Discussion Locked

connecting to unsecured wireless: is it hijacking?

0 helpful
342 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

342 replies

by danag429

The hotel is providing free wireless access for their guests and anyone else in their environment. If they were concerned and wanted to charge, they'd have a password that they give to the guests only. But I'll bet if you talk to the people at the hotel they'll be glad you're seeing their page (advertising) and say "Enjoy, you're welcome".

by cactus pete

Every server on the internet does NOT allow pass through traffic.

ISPs have agreements with partners about fees for routing traffic.

And there will never be any way that your request to read a CNN page ever goes through my connection to the internet.

by cactus pete

There are laws against it. You just can't recall having read it, I'm sure. Or perhaps there isn't a law where you live, I didn't check. But there are, indeed, laws against it.

by unclerob

.... but you still don't account for the lack of security. It's an unsecured WLAN which allows unauthorized use which is the cause of the problem to begin with. If it was a secured WLAN, no one would be able to access the internet without being an authorized user. Take into account one thing: no one owns the radio waves being transmitted, as a provider you're simply the source of their transmission, in which case radio waves are really an intangible resource - you can't take back what you've transmitted. If you are providing unsecured wireless internet access, you can't fault the person who happens to pick up the signal and make use of them, the only person at fault is that person who didn't take the necessary security precautions. Once the unsecured wireless signal leaves the confines of your physical area and enters a public place, the person who happens to hitch a ride on your network connection isn't at fault. He didn't physically walk into your office and sit down at a desk, he sat in public lobby, got curious and snooped around and found that a few WLAN's were available and broadcasting a strong enough signal for someone to make use of.

You've mentioned analogies a few times and granted mine aren't great but I still think that the WLAN is unsecure, if you don't take the precautions of securing it so that an unauthorized user can't make use of it, you can't fault him for using it.

Let's look at it from another point of view, let's say that it is theft. Your unsecured wireless signal has left the physical confines of your office and is strong enough to provide access to users in the public lobby or even outside on the front door step of the building. Since this wireless signal is yours and you haven't taken precautions to secure your WLAN from unauthorized use, should you pay extra rent to the building owner to cover the entire area that your wireless signal is being broadcast over? In this analogy, the signal is yours as you do lay claim to it, and if someone else uses it without your consent, it's theft. Therefore it's a tangible resource but since it is yours and your allowing it to be broadcast to an area exceeding the physical limits of your office, shouldn't you pay extra rent since you're taking up extra space? Sure the radio waves don't take up physical space but the range of your wireless access point allows you to cover a physical range greater than what you currently occupy. What if your signal interfere's with another poorly setup WLAN and causes users to get disconnected and reconnected to another nearby WLAN. Troubleshooting, downtime, network access issues, etc. these all cost money - since it's YOUR signal are you then responsible for paying damages to these other businesses because you're broadcasting your signal beyond your physical premises?

Obviously this sounds rather foolish. Radio waves are intangible, once they're broadcast you can't reel them back in, they have no physical weight, color or appearance. If the unsecured signal enters a public area, they're available for use for those savvy enough to make use of them. It's not like finding money on the ground or stealing something physical (car, money, girlfriend? - HA!)

Plus if you want to get technical about it, we're not radio stations but since we're broadcasting wireless signals shouldn't we pay the applicable legislative,admin & licensing fees for the right to broadcast a signal into public areas.

I think it would be cheaper & wiser just to secure the WLAN so that the signals are only sent to it's intended user base. Once the signal hits the public, they're free game to those who want to use them.

How's that for an opinion! I now await the beating you will surely give me for being so insolent in my response to you; please take it easy on me, I have a wife & family - they need my paycheque :-)

by cactus pete

But you're right, this isn't radio. Radios receive only. When you establish a two-way communication, you have broken the law.

by unclerob

Thanks Max, Excellent point!
If you don't secure your WLAN, you can't complain if someone hitches a ride on your network connection. If it means that much to you that you can't tolerate unauthorized access to your WLAN, setup the necessary security to prevent it from happening in the first place.

by cactus pete

All APs that should be secure, should be secured!

But that doesn't mean it's OK to take advantage of an open access point.

Sure, they might not mind for anyone connecting in a "onesy twosy" fashion, but I'm sure they don't want you to make a habit of it, either.

Just because someone is stupid doesn't make you right.

by unclerob

....You shouldn't take advantage of stupid people, not because it's illegal because it isn't, stupid people get taken advantage of all the time (like the time I got married - HA! just kidding) but because it's not right.

But this changes this from being an issue of whether it's legal or not to whether it's the right thing to do.

Is this the right thing to do? - probably not. You are getting a free ride on that person's wireless network and if you're harmless and just surfing the net you're not doing anything worse than hogging up his network bandwidth without letting him know. The right thing to do would be to find the office broadcasting the signal and tell them to secure that network in a hurry before someone does something worse than surf the net on their dime. But I don't think it's illegal and the owner of the access point needs to take responsibility for administration of the equipment that he owns.

And if we're agreed (it's ok if you don't) that it's not illegal, than the question is ultimately one of ethics, is it right or wrong to do this?

But we humans tend to be a strange bunch, everyone has their own take on what's right & wrong but we're all built with a common instinct that instructs as to what is right or wrong for us. I guess that's why there so much conflict in the world, we can't agree on anything. Take a look at the length of this current discussion (don't get me wrong, I think it's amazing to get this much input from so many people on such an interesting topic), we probably have near equal amounts of people for & against the unauthorized use of this wireless signal, we're all tugging on the opposite end of this radio wave in question.

What's the moral in all of this: don't take advantage of stupid people (I could be one of them), try to do the right thing (everything isn't black & white and 256 shades of grey tend to confuse alot of people), secure your WLAN access points from unauthorized used and continue to take part in awesome techrepublic discussions such as these.

by 280turbo

I agree, that if you don't secure your WLAN, you leave yourself wide open for others to use the signal. If you leave you car parked on the street, unlocked and keys in it, that doesn't mean you want someone to take your car, but if it gets stolen, good luck getting the insurance company to pay because you were dumb enough to leave it unsecured. If the car was locked and broken into, different story. I see signs in public places all the time telling people to "lock your valuables and don't leave them out where they can be seen" I feel that this is the same, if you don't want someone else using your stuff, LOCK IT DOWN ! Why do people use antivirus - so they don't get infected. Why use a firewall - to keep others out of your PC. The same rule applies to wireless networks - If you don't want someone else to touch it, Secure it. If you don't know how, go on the internet and do some research, hire someone to do it, or just deal with it. If I found out that someone was accessing my wireless network, I wouldn't try to have them prosecuted, I would lock it down and blame myself for not securing it in the first place. You can't always count on people to do the "right thing", so you have to protect yourself and property.

by maxwell edison

.
Whereas the food in your analogy is consumed, eventually to disappear, not to be "sold" to someone else, the bandwidth is not.

A better analogy might be when a person steps into a warm buffet restaurant on frigid day just to warm up a bit. The person is not a "paying" customer, but is taking advantage of the heat nonetheless. Or perhaps a traveler using a restroom. It might be intended for customers only, but gee, one little flush won't matter.

There's a difference between using and consuming.

by cactus pete

You're right, no manager worth their salt should turn out a single [possibly future patron] person for using the restroom when they aren't a customer.

And if a stranger needed my [fictional] open access point for a quickie, I would allow that, no problem.

But that previously mentioned manager might not appreciate a line of people using the toilet all day.

So the extremes, one's OK, one isn't.

It might not be legal to tap someone's moronically open AP, but it's really not worth the effort to prosecute, either. The ethically dilemma is, how much is OK? How do you know? On what level of technical aptitude must the owner be for this to be a different story? Should it even be rated per that level of knowledge?

I don't know where the line is, but some things are easily on either side of it.

by tradergeorge

is that the owner of the restaurant provides these facilities knowing that a few non-customers will use them and agrees to the use as a cost of doing business.

If you really believe that bandwidth is a non-consumable quantity, you need to learn more about the infrastrucrure of connections to the internet (or maybe just talk to your ISP). Like the minutes on your cellphone plan, it is only "unlimited" until you exceed your allotment. Then it becomes very expensive, very quickly.

by sql_joe

Max,

Wow. You think its OK to break the law because well...its only speeding after all. Tell that to the hundreds of people who die each year and their loved ones....its only speeding after all.

As to the hijacking issue. I do not know the law, but if its being broadcast publicly, is their not a chance that it wasn't intended as a public connection? In this specific example, I don't see how we can call it hijacking when given that:

1) There do exist public access networks;
2) There is no way to differentiate a private network from a public one if there is no security or wanring notice applied.
3) The user in question specifically did not attempt to hack or fake a log in.

I also know for us, in order to have protection under the law, we had to put a notice on all our systems that appear at login stating the system was for the use of XXXX company Employees only...etc etc.

So Max, I agree with you about hijacking, but I still don't think its okay to break the law, just because you don't think a particular law is important. Some people think they shouldn't have to pay for computer software too - is it okay for them to copy from their friends? Who should decide what laws we obey and don't obey? If everyone decides on their own what laws are important enough to obey, then why have any at all? Where do we draw the line?

by maxwell edison

.
There's a difference between "breaking the law", per se, and acting carelessly or recklessly.

In some states driving a motorcycle without a helmet is "breaking the law". But hey, if a guy is opposed to it, and he's willing to suffer the consequences if stopped (by either a police officer or a tree), then there's no real harm done. The same might apply to driving 85 mph on a 75 mph Interstate in the middle of Montana. But no, I sure wouldn't condone driving 85 MPH in my neighborhood or through various city business districts. While one might simply be considered pushing the limit a little bit, the other would be recklessly endangering others. I think the former is okay, but the latter is not.

But that's speaking for myself. I don't presume to judge another because he thinks differently. If a person wants to follow the "letter of the law", regardless of what that law may be, knock yourself out. And if that makes a person feel morally superior to others, well, that's his problem, not mine.

Sometimes laws are stupid and they don't make sense. It's lawful for two 18 year-olds to get married and consummate that marriage, but they can't "watch the deed" being performed by others on the "big screen" until they're 21 -- that's stupid. It's lawful for an 18 year old to join the US Marines, but it's unlawful for the same guy to buy a beer -- that's stupid.

More stupid laws:

Did you know that there is a law on the books in Tennessee that says a man must run in front of a vehicle that a woman is driving -- and that car may not go faster than five miles an hour!

But there is a GOOD Tennessee law that actually states that driving is not to be done while asleep.

And also in Tennessee, you can't shoot any game from a moving automobile -- other than whales, of course.

Did you know that in Ohio, if you ignore a public speaker on Decoration Day (Memorial Day) to such an extent as to publicly play croquet or pitch horseshoes within one mile of the speaker's stand, you can be fined $25.00.

And since one of the strictest "law abiders" in this thread is from Michigan:

It is against the law to swear in front of women and children in the state of Michigan.

Bit it IS legal for a robber to file a law suit, if he or she got hurt in your house while robbing it.

And in Michigan, a woman isn't allowed to cut her own hair without her husband's permission.

In my state and/or city:

It is actually illegal for car dealers to show cars on a Sunday. (Yes, all dealerships are closed on Sunday - as are the liquor stores.)

And it is equally illegal to drive a black car on Sundays. (I wonder if I'm breaking the law by driving my black pickup truck on Sunday?)

It is unlawful to lend your vacuum cleaner to your next-door neighbor. (There must have been a Hoover dealer on the city council at one time)

So no, not all laws are created equal. Murder and rape is breaking the law; but so is having your barking dog in the backyard after a certain hour of the evening. To consider those two as equally heinous is silly.

Personally, I don't need laws, per se, to be my moral compass. And no, I don't presume to take the moral high-ground and attempt to dictate such things to others -- as long as they are not hurting innocent bystanders in the process. So no, I don't think that all cases of "breaking the law" makes a person morally inferior to others who might make a different choice. And yes, breaking some laws, in my opinion, is perfectly okay.

by nobby57

The access page is similar to the hotel's home page but it is obviously intended for the wireless guests. It has links to various hotel services and local businesses and theatres, etc.

No mention is made of public access, nor does it say anything to imply that it is a service for hotel guests only. It's a very attractive professionally designed page. If it were intended for the public at large it would make a good impression for the hotel; however it is hard on the face of it to make that assumption based on the page content.

I intend to speak to them when I go back to work (in two weeks) and if this thread is still alive, I will post what they had to say. I'm curious myself. As several posters have observed, this is not a real big question either way, but it does serve to illuminate one of the ethical dilemmas posed everyday by our evolving capabilities.

That said, it seems clear to me that in all ages and every time, much of ethics devolves upon the individual. So we do face new questions today, but they may not be much different from some of the old ones -- and our responsibility, now as then, is often exercised in secret, where the only person who knows what we are doing is us. What does it take to satisfy yourself?

I think if I find out that their intent, at the hotel, was not for the public to make use of their network, I would feel obliged to let them know and stop using it. Too bad, though -- I hope it turns out the other way!

by cactus pete

Seems like it's a marketing tool - and any costs for the connectyion each month are part of a fixed fee. Probably not even worth the cost to them to think about options of creating a login page, or having the text changed by the web designer [at $250/hr] to indicate acceptable use.

by cactus pete

Somewhere way down near the bottom I explained my position a little more: Here's a brief recap...

It IS illegal - but an extremely minor offense likely wouldn't even be noticed, let alone be worth trying to prosecute.

There would clearly be a line crossed if the unsecure AP were used for hosting a Child Pornography site - And the RIAA could probably have a case against hosting a music swapping server...

Someone else used the example of stealing $100 might be OK to you, but $1,000,000 wouldn't.

So someone took a penny from you, it's not worth even thinking about [to most people]. But the line where it DOES matter could vary from person to person. The fact that it isn't worth fighting about doesn't mean it isn't illegal - it just means you don't care. And that's OK.

by Member 26741217

I suspect that questions such as those raised in this thread are going to become more common in the years to come. As more "services" become widespread and available for convenience, there will be questions about who is allowed to benefit from them. As more "things" are able to be digitized and transmitted, there will be questions about who is allowed to have/use/enjoy them. The current "service" under debate is wireless network access, but what's next? The current "things" under debate are pictures, songs, and movies, but what's next? If individuals rely upon precise restrictions to specifically forbid use of "services" and "things" that are not theirs to use I think that bodes ill for society in general. I believe there must be an overarching sense of right and wrong that comes into play without resorting to being guided by laws, signs, or banner messages. I believe it demonstrates flawed moral logic to attempt to put the burden of controlling behavior on the parties that provide the "services" and "things". If we refuse to respect the interests of others in an ever-increasing number of contexts I'm worried about the ultimate consequences.

by a16659235

1. Buy wi-fi, setup and use suggests that the owner read the manual(s) and made a "reasonable" attempt to utilize this new equipment resource according to the many various features the equipment offered.
2. Liability? Placed on whom? Owner? or Casual user who happens to find an open unsecured line of comm.
3. Gazillion ("get this *Hypothetical* of course") methods to compare apples to oranges, lawns chairs to HAM radio signals. (ever think of that?)
4. Public domain? Is this included? What was the intent of the wi-fi? Private vs. public?
5. Did Santa leave you a brand new RAID-10 Server rack under the tree this year?

OK, back to the question: If what you did is called "hi-jacking" then clearly this is true. You did do something that was wrong in terms of personal integrity and self respect for other's property. Laws broken? Maybe so as well. (IMHO-It's also your own company's wi-fi as well giving you 'legal' access-unless you have been restricted from accessing the network.)
Nevertheless, If you see it open and it's unsecured, take a few seconds or more to think it over and make an ethical evaluation >decision.

Great question and thanks for asking.

by maxwell edison

.
I think the line will become obvious when you cross it.

However, another thought I've had is to give it time. Relatively speaking, wireless networking is still in its extreme infancy. We (as an industry) are still working out all the details, and given time these kinds of things will be worked out when all the dust settles, so to speak.

by robotech

This is a bad and misleading post. The law you referred to affects SECURED "computers" belonging to a financial institution or a Government institution, not Joe Schmoe's WLAN.
Most (if not all) of the analogies mentioned in this thread fall short of being applicable because they do not take into consideration the technological differences.
The (Modern) INTERNET was conceptualized and designed as a PUBLIC network, not a private one. Radio waves cannot be treated as Cat5 cabling on private premises, because the very nature of radio waves makes them public and accessible by persons outside of your property. Just as satellite TV and cable companies scramble certain signals that are not meant for just anyone, 802.x signals that are not meant for everyone should have basic scrambling of some sort, be it authentication etc.

The illegal part of WiFi access is: Sniffing the signals to break the authentication code, or to steal a MAC address that belongs to a machine that is duly authorized to use the network. Also, trying to break into a node on the network that has a warning about illegal access, or a node that has some security to which we were not given the password.
The issue is best viewed with the following analogy: A park in a residential area has its gate open. This is the equivalent to a WiFi WAP with no security. I can use the park, but I can't change anything or access the Electrical room etc. because the park isn't mine, neither am I responsible for its implementation, maintenance etc.
On the other hand, a Park with its gate open and a sign that says: "Park use restricted to residents of WiFi Gardens only." is comparable to a WLAN that is not meant for Public Access.

I've been to several buidlings where there are several WAPs owned by the same company, some are secured for authorized use only, and others are left open for public use. It would be very hard to prosecute someone for checking his/her e-mail by piggybacking on your 802.x signal, when it is a common/desired practise by so many other owners.
Of course, since the WAP isn't mine, I am not authorized to modify it's configuration or even attempt to modify it, since my intentions would have now changed from browser to intruder. It's like your home. None of us would object to someone running onto our lawn to retrieve a ball, but if it bounces in through an open window, permission is obviously required.

by steve_te

The question at hand reminds me of "...well, if ya' gotta' ask!" Although, that line even becomes blurred in our ever-evolving, cross-communicating world.

Initial logic says ...an admin that configures a WLAN to broadcast the SID is (a) desiring that others use that connection point as a public hot-spot or (b) that the admin is simply not privy to the proper configuration and security practices of a WLAN. If you take the "they asked for it" attitude .....please seek professional help. Obviously, not the case in this gentleman's scenario or he wouldn't have posed the morality question.

The question posed, itself, could be debated both ways, and possibly without end, nearly to the degree of p2p file sharing a couple of years ago (let's not go down that road).

However, the "right" approach to this issue seems to be one of doing the right thing if at all possible. The right thing being; if (for example) you have access to the IT dept. in this building, or can find it via some directory, maybe it would be the right thing to "ask" that department of their intention of the open WLAN. You might find that (a) they were simply ignorant of the circumstance or (b) intended for it to be used as configured. Either way ..everyone is square!

Obviously, it wasn't an airport or a coffee shop. Does one really "have" to connect in the lobby on a regular basis? Surely not.

It's seeing the forest in spite of the trees! If it feels awkward or one's concsious says "maybe I shouldn't do that" then 9 times out of 10 that gut feeling is accurate.

Play it safe, not sorry. No one loses a life in this scenario. If someone "were" losing their life and connecting to this WLAN was possible ...by all means hop on-board and apologize later!!! Otherwise, take the time for due diligence and ask the neighbor before parking your car in there driveway.

Steve
Lake City, AR

by kzin1

You travel around europe and connect to different networks.
Some teleco's block access to you because your home network
doesn't revenue share others let you connect. If a WI-FI network
isn't secure one can presume it is available for use. Just because
the wireless transmitter is sub $100 doesn't mean that you have
to apply retard logic when configuring..

by itaintnothang

OK, what is public frequency? HAM radios are public, CB's are public, and WiFi's are public frequency. everyone has a right to use that frequency. I guess when I listen to HAM radio I am hijaking someone elses conversation.

Its not the ISPs fault. 99% of the time they dont even know when a customer sets up a WLAN.

It is the person who set up his WLAN and forgot to secure it.

The anly blame I could possibly see puting on the user is the moral obligation to inform the owner that they have not secured their network.

Personaly, I have 2 WLAN's set up at my home. one is secured for my personal use and is inside my network. the other is unsecured and open to the public. all it can access is the internet, but that is what I wish to do for my neighbors.

I have 3 neighbors that used to have unsecured WLAN's, I contacted them and they paid me to set up basic security on their's. Most people dont have a clue what security means. and in most cases if they are that clueless, it probably isnt on a network that has any thing important on it. Maybe a personal laptop, which is rarely ever even conected.

Is it leagal?

Im not a lawyer, but my understanding is that it is public frequency for public use. If someone is not suposed to be there then treat it as if they arent. Other wise it is public property. It becomes private the moment you secure it.

by pineapplebob

As an Architect it amazes me how many attorneys think they know architecture and are "DEAD WRONG" yet espouse their opinions in a similar fashion.

Follow up your statement with some examples of law that specifically answer such questions and make your case.

by daguru

Regardless of whether or not a WLAN is correctly or incorrectly configured, any user who sends, receives or monitors messages/traffic on that network without the expressed permission to do so is hijacking that network. Should the individual whom created/setup the network be impuned? Of course. Should the person(s) responsible for securing it and maintaining it be allowed to find employment elsewhere? Surely.

However, the mere fact that a connection is available and access is allowed (without expressed permission to access it, one must be inclined to say 'inadvertently allowed') does not give way to the assumption that it's okay to do so.

ALthough I do not have a fence around my residential property, one would not (and wisely should not) assume that it's okay to traverse my property to get to the other section of the sub-division. My dogs would probably have something to say about it if someone did...as they have demonstrated their displeasure in that in the past.

by mrafrohead

and when you pass, I'll bet you get right back over again right?

the left lane is NOT to be travelled in. It is a passing lane.

by tantien

Such a great topic and so germaine to my dilmema too. I am sitting in my own home and I put my wireless card in only to find that, after Xmas a person in my neighborhood had installed a new unsecured wireless lan. I was instantly associated to this AP. They had renamed the SSID to (an example) "TheSmiths56GLAN". I've looked up their name in the phonebook and there is only one of a name like this in my very local neighborhood. I am a CISSP. I ethically had a problem riding on their LAN even though I could without damage or privacy invasion. I could call them, but I'm unsure of my responsiblity to do so. My gut tells me that this is not right or else I wouldn't be doubting my actions. I've not actively used this connection, though it is very tempting.

So this question/topic is near and dear to my situation. Any thoughts (need I ask?) about whether if you knew the name of the owners, you'd tell the owners of the WLAN in order to warn them or better secure their network.

by mikefromco

I doubt I'd let them know unless I knew them.
Nor would I have any great interest in riding their LAN. Why bother, my DSL works just fine.
The question in a public building or public area is more dicey. How would anyone know if it is private or public unless it is so named?
Personally, I think it's silly to rename the SSID and not secure it. I think mine is named linksys but only allows my mac addresses to use it.

by rmuldavin

Out here in rural area, I have yet to find anyone that can recieve or send wifi type systems.

But, I am "talking" it up, going slow, first establish one to one contacts with external antenna, then work with triplet antennae, one by one a network can grow, it surely with take face-to-face, social contacts, fine.

But all members of the family will likely taken an interest.

Today many people use the Internet in our rural area, few have satilite recieption, one T1 here, generally the corporations are using farmers land without honest payment, if any, to run the cables.

Wireless towers for cell phones are sbriingiing up.

Wire may be going out, but "evolution" is slow for product changes, except for total system crash, then the top downers loot the ashes.

But local independence for communication, that is, traditional "Congress shall make no law ...", like our Bill of Rights, depends on traditional skills.

Top down access to the bottom can be placed into a triplet balance with local access to the widest band communications.

Best, rmuldavin

by finleydc

In a similar situation I called and notified my neighbors of their open connection, and offered to help them secure it. I like my neighbors. Consumer systems are marketed with weak default settings intended to work the first time, guaranteeing an unsecure connection.

The true ethical test in this* situation comes when you don't know, or worse, don't even LIKE your neighbors. Your response then reflects your personal moral standard. (*One could argue that this situation is NOT the same as one in which you encounter an open wireless access point in a professionally managed network, where the admin should know better. However, if you were that administrator, wouldn't you want to know you had a back door left open? If it remains open after that, you could then argue that you have an implicit invitation...)

by mark2

I like you feel that when setting up my Wi-Fi (Unsecured) that it is open for business. I set up using a Linksys G using cables and external antennas on the roof so other people could use it!! I wish that everyone felt the way I do, we would have an Umbrella in no time at all. You can use softwalls and other way of protecting what you don?t want others to get at. Thank you for bring up this topic as it needs more, much more discussion.

Thanks
mark

by mgordon

The question on the table is whether it is ETHICAL. Whether it is legal won't be decided until the Supreme Court says so one way or the other; until then it's a bit of a gamble; although along the path to the Supreme Court is littered with expensive cases and you don't want to be one of them.

If all lawyers interpreted the law the same, we wouldn't need very many lawyers.

Still, it pays to be aware of some laws that would be candidates for being pressed into service in this as-yet fuzzy area.

ECPA: if you intercept communications via the wireless access point, you must not divulge it (Electronic Communications Privacy Act).

DMCA: Digital Millenium Copyright Act. Has provisions against decrypting communications.

Various wiretapping laws could possibly be brought to bear on the issue.

All of these that come to mind pertain to interception of communications presumed to be private. But where no expectation of privacy exists, these particular laws are not likely to be useful.

Ethically I have very little problem with it. If I put a telephone out on the sidewalk in front of my house, passers-by may infer that I intend for it to be a public phone. I might just be an idiot of course. But it creates an "easement" or in other words not only does the public enjoy freedom from prosecution, in extreme cases you can be prevented from removing the public convenience that you have created.

Suppose I put a telephone on the sidewalk in front of my house, with a long wire into my home. Is that a public convenience? It is impossible for passers-by to know your intentions, therefore they use the "reasonable man" theory to infer whether it is a public convenience. Since nobody puts personal phones out on the sidewalk where any passer-by can use it, we infer that any such instance must be for the public convenience. I too am not a lawyer, but guess what, lawyers do not make laws, legislatures make them and juries decide them, including nullifying a stupid law.

Whether you SHOULD use a "found" wireless hot spot is somewhat doubtful. You'd better be using encryption 'cause you might have stumbled onto a "honeypot" sniffing YOUR communications.

by mgordon

Good reasoning; bad analogy. The lawns of IBM and Microsoft enjoy certain "expectations" that are widely recognized and yet not ironbound. I speak of "easements" whereby the public has certain rights of passage. The postman, for instance, has a right to come to your house and deliver mail; it is not trespass.

Since wireless access points are a new technology for which no precise analogy exists, applicable laws will be bent from other purposes; sometimes in favor of a public view, sometimes in favor of a private view.

It certainly arouses my curiosity. From a radio standpoint, you are perfectly free to intercept the signal and both points are using unlicensed frequencies. Not only is it unlicensed, but it is non-exclusive; meaning you have as much right to it as anyone else (I'm not a lawyer, but I *am* a FCC licensed radio engineer). So there's simply not an issue with regard to the radio itself. The person that hooks up a transmitter to his network is acting no differently than a person that puts a loudspeaker in a public area for all to hear. If you hear it, that is an unavoidable consequence of the publisher of the media doing so in a public manner and in a public place. So, he is "broadcasting" and you are entitled to receive broadcasts. Some effort was made to limit this with regard to cellphones; for a while scanners were not permitted to tune those frequencies but I think that's been dropped as an issue, an abridgement of your freedoms. Now then, suppose someone puts up a microphone where it hears the emissions of people in that public area. Must they all shut up so as not to imping on his microphone? That's just stupid. So any reception of the public by a microphone placed where the public can speak to it, is not protected. The fact that what he picks up on his microphone he carries at his expense to some distant point is not material to the fact that he placed public broadcasting and listening equipment where the public can, and probably will utilize it.

I too would like to see this case law. I consider defective any law that treats wireless access points special with regard to public broadcasting and listening stations.

Of course, certain laws pertain to the communications you may gather. If the communications are encrypted, the the DCMA can be brought to bear; and also the ECPA. But if the communications are not encrypted, it is a BROADCAST and can be published, just as the USENET newsgroups can be published, because they ALREADY ARE PUBLISHED.

by christopher.seward

The postman is not a John Doe walking down the street. He is authorized to be there. An easement is granted for a specific purpose(s). Therein lies the difference. Easements are not applied to entire grounds, there are clearly laid out in scope and purpose, and area.

by thechas

First, especially considering the vituperative nature of some of the posts, let us please move this way off-topic issue to another thread.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=167266&start=0

I will not read or respond to any more posts in this thread!

Second, I am not as discourteous as my comments have been interpreted.
Please read the first post in the new thread for clarification.

Finally, there is only 1 acceptable reason for ANY driver to drive faster than the posted speed limit:

IF (and only if) a life is on the line, AND your getting to your destination mere seconds sooner will have a positive impact on the person who's life is in danger, then by all means, God Speed!

Otherwise, SLOW down and obey the law!

Remember, post your comments in this new thread:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=167266&start=0

Chas

by mgordon

What I would like to see more, is recognition of the "expectation of privacy" that pertains in so many other areas of public/private conflict.

In a public place, I can take your photograph and do quite a lot with it. If you are in your backyard, I can still take your photo with a telephoto lens but I am very limited in what I can do with it. If you are in your home, I cannot deliberately take your photo through your window with a telephoto lens -- you have a "expectation of privacy".

Now then, obviously your expectation might differ from someone elses, so a sort of community standard exists; in Hollywood for instance the paparazzi have changed the expectation of privacy somewhat.

In a rural neighborhood, lets say a small but dense concentration of single family dwellings or apartments, we can assume that people have installed WAPs for their own convenience, often to let their neighbors share an internet connection, but do not expect to have total strangers on it. They could perhaps make a case for privacy. But an office on main street whose signal covers several thousand square feet of public street and sidewalk; or the stated circumstance of an office building lobby which possesses a type of public easement, does not have that expectation of privacy and on the contrary, if the PLACE is public, or is a place of public accomodation (good way to tell is that if the ADA [Americans with Disabilities Act] pertains, then it is a place of public accomodation) then one can infer that wireless signals that are unencrypted are meant to be unencrypted and available.

I don't even want people bothering me with it. If I put a WAP in the lobby, please don't every one that uses it come bothering me, "Oh, I found a WAP signal in the lobby! Did you know?" "Yes, thank you, I put it there. Enjoy."

Now then, as to discerning intention; if it is not encrypted and the SSID is not "Linksys", then it is deliberate. If the SSID is "Linksys" and it is not encrypted, then yes you *could* be dealing with an idiot that did not mean for it to be public.

by mgordon

Have you heard of "strict liability"? It defines those torts (crimes) for which ignorance is no excuse; in fact, for which nothing is an excuse. For everything else, ignorance *is* an excuse although usually only partially. In other words, "intent" is a factor in most crimes; even serious ones -- it is what changes manslaughter into murder. It is why some crimes are a misdemeanor the first time but repeated it becomes a felony; you are no longer considered ignorant if you come before the judge for the same crime. But some grandmother that gets a laptop at Christmas and inadvertently tunes in her next door neighbor's network very likely has no idea. If they are both clueless, their workgroups are both "Workgroup" and sooner or later they'll discover this mysterious extra drive letter and start poking around each other's hard drives! Is it a CRIME? Duh! How can it be? If it is, the blame rests with Intel and Microsoft for putting SERVERS and radio transceivers in the homes of people that don't know what they have.

by mgordon

Preserve you rightful place in front of your own home? Sir, that is not your rightful place. Every city I have lived in, the street is city property and so is the sidewalk. If you put chairs out overnight, you have abandonded them, you have no rights to them. If you put chairs out and run to get a soda, you have not abandoned them but you'd be not very smart not to have someone there to mind the chairs and keep your claim valid.

Suppose you come back from your soda and find some men sitting in your chairs. You become angry and shout out to the police, saying, "These men are in my chairs!" and the police comes, says to the men, "Are these your chairs?" If they say yes, the policeman is probably going to lose interest -- the fact that the chairs are on city property in front of your house means very little; those chairs could belong to ANYONE and be placed in front of your house so long as they are on public property, namely the sidewalk or street.

So to drag this back (if we can) to wireless access points; if your signal TRESPASSES onto city property, I don't see what rights you still have to that signal.

by cactus pete

Sir or Madam-

Please look up the word facetiousness.

The reference towards "rightful place" in front of one's home was said with such an air.

by cactus pete

First, your signal doesn't trespass - the FCC has declared it OK already.

Next, no, I have no recourse over you having listened to my broadcast signal. But technically, if you then begin the two-way conversation with that signal and begin to use my infrastructure, you have violated the law. You are no longer passively listening to the broadcast, but are now actively using my resources without permission.

by cactus pete

Is some leniency. That you even demonstrated in the above scenarios - and the crime was still a crime - you were just guilty of a lesser one for being ignorant.

by mgordon

Private land is not 100 percent private or exclusive although many people think it is; and as it has been pointed out, public land is not libertarian; it does not mean you can do anything, although again many people are confused about this one.

Certain kinds of urgency or emergency create easements. All emergency workers have easement for instance; police or firemen responding to your emergency, even if you did not call them, have a right to cross your land.

The FCC has very precise rules about who can use radio frequencies and when, but an easement exists for certain dire emergencies.

Since WAPs are fairly new, the concept of "easement" probably needs refinement at law and I would expect to find quite a lot of variability in local law about it.

by mgordon

It would be a very good post if we were discussing hacking into someone's computer. But we are discussing listening to their radio broadcast and speaking into their microphone which has been placed where the public can speak into it. No "hacking" need take place whatsoever. Most laptops now come equipped to all-but-automatically bind to that unencrypted WAP and many people will make the one or two clicks needed to make the connection without thinking twice. Easier than tuning a radio; because it IS a radio.

by mgordon

Indeed it does and it speaks to intention, which you cannot very well discern. You must INFER intention by the nature of the surroundings and what is taking place, how often and by whom.

Suppose you sniff every day for unsecured WAPs from the competition. One day, a previously secured WAP is broken and lets you in. You know perfectly well what the intention was; and could probably be prosecuted, although I'm not sure what law pertains if you only access the WAP but no computer behind it.

On the other hand, in the stated scenario of a lobby, a place of public accomodation in other words, with a presumably long-established unsecured WAP that could have been secured at any time, an "easement" exists, in my opinion, that protects your right of access -- and I don't even say privilege. If it stays there long enough, the easement can become a right.

Suppose for many years your neighbors have taken a shortcut to the city park across your back yard. They've worn a trail. Then one day you erect a fence. I've heard of cases where the landowner can be required to remove the fence and maintain the trail; it has become an easement.

For the astute reader, be sure to secure your corporate access points even if you don't think you need to; in order to prevent just such an easement. It's just my opinion but I have relatives of mine who have ran afoul of easement laws on their private land and were not permitted to build fences or even restrict access to parts of their land.

by mgordon

Very cool avatar.

Anyway, I was hoping that the responses would discuss the various theories of trespass, public accomodation, radio broadcasting vs computer intrusion -- various ways in which various existing laws might attempt to be brought to bear for or against strangers accessing WAPs in various ways and places.

These theories will eventuall distill into a consensus of some kind which will eventually be legislated into law. Our opinions DO matter, although not by a lot.

by mgordon

It is not always effective to use the approach you have used. You must be libertarian and academic, as am I, since it is a very good argument that tends to be useless in real life.

Here's the scenario: I cannot rightly take a dollar from you against your will and the greater the sum the greater the wrong. But, suppose I and my neighbor conspire to take your money. Is it right? No. How about the whole neighborhood. We decide to take your money; maybe even disguise the act by kicking in some of our own. Is it right? No; it will be some form of extortion or stealing. A thousand people? Million? At what point does it suddenly become RIGHT? The answer can only be that there is no point, no magical number; and yet, we pay taxes, unwillingly for most of us, since doing so is preferable to the sheriff coming and taking our property at gunpoint. That happens because of "eminent domain" a philosophy that itself suffers from the same flawed logic as taxation. But the government does it because it CAN, and it is necessary, and we have some theories about "social contract" that you subscribed to when you were born even though it was the ONLY contract you can subscribe to when you are born!

These theories that stand in conflict to simple logic pertain to a great many things and are what create oddities called "easements" that I have bene pushing tonight. Easements are neither right nor wrong; they are "expedient", they exist. The constitution of the US does speak to "promote the common welfare" which some people amazingly think means their welfare CHECK but that's a different story -- the Constitution does allow for subdivisions of government to take away some of your rights for the "common welfare" and one of those rights MAY turn out to be your right to publish an unsecured WAP frequency and have nobody permitted to use it but yourself. But as we have seen with the fellow whose SSID is "SALAD", how can you possibly know whether a WAP is intended to be publicly accessible? There is only one possible way -- the presence or absence of some sort of access control.

by mgordon

What if you have put the microphone to your equipment out where the public, enjoying their rights to "speak" (first amendment) in a place where such speech is permitted, "inadvertently" intrude upon your microphone (the input half of your WAP). Is that breaking the law? You have made it impossible or difficult not to intrude. People must have a SAFE HARBOR, some way of obeying the law.

Your desire not to be the common carrier for their speech is irrelevant IF you put your microphone in a public place. If KSL television sends out a reporter and he sets his microphone down, live on the street, do you think anyone can be prosecuted for speaking into it? They have stolen nothing; they are not even touching the microphone. They merely speak, and what they say is carried to a million homes (well that might be too many for KSL). Have they broken the law? No. Did they know they ought not to be doing so? Bet on it! The fault is one hundred percent on KSL to not let that happen, and they take precautions -- first they don't let the public very close to their input equipment. Second, they time-delay everything to bleep out any words spoken by passers-by that they don't want to publish.

I have both commercial and amateur radio licenses. That undoubtedly colors my opinions somewhat. But I have strict liability on what gets "published" by my radio equipment, I am responsible. If I let my kids talk on my radio, that is legal but I am responsible for the outcome -- *I* own the radio, therefore I am responsible for its operation.

WAP's are radios; the owners of WAPs are responsible for their operation. A WAP is a bridge between wireless radio communications, laws and theories, and wired communications, laws and theories. Which pertains? If I ever sit on a jury; only one thing pertains -- the WAP itself and the responsibility its owner has to use it correctly. The public cannot know what is on the other side of a WAP; it might not be the "public internet" at all (not that there is any such entity called "public internet" of course). The burden cannot be upon a person who has no way to find out. Even in Wisconsin, it is possible to find out whether land is private. But WAP's? HOW do you find out? You cannot.

by stevebuck

Agreed, it is not a good analogy. It would be the same as connecting your notebook's AC adapter to any available AC outlet to charge up your battery. Is the outlet there for the floor waxer or is it there to freely use to charge your battery? I've seen it in every airport I go to also, someone stretched out on the floor typing away with their AC cord plugged in the wall where ever there is an available AC socket. If that's not stealing, I don't know what is. So, connecting to an RJ-45 port or an AC power receptacle cannot be assumed to be free. Tapping into a wireless network and cracking a WEP key is also a no-no. But if I'm in a public area and there is a free AP connection I'll use it just like the water fountain.

by bigaldepr

When radio was first invented, the question arose about the rights and ownership of the airwaves. You are free to receive any signal, and as far as the FCC is concerned you are granted the right to transmit within the certain frequency and power limits. There is no expectation of privacy associated with radio transmitions.

With a RJ-45 connection, to me this like a waste basket or water fountain. If it located in a public place where there is no expectation of privacy and there is no notice posted that its use is restricted, then it would be consider to be for public use. Connecting inside an office on the otherhand would be like looking through someone file cabinets. Privacy is expected.

At a minimum the system manager should provide notification at the time a connection is made that this a private resource and its use is restricted. This is the equivalent to a No Trespassing sign advising you that the owner of the resource considers it private.

Likewise the use of such a resource should not be considered private either. It would be expected that if you used such a resource, the provider could view or copy any files it found. It would be your responsibility to protect sensitive information on your computer. Most coporate policies provide no expectation of privacy even to the employees.

by christopher.seward

I agree with this to an extent, but I can give a personal example of a need for an RJ45 connection in a public area, but not for public use. Many business clients of mine have RJ45 jacks in their waiting rooms, lobbies, etc. This includes private businesses aa well as hotels, and even restaurants. I set these jacks up so that my clients could set up a PC to display information such as which room a particular meeting is in, or welcome to visitors, etc. These are not intended for public use.

by calgary

Hijacking aside you may open yourself up for eavesdropping from a ?duckblind?. I can (not that I have) put up an unsecured AP and wait for the flock to land. Once you join my AP I can sniff the link and gain all sorts of info from you. For instance, your email username and password are not encrypted in the data packet. If you have file or drive sharing turned on watch out. Just be careful.

by thechas

First, those who wish to respond or vent, please move to this thread:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=167266&start=0

I am not as discourteous as some of the comments have implied.

I only get into the left lane when I have a legitimate reason to.

Yes, in heavy traffic, I may feel the need to prepare to exit several miles back. Even then, I only change lanes when there is a gap in traffic. Typically, I am in the left lane for less than 3 minutes.

Yes, I may spend a little more time in the left lane than some of you like.
However, if the speeders would show a little more courtesy, the legal drivers would not need to change lanes so tepidly.

1. Give us space. Allow us to do as we learned in drivers training and wait until we see the vehicle we are passing in our mirror so we can safely move back to the right.
Also, PLEASE wait until we are all the way into the right lane before you close the gap between us.

2. When we have our left signal on near an exit, let us change lanes and exit safely. It is only after we are forced to miss our exit a few times that we start getting into the left lane early.

I am saddened by the number of people who take light of THEIR traffic laws.

After some thought, I think I understand why.
Speeding and other traffic violations are the only laws you can break with little or no repercussions.
It is the only opportunity you have to strike out against the system.

Why not channel your energies into something that creates a positive change?

Now for the Karma:

May all of you speed demons spend your next trip behind an Amish funeral procession.

Chas

by cybrsage13

You are wrong about the Internet. It was not "The INTERNET was conceptualized and designed as a PUBLIC network, not a private one."

The Internet of today was originally created by the US Dept of Defense, and called the ARPANet. It was designed to link the military mainframes together to ensure communications in the event of a nuclear war. It was a VERY private network, and they never dreamed it would be a world-wide open network some day.

Al Gore also did not invent it, nor was he even instrumental in its creation. He was instrumental in the funding of the infrastructure in use by what the ARPANet metamorphed INTO, which is now called the Internet.

The rest of your post sounds reasonable, though.

by robotech

What I really meant was; The MODERN Internet. What you mentioned I studied in college, so there was no need for the Al Gore line. I think Al Gore was the only person who wasn't laughing when he said that. Anyway, after realizing that the Internet was not going to remain PRIVATE, then the focus became public. RFCs, DNS etc. Everything adopted a PUBLIC focus. But initially, as you rightly pointed out, it was PRIVATE.

by cybrsage13

I am that asshole who has forced left-lane vigilanties off the road. I have managed to get infront of them and slammed my brakes...my 7 year old 100,000 mile car has has many brand new back ends placed on it, thanks to left-lane vigilanties.

by edmundjeevan

it maybe an security breach for a techie, but for a layman its nothing but an additional value-add so that he can easily get connected to the network.

by christopher.seward

I thnk there is a difference between what to expect at a university over what to expect in a hotel lobby, but I see the point that there may be places where to mentality of thinking it's OK to just plug in. Point taken.

by rwcarlse

I say use the hotspot if it's a "hotspot" or not. It's not your fault someone left it wide open for public access. With the way people set up networks nowadays you never know if they meant to leave it that way or not. I also think it depends on location. If your in a goverment building and there is an unsecureed AP it's my guess you should tell them about it (then I hope that wouldn't be the case). However, if you're in a hotel lobby there's a good chance it's supposed to be for public access. Now if you're using the network with Cain and Able that's when you've crossed the line...Use the public access for what it is...but don't abuse the privelege. That's what screws the rest of us.

by cactus pete

It is not a question of YOU broadcasting on my AP, arther YOu accessing a network to which you have no explicit authorization.

by christopher.seward

In the end, it comes down to one thing. Legally, if you are not given permission, or informed that it is OK, you don't have a right to it.

I give my kids one particular rule that covers most (but not all) circumstances..."If it's not yours, don't touch it." Works in my house. :-)

by montgomery gator

If it is intentional, companies could post a sign along the lines of "WLAN Provided as a Public Service". That would get the business some good will from your visitors, and avoid the need for conscientious visitors to make comments.

by rob

Totally disagree with your percentages. The vendor is under NO obligation to assist the end user with securing his/her network. Network architecture rests solely at the feet of the network's owner.

As for the home user, the responsibility lies squarely on them as well. From a vendor's standpoint it is a nightmare trying to walk untrained and technically unsavvy individuals through complicated and varied procedure.

From an ISP standpoint if I, as the Service Provider, am going to shoulder the responsibility of securing your network then know I'm not leaving it up to you to do the setup and installation. I'm sending a trained technician to your location and I'm charging you for the service. Responsibility doesn't come without cost.

Bottom line, if you're a techie and can handle doing the research and taking the time to understand what it is your doing then great, go for it. Otherwise, hire a professional. I don't see people wiring their own homes for phones, cable tv, or electricity. Why should they do it with networking simply because the equipment is available for purchase?

Just my .02 worth.

by ngl0578

it should not be too difficult for a vendor to change from defaulting security settings to off, to putting in a random code and placing that code in the manual or even on a strip of paper in the box. that one step would make off the shelf access points at least minimally secure right out of the box.

granted a wep code is not great security, but it is better to have the weak chain keeping the door closed, than not. that way, if a person/organization wants to put a free for all access point out.. they can turn off the security themselves.

by montgomery gator

..Is that animated Avatar from "Office Space"? Hard to tell with the resolution, but it looks like the scene where they destroyed the printer they hated so much.

by loptr.chaote

"Hijacking"? That would mean you took total control of their network, not allowing their regular traffic to go where it should.

It might be considered "leeching", since they probably pay for internet access, but unless it's ISDN or similar technology where you pay by traffic/packet amount.

But in this case, some moralists would probably claim that it is, but I can't really bother with moral and ethics in a case where there is no real victim.

If you started sniffing the network and reading mail, that is a different topic because then you actually invade someones privacy, but it's not worse than someone standing right behind their back staring at the monitor. Unethical? Maybe. Annoying? Yes.

But if one connects to an open network and uses a reasonable amount of bandwith that can hardly fall as unethical from my perspective, since there is no real victim.

[And one could go on about the duty and responsibility of people buying and setting up wireless access points in their home/wherever.]

by rmuldavin

Yes,it the local conditions determing user choice.

Like Black Hole string theory, it's Willard Gibbs "phases", "mixed phases", "eguilibrium" made into mathematical relations.

And so black holes, here, our sense of touch, to imagined for now, black holes at relative far distances, flat services, layered, information devives.

Leaving a WiFi without security, first, for my level of use, leaves the challenge of mixing machine language dominance, right now, maybe "fact" that four digits, (0,1,2,3) gives motherboard control of users machine, plus or minus, the complexity supporting the interneting and the people making their living, wager, fun, and "gain".

BEST, RMULDAVIN

by technicallyright

To alieviate any unwarranted access or attempts to access I have always tried to disconnect inactive jacks when not in use. Especially in public places or meeting rooms. Is this practical? I think so, just make it part of a process. When someone schedules a meeting room or A/V equipment for such a display, have the jack activated for the required time period.

It seems like a lot of extra work but it secures your network in many ways.

As for the wireless hotspot...if it is intended for public use perhaps it should be posted.

I think notifying someone of an open door would be prudent and probably appreciated. As someone else stated, it also makes for good networking.

by brazen1

So I'm thinking: If you walk past a car and notice the owner left the keys in it, do you automatically assume they left it for public use? Likewise if someone leaves the door to their house unlocked when they are not there, does that mean you are free to go on in and roam around?

by cactus pete

Most of the rest of thesee posts below correct you before you made the statement, but I suppose you haven't read that far. What I take issue [in addition] with is:

"It's not your fault someone left it wide open for public access."

It's not my fault you have no fence around your front yard, think I'll dig for worms...

Those worms must be there for public access.

by bronzemouse2003

If you shot the deer on public property, and it returned to private property, Law Enforcement would provide access to finish the animal off. Cruelty to animals ya know.

Not so with an open wireless LAN. When the owner shuts it off, it's off. And should have been from the beginning.

by cactus pete

I said non-fatal. CVould have been a scratch. I doubt that qualifies. You see my point.

Besides, hunting laws aren't federal [mostly].

And we've put to rest the argument that just because it's there doesn't mean it's for you to use.

by brenttj8

don't Architects work with copy written information, what are the implications of this?

by fedup

In Colorado, you DO NOT have to post your land. It is the hunters responsibility to find the owner and ask permission. So in Colorado, I guess, you have to ask permission to use their connection.

by awfernald

If they have access policies and procedures in place, and they fail to follow those policies and procedures, then they have by default NOT securitized their network.

ANYONE in the public who gains access cannot be expected to know whether they are accessing a public/private network, nor whether they are allowed to access it.

If you tried to "charge" them with a crime here, they would walk because the first line of questioning by the defense lawyer would be:

What type of WAP device do you have installed?
What type of security does it have built in to prevent unauthorized access?
Was this security turned on?
Does this device have any type of warning messages that would appear to someone when they connected their remote computer to it?
If so, was this turned on?
If so, what was the message? Did it state that this was a private network that it was not permitted to access without permission?

By this time, the jury will admit that the people wanting to prosecute this poor wap sap are just trying to cover up their incompetence and their failures.

I'm sure that someone will say that "well, if someone leaves their house door unlocked, it isn't an open invitation to come in and make yourself at home!" However, that doesn't apply as this is more like a hosped with free rooms, whereby if you don't lock the door to your room, everyone has free access (by design), and thus you can't blame someone for walking in.

As far as I'm concerned, if someone leaves their WAP unsecured, then they have done it intentionally for the purpose of providing free access. Why do I say that? Because I think if you are smart enough to put one of these in, then you should be smart enough to figure out how to turn on the security.

by cactus pete

"securitized"???

You're right, people who connect these devices SHOULD be smart enough to secure them. But they aren't always. And people who they pay to install them don't want to deal with support later, so THEY leave it open - the unsuspecting consumer is none the wiser.

Perhaps non-technical users should not be permitted to buy things they don't fully understand - hell, you have to at least have a driver's license, right?

When is the last time you checked the pressure in your tires? How about changed your oil? The break fluid? Flushed out the radiator recently? How much tread is on those tires? Before you started the engine, did you check the break pad wear? Are all of the lights working in the signals? Any indication of leaks on the ground? Ad nauseum...

I'm sure you do the respectful thing that any common driver knows is the proper thing to do before driving a car...

A lawyer can ask all the questions he wants to influence what people think - doesn't mean he's correct in any way... If you think lawyers know anything their researchers don't feed them, you haven't ever met one.

Smart people don't necessarily know diddly about APs. But if you're so smart, you should know better. Just because it's there doesn't mean it's for you.

by carltonj

Broadcasting a wi-fi SSID, and not putting any
authentication requirements in place is like leaving a
note on the front door of your home stating, "door is
unlocked, come on in and help yourself to anything in
the fridge".

I have no qualms about riding free on someone else's
network.

by danfugett

Maybe it depends on the sort of society members of the IT field want to contribute to building.

by starlift

We had quite a bit of snow recently and many sidewalks are covered... I recently saw a shoveled, salted clean patch of walkway going diagonally across a corner between two streets that I knew were public areas... I did NOT trudge through the snow and ice. I DID avail myself of the readily available walkway.(HotSpot). I also did NOT go from the diagonal walkway into the building it also connected to...(server files and network)... I will take any unmarked shortcut that presents itself as clearly, visibly available (broadcast SSID), but I will NOT go into your building on my way to the other street (the internet)... I am just grateful for the shoveled path, and will not tromp my wet feet in your building....

by danfugett

My responsibility is not diminished because someone else might have failed to secure their network. It is entirely my responsibility to know if this is a public hotspot or a private unsecure network.

In the end, this is not just about legalities and ethics, but IT citinzenship where technology is emerging. I think we know not to go in a door and get a drink from a refrigerator simply because someone left the door unlocked. Further, we need to not make excuses to be less than responsible citizend.

Dan Fugett

by calzinman at earthlink.net

What can I say? I'm a bureaucrat. But I'm also an ex-academic. When somebody tells me I can't do something and cites me a law or regulation, I have to check it out. If you read the law, which you can find at: http://www.swiss.ai.mit.edu/6805/legislation/18usc1030/18usc1030.html
it says nothing about this topic. As a later poster noted ("Bad Reply"), the law is restricted to unauthorized access to a government or financial institution, and causing damage or trying to deny service or cause disruption (basically, introduce worms, virii, trojans, and the like). The contemplated activity of hijacking a WiFi connection does not even loosely fall under the provisions of this law.

I do think it's bad form to do it, unless it is expressly permitted, but I believe it's a matter of good manners, not draconian laws.

Actually, for me, the issue is entirely academic, as the only laptop I have is for work and I only use it connected by RJ-45 (at work or at home).

by chasbeard

How can you be sure this was not a reverse honeypot? Read George Ou's article "You use my hotspot, I?ll use your credit card" on ZDNet. I think it either is or use to be a sister site to CNET. The link is http://blogs.zdnet.com/Ou/index.php?p=30&tag=nl.e540-2
The article discusses blackhat hacker hotspots meant to catch unsuspecting (not innocent) free-riders. It references an earlier "recent story on "Evil twin" Wi-Fi networks". Remember what your parents said about not talking to strangers.

Remember, also, that many employers are watching their employees' activities, even when they are not doing a good job of closing the barn door. So, while you may not have meant any harm, you can only hope that 1) you are either did not log in to anything secure (using login and password or credit card) or 2) that noone was keystroke logging.

by goncooflib

I think most wireless network that are setup in this unsecure fashion is probably by individuals who are not networking savvy. Some indivduals buy that wireless router and just connect it to their cable or dsl modem without establishing some security measures. This should not be use as an advantage by others to intrude into their network. If for some reason the individual suspect that his system is not perfoming right and calls in a tech, the intruder mac address and other particulars could show up in the router and that individual could be sued becuase of his unauthorized access to another person's system.
I read an document on the department of justice website pertaining to alerting an individul when logging on to your system. Before an individual logs into to your system a warning remark like "Unauthorized users will be prosecuted if..." should be presented to the user. This document futher when on to that say that this could be a legal basis for prosecuting a hacker, etc.
I think individuals are to exhibit some professionalism by leaving an unsecure network alone becuase you may not be caught immediately but a day may come when the log of an individual's router is spill out and the intruder's mac address will show up.

by tradergeorge

The problem with trying to make stealing access analogous to taxation is that the bandwidth theft does nothing to promote the "common good" you speak of. It does the opposite, by increasing costs for everyone else except the thief.

The theory of easements is a bit more intriguing, but still not applicable. An easement is, as you indicated, something that is created by law for expediency. But assuming an easement, as in the case of taking bandwidth where no law exists granting it, is still theft.

The concept of "access control" as establishing "intent", is analogous to assuming that if there is no lock on a door, it is okay to enter and take whatever is inside.

by tradergeorge

The best way to prove or disprove a concept is to test the extreme cases. If the concept proves valid in the extremes, it is valid in the "lesser" cases.

This is about theft, no matter how you look at it. The real question is whether it is theft to the degree that prosecution is advised for the worth and mitigation of the case in question.

by cactus pete

It's not worth arguing the extremes, they are known. We need to figure out where the breaking point is so that we can state what has crossed the line so we should care about it.

by scooterb

It appears it would take someone days to filter through all the reply's to this post. And there are obviously differing opinions. Mine is fairly straight forward. Whether or not it is legal or illegal would be a situation that would have to be decided in a court room. And I don't think it would be a quick trial either. There are too many variables. My solution is more simplistic. I ask myself if it is ethical? My answer, no. I say that based upon my being a System Administrator and Network Engineer. Now, whether the person who set up this wireless network is indeed qualified or not to set up a WiFi network is a question for further examination. I would think that any diligent SA would not leave their network open for intrusion. Therefore, maybe the person is a newby and doesn't yet know about such things. The proper thing might be to send an email to the webmaster@opennetwork.com and tell him that he needs to lock his network down. I can tell you this, if it is a government entity that has the wireless network and you invite yourself in, it is equivalent to tresspassing on federal property and the feds (FBI that is) will come after you. They will also chastise the SA who left it open, but trust me they will find you and prosecute you. I know this is a fact because it happened to me. I work for a government entity and in my newness left a mail server unprotected. It got hacked and I had to rebuild it and so on. But, the feds went after them and worked with foriegn governments to prosecute the hackers. I did get my butt reemed but I learned alot about IDS and locking down your network. So, to keep from rambling any more. I think that it is a question that you have to answer based upon your own morals and ethics. We should all know better.

by awfernald

You say your system got "hacked" and that you had to rebuild it, which to me indicates that the person did some type of harm/damage to the system.

What we are talking about here, is someone left open a port on a wireless hub, and another person got in, and used that companies resources to access the internet.

There was no security on the hub, no sign-on message, and no intent by the person to "hack" into anything.

In this case, why should the user "assume" that his actions are trespassing?

The logical case is one of several:

a) This hub is a free hub for people who are here drinking coffee or having a donut to access the internet....
b) This hub is NOT a free hub, but the person installing it left it completely vulnerable, and I am supposed to assume this is the case when it is such terribly hard work to configure a secure hub.

It's either A or B (unless someone intentionally turned of security to spite the company through proxy)

With how easy it is to enable security, I would always tend towards option A until I had any indication that the access was NOT intended to be free.

As soon as you get any indications of option B, then at that point, you are violating ethics and possibly the law (though I don't think you would ever be successfully charged).