Discussion Locked

Brand new network - Purchase W2K or XP?

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are setting a network with one w2k server and ten PC's. Are there any drawbacks using XP pro instead of W2K Pro? Thanks for your opinion.

-Craig

15 replies

by lordinfidel

While there are a million reasons why I say stay with 2k, I will mention 1.

Activation codes.

If you ever need to reinstall the OS, you have to go thru the activiation code thing all over again and beg M$ for a new code.

Stick with 2K. There is very little that your users are going to get from XP that they dont already get in 2K. Plus XP is harder to secure and gives users native access remotely to their system.

Did I say just one thing, oh well

by barns

There has been a lot of crying about activation codes. If you have to reinstall all you have to do is make a phone call and give the reason for reinstalling. The reason doesn't even have to be honest. They won't say no, "you can't". I have don'tit quite often, there is no begging.

If you are setting up a network you should always get in the habit of Ghosting your machines anyway to save you the trouble of reinstalling. This will also eliminate the problem of activation.

by lordinfidel

Depending on what stage you ghost your machines will depend on whether or not you need to activate them.

Generally though, the purpose of ghost is for rapid deployment. (I use ghost often) But I use it with sysprep so that the SID's are destroyed.

I can install all of my programs, sp's and hf's, run sysprep, shutdown and clone that drive, and I have a new OS with a new sid with every machine that was cloned from it.

The problem is, that if you clone an existing machine without sysprep, you get the same SID for the machine, even after changing the machine name.

In a corp enviroment, calling everytime I need to do an install is just not feesible. If I need to rapid deploy machines, calling is not an option.

by ghstinshll

go with 2K, if ghosts a lot easier, and again, no activation... XP is a little ahead of normal user's learning code as well. Personally, I even wonder why MS really put XP out.

Stick with 2k. A business has NO need for XP...

by falco bramble

Good luck purchasing W2K, it's been made obsolete by MS, or aleast I can't buy a copy of it.

As for activation of XP, if your getting 10m copies, it 's going to be cheaper to go with volume licensing, therefore, no activation codes required.

by lordinfidel

While you still can't technically buy 2K licenses.

(This is assuming that you already have a 2K install disk)

You can buy XP licenses and use it to downgrade to 2K. This is what I now have to do on my netwk and with my clients. The license says that you can downgrade for a "period of reasonable use" (whatever the hell that means).

by maxwell edison

While it is true that you can't purchase Windows 2000 Professional under their open license (or other) agreements, you can indeed buy the individual boxed product. MicroWarehouse has a gazillion of them at around $280. But you can't buy the "upgrade", you have to buy the full version

And for the bargain seeker, ebay has listed a bunch of Windows 2000 – both full and upgrade (also some Server2000). And needing only 10 seats, that could be a viable option.

by lordinfidel

That can still be purchased thru open license as is. They have not forced the next generation of server since it is not even out for sale.

.Net framework is just being implemented in production networks (at least for us we are still in development phase, we don't plan to deploy it for another year)

.Net srvr will probably take about another 2 years until we see it appearing as wide spread as 2K.

by mrafrohead

The activation part blows...

Unless you know someone with a corporate disk. I think you could just use the corporate disk and then just buy the licenses through an online company. Then you won't have to deal with activation.

As for the otherparts of it though, you're at work to work. XP is only a fruity fluffy version of 2k. And it's networking components suck. They take the liberty of changing your settings for you. I know, it's a very thoughtful and handy feature. Until you're locked out of your files and XP doesn't want to let you back in to change their permissions even though you're the admin.

But that's just my experience:)

Mrafrohead

by c.barnhorst

As long as the hardware is adequate for XP you will be better off with XP in the long run. XP's life cycle extends much further into the future. If you already had Win2k Pro licenses it would be different. I work for the State of Colorado and we are just now upgrading to XP Pro from Win2k Pro on our clients. The IT types doing the migrations are telling me that XP Pro is a feature packed client.

by nomadss1

xp is not very friendly to any user who wants to tweak or add other programs if xp decides for what ever reason to turn you down and it does quite often then your stuck even trying to get help through MS is a nightmare and they will only send genricreplies to emails.In my opinion xp is a spy and if you don't want your company business being sent to bill gates to go through then xp is out of the question.May xp go the way of dinosaurs and fast.

by admin

How does xp send him that information? (company business being sent to bill gates)How much does it send? What mechanism does it use?

Just Curious. :)

by lordinfidel

There is an old saying in IT,

"It's not a bug its a feature"

With the time I dabbled in XP, if found it
fairly difficult to secure. When ever I would
turn one thing off I would have to re-enable
it cause it would majorly break other things.

2K on the other hand is very well documented on how to secure it. In fact you can actually make your 2K machine a bastion host.

As far as XP goes and OS's in general. A good benchmark to tell whether or not you should deploy the OS is if there is a Hacking Exposed book/section dedicated to it.

Since there is none for XP, it will stay in a purely test mode.

by milvio

Wik2k is the best option because is more mature than xp and the mayorite of the holes had being close or are in the process of being close, but be smart. First buy xp license on open,(no need to actived the software), and it is a lot cheaper, secondget a copy of win2k (since xp license are good for win2k)and istall it. this way you can have the best of the two worlds and you are ready when the time came to upgrade to xp let's say about 1 year or 2 you already cover, and you can move yo xp little by little.

This discussion is closed to new replies.