CodeWarriorz Thoughts
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
After Hours
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
CNN) -- Time Inc. announced Thursday it will turn over the subpoenaed records from journalist Matt Cooper regarding the leak of a CIA operative's name, following a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court not to hear an appeal in the case.
Cooper, Time's White House correspondent, and New York Times reporter Judith Miller are facing up to four months in jail for refusing to reveal their confidential sources in the matter to a grand jury.
Chicago Sun-Times columnist and CNN political analyst Bob Novak was the first to reveal the CIA employee's identity and CNN's Ed Henry spoke with Novak Wednesday about the ruling.
ED HENRY: Bob, first, what's your reaction to the Supreme Court saying they would not hear this case?
BOB NOVAK: Well, I deplore the thought of reporters -- I've been a reporter all my life -- going to jail for any period of time for not revealing sources, and there needs to be a federal shield law preventing that as there are shield laws in 49 out of 50 states. But, Ed, I -- my lawyer said I cannot answer any specific questions about this case until it is resolved, which I hope is very soon.
HENRY: In general, though, you believe in the principle of keeping the identity secret of confidential sources. Have you ever revealed the identity of one of your confidential sources?
NOVAK: Well, people know -- who have read my column know there have been special case[s] where I have. But the question of being coerced to by the government and being put in prison is, I think, something that should be protected by act of Congress.
HENRY: In general, have you cooperated with investigators in this case?
NOVAK: I can't answer any questions about this case at all.
HENRY: OK. Now, just in general about the principle at stake here -- William Safire, fellow conservative, wrote an op-ed in The New York Times saying that at the very least, he believes that you owe your readers, and in this case, your viewers, some explanation. He said, "Mr. Novak should finally write the column he owes readers and colleagues perhaps explaining how his two sources, who may have truthfully revealed themselves to investigators, managed to get the prosecutor off his back." I think that's the question. Why sit that there are two reporters out there who may go to jail, Bob, but it doesn't appear that you are going to go to jail?
NOVAK: Well, that's what I can't reveal until this case is finished. I hope it is finished soon. And when it does, I agree with Mr. Safire, I will reveal all in a column and on the air.
HENRY: Do you understand why in general there's frustration among fellow journalist[s] after 41 years of distinguished work, where you've always pushed and been a fierce advocate of the public's right to know, you're not letting the public know about such a critical case, and two people may go to jail.
NOVAK: Well, they are not going to jail because of me. Whether I answer your questions or not, it has nothing to do with that. That's very ridiculous to think that I am the cause of their going to jail. I don't think they should be going to jail.
HENRY: Yes. But I didn't say you were the cause. But there are some people...
NOVAK: Yes, you do did.
HENRY: No, but some people feel if you would come forward with the information that you have, that maybe they would not go to jail.
NOVAK: But you don't know -- Ed, you don't know anything about the case. And those people who say that don't know anything about the case. And unfortunately, as somebody who likes to write, I'd like to say a lot about the case, but because of my attorney's advice I can't. But I will. And there might be some surprising things.
HENRY: We'll all be waiting to hear that story finally told, Bob.
==========SNIP======================
I personally believe NOVAK should be on trial...after all,
he was the rotten, slime covered pipe from which the information first leaked apparently from the article...
PUT NOVAK ON TRIAL!
CNN) -- Time Inc. announced Thursday it will turn over the subpoenaed records from journalist Matt Cooper regarding the leak of a CIA operative's name, following a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court not to hear an appeal in the case.
Cooper, Time's White House correspondent, and New York Times reporter Judith Miller are facing up to four months in jail for refusing to reveal their confidential sources in the matter to a grand jury.
Chicago Sun-Times columnist and CNN political analyst Bob Novak was the first to reveal the CIA employee's identity and CNN's Ed Henry spoke with Novak Wednesday about the ruling.
ED HENRY: Bob, first, what's your reaction to the Supreme Court saying they would not hear this case?
BOB NOVAK: Well, I deplore the thought of reporters -- I've been a reporter all my life -- going to jail for any period of time for not revealing sources, and there needs to be a federal shield law preventing that as there are shield laws in 49 out of 50 states. But, Ed, I -- my lawyer said I cannot answer any specific questions about this case until it is resolved, which I hope is very soon.
HENRY: In general, though, you believe in the principle of keeping the identity secret of confidential sources. Have you ever revealed the identity of one of your confidential sources?
NOVAK: Well, people know -- who have read my column know there have been special case[s] where I have. But the question of being coerced to by the government and being put in prison is, I think, something that should be protected by act of Congress.
HENRY: In general, have you cooperated with investigators in this case?
NOVAK: I can't answer any questions about this case at all.
HENRY: OK. Now, just in general about the principle at stake here -- William Safire, fellow conservative, wrote an op-ed in The New York Times saying that at the very least, he believes that you owe your readers, and in this case, your viewers, some explanation. He said, "Mr. Novak should finally write the column he owes readers and colleagues perhaps explaining how his two sources, who may have truthfully revealed themselves to investigators, managed to get the prosecutor off his back." I think that's the question. Why sit that there are two reporters out there who may go to jail, Bob, but it doesn't appear that you are going to go to jail?
NOVAK: Well, that's what I can't reveal until this case is finished. I hope it is finished soon. And when it does, I agree with Mr. Safire, I will reveal all in a column and on the air.
HENRY: Do you understand why in general there's frustration among fellow journalist[s] after 41 years of distinguished work, where you've always pushed and been a fierce advocate of the public's right to know, you're not letting the public know about such a critical case, and two people may go to jail.
NOVAK: Well, they are not going to jail because of me. Whether I answer your questions or not, it has nothing to do with that. That's very ridiculous to think that I am the cause of their going to jail. I don't think they should be going to jail.
HENRY: Yes. But I didn't say you were the cause. But there are some people...
NOVAK: Yes, you do did.
HENRY: No, but some people feel if you would come forward with the information that you have, that maybe they would not go to jail.
NOVAK: But you don't know -- Ed, you don't know anything about the case. And those people who say that don't know anything about the case. And unfortunately, as somebody who likes to write, I'd like to say a lot about the case, but because of my attorney's advice I can't. But I will. And there might be some surprising things.
HENRY: We'll all be waiting to hear that story finally told, Bob.
==========SNIP======================
I personally believe NOVAK should be on trial...after all,
he was the rotten, slime covered pipe from which the information first leaked apparently from the article...
PUT NOVAK ON TRIAL!
CNN) -- Time Inc. announced Thursday it will turn over the subpoenaed records from journalist Matt Cooper regarding the leak of a CIA operative's name, following a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court not to hear an appeal in the case.
Cooper, Time's White House correspondent, and New York Times reporter Judith Miller are facing up to four months in jail for refusing to reveal their confidential sources in the matter to a grand jury.
Chicago Sun-Times columnist and CNN political analyst Bob Novak was the first to reveal the CIA employee's identity and CNN's Ed Henry spoke with Novak Wednesday about the ruling.
ED HENRY: Bob, first, what's your reaction to the Supreme Court saying they would not hear this case?
BOB NOVAK: Well, I deplore the thought of reporters -- I've been a reporter all my life -- going to jail for any period of time for not revealing sources, and there needs to be a federal shield law preventing that as there are shield laws in 49 out of 50 states. But, Ed, I -- my lawyer said I cannot answer any specific questions about this case until it is resolved, which I hope is very soon.
HENRY: In general, though, you believe in the principle of keeping the identity secret of confidential sources. Have you ever revealed the identity of one of your confidential sources?
NOVAK: Well, people know -- who have read my column know there have been special case[s] where I have. But the question of being coerced to by the government and being put in prison is, I think, something that should be protected by act of Congress.
HENRY: In general, have you cooperated with investigators in this case?
NOVAK: I can't answer any questions about this case at all.
HENRY: OK. Now, just in general about the principle at stake here -- William Safire, fellow conservative, wrote an op-ed in The New York Times saying that at the very least, he believes that you owe your readers, and in this case, your viewers, some explanation. He said, "Mr. Novak should finally write the column he owes readers and colleagues perhaps explaining how his two sources, who may have truthfully revealed themselves to investigators, managed to get the prosecutor off his back." I think that's the question. Why sit that there are two reporters out there who may go to jail, Bob, but it doesn't appear that you are going to go to jail?
NOVAK: Well, that's what I can't reveal until this case is finished. I hope it is finished soon. And when it does, I agree with Mr. Safire, I will reveal all in a column and on the air.
HENRY: Do you understand why in general there's frustration among fellow journalist[s] after 41 years of distinguished work, where you've always pushed and been a fierce advocate of the public's right to know, you're not letting the public know about such a critical case, and two people may go to jail.
NOVAK: Well, they are not going to jail because of me. Whether I answer your questions or not, it has nothing to do with that. That's very ridiculous to think that I am the cause of their going to jail. I don't think they should be going to jail.
HENRY: Yes. But I didn't say you were the cause. But there are some people...
NOVAK: Yes, you do did.
HENRY: No, but some people feel if you would come forward with the information that you have, that maybe they would not go to jail.
NOVAK: But you don't know -- Ed, you don't know anything about the case. And those people who say that don't know anything about the case. And unfortunately, as somebody who likes to write, I'd like to say a lot about the case, but because of my attorney's advice I can't. But I will. And there might be some surprising things.
HENRY: We'll all be waiting to hear that story finally told, Bob.
==========SNIP======================
I personally believe NOVAK should be on trial...after all,
he was the rotten, slime covered pipe from which the information first leaked apparently from the article...
PUT NOVAK ON TRIAL!
CNN) -- Time Inc. announced Thursday it will turn over the subpoenaed records from journalist Matt Cooper regarding the leak of a CIA operative's name, following a decision by the U.S. Supreme Court not to hear an appeal in the case.
Cooper, Time's White House correspondent, and New York Times reporter Judith Miller are facing up to four months in jail for refusing to reveal their confidential sources in the matter to a grand jury.
Chicago Sun-Times columnist and CNN political analyst Bob Novak was the first to reveal the CIA employee's identity and CNN's Ed Henry spoke with Novak Wednesday about the ruling.
ED HENRY: Bob, first, what's your reaction to the Supreme Court saying they would not hear this case?
BOB NOVAK: Well, I deplore the thought of reporters -- I've been a reporter all my life -- going to jail for any period of time for not revealing sources, and there needs to be a federal shield law preventing that as there are shield laws in 49 out of 50 states. But, Ed, I -- my lawyer said I cannot answer any specific questions about this case until it is resolved, which I hope is very soon.
HENRY: In general, though, you believe in the principle of keeping the identity secret of confidential sources. Have you ever revealed the identity of one of your confidential sources?
NOVAK: Well, people know -- who have read my column know there have been special case[s] where I have. But the question of being coerced to by the government and being put in prison is, I think, something that should be protected by act of Congress.
HENRY: In general, have you cooperated with investigators in this case?
NOVAK: I can't answer any questions about this case at all.
HENRY: OK. Now, just in general about the principle at stake here -- William Safire, fellow conservative, wrote an op-ed in The New York Times saying that at the very least, he believes that you owe your readers, and in this case, your viewers, some explanation. He said, "Mr. Novak should finally write the column he owes readers and colleagues perhaps explaining how his two sources, who may have truthfully revealed themselves to investigators, managed to get the prosecutor off his back." I think that's the question. Why sit that there are two reporters out there who may go to jail, Bob, but it doesn't appear that you are going to go to jail?
NOVAK: Well, that's what I can't reveal until this case is finished. I hope it is finished soon. And when it does, I agree with Mr. Safire, I will reveal all in a column and on the air.
HENRY: Do you understand why in general there's frustration among fellow journalist[s] after 41 years of distinguished work, where you've always pushed and been a fierce advocate of the public's right to know, you're not letting the public know about such a critical case, and two people may go to jail.
NOVAK: Well, they are not going to jail because of me. Whether I answer your questions or not, it has nothing to do with that. That's very ridiculous to think that I am the cause of their going to jail. I don't think they should be going to jail.
HENRY: Yes. But I didn't say you were the cause. But there are some people...
NOVAK: Yes, you do did.
HENRY: No, but some people feel if you would come forward with the information that you have, that maybe they would not go to jail.
NOVAK: But you don't know -- Ed, you don't know anything about the case. And those people who say that don't know anything about the case. And unfortunately, as somebody who likes to write, I'd like to say a lot about the case, but because of my attorney's advice I can't. But I will. And there might be some surprising things.
HENRY: We'll all be waiting to hear that story finally told, Bob.
==========SNIP======================
I personally believe NOVAK should be on trial...after all,
he was the rotten, slime covered pipe from which the information first leaked apparently from the article...
PUT NOVAK ON TRIAL!
Brent Bozell: Penn and Teller trash Mother Teresa
Penn and Teller trash Mother Teresa
Brent Bozell (archive)
June 3, 2005 | Print | Send
A year ago, I attended the Viacom shareholders meeting in New York. When an investor questioned the propriety of this media behemoth launching a gay cable television network, Chairman Sumner Redstone virtually leapt at the opportunity to defend Viacom's commitment to tolerance and diversity.
But not for Catholics. Viacom has no problem whatever insulting Catholics.
The Catholic League's William Donohue is America's leading watchdog of all things anti-Catholic in the media and the culture. In 12 years at the helm he's seen a lot of bashing and trashing and believes there's been nothing as outrageous as the May 23 edition of the professional magician duo Penn and Teller's aptly titled show "B.S." [spelled out] on Viacom's pay-cable channel Showtime.
While the episode titled "Holier Than Thou" ends with a few smacks at Mahatma Gandhi and the Dalai Lama, Penn Jillette mostly savaged the world's most beloved woman of the 20th century by Catholics and non-Catholics alike. The woman beatified by Pope John Paul II and surely to be declared a saint was known as Mother Teresa. On this Viacom/Showtime program she is called "Mother F---ing Teresa."
The show features notoriously vicious anti-Catholics like Christopher Hitchens and Aroup Chatterjee. Viewers are told that she intentionally let the poor suffer, providing neither beds nor bathroom facilities. "She had the f---king coin and pissed it away on nunneries," says Penn Jillette.
Donohue said it did not bother him they called him "Catholic Boy" on the show, and not even when they referred to him with the F word since he could "only see good in her." But when they mocked the Catholic Church's teaching on the meaning of suffering; when the nuns who worked with Mother Teresa in the Missionaries of Charity were referred to with the F-word and the offensive C-word for female genitalia; and when they said of the poor that "They had to suffer so that Mother [F-word] Teresa could be enlightened," he protested. "They are behaved like monsters ... It turned into hate speech."
This anti-Catholicism is no accident. The Showtime website actually boasts about the aching anti-religious bigotry behind the show. "By their own admission, Penn & Teller have been dying to do a show like this. Confirmed skeptics and pro-science atheists (they call God an 'imaginary friend'), these magicians are big fans of the art of debunking." The Showtime booster copy continues: "As our increasingly anti-intellectual, anti-science culture moves on each day to new crackpot subject matters, Penn & Teller are there to aggressively shoot down whack-jobs and fuzzy thinkers, no matter where they originate."
Isn't Showtime a piece of work? This junkyard of "edgy" programming was the final resting place of "The Reagans," the canceled CBS TV-movie making up vile charges against a man on his deathbed. It has two regular dramatic series celebrating the gay lifestyle, "Queer as Folk" for the men, and "The L Word" for the women. It recently began airing the original movie "Our Fathers," a movie on the Boston pedophile-priest scandals, which even the Washington Post called "Showtime's Unholy Mess." Four years ago at this time, Showtime was airing the original film "Sister Mary Explains It All," starring Diane Keaton as a vicious nun who ruined the lives of schoolchildren.
Now it has the two smart-aleck magicians reviling, with F bombs, the holiest women walking the face of the Earth while attacking the entire concept of holiness as a racket for "whack jobs and fuzzy thinkers."
The Catholic League protested outside this year's shareholders meeting of Viacom in New York, but tight-lipped Showtime could only remark on this inflammatory show by patting itself on the back as a haven for free speech. They claim they're "in the unique position to give artists the creative freedom to express their views," unlike other broadcast and cable networks who avoid "controversial subject matter." Sadly, and predictably, the TV writers who've happened upon the Penn and Teller show haven't exactly criticized their shtick. Associated Press reporter Frazier Moore praised the duo as "sassy secularists in a priesthood of knaves."
Didn't anyone involved in the making of this trash -- the writers, director, producers and the like -- see the wretched ugliness of the product? What of the Showtime front office -- the programming executives, the public relations/marketing staff? In fact, they all saw it and approved it. What of the Viacom leadership, the board of directors? One presumes they didn't see it, so busy are they giving speeches about corporate commitments to diversity and tolerance.
Brent Bozell is President of Media Research Center, a Townhall.com member group.
==========-SNIP-==========
Penn Jillette is an ASSHOLE as are the other atheists at the Skeptical Inquirer
USE OF FORCE CONTINUUM
This Use of Force Continuum is from the Alaska State Troopers
The court case is just one of many
to demonstrate what I proffer is true.
What people are not understanding is that the police, firemen, FBI, ect are all members of a paramilitary organization(s) They have been militarized and not not civil officers to which they appear to want us to believe they are. Ask them? I have the commissioning documents on the AST, but this is not included as yahoo will not pass all of the info in one post. If wanted, e-mail and I will forward.
They use the Use of Force Continuum against us. All Police Force types will have a policy and procedures manual, which will have a Use of Force Continuum contained within. You may have to lean on them to produce the Use of Force Continuum parts, as they don't want the public to know who they are and what they are doing.
FROM Alaska State Troopers Use of Force Continuum parts:
1. First read the 107.101 intent of the disclaimer as evidence.
2. 107.020 (A)(1) the purpose of the use of the force is to gain control of a person, ect.
3. 107.020 (B), when practical, a verbal warning should be used before force is being used.
4. 107.020 (C)(1) Can't use force as punishment or retaliation.
5. 107.020 (C)(2) Accomplish the officers "lawful" objectives, etc including physical control.
6. 107.020 (C)(3) can use any level of force
7. 107.020 (C)(4) The Use of Force Continuum
a. Officer presence, uniform
b. Verbal Commands [military orders in reality]
c. Soft hand techniques - grabbing you and a heel hand hit.
d. OC - pepper spray [you will got to jail if they use this]
e. Batons
f. TAZARS
g. Deadly force
8. 107.030 A use of Force Form just be filled out. Ask for it!
So what is happening when a police officer walks up to your car window with his traffic lights flashing or walks up to you in the street.
First he is ALWAYS USING FORCE against you to gain control of YOU and to conduct an custodial interrogation[investigation] and he is instilling FEAR!
Should you not be in FEAR of your LIFE knowing of the Use of Force Continuum that the OFFICER is using, is trained to use, and will not stop until [continuum] YOU SUBMIT while he is carrying weapons of deadly force, OC, and TZAR's to use at his discretion as long as he justifies said use to HIS leaders and the DA?
You can use the am I under arrest, am I free to go and are you conducting a custodial interrogation to invoke your Constitutional secured rights.
After that is accomplished, I would clearly use the words similar to "I am in fear of my life, as I know you have been trained in the use of deadly force and you are now using the Use of Force Continuum and to what ends, I do not know. I see [or suspect] that you have a loaded weapon, OC [pepper spray], a TAZAR and who knows what else upon your person at this time. Is that correct Sir?
Because I am in in Fear of my Life, I, John Doe, under the laws of necessity am giving you some identification. Otherwise, stand upon you constitutional rights, unless your safety or whatever becomes an issue. Being dead or injured, does not justify being right. Live to fight another day.
This should then disable all evidence that could be used against you in any future Complaint or whatever.
But also, if you have demanded Assistance of Counsel, the cop should then be liable to a law suit if he continues, which most of them will. He violated your constitutionally secured right and did not have jurisdiction to proceed. This last part of jurisdiction to proceed, I will be researching out in the near future to validate if true, i.e. exceeded his authority.
To further validate that the Police are Military, we find in the Alaska Statutes the following:
AS 18.65.110 Members not to interfere with rights and property.
Members of the state troopers may not interfere with the rights or property of any person except in a lawful manner necessary for the prevention of crime or the capture and arrest of an offender.
The troopers can not even arrest. They must capture and arrest! Capture means taking by military power, then arrest (civil side). See United States v. Athens Armory, 24 F.Cas. 878, 880 (1868)
Alaska Department of Public Safety Operating Procedures Manual Use of Force
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is a case from New York explaining the use of force by police.
Police use of Taser is cut
By John Steele
(Filed: 04/07/2005)
Taser stun guns are "too dangerous" to be handed out to all patrolling police officers, a Home Office minister has said.
Despite police support for issuing them more widely, Hazel Blears said that Tasers, which deliver a 50,000-volt shock to disable their targets, were not appropriate for "everyday circumstances".
At present only authorised firearms officers are allowed to use Tasers. But a poll at the Police Federation's recent annual conference suggested a large majority favoured giving them to all operational officers.
"Taser is quite a dangerous weapon," Miss Blears told Police Review magazine. "It is substantially different from handcuffs and a truncheon, and I would not want to see everyone on the streets having that kind of weapon."
Taser Manufacturer Sues USA Today
July 3, 2005 11:35 a.m. EST
Christina Ficara - All Headline News Staff Reporter
SCOTTSDALE, AZ (AHN) - Taser Internationl Inc., the manufacturing company of the controversal stun gun, announced Friday it filed a libel lawsuit against USA Today publisher Gannett Co. for misleading readers about their products' safety.Taser, which has been under scrutiny over the safety of its stun guns, said it filed suit in Arizona Superior Court accusing Gannett of libel, false light invasion of privacy, injurious falsehood and tortious interference with business relations. The lawsuit is in response to a June 3 USA Today article, which Taser believes overstated the level of electrical output of one of Taser's stun guns. According to Taser, the newspaper "further sensationalized" the story with photographic comparisons of the power of the Taser gun with the electrical output of an electric chair, a lightning storm and an electric train track. The article reported the electrical output of the gun was more than 100 times that of the electric chair, when in fact the average electrical current of Taser guns is 1,000 times less than that of an electric chair, refutes Taser.
Representatives from Gannett Co. have not commented on the allegations.
Buffalo News - Ontario death raises questionNiagara Regional Police are attempting to determine whether a 50,000-volt Taser stun gun caused the death of a 39-year-old burglary suspect in Beamsville, Ont.
The death of James Foldi occurred Friday, several days after the police agency began using Tasers to incapacitate combative criminal suspects.
Meanwhile, Niagara Regional Police used a Taser stun gun Saturday night on a 35-year-old Welland, Ont., man with "both hands clenched" who threatened to kill police. Police said the Welland man was uninjured by the stun gun and was arrested.
The Ontario case that might have caused a suspect's death is being watched by Niagara Falls, N.Y., Police Superintendent John R. Chella.
His department started using Tasers about six months ago. Chella said he does not know of any other police department in Western New York that is currently using the device.
"It's very unfortunate to hear about that happening in Ontario, and we'll be waiting to hear exactly what happened," Chella said. "But in our department, I've been happy with (the Taser's) performance. . . . The company that makes them has assured us that they've been thoroughly tested for safety."
In April, Amnesty International issued a report saying that there were 103 documented Taser-related deaths in North America between June 2001 and March 2005. In Florida, critics who are protesting the Taser say it has killed 25 people in the state.
The maker of the device, Taser International of Scottsdale, Ariz., says the device saves lives every day by allowing police, private security and the military to safely control dangerous and combative suspects.
Chella said his department has used the Taser during the arrests of highly agitated suspects. On June 26, Niagara Falls officers said, they used a Taser to subdue a belligerent and intoxicated 19-year-old man who tried to flee when police attempted to question him on Military Road.
On March 19, Niagara Falls officers used the Taser to stun a 26-year-old man who was accused of trying to force his way into a Third Street nightclub while armed with a box cutter.
"We do a lot of training with any officer who will be using the Taser, and we review every use of it," Chella said. "We've had weeks where it was used two or three times. We've had weeks where it wasn't used at all."
Niagara Regional Police have released little information about the death of Foldi, except to say that a Taser device that was reportedly fired at Foldi has been "seized for examination."
Officers were dispatched to Village Park Drive in Beamsville, near St. Catharines, to investigate an early morning break-in, the police agency said. Foldi was placed under arrest near the scene of the break-in, and at that time, officers "observed that (Foldi) required immediate medical attention."
The Hamilton Spectator newspaper reported Saturday that Foldi was already "bleeding heavily" before police arrived on the scene.
The newspaper said windows were broken at several homes and added that Foldi left blood at more than a dozen locations.
A woman whose home was allegedly entered by Foldi told the newspaper she heard three Taser shots after hearing Foldi pleading with police not to shoot him.
A civilian agency known as the Special Investigations Unit is investigating the death. Police said the special unit looks into incidents in Ontario involving police and civilians that have resulted in serious injury, sexual assault or death.
Saturday night, Niagara Regional Police officers saw a man walking down a street in Welland carrying a crowbar at about 10:15 p.m., police said, and he ignored their requests to stop, telling them, "I'm going to take care of it."
Staff Sgt. Brian Nesbitt said the man then walked into a Harold Avenue house, confronted the residents and only left the house when escorted out by the three officers.
Once outside, police said, the man became aggressive, with "both hands clenched," and told the officers, "I'm going to . . . kill you."
Nesbitt said the man was pepper-sprayed, but it had "little effect on him," so police subdued him with the Taser. The man, whose identity was not released, was arrested and charged with uttering a death threat.
"(The Taser stun guns) are relatively new here, but from what I hear they're a very effective tool," Nesbitt said Sunday. "I spoke to the officer involved, and he said they were amazed how effective it was. It took immediate effect, and (the man) was handcuffed and taken into custody without anyone getting hurt."
Across the border, Chella said he is unaware of any misuse of the Taser in his department.
He said the department has eight Taser units, which cost about $500 each. "The expensive part is that it costs $40 to recharge each time it is used," he said.
The region's largest police force, the Buffalo Police Department, has been approached about buying Tasers but has decided not to use the devices, Deputy Commissioner Crystalea Burns Pelletier said. "I feel there is a lot more testing that needs to be done on the Taser," she said.
The Taser gun fires probes, attached to wires, which can incapacitate someone from as far as 35 feet away. Its manufacturer says the device "overrides the motor nervous system, blocking command and control of the human body."
Tasers are in use or in testing in 7,200 law enforcement, military and correctional agencies in the United States and other countries, Taser International says.
"Taser devices save lives," the company says in a statement on its Web site. "Taser devices dramatically reduce injury rates to suspects and officers."
Federal Flag Code: "Therefore, the lapel flag pin being a replica, should be worn on the left lapel near the heart. "
PER THE FEDERAL FLAG CODE..WHEN ONE WEARS THE FLAG LAPEL PIN, IT SHOULD BE WORN ON THE LEFT NEAR THE HEART IT SAYS...BUT THEY DON'T SPECIFY IF SOMEONE HAS TOTAL SITUS INVERSUS, IF THE PIN, OWING TO THE REVERSE LOCATION OF THE HEART, SHOULD BE WORN ON THE RIGHT....
MAKES YOU GO...HMMMMMMMMMM !
SEE...THERE IS A SITUS INVERSUS TOTALIS WITH DEXTROCARDIA..OR
RIGHT SIDED HEART POSITION!
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
Boycott-MPAA - RELECTIONS ON THE FOURTH OF JULY
I am writing this on the 3rd of July, 2005, as I think about the holiday that we are celebrating in the United States.
The 4th of July is also called Independence Day, celebration the day we here in the States declared our independence from the British. It was a bold move, and yes, under British law, was an illegal act. Certainly, the colonists, in directly opposing King George, were seen as insurgents (hmmm...sound familar?) and yes, as they crouched behind trees and mounds of earth and fired at the uniformed troops, were said by many in the British government, to be terrorists. After all, they did sabotage English property, and kill soldiers employed by the Crown.
It was a homegrown revolution, a response to having what you perceive as your country, occupied by a foreign power, and having foreign rule imposed on you by military force.
We supposedly went through the pains accompanying birth as a nation, in hopes of finding freedom.
Here we are, in the 21st century, facing multinational groups like the RIAA and MPAA trying to hunt us down like dogs, threatening to sue citizens of this country for outrageous sums, for the alleged tort of "copyright infringement". Not only this, but they are not putting pressure on the governments here, and by their sister groups, on governments abroad, to similarly hunt down people sharing bits of ones and zeros.
The Supreme Court has ruled that citizens cannot sue police for failing to enforce orders of protection, even in cases where that failure was the proximate cause of someone becoming killed. In previous rulings, it has been ruled that police have NO specific duty to protect and serve you as a citizen, so this ruling was not a surprise.
The Court also ruled that a large company can decide it wants someone's home, put pressure on a local government, and have that property taken from the private citizen using "eminent domain".
These are only the latest in a string of outrageous court rulings that are effectively eviscerating our rights, freedoms, and liberties.
Daily, our freedoms and liberties are disappearing like drops of a Spring showerr, sizzling to their death on a hot sidewalk, and their spirits descending into a polluted atmosphere.
The point of course is that I am afraid, though many are motivated to oppose these obscene developments, they feel impotent to effect change.
Where is our right to petition a redress for grievances?
Our country was born amid musket fires, and now, most communities have past ordinanaces that not only can people not fire guns into the air to celebrate, they can't even fire off fireworks like black cats and sparklers.
So, here we are, under the regime of a man some call "King George", who is also sending troops to occupy lands across the seas. Our men and women are dying there too, and for what?
We know that eventually, we must remove our troops, but apparently, the current King George wants to put that eventuality off until many mroe of our best and brightest come home maimed, psychologically damaged, or in body bags, or, as they have been euphemstically named, "travel tubes".
So, history DOES repeat itself.
Are we prepared to be there TWELVE MORE YEARS (the reported average length of insurgencies)...are we prepared for many , many more of the dreams of American youth to die shattered in the sands of Babylon ?
~Editorial Comment only reflects "CODEWARRIORZ THOUGHTS"
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
USATODAY.com - Bush: U.S. will stay in Iraq 'until the fight is won'Bush: U.S. will stay in Iraq 'until the fight is won'
MORGANTOWN, W. Va. (AP) ? President Bush, speaking on America's birthday, said the insurgents in Iraq will fail to stop democracy in that country and U.S. forces will stay "until the fight is won."
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
Newsday.com: Summary Box: Reporter Goes to JailSummary Box: Reporter Goes to Jail
Email this story
Printer friendly format
By The Associated Press
July 6, 2005, 6:39 PM EDT
CODE OF SILENCE: New York Times reporter Judith Miller went to jail for refusing to name a source during an investigation into the leak of a CIA operative's name.
WHY: The judge said Miller was in civil contempt of court, and time in jail could persuade her to change her mind about revealing her source.
PATRICK HENRY - AMERICA?S RADICAL DISSENTER: "This is one of the reasons he declined to serve at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia. The public reason he gave for not attending was, as he so eloquently put it, ?I smell a rat!? "
Bush Says He's Fine After Bike Accident
Thursday July 7, 2005 10:31 AM
AP Photo XGLE102
By TOM RAUM
Associated Press Writer
GLENEAGLES, Scotland (AP) - Fresh bandages on his left hand from a mountain biking accident, President Bush said Thursday he's doing well - and so apparently is the Scottish police officer with whom he collided.
``It just goes to show I should act my age,'' Bush, who turned 59 on Wednesday, joked with reporters.
Bush lost control of his bike Wednesday on a slick stretch of pavement and ran into the local officer, who was on foot, knocking him over.
``When you ride hard on a mountain bike, sometimes you fall. Otherwise, you're not riding hard,'' Bush said.
The spill occurred as Bush was exercising after arriving here to attend a summit of the Group of Eight nations.
Bush, who was wearing a helmet, suffered minor scrapes and bruises to his left hand and arm that required bandages by the White House physician, White House spokesman Scott McClellan said. The officer, a member of the police department of Strathclyde who was on a security detail, was briefly taken to the hospital and suffered a minor ankle injury.
The president said he called the officer's cell phone later Wednesday and talked to him as he was on his way home from the hospital. ``He's doing fine,'' Bush said.
``I was less concerned about myself and more concerned about him,'' Bush said.
Bush said the accident happened after he had been riding for about an hour on the grounds of the golf resort here that is the site of the summit. Bush said he was ``flying'' on his bike. ``The pavement was slick...The bike came out from under me,'' he said.
Bush's bike was damaged, requiring him to ride back to the hotel in a Secret Service vehicle.
But the fall didn't affect the president's schedule. Dressed in a tuxedo and showing no signs of distress, he attended the summit's opening dinner hosted by Queen Elizabeth on Wednesday night.
On Thursday morning, Bush appeared alongside British Prime Minister Tony Blair with flesh-colored bandages on two fingers of his left hand.
``I think I found my limitation,'' the president said.
A year ago, Bush was cut and bruised when he sailed over the handlebars while riding a mountain bike at his Texas ranch.
========Snip===========
And..taking a trip down memory lane..here's another story from
CodeWarriorz Thoughts about another of his bicycle crashes..
Bush's "Accident Proneness" Goes back a while
"Bush Bruised Diving To Avoid Truck "
Now, more recently we remember poor little Georgy almost choking to death on a pretzel, falling off the couch and hitting this head...he fell off his bike and scraped his face and hands up....
and looking back to 1999...
"AUSTIN, Texas ?? Gov. George W. Bush, the Republican presidential front-runner, sustained minor injuries to his right leg and hip Monday when he dived to avoid a truck trailer that overturned near his jogging path.
Bush was treated at the scene and later traveled to New Hampshire for a scheduled campaign swing, said Linda Edwards, Bush's press secretary.
Staff Sgt. Roscoe Hughey, a 39-year-old Texas Department of Public Safety agent who was accompanying Bush on a bicycle, received bruises to his left side, DPS spokeswoman Tela Mange said. He was treated at the Brackenridge Hospital emergency room and released about four hours later, said hospital spokeswoman Stephanie Elsea.
Bush was running on the hike-and-bike trail around Town Lake in downtown Austin when the accident occurred about 12:06 p.m, according to Ms. Edwards and the Austin Police Department,
A truck pulling a dumpster-like trailer was traveling on the street that parallels the jogging trail when the trailer overturned. Debris ? including chunks of concrete and wood ? were dumped across the jogging path.
"We're not clear what made it lose control, but the truck was out of control," Ms. Edwards said.
She said Bush told her the injuries to his right leg and right hip were suffered when he dived to get out of the way. "
============SNIP=================
For a non-drunk, he sures does have a lot of accidents.
Wipe-Out: Bush Crashes Bike At G-8
President Suffers Minor Scrapes, Bruises
POSTED: 4:08 pm EDT July 6, 2005
UPDATED: 4:59 pm EDT July 6, 2005
GLENEAGLES, Scotland -- President George W. Bush has some scrapes on his hands and arms after a bike collision with a Scottish police officer at the resort where the G-8 summit is taking place.
The officer has been taken to a hospital. Police said he has a "very minor" ankle injury.
White House spokesman Scott McClellan said Bush was going at "a pretty good speed" and took a spill after the crash. He needed bandages from the White House physician. The presidential bike took some damage.
McClellan said the officer is from a nearby town and was on a security detail. He said Bush was worried about the officer and talked with him after the crash, and will likely call the officer later.
Bush attended a dinner hosted by Queen Elizabeth at the Group of Eight economic summit after the crash. He wore a tuxedo and showed no signs of distress.
LONDON, July 7 (Xinhuanet) -- London's entire railway network was suspended Thursday after an explosion in the city's financial district injured several people, British transport police said.
The explosion was reported near the area near Liverpool Street railway station during rush hour.
The subway maintenance company said a power surge caused the explosion.
London Underground reported a second incident at another subway station in northwest London, but gave no details.
Police evacuated several tube stations after the incidents, including the busy King's Cross station in north London.
AP Newswire - Blasts destroy bus, disrupt London subwayExplosions on Double-Decker Bus and in London's Subway System Cause Havoc As G-8 Gets Underway
Several blasts went off on the London subway and on at least one double-decker bus during the morning rush hour Thursday, police said, injuring riders and prompting officials to shut down the entire underground transport network.
British Home Secretary Charles Clarke said there had been "terrible injuries."
The near simultaneous explosions came a day after London was awarded the 2012 Olympics and as the G-8 summit was getting underway in Scotland. Initial reports blamed a power surge, but officials were not ruling out an intentional attack.
One witness, Darren Hall, said some passengers emerging from an evacuated subway station had soot and blood on their faces. He told BBC TV that he was evacuated along with others near the major King's Cross station and only afterward heard a blast.
Sky News showed a picture of a mangled red bus; police said they suspected a bomb caused the explosion.
Police confirmed an explosion destroyed a double-decker bus at Russell Square in central London, and Dow Jones Newswires reported police reporting explosions on at least two others buses.
A witness at the Russell Square blast said the entire top deck of that bus was destroyed.
"I was on the bus in front and heard an incredible bang, I turned round and half the double decker bus was in the air," Belinda Seabrook told Press Association, the British news agency.
She said the bus was packed with people.
"It was a massive explosion and there were papers and half a bus flying through the air," she said.
There was no immediate official comment from British Prime Minister Tony Blair, who was hosting the world's most powerful leaders at Gleneagles, Scotland. It was not clear if the G-8 gathering focusing on climate change and aid for Africa _ but from which Iraq has largely been left off the agenda _ would have to be postponed.
Police said incidents were reported at the Aldgate station near the Liverpool Street railway terminal, Edgware Road and King's Cross in north London, Old Street in the financial district and Russell Square in central London, near the British Museum.
London Ambulance Service said several vehicles had been dispatched to the area near Liverpool Street station.
"We believe there was some sort of explosion. There are some walking wounded at Aldgate," said a spokesman for City of London police, speaking on condition of anonymity.
"We are not sure of the scale of the incident. Reports are still coming in."
Bradley Anderson, a subway passenger, told Sky News that "there was some kind of explosion or something" as his train reached the Edgware Road station in northeast London.
"Everything went black and we collided into some kind of oncoming train," Anderson said.
July 07, 2005
By: Robert Gellman
rgellman@netacc.net
The recently enacted Real ID Act may turn out to be an interesting bellwether for privacy over the next few years. It?s a complicated piece of legislation, with a checkered history and many opponents in many places. Yet it passed Congress this year without significant debate, amendments or a vote on the merits.
If all those descriptions sound disjointed, then keep reading. This is one of those complex situations where you need to juggle a number of balls to keep track of what happened and to understand what the controversies are. It?s all so complex that the discussion will continue in my next column.
The author of the law is Rep. James Sensenbrenner, R-WI, chair of the House Judiciary Committee. His goals included making it harder for everyone to obtain a driver?s license without meeting a higher standard of proof and clamping down on the issuance of driver?s licenses to illegal aliens.
The history dates to last year when Sensenbrenner wanted to add his proposal to the intelligence community reform legislation that resulted from the recommendations of the 9/11 Commission. Opposition to Sensenbrenner?s ID bill was strong in the Senate, and the House leadership held up that must-pass reform bill in response to Sensenbrenner?s protest over the Senate?s refusal to accept it. In the end, however, political pressure for intelligence reform was too great. The compromise was that the reform bill would pass, but the ID bill would come up at another time and in another way.
That?s what happened this year. The bill was attached to another must-pass bill authorizing money for the troops in Iraq. Senators were unhappy, but they were unwilling to push this fight to the wall, and Sensenbrenner got his way. Not only did his bill pass, but it also repealed a law enacted last year and already being implemented to strengthen the driver?s license process.
To be sure, there was support for the ID bill from most Republicans in the House, but the opposition in the Senate was probably strong enough to kill it again if the bill came up on its own. Sensenbrenner?s personal determination to pass the bill was the determining factor. The House leadership?s commitment to Sensenbrenner was also important. Curiously, the bill moved through the legislative process with little public attention until the very end. When the press and the public began to notice what was happening, the opposition was too late.
The new law says that unless state license procedures meet federal standards, the federal government will not accept the driver?s license as identification. If you think that it doesn?t matter, consider what you have to do to board an airplane, enter a federal building, apply for Social Security benefits, qualify for Medicare or otherwise interface with a federal agency. Most people show a driver?s license. You could use a passport if you have one, but most people do not. Almost no one carries a passport, anyway.
For most people, the driver?s license is the identification card used most often. It is commonly described as a de facto national identifier, and critics charge that the Real ID Act will go several steps further toward making the license an official national identifier. The law doesn?t quite do that, but it does advance in that direction. Much of the rhetoric and the newspaper editorials about the act focused on the national identifier angle, but there are plenty of other opponents to the law.
Some objected because of the law?s effect on the availability of driver?s licenses to illegal aliens. The act tells states that they must verify whether an applicant for a license or renewal is in the country legally. Licenses for aliens has been controversial, and states have implemented a range of solutions, including no driver?s licenses for illegals on one end and full licenses on the other. For our purposes, we can mostly set those issues aside except to note that the immigration community will continue to be a source of objection to the Real ID Act in the future.
Opposition to the Real ID Act also comes from the states. They see the legislation as an unfunded mandate with a large price tag. The Congressional Budget Office estimated the costs at $100 million, but the National Conference of State Legislatures thinks the national price tag will be $500 million to $700 million. If you assign a cost to the time that people will spend waiting in line, the price tag could double.
The act does not take effect for three years, so I anticipate that there will be time for the issues to come back to a boil. My guess is that the immigration aspects of the act will cut both ways politically, and the federalism questions aren?t much different than many other comparable issues raised by federal legislation all the time. It?s the privacy issue that is most likely to continue to resonate broadly and to provide cover for politicians and interest groups otherwise unhappy about the Real ID Act.
Why might the privacy issue be so potent here? The factor that most often undermines the public?s desire for privacy is the public?s desire for convenience. People will give up their privacy for shorter lines, less hassle and faster transactions. The Real ID Act will result in exactly the opposite. We?ll find out why next month.
For those who advocate the Iraqi War by saying that we need to "Fight Them There So We Don't Have to Fight Them Here"...the attacks in London seem to prove you wrong, don't they!
Egypt's Iraq envoy murdered, Zarqawi group claims killing - Forbes.comEgypt's Iraq envoy murdered, Zarqawi group claims killing
07.07.2005, 03:27 PM
CAIRO (AFX) - The Egyptian ambassador to Iraq has been murdered by his captors, the office of President Hosni Mubarak said,
The killing was claimed by the group of Al-Qaeda's Iraq frontman Abu Musab al-Zarqawi.
Ambassador-designate Ihab al-Sharif, 51, who was the first foreign head of mission to have been kidnapped and murdered since Iraq's hostage crisis began, was abducted at the weekend while walking in a Baghdad street.
'This terrorist act will not dissuade Egypt from adopting strong positions in solidarity with Iraq and its people and will not make Egypt go back on its support to the country and Arab causes,' the presidency said.
'Mubarak passes on his sincere condolences to the family of Ihab al-Sharif, who he considers to be a martyr of the country,' it added, quoted by the Mena agency.
The Al-Qaeda Organization in the Land of Two Rivers released a statement on its website claiming the killing of Sharif, who had been due to become the first ambassador from an Arab country to Iraq.
A short video on the website showed a blindfolded Sharif wearing a black-and-white polo shirt and identifying himself as he recalled his career at the foreign ministry, which included a stint as number two diplomat at the Egyptian embassy in Israel.
However unlike previous instances in which hostages have been killed, the video did not show footage of Sharif's execution, who was married with two daughters.
Sharif, who was named to his post in June, had been due to present his credentials as ambassador to the Iraqi authorities.
The statement also condemned Egypt's policies in the region, particularly in Iraq, where it was 'the first Arab country to send an ambassador... in response to the orders of the Crusaders.'
Herald.com | 07/07/2005 | Limbaugh loses fight over MD records
Limbaugh loses fight over MD records
Ending a legal battle, a judge turned over some of conservative talk-show host Rush Limbaugh's medical records to prosecutors looking into allegations of prescription drug abuse.
BY SUSAN SPENCER-WENDEL
Palm Beach Post
WEST PALM BEACH - A judge handed some of Rush Limbaugh's medical records to prosecutors Wednesday in a blunt ending to the conservative talk-show king's battle to keep his medical records private and out of their hands.
Palm Beach County Circuit Judge Thomas Barkdull III also returned a thicker stack of records to Limbaugh's lawyer, Roy Black, at a brief hearing in open court.
Barkdull divvied up the records, deciding which would be returned to Limbaugh and which would be forwarded to Assistant State Attorney James Martz for use in the criminal investigation of Limbaugh.
Black's stack was visibly thicker than Martz's.
''Mine's bigger than yours,'' Black quipped to Martz before leaving court.
''It's not the size that matters,'' Martz retorted.
The brief handoff ended Limbaugh's string of losses in Florida courts over his claim that the records' seizure violated his privacy rights.
Black reviewed the files later Wednesday and issued a statement saying ''most'' of Limbaugh's records had been returned to him.
''This proves our point that the state's wholesale seizure of Mr. Limbaugh's medical records was improper,'' Black wrote.
Limbaugh, 54, of Palm Beach, has not been charged with any crime. He's been a target of investigators since his former housekeeper told the state attorney's office a story of his rampant prescription drug abuse.
Investigators got search warrants and seized records from Limbaugh's doctor offices, shortly after Limbaugh's public admission he was addicted.
The warrants detailed the housekeeper's claims and alleged possible doctor-shopping, or seeking duplicate prescriptions from doctors. That felony has almost never been prosecuted in the county.
Attached to the warrants as evidence was a list of prescription drugs from one pharmacy in Palm Beach detailing Limbaugh's usage. Large amounts of commonly abused painkillers were on the list, but most of the prescriptions were written by one doctor.
Black told reporters that media accounts have distorted the amount of drugs on that list, adding that Limbaugh followed the prescribed amount.
Limbaugh made no comment on his radio show
=====SNIP=========
Is it a surprise that someone with a first name of "RUSH" might be using narcotics?
Although from time to time I will dabble in speculation about conspiracies, I usually do not get obsessed with number symbolism.
Certainly, there were many speculating about the fact that the Twin Towers attack was done on 9-11 , which also happens to be the number one dials in the States for emergency help...and then, there are those that talk about there being 911 days difference between the Twin Towers event and the Madrid train bombings...
http://www.snopes.com/rumors/madrid.asp
But, even I tend not to notice those, or put much stock in them...I did think about today's event...7-7-2005. If you add up the digits in the year to one number...the result is 7-7-7.
And, as things sometimes do, this led me to think about this phrase "7 come 11", something which, for one reason or another, pops up into my head every time I see the numbers 7 and 11 associated.
So, where the hell does this "7 come 11" phrase come from?
Most think it is from dice games.
Now, if we go to the Bible...Genesis 11:7 says
"Go to, let us go down, and there confound their language, that they may not understand one another's speech."
Well...we get confounded around here a lot.
If you go to the FAA site and look at 7-7-7
you find this:
http://www.faa.gov/atpubs/ATC/Chp7/atc0707.html#7-7-7
"Section 7. Terminal Radar Service
Area (TRSA)- Terminal
7-7-1. APPLICATION
Apply TRSA procedures within the designated TRSA in addition to the basic services described in Chapter 7, Visual, Section 6, Basic Radar Service to VFR Aircraft- Terminal.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-2. ISSUANCE OF EFC
Inform the pilot when to expect further clearance when VFR aircraft are held either inside or outside the TRSA.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-3. SEPARATION
Separate VFR aircraft from VFR/IFR aircraft by any one of the following:
a. Visual separation, as specified in para 7-2-1, Visual Separation, para 7-4-2, Vectors for Visual Approach, and para 7-6-7, Sequencing.
NOTE-
Issue wake turbulence cautionary advisories in accordance with para 2-1-20, Wake Turbulence Cautionary Advisories.
b. 500 feet vertical separation.
c. Target resolution when using broadband radar systems. The application of target resolutions at locations not using broadband radar will be individually approved by the Program Director for Air Traffic Planning and Procedures, ATP-1.
NOTE-
Apply the provisions of para 5-5-4, Minima, subparas d and e when wake turbulence separation is required.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-4. HELICOPTER TRAFFIC
Helicopters need not be separated from other helicopters. Traffic information shall be exchanged, as necessary.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-5. ALTITUDE ASSIGNMENTS
a. Altitude information contained in a clearance, instruction, or advisory to VFR aircraft shall meet MVA, MSA, or minimum IFR altitude criteria.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Flight Direction, Para 4-5-2.
FAAO 7110.65, Exceptions, Para 4-5-3.
FAAO 7110.65, Minimum En Route Altitudes, Para 4-5-6.
b. If required, issue altitude assignments, consistent with the provisions of 14 CFR Section 91.119.
NOTE-
The MSAs are:
(1) Over congested areas, an altitude at least 1,000 feet above the highest obstacle; and
(2) Over other than congested areas, an altitude at least 500 feet above the surface.
c. When necessary to assign an altitude for separation purposes to VFR aircraft contrary to 14 CFR Section 91.159, advise the aircraft to resume altitudes appropriate for the direction of flight when the altitude assignment is no longer needed for separation or when leaving the TRSA.
PHRASEOLOGY-
RESUME APPROPRIATE VFR ALTITUDES.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Practice Approaches, Para 4-8-11.
FAAO 7110.65, Application, Para 5-6-1.
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-6. APPROACH INTERVAL
The tower shall specify the approach interval.
REFERENCE-
FAAO 7110.65, Visual Separation, Para 7-2-1.
7-7-7. TRSA DEPARTURE INFORMATION
a. At controlled airports within the TRSA, inform a departing aircraft proposing to operate within the TRSA when to contact departure control and the frequency to use. If the aircraft is properly equipped, ground control or clearance delivery shall issue the appropriate beacon code.
NOTE-
Departing aircraft are assumed to want TRSA service unless the pilot states, "negative TRSA service," or makes a similar comment. Pilots are expected to inform the controller of intended destination and/or route of flight and altitude."
Oh, to heck with numerology...
:)
Fox News' Brian Kilmeade: London terror attack ... [Media Matters for America]
You have to watch this clip to believe it!
http://mediamatters.org/static/video/foxandfriends-200507070004.wmv
"Fox News' Brian Kilmeade: London terror attack near G8 summit "works to ... Western world's advantage, for people to experience something like this together"
The following exchange between Fox News host Brian Kilmeade and Fox News business contributor and substitute host Stuart Varney occurred during breaking news coverage of the attacks on London subways and buses on the July 7 edition of Fox News' Fox & Friends:
KILMEADE: And he [British Prime Minister Tony Blair] made the statement, clearly shaken, but clearly determined. This is his second address in the last hour. First to the people of London, and now at the G8 summit, where their topic Number 1 --believe it or not-- was global warming, the second was African aid. And that was the first time since 9-11 when they should know, and they do know now, that terrorism should be Number 1. But it's important for them all to be together. I think that works to our advantage, in the Western world's advantage, for people to experience something like this together, just 500 miles from where the attacks have happened.
VARNEY: It puts the Number 1 issue right back on the front burner right at the point where all these world leaders are meeting. It takes global warming off the front burner. It takes African aid off the front burner. It sticks terrorism and the fight on the war on terror, right up front all over again.
KILMEADE: Yeah."
If anything is learned from the horrible loss of life due to the London attacks, it is that this bizarre notion that we need to be in Iraq to "fight them there so we don't have to fight them here."
Tell that to the families of British soldiers serving in Iraq that sustained injuries or deaths in the attacks of 7-7-2005.
NEW YORK, July 8 (Xinhuanet) -- New York senator Hillary Clinton on Friday criticized the Bush administration for failing to deliver needed rail and subway security to deter a London-style attack on commuters.
Clinton, who is pushing for more federal dollars for high-tech terror prevention, said the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has been slow to distribute most of the 150 million dollars given by Congress for rail and transit protection.
"I'm absolutely outraged by the failure of the administration to release the funding that Congress approved last year," said Clinton. "I just don't understand what the holdup is." Clinton and eight other Democratic senators sent a letter to DHS Secretary Michael Chertoff Friday urging him to distribute the unused money quickly.
The agency has looked at high-tech ways to improve transit security but has not instituted anything since testing a system last year.
The United States has earmarked about 300 million dollars for rail security since Sept. 11 terror attacks in 2001.
Senator Clinton argued that New York and other metropolitan areas should use more of the security cameras prevalent throughout London. Investigators piecing together clues from Thursday's bombing are reviewing many tapes from those cameras to try to identify the culprits.
Many lawmakers from densely populated areas have complained that since 2001, the federal government has wasted homeland security money by spreading it out to rural areas where the risk of terror attacks is relatively low.
Clinton argued the London attacks are another sign that the government needs to send a greater share of anti-terror money to cities.
"Too much money has been wasted. It's just been sent around the countryside it hasn't been focused on what the major targets are," she said
TOP White House adviser Karl Rove was one of the secret sources who spoke to reporters about a covert CIA operative whose identity was leaked to the media, Newsweek has reported.
Mr Rove's lawyer, Robert Luskin, confirmed Mr Rove talked to Time about former ambassador Joseph Wilson and his wife, CIA agent Valerie Plame, the magazine reported.
Mr Luskin said Mr Rove had recently given Time reporter Matt Cooper permission to testify about the conversation to a grand jury investigating the leak in 2003, Newsweek reported.
A US federal judge ordered Cooper and New York Times reporter Judith Miller to testify and reveal their confidential sources.
Cooper last week avoided a jail sentence for contempt of court by agreeing to testify in the case.
Miller refused to testify and was jailed.
The case has become an important test involving freedom of the press, and has pitted the media's traditional use of anonymous sources against the efforts of a federal government prosecutor to investigate a possible crime.
It is illegal to knowingly reveal the identity of an undercover CIA agent.
Mr Rove has previously made statements about the Plame leak but has never publicly acknowledged talking to any reporter about the CIA agent.
Advertisement:
He has chosen his words carefully when questioned about the leak.
"I didn't know her name, I didn't leak her name," he told CNN last year when asked if he had had anything to do with the leak of Ms Plame's name.
Special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald has been leading a two-year investigation into the leak, amid questions about whether it came from White House as part of an attempt to discredit Mr Wilson after he contradicted President George W. Bush's assertions about Iraq's weapons of mass destruction.
Mr Wilson wrote an opinion column in The New York Times saying he had been sent by the CIA in 2002 to investigate the Bush Administration's claim that Iraq was trying to buy uranium from Africa ? a claim the administration used to justify going to war in Iraq.
Mr Wilson said he found no evidence to support the claim.
The Newsweek article said an email Cooper sent his bureau chief after briefly talking with Mr Rove stated "it was, KR said, Wilson's wife, who apparently works at the agency on wmd (weapons of mass destruction) issues who authorised the trip".
The email did not suggest Mr Rove had used Ms Plame's name, or that he knew she was a covert agent, the article said.
"Karl Rove has shared with Fitzgerald all the information he has about any potentially relevant contacts he has had with any reporters, including Matt Cooper," Mr Luskin told Newsweek.
The Moderate Voice - Newest Rove Revelation: Legally Harmful Smoking Gun?
Newest Rove Revelation: Legally Harmful Smoking Gun?
by Joe Gandelman
"Do you know who I am? I'm Mo Green, I made my bones when you were going out with Cheerleaders." ? Mo Green in The Godfather.
A new Newsweek story fingers Bush political right-hand-man Karl Rove as at least one person who told a reporter that Joe Wilson's wife worked as a CIA agent.
But now the prevailing question is: did Rove's alleged role and the way he allegedly played it fall under the detailed law or will this be a case of something that may be politically reprehensible ? but not actually unlawful. And, if that's the case, what (if anything) will President George Bush do in light of his own previous comments?
At issue is Michael Isakoff's latest now-it-can-be-told piece. A few key sections:
It was 11:07 on a Friday morning, July 11, 2003, and Time magazine correspondent Matt Cooper was tapping out an e-mail to his bureau chief, Michael Duffy. "Subject: Rove/P&C," (for personal and confidential), Cooper began. "Spoke to Rove on double super secret background for about two mins before he went on vacation ..." Cooper proceeded to spell out some guidance on a story that was beginning to roil Washington. He finished, "please don't source this to rove or even WH [White House]" and suggested another reporter check with the CIA.
Last week, after Time turned over that e-mail, among other notes and e-mails, Cooper agreed to testify before a grand jury in the Valerie Plame case. Explaining that he had obtained last-minute "personal consent" from his source, Cooper was able to avoid a jail sentence for contempt of court....
So it would appear some newspaper and analysts' speculation was on-the-dime: Cooper likely heard from Rove who told him to go ahead with his tesimony. Would Rove agree to THAT if he felt he was possibly heading to the slammer....or is it more likely his top lawyer gave him good news?
But the most damning part of the Newsweek story is this:
In a brief conversation with Rove, Cooper asked what to make of the flap over Wilson's criticisms. NEWSWEEK obtained a copy of the e-mail that Cooper sent his bureau chief after speaking to Rove. (The e-mail was authenticated by a source intimately familiar with Time's editorial handling of the Wilson story, but who has asked not to be identified because of the magazine's corporate decision not to disclose its contents.) Cooper wrote that Rove offered him a "big warning" not to "get too far out on Wilson." Rove told Cooper that Wilson's trip had not been authorized by "DCIA"?CIA Director George Tenet?or Vice President Dick Cheney. Rather, "it was, KR said, wilson's wife, who apparently works at the agency on wmd [weapons of mass destruction] issues who authorized the trip." Wilson's wife is Plame, then an undercover agent working as an analyst in the CIA's Directorate of Operations counterproliferation division. (Cooper later included the essence of what Rove told him in an online story.) The e-mail characterizing the conversation continues: "not only the genesis of the trip is flawed an[d] suspect but so is the report. he [Rove] implied strongly there's still plenty to implicate iraqi interest in acquiring uranium fro[m] Niger ... "
Nothing in the Cooper e-mail suggests that Rove used Plame's name or knew she was a covert operative. Nonetheless, it is significant that Rove was speaking to Cooper before Novak's column appeared; in other words, before Plame's identity had been published. Fitzgerald has been looking for evidence that Rove spoke to other reporters as well. "Karl Rove has shared with Fitzgerald all the information he has about any potentially relevant contacts he has had with any reporters, including Matt Cooper," Luskin told NEWSWEEK.
A source close to Rove, who declined to be identified because he did not wish to run afoul of the prosecutor or government investigators, added that there was "absolutely no inconsistency" between Cooper's e-mail and what Rove has testified to during his three grand-jury appearances in the case. "A fair reading of the e-mail makes clear that the information conveyed was not part of an organized effort to disclose Plame's identity, but was an effort to discourage Time from publishing things that turned out to be false," the source said, referring to claims in circulation at the time that Cheney and high-level CIA officials arranged for Wilson's trip to Africa.
It almost sounds as if we've come full circle, back to the era of the highly-derided (particularly by Republicans) "it all depends on what is is."
And it's possible there's enough "wiggle room" so that "is" in this case really "ain't" and it won't mean penalties under the law.
But if it indeed comes out ? definitively ? that Rove was a participant (either just him or several others) it will be absolutely fascinating to see President George Bush wiggle out of this Feb. 11, 2004 story:
President Bush said Tuesday he welcomes a Justice Department investigation into who revealed the classified identity of a CIA operative.
"If there's a leak out of my administration, I want to know who it is," Bush told reporters at an impromptu news conference during a fund-raising stop in Chicago, Illinois. "If the person has violated law, that person will be taken care of.
"I welcome the investigation. I am absolutely confident the Justice Department will do a good job.
"I want to know the truth," the president continued. "Leaks of classified information are bad things."
He added that he did not know of "anybody in my administration who leaked classified information."
Bush said he has told his administration to cooperate fully with the investigation and asked anyone with knowledge of the case to come forward.
So: if Rove did tell Bush, how WAS Rove "taken care of?" There wasn't the slightest carefully couched comment from the President's p.r. team that Rove might have been involved in this in anyway. Was he "taken care of" by admonishment? Was he punished by being forced to listen to Tom Cruise lecture him on psychiatry? Or something a bit less severe than that?
If he didn't tell Bush, then that would mean he has mislead the President. Shouldn't Rove then take the honorable path and decide it's time to "move in another direction" or accept some nice, big, fat offer in the private sector?
Or will the argument be "well, he didn't really violate the law ? so there!" implying that Rove's alleged role was perfectly OK. If so, then it would suggest that this kind of behavior sets the political bar at a new (low) level and a future Democratic administration has the go-ahead to use the same tactics.
Some additional thoughts:
Since this is a complex law (and we will leave government and weblog lawyers to write more about that) we won't venture to say how we think the case itself will come out. But it does appear as if it is possible (and likely given Copper's message from his source to go ahead) that Rove will not be prosecuted.
No matter what happens, it boldly underlined Rove's role as what analysts in the 1960s used to call a "political hatchet man," a hands-on operative who will seek to overtly and, even moreso, covertly discredit and destroy anyone who stands in the way of his boss' objectives.
The country could be faced with a situation where Rove's role is confirmed, Bush's comments above are never addressed or justified with lawyerly parsing, and Rove does NOT resign but continues with absolutely no legal, political or personal consquences.
If we'd have to bet money, we'd bet on that outcome, simply because of the way politics seems to operate in the 21st century, where past rules of the game involving ethics and propriety are seemingly changed according to the circumstance and power to do so. If that happens, look for Democrats to be outraged, Republicans and talk show hosts to quickly adjust and hammer away with whatever defense arguments their team offers ? and the actual situation remain unchanged.
Except for one thing.
Credibility.
If Rove played a prominent role, it'll raise one more question about veracity.
Swing voters, centrists and even some Republicans would not be unaware of the disconnect if Karl Rove was involved and those who had indigantly blasted the honesty of the Clinton adminstration felt this is really no big deal...because he's Karl Rove.
BUT THAT'S JUST OUR VIEW. THERE ARE OTHERS AND HERE'S A CROSS SECTION:
--Wizbang
The fact that Plame sent Wilson on the trip to Nigeria was an important part of debunking Wilson's report. This was no political smear, it was the pointing out of nepotism which further supported the idea that Wilson's trip was politically, not factually, motivated. If keeping Plame's identity a secret was such a top priority then maybe she and her husband shouldn't have gotten involved with the phony trip to Nigeria. If anything, these revelations are far more damaging to Plame and her husband than they are to Rove.
--Matt Sheffield:"The gossip spread more widely and rapidly after Wilson went public with his mission in a New York Times op-ed blasting the Bush admin and the war in Iraq (a National Review contributor disclosed in 2003 that he knew about Plame before Novak's column). Eventually, several reporters heard about the gossip, but only Novak and Cooper decided to pass it along. Like many of the kerfuffles created by Clinton foes in the 90s, the Plame game seems to be another scandalous non-scandal."
--Americablog:"Meanwhile, we still have to see whether or not crimes were committed. Rove doing the perp walk is still a real possibility. Besides that, there should be ramifications for Rove. So, you have your leaker now, George Bush, what are you going to do about it? And, it would be really, really great if this week, if the White House Press Corps asked some questions about Rove...or maybe they are have kind of double super secret background, too."
--Captain Ed:
So far, this lead has gone nowhere in the Plame leak. Patrick Fitzgerald has done nothing but embarrass himself by jailing a reporter and turning her into a martyr over something that probably doesn't amount to a prosecutable crime in the first place. It will be damned difficult to generate any outrage on behalf of a CIA agent who sent her husband on a public mission to undermine the American government during a time of war, mostly through lies and half-truths, and who now wants to hide behind a covert status that no one can actually establish applied at the time. Fitzgerald needs to close the case and let Judith Miller out of jail.
He goes into more detail in this follow up post, arguing the left will make a fuss over it but in the end its a non-scandal.
--Andrew Sullivan:"The salient fact is that Rove appears to have told Cooper about Wilson's wife working at the CIA before the Novak column appeared. Rove was clearly coordinating a message to discredit Wilson by linking him to his wife, and implying that Wilson had no real authorization from the senior levels of the administration. Rove may not be guilty of a crime, if he did not disclose her name and did not know she was undercover. He is guilty of sleaze and spin. But then that's also hardly news, is it?"
--Pejmanesque:"There is--I am sure--more information that will come out regarding this story. But for now, there is not enough to "frog march" Karl Rove out of the White House. Not nearly enough."
--Laura Rosen:"Isikoff confirms that Rove is the source who gave Cooper direct permission to testify last week at the last minute. I find it fascinating that Rove was not only campaigning to discredit Wilson, but that he was pushing so hard to legitimate the bogus Iraq- Niger uranium information, just days before the administration capitulated and said it shouldn't have used that language in Bush's SOTU."
--Mahablog:
Bush won't do anything about that, of course, unless it occurs to him that Rove is a bigger political liability than he is an asset. Bush doesn't care about national security or the law or anything other than himself. As long as Bush wants to keep Rove around, the Right will form a solid wall of denial, built mostly on narrowly constructed legalisms (e.g., Rove didn't know she was an operative, so he didn't commit a crime, so he didn't do anything wrong, and liberals stink) and misdirection (shifting the story from White House lies about uranium to who authorized Joe Wilson's trip to Niger).
--Peking Duck thinks it is a smoking gun:
It's going to be a fun second term for our war-time president. Every success he claims ? No Child Left Behind, the War on Terror, the war in Iraq, tax reform, Medicare reform, Clear Skies (!), et. al. ? every one is propped up by sloganeering, photo ops, deception, deceit and outright lies. They're built on sand, and once the tide rises they'll come crashing down, one by one. Karl Rove's fall will almost certainly help raise the tide.
--Cookie Jill at skippy has links to a July 14 Novak column that suggest KR may not get presents from Santa this year:"so...rove knows and is circulating information on 11 july that he obtained from an article published on 14 july. wonder where rove hides his crystal balls.
--Digby:
The big question that was swirling wasn't who sent Wilson on the trip, for gawds sake. It was whether they knew the Niger documents were forgeries and spread it around anyway. Karl's little phone call was an effort to cover-up the fact that the administration had lied its ass off making the case for war --- Valerie Plame was a pawn they used to try to taint Wilson as some kind of hen-pecked househusband when he exposed an element of their bogus evidence. Regardless of whether Rove knew she was an NOC, and this doesn't prove it one way or the other, it proves he was a scumbag who was engineering a cover-up. One thing we know for sure is that Wilson was right.
Karl Rove and others in the White House exposed an undercover CIA agent in order to cover up their lies about Iraq.
In a follow up post, he says Rove should resign, broken law or not. "Wringing our hands and saying nothing will ever happen because he's Superman is a self-fulfilling prophecy. The dirtiest most devious president in history was brought down by his own paranoia and sloppiness. Karl Rove is no more omnipotent than he was," he writes.
--Betsy Newmark:
Think about this. Wilson was a has-been, small potatoes diplomat. She's an obscure worker at the CIA. Why do people like Andrea Mitchell know where she works? You think he was a big a attention-grabber before all this as he was after?
I just think that Rove's legal innocence will be beside the point. Just wait for Bush to go to Crawford. The whole month of August will be taken up with sides arguing about whether or not Rove should be fired. Every summer of Bush's presidency except in 2004 there has been some scandalette that the media, for want of any other story, has blown way out of proportion. All we can hope is that they will concentrate more on terrorism threats and the Supreme Court nomination(s) and this brouhaha will be swallowed up by more important stories.
--The Talking Dog (written on July 6 but still relevant in its main point):
If, in fact, Mr. Rove knowingly disclosed the name and identity of a covert American operative, he is guilty of not only the specific felony of doing so, but quite likely treason, and to the extent his deliberate outing of an American covert operative resulted in the death or deaths of field operatives, he should, in all fairness, be facing the death penalty. Understand the principle of "IIOKIYAR", which most of you understand (but simply means "It's OK if you are a Republican"). Don't worry: there's no limit to what that simple phrase covers, up to and including treason. Special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald will just have to come to that realization himself, if he attempts to actually... you know... do anything to Rove. But that's the way it is.
--Common Sense Desk:"Unfortunately, of all of the sins that are apparent in this mess I think that the sin of hypocrisy is among the worst. It is one of many such sins committed by this man who is entrusted to advise our president. That is a sacred trust. Whether he has committed an indictable offense or not is irrelevant. He betrayed the American people and our great Republic by playing politics with sensitive information to provide cover, not just for his own despicable ass, but also for the others complicit in the charade that has put us in an untenable position in Iraq and pretty much everywhere else."
--Powerline details the reasons why its authors (who are lawyers) do not feel Rove has legal problems. Key quote:
It is hard to see how Rove could be indicted for violation of the Intelligence Identities Protection Act, and it is very unlikely that he would have been foolish enough to testify falsely before the grand jury about his conversations with journalists. None of this will matter much, though, when it is publicly acknowledged that Rove was one of the sources of the Plame "leak." (This isn't, by the way, the sort of communication that is ordinarily referred to as a "leak.") We can expect a media feeding frenzy or potentially unprecedented proportions.
Rove presumably told the President that he was one of the sources of the Plame information long ago. It is interesting that Bush didn't take the path of least resistance and ease Rove out of the administration at the end of his first term. The President's reputation for loyalty to has aides is certainly well-deserved.
--The Kudzu Files:"Assuming the information is correct, if Karl Rove is not fired, and explicitly and completely separated from the Bush Administration, the minute he is positively identified as the source - if George Bush hesitates to dismiss him immediately - then President George Bush should be impeached. This is far, far more serious than oral sex in the White House, or possibly making a few thousand dollars on a twenty-year-old land deal. This is what the issue should have been all along - are the lives of American intelligence operatives worth more than political expediency, or not? George Bush likes clear-cut, black-and-white issues. Mr. President, it doesn't get more clear-cut than this."
--Southpaw:"I think that Rove now realizes that there is no way out of this for him short of another Saturday Night Massacre. Fitzgerald has to go, but even with a subservient Congress and librul media, he still needs some political cover before he can order Fitzgerald's firing......Personally, I think that Rove's chances of getting away with this are about 50/50. Which is 50% better than they should be. Thanks for going to the tank, American news media. Thanks a lot."
--A FASCINATING post at Arguing With Signposts, a blog written by a journalism prof. He analyzes this story from the standpoint of sourcing. We'd ruin it by paraphrasing so read it in full yourself.
Top Bush adviser revealed as Plame source
By Holly Yeager in Washington
Published: July 10 2005 23:17 | Last updated: July 10 2005 23:17
Karl Rove, President George W. Bush's top political adviser, was the secret source who gave a Time magazine reporter permission to testify last week, thus avoiding jail for contempt of court, Newsweek reported on Sunday.
Mr Rove has been the subject of growing speculation as two journalists faced prison for failing to reveal their sources to a federal prosecutor investigating the leak of the identity of Valerie Plame, an undercover CIA officer.
Last week Judith Miller of the New York Times was jailed after she refused to testify before a grand jury about her source. Matt Cooper, of Time magazine, had expected to keep his source a secret as well. But in dramatic fashion, just as he was about to persist in maintaining his silence, he said he received permission from his source to testify in court.
Mr Cooper has refused to identify his source publicly. But in this week's edition Newsweek said Mr Rove's attorney had confirmed that Mr Rove had discussed Joseph Wilson, a former ambassador who is married to Ms Plame, with Mr Cooper and that he gave Mr Cooper permission to testify.
It is illegal to reveal knowingly the identity of an undercover officer, and the prosecutor has been searching for the source of the leak who revealed Ms Plame's identity, which was first reported by Robert Novak, a columnist.
Mr Rove has insisted he did not leak Ms Plame's name, and e-mail accounts included in the Newsweek story only make clear that he talked to Mr Cooper about Mr Wilson's wife, without revealing her name.
?Nothing in the Cooper e-mail suggests that Rove used Plame's name or knew she was a covert operative,? according to Newsweek. ?Nonetheless, it is significant that Rove was speaking to Cooper before Novak's column appeared; in other words, before Plame's identity had been published.?
David Corn: Explosive New Rove Revelation Coming Soon? UPDATE: It's Here - Yahoo! News
Time to get ready for the Karl Rove frog-march?
I don't usually blog on Saturday evenings. But I've received information too good not to share immediately. It was only yesterday that I was bemoaning the probability that -- after a week of apparent Rove-related revelations--it might be a while before any more news emerged about the Plame/CIA leak. Yet tonight I received this as-solid-as-it-gets tip: on Sunday Newsweek is posting a story that nails Rove. The newsmagazine has obtained documentary evidence that Rove was indeed a key source for Time magazine's Matt Cooper and that Rove--prior to the publication of the Bob Novak column that first publicly disclosed Valerie Wilson/Plame as a CIA official -- told Cooper that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson's wife apparently worked at the CIA and was involved in Joseph Wilson's now-controversial trip to Niger.
To be clear, this new evidence does not necessarily mean slammer-time for Rove. Under the relevant law, it's only a crime for a government official to identify a covert intelligence official if the government official knows the intelligence officer is under cover, and this documentary evidence, I'm told, does not address this particular point. But this new evidence does show that Rove -- despite his lawyers claim that Rove "did not tell any reporter that Valerie Plame worked for the CIA" -- did reveal to Cooper in a deep-background conversation that Wilson's wife was in the CIA. No wonder special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald pursued Cooper so fiercely. And Fitzgerald must have been delighted when Time magazine -- over Cooper's objection--surrendered Cooper's emails and notes, which, according to a previous Newsweek posting by Michael Isikoff, named Rove as Cooper's source. In court on Wednesday, Fitzgerald said that following his receipt of Cooper's emails and notes "it is clear to us we need [Cooper's] testimony perhaps more so than in the past." This was a clue that Fitzgerald had scored big when he obtained the Cooper material.
This new evidence could place Rove in serious political, if not legal, jeopardy (or, at least it should). If what I am told is true, this is proof that the Bush White House was using any information it could gather on Joseph Wilson -- even classified information related to national security -- to pursue a vendetta against Wilson, a White House critic. Even if it turns out Rove did not break the law regarding the naming of intelligence officials, this new disclosure could prove Rove guilty of leaking a national security secret to a reporter for political ends. What would George W. Bush do about that?
On September 27, 2003 -- after the news broke that the Justice Department, responding to a request from the CIA, was investigating the Plame/CIA leak -- White House press secretary Scott McClellan said of the Plame/CIA leak, "That is not the way this White House operates, and no one would be authorized to do such a thing." He also declared that the allegation that Rove was involved in this leak was "a ridiculous suggestion, and it is simply not true." Days later, Bush issued a straightforward statement about the Plame/CIA leak:
There are too many leaks of classified information in Washington. If there's leaks out of my administration, I want to know who it is, and if the person has violated the law, the person will be taken care of.
Perhaps Bush won't have to "take care of" Rove if this new evidence does not lead to a prosecutable violation of the law. But Bush also called on any government official with knowledge of the leak to "come forward and speak out." Has Rove done so? No. So it seems he violated a presidential command. Would Bush be obliged to fire him for insubordination? And there's another key point to consider: whether Rove told the truth when he testified to Fitzgerald's grand jury. Rove's attorney, Robert Luskin, has acknowledged that Rove appeared before the grand jury, and Luskin has said that Rove did speak to Cooper prior to the publication of the Novak column. But what did Rove tell Fitzgerald and the grand jury about this conversation with Cooper? And -- here's the big question -- does Rove's account jibe with the new documentary evidence that Newsweek is scheduled to disclose? If it does not, Fitzgerald would have a good start on a perjury charge against Rove.
At a public meeting in the summer of 2003, Joseph Wilson, responding to a question about the leak, quipped that it would be interesting "to see whether or not we can get Karl Rove frog-marched out of the White House in handcuffs." He then had to pull back from that comment and concede he had no evidence to support his hunch that Rove was one of the leakers. (By the way, Novak cited two unnamed Bush administration officials when he published the Plame/CIA leak.) With Newsweek's latest article, we may be getting closer to frog-marching time.
Matt Cooper's Source - Newsweek National News - MSNBC.com
By Michael Isikoff
Newsweek
July 18 issue - It was 11:07 on a Friday morning, July 11, 2003, and Time magazine correspondent Matt Cooper was tapping out an e-mail to his bureau chief, Michael Duffy. "Subject: Rove/P&C," (for personal and confidential), Cooper began. "Spoke to Rove on double super secret background for about two mins before he went on vacation ..." Cooper proceeded to spell out some guidance on a story that was beginning to roil Washington. He finished, "please don't source this to rove or even WH [White House]" and suggested another reporter check with the CIA.
Last week, after Time turned over that e-mail, among other notes and e-mails, Cooper agreed to testify before a grand jury in the Valerie Plame case. Explaining that he had obtained last-minute "personal consent" from his source, Cooper was able to avoid a jail sentence for contempt of court. Another reporter, Judith Miller of The New York Times, refused to identify her source and chose to go to jail instead.
For two years, a federal prosecutor, Patrick Fitzgerald, has been investigating the leak of Plame's identity as an undercover CIA agent. The leak was first reported by columnist Robert Novak on July 14, 2003. Novak apparently made some arrangement with the prosecutor, but Fitzgerald continued to press other reporters for their sources, possibly to show a pattern (to prove intent) or to make a perjury case. (It is illegal to knowingly identify an undercover CIA officer.) Rove's words on the Plame case have always been carefully chosen. "I didn't know her name. I didn't leak her name," Rove told CNN last year when asked if he had anything to do with the Plame leak. Rove has never publicly acknowledged talking to any reporter about former ambassador Joseph Wilson and his wife. But last week, his lawyer, Robert Luskin, confirmed to NEWSWEEK that Rove did?and that Rove was the secret source who, at the request of both Cooper's lawyer and the prosecutor, gave Cooper permission to testify.
The controversy arose when Wilson wrote an op-ed column in The New York Times saying that he had been sent by the CIA in February 2002 to investigate charges that Iraq was trying to buy uranium from the African country of Niger. Wilson said he had found no evidence to support the claim. Wilson's column was an early attack on the evidence used by the Bush administration to justify going to war in Iraq. The White House wished to discredit Wilson and his attacks. The question for the prosecutor is whether someone in the administration, in an effort to undermine Wilson's credibility, intentionally revealed the covert identity of his wife.
In a brief conversation with Rove, Cooper asked what to make of the flap over Wilson's criticisms. NEWSWEEK obtained a copy of the e-mail that Cooper sent his bureau chief after speaking to Rove. (The e-mail was authenticated by a source intimately familiar with Time's editorial handling of the Wilson story, but who has asked not to be identified because of the magazine's corporate decision not to disclose its contents.) Cooper wrote that Rove offered him a "big warning" not to "get too far out on Wilson." Rove told Cooper that Wilson's trip had not been authorized by "DCIA"?CIA Director George Tenet?or Vice President Dick Cheney. Rather, "it was, KR said, wilson's wife, who apparently works at the agency on wmd [weapons of mass destruction] issues who authorized the trip." Wilson's wife is Plame, then an undercover agent working as an analyst in the CIA's Directorate of Operations counterproliferation division. (Cooper later included the essence of what Rove told him in an online story.) The e-mail characterizing the conversation continues: "not only the genesis of the trip is flawed an[d] suspect but so is the report. he [Rove] implied strongly there's still plenty to implicate iraqi interest in acquiring uranium fro[m] Niger ... "
Nothing in the Cooper e-mail suggests that Rove used Plame's name or knew she was a covert operative. Nonetheless, it is significant that Rove was speaking to Cooper before Novak's column appeared; in other words, before Plame's identity had been published. Fitzgerald has been looking for evidence that Rove spoke to other reporters as well. "Karl Rove has shared with Fitzgerald all the information he has about any potentially relevant contacts he has had with any reporters, including Matt Cooper," Luskin told NEWSWEEK.
Scribe Journal: Karl Rove and the Valerie Plame Leak - The National Ledger
Karl Rove and the Valerie Plame Leak
Newsweek's latest weekly feature of the Karl Rove and Valerie Plame story is up. This time it?s a bit more interesting than last week's breathless Larry O'Donnell promise of the "It's Rove" revelation.
Newsweek reports that Time magazine correspondent Matt Cooper sent an e-mail at 11:07 on a Friday morning, July 11, 2003 to his bureau chief, Michael Duffy.
Subject: Rove/P&C," (for personal and confidential)
"Spoke to Rove on double super secret background for about two mins before he went on vacation..." Cooper proceeded to spell out some guidance on a story that was beginning to roil Washington. He finished, "please don't source this to [R]ove or even WH [White House]" and suggested another reporter check with the CIA.
Cooper is free from jail as he turned over this e-mail [and others] and has agreed to testify in the Valerie Plame case and disclose his source to Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald. Cooper's source gave him permission to testify.
So is Rove ready to be "frog marched" out of the White House as Bush-hater and Valerie Plame's hubby Joe Wilson has fantasized about?
David Corn warns the Bush haters to be cautious:
To be clear, this new evidence does not necessarily mean slammer-time for Rove. Under the relevant law, it's only a crime for a government official to identify a covert intelligence official if the government official knows the intelligence officer is under cover, and this documentary evidence, I'm told, does not address this particular point. But this new evidence does show that Rove -- despite his lawyers claim that Rove "did not tell any reporter that Valerie Plame worked for the CIA" -- did reveal to Cooper in a deep-background conversation that Wilson's wife was in the CIA.
Timeline
Valerie Plame's name first appeared in a July 14, 2003, syndicated column by Robert Novak. But that column was written before July 11th, and was distributed by Creators Syndicate over the Associated Press wire on July 11th. [It appears that Rove spoke to Cooper sometime in the morning on July 11th.] The column is also e-mailed to those publications that syndicate the column.
Novak was chasing the story as early as July 7 according to the transcript of "CNN WOLF BLITZER REPORTS"
ROBERT NOVAK, CO-HOST, "CROSSFIRE": Former Ambassador Wilson broke the secrecy that a retired diplomat, unknown, had gone to Niger in the year 2002 to investigate whether the Iraqis tried to buy yellow cake, uranium from Niger.
BLITZER: You mean when he wrote that op-ed page article in "The New York Times"?
NOVAK: "New York Times." That was on a Sunday morning.
On Monday, [July 7] I began to report on something that I thought was very curious. Why was it that Ambassador Wilson, who had no particular experience in weapons of mass destruction, and was a sharp critic of the Iraqi policy of President Bush and, also, had been a high-ranking official in the Clinton White House, who had contributed politically to Democrats -- some Republicans, but mostly Democrats -- why was he being selected?
I asked this question to a senior Bush administration official, and he said that he believed that the assignment was suggested by an employee at the CIA in the Counterproliferation Office who happened to be ambassador Wilson's wife, Valerie Plame.
I then called another senior official of the Bush administration, and he said, Oh, you know about that? And he confirmed that that was an accurate story. I then called the CIA. They said that, to their knowledge, he did not -- that the mission was not suggested by Ambassador Wilson's wife, but that she had been asked by her colleagues in the Counterproliferation Office, to contact her husband. So she was involved.
BLITZER: Because he was a former ambassador in Gabon, he knew that part of Africa, and that's, presumably, why they wanted to send him on this mission.
NOVAK: I'm not going into motives. I thought it was strange because he is not an expert in counterproliferation. He had not been ambassador to Niger, he had served in Niger at one time.
BLITZER: But he was a senior on African affairs at the NFC under Clinton?
NOVAK: Under Clinton, that's correct.
So that was the story I wrote, was about the details of Ambassador Wilson's mission, which created a great storm. And in the sixth paragraph of a ten-paragraph story I mentioned that two senior administration officials had said it was suggested by his wife, who worked at the CIA.
Intelligence Identities Protection Act
Also take note: To constitute a violation of the Intelligence Identities Protection Act, a disclosure by a government official must have been deliberate, the person doing it must have known that the CIA officer was a covert agent, and he or she must have known that "the United States is taking affirmative measures to conceal such covert agent's intelligence relationship to the United States.
Karl Rove may not be in legal trouble, but there's no question this will get very interesting soon.
--By CK Rairden
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
The Seattle-Post Intelligencer calls for a federal shield law and adds:
Another strange twist in this story is that the journalist who first "outed" Plame in his column, conservative commentator Robert Novak, apparently faces no jail time, no contempt charge, none of the pressure Hogan and federal prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald have placed on Cooper and Miller. Does Novak enjoy his own personal shield for being a White House toady?
After all, the presumed motive of the "two senior (Bush) administration officials" who exposed Plame to Novak and other journalists was to punish her husband, former Ambassador Joseph Wilson, who blew the whistle on President Bush's Niger-sold-uranium-to-Iraq part of the justification for going to war.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Penn Jillette Is A Hypocrite - Warner Todd HustonBut, what struck me the most about this whole little incident is its delineation of the typical, liberal I-am-more-tolerant-than-you line of thinking and the assumption that the left is more in tune with liberty than anyone else. Though, don't get me wrong on one point, I am NOT claiming Penn Jillette is the typical modern leftist, though he runs in that crowd and must feel the pressure to toe their line quite often. Like I said, some of his opinions are quite in line with today's left.
No, what was funny was that, while Jillette was putting on airs as the protector of our freedom of speech, while he was presenting himself as the arbiter of all our freedoms, he ALSO had speech he would like to see squelched. Proving that no one tolerates all or just any kind of free speech and we all want to see limits on what others say in the public square. Some want to see no holds barred on the radio, allowing the hosts to say what ever pops into their minds at any given moment as Penn seemed to advocate. Yet he also seemingly would stop Mel Gibson from being able to create and sell his movie about Christ as well as say what was on his mind in interviews about the work.
ABC News: '20/20' RESPONSE TO SPCA
========snip============
DEAR 20/20 :
AS A CITIZEN WHO LOVES ANIMALS, IT IS MY CONSIDERATE OPINION THAT YOU ARE A BUNCH OF FAT, STUPID,
MOTHERF'ERS AND ASSHOLES. AND, THAT'S ME BEING POLITE!
fuck you 20/20~
~CodeWarriorz Thoughts
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Rove Scandal: Who's Lying Now? - Yahoo! News
The Nation -- Who's lying?
ADVERTISEMENT
ZIP code where you park at night.
Do you currently have auto insurance? Yes No
Have you had a U.S driver's license for more than 3 years? Yes No
Has any driver in your household had 2 or more accidents or moving violations in the last 3 years? Yes No
That's the question to ask after both The New York Times and The Washington Post published front-page articles that reported that Karl Rove did speak to conservative columnist Bob Novak before Novak wrote an article revealing the CIA identity of Valerie Wilson and that Rove had confirmed to Novak that Valerie Wilson worked at the CIA.
Each account is attributed to a single unnamed source. The Times identifies its sourced as "someone who has been officially briefed on the matter." The Post cited "a lawyer involved in the case." And the account provided is one that apparently would help Rove fend off a criminal charge. Both newspapers say that Novak called Rove on July 8, 2003 (six days before Novak published the piece that outed Valerie Wilson), that Novak said he had learned that Valerie Wilson worked at the CIA (he referred to her by her maiden name, Valerie Plame), and that Rove confirmed that he had heard that, too. Each story says its source claimed that Rove had learned about Valerie Wilson's CIA position from other journalists.
The point here is to show that Rove was not peddling the information, that he had not received it from a classified source, and that he did not have reason to know that Valerie Wilson was working at the CIA under cover. Under the relevant law--the Intelligence Identities Protection Act--it is only a crime for a government official to disclose identifying information about a covert US intelligence officer if the government official received that information from a classified source and is aware that the officer is a clandestine employee of the CIA. Consequently, Rove defenders can cite the account planted in the Times and the Post and claim that he did not violate the law because he had heard about Valerie Wilson from a journalist (not a classified source) and because there is no indication he knew of her covert status.
This might work. But, of course, it is up to special prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald to determine if Rove or anyone else (remember Novak cited two sources) broke the law or engaged in perjury or obstruction of justice. And there is no telling if this account is indeed accurate. But this new disclosure does lead to an obvious conclusion: somebody has lied.
A week after Novak wrote this column, he told Newsday that his sources came to him with the information: "I didn't dig it out, it was given to me," he said. "They thought it was significant, they gave me the name and I used it." Was Novak lying when said that? And before the infamous Matt Cooper email was revealed by Newsweek days ago, Rove's lawyer, Robert Luskin, told Newsweek that Rove "did not tell any reporter that Valerie Plame worked for the CIA." Now, the official pro-Rove line is that he confirmed for Novak that Valerie Wilson worked for the CIA. Was Rove's lawyer lying when he said that?
******
Don't forget about DAVID CORN's BLOG at www.davidcorn.com. Read recent postings on Rove and the Plame/CIA leak and other in-the-news subjects.
*******
But the more significant question is, who lied at the White House? As has been much noted, in 2003, press secretary Scott McClellan repeatedly said that Karl Rove was not involved in the leak. Confirming the leak for Novak would certainly count as involvement (as would passing it on to Cooper three days later but when this classified information was still not public).
So who didn't tell the truth at 1600 Pennsylvania? Did McClellan know of Rove's involvement and knowingly peddle a false story? McClellan has claimed he talked to Rove before publicly clearing him of involvement. Does that mean that Rove lied to McClellan? Perhaps. McClellan is not considered to be a true member of the White House's inner circle. But who else did Rove talk to about this in the White House? If anyone else knew of his involvement, then that aide stood silent while McClellan misled the public. Moreover, did Rove tell George W. Bush? If so, Bush then allowed McClellan to lie for Rove. If not, then Rove disregarded Bush when Bush said he wanted to know what had happened.
Here's the bottom line (based on the Rove-friendly leaks): Rove permitted the White House to lie for him. What's unknown is who else in the White House realized the Rove-was-not-involved line was a lie. And the latest accounts also show that Rove did share classified information--Valerie Wilson's employment status with the CIA was classified--with two reporters. Bush has previously said he would fire anyone who leaked classified information. Rove has practically admitted leaking classified information. What Bush will do about that?
This story put on Friday may help Rove avoid a criminal charge. But it still causes (or should cause) serious problems for him and the White House. It indicates that both misconduct and a cover-up of unknown size did occur. Rove or his legal team must have concluded he was in a rather bad spot if they needed to pass this account to the media, for it supports a hard-to-deny conclusion: Rove leaked and then hid behind a lie.
******
Now I'm Smeared as the Leaker: To see how I was sideswiped by an absurd and stupid conservative attack (meant to defend Novak and Rove), visit www.davidcorn.com. You won't believe how low a rightwinger will sink.
*******************
SCO bullish despite email revelations - ZDNet UK NewsSCO bullish despite email revelations
Renai LeMay
ZDNet Australia
July 15, 2005, 15:35 BST
Tell us your opinion
The SCO group has denied that an internal email has undermined its case against IBM that Linux contains copyrighted Unix code
SCO rubbishes 'smoking gun' email The SCO group has dismissed claims that an email that refuted suggestion that Linux contained any copyright infringement is damaging to their case against IBM
The SCO Group has slammed as "inaccurate" suggestions an email from one of its own engineers showed Linux did not contain copyright Unix code.
The 2002 email, published by Groklaw as part of its ongoing coverage of SCO's copyright infringement claims against IBM and Autozone, was sent to a senior vice-president at the company by an in-house engineer and later forwarded on to chief executive Darl McBride.
"At the end, we had found absolutely nothing ie [sic] no evidence of any copyright infringement whatsoever," engineer Michael Davidson wrote of his and an external consultants' attempts to find copyrighted Unix code in Linux.
However, SCO said in a statement this afternoon, "it would simply be inaccurate ? and misleading ? to use Mr Davidson's email to suggest that SCO?s internal investigation revealed no problems."
SCO emailed the media a memo sent in 1999 from that external consultant, Robert Swartz, to SCO's Steve Sabbath, who was at the time the company's general counsel. The memo details Swartz's initial findings which ? according to SCO ? demonstrate there is cause for concern as to whether portions of protected Unix code were copied into Linux.
"This memo shows that Mr. Davidson's email is referring to an investigation limited to literal copying, which is not the standard for copyright violations, and which can be avoided by deliberate obfuscation, as the memo itself points out," the company said. SCO also pointed out its legal wrangling with IBM dealt with more recent versions of the Linux code than were mentioned in the memo.
"Even more importantly, this memo shows that there are problems with Linux. It also notes that additional investigation is required to locate all of the problems, which SCO has been continuing in discovery in the IBM and Autozone cases," said SCO.
SCO sued IBM in 2003 for more than $1bn (?570m), alleging that IBM had misappropriated Unix technology to which SCO claimed intellectual-property rights.
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Penn Jillette?s daughter born with a superhero handle - Blogging Baby - www.bloggingbaby.com _ Penn Jillette, of Penn & Teller fame, has named his new baby daughter this. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. That?s not a typo. Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette. She was born on Friday, and Penn and his wife Emily are, umm, proud of their little superhero-to-be.
========================SNIP==============
What a stupid motherfucking asshole of a dad this poor girl has..he named her Moxie CrimeFighter Jillette...you FUCKING ASSHOLE Jillette....FUCK YOU!
Why isn?t Novak facing jail like other reporters?
By Carol Marin
CHICAGO ? I just can?t figure it out. Why in the world is New York Times reporter Judith Miller headed to jail next week while my Sun-Times colleague Robert Novak is not? Why is a reporter who has written not one single word about a CIA operative about to be sent to the federal slammer while another reporter, the one who actually broke the story, isn?t in similar trouble?
Don?t get me wrong. I like and respect Bob Novak and don?t want to ever see him in an orange jump suit. Or think about him being strip-searched upon intake to federal prison. Then again, I never even met Judith Miller, and I don?t want that happening to her, either.
I called Novak in Washington to see if he could help me make sense of all this. ?I can?t say anything,? he said, citing advice of counsel and the pending federal investigation.
This is a confusing story that centers on two critical and, in this case, competing values: the rule of law vs. the need of reporters to protect their sources. This is, in my opinion, also a story of an over-zealous federal prosecutor and a mostly timid press corps.
It was two years ago this month that former Ambassador Joseph Wilson tore into the Bush administration for going to war with Iraq, in part, on claims that Saddam Hussein was in hot pursuit of yellow cake uranium from Africa. Wilson said the administration?s claim was bogus because he was the guy the CIA sent to find out.
It was Novak who then wrote a column citing ?two senior administration officials? who cast doubt on Wilson?s mission. They told Novak it was Wilson?s wife, a CIA operative named Valerie Plame, who sent him to Africa. The implication was that it was a meaningless junket.
Who were those ?two senior administration officials? and what business did they have outing a supposedly ?covert? CIA operative?
Enter Chicago?s own U.S. Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, who was appointed special prosecutor to find out. With a federal grand jury at his disposal, Fitzgerald began questioning not only administration officials but members of the press.
Now, two years later, the investigation is heading to a close. And for some reason that most of us have trouble understanding, two reporters other than Novak are risking jail. Though Matthew Cooper of Time magazine wrote about Plame after Novak did and Judith Miller of the New York Times never wrote about her at all, they refused to identify sources with whom they discussed the matter, and so a federal judge has ordered them to jail.
As I write this, Time magazine has caved and, against Cooper?s wishes, handed over his notes. Miller is now the lone holdout.
What no one understands, myself included, is Novak?s silence. Can he confirm he got a subpoena? ?I can?t do that,? he told me. Can he explain the distinction between himself and these two reporters? ?I can?t get into that,? he said.
For 41 years, Novak built his career and reputation by asking the toughest of questions. Now, the tables turned, he refuses to answer them. Isn?t that, I asked, grounds for criticism?
?No,? Novak told me, ?because this is a criminal investigation.?
By any standard, it is a curious criminal investigation. Even the authors of the 1982 federal law that made it illegal to disclose the identity of a ?covert? CIA operative have gone on record saying in this particular case the law does not appear to have been broken. Why? Because, according to federal legal experts Victoria Toensing and Bruce Sanford, Valerie Plame wasn?t working covertly, and the CIA, when contacted by Novak in advance of his story, never offered any objection to him publishing her name.
OK, if that?s true, what?s the law that?s been broken?
It boils down to this. Fitzgerald, in his zeal, has made reporters the criminals here and taken them to federal court to force them to disclose their sources. Though there are reporter shield laws in most states, there is no similar protection federally. By that standard, Cooper and Miller, ordered in court to give up their sources, break the law by not disclosing. With Time magazine buckling, Cooper may not go to jail, but it looks like Miller will.
Has there been a hue and cry about all of this from the media? Not enough. Not even we at the Sun-Times, in my view, have done enough to trumpet what I think should be our profound outrage at what?s going on. Novak is certainly entitled to protect his legal rights as he sees fit, but this is an issue that affects every working journalist.
But I fear it?s too late. The damage has been done, or as the Bush administration likes to say, ?Mission Accomplished.? Our profession, which relies on anonymous sources for everything from Watergate to Hired Truck investigations, looks lame and weak and fearful. And any budding Deep Throats, these days, have far less reason to risk a trip to the parking garage.
Sort by Trending