Discussion Locked

Christmas has been hijacked

0 helpful
237 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

237 replies

by jamesrl

But relevant to Christmas:

They said there'll be snow at Christmas
They said there'll be peace on Earth
But instead it just kept on raining
A veil of tears for the Virgin's birth
I remember one Christmas morning
A winters light and a distant choir
And the peal of a bell and that Christmas Tree smell
And their eyes full of tinsel and fire
They sold me a dream of Christmas
They sold me a Silent Night
And they told me a fairy story
'Till I believed in the Israelite
And I believed in Father Christmas
And I looked at the sky with excited eyes
'Till I woke with a yawn in the first light of dawn
And I saw him and through his disguise

I wish you a hopeful Christmas
I wish you a brave New Year
All anguish pain and sadness
Leave your heart and let your road be clear
They said there'll be snow at Christmas
They said there'll be peace on Earth
Hallelujah Noel be it Heaven or Hell
The Christmas you get you deserve.

by jardinier

but it came because several times in the past Neil has said the same thing: "Julian you're being an arse again" whenever he disagrees with or doesn't approve of my opinion.

It would not have occurred to me to make such a reply if I wasn't tired of getting this same remark from Neil.

I am also tired of him taking every opportunity to remind us he is an atheist. Who cares? I certainly don't.

And for the record, as I have said elsewhere, I am not, never have been and hopefully never will be a Christian.

by jardinier

to label this majestic oratorio an "advertising jingle."

Offensive, stupid and probably a reaction to the Christian content.

by puppybreath

You'd also find it offensive if someone heard it played on an elevator and referred to it as "elevator music"?

by nicknielsen

neil compared The Messiah specifically to Don Giovanni and Aida: two operas. He obviously thinks the operas are of much higher quality than The Messiah. I'm not a fan of opera, so I disagree.

And if you look at Handel's history, you may find calling him the Billy Davis of his day is a valid comparison.

by Member 25348569

I used a LOT of hyperbole to make my point.

Really, I think that Messiah is a fine piece of music but it is one where few could - or would want to - whistle anything other than the Hallelujah Chorus.

:)

by jardinier

I could be called a partial hypocrite myself. I was forgetting how far, over the years, I have drifted away from mainstream Christian doctrine.

While I have never considered myself a Christian in the sense of accepting that Christ died for my sins, I did accept the general package.

I do believe Jesus was a messiah of some kind -- undoubtedly the most significant since Gautama Buddha sat under the bodhi tree.

However as I was listening to the Hallelujah Chorus last night, I realized I was quite skeptical about certain claims of Christianity.

by jardinier

is not a major element in Western music and I am not sure that it is included in liturgical music at all.

Western music has evolved because of Christianity. Even jazz was a spin-off from negro spirituals.

I don't need to tell you the stages in the evolution of Western classical music. No Christianity and we would still be singing folk songs.

by jardinier

Firstly, as stated elsewhere, I do not call myself a Christian. Secondly, I am not a homophobe.

[i]"your continually stated disinterest in people of alternate or no chosen faith."[/i]

I don't know where you got those ideas. I am always in trouble at Christian websites for saying good things about other religions, especially Eastern religions. At various times on census forms I have stated as my religion: "Hindu" or "Taoist."

I have nothing against atheists but I tire of those who make a religion of their belief and never miss an opportunity to remind me (us).

There are many, many atheists who get on with their lives quietly without blowing their atheist trumpet all the time.

by Member 25348569

What I believe, I worked out all on my own.

However, I visited the site to see what was there. It's difficult for me to get excited about it because my take on the Bible is that it is myth, oral history, dietary advice, moral tales and so on all wrapped up into something that many people take far, far too seriously. So, unless I want to particularly argue with Christians, I care not one jot for contradictions in the Bible.

And I don't. I don't NEED to argue religion and I rarely do unless someone starts it.

In the case of this thread, I was happy posting Christmas music until some Aussie Arse piped up with "I would consider it hypocritical for an atheist to declare a liking for this kind of music and at the same time deny the existence of God."

Couldn't let that go, now, could I - you got right in my face. Especially when it was such an IDIOT statement - something recognised by every other poster as well.

As I've said before, don't prod and I won't rip your arm off.

:)

by Member 25348569

and a perfect example of why I find you a pain in these discussions.

Put simply, had there been no Christianity, we have absolutely NO IDEA how the world would be different to what we have today with regards to music or anything else. The key word is "different". No implication on MY part as to whether the world - of music or anything else - would be better or worse without religion. Still, it's the 30th anniversary of the murder of John Lennon so I can "Imagine".

Think outside your little box. Even the word "music" is of Greek origins and pre-dates Christianity.

by jamesrl

And that is from a person who conducted church choirs for years. Me.

Percussion is not a major element of Western Music? Balderdash. Shear ignorance. Almost every church I've ever been to has a percussion instrument that gets used frequently. Its called a PIANO. And even before the piano became popular, tambourines and other drums were used in carolling.

And while any musicologist would agree that Western music has been heavily influenced by the developments of church music, that does mean that there were no other forms of western music, opera, folk music, work songs all of which contributed to what we have today.

For all your hanging around Christians and other spiritual people you haven't learned humuility.

by nicknielsen

[i]I am also tired of him taking every opportunity to remind us he is an atheist. Who cares? I certainly don't.[/i]

Your very first post in this discussion, Thanks Max, and the others who have posted videos, contains the "hypocrite" statement.

[u]You[/u] are the one who fired the first shot in this exchange; at what point prior to that was anybody in your face? And now you want to be a WATB about it?

I'm starting to agree with neil...

by puppybreath

T'was the nocturnal segment of the diurnal period preceding the annual Yuletide celebration, and throughout our place of residence, kinetic energy was not in evidence among the possessors of this potential, including that species of domestic rodent known as Mus Musculus.

Hosiery was meticulously suspended from the forward edge of the wood burning caloric apparatus, pursuant to our anticipatory pleasure regarding an imminent visitation from an eccentric philanthropist among whose folkloric appellations is the honorific St. Nicholas.

The prepubescent siblings, comfortably ensconced in their respective accommodations of repose, were experiencing subconscious visual hallucinations of variegated fruit confections moving rhythmically through their cerebrums.

My conjugal partner and I, attired in our nocturnal head coverings, were about to take slumberous advantage of the hibernal darkness, when upon the arenaceous exterior portion of the grounds there ascended such a cacophony of dissonance, that I felt compelled to arise with alacrity from my place of repose for the purpose of ascertaining the precise source thereof.

Hastening to the casement, I forthwith opened the barriers sealing this fenestration, noting thereupon that the lunar brilliance without, reflected as it was on the surface of a recent crystalline precipitation, might be said to rival that of the solar meridian itself -- thus permitting my incredulous optical sensory organs to behold a miniature airborne runnered conveyance drawn by eight diminutive specimens of the genus Rangifer, piloted by a minuscule, aged chauffeur so ebullient and nimble it became instantly apparent to me that he was our anticipated caller.

With his ungulate motive power traveling at what may possibly have been more vertiginous velocity than patriotic acclaim predicates, he vociferated loudly, expelled breath musically through contracted labia, and addressed each of the octet by his or her respective cognomen -- "On Dasher, on Prancer....." et al. -- guiding them to the uppermost exterior level of our abode, through which structure I could readily distinguish the concatenations of each of the 32 cloven pedal extremities.

As I retracted my cranium from its erstwhile location, and was performing a 180 degree pivot, our distinguished visitant achieved, with utmost celerity and via a downward leap, entry by way of the smoke passage.

He was clad entirely in animal pelts soiled by the ebony residue from oxidations of carboniferous fuels, which had accumulated on the walls of said pathway. His resemblance to a street vendor I attributed largely to the plethora of assorted playthings, which he bore dorsally in a commodious cloth receptacle.

His visual input centers were scintillating with the reflected luminosity, while his submaxillary indentations gave every evidence of engaging amiability. The capillaries of his malar regions and nasal appurtenance were engorged with blood which suffused the subcutaneous layers, the former approximating the coloration of albino's floral emblem, the latter that of the Prunus Avium, or sweet cherry. His amusing sub- and supra- labials resembled nothing so much as a loop knot, and their ambient hirsute facial adornment appeared like small tabular, and columnar crystals of frozen water.

Clenched firmly between his incisors was a smoking piece whose gray fumes, forming a tenuous ellipse about his occiput, were suggestive of a decorative seasonal circlet of holly. His visage was wider than it was high, and when he waxed audibly mirthful, his corpulent abdominal region undulated in the manner of impected fruit syrup in a hemispherical container.

He was, in short, neither more nor less than an obese, jocund, multigeniarian gnome, the optical perception of whom rendered me visibly frolicsome despite every effort to refrain from so being. By swiftly lowering, then elevating one eyelid and rotating his cranium slightly to one side, he indicated that trepidation on my part was groundless.

Without utterance and with dispatch, he commenced filling the aforementioned hosiery from that dorsally transported woven container. Upon completion of this task, he executed an about-face, placed a single manual digit in lateral juxtaposition to his olfactory organ, inclined his cranium forward in a gesture of leave-taking, and forthwith effected his egress by renegotiating(in reverse) the smoke passage.

He then propelled himself in a short vector onto his conveyance, directed a musical expulsion of air through his contracted oral sphincter to the antlered quadrupeds of burden, and proceeded to soar aloft in a movement heretofore observable chiefly among the seed bearing portions of a common weed.

But I overheard his vocalization beyond the limits of visibility: "Ecstatic Yuletide to the planetary constituency, and to the selfsame assemblage, my sincerest wishes for a salubrious, beneficial, and gratifying, pleasurable period between sunset and the dawn.!"

by netman1958

'Twas the night before Christmas,
And all through the house,
No food was a-stirrin',
Not even a mouse.

Stockings were hung round
Dad's nick like a tie,
Along with a note that said,
"Presents or die."

Children were plotting
All night in their beds,
While the wife's constant whining
Was splitting his head.

But daddy had money
This year in the bank,
Then they closed up early,
And now dad's in a tank.

All of a sudden,
Santa appeared,
A sneer on his face,
Booze in his beard.

"Santa," I said,
As he laughed merrily,
"You do so much for others,
Do something for me."

"Bundy," he said,
"You only sell shoes,
Your son is a sneak thief,
Your daughter's a flooze."

"Ho ho," Santa said,
"Should I mention your wife?
Her hair's like an A-bomb,
Her nails like a knife."

He climbs up the chimney,
That fat piece of dung,
He mooned me two times,
He stuck out his tongue.

I heard him exclaim,
As he broke wind with glee,
"You're married with children,
You'll never be free."

by nicknielsen

This is the lawyer's version:

The Night Before Christmas...Legally Speaking

Whereas, on or about the night prior to Christmas, there did occur at a certain improved piece of real property (hereinafter "the House") a general lack of stirring by all creatures therein, including, but not limited to a mouse.

A variety of foot apparel, e.g., stocking, socks, etc., had been affixed by and around the chimney in said House in the hope and/or belief that St. Nick AKA/St. Nicholas AKA/Santa Claus (hereinafter "Claus") would arrive at sometime thereafter.

The minor residents, i.e., the children, of the aforementioned House were located in their individual beds and were engaged in nocturnal hallucinations, i.e., dreams, wherein visions of confectionery treats, including, but not limited to, candies, nuts and/or sugar plums, did dance, cavort and otherwise appear in said dreams.

Whereupon the party of the first part (sometimes hereinafter referred to as "I"), being the joint-owner in fee simple of the House with the party of the second part (hereinafter "Mamma"), and said Mamma had retired for a sustained period of sleep. (At such time, the parties were clad in various forms of headgear, e.g., kerchief and cap.)

Suddenly, and without prior notice or warning, there did occur upon the unimproved real property adjacent and appurtenant to said House, i.e., the lawn, a certain disruption of unknown nature, cause and/or circumstance. The party of the first part did immediately rush to a window in the House to investigate the cause of such disturbance.

At that time, the party of the first part did observe, with some degree of wonder and/or disbelief, a miniature sleigh (hereinafter "the Vehicle") being pulled and/or drawn very rapidly through the air by approximately eight (8) reindeer. The driver of the Vehicle appeared to be and in fact was, the previously referenced Claus.

Said Claus was providing specific direction, instruction and guidance to the approximately eight (8) reindeer and specifically identified the animal co-conspirators by name: Dasher, Dancer, Prancer, Vixen, Comet, Cupid, Donner and Blitzen (hereinafter "the Deer"). (Upon information and belief, it is further asserted that an additional coconspirator named "Rudolph" may have been involved.)

The party of the first part witnessed Claus, the Vehicle and the Deer intentionally and willfully trespass upon the roofs of several residences located adjacent to and in the vicinity of the House, and noted that the Vehicle was heavily laden with packages, toys and other items of unknown origin or nature. Suddenly, without prior invitation or permission, either express or implied, the Vehicle arrived at the House, and Claus entered said House via the chimney.

Said Claus was clad in a red fur suit, which was partially covered with residue from the chimney, and he carried a large sack containing a portion of the aforementioned packages, toys, and other unknown items. He was smoking what appeared to be tobacco in a small pipe in blatant violation of local ordinances and health regulations.

Claus did not speak, but immediately began to fill the stocking of the minor children, which hung adjacent to the chimney, with toys and other small gifts. (Said items did not, however, constitute "gifts" to said minors pursuant to the applicable provisions of the US Tax Code.)

Upon completion of such task, Claus touched the side of his nose and flew, rose and/or ascended up the chimney of the House to the roof where the Vehicle and Deer waited and/or served as "lookouts." Claus immediately departed for an unknown destination.

However, prior to the departure of the Vehicle, Deer and Claus from said House, the party of the first part did hear Claus state and/or exclaim:
"Merry Christmas to all and to all a good night!"
Or words to that effect.

by nicknielsen

:D

And sing along as best I can on all the choruses. My favorite part of the whole has always been the first half of Part Two. The Hallelujah Chorus is a majestic piece of music, but I like these choruses more:

- Behold the Lamb of God
- Surely He hath borne our griefs
- And with His stripes
- All we, like sheep,
- He trusted in God

I think it's the minor keys...although when I was younger, it could have been the message.

by jamesrl

As a majestic chorus, I prefer "Worthy is the lamb".

Some of my favorite moments are not the choruses but the solos. The duet "He shall feed his flock" is often touching.

As a singer, and I know others feel this way, the Halleljah chorus is "too" familiar. Its often done as a highlight at Christmas even when you aren't doing the whole Messiah, brought out as an encore etc.

by ansugisalas

I think it's probably empowering to hear the "and we like sheep" chorus... not alone, then in spirit ;) :p

by nexs

And we can only hope that racism can be defeated, or at least down to a manageable level.

I've always thought of Melbourne as the multicultural capital of the world. In fact, as kids, a friend and I would travel to Melbourne and play 'Spot The Aussie'. We'd lose, of course.
But despite that, and I say this purely as information, I have met only a handful of Aborigines who place themselves above the racism.
Now I know that there's more out there, and I'd love to meet them, I just haven't met many.

by vuture

The history of Christmas is long. So long, in fact, that much mythology and legend surrounding the holiday. The way we celebrate Christmas in America is less than 200 years old. In fact, it is closer to 150. We borrowed much of the traditions we have from numerous cultures that immigrated here from other countries since the United States was born. Before that, December 25th was a church calendar day that celebrated the birth of Jesus Christ. No trees. No presents. No cards. No garland. No Santa Claus. No reindeer. No ho! ho! ho!
It had been that way, pretty much since around the 3rd century when the very young catholic church was forming in several parts of the world. The church that was located in Rome was called the Roman Catholic church (catholic meaning "universal") To ease the conversion of the pagan Romans that believed in multiple dieties like Jupiter, Neptune, Venus, Apollo and others, the church at Rome chose saints and figures of the biblical stories as proxies for the Roman dieties. One such diety was Saturn, the god of agriculture and the harvest. His Roman holiday is Saturnalia which was celebrated around the winter solstice (on or about Dec. 21st). This is it the holiday the church at Rome chose to celebrate the birth of Christ because it was an easy substitute. The great majority of modern scholars agree Jesus of Nazareth was born sometime in the spring, probably April. But when you need converts and in Rome, do as the Romans do. The day stuck and now we celebrate Christ's birthday on December 25th. We put up Christmas trees but no one really knows why. We hand garland and mistletoe though no one can explain where the idea came from. They are just traditions. The message of Christmas is "Peace on Earth. Goodwill toward men." If we remember that, it doesn't matter what religion it represents or where it came from. Its meaning and message are universal. Be kind and good towards one another and treat others as you would have them treat you. Too bad so many get hung up in semantics and religious dogmas and political correctness to overlook that. Because I don't care what you say or how many times you say it. If your actions don't back up the words, then the words are meaningless.

by rayray247

Christ mas is my least favorite holiday because all it is, is a whole bunch of little greedy kids wanting everything in the world and when i was a kid i got mostly all clothes and i think some familys need to consider no gifts this year and spending time with the family!

by eyesak

Catch the Christmas Spirit.

There will be greedy kids, if their parent or parents teach them those sort of values, whether or not people celebrate Christmas.

The poor and the needy will receive food, presents, blankets etc.

I like to think of that side of Christmas,
and families gathering together and sharing themselves with each other and food and Love.

Yes children will be glad to get gifts, it is an exiting time for many of them!

Others will be mad because the are unsatisfied - that is typical of people.
Still others in need will feel left out, lets give to some of those and teach our children to do the same!

I was always excited to get new clothes on Christmas, and a toy or two, we did not get that much, but still we had a joyous time.

I understand the sentiment, there are many children who get too many things but not enough Love. Some kids may not need much, but just a little something would be nice, otherwise they will feel left out.

I will give both gifts and Love.

Join in on the fun - join in on the celebration!

I think it is safe to wish Jesus an happy birthday any day even it the date is wrong, since there are too many theories to worry about.

The main thing is being thankful that Jesus was born to teach and to sacrifice himself for whosoever will believe and accept him as God in the flesh.

If you don't believe that, then no one will sue you for celebrating or not.

As for my family we will celebrate!

by stephen.johansen

I agree that those who get offended by Christmas, don't celebrate. Those who have other religions then celebrate them. But don't stuff with our Christmas. I'm no Christian but Christmas is still a special time for us. Don't deny us our holidays cause it doesn't fit in with yours. P.S. This is not directed at anyone specifically so if you winge then I really don't care. MERRY CHRISTMAS ALL

This discussion is closed to new replies.