Question Locked

Cant load XPPro on a 200 gig sata hd

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
everytime I try to load XPPro on my 200 G HD. Once I get to the create partion part of the loading process my computer shuts off. I have an A8N-la MOBO and 4 gig of memory.and a 200 gig samsung hd.

16 replies

by thumbsup2

You need to load the SATA drivers before XP. During setup/install, there will be a place where you press F6 to load drivers. You DO have them on a floppy/CD/USB thumb drive somewhere, don't you?

by nepenthe0

[i]jpensmith[/i] has posed a problem that has been discussed previously in the Forum, but I still don't understand what's going on here.

His computer seems to have the original SATA hard drive. Shouldn't the SATA drivers be included in the installation/recovery CD?

If the original hard drive were of IDE genre, wouldn't he have to replace the motherboard to reconfigure with a SATA hard drive?

I just purchased a WD SATA hard drive which installed without any additional drivers. Suppose I needed them? Where is the best source?

Rick/Portland, OR

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]His computer seems to have the original SATA hard drive. Shouldn't the SATA drivers be included in the installation/recovery CD?[/i]

That motherboard may or may not be part of a manufacturers (HP, Compaq) bundle. He may have built the PC himself. It is/was available for solo purchase. If he built the machine himself, he has no recovery discs. It's also a good bet he has no recovery partition in that case.

If he has an early copy of XP Pro (as I do), it will have no SATA drivers. It was the release of XPSP2 as an OS that included SATA drivers. In which case he will have to install SATA drivers from floppy, USB, or do something called 'slipstreaming' an XP disc (a something that I have no idea how to do, or even exactly what it is).

[i]If the original hard drive were of IDE genre, wouldn't he have to replace the motherboard to reconfigure with a SATA hard drive?[/i] My motherboard, an ASUS K8N, supports both SATA and IDE.

Also, most people do not think to order a CD for a Service Pack. Even if he did have a SP disc, it's useless until after the OS is installed.

The best source for drivers is usually the manufacturer of the hardware in question. I keep a folder on my computer, and a copy backed up to CD of all relevant drivers for my machines. Once I have hunted them down, I see no reason to have to do so again and again. FWIW, I do the same with all the freeware executables I download.

HTH?

edit again: clarify

by thumbsup2

(Q) [b]His computer seems to have the original SATA hard drive. Shouldn't the SATA drivers be included in the installation/recovery CD?[/b]

(A) First, he didn't say this was an original anything, so don't assume it is. There are many ways to install an OS and many reasons to do it. We must ask to be sure of what they're actually doing.

Second, not all computers come with a recovery CD. Some, especially custom builds, come with an OEM copy of Windows which is usually installed by the shop that built the computer and who know how to get things set up using it. OEM copies require SATA drivers. The builders usually provide a "giblets box" which contains drivers for all of the peripherals installed, including the HDD. Even if the system comes with a recovery CD, it may only point to the hidden installation partition on the original HDD where the files are actually stored. Often a person will upgrade something like the HDD and the recovery CD will no longer work because the partition is missing, so they either buy another retail copy of Windows (the legal way) or buy an OEM copy along with the HDD (another legal way) or worse, borrow someone else's to get the system up and running (the illegal way). When they're using an installation CD that is not specifically designed for the system they now have, for whatever reason, the SATA drivers must be installed before Windows will install. Note: An OEM CD is not the same as a recovery CD furnished with the computer.

(Q) [b]If the original hard drive were of IDE genre, wouldn't he have to replace the motherboard to reconfigure with a SATA hard drive?[/b]

(A) Not if the MB had a SATA controller on it in addition to the IDE controllers. Until recently, MB's had both controllers, IDE and SATA. Most still do, but some are now coming out with SATA only controllers (bummer!). In the recent "good old days", one could purchase a computer with either type of drive in it, or both, if they wanted to. Since, in the early days of the SATA drives they were more expensive than their IDE counterpart, lots of people opted for the cheaper IDE drives. Even manufacturers cut expenses back then and put IDE drives in instead of SATA so they could sell the computer for a few bucks less than then competitors. Now, SATA and IDE prices are about the same, so people go out and buy the "new thing" to replace their older failing HDD, not realizing what kinds of problems they'll be facing to get it up and running. Yes, if the old drive is still in tact, they can clone it and be off and running. However, many people like to install fresh on their new drive (recommended anyway) so they don't bring all their old baggage into the new drive.

(Q) [b]I just purchased a WD SATA hard drive which installed without any additional drivers. Suppose I needed them? Where is the best source?[/b]

(A) Your situation was different. I know from our previous chats that you ghosted your old drive which had the SATA drivers built into an existing installation of Windows. That's completely different than installing Windows fresh. Had you needed drivers for a clean install, you would go to the drive manufacturer's web site where you would find drivers for your specific drive as well as instructions on how to use them. Now, I also know from our previous chats that the drive you purchased wasn't listed yet on the manufacturer's web site. So, you might have been literally up the creek without physically calling the manufacturer. Often their customer support can give you access to their FTP site where you could have downloaded the drivers. They may have been written in Malaysian, but they would have been there. ;)

Does that clear things up a bit for you?

----

by thumbsup2

Just so you know, Rick, there are many flavors of Windows XP. And, I'm not just talking about Home vs Pro or SP1, SP2, SP3. Each flavor has it's own installation requirements. I'll try to list them here, if I can remember them all.

(1) Windows XP Retail Full (Home or Pro): The original sold in a fancy retail box on the store shelf. It would only install on a clean, unformatted hard drive. If you tried to put it on a drive that was already formatted, it would squawk at you and then format the drive all over again. It would not install over the top of a previous OS. And, the original did not come with even so much as the slightest knowledge of SATA. That came later with service packs.

(2) Windows XP Retail Upgrade (Home or Pro): The original sold in another fancy retail box on the store shelf, but was ONLY used to upgrade an existing OS like Win98. It would check the hard drive for an existing OS to upgrade and refuse to install if it couldn't find that previous OS. It wouldn't upgrade WinNT or Win2K. Only Win95, Win98 and WinME (ugh!). Of course, there were ways to fool it into installing on a clean drive, but most people didn't know about those tricks, and still don't. ;) This upgrade is what the majority of people purchased though when WinXP first came out. It was about $100 cheaper than the full blown WinXP retail. So, they just upgraded what they already had. The original WinXP Upgrade knew nothing about SATA either. And, as far as I know, it never changed even after SP1, SP2 and SP3 came out. The service packs still had to be purchased separately (or downloaded) and applied to the original upgrade.

(3) Windows XP OEM: Could be either Pro or Home, but it was ONLY to have been sold with custom built systems or major components like a MB or HDD. It wasn't for retail sales. If you purchased a major component like a MB, you qualified to buy an OEM copy of WinXP. The OEM version of WinXP came with no manual, no box, no instructions, nothing, except the CD in a plain white envelope and a CD KEY. It too, knew nothing about SATA. Manufacturers like DELL, HP, Gateway, eMachine, etc... did NOT furnish OEM copies of WinXP though. It was used by smaller Mom & Pop shops that custom built their own retail systems or by those of us who prefer to build their own systems. As the service packs came out, the OEM's were updated by Microsoft. So, you could purchase WinXP OEM SP1, WinXP OEM SP2, and now, probably OEM SP3.

(4) Windows XP Recovery CD: Each major manufacturer (DELL, HP, etc..) had their own versions of a recovery CD. Some of them included the installation files on the CD itself. Others only had routines that would extract the installation files from a hidden partition on the hard drive. In both cases, drivers for their specific equipment were included. In either case, the installation files were not as complete as the retail or OEM CDs were. They included JUST the files needed to get their particular system configuration up and running. All of the frills that were included on the Retail and OEM copies were missing. Some manufacturers went as far as including enough of the drivers so that one CD could boot several different models, but JUST those models. In other words, you couldn't use a DELL recovery CD to set up an HP computer, even if the installation files were on the CD and not the HDD. There is another difference between manufacturer's recovery disks. Some of them, if you boot to the CD, it will ask you what you want to do. With others, booting to the CD will start the recovery process, wiping the drive without asking and continue until it's done, no questions asked. I've only bumped into this last type one time and that's all it took for me to learn not to do it again. At least not from that manufacturer anyway.

(5) Windows XP, but NO CD AT ALL: This was the worst of the bunch, in my opinion. You buy a computer and were expected to create your own Windows Installation CD after you got it booted up and running for the first time. The instructions weren't very clear, so many people didn't realize they needed to create their own CD until after their HDD had already failed and they had lost the ability to do it. Even if they did create a bootable CD as expected of them, it would only return the system to the original configuration. So, if they had a catastrophe which took out the HDD and the video card both, they would have a hard time getting the system up and running again because the first boot would probably BSOD due to incorrect video drivers. Oh, it could be done. But, it wasn't for the faint of heart. Most ended up taking their system to a repair shop to get it going. Generally, these were the first WinXP machines, so the version of Windows on them was the original, no service packs. It wouldn't have included any knowledge of SATA unless the manufacturer had used a SATA drive in their build and included that with the files that built the CD.

So, as you can see, there are reasons why we ask, not only what OS they're installing, but what type of CD a person is using. Versions of XP (home or pro, sp's or not) as well as the type of CD (recovery, upgrade, retail, oem) all make a huge difference in how we advise someone. And, we can never assume that when someone says they're trying to install XP that they're using any one of the flavors above. We almost always have to ask, unless they provide the make/model of computer so we can make an educated guess based on our experience. Even then, we're occasionally wrong. :D

---

by boxfiddler Hot topic

and you got in that bit about never assume anything, which of course I forgot to add. I think you would be a good teacher! B-)

re: do the same. Sheesh, I learned that one the hard way. After a major crash and redo, I discovered, much to my horror, that I had neglected to backup my Updates and Exe's folder. I don't know how many hours I spent hunting down freebies I used a lot. Lost all my bookmarks in that one too. Didn't learn enough there, I still sometimes forget to back up those. lol

by thumbsup2

I do teach a bit already, as part of my job (Technical Support). And, I even have a few who have to be retrained every Monday morning because they forgot over the weekend how to copy n paste or format a Word document or enter a formula in an Excel spreadsheet! I can almost set my watch by the ones who can't remember how to log into Outlook! ;)

Yeah, yeah, back up, back up, save, save, back up! I tell everybody at work, save often while working on it and back it up when you're done. Geeze, you'd think I would take my own advice at home. But, I just did a back up of my own files last weekend after neglecting to do it for over a year. :0 Even after learning my lesson like you, the hard way and loosing stuff then having to find it again, I'm still terrible at following my own advice! ;)

by nepenthe0

I know this isn't the last time we'll see these issues raised in the Forum, but your explanations make sense, and hopefully the knowledge will trickle out to the beleaguered consumer.

It would be nice if TR hosted a [i]Download[/i] covering this stuff. Perhaps you and Boxfiddler should jointly write one?

Rick/Portland, OR

by boxfiddler Hot topic

inherent in your suggestion that ThumbsUp2 and I write a paper for TR.

I must respectfully decline, however. I enjoy writing, and I enjoy helping, but my plate is as full as I care for it to get. It took me a long time to realize that I need to reserve time for me and my enjoyments, and I can't commit to anything more without giving some of that up. Won't do that.

Flattery will get you almost everywhere! ;)

by thumbsup2

Thank you very much. And, I would have to respectfully decline for the same reasons as Boxy. My plate is full.

Besides, if we made it too easy for people to find the help they are looking for, we wouldn't have the pleasure of helping them in the forums! Geeze, you don't want to take ALL of our fun away, now do you? ;)

(danged typos that spring up when I'm laughing!)

by oh smeg

According to ASUS they don't have a A8N-LA M'Board never did and still don't. What they do have is a A8N with the following Suffixes

32-SLI
5X
E
SLI
SLI Deluxe
SLI Premium
SLI SE
VM
VM CSM
and finally a
VM CSM/NPB

But regardless some M'Boards support SATA and others do not however Windows XP never has Natively so you need to add a driver by pressing the F6 Key when the first blue screen appears.

However from what you say here the SATA Drive is being recognized but when it comes to formating it the system reboots without going through the Formating process is that correct? Do you see a Yellow line appear across the screen or not?

If you see the yellow line the system will reboot by itself with a Red line counting down to the restart. At that point you do not touch anything and especially do not press any Key when you see the [b]Press Any Key to Boot off the CD Message[/b] you need to allow the Windows Install process to do it's thing and not be constantly restarting the XP Install Procedure all over again.

If you are not seeing a Yellow line moving across the screen at the Format Stage either the M'Board or HDD is faulty and requires attention so try the Sea tools utility to test the drive available from here

http://tinyurl.com/yvq99t

If the drive fails the test you need to check it again in another computer as it may be the M'Boards SATA Controller which is at fault so trying it in another Computer will check the HDD. If it passes both the M'Board and HDD are OK.

I hope that is useful to you.

Col

by oh smeg

Why doesn't ASUS List the M'Board on their Web Site. :(

I didn't think I needed to Goggle when I knew who the maker was. ASUS doesn't even list the LA in the downloads for BIOS or Drivers. So I can only assume that Goggle is broken and finding incorrect Web Sites full of Typo's. :p

Col

by nepenthe0

Boxfiddler and ThumbsUp2 have taught me that assumptions are dangerous creatures. The URL Boxfiddler gave you is probably valid, because at the bottom you see [i]Copyright 1996-2008 Geeks.com[/i].

I have encountered the same phenomemon with Western Digital, which had posted no retail source for its new VelociRaptor HD. I located the HD at NewEgg.com and ordered it from that source, unable to obtain it directly from WD.

If you check the WD website, their new ultra high performance desktop HD (WD3000GLFS) is unlisted, yet I have it installed in my computer.

The lessons to be learned here:

1) Don't place unlimited trust in any one source of information;

2) When time and circumstances permit, try to verify the accuracy of web posted information by checking a corroboratory source.

3) There are 2 types of folks: those who [b]have[/b] put a foot in their mouth, and those who [b]will[/b] put a foot in their mouth. Trust me - I've just done it.

Rick/Portland, OR

This discussion is closed to new replies.