Discussion Locked

Considering dropping cable for satellite

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm considering dropping cable television service for a satellite service because of Time-Warner's prices. I don't care about premium movie services, pay-per-view events, sports packages, on-demand services, or anything outside one of the 150- or 200-channel packages. I'd like one HD / DVR receiver and a second "plain" receiver for the older TV in the den.

I've only got a limited number of questions so far, and I'm looking for suggestions as to what I need to look out for. Here's what I have so far:

* Do I need to connect the receiver to a phone line? Why?

* Can I use the existing cable television wiring or is rewiring / additional wiring required?

* Can I get my local broadcast network channels?

What else do I need to ask the Dish Network and DirecTV sales reps?

9 replies

by tig2

I've had satellite. I have cable now.

In heavy weather- we get tornadoes here- your reception will be crap. In general, cable doesn't have that limitation.

They swear that you have to have a phone line so that you can order pay per view and so that they can both send upgrades to the box software and send you messages. I had the sat for a year. I never had a phone line in that house. Didn't seem to be a problem.

The existing cable in the house worked for me but the prior occupant also had sat.

All my local channels came in just fine.

I had DirecTV. The only difficulty I had with them was when I tried to disconnect the service. The CSR kept trying to get me to move the service to my new address. I finally had to ask for her supervisor to complete the disconnect.

I would add, find out what their disconnect policies are.

by charliespencer

I have a reception problem with cable in the summer. When the temperature gets above the high 90's, many of the digital channels either pixelate or disappear entirely. As the temperature cools in the late evening, they come back.

by chiefywiggum

i've had a satelite for 10 years now (dish network). no complaints, cable is more expensive and their service and choice of programming was crap.

you will lose your signal in heavy cloud cover. it's not necessary to have a phone line plugged into the reciever except to order pay per view or change your programming packages. dish gives you 5 dollar price cut to have the phone line connected - which pay for the second reciever fee.

good luck

by jamesrl

I switched from cable to satellite 8 years ago.

The reasons for me were that my "analog" cable was bad - reception was spotty, picture was fuzzy. Digital didn't exist at that point for cable. But all satellite channels come through as digital. Satellite picture looks so much better than analog cable.

I do get interruptions a could of times a year. It does depend on your location. I've never had an interruption longer than an half an hour. Snow very rarely interrupts - only in a very strong blizzard (not from a couple of inches sitting on the dish). Its usually hurricane type conditions. My receiver has an antenna attachment so I can plug in rabbit ears for channels that satellite doesn't provide, or if the reception goes.

Heres the answers to your questions:

Do I need to connect the receiver to a phone line? Why?

If you don't use Pay Per View, then you don't need this. Your provider may have the ability to order PPV without calling an operator, by using a modem built in to the receiver. I never use this anymore. It is handier than calling on the phone and waiting on hold for an operator.

Can I use the existing cable television wiring or is rewiring / additional wiring required?

Satellite cabling is different than regular cable coax, in that it passes electrical current to the satellite dish's receiving head. You need new cabling.

* Can I get my local broadcast network channels?
Depends on the offering of your provider. My provider gives me 95% of the channels I could get by antenna and many many more. There are some anomolies. I get Fox Rochester instead of Fox Buffalo, though Buffalo is closer to Toronto. The added value, and something I can't get from cable, is I also get all the major networks in time zones across the country. I don't get every CTV, CBC or Global station across the country, but I do get a couple in each timezone, and that gives me options for timeshifting. If I miss the beginning of a show, I can wait till it comes around again. Even some of the specialty channels now have east and west channels (History, Showcase etc).

Much of what you want to ask is around packages - you want the flexibility to drop or add channels easily. The more flexibility the better.

As for location - they should be able to quickly tell you - if you are on the side of a mountain, you may get great reception or none at all depending on where the actual satellite is. Note that the difference between great and good is not visible - digital is digital. Medicocre reception means you may get dropped more often.

I installed my own BTW. But if they offer free installation, take it.

James

by jdclyde

I have not heard anything good about internet over a satellite over cable/dsl other than it is available in remote locations where cable/dsl are not.

by jamesrl

My provider sold me a receiver that could be used for internet, but they don't have the service.

One of my staff live in a remote location and can't get DSL or cable. I've priced satellite and its still pretty pricey.

James

by charliespencer

I certainly am not considering using the satellite for Internet connectivity, primarily because it's very expensive. I am going to ask if either satellite company offers a DSL at a bundled rate.

This discussion is closed to new replies.