sense. Now your computer is being attacked by "Genuine Windows", and also by Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) malware.

[b]Thank you, Microsoft![/b]

Beginning back in 1992, I relied on Microsoft, Windows, and MS Office (then separate programs) to power my computer. I was thankful to Microsoft for empowering me to be able to compute independently, and do it better, without a mainframe or minicomputer. It was a new level of independence and empowerment that was not possible in the 1970s, and only began to emerge in the 1980s.

Now, I really have to thank Microsoft again. Their very serious stunningly stupid mistake with WGA has forced me to make the effort to permanently migrate to Linux and Mac OS X, and to OpenOffice and other FOSS. This has empowered me even more. Not only am I every bit as productive and safer from malware, I'm also saving large sums of money.

--------------------------------------

(1) Windows Activation Trojan
http://www.microsoft-watch.com/content/security/windows_activation_trojan.html

(2) Microsoft piracy control window
http://www.symantec.com/enterprise/security_response/weblog/upload/2007/05/Kardphisher11.html

(3) Windows activation window
http://www.symantec.com/enterprise/security_response/weblog/upload/2007/05/Kardphisher2.html

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Am copying and sending to a number of folks I know who think I am nuts in my objections to the latest and greatest Windows.

by techexec2

.
You're welcome boxfiddler...

I expect there to be destructive WGA malware also, not just thievery like this one. The destructive malware will infect your Vista system, trigger de-activation, and advance the clock 31 days, producing INSTANT "reduced functionality mode" where you cannot use your computer at all (for your OWN work that is). Won't THAT be a great day to have something important to do.

I think an ice cube has a much better chance of surviving in hell than Microsoft does on getting complete control over this.

I can hear the howls of protest now...

by jackie40d1

That Windows WGA would come back and bite them in their Bottoms is beyond counting . .
Was glad to see those links about windows problems ! I am saving them just for the next person whom has this great love for WINDOWS . .
Think I will print out the pages also

by absolutely

In the spirit of Microsoft, just capitalize on the opportunity when you see it, and THANK NOBODY!

[i]Now, I really have to thank Microsoft again. Their very serious stunningly stupid mistake with WGA has forced me to make the effort to permanently migrate to Linux and Mac OS X, and to OpenOffice and other FOSS. This has empowered me even more. Not only am I every bit as productive and safer from malware, I'm also saving large sums of money.[/i]

Give a couple rupies to some Indians, if you feel like it, but thank nobody.

by techexec2

.
Canonical, the company behind the Kubuntu (and Ubuntu) Linux distributions, recently released Kubuntu version 7.04 . Kubuntu is "end user Linux". It's not an "erector set" for computer geeks. Windows users who are interested in freeing themselves from Microsoft tyranny should download the Kubuntu 7.04 CD and try it (1).

Highlights:

** Most polished version of Linux I have ever seen. Windows users will like and be immediately comfortable with the K Desktop Environment (KDE) in Kubuntu.

** Boots "live" from the CD in just a few minutes (no changes to your hard drive). You can even fully use it this way. Spend the day with it. Save files to a USB thumb drive.

** Automatically detects all of your hardware, even wireless networking.

** Includes the latest OpenOffice suite.

** Installs from the same CD to your hard drive in just [u]15 minutes[/u]! Best OS installation I have ever seen. Better than every Windows install I have ever done, including Vista.

** Best "Add/Remove Programs" I have ever seen, bar none, even better than Windows. Installs additional software online [u]in seconds just by selecting it with the mouse[/u]. No dependency problems. No CDs. No CD keys. No activation. No de-activation.

** Price: $0.

[b]A good Kubuntu 7.04 article[/b]

Here (2) is a good article about Kubuntu 7.04 "Feisty Fawn".

--------------------------------

(1) Kubuntu -- The best Linux I have seen for Windows switchers
http://www.kubuntu.com

(2) Seven steps to Feisty Fawn bliss
http://desktoplinux.com/articles/AT3648616185.html

by w2ktechman

but I have yet to try to install it. Maybe sometime this week, as I have been very busy recently. Last week I had inquired about Feisty Fawn, and received some good feedback in peer mail mainly. It sounds like a lot of people are looking at this OS happily so far.

by jackie40d1

You must have been downloading it same time as I could only get 153 k download speed took almost 1 hour but I got a lot done during that time . . I got to add it to the 100 gig drive ( my 3rd drive for checking out O/S's ) and run it up as to what it can do and whats in it . .
I change whats plugged in and have to go back thru the CMOS as to what boots where ( my CMOS has got to be so confused being changed so often )

by so.cal guy

Well i really don't think Microsoft cares if a few people jump ship

By Reuters
4:14 PM EDT Thu. Apr. 26, 2007
SEATTLE - Microsoft Corp. posted a 65 percent rise in quarterly profit Thursday, topping Wall Street estimates due to better-than-expected demand for its new Windows Vista operating system.

Shares of Microsoft rose 5 percent after the announcement, in which the world's biggest software company also forecast 2008 profit at the mid-point of a range of analyst estimates.

"The strength of Vista is really driving this," said Kim Caughey, analyst at Fort Pitt Capital Group. She added that the company had set "manageable expectations for the full year 2008, which generally allows them some headroom."

Whine cry stomp your feet say Microsoft is dieing they are dead we hear this every time a new OS rolls out the door.

and sure a few leave and start using something else but not near enough to put a dent in Microsoft's profit margin.

and for everyone that leaves 10 takes there place so like i said i don't really think Microsoft really cares if a few jumps ship

by techexec2

.
The jury is still out on whether Microsoft is going to feel any pain or not.

[b][i]"...Microsoft Corp. posted a 65 percent rise in quarterly profit Thursday, topping Wall Street estimates due to better-than-expected demand for its new Windows Vista operating system..."[/i][/b]

Can you say "channel stuffing". And "better than expected" doesn't mean a darn thing. What about low expectations?

Frankly, I don't believe those numbers are caused by Vista's sales strength. I could be wrong of course. But, since I'm an analyst, it [u]must[/u] be true. Furthermore, a rise in sales should be expected. Throughout 2006 Vista was expected to be delivered for the Christmas PC sales season. This caused many PC buyers to wait. Then it was delayed until January and people waited some more. So, there darn well [u]should[/u] be a spike in demand in calendar Q1. Doesn't prove anything. As the word is getting around about all of the problems with Vista, what will the affect on sales be in calendar Q2 through Q4?

[b][i]"...Whine cry stomp your feet say Microsoft is dieing they are dead we hear this every time a new OS rolls out the door..."[/i][/b]

I never said Microsoft is dying or dead. But, it could be said that Microsoft is "dead" to me.

[b][i]"..."The strength of Vista is really driving this," said Kim Caughey, analyst at Fort Pitt Capital Group..."[/i][/b]

I don't think Vista is anywhere near as strong as this analyst says. The rejection of Vista is unprecedented. PC OEMs are going back to offering XP. I checked yesterday and couldn't even find Vista upgrades for sale on ZipZoomFly.com. In fact, when you click on "Operating Systems" on their home page, you get a page that lists only XP (1). I got a chuckle out of that!

And, now Dell is offering Linux in an unprecedented way. There is something going on that we cannot put numbers to yet. Personally, I never DREAMED I would ever stop running Windows, yet that is exactly what I'm doing.

-------------------------------

(1) The "Operating Systems" page on ZipZoomFly - sells only Windows XP
http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ThirdCategoryList.jsp?SecondCategoryCode=1202

by absolutely

follows strength or weakness in quality of technology by a considerable period, as in the duration of the dot.com bubble before the dot.com bust.

[b][i]"..."The strength of Vista is really driving this," said Kim Caughey, analyst at Fort Pitt Capital Group..."[/b][/i]

Depends which strength you mean. Still strong selling points to a lot of consumers? Sure. Strong technological basis? Maybe, maybe not.

by so.cal guy

since I'm am posting how much there stock went up and since they can not lie about what there earnings are because i don't think balmer wants to go to jail for lying to share holders. about earnings and quarterly profits.

and looking at the pass trends and all the FUD mostly spread by people who have never even used the new OS

i stand by what i said in my last post and when the next Microsoft OS is released it will be the same thing all over again

this is the death is Microsoft it's dieing the open soruce guys will be spreading there FUD some will be jumping ship most will be staying Microsoft will work out the bugs out of the new OS the FUD will die down till the next time.

it does not take an analyst to see that all you have to do is look at the passed

by magpie_z

go to the left column and click on windows heading to reach full pages of what is for sale. You will find Vista OEM and Retail there.

by absolutely

[i]and looking at the pass trends and all the FUD mostly spread by people who have never even used the new OS [/i]

I have not used Vista.

I don't plan to do so any sooner than my employer makes necessary. Blech!

by jackie40d1

May 6, 2007 10:10 AM
Windows Activation Trojan

Joe Wilcox
Joe Wilcox

Windows Genuine Advantage is the target of a new Trojan, which pretends to be Microsoft's activation mechanism.

Symantec issued a bulletin in late April on the Kardphisher Trojan, which has a threat rating of "very low." But the Trojan picked up new attention over the weekend, following a Friday post on Symantec's security Weblog.

The Trojan takes advantage of one controversial feature of Microsoft's Windows Genuine Advantage anti-piracy mechanism: revalidation. To receive most downloads, including Internet Explorer or anything from the Windows Update Web site, end users must validate that their computers are, in Microsoft parlance, "genuine." But one validation isn't enough. Microsoft has Windows clients periodically revalidate. The process is designed to catch new pirated versions as Microsoft continually updates its piracy database.

Revalidation is an increasingly familiar process for many end users and, for some, warnings of counterfeit software should the software fail validation. The counterfeit popup appears when the computer reboots or wakes from sleep. The Trojan plays off both behaviors and even Windows Vista's mechanism of essentially shutting down when product activation fails.

The Trojan launches a Windows Piracy Control Screen on bootup following infection.

"You can choose only 'Yes' or 'No,'" Takashi Katsuki wrote on the Symantec security Weblog. "You can't run Task Manager or any other applications. If you choose 'No' your PC will be shut down immediately."

If the end user chooses "Yes," an "Activation of Windows" box opens, requesting personal information, including credit card number.

Katsuki explains:

"Now you may think 'It can't be true. I have activated my legitimate copy of Windows. MS can't do such a thing!.' Surely almost everyone will notice that something strange is going on, and hopefully very few people will actually become victims by inputting their credit card details. But unfortunately even the people who are not tempted to give up their information this time might well become victims the next time. After all, failure to follow the on-screen instructions results in your PC shutting down immediately."

Microsoft has started selling Windows Vista upgrades online, which is a scenario where the company would ask for a credit card. Like a slick grifter, Trojans seek to create confusion and in doing so lead people to act stupidly. Microsoft would ask for its money upfront. Still, there is plenty of trial software out there for which people would pay after a set time period. So, for some end users there is ingrained behavior about paying for something after a period of usage.

Katsuki warned: "This Trojan teaches us all a good lesson?trust no one."

That's sad advice.

Windows WGA Malware is here! (1)

This insidious malware is a trojan that phishes for credit card numbers. Here's how it works:

"...Revalidation is an increasingly familiar process for many end users and, for some, warnings of counterfeit software should the software fail validation. The counterfeit popup appears when the computer reboots or wakes from sleep. The Trojan plays off both behaviors and even Windows Vista's mechanism of essentially shutting down when product activation fails.

The Trojan launches a Windows Piracy Control Screen (2) on bootup following infection.

"You can choose only 'Yes' or 'No,'" Takashi Katsuki wrote on the Symantec security Weblog. "You can't run Task Manager or any other applications. If you choose 'No' your PC will be shut down immediately."

If the end user chooses "Yes," an "Activation of Windows" box opens (3), requesting personal information, including credit card number..." (1)

I especially love the part where it says "Important: your card will NOT be charged" (2). Outstanding!

Anyone with half a brain could have anticipated this move by the criminals. They have lots of university degrees in Redmond, but no friggin' common sense. Now your computer is being attacked by "Genuine Windows", and also by Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) malware.

(1) Windows Activation Trojan
http://www.microsoft-watch.com/content/security/windows_activation_trojan.html

(2) Microsoft piracy control window
http://www.symantec.com/enterprise/security_response/weblog/upload/2007/05/Kardphisher11.html

(3) Windows activation window
http://www.symantec.com/enterprise/security_response/weblog/upload/2007/05/Kardphisher2.html
Posted: 05/07/2007 @ 06:37 AM (PDT) (edited 05/07/2007 @ 09:49 AM (PDT))

by jackie40d1

The bad guys are getting smarter ! They invented a Malware Trogen just for Windows ..
Something will trigger the windows activation form and if you do not fill in the spots you do not get to run your computer . . BUT all the info you filled in goes to the Hackers ta dah !
You just gave them all your ID and card info and address . . just guess whom had their ID stolen . . And thanks to MS it will expand to other stuff hehehehe Welcome to LINUX all you windows users . . Add Code weavers Pro to it and your off and running all the Windows main line stuff and with cedgea or something like that you can run tons of windows games . . for a LOT less in cost ! !

by hal 9000

As one American writer said many years ago.

Yes you have quoted a raise in the M$ Stock price but not compared it to what it was a year ago or even 5 years ago and how much has been wiped off M$ by a drop in share values?

Anything is correct to say that there was a raise of such and such after a day but you need to look at the long term trends to see what is happening with the Markets Belief in any company. If M$ shares have increased dramatically in a 1 day trading period how much have they increased to and what is that in comparison to their all time High? After all M$ doesn't have any real competition so why has their share price been constantly dropping over the past few years?

Don't quote me one days trading and expect any massive explanations of how great that is look at the long term issues surrounding the company and what is happening in the Share Market to that company and then you just may begin to understand why there was such a dramatic lift in 1 days trading and then the profit takers moved in and the share price went where?

Col

by so.cal guy

Hal this is not one days trading you open source guys are free to dream that one day the world of software will turn into the socialist utopia where there is no Microsoft

where you have the right to just download any company's work and change it at will but i have a fact check for you thats not going to happen.

all you have to do is look at the Microsoft's stocks trends and as a company with $49 billion in the bank. to say vista is going to kill it is just well wishful thinking

believe what you wish but i am not talking about a one day quote it's a posted a 65 percent rise in quarterly profit thats hardly a days quote.

by apotheon

Personally, I'm holding out for a free market economy with no monopolistic Microsoft squeezing out the competition. That'd be more like the perfect "utopia" for me.

by apotheon

I was actually very mildly impressed with a couple changes to the UI with the introduction of Aero Glass.

I say "impressed" because, compared to earlier Microsoft UI updates in about the last decade, Aero Glass is a much greater advance in the kind of productivity enhancement it provides. I say "mildly" because those advancements pretty much consist of nothing more than very limited versions of similar functionality that has been available with Unixlike systems for a decade or two.

I was much, much more impressed with how slow the UI on a brand new laptop with a Core 2 Duo processor and two gigabytes of RAM can be at times. Four and a half seconds just to open a control panel dialog on that system is staggering.

by ghostbrowser

And you agreed to their licence
Here is some of the things checked by activation

Display Adapter
SCSI Adapter
IDE Adapter
Network Adapter MAC Address
RAM Amount Range (i.e. 0-64mb, 64-128mb, etc)
Processor Type
Processor Serial Number
Hard Drive Device
Hard Drive Volume Serial Number
CD?ROM / CD-RW / DVD-ROM

by ghostbrowser

If I remember right I think its 5 years support + 5 years extended support
Extended support means no new support
They just allow you to get the existing updates

by techexec2

.
Of course! That's the point! I did not say they were not offering Vista at all. However, you will note that they are not listing the Vista upgrade versions at all (not even "backordered"). That can only mean that they are not moving well at all.

An online store is just like a retail store. They position goods that are moving in the "front", and goods that are not moving well in the "back". The "front" of an online store is certainly the home page -- no Vista there. Another "front" or "end of aisle" is the product category "home" pages like the "Operating Systems" page. Vista was not on that page either, but XP was. To find Vista, you had to go all the way to its "shelf" in the correct "aisle".

If Vista were really selling well, it would be featured better on that site like it was when it was released in January.

by jackie40d1

I was sitting here laughing when I read the opening of the next question to be . . As it just about was my thoughts also ! Bet it got
RICKK's attention !

by thegooch1

Sorry, the idea of Linux is good, but the execution is bad. Way too many features of M$ compatible software are not available in the Linux world. Trust me, I ran Linux exclusively for 4 years and finally gave up when things such as my Blackberry server would not run on it. Those were the most frustrating 4 years of my life.

by thegooch1

Fortunately, EULA's are nothing more than vendor wish lists. You see, contracts have to signed by both parties, and both parties must receive something from the deal. In addition, they have no way to verify that you agreed to anything. Clicking on the "ok" button is not a signature, neither is checking a "I agree" box.

by thegooch1

There were tons of frustrations with Linux, but when I replaced my Treo with a Blackberry Pearl, that was the straw that broke the camels back. Blackberry + Blackberry Exchange Server + MS Outlook = get rid of Linux.

-John

by w2ktechman

I have mostly moved to Linux already at home. I am keeping XP for now, but who knows how long. I havent booted the XP system in almost 2 1/2 weeks.

by techexec2

.
Clickwrap license agreements have been upheld so far in court cases.

[i]"...Few cases have considered the validity of clickwrap licenses. However, in the cases that have challenged their validity, the terms of the contract have ultimately been upheld..."[/i] (1)(2)

------------------------------

(1) Clickwrap
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clickwrap

(2) Decision defining requirements for a valid clickwrap license
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specht_v._Netscape_Communications_Corp.

by apotheon

It's like you've decided to replace the seat covers on your car, and because the seat covers were designed for different seats you replace the seats, and because the new seats don't attach properly to the car you replace the car.

. . . or maybe you bought new headlights without checking to make sure they'd fit the car you have. Now, you find yourself buying a Yugo to replace your Toyota.