Christmas has been hijacked
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by darryl~
My wife and I aren't the most upstanding "church goers" in Truro but at least we know not to take the whole "political correct" thing too far when it involves religion.
Sometimes I differ in opinion with you but seldom comment on your posts as things can become very heated at times.
I think you nailed this one 100% correct.
A couple of years ago there was quite a debate between Nova Scotia and Boston. Every Christmas a giant White Spruce is sent from Nova Scotia to the city of Boston as a "thank you" for their relief assistance after the Halifax Explosion December 6, 1917 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halifax_Explosion). It's always a big deal here and is a great honor to have the tree selected come from one's own property....the Boston puts up the tree in the city square and decorates it.
A couple years ago Boston was going to call it a "Holiday Tree"....oh my....some of the things being said by people from my home province made me a little embarrassed to be a Nova Scotian....the thing was called a Christmas Tree for 90 years & was totally accepted as such.....why change it now?
Do ya know what I mean? It's just silly.
by ansugisalas
by darryl~
it's still for sale....even dropped the price...."The Church of Scum"....I even went and took a look at it...the problem is the land....it's very close to the road (basically just has a parking lot for a front yard)....there's a little "green space" on the sides (about 20 feet per side) and the back is straight down a steep bank to a river. It's just not a good place for a 6 yr old little girl.
They've been selling a lot of churches in Nova Scotia over the past few years....the older "churc h goers" have been dieing off and many churches have been idle....some have even been carefully taken down & assembled down in the USA (we have some very old "loyalist" era churches).
It's really too bad....I'd love to buy one.
If the church our little one was christened in ever goes up for sale....well...I'll just have to buy that one..... http://www.colchester.ca/north-colchester (Holy Trinity Anglican Church) which is kinda funny because neither Purple or I are Anglican - it was my grandmother's church ;)
OK, gloves off.
Let's try to put it simply - for the hard of understanding. Absolutely I enjoy things that would not have been written if the author didn't BELIEVE that God existed. What the AUTHOR believed may differ from MY beliefs but that doesn't alter my appreciation of the music. The libretto of Messiah, derived from the Bible is, to me, as much fiction as the story told in Carmen but that doesn't matter at all. It isn't MORE fictional because it's religious.
EVERYBODY believes something different to everyone else.
Every composer reflects to a greater or lesser extent the cultural, religious and politics of the time and environment in which they wrote. The majority of circumstances and contexts are totally alien to me yet it doesn't detract from my enjoyment of the music.
You know, I'm not going to point out the fact that you say that YOU aren't a Christian and that YOU enjoy Carols and that, somehow, YOU aren't a hypocrite and I am because that would just be too easy. Just show you up as the idiot you are. No. I'm better than that. So I'll not mention it. Mmmmmph! Zipped shut!
Faith supported by subjective experience? Do you realise how stupid that statement is? I suspect not. No, I really can't be bothered to try to give you a "personal experience" because, you see, I don't wish (and I'm certainly not told by my Book of Holy Words) to convince you, convert you, save your immortal soul or otherwise attempt to change your views in the slightest. Trust me, your immortal soul - should you have one - is yours to do with as you see fit.
Yes, it's an opinion! It's MY opinion! It's MY logic that brings me to believe what I believe and to disbelieve what I disbelieve. Yes! Just mine! Nobody TOLD me to do it.
I.WORKED.IT.OUT.ALL.ON.MY.OWN.
Without a safety net.
Is the penny at last dropping? Probably not.
Oh, and like I give a rat's fart what YOU think! There are people on this board who I do respect - nearly all of them, in fact, and some quite a lot - whether I agree with them or not.
But you aren't one of them.
Oh, no.
Not even close.
by ansugisalas
It's such an ironic thing, believing that there's no cause for belief. At odds with itself.
I know some people think agnosticism is wishy-washy bet-hedging non-committing baloney.
It's not. In fact, it's really scary.
See, there's the VOID. It's there. It's nothingness and the feeling that something may, or may not, be watching from that nothingness.
Some believers say "There's something there, alright, it's my master - it's looking out for me, because I follow this book here, and what I feel inside when I read it".
Atheists say "There's nothing there. Nope. Closing my eyes here, not looking. Stuffing my ears too, laa-laaa-laa-laaa, can't hear a thing."
Agnostics know there's either something there or not. And they accept it, turning their backs on the VOID, despite the feeling of eyes staring, or no eyes not staring, at them, from out of nothing. It takes discipline not freak out, and it takes discipline to not decide either way.
No comfortable lies (that may or may not turn out to be true).
by ansugisalas
I went and got myself into trouble... again?!?
Where'd I put that anti-inquisitor aerosol?
choir boy at them that will distract them long enough to shoot the buggers.
Not pc on so many levels Tony, oops....
by ansugisalas
by oz_media
[i]"I would consider it hypocritical for an atheist to declare a liking for this kind of music and at the same time deny the existence of God. Without the religion of Christianity this music would never have been composed in the first place.[/i]
Okay that's two parts really, firstly,
[i]"I would consider it hypocritical for an atheist to declare a liking for this kind of music and at the same time deny the existence of God. [/i]
Handel's Messiah is an amazing composition, my ex played it at several concerts while we were together and I enjoyed them immensely, as did several thousand others in attenance.
I wouldn't suggest that others, who were not religiously bound, were aethiests or hypocrites for attending and enjoying such fantastic music played by such professional and talented musicians; such a comment would be absolute absurdity, even for me!
[i]Without the religion of Christianity this music would never have been composed in the first place.[/i]
Without the drums declaring war on a neighbouring tribe, percussion in such pieces would not exist either. The motivation for such composition is irrelevant to most, even if it holds religious meaning for many also; though I tend to feel you'd find yourself alone with such comments even amongst the Christian community.
Well composed pieces are a culmination of feeling, it makes one happy, sad, angry, relaxed and any other number feelings. the prsonl motivation to write music is not important really, the music effects every listener in a different way and holds different meaning to them also.
Regardless of lyrics, music does not segregate people, it is the one form of communication that remains constant globally and without race, religion imposed.
CERTAINLY there are many hymns that would contain lyrics of a specifically religious nature, however the music that accompanies it is not religious at all, if it has that meaning for youm, you need to understand that music's 'meaning' changes with the listener.
I listen to all music, well not country anymore, and I see value in the MUSIC itself, tones that are ever changing though almost predictable and offering an element of surprise when they change in direction, it rises and falls, softens and hardens. I choose music to listen to that suits my current mood or even to direct my chosen mood, sounds that I find pleasant to listen to at any given time. I used to love Christmas carols and the fun of singing them with my friends and peers annually and getting into the spirit of Christmas, which holds a different meaning 'spirit' for all involved, religious or not. Even within the followers of Christianity, they all have different ideas of what THEIR religion means to THEM. Some have much more open and spiritual views of Christianity, others adhere to teh old testament this makes neither a hypocrite though. Singing carols does not mean I practice "Christianity" (in a traditional sense, if there even is such a thing), nor does NOT enjoying carols make me an hypocrite.
The one thing I love most about music is that it does not discern between race colour or religion. Music from around teh globe all sounds very different and unique, however it is based on the same principles, regardless of region.
To quote Sharespeare, [i][b]"If music be the food of love, play on."[/i][/b]
by oz_media
I can see that in the sense that it has been commericialized and used for setting th etone of Christmas due to it's popularity and people's familiarity.
Personally I am a huge Bruckner fan, but that's neither here nor there with respect to this thred.
by oz_media
How do you worship a non-God?
If you don't believe in something, does that mean you must then worship something else?
by nicknielsen
by oz_media
by nexs
I tend to agree with you on this one Maxwell. But I don't think that is is localized to just christmas.
Political correctness has been taken many steps too far. Especially when things like "Baa Baa Black Sheep" get changed. I recently found out that it's wrong to call those long, black boards which you use chalk on to draw/write, a 'Blackboard'. Apparently it is offensive and racist.
Get farked! It's only racist if you want it to be. We called it a Blackboard because the board was black, not because the Australian natives have darker skin than us.
Political correctness can take a long walk of a short pier.
by darryl~
by oz_media
Assuming origin, purely based on skin tone, is racism in action.
If you are blonde haired and blue eyed, are you deemed Arayan-American?
My close friend is black, not African American, he's black. He wasn't born in Africa but Alabama. His skin is not actually BLACK (very close, he's really dark skinned) but he's offended by the term African American.
The people that choose to call him African-American are not being any less racist at all, than those who say black.
Since when is segregating someone based on distant ancestoral origin, any better than based on the colour of his skin?
We don't call others Swedish-American, Anglo-American, Russian-American etc. We refer to them generally as WHITE or even worse, American. But the people that actually ARE from North America are indigenous-American?
F**k off to polticial correctness already, lets all just be humans for once and describe what we see, not what we think people feel.
Since when was it deemed more poltically correct to refer to you by a place you never came from, based on your skin tone, rather than referring to you based on the difference of your skin tone.
You can't see someone and KNOW they came from Africa, it is simply a blatantly racist assumption based purely on skin colour. You CAN see someone and describe them by their unique skin tone rather accurately though, how is the latter deemed racist?
Three whire guys and a black guy in a room.
If you wish to note something the black guy said, it's not offensive to say he was the black guy in the room. If you said 'the white guy' people might need further clarification, 'the white guy with the blue shirt.'
If there are three black guys and a white guy in a room, same thing applies.
It's NOT racist, assuming origin based on skin tone is though.
by nexs
I see your point, and agree mostly, I don't agree with the term African-American (or in my case Indigenous-Australian) as a racist remark. In fact, it would be spoken as a way of trying to be polite.
I'm sure that any sensible person would appreciate the effort and thought put into it, rather than assuming racism.
Another point in that matter would be that many non-Caucasian (and the Caucasian for that matter) people would be proud of their heritage and culture (ie: the African-American). So I suppose that it would depend entirely on the individual.
by oz_media
I bet you've never liked a gay songwriter, it would be very unChristian to do so and obviously would make you a hypcrite, being a straight man.
When a gay man writes music that is based on the experiences and feelings of being a gay man and it appeals to millions of straight men worldwide, are they all hypocrites?
Elton John, Freddy Mercury (Queen), Rob Halford (Judas Priest).
If Holwin' Wolf didn't have a hard time being acceppted as a minority, if his love interests did not fail, if he hadn't fallen on hard times, if he didn't drink himself into sadness, much of the blues that he wrote would not exist either. The thousands of bands, Beatles, Stones, The WHO, countless heavy metal acts, Jimmy Hendrix, ZZtop, rock N roll in general, would not exist. Enjoying and being influenced by their music does not mean that you want support being a black man fighting against repression, or that I want to get drunk and forget my lost loves, nor can I say I even fully understand or view it from his perspective. I have my OWN feelings when I listen to his music that are not driven by sharing his views.
I don't think you gave your comments a moment's thought, if so it is premeditated baiting. I think you posted purely from emotion and your continually stated disinterest in people of alternate or nor chosen faith.
by craturus
So...your complaining that Christmas is being taken over, yes? I would quote "What was once an almost exclusive Christian day of celebration..." This is very clearly untrue, this holiday was first celebrated as the winter solstice, before Christians usurped it. So, your premise for this point is incorrect.
Perhaps, the person(s) sending the card choose not to include this Christan holiday because they do not agree with the underlay principle of greed (clearly unchristian) the it now has; but than again, maybe they recognize the many evils of this church and choose not to acknowledge its holiday.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
they're not going to acknowledge 'this holiday', they shouldn't shop for, banquet for, vacation over 'this holiday'.
On the other hand, the usurping of the solstice has certainly come back to haunt the world. I find that amusing.
I wouldn't lay the usurping of the Winter Solstice at the feet of 'all' Christianity. That was a Catholic thing.
I thought it was the Lutherans in Lake Wobegon.
______
no, "e".
is the root form of christianity, certainly in the organised church sense. So as christians I'm afraid you maintained the original theft and denying that it has anything to with you is reminiscent of hand washing.....
If it's a real concern, pehaps the you should set up the sect of Boxfiddler and celebrate the birth of Christ on a less 'erm convenient day. :D
In these PC days you could probably get your holiday moved and be available for work during the solstice when all those thieves and pagans normally have time off.
"in posession of stolen holidays". If you give it back then you won't be prosecuted.
Then we could ALL celebrate Dies Natalis Solis Invicti - Christians, too - and Max wouldn't be able to start up a thread complaining of hijacking.
:)
Although, thinking about it , Dies Natalis Solis Invicti doesn't work in the Southern Hemisphere but as all of the Aussies and Kiwis are partying on the beach at that time of year, they wouldn't even notice.
Woddayasay, Bruce? They've stopped the Chrissie hols? That'll piss of the ankle-biters.
No worries. Chuck us another tinny.
(With reference to our Australian friends, with England one up in the current Ashes Series, I have this to say, "HA HA HA HA HA!")
by ansugisalas
by jamesrl
Thanks, but I like my gravy savoury and my honey mead sweet.Of course I don't get my mead very often, only when I'm good.
As for plunder, I don't work on wall street. Have you seen that Monty Python movie?
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0215685/
by nicknielsen
...[i]there really are atheists out there so insecure that they can't enjoy a thing of beauty (subjectively, to them) on account of it's associations. [/i]
If they can't accept that others may find inspiration (and beauty) in something in which they don't believe, that's [b]their[/b] problem. Regardless of the inspiration, beauty is its own reason for existence.
by nicknielsen
I've performed Carmina Burana three times: twice in the chorus, and once in the orchestra. I much preferred the orchestra.
I sang second tenor for the first choral performance, baritone for the second. Orff appears to have believed that the accepted ranges for male voices were just too low. In the arrangement we had, both tenor parts were written using treble clef, the baritone using tenor clef. (Added: The tenor parts were sung as written and not tranposed down the octave!) I don't think the first tenors ever dropped below the staff, and the second tenors might have gone as low as middle C once or twice. The baritones had notes above the staff (in [u]tenor clef[/u]!) Even the basses had parts with a ledger line or two involved.
I remember the tenor soloist breaking us up during a dress rehearsal by commenting that he couldn't do justice to Olim lacus colueram that night because he saved his tightest shorts for performances.
First trumpet was much easier.
by ansugisalas
all this time I was thinking of mentioning Carmina... but since we were talking religious - as opposed to deliberately blasphemous - music, I didn't. I'm sorry for the faux pas of underestimating TR subject flux :D.
A funny thing; over here, Ibuprofen pain killers are marketed mostly under a big brand name - Burana! To my mind always comes an image from that; a man with a hangover getting blasted with, in sequence, two phrase fragments - the opening O Fortuna! Immediately followed by "WAAAAFNA!!!". Repeat ad nauseam ]:)
by jamesrl
And both times I wished I was playing the timpani like I did in high school.
Loved doing it Carmina.
by nicknielsen
The most fun I ever had in performance was brass choir. Mostly the Baroque classics (Purcell, Albinoni Bach, Handel, etc.), but we also did more current arrangements (Herb Alpert, for example). Then our music director introduced us to Fanfare for the Common Man. We had to bring in the rest of the brass (all seven of them :) ), borrow two tympani, and import two horn players, but we did it, and fairly well, too.
But that year, from a 35-chair high school band, we sent six of seven trumpets to county festival: four to band, and both first and second chair in county orchestra. That was the year we did Carmina.
Band had it easy that year: Buglers Holiday and Variations on America, among others.
by nicknielsen
[i]So people who enjoy Christmas music must accept that it has been created by people who do believe in the Christian god.[/i]
What inspired them to write the music is immaterial to me if I enjoy the music. If I find the music beautiful, I don't give a flip about the beliefs of the person who created it and how those beliefs influenced the creation. I simply enjoy the music for its own sake.
The same applies to paintings, drawings, carvings, etchings, statuary, buildings, the Grand Canyon, Niagara Falls, the Matterhorn, the Serengeti and all the rest. You can speculate all you wish about how and why it came to be, and who or what might have had a hand in, but I'm not going to worry about that. I'm simply going to enjoy its beauty without worrying about the why.
by av .
Good idea.
AV
by jamesrl
http://www.youtube.com/user/wrmp#p/a/u/6/FoawKrKsquw
This is my choir, singing at L'eglise de la Madeline in Paris last March.
The piece was written for women. But we were short a few low altos. So for the second and third parts I was asked to join them. I'm trying to blend, not to sing out too much, but to sound like an alto, its just on the edge of falsetto.
by jamesrl
I have an album with the Lincoln Portrait
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2vJLJdrS_Go
as well as Fanfare and parts of Rodeo. Great stuff all of it.
by jamesrl
by oz_media
If you are American, born in America and secon or third generation American, then being called "Afircan American is not polite at all. Being deemed AMERICAN is far more respectful. Now there's the Californian guy with the blonde hair, the olive skinned guy from Idaho and the black guy from Alabama. All are Americans, and using colour is simply descriptive, it's not a relation of dissention at all.
The whole PC thing is ridiculous, it only serves the conscience of those who feel being "politically correct" is wothwhile.
If I want to call my friend something derogatory, I wouldn't be calling him black, there are far more derogatory terms to make such a point. Why would calling him black be derogatory or even seen as offensive? Because politically correct society has deemed it so, not him.
by oz_media
"Ho Ho F'ing Ho
What a croc of sh*t,"
Honestly Santee, you strike ma as a guy that would really enjoy Kevin Blooy Wilson (The Ozzie Yobbo).
If you don't already own all his music, you need to familiarize yourself with the following songs,
Santa Claus (one of my fav KBW songs! I'm not sure if I care for the vieo with it though)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tEe55NxFSSU
Ho Ho F***ing Ho
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhF47j2VK6M
Dicktaphone
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M01Nn_Jo_m4&feature=related
(And one we can ALL relate to)
Absolute c__t of a day:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaUfBSFq45M&feature=related
Warning: not for little boys and girls, old anyone else with no sense of ha ha.
by seanferd
by oz_media
by nexs
But some people don't appreciate the attempt and jump straight into defensiveness.
Maybe some people just want personal conflict.
by jamesrl
by nexs
I was born in Australia. My mother was born in middle England. My grandmother still has not become a legal Australian citizen, and has been in Australia for around 40 years but still barracks for the Australian Test team in The Ashes. She regards herself Australian.
But her accent is still thick British. Though not abusively Australian Patriotic.
by nexs
Of attitude that pisses me off. If you make an effort to do the right thing and this particular breed of person (whether they are black, white, olive, multicoloured) will take anything you say to be offensive, and make a big deal of it, it just really grinds my gears, so to speak.
If I were to call someone 'African American' and they correct me politely by saying 'Actually, I was born in Alabama', then I'd be happy to continue a polite conversation with them.
But should they decide that they were born in America and I was being racist, and a hoo-har starts, then I would definitely afford no more time to this person.
But you are absolutely right regarding derogatory remarks. There is far worse things you could say to someone than describing the colour of their skin.
by oz_media
But we have discussed it several times, usually because it comes up here and I point out some of the comments to him. But he knows all about it, obviously as he is from the US and grew up in a predominantly black neighbourhood.
It's funny sometimes when we are in public, he'll pass another black guy and give him a nod of recognition. THis usually leaves the other guy woindering if he knows him from somewhere; there just isn't the same kind of issue with it here. Nobody gives a crap because our whole city is multicultural of every race and colour you can imagine. In fact, Asians (Chinese, Japanes etc.) are a majority now in Richmond.
I know racism still exists with many people here and everywhere, but I've noticed more mixed race groups of people in public here than south of the border.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by nexs
by seanferd
I'm having some difficulty with this:
You enjoy music that was composed by people who had faith in God.
If that God didn't exist, as you believe, there would be no such music for you to enjoy.
How does that even make sense? All that is required is for the Believers to have their faith, and an artful way of expressing it, regardless as to whether or not their particular god(s) exist(s).
Do people who find the remaining bit of the Parthenon beautiful have to believe in Athena? If not, does that make them hypocritical?
The cathedral looks familiar, though (was in Paris, sketching a bridge, once; stayed in a cheap place on the Left Bank; ate at [i]prix fixe[/i] places). Almost got killed crossing a roundabout by two cheap Renaults racing abreast that divided at the last moment.
Must have been that God foresaw the need for me to be here celebrating Christmas with you guys.
by seanferd
by nicknielsen
by seanferd
by seanferd
That is the whole thing.
It's those occasions when, e.g., "race" (and I use the term lightly) is pointed out when there is no need.
by ansugisalas
the river bank... for getting rid of corpses, if the current is strong enough.
To live in, no, that's not ideal :)
by ansugisalas
they obviously think there's something so wrong with the other person that they *musn't* speak of it.
Basil: "Don't mention the war!"
Trying to tip-toe around a great imaginary big (african) elephant in the room is the problem.
by jamesrl
The Eglise de la Madeline was built by Napoleon as a memorial to his Grand Army. When Napoleon was overthrown and monarchy restored, the king gave the place to the church. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%89glise_de_la_Madeleine
The music sounds old, but it was actually written by Richard Rodgers for the Sound of Music. It was sung near the beginning by the nuns. At Notre Dame, they demanded to vette every piece of music we sang and turned up their nose at this one, refusing because it wasn't old enough, or written by a known classical composer. But we snuck it in anyway. L'Eglise de la Madeline didn't vette the music, as long as it was sacred, they were happy.
The right to be greeted with a christian specific wish of good cheer....
What was that by the way, the 11th commandment.
Thou shall not be punished for being kind on my son's birthday.
:p
by oz_media
by jamesrl
by ansugisalas
by ansugisalas
Not, Byzantine?
Christmas should probably be in July.
That, at least here, is traditionally a "slow month" in agriculture, and so, much more like to be chosen for a great big tally.
And it's warm, so sheperds are out in the pastures at night.
And of course, the damning evidence: July? = "Yule, aye" :p
by ansugisalas
Osiris, too, a mere pup.
The god that dies and comes back. Very vhery vherie oulde.
The 25th December is the first day that the Sun can be seen to be moving South following the Winter solstice, without the aid of scientific instruments. It's been a Significant Day since Man could reason and remember.
Generally I find that most people miss just how awesome the 25th December is!
I just quoted the Latin as it pre-dated the Christian. Unlike the followers of JC, the Romans didn't usurp the festival, just gave it a Latin name and accepted it.
:)
by ansugisalas
by nicknielsen
[i]The 25th December is the first day that the Sun can be seen to be moving South following the Winter solstice, without the aid of scientific instruments. [/i]
Shouldn't that read "The 25th December is the first day that the Sun can be seen to be moving [b]North[/b] following the Winter solstice, without the aid of scientific instruments."?
by jamesrl
And just where in the constitution does it say you have the right to be addressed in a manner of your choosing? Or that you have a right to see ads that mention Christmas?
Would it not impinge on their rights of free speech to address you how they see fit, and advertise however they want.
Or am I missing something here?
Cause what you propose sounds more like China than a free country founded on democratic principles.
by nicknielsen
You have the right to say and think as you like, so long as I agree with it.
It's been that way since the beginning.
by seanferd
by drwiremore
Christmas celebrates the birth of Christ.
To some this is a Christmas, and to others either a holiday or simply December. However, we all celebrate this time of year, in some way, with a holiday spirit. Therefore: I extend to you my Christmas & Holiday wish: good will to all and peace on earth.
Merry Christmas
Happy New Year
Happy Hanukkah
Happy Kwanzaa
Happy Earth
Peace and Goodwill to all ... to you, your family and your friends this Christmas - Holiday - December season.. ~dw
by oz_media
I don't celebrate my birthday on July 13 or some other day just because I think it's more significant; like celebrating my birthday on the first day of spring break or something.
Wasn't Jesus supposed to be born in the 'month' of Tishri, somewhere between what we now call September and October? So why do we have to celebrate HIS birthday on Christmas?
Oh well, a Festivus for the rest of us. :D
Just teasing, Happy Ho-Ho to you too. ;)
by nicknielsen
I was a young airman and my then-roommate had been so loud coming in the night before, he woke the people in the rooms on either side. He had to work that morning, just like everybody else in the barracks, but was still sound asleep. So we gave him an alarm: Fanfare for the Common Man.
GONGGGG. BOOM BOOM!
He sat bolt upright, holding his head.
Gongggg. Boom Boom!
He laid back down.
gonggg. boom boom!
He thought he was home-free...
BA-DA-DAAAAAAA!
:^0
If you can't tell, I was not particularly fond of this particular roommate. B-)
by boxfiddler Hot topic
Has a ring to it... :^0
I'm afraid I'm not up to that level of accountability. Hell, I couldn't even climb the ladder of rank in the Church of Scum. :0
Personally, I don't care where the holiday originated, or who and how many 'hijacked' it from whom. I celebrate a spiritual holiday because that's what I understand it to be. I take offense at the consumerizing of it, but I take offense at the consumerization of life in general.
I delineate between Catholic and most other Christian denominations because the Catholic Church is in occasional, flagrant violation of Biblical teaching.
I'm nitpicky that way. ;)
I like to stir a little, too.
by nicknielsen
The Bible as we know it today was formalized by the Church in 382 CE. As many different translations as there are today, virtually every one of those contains the same books as the Vulgate, the original Latin Bible. http://www.sacred-texts.com/bib/index.htm
And you know as well as I do that Biblical "teaching" is often entirely dependent on who is reading the Bible at the time.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
that in accordance with what I read in the Bible. Not what ANY church reads in the Bible.
Which is quite to your point. ;)
by seanferd
by seanferd
It's part of the Human Condition, at least for some people.
Heck, some people are offended simply because another group exists at all. (But they act "defensive".) :0
by eyesak
This is regarding America -
Maybe the majority where you live is different.
So the Majority - Believes in Christmas.
Christmas wishes will be wished.
Nothing wrong with Happy Holidays - Just don't be too offended if someone wishes you a Merry Christmas.
Funny how Hanukkah and others don't matter - people focus on Christmas to ban - leave out.
Wonder why?
Yes the stores have rights, I support that -
But the Majority believes and Loves Christmas. A good excuse for busy adults to do random acts of kindness without being questioned - to say that they are not nice if they need an excuse is ridiculous.
Have yourself a Merry Christmas Mates and Blokes and the US, and everywhere else.
Jesus Is the reason for the season.
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_Americans_celebrate_Christmas
Majority OK with nativity scenes:
by nicknielsen
I fall in the majority that celebrates the holiday and feels that a nativity scene should be allowed as part of a holiday display, but only if symbols from other religions are also allowed.
I also happen to feel that my religious beliefs are between me and the deity of my choice, extend the same courtesy to everybody else, and expect the same in return. One of the major factors in my abandonment of organized religion was my perception that Jesus was teaching not only tolerance, but acceptance as well. I can see no other meaning in "Love thy neighbor as thyself".
by jamesrl
by ansugisalas
It was an undeniable association.
It sums up the near-psychotic short-circuited state of mind that must precede the use of that kind of PC labelling.
Exactly like old Basil... and I don't mean the hRRamster.
by maecuff
I don't care what they are called. I really don't care.
I also have no qualms about wishing people a Merry Christmas.
I don't know why people get their panties in a bunch over Christmas. Because December 25th is Christmas. It just is. That doesn't take away from any other celebrations.
Either way, I don't get offended by the whole 'holiday' thing versus 'Christmas'.
As long as I get something sparkly and my friends and family are happy and healthy..that's good enough for me.
by ansugisalas
I've sung in that choir, but I wasn't around for that recording.
Singing the Vespers was quite a rush. It was physically challenging - working the bellows at a controlled peak output for four hours - like walking uphill for four hours, minus the thin air, luckily.
Better late than never, at my age. Thank you Ansu for those selections.
I will endeavor to have them play when next at my anvil hammering work of the Lord.
by seanferd
by nicknielsen
When I was in high school, the chorus did a piece by (I think) Bortniansky that was my introduction to Russian choral music. I can't remember the name of the piece, but I can remember there were five voices: soprano, alto, tenor, baritone, and bass.
And the basses got well down under the clef.
by ansugisalas
two added lines, and only then - under - the note.
But I love it that we could make something so heavy, so massive - dance, really dance. The mountain of sound swaying, with almost giddy movement of feet - chicken legged no doubt - underneath.
Since from second grade -- age, seven?
Her mom was the school nurse. Her dad was the Music Teacher. Music was mandatory where I went. So, I am proud to say that I know what means, G-clef. Went on from there to play the French Horn, to the dismay of my family through the year of a twelve-year-olds' practice. Got that thing reasonably down with the lips and the tongue -- the, phhbbtt -- that makes the sound come out. I wanted the trumpet, but I was low boy on the totem pole, and the French Horn was all that was left.
Like the redhead girl next door, she and her dad and her mom moved next door to my house -- gadzooks! I was still too young, not to appreciate her charms, but the opportunity. She said to me one day, "You're shy, aren't you?" Stammer.
They moved away next year. I have no idea of where they went or where she is, or if she still is.
Love of my young life.
Stirrings.
by ansugisalas
The solstice can vary from the 21st into the 22nd. If you have a fixed festival then you'd set three or four days after the solstice. Might well have originally been the equivalent of the 24th. Oi! Stonehenge is reading a day fast again!
On the few days either side of the Summer of Winter solstices, the day length only changes by a few seconds per day. The Sun's altitude (in London, anyway) doesn't change measurably between the 19th and the 24th.
by nicknielsen
by ansugisalas
by jamesrl
I bought a cheap CD of various classical music and played it in the car one recent trip. It had a version of "Great Gate at Kiev" and I groaned when I heard it, as it was a solo piano instead of the full orchestra. Still it moved me - memories of playing it, 1812 Overture, Night on Bald Mountain, Sabre Dance etc as a brass player in high school.
I will be getting a "real" version for Christmas and pumping it up - for the kids education of course.
by nicknielsen
It's not on Youtube, but this one is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lP5D_g-Irxo
He uses a lot less legato than I'm used to.
Edit: Oh, very nice. The entirety is here in three (correction, four) videos. The more I listen, the more inclined I become to start looking for the CD...whoa, runaway Bydlo! :0
move north. Yep, got my directions mixed up because I was too busy trying take the mick out of the Aussies and wasn't concentrating got a bit confused.
I will go away and hide in a corner and cry myself to sleep...
:_|
by ansugisalas
The whole thing...
Somehow I'd hidden all these musical memories in a cache that now burst:
Sacre du printemps, too!
But the french have some good ones too; Bolero and Satie's quirky piano little pieces.
by ansugisalas
by nicknielsen
Sort by Trending