Discussion Locked

connecting to unsecured wireless: is it hijacking?

0 helpful
342 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

342 replies

by Member 26741217

Just so I understand...

Are you (as an Executive IS/IT Management) saying that any action is legal/moral/ethical/right/just unless and until you are specifically informed that it's not? Does conscience ever come into play in decisions?

by rob

Well, your thoughts sound good on paper but be prepared to field hundred (thousands) of calls when the thing doesn't work right out of the box. Most end-users (in my experience) do not read documentation. They're first course of action would be to call Tech Support and complain. Fielding calls cost money.

by hyoi

I would have to agree with many of the other posts that I would have to assume that an unsecured WAP in a public place would have to be available for the public to use. Maybe the admin did not mean for it to be that way, but it isn't my job to analyze his job performance, or second guess an available net connection. With the prevalence of Public WAP's, any admin worth his salt should know to secure it, and if he doesn't, that isn't my problem. It becomes a problem when I'm using an unsecured WAP that isn't in a public space, or I'm causing harm/intruding on the unsecured network.

by aidplus

Its often not easy to identify who owns the bandwidth. If its there, it may be for public use or it may be unintentional. If you are able to ascertain who owns it, it would be ethically logical to ask to be able to use it. Dont forget, they may also be snooping on you when you use it.
But you are also legally bound not to use it for illegal means. If they pay for this extra bandwidth, you are in reality stealing. Mostly its for conviencne of guests and you really have no rights to it. Morally desist.

by scooterb

I would agree with you here bwalker@. If I remember correctly anyway, when I have signed on to hotspots at Starbucks, Barnes & Noble, etc, I am ususally presented with some kind of welcome page or something to indicate that I have signed on to a network belonging to a particular entity. It is not the same thing as justturning on my laptop and immediately being assiciated with an AP and jumping on the internet. If that happened to me (it hasn't yet), then I would immediately begin to question "How did I get here?". And again, I would say that if it did happen, there are some obvious lackings on the part of the person who set it up. If I walk into my local super-duper have evrything-in-the-world department store, there is no sign at the door saying, "Don't steal from us because it is illegal and we will prosecute you". It is simply understood that if you are caught stealing, they will prosecute you. I would consider it the same situation. There may not be any sign saying "You have signed on to the "Please rape and Pilage Me WiFi network"" but we as PROFESSIONALS know that it isn't right. So we have to have a higher level of responsibility.

by rojackson

The instructions out of the box of any AP allow for and suggest using security. Failure to do so, especially in a public area should cause the guy who hung the AP up to be fired. If I find an open AP in a public area then I am assuming that the owner has taken that into consideration.

I am a professional, and I don't agree with you at all. Exploring the network (if it is available) and "raping and pillaging" the devices connected would be unprofessional, so would snooping to see what was there, but that wasn't stated.

The policy of the company I just managed was that our WAP was open ][ as a public service. We knew it and made sure the rest of our network was secure. Mi red es su red.

by scooterb

I agree that whoever set up the network should probably be fired. But, according to your logic you are saying that just because it's there I am going to use it. That's like saying that if I find the front door to your house open, I can come on in and use what I want to and do anything else I want to. You , as the homeowner have been given ample education to lock your door when you leave your house, but if you don't that makes it okay? That kind of logic doesn't jive bro.

Leaving a network open for a public service is one thing. I would imagine that the enviroment you were in made it condusive to business contacts, etc. In that case it might be okay. I am not even sure about that.

I am sure that we weren't presented all the intimate details about the particular situation he encountered. This was just a general post asking a question that in my opinion equates to ethics and integrity. Like I said before, if we are truly professionals then we have to take the high road and do what is ethically and morally correct. It would be far more correct to send a message to the possibly new SA inviting him to lock down his network.

Think about when you first started out. Would it have been right for some seasoned SA to come to your place and plug his laptop into your network and start surfing? No, he would probably came to find you or one of your staff and make arrangements to join the network. It's the right thing to do.

by cdougherty

I've often scoured my neighborhood and found AP's that were unsecured. I went home, printed up flyers with information about the dangers of operating an unsecured AP and gave my email address for anyone interested in having me come to secure their AP. I charged $25 to come in, change their SSID and set MAC lists with a key and off to the bank I went. In two weeks I made $400, not a bad take for 10 minutes worth of work. Instead of taking advantage and riding someone else's pipeline, use your "expertise" and provide a service to those around you. My two cents.

by maxpower1111

No doubt your intent was honest and just.
But, to actively seek/find and offer to fix a vulnerability, without the owner of said resource first requesting that you do so; is a direct violation of federal computer crime laws. Believe it or not it's considered a form of extortion.

I can?t quote the actual legal term, (part: section), but I recall reading about it here at TechRepublic. The law was put on the books after someone less upstanding than yourself, actually hacked corporate networks then offered to ?help fix their vulnerabilities?. He was busted in a sting operation in Europe, and the law was subsequently passed.

So just be careful.

by rojackson

The writer said that he noticed that there were several open AP's. He printed flyers and let people know that he could secure AP's. He did not say that he actively entered the networks or hacked systems and then approached the owners.

The writer's initiative and entrepenuership should be applauded.

You can't help but notice an AP if it is broadcasting it's SSID that isn't breaking the law.

by elfhaime

It appears that you have indeed been the perpetrater of highjacking,but then so have I. Something to think about?

noun: robbery of a traveller or vehicle in transit or seizing control of a vehicle by the use of force
verb: take arbitrarily or by force

by rojackson

I think that your assumption is vaild. I formalize the assumption by using the brackets as part of the SID ][ NETWORKNAME means that you have stumbled across a friendly WAN []NETWORKNAME means that you do not want outside users (even if they can get in).

Granted not everyone is familiar with this "netiquette" but it is easily found when researched. Bottom line is that if someone hangs a wireless network out there and doesn't close it up using WEP, MAC restrictions or whatever then it is not reasonable to think that wireless users may stumble upon the network and use it.

by rojackson

The analogies don't hold. Stealing a car means you take someone's property and that they cannot use it. Digging for worms means you cause damage to someone's lawn. The gentleman did no damage, didn't crash the network, didn't look for servers, maybe used a few K of bandwidth for IM in a public area.

We live in a society where hotspots and ubiquitous access are coming and here in many places. Caveat Installer!

by rojackson

Really, what law have you broken by entering a network? have you accessed computers, have you tried to steal corporate data? Have you stolen copyrighted material? Are you sniffing traffic, stealing passwords? NO, NO, NO.

If I HIJACK a network...ain't no one else gonna get to use it, but if someone is gracious enough to share their network then they have proven that they "get it."

by rojackson

There is already a convention in place that allows the proprietor of a WAP to strictly communicate his/her underlying intentions. "[]" in the name means this is a closed WAP please don't come in (or try). "][" in the name means I know that you can see my WAP and you are welcome to use it, just don't abuse it.

If we all would use this convention then we could look at a list of WAPs in a public area and know if there were any that were open on purpose!

Of course there is the problem of all the "Linksys" WAPs.

;)

by vltiii

I don't have anything of value to add here. I just wanted to acknowledge your animation...very nice!

by vltiii

You don't know where to look!?!?!? The fact that you posted to this thread indicates that you have access to the internet. Try google or whatever your search engine of choice is. Try your city's website! How do you generally look up things you don't know about?

by cactus pete

Fine, let's make the analogies hold:

You replace the divots, you return the car after its use. Now?

by arlie1kenobi1

Upon hearing your story I had to admit that my thinking was the same. Yet when I gave it a moments thought I realized that my thinking was faulty. If we used the same resoning we could conclude that the person who didn't have their house doors locked was asking you to come in without even knocking. Company would think that everything in your house was open territory since it was accessable, and that they could do whatever they wanted. Eat your food, no problem, go take a shower, hey it's not locked!
I could go on, but I think you get the point. We ought not to think that everything we have access to belongs to us.
Arlie Black

by thechas

I had some new thoughts on this topic the last few days.

Basically, I have concluded that the only reason some people think it is okay to use any open wireless LAN is because they are not making a physical connection to the network.

Would you have looked around for a CAT5 jack and plugged into the buildings network?

Would you go over to your neighbors house and connect to his water hose, or outdoor power outlet just because it was easier than dragging out your own hose?

Or, even worse, would you shut off your own water and power and just hook up to your neighbor?

Or, would you drive into a neighborhood where you don't know anyone and hook up water and power to your RV?

Of course not!

Yet, some people feel they have the right to make use of an open network.

The only difference is that with a WLAN connection you cannot be seen connecting up.

Chas

by mrafrohead

Good point, if I saw a cat5 chillin in the corner, I'd stay far away from it unless I was planning on doing something I shouldn't do. I wouldn't even want to be seen near it.

Though a wireless network I wouldn't think twice about connecting to.

by cactus pete

We've mentioned that before, but you cobbled the words together very well. I can't believe others still believe they should do that...

by mark

I didn't have a chance to read all the replys to this question... but when we think about it to me the answer seems pretty obvious. A wireless signal is really no different than when I use to turn on my CB and pickup the conversations on various channels. Or tune my radio to various stations. With my satelite dish I can pickup some pretty crazy broadcast! If it is not the intentions of the owner or the individual who set up the wireless AP to broadcast an unsecured signal then the responsiblity is really on the owner to secure it. Now on the flip side, if you are using someones wireless signal...the right and moral thing to do is not to tamper (change) with anything on that wireless network..ie:router or other workstations.

by thechas

You are allowed to RECEIVE any open transmission.

You are NOT allowed to transmit at random.

In order to connect to a WLAN and use the Internet connection, you MUST transmit.

Prior to the CB craze in the mid 70's, the CB band was a lot more restrictive than it is now.

The large increase of users overwhelmed the FCC and their ability to issue licenses and monitor the band.

Even with the allowance to receive open transmissions, there are restrictions as to what you are allowed to do with the content of some frequencies.

It is illegal to make use of or pass on information from monitoring cellular and cordless telephone frequencies.

Several years ago, all scanner manufactures had to change their scanners so they could not listen in on cell phones or cordless phones.

Chas

by neil cotton

We also have to distinguish between what is public and what is private. If you are in a gotel lobby, then if we are talking about who the intended users of the connection are. We are not talking about private..(staff only), and we are not talking about public (as in it is expected that ANYONE can come in and use it). In the lobby situation you can assume that the intended users were Clients/Visitors.

The aqdministrator/owner would have no qualms about hotel guests sat int he lobby making use of this OPEN access point. However, if there were loads of random people, who just roamed in off the streets sat on the floor, utalising this CLIENT INTENDED service.

What we have to distinguish is does the responsibility lie on the hosting party to inform people of their right to use the system, or that they don't have a right to use the system.

In most cases, you would assume that places like a hotel lobby, restraunt, service station or meeting room would, they don't do it purely for the users benefit. They install these services to improve the service they provide to their clientel. They normally do this via signs.

ALSO

If you are sat in the window of a restraunt, across the street, the family living in the house over the road, have set up a AP broadcasting SSID in the window, becasue thats where the computer is, in the kids bedroom. Due to the proximmity of the restraunt window and the bedroom window, can you assume that it is provided by the restraunt.

Anybody that would be setting up a wireless network for public/open/or client access should be broadcasting a SSID that states that.

by neil cotton

--Quote-- KTC
"once I've "jumped onto" an unsecure wireless network, I have broken the law."

This isn't actually illegal. These is nothing in the data protection act or computer missuse act that says it is actually a criminal act to stumble onto a unsecured wireless network. The DPA and CMA DO define that it is illegal to gain unauthorised access, but their definition of UNAUTHORISED is actually the breaking of, or attempt to break passwords or encryption.

As there have been no tried cases in regard to this, no jury or court has passed judgement on the unauthorised access with no maliscious intent so it can not be deemed "illegal".

The argument is that it would be unethical. However the line has to be defined between what is construed as "getting in" and "just somehow being in".

Roaming scan with built in WiFi cards means that you could be using someone elses unsecure connection and not know the blind bit of difference. What if you set up a WiFi system in your house, however so has the guy next door. And you happen to be getting a stronger signal from one of his APs and you are end up using his network, unintentional - yes, unethical - no, missuse - no, unauthorised - yes.

by vegasitguy03

- 18 U.S.C sec. 2511 (2)(g)(v):
"[It shall not be unlawful} for other users of the same frequency to intercept any radio communication made through a system that utilizes frequencies monitored by individuals engaged in the provision of the use of such system, if such communication is not scrambled or encrypted...

conclusion: if its open, its legal
if its protected: illegal

by tejasx.patki

Does a wireless network fall under the legal definition of "radio communication"? I did not search and I am no man of law but my guess is that it does not.

by jellimonsta

WiFi is RF (Radio Frequency), therefore, it would be logical to me that it could be described as 'radio communication'. Not that I am a man of law either. IMHO.

by jmgarvin

I don't think the law really was meant for data and couldn't a slimebag lawyer argue that data is encrypted because we can't "hear" it?

by techrepublic

Can you legally connect to an unsecured wireless network?

Reviewing the only law I was able to find that is directly
applicable to this question:

http://www.swiss.ai.mit.edu/6805/legislation/
18usc1030/18usc1030.html

Basically, it is illegal to cause damage, enter and/or deny access
to someone else's secured network.

So, if you install or send worms, viruses, spam, etc., you are
breaking the law. If the network is closed, encrypted or MAC
protected and you enter, you are breaking the law. If you
barrage the network so that the legitimate owner can't use it
would be illegal.

This has never been tested in court and probably never will. I
believe the reason is analogous to property. If I leave my car
unlocked and you enter, you trespass. If you ask permission and
I deny it, you trespass. If I lock the doors and you enter, you
trespass. However, if I give you permission, you can enter.

When a computer connects to a wifi network, it asks for
permission, if granted, then you are not trespassing. If it is
closed, denies access or requests a password and you enter,
then you are trespassing.

Also, it would be a logistical nightmare to enforce this. There are
so many open public networks whose use is encouraged, Apple
Store, Parks, etc., how do you know you are not connecting to a
network that is available for public use. The only answer is that
you do know, if it is closed, asks for a password or denies access
to the connection request, it is NOT available for public use.

Caveat emptor, your information sent over that network is
unsecured and is subject to collection, and viewing.

Of course, there are moral issues involved also. Checking a web
site or your email wouldn't be a burden on the network
connection, but downloading gigabytes from newsgroups would
be morally wrong.

by Member 29327465

I hadn't considered the nuance that within the wireless protocol itself there is a request for permission. That makes sense to me.

8 months after this topic started I still think that the hardware manufacturers are the ones who caused, and are the only ones who can solve, this problem. If unsecuring a wireless point were as difficult as securing it is today, then I don't think there would be any issue at all. We'll all know that an open network was intended.

Ned

by hozcanhan

Suppose there is a house , you are passing by , and the doors and windows are wide open . Suppose a beautiful brunette ( change the brunette with a "couple" or handsome blonde soap opera actor for our ladies eyes) is appearing half naked through this door and then that door and a little later through the window. NOW ...
what "legalities or general ettiquitte" can you talk about , when your eyes "involuntarily" look to catch more details out of curiosity . It is the free will of the house owner to close or open the doors/windows. But , if you step into the garden/backyard and take a pair of binaculars or climb the tree in the garden to "satisfy" some "further curiosity" then you are stepping into legalities and ettiquitte ..Until that step ......no one can indict you ...

by maxwell edison

.
To be analogous to "looking into the house", one would have to suggest that he would be looking into the corporate network that was left open. No one suggested that.

A better analogy would be to sit out on the sidewalk listening to the music coming from the house, which could be heard by whomever passed by, because they left a window open.

by mvmughal

If the medium used is "public" frequency and not secure I don't think there is any problem.

In the comment from "Ned Rhinelander (CNET)" he stated "no one gave me permission to connect..." No one gives you permission to connect to any radio station, no one gives you permission to connect to the emegerency channels and listen in on scanners, no one give you permission to connect to news feeds using those huge dishes... They are all public frequencies. If they don't want you they scramble their signals.

The same is true with wireless if someone doesn't want you secure it... it's public frequency in public space! How about a step further public space in your private home, your neighbors access points blasting that ssid into your private space announcing "I'm SSID-X connect to me"?

by aph

The FCC doesn't count wardriving as illegal, as per this quote from FCC spokesman Jim Schlichting. (http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/computing/personaltech/20050613-9999-lz1b13canned.html).

"Schlichting said the FCC has no regulations against using an unsecured wireless signal that is 'transmitted into the public domain.'"

However, later on in the article, an ISP (Cox Communications) weighs in that if you leave your network unsecure, you're enabling theft of services. So the user is held liable, not the hijacker, depending on the ISP's terms of service.

So, while it's not illegal, the ethics are shady at best.

by cybdiver1

Don't quote me, but I think the FCC regulations regulations arding transmitted signals applies.As long as the signal is not military or scrambled it's yours. You can refrence similar regulations with regard to Satalite TV.
Any Lawyers available to back me?

by sql_joe

I agree there are just some very stupid laws on the books,

AND I agree with you that it is insane that you can die for your country, but you can't have a drink before you do it. Its also very silly that its legal for people to have sex, but they can't watch it.

I'm certainly not trying to take the moral high ground here, nor am I qualified for that role. It just goes back to my original question. Where do we draw the line?

We have about a teenager a month getting killed locally, why? Because they're speeding. It doesn't help when you watch their parents passing illegally and exceeding the speed limit. Then, for some reason, they blame the roads, or the driver being passed (who was driving the limit), or something else YET no one would be dead if all they did was drive the limit. A silly law? If you ask anyone, then the answer is yes. The damage and death toll tell another story.

As to equality of how heinous a crime is. I can't answer that - though I kind of thought that's what sentencing, fines, and level of enforcement were sort of about.

George

This discussion is closed to new replies.