Discussion Locked

Bowling for Columbine- Fear in IT p1

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I finally got around to seeing the movie "Bowling for Columbine" last weekend and have been thinking about it all day, but as soon as I hit TR today it has really really struck a chord with me. I just responded to someone who was talking about taking different parts of a program and reassembling them, adding some of their own etc. and never used the word "hack" once. To be honest, I have wondered on several occasions how much I wanted to discuss or say online about the internal workings of somebig name software companies.
There have been numerous occasions here (and other online haunts) where I have bit my tongue about certain issues that although I absolutely know aren't connected to US national security, I would rather not have connected to any handle that can be traced to me.

I like to be a pretty straightforward person and getting the job done, whatever I take on, is important to me, but it seems I and many others in IT live in a community of fear increasingly. Citizens afraid we read their mail because we can but chose not to, or even afraid we will expose their innermost secrets or thoughts to the entire world. People afraid that we will steal their cc numbers or mess with their identity some how. Businesses that are afraid we more than any other department can sabotage to the point of collapse. Now governments spread fear about us and say that we potentially can threaten a nations security.... it's almost worse in some ways, the associated fear, than that of guns or bombs.

47 replies

by admin

I don't have any answers, it just really saddens me because this field always held so much excitment about helping people and having a better future. It feels now at times a little like those scientists that pursued a magical energy source and unleashed nuclear weaponary and then lived with the fact that their knowledge now made them marked men of sorts.

Does anyone else see the fear that has crept everywhere into this industry?

by admin

on computer crime the past few years? We used to be lucky to hear a snippet about Mitnick. Now everday almost it"s "Electronic Crime!" "Hackers" "Terrorist Networks" "Hidden Terrorist Codes in Innocent Files" "Hard Disks Siezed" etc.etc.etc.etc. adnauseum

Someone could probably make a lot of money real soon with a computer crime reality show...

by tbragsda

Great movie, read his book "Stupid White Men".

As for your question. I know that I have
always been a professional. I never comprised my integrity by doing anything to damage or deceive. This is not to say that it never looks like I do, or that I never get into situations I don't like.

Recently I was asked to compile retrieve approx. 100 email from several internal clients. This is NOT a unusual request, but something I dislike. I normally do this by collecting them, printing them to a bogus queue, and connecting the queue to a live printer on the weekend to run. This time I was in a rush, and printed them during work hours. The printer is close, and secure, but another group was actually watching the queue (very unusual) and saw all I was printing. They informed the users thinking I was prying into their business.

Point is I don't feel that I have every done anything but help people and the COs I work for to succeed, but others may see something different.

by generalist

Personally I would like to see a computer reality show on how computers are used in daily life behind the scenes. Unfortunately it would take a lot of work to give it the violence and/or sex appeal necessary to catch the public's attention.

You have to admit that IT isn't a really flashy profession, despite the glitz of the dot bombs.

Perhaps we should get a group of people together to do 'high-profile' critiques of how IT and computers are portrayed in movies and news. I personally would love to see some of the less IT literate Hollywood types shown to be idiots when it comes to basic computer and information science. And if it can be done in an entertaining and educational way, so much the better.

Hmmmm. Movie critics can get away with dismissing a movie as being flawed because of plot, characterization and other aspects. Therefore we in IT should be able to do the same thing when focused on the IT side.

by maxwell edison

Michael Moore’s views (on everything) are so far removed from the realm of reality, and his presentation methods are so slanted and biased, that I wouldn’t give him or anything he says or writes a second thought. Actually, I wouldn’t even give it a first thought. I would simply dismiss it - and him - as a scare-mongering opportunist whose socialistic views are outdated, and whose attitude towards business and the American capitalistic system are, in my opinion, repressive and disingenuous. He lies, he misrepresents, he slanders, and he takes things out of context - all to promote his self-serving political agenda.

(Do you want to know what I really think about him?)

However, your discussion is about much more than just Moore. (pun intended)

As Benjamin Franklin once said, anyone who would "give up essential liberty for temporary security deserves neither liberty nor security."

I may post more opinion later.

by generalist

Perhaps we should do some research on this person's excesses and, with lots of hard data from a variety of sources, present a case on why the more you see Moore, the less you should believe him.

It would be even more interesting to come up with apsuedo-documentary on how some media types attempt to influence people via lies, misrepresentation, slander and taking things out of context.

by mrafrohead

Very much so Admin...

Very much so...

It is rather disturbing. For me. I think that my employers are afraid of me and what I can do because of the knowledge that I possess. For no reason though, as I do have ethics. Their fears are needless and a waste of emotion.

Whenever there's a system here that needs to be gotten into, I am the person that am called to do it. Because I can break into almost anything rather quick. If I don't know how to do it, I know where to go to research it and learn it. Not to mention I collect software so I have a vast assortment of free utilties at my fingertips. Linux. Got to love it!!!

But to the point. I think that my abilities here have inhibited me. It is beginning to dawn on me that the Company is afraid of giving me too much information for what I "could" do. The funny part though is that I don't need the information and could do it NOW.

But the fear they feel is very real. I don't think that people in positions of authority like the feeling of being vulnerable. Of knowing that there is someone out there that is better at their job than they are. I think that it hits a nerve with them and makes them very uncomfortable.

Have I learned anything from this?? You freakin betcha. I'm looking to move on to a smaller company that's not Corporate. And when I find it you can fr33kin bet I will NEVER tell them of my hobbies and what I can really do other than what the job calls for.

And no more hacking into company computers for my boss so they can take a little looksey. I think that's what sealed my fate...

Sad But True...

Mrafrohead

by maxwell edison

"Viewers attending a Moore film should be aware that the director has a history of 'faking' scenes."

"...not everything that appears on screen can be believed."

"...behind-the-scenes shenanigans..."

"...dubious...documentary tactics..."

"...his convoluted logic..."

"...grandstanding stunts..."

Source:

http://movie-reviews.colossus.net/movies/b/bowling_columbine.html

Bottom line: If you can't believe EVERYTHING he says, how can you believe ANYTHING he says?

by jkaras

I'm not exactly a fan of Moore, but he forces you to ponder what's going on and that's what is important. All of our movies are flash in the pan entertainment trying to impliment small moral messages to give them credibility. All news, papers, ect..are skewed to promote $$$ and not the truth. How many times have you seen 10 different body counts from various media reports on 1 incident. We all know there isnt complete truth due to the act of persuasion to keep audience attentative. It is your responsabilty to determine fact from fiction. All reporters sell out anybody and have the biggest boneyard in their closets. Because they only care about their own agenda or media puppet. I will however look at that link you posted, I'd like to see what he's guilty of. As for the "terrorism" buzz word I for 1 am sick of every shady individual being media blasted as a terrorist. It's getting rediculous to the point of absurdity. I do admit it troubles me that our government are holding so called terrorists without any rights guaranteed to us by our constitution, but not guilty execs. We are shifting to a cashless society with government becoming too controling. I will conciede that we need to protect the internet to keep predators away, but at what expense? We all know that George W. is a puppet and now our country is starting to resemble daddy Bush's new world order, curious huh?

by maxwell edison

"The only thing we have to fear is fear itself."

-Franklin Roosevelt 1932

This is just as true today as then, perhaps more so.

by oldefar

Roosevelt was a politician and a master spin doctor. Anyone who has been in a life threatening situation will attest that there are things besides fear to fear.

Roosevelt had a valid objective - to prevent panic that could lead to a breakdown ofsocial order. Worse was the threat of individuals exchanging temporary security for essential freedom as Franklin warned. That threat was demonstrated in the faciest states of the time, and is again a threat in our current time.

by admin

My questions to you, my peers, are:

Can we lessen the stigma and fear that surrounds IT professionals and if so, how?

What will we have to give up, if anything, to lessen fear?

Is it worth even trying to lessen the fear in the average citizen, or is it not worth the price? Why or why not?

I don't know if anyone will reply, but whoever does, no matter what your opinion, I thank you
-wholeheartedly.

by thechas

The root 'problem' for IT is that corporate America and the government have finally figured out that information = power!

That is why the CIO reports to the President or Corporate board and not some lower VP several steps down the ladder.

Another factor is that people fear what they do not understand. Power mongers than capitalize on that fear and use it to increase there power and control over the entire population.

My point is education is the key to reducing the fear.
Further, ALLeducation systems need to require that students at all levels take at least 1 semester of ethics.

In the US, that would mean:
Grade School
Junior High
High School
College
Post Grad

should all require 1 sememster of ethics.

Chas

by mrafrohead

Very true Chas. Ethics are very important.

Maybe those fear that us with this knowledge/power are afraid that we have no ethics...

by jkaras

Whenever you have any bit of power over someone they will feel that fear, it's just human nature coupled with our teachings of competition. However kids are rapidly becoming computer literate and savy due to the exposure of computers at an early agethat gives them a leg up on grownups who are now begining to become familiar with them. The example of the 5 year old that can program the vcr whereas the parent cant change the time leaving it on 12:00. As the next generation begins to eclipse us that fear will turn to understanding where it will feel like a more even playing field. The most remarkable point driven in from the movie "Bowling for Columbine" is that the media constantly barrages us with fear tactics to stay tuned rather than report the news. This tactic has brought out many phobias that plague our society. Fear sells and tv will capitolize on it evry chance they get. So if it isnt this fear it will be someother fear.

by generalist

I suspect that it will be a slow process with the biggest obstacle being the news and entertainment media. Over the past few decades they have done an excellent job of showing that technologists and scientists can be hazardous to your health.

Unfortunately, since 'bad news' sells both news programs and movies better than 'good news', people rarely see all the good that technologists and scientists do. And when the good side is presented, it tends to be in documentaries that aren't likely to seen by many.

But presenting the good side needs to be done.

by djent

History proves that some cynicism is healthy and justified. Its to easy to blame the media, they cater to a public thirst to live vicariously in crisis conditions, ie: 24/7 coverage of 911, Desert Storm, NASCAR races and hockey games adinfinitum. Education is a partial answer but will only come though evoloution given the volume of information and there are some that still believe the earth is flat and the Holocost was a PR hoax. There is a fine line between healthy cynicism and paranoia with no clear definition.

by admin

People working with computers develop medical equipment that saves thousands of people lives, even millions or more :)

Administrators develop an instantaneous cooperative project to go and repair\rebuild infrastructure after a disaster.

A massive voluntary cooperative computing project makes a major scientific advance or discovery.

Independant progammers join forces and create software that all people worldwide can afford :)

Because of advancements in computing, a world of leisure is created where everyone can devote a great deal of their life to the arts and sciences.

A new era of music is ushered in where almost anyone can create, record and publish their music on a very small budget and provide access to to it instantaneously at low or no cost to the entire world :)

Ok, I want to have time to play first person shooters too, but we already have enough of those movies! :>

by mrafrohead

Can we lessen the stima and fear that surrounds IT professionals and if so, how???

No we can not. Think of it like this. Most people are afraid of computers. I sure as shit know that I was when I was younger. The first time I looked into a case I thought I was going to break the machine. Most people still feel that and hesitate to even turn one on. With fear like that it will inhibit them from learning how they work and what they can do with them. All I have to say is this though, If I could learn it, anyone can!!!

What will we have to give up, if anything, to lessen fear?

Our networks and our jobs. Our authority. People feel powerless with these machines. Why that is I don't know. Ignorance maybe. The desire to not learn how they work maybe?? I'm not really sure. I do know though that most people don't want to take the time to learn how these simple machines work. They'd rather have US do it and then cower when we flex our abilities...

Is it worth even trying to lessen the fear in the average citizen, or is it not worth the price? Why or why not?

To do that I think that we would have to educate everyone on how computers work. Why they do what they do and how they do them. For that, I don't thinkit will happen. Think of the people that are afraid of what we can do. They are the people that are uneducated about it. They can't properly secure their machines. They don't know how to handle an attack no matter how small it is. It literally will drop them to their knees. Trying to teach someone that doesn't want to learn is equivalent to beating your head against a wall. It's their own shortcomings that are spawning the fears that they feel.

I hope that I am taking your questions in the right context and answering appropriately. Hopefully my nonsense will make some sort of sense.

Mrafrohead

by generalist

I think we need to encourage people to question their news sources.

If their news sources are accurate, they should be praised. If their news sources have problems, they should hound said sources until either the problems go away or the news source goes away.

Perhaps the Internet could be used as a medium for this type of thing. We would then need to have the reporting mechanism.

by mrafrohead

The thing that bothers me mostly about what you are presenting here is this. I find it hard to believe now that our BullShite Patriot Act has been passed. Those of us that "change" things around a little bit are now considered "Terrorists". We lose our rights completely. In their entirety. Go straight to jail and don't pass go. When we aren't hurting anything or anyone. Yet rapists and murderers, child abusers and exploiters are allowed to run rampant with nothing more than a slap on thewrist.

I find it disgusting and appauling. I feel that those of us in the US are shafted with that BS act.

But then again, what we do and what companies do differ. Because those of us that are the small fish cant afford to buy out our F***edup Government and make them look the other direction. We're just used as examples.

But that's just my opinion.

As for this movie y'all are talking about. I'll have to watch it. I would like to know more about what you are talking about other than what you have stated in this thread.

Mrafrohead

by maxwell edison

You said the following:

"...hard to believe now that our BullShite Patriot Act has been passed."

Question: What specifically about the Patriot Act do you find troublesome?

"Those of us that 'change' things around a little bit are now considered 'Terrorists'."

Question: How so, and what are some examples of this happening?

"We lose our rights completely."

Question: Again, how so, and what are some examples of this happening?

Question: Which of these "terrible" things has happened to you or to someone you "directly" know?

Disclaimer - where I stand:

I don't claim to know all the details and/or repercussions of the Patriot Act. But I do know what "generally" brought it about and what its "intended" purpose is. And, quite frankly, it doesn't bother me a whole lot. One thing the act will provide for is this: Law enforcement agencies "may" monitor certain individual's Internet activity - WITH a court's permission - in an attempt to locate those who may be considered a threat to our national security.

I kind of look at it this way: Law enforcement monitors me all the time. For example, it sets up radar traps - traps through which I pass - in their attempt to nail speeders. If I'm not speeding, no problem. Whether they monitor the Interstate highway or the Information Super Highway, I don't think they intend to take away my liberties. Quite frankly, I don't worry about it. In fact, I'm more concerned about the unbridled - and unchecked - power of the Internal Revenue Service. (Damn, I hope the IRS doesn't read this.)

by mrafrohead

What do I find troublesome...

Well, to start. The fact that those of us that change things around, as noted in teh beginning of this thread. We get the label "hacker". Right now, you lose your constitutional rights if you are found to be one, and you are given a straight pass to jail. Because we're now labled an "electronic terrorist".

I have tried to locate some exact text from the act that would work for you, but unfortunately I'm not having much luck. I can say though I have read a lot about it and what I am saying is very real.

As for your final questions. I honestly prefer to not answer them in an open forum type environment. I just don't feel comfortable with that.

I know you're looking for specific answers and I wish I could answer you more, but if you can trust my vagueness, that would be best for me. I can assure you though, I do know what I am talking about when it pertains to this matter as long as the many sites I have been to were not misinformed.

Here is one site that will give you the act. Although I was looking for it in more "laymans terms".

http://216.110.42.179/docs/usa.act.final.102401.html

Mrafrohead

by maxwell edison

You said, "It would be even more interesting to come up with a psuedo-documentary on how some media types attempt to influence people via lies, misrepresentation, slander and taking things out of context."

Yes indeed, that would be quite interesting. But who (which media outlet) would show and/or produce it?

by mrafrohead

We could produce it on the net for the likes of people like us. Eventually it will make it to the mainstream...

by generalist

A net based production would work out quite well, especially if there are enough people talking about it.

Of course to do it right, we would have to make sure that all our facts meet rigorous ethical, legal and news reporting standards. And we would also need to build a defense in depth to handle those who try to discredit the site by disinformation.

In effect, we would become a media outlet that would hopefully represent the ideals of the profession as opposed to the realities.

Oh, and for good measure, we would have to make sure that site is defended from crackers and other types. The dark side of IT does exist, unfortunately.

by maxwell edison

I've read (OK, I've skimmed) the Patriot Act, and I've read and listened to opinion - both pro and con - concerning the implications of its passage. There's nothing in there that's blatantly violating the average citizen's liberties and/or privacy.

Could some unscrupulous federal agent "spy" on you or me? I suppose so, but that could be done with or without the Patriot Act. Will it happen? Probably not. They have better things to do than simply "cyber snoop" - things like catching those terrorists and/or criminals who mean to inflict harm on you and me. They may intend to inflict harm by shutting down America's financial infrastructure - most, if not all, of which is accessible via the Internet. They may intend to inflict harm by shutting down the e-commerce sites that we maintain and rely upon for our livelihood. What about those who intend to inflict harm by trespassing on your or my network? I could go on, but I'm sure you get the point.

They're not "out to get us". They're not trying to limit our access, limit our speech, or stifle our creativity. They're intention is to prevent another 9-11, pure and simple. And the next 9-11 may come in any form - including "electronic warfare". If someone hacks into something in an attempt to steal or destroy, regardless of how big or small, significant or negligible, I'm all in favor of considering methods by which they can be stopped.

Now don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting that it's perfect, nor will it be a "cure-all"for anything and everything. Nor am I saying it's perfect or without flaws. The jury is still out, so to speak.

The SANS institute has an interesting article that may interest you. It presents the Patriot Act in easy to understand manner. For example:

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

Section 105 orders the expansion of the nation’s electronic crime task force "for the purpose of preventing, detecting, and investigating various forms of electronic crimes, including potential terrorist attacks against critical infrastructureand financial payment systems." This expansion will mean the creation of many new jobs in IT Security. As the number of jobs increases, so will the frequency and quality of training available to those interested in IT Security.

Section 206 increases the ability of the government to track persons who attempt to disguise their identity.

Section 211 makes it possible for cable companies to provide customer information to the government without notifying the customer.

Section 223 gives protection to the federal government against lawsuits. ITSPs should note that there are some checks and balances in place for improper behavior of government officials.

Title III through Title VI deals with financial issues in regards to terrorism, border protection, removing investigation obstacles, and victim compensation respectively.

Conclusion: In the global marketplace, opportunities for malicious behavior on US computer systems abound.

These are only small excerpts from that article.

The link:

http://rr.sans.org/legal/patriot_act2.php

It really is interesting to read.

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

What/Who is the SANS Institute?

The SANS (SysAdmin, Audit, Network, Security) Institute was established in 1989 as a cooperative research and education organization. The SANS Institute enables more than 156,000 security professionals, auditors, system administrators, and network administrators to share the lessons they are learning and find solutions to the challenges they face. At the heart of SANS are the many security practitioners in government agencies, corporations, and universities around the world who invest hundreds of hours each year in research and teaching to help the entire information security community.

http://www.sans.org/aboutsans.php

http://rr.sans.org/index.php

----------

We're all treading on new ground here - unchartered territory. As IT professionals we can be a part of defining what the future will hold. Like it or not, security and safety has become the major issue of the cyber-day. Whether it's a terrorist group planning the next 9-11, a "hacker" out to destroy a business, a thief out to steal someone's identity - and bank account, or some pervert trying to lure someone's young daughter into his trap, the Internet has become the weapon of choice for many of them. There are solutions - most of which are yet to be discovered. Let's be a part of finding them.

by mrafrohead

Well...

As for those who may make attempts to trespass your/my network. I figure that if they do get by, then it is OUR responsibilty to deal with it. NOT the Governments. If we weren't smart enough to secure our own network, then we first of all have no business whining about it. And second of all have a lot more research to do before we should be permitted to admin a network. I do understand that there are new exploits that are discovered almost daily. But my point is this. WE as Admins and security experts, it is our job to stay on top of this type of thing and make sure that it doesn't happen. If we are leaving our networks open full of holes. That's no fault but the person who left it open.

If someone hacks into something to destroy or steal... Well that's not admirable and Karma will definately get them. But again, I think that it's on the hands of the sysadmins to figure out who did it and report them to the authorities. Our Government has no business dealing with that. Our Government shouldn't be responsible for a weak admin improperly securing their network. I don't pay taxes to have our Government patrol private and personal networks. They can patrol their own networks and stay out of ours!

****to be continued****

by mrafrohead

As to be a part of finding a solution. I couldn't agree more with you on that one. I think that we should all take part in helping. If you find a vulnerability. Share it with all you know, so they can protect themselves from it also. Because one weak link in the chain can make them all fall down. There is no reason for the vulnerabilities to exist when places like Bugtraq and this forum exist. It is our responsibility to ourselves as IT professionals to make sure that we all know of bugsand problems and their appropriate fixes to ensure that we are all protected. In this aspect, we are all the same in this profession. There are no "barriers" and we should all take the time to look after one another. But that's us. Not our Government. They need to mind their own business and figure out how to fix the problems within this Country.

And another thing. Please don't get me wrong. I am not against our Country. I love this country dearly and I would die for it and the freedom of all Americans if need be. But our Government, my friend, they scare the sh*t out of me. They are unscrupulous and are falling into the same pattern that we originally left England for. The Patriot Act is another step by our Government in theWRONG direction.

Mrafrohead

by road-dog

factor in this industry, cutting both ways. Take for example the dotcom boom, comapnies trading at insane levels without showing any profits, because Ecommerce was the "next big thing". The downside of that is what we are experiencing right now, a vast upswell of cynicism resulting from and contributing to the collapse.

People are rash, panicky, and prone to huge swings in opinion when properly motivated by the news of the day, provided by 7/24 news channels competing for viewership by providing alarmist headlines backed up by poorly researched drivel.

Combating this is an uphill battle when the opposing viewpoint cannot be properly made via soundbite. Our position is compromised by the poor business practices of Arthur Anderson andthe like.

This education process must be handled in the trenches on a daily basis. Ethics must drive every recommendation we make and every thing that we do. If we go onsite at a customer location, we cannot undercut our credibility by engaging in unethical practices when they help the customer.

If we assist a customer by relaxing our standards, then the customer knows we will similarly hurt them if we are assisting another customer.

Don't wait for the news to show us "doing it right". It will not happen.

by maxwell edison

Michael Moore is given much more credit than he deserves, and that sentiment is picked up by unsuspecting dupes who don’t have the inclination or wherewithal to determine the whole story, the rest of the story, or the true story. He’s nomore than a self-serving, self-absorbed, hypocritical opportunist. It galls me to see a well-to-do, affluent, multi-millionaire, business owner (like Moore) profit by criticizing well-to-do, affluent, multi-millionaire, business owners – as hedoes in his books and films.

As far as the government holding terrorists in violation of our constitutional rights, you have to take two things into consideration. First of all, the US Constitution applies only to US citizens, not citizens of other countries. (Even though, I will admit, the underlying principles should – and usually do – apply to all citizens of the world.) However, in a time of war – and make no mistake about it, we are at war – to error on the sideof caution is the wise choice.

You also said, “We all know that George W. is a puppet” No, we don’t all know that. If you have any specific and verifiable information to support your assertion, please share it with us. In the meantime, I maintain that George W. is not a puppet. To the contrary, he has shown more than enough times that he’s his own man who will not yield to polls, public opinion, public criticism, media pressure, or suggestions from his father’s current or former aids. Those who label him as an independent cowboy are more accurate than those who call him a puppet. And as far as “daddy Bush's new world order”, again, I disagree. The way George W. has snubbed and/or stood up against the United Nations certainly proves that assertion is flawed.

We can certainly agree to disagree, but you should refrain from inclusive statements like, “We all know̶

by jkaras

Max, I respect your opinions regardless (well spoken with intelligence)whether I disagree with you or agree on some points or different levels of agreement. I never met Moore and I only know of his works. Who he really is or isnt will be reserved when I meet the man and judge for myself. I'm sure your info about him and his practices might have some validity to them and I'd like to see for myself whether it's spin doctoring ect.. The same can be said for George W. (conceide I'm a bit hypocritical)but I'm not the biggest fan of him or his family despite my uncle has met with them multiple times. Lets not forget that the Bush empire was built with Bin Ladden money funding their first oil riggs way back when and when 911 started our government flewout all Bin Ladden family from the USA (reported by Moore, not sure if it's fact but no one called him on it). Needless to say this incident profited both families in their own countries as keepers of the faith assuring them more powerful influence. George senior's platform was his NWO that would usher in gov control=security, trust the gov not question. Now we are giving away freedoms to receive that security, a bit fishy you gotta admit. Finally we havent declared war on any nation, butthe abstract idea of terrorism like drugs ect... If it's ok to deny rights due to war then were the Germans, Vietnamese, or various rulers who imprisoned possible problematic people justified. Our country stands for freedom and justice for all, not only when it suits our purpose for security. If your ancestry was in question how would you feel to be imprisioned without a voice or if another nation imprisioned your loved one without valid proof I'm sure you would demand release. This type of behavior makes us all look like hypocrites to the world.

by mrafrohead

The both of you. I admire your ability to be so well spoken!! I just had to throw that in;)

But Jkaras - I think that you are hitting the nail on the head. I couldn't have said it better myself.

Mrafrohead

by maxwell edison

A lie will travel 10,000 miles before the truth puts its shoes on.
-Chinese proverb

You said:
“…The Bush Empire was built with bin laden money funding their first oil rigs way back when.”

False:
The Bush family was not “in bed” with bin Laden or any other Arab oil connection. Osama bin Laden and/or his family were not even in the oil business. They were in the construction business. And Osama, he simply “inherited” all his money from his wealthy Saudi father – a contractor.

Source:
BBC article
http://tinyurl.com/40h9

In 1953, Bush got money from Brown Brothers Harriman and, with partners Hugh and Bill Liedtke, formed Zapata Petroleum. By the late 1950s they were millionaires. Bush bought subsidiary Zapata Off-Shore from his partners and went into business on his own in 1954. By 1958, the new company was drilling on the Cay Sal Bank in the Eastern Gulf of Mexico. These islands had been leased to Nixon supporter and CIA contractor Howard Hughes the previous year and were later used as a base for CIA raids on Cuba. The CIA was using companies like Zapata to stage and supply secret missions attacking Fidel Castro’s Cuban government in advance of the Bay of Pigs invasion. The CIA’s codename for that invasion was “Operation Zapata.”

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

The Bush family (George Sr.), if anything, was “in bed” with the CIA conducting clandestine missions – primarily in Cuba. The Bush oil fortune was made with funding from American sources (maybe with CIA help – who knows?)

You said:
“…reported by Moore, not sure if it's fact but no one called him on it.”

FALSE:
Yes, it was – falsely – reported by Moore and – falsely - repeated through main stream media outlets. But he was “called on it”.

? No flights took bin Laden family members out of the USA "two days" after the September 11 attacks. The flights Moore decries took place a week after the attacks, and they left only after the FAA had allowed regular passenger air travel to resume.

? Bin Laden family members were not allowed to slip out of the USA "over the objections of the FBI" or before the FBI had an opportunity to "interrogate" them, as nearly every news account of these flights mentions that the FBI questioned the departing Saudis, grounded their planes, and supervised their departures.

? The flights which carried bin Laden family members back to Saudi Arabia were not "secret," as the press reported on them within days of their occurrence. (One could hardly expect that either the U.S. or the Saudi government was going to provide the world with advance notice about the departure of planes carrying people who had good reason to fear for their lives.)

Source:
http://tinyurl.com/40gn

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

You said:
“...haven’t declared war on any nation, but the abstract idea of terrorism.”

Fact:
Look at the pictures of the rubble and/or the twin towers burning in New York and ask yourself if that’s an “abstract” idea. Ask yourself if stealing our airliners for the purpose of crashing them into our buildings to kill our brothers and sisters is an abstract idea. Ask the families of the sailors killed on the USS Cole if their funerals were “abstract” ideas. Ask the families of the soldiers killed in the pentagon if those were “abstract” deaths.

Abstract? Not even close. Terrorism – as we know it – has no nation. How can war be declared on a nation without borders? There are terrorist cells in scores of countries all over the world – including our own.

Here’s an abstract idea for you. Imagine that your mother or father, son or daughter, husband or wife was in the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. Imagine that you haven’t seen him or her since. Imagine you suffered that loss. Imagine. Would you still be singing the same tune? I doubt it.

Your soapbox:
I too, get up on a soapbox from time to time. If I've offended anyone in any way, believe me, that was not my intention. These are a "hot-button" issue for me.

Best regards,

Maxwell

by maxwell edison

We can certainly agree to disagree, but you should refrain from inclusive statements like, “We all know" because no, we do not all "know" or agree. So please, speak for yourself.

by generalist

Whenever I see a statement that begins with "We all know..." I immediately think of ways to shoot said statement down. It is one of those statements that can be shot down with a single example of somebody either not knowing something or knowing something different.

It is like someone using the word "Everybody..." when you really mean "A lot of people..."

As an example of the above, let me make the FALSE statement that "Everybody knows that one plus one is two."

This statement is falsebecause, around my household, people know that the answer can be two or ten, depending upon which base you use.

by admin

I have been pretty busy and am just returning to the board again and as I read down, I wanted to address my position on Michael Moore. I think he sensationalizes his position in a different way than much of the current media, but to a similar end. I'm not sure whether he has to or not, but on the issue of trust I know I can trust myself and so when a not completely trustworthy source leads me into seeing a truth, I do not despise nor throw it out, but nod a little thank you in their direction. Whether or not Michael Moore has a slant on his political views or outright lies for an agenda does not, for me, mean that fear in our culture no longer exists.

I am replying to this entire thread, and I finally went back up here to break in, it's not this specific post, while the point is well taken that "we" may not all share the same knowledge and experience, attitudes and bias, we do all share the capability of independantly coming to our own conclusion, and mine (which is evidently shared by some other professionals) is that fear is increasing in the IT profession.

by mrafrohead

If we do seriously start it up. Yes I think that we will need to show all sides. Including the crackers and the like. Because of them a lot of security issues are found and fixed. Also, I think we could make it documentaryish. If it was done right, it could make it to a film festival type place. And imagine the exposure from there!!!

by road-dog

I strongly disagree with your assertion that Dubya is a puppet of anyone. The biggest thing that he gets bashed for in the press is his willingness to buck the U.N. and assert our soveriegnity. His record simply does not indicate any such relationship with anyone.

He riles liberals with his "right wing" actions such as tax policies. He thoroughly P.O.'d conservatives with his "big government" actions such as the farm bill.

The "big oil" conspiracy is easily laid to rest in light of the results of Gulf war I. That war was supposedly for Texaco also, and as history shows, we did not occupy the gulf and seize control of any oil fields. We put out that psychopath's fires and got back out.

The Homeland security act has angered folks all over the spectrum, from liberals on immigration reform and scrutiny to conservatives on privacy and cost.

Suffice it to say, calling him a puppet is a shallow and simplistic statement that is easily refuted with only a superficial analysis of the record.

I also find it interesting that you champion imaginary Constitutional protections for illegal immigrants and forign nationals while convicting corporate officers without due process. You cannot have it both ways and your hypocrisy is showing....

I do agree that the news is skewed toward ratings over responsibility. The basic mindset of many people is to accept headlines as fact and not to think over complex issues in sufficient depth to debate them with anything other than attention deficit friendly catch phrases. This is the audience that the national news outlets cater to.

That is the cause of the big splash that Fox News has made on the face of the national news. Fox has dared to offset the liberal bias of the other news channels. They don't often dig as deeply as they should, but an equally simplistic but opposing viewpoint creates questions in the minds of viewers.

by generalist

The body count problem can have a variety of sources.

First, it could simply be a matter of the time of day something happens. Different media organizations have different cutoff times for their reporting.

Second, there may be different sources for the data. If more than one 'source' organization is involved, they may have different numbers because of their own sources.

Third, politics can have an important factor, especially in wars. For example, the number of civilians killed because of a misdirected bomb may be an artificially low number for the group dropping the bomb and an artificially high number for the group being bombed.

Then you have editors. They may decide to the best available number because it feels right based on their experience with both the topic and the sources. Or they may have a political agenda that they want to promote. Or they even may have a bad day when everything they do is wrong.

by mrafrohead

Or they could just be straight up lying like they did recently with the guy that died in Afghanistan. The one that was shot in the firefight two weeks ago I think it was.

Straight lie. Right off the bat.

Mrafrohead

BTW - it was not just from one media source, but many. All of them are equally as guilty.

by generalist

Media sources are dependent upon other sources for their information. So it is quite possible that multiple media sources may use the same information source and be 'lying' if that information source is lying.

Now I can forgive a media source for 'lying' because they trusted the information of an organization or person that they assumed was telling the truth. At some point you have to trust your sources.

But if the media source refuses to admit that they made a mistake and publish a retraction, then they go from victim to 'liar by omission' and deserve to be condemned.

Unfortunately, while some organizations do publish retractions and corrections, they often fail to give them the same weight as the original news. Thus if an error is either a headline in a newspaper or a three minute feature in a news show, it is unlikely that you'll find the retraction as a headline or a three minute feature.

by mrafrohead

Well I can say that I know that the news places I viewed. They made NO retractions and the lie continued for more than TWO days!!!

The truth was known BEFORE the posting even started!

This discussion is closed to new replies.