Discussion Locked

Countries in the UN against the U.S.

0 helpful
178 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Someone sent the following information to me in an email. I went to Google to try to verify the information. According to Snopes.com, http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/outrage/unvote.asp , their results were even worse (An excerpt from their page is below).

Now, I know that the U.S. tried Isolationism before and found out it didn?t work very well, for us, or for the rest of the world. And, I don?t think it would work now. However, I?m beginning to wonder, since there are so many countries that hate us and are so against us, if we should quit sending all this money to them and start using it here. I think it could very well help fix our own house to where it should be. Even if we just cut all of it in half. That way the other nations are still getting money from us but just not as much. Also, we would have a whole lot more money here to fix things. Of course, I know if we did that these other countries would start in even more loudly than they are now about how the ?U.S. should do more for us because they are so rich and we are so poor.? Well, they hate us already so what would it matter if they did start yelling louder?

Now, do I think we could or should do this? I don?t know but it sure is getting more tempting? What do you guys think?

(The email sent to me)
How they vote in the United Nations:

Below are the actual voting records of various Arabic/Islamic States which are recorded in both the US State Department and United Nations records:

Kuwait votes against the United States 67% of the time
Qatar votes against the United States 67% of the time
Morocco votes against the United States 70% of the time
United Arab Emirates votes against the U. S. 70% of the time.
Jordan votes against the United States 71% of the time.
Tunisia votes against the United States 71% of the time.
Saudi Arabia votes against the United States 73% of the time.
Yemen votes against the United States 74% of the time.
Algeria votes against the United States 74% of the time.
Oman votes against the United States 74% of the time.
Sudan votes against the United States 75% of the time.
Pakistan votes against the United States 75% of the time.
Libya votes against the United States 76% of the time.
Egypt votes against the United States 79% of the time.
Lebanon votes against the United States 80% of the time.
India votes against the United States 81% of the time.
Syria votes against the United States 84% of the time.
Mauritania votes against the United States 87% of the time

U S Foreign Aid to those that hate us:

Egypt, after voting 79% of the time against the United States, still receives $2 billion annually in US Foreign Aid.

Jordan votes 71% against the United States, and receives $192,814,000 annually in US Foreign Aid.

Pakistan votes 75% against the United States, and receives $6,721,000 annually in US Foreign Aid.

India votes 81% against the United States, and receives $143,699,000 annually.

Well, you get the idea .......

Perhaps it's time to get out of the U.N. and give the tax savings back to the American workers who are skimping and sacrificing to pay the taxes they receive as aid, and to buy their oil.
Disgusting isn't it?

___________________________________

"The results of this tally were even worse (from a U.S. perspective) than the message quoted above indicates, with the countries named voting contrary to the U.S. position on U.N. resolutions an aggregate 88% of the time. (Even though India is neither Arab nor particularly Islamic, we included it in our chart because the widely-circulated e-mailed list did.)
Country Times Voted With U.S. Times Voted Against U.S. % of Votes Against U.S.
Kuwait 10 61 86%
Qatar 9 64 88%
Morocco 8 62 89%
United Arab Emirates 8 61 88%
Jordan 9 64 88%
Tunisia 8 63 89%
Saudi Arabia 7 62 90%
Yemen 9 64 88%
Algeria 9 63 88%
Oman 9 63 88%
Sudan 10 60 86%
Pakistan 9 59 87%
Libya 8 63 89%
Egypt 10 63 86%
Lebanon 7 62 90%
India 14 52 79%
Syria 7 59 89%
Mauritania 7 63 90%" http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/outrage/unvote.asp

(Note: I'm not sure how to format the table in here like it was from Snopes but you can click on the link above and read their whole page.)

178 replies

by jaqui

However, we also surveyed the U.N. voting records of several countries generally considered to be close allies of the U.S., and those results were none too impressive either. Only Israel consistently voted with the U.S.:

Country Times Voted With U.S. Times Voted Against U.S. % of Votes Against U.S.
Australia 33 26 44%
Canada 31 32 51%
Israel 56 7 11%
Japan 26 36 58%
United Kingdom 40 27 40%
France 36 31 46%

when even countries perceived to be friendly are getting close to 50% against the us on average, it really indicates that the us is screwing up in a large way.

by old guy

That's the reason I posted the link so people could read the whole message.

However, that may be an even stronger point for isolationism again. (Note: as I stated earlier, no I don't think that works but it sure is tempting.)

Edited to add I knew my original post was going to really long any way so I did try to compact it.

by x-marcap

Were a real Piece of work... And, John Bolton is right, The UN is a haven for those who despise the USA.

It is a horribly corrupt environment.

Cuba, Syria and Red China on human rights committees. Give me a break...

The corruption for oil for food hits Kofi Annan's family, but they didn't pay it back to the Iraqi people. The UN is a safe place for piss-ant countries to tweak the USA, and try to give the USA crap. I have met British people who still call the USA "The colonies". The Biggest problem is the USA is just about the only friend Israel has in the whole world.

Look to see how often the Arab states and Muslim countries vote against Isreal. That is the real telling story...

by oz_media

The US was just as irresponsible and breached many sanctions THEY imposed as part of the OFF program. The US was encouraging small third world countries breach sanctions and trade for oil, that the US in turn was buying from them.
Just two months after the US Embassy's report to congress outlined this in a 60 page document (that was posted on the White House Site) they AMMENDED it and removed all but a few mentions of US breaches. Conveniently drilled for just over 60 pages to 22.

Why didn't your government want the information made available to US public? The document WAS provided by the US Embassy as their official report to congress.

It certainly didn't echo the Bs coming from Washington though, and the war was being justified (if they consider it justified) at the same time. Heap O shite from your government if you ask anyone with a brain.

Your country isn't all peaches and cream, trying to fend off the evil world around it, don't disillusion yourself.

by tig2

Isn't that figure higher? We provide the land the building stands on even though we have no legal power inside that building. As the building stands on some prime real estate and I do not believe that the UN pays taxes for the increasing value of that land, doesn't that impact the actual costs we pay?

by oz_media

That's no different than saying, they don't like me, so it's no wonder I've always said I don't like them.

Perhaps the whole issue is that your government has chastized teh UN for EVERYTHING they have ever done, though GWB does play a good lie when he says how much he trusts and relies on the UN.

Your citizens are mainly oppsed to the UN too.

So to reverse your clever comment, poerhaps THEY vote against you BECASE you don't like them. And yet you see it as the other way around, how convenient. Obviously a completely irrelevant and inapplicable comment on yor part.

Unless you can prove that the chicken came before the egg, of course.

by maxwell edison

So you think I'm stupid, I think you're stupid. What else is new?

I will add this, however. I've been harping on the inept and corrupt United Nations for years, and you know it. This particular discussion had nothing to do with forming my opinion.

by jardinier

unless they are linked to the issues which were voted upon.

For example: A country may have voted against the US any number of times over a particular issue. So that country may have voted against the US 80 per cent of the time, but always over one issue or closely related issues.

In other words I think the statistics are meaningless in the form in which they have been presented.

by jaqui

the war on terrorism votes? when only england voted with the us?

the rest of the world said get screwed, we will not support this act of terrorism.

by old guy

suggesting that the U.S. is the terrorist now although we are the ones who were attacked first?

by x-marcap

We will not let even our buddies to the North tell us we cannot defend ourselves.

There should have been no question about what should have happened. The whole world should be against terrorism...

Many countries don't want to stand against terrorists as they worry about becoming a target...

by jdclyde

Half the countries on the first list are the ones that are the CAUSE of most of the terrorists attacks around the world.

Can't imagine them not wanting the UN to do anything about terrorists?

by old guy

that "Since we had to start somewhere, we tallied the recorded votes for all resolutions put before the General Assembly so far during the current session, running from October 2003 to mid-April 2004." The key word here is "all" so that probably did include repeat resolutions. In the big picture, though, if that many countries, whether from this report or just from the general messages voiced from those countries, are against us or hate so badly then why shouldn't we cut them off or funds in half?

by Member 25348569

If you don't give them any money then they won't have any money to buy anything off you and your industry will go down the pan and then you won't have any money to give them anyway even though you're not.

Wooo! Global Economics is complicated...

Anyway, why should [b]they[/b] "like" you? Because you give them money? Hmmmmm. Paul McCartney has just found out big-time that "Money can't buy you love". I would have thought that you'd have sussed it out by now as well.

Who is the worse person: the prostitute or the person who pays her for sex?

So, stop paying or don't. The choice is yours. But please stop acting surprised or outraged that the majority of Muslim countries really don't like you (both of us, really) for whatever reasons. We have an armed presence in their Holy places while we try to make them over in our own image. Hell. I'd be pissed if you then tried to buy me off.

Still, if you retreat into isolationism and the world economy goes down the pan then at least it'll cut your oil imports.

Just my 2ps worth.

by jardinier

to make any comment on what the USA should do about foreign aid.

I was merely suggesting that these figures, in the form that they are presented, do not prove that any of those countries hate the USA.

Disagreement does not equate with hatred.

by cactus pete

They could have started at 1990, or 1980...

That would reveal trends and reactions to date-specific events.

These overly raw statistics don't mean much of anything.

by dawgit

Now there's a question no-one wants to answer. Almost every country in that pot supplies the US with something it needs to do anything. (except eat) Not to mention that the US is in debt to most, due to not paying for what is taken. You do realize that with-out forign products the US could not even have a war in IRAQ?? (geeez, the things they just don't talk about in the US)

by dawgit

constitutes 'Voting Against'? One could also say that the US Congress votes against the US in almost every sesion, in that (hopefully) not everything proposed is passed. Who decided what 'Against' is? It just sounds like more 'Neo-Con', anti-UN, B.S..

by x-marcap

Get the UN out of the US, the US out of the UN and the UN out of my pocket, forever.

Neo-con. I am not new, I am not a con, not even arrested.;-) It isn't in my mind either. I am an arch-conservative, neo-cons are moderates.

I want spending halted on garbage, and the government back in doing what it should be doing constitutionally... Do I like the UN? You have got to be kidding. I think we should let the poor souls starve who oppose us. Reagan's biggest mistake was sending wheat to the USSR. We should have starved them out. They'd have been in a better situation much sooner.

by oz_media

Finally someone gets it.

Now look at the countries involved, do you REALLY think that they would be expected to agree on most of the US imposed issues at the UN? Would they be expected to vote WITH the US for sanctions against them?

How about other counties like England, France and Germany? Do these ocuntries side with THEIR issues at the UN, I would expect not.

It's a completely ridiculous list of stats, it is 100% created to make Americans slam and slander the 'bad guys' and keep Americans PO'd with the middle east and other less prosperous countries and in favour of the war being posed against them.

Pretty bad, elementary school finger pointing actually. And as we see here, they gobbled it up like they were starved.

by jaqui

voted against sending troops into Iraq, so by sending them in, the US is the agressor Nation.

England was the only country that agreed with the US on that.

remember the whole "Freedom Fries" issue? caused by France stating that it would be a terroist act to invade to get usama bin-laden.

by old guy

that we are not allowed to retaliate for the destruction they caused in human lives here? To me that sounds like it's ok for any country to come over here and kick us in the butt but we're not allowed to do anything about it--just keep sending them the money. Would that make the rest of the world happy with the U.S.?

by jaqui

x billions to build the freedom tower and clean up the mess.

y trillions for the military expenses

as opposed to having the regional government pay policing costs to turn him over to you for trial.

does having all americans suffer under debt for 200 years make sence over having the foreign government pay for getting those responsible?

does killing innocent bystandars and giving their relatives cause to BECOME terrorists against the US as opposed to having them respect the means used make sence?

the "war on terroism" is a means to increase the total number of terrorists, for every bystander killed, you create 12 terrorists.

by Member 25348569

(and it'll probably wind Maxwell up) but it's not "country to come over here and kick us in the butt".

Al Qaeda - who are the at the root of all of this - are an "organisation" for which the main aim is to overthrow the Saudi Monarchy. Yes, Afghanistan may have sheltered some of them as the government there was radical islamists who probably had the same ideals. Anyway, you seriously taught them a lesson for doing [b]that[/b]. Unfortunately, I fear that the lesson is going to be taught straight back over the next few yearsas you're doing a wonderful job for their recruitment drive. Good Morning, Vietnam. Reprise...

But to move on from there and use 911 as a justification for the invasion of Iraq is still too much for me to swallow. That one isn't going too well, either. Good Morning, Vietnam. Reprise...

Just as an afterthought. What do you propose the UK does to the area responsible for providing the terrorists who carried out the 7/7 suicide bombings in revenge for the Iraq invasion? We know exactly where that is : - http://tinyurl.com/jm73j

Personally, I'd nuke the place.

by oz_media

You are talkin gabout events leading up to teh Iraq invasion.

The war that WAS justified, had your president callign it a victory and removing the vast majority of troops and funding while others try to fight the continuing war on yor behalf. Iraq wasn't the terrorist organization that attacked you and neither was Saddam.

Don't get the two so easilt mixed up as millions of Americans do each day.

by jdclyde

Having or not having UN support is NOT what defines an act of terrorism.

The UN is corrupt from the top down and has nothing valid to add to anything.

The frogs can go back to their own racist ways as they deal with their own 25% unemployment amoung third generation citizens that are still regarded as immigrants. By that standard, I would still be considered an immigrant instead of a US citizen. The hell with the french.

by maxwell edison

The UN voted not to reappoint the United States to its seat on the Human Rights Commission, but in the same vote, it gave a seat to Sudan, a country that tolerates the practice of slavery.

Source: http://capmag.com/article.asp?ID=903

Yea right, jaqui. I guess this "indicates" the US screwed up.

This is just one such example. I could find scores of others.

And if any other dipstick America-Hater, like jaqui, wants to suggest such a stupid thing as he did, list the issues on which the United Nations actually voted. Go ahead, jaqui, list the actual votes, qualify and justify them, and then make your stupid comments.

by dawgit

I do believe the US has lost it's creditability in that after the prision scandel in Iraq. And the rumurs of secret 'jails' (?) all over the place. And the fact that the US stilll has captital punishment. No, the US will have a hard time, and a long time get get it back. Sad as it is.

by old guy

That's one of the primary reasons Isolationism did not and will not work.

I'm not really surprised they hate us because our troops are in their country but didn't they come over here and do the kicking first? Actually, I still think the Crusades made the Muslims hate us to begin with and, yes, I agree, if they did that to me I would hate the christians (from that area--I wasn't there and didn't have anything to do with it) too.

by jamesrl

If you look at the Muslim world after the crusades, there are instances where Christians and Jews were tolerated, and even integrated into Muslim societies. Many Muslim califates has Jewish administrators(the bureaucratic power behind the throne). You can argue that in Spain, the Muslims were more tolerant to the jews there than the Christians who threw out the Muslims.

I don't support Terror from anyone, but I can come up with a short list of reasons why mulims hate the US;

1) The US supports Israel, with a huge chunk of aid, including military aid. Don't underestimate how deep the feeling is regarding Palestinians in camps in Isreal.

2)The US supported dictators in the middle east. The Shah of Iran was every bit as vicious and cruel as Saddam in terms of political prisoners, use of torture etc. The US supports the Royal families in Saudi, Kuwait and Jordan, while the radical muslims would like these countries to be run by Imams not people they see as US puppets . The radicals also dislike Egypt's rulers as they suppress radicals and made peace with Isreal.

I'm not saying the middle eastern Muslims are rigth and the US is wrong - thats far too simplistic. But it didn't start that recently.

James

by cactus pete

If you consider the beginning of time to be the day planes flew into skyscrapers, then yes, "they" came over here and started the kicking.

However, (and I'm not saying that I agree with this) Osama has always upheld that US troops on Saudi sands was a desecration. In his mind, had we left, he would not have terrorized (or so I interpret) in NY, etc.

typo

by old guy

the radical Muslims have always hated the infidels such as Western culture. And,they have been killing each other and other people that get in their way all through time. I think if you put those two things together they would have come after us one way or another at some point whether we were on their soil or not.

I may be wrong because I certainly wouldn't be able to prove this but I can't help but think that the Amercian government has always been asked to help with turmoil in these countries by either their governments or at least part of their government first. Can anyone show that we have at anytime just shown up on a country's doorstep with the military without that country asking for help in their turmoil?

Edited for structure.

by dawgit

If Saudi was the problem, then why didn't the US invade them instead of Iraq? (instead of pulling out what troops were there)

by old guy

while writing my comments on the original post (we don't have to comment on the shape or state of my mind :) ) I actually looked at that as two separate aspects. It seems that a lot of countries claim to hate us with their general demeaner as well as their comments publicly. I do think that the votes would portray some of that as well, though.

by jardinier

I am regularly accused at this website of hating America, but I don't hate America and never have.

I am accused of hating Americans, but I don't hate Americans and never have.

I don't even hate George Bush and his administration.

I DO hate John Howard for sending Australian troops to Iraq and subsequently and inevitably making Australia a prime target for terrorist attacks.

In fact if John Howard hadn't got Australia involved in Iraq, I doubt that I would have any particular interest in America or its foreign policy.

by old guy

reading some of your posts in other discussions it sure sounded like you (since hate may be too strong a word) really really dislike what America does. Maybe all of us misread your thoughts and comments...hmmmm. ?:|
Whatever on the past. At least in this discussion you haven't said or even alluded to hating America.

Jules, "I doubt that I would have any particular interest in America or its foreign policy." did you really write that with a straight face??? :)

Edited to fix emoticon.

by wingedmonkey

1. Has the money giving made a difference? The figures do not look good on paper now, but would the percentage of votes against the US have been higher if the money had not been given.

2. Does the voting mean anything anymore. G.W. went ahead with his plans inspite of the opposition.

3. I agree with the idea that the giving of the money is an attempt to curry favor. But if the end gain is not votes for the US, then what instead is being gained by the giving of the money gifts. There may a lot more to this picture.

by old guy

that there may be a lot more to this picture. Aside from all the aid the U.S. furnishes for different countries, especially in emergencies, such as Tsunamis etc. there is usually a tremendous amount of aid furnished by churches and private donations to countries during these times. Maybe the money might have a political agenda from the government but it sure seems like the U.S. has always tried to take care of people (countries) in need because we feel we should. When I have donated for specific causes, such as disasters it had nothing to do with trying to make these folks like us. It was just because we needed to. In spite of all this it seems that, according to a lot of these other countries, nothing we do is right or good enough for them. If that's the case then why do we keep it up? IMO, that's just us--we've always tried to help out people in need.

by old guy

I think you said to let the regional governments pay for policing costs. If you mean let the local governments in those countries take care of turning over the terriosts then it's quite obvious they don't have the means, knowledge, or desire to do so without being pushed.

I think you are correct in the fact that this probably is increasing the number of terrorists. Unfortunately, I don't think we could nuke all muslim countries and completely wipe out anyone who even desires to be a terrorist at one time without really having problems. For a lot of people a typical kneejerk reaction would be just that--nuke 'em all. I don't think that is a viable option. However, to say that we are now the "terrorists" because we want to stop that from happening again is just totally incorrect. It seems that these actual terrorist just wants to hurt America in any way they can. How do you stop them?

by jardinier

does not equate with hating America or Americans.

And yes I did write that comment with a straight face because it is the simple truth. I joined TR shortly before the invasion of Iraq and the first long discussion I recall was titled: "Why?" I don't recall the actual slant of the discussion but it was questioning the whole thing about terrorists and the imminent invasion of Iraq.

The Labor Party in Australia was strongly against the idea of joining the COW, but they were in opposition so there was nothing they could do about. Actually the whole business was shonky because my understanding has been (perhaps I am wrong) that before declaring war on a country the matter should be debated by the whole parliament.

Well I don't know the legalities of it but it was pretty clear that it was Howard's personal decision and I don't really know why he made that decision.

I now see that it was a mistake to announce that I was a journalist because, as the only person in these discussions who has claimed a background in the media, I have been the scapegoat for everyone's gripes about the media in general.

Although Max will never admit it, the reporting of the war in Iraq -- especially by the Sydney Morning Herald journalist, Paul McGeough -- has proven in retrospect to be totally accurate and fair in every way.

Apparently it is a concept which cannot be grasped by (some) Americans, that a major metropolitan daily newspaper can remain politically neutral.

Well I suppose Maxwell won't be able to resist butting in here but I no longer take him seriously and so I'll let him stand on his soapbox and blabber on with his predictable and unchanging views.

by cactus pete

If you nuked all Islamic countries, would you get all the terrorists?

If you nuked all Muslims, would there be any countries not affected?

If you nuked all Islamic countries, would that be a rational and equal reaction?

If you nuked all the Islamic countries, would you prove the terrorists right?

The action in Afghanistan wasn't (isn't) finished, but I'm sorry to say that I feel resources that should be there are now diverted elsewhere.

The answer, I think, should have been to stay focused and remove the proven terrorists completely. At the moment, I think we've abondoned the known for the unknown.

by cactus pete

OK, I'm familiar with the M1 and roads of such designation from my travels, but What's with all the As? Autoways?

by old guy

that I personally do not think that the answer would be to nuke anyone. That would not actually resolve the issue and would actually cause untold more issues.

I wish I had a perfect answer. However, due to all of these circumstances it certainly is take care of our own house first. That would mean cutting off a lot of aid. Maybe if President Bush and/or Congress sent a message to all the other governments, "you keep your terrorists away from the U.S. and then we will send you money." Otherwise, no money--take care of your own stuff. That could let us have more money and resources for better security on our own shores to maybe keep out the terrorists. Hmmm.

by jdclyde

If the money was not taxed so heavily on the citizens, they would have the money to buy our products ourselves.

It is a not hard to figure that HALF of all funds is wasted on overhead and corruption when ever there is a handoff between two countries. (assuming even HALF gets to anywhere but the corrupt leaders pockets).

Let the people that make the money, spend the money.

You are an ally or your not. Canada and the UK are seen to be allies. This does not mean they have to do as we tell them (all the time). It means they have similar ideals and goals that should lead both to similar conclusions more often than not.

The frogs? Just petty people pissed that they are not a world power in anyway. Like a yappy little dog.

Isolationism is not the answer.

To stop wasting money on people that are ungrateful and undeserving is a good start.

Get out of the muslim countries. let them go back to killing each other like the curs they are, instead of us.

Who ever is alive when it is over, try to make them a trade partner.

Natural selection at work? A weaker species is always replaced by a more stronger species.

by Member 25348569

We could have started a couple of countries ago by not invading in the first place...

Some things are so obvious, Doctor Watson, that they need not be stated!

by Member 25348569

The A-roads are the main trunk routes that existed pre-motorway. They work in a rough radial system out of London - A1 goes North up the East side, A2 East, A3 South West, A4 West, a5 North West around to the A6, North up the West side.

Within each "pie-slice" there are more roads with two-digit numbers and these are usually main routes also, either running parallel to the main route or in some cases running between them. i.e. between the A2 and the A3 there is, moving clockwise, A20, A21, A22 and so on. They carry on subdividing from there. We do not do grids! :)

Leeds has the A1 - main N/S route running to the East and has the A6 running up across the other side of the Pennines in the West so most of the roads are A6x or A6xx. The green routes are major routes and the red ones less so and this is not always reflected in the numbers.

We carry on until we've got to the end of three digits. Then we start on the B roads...

Motorways are named (roughly) after the most appropriate A-road although the M5 doesn't fit a damn thing.

There's a similar scheme for for Scotland starting with the A7.

Neil :D

Provided free of charge by NITS (tm) so visiting Yanks don't get (very) lost.

p.s. A lot of the roads were there before population shifts and have been widened - some have not. Others have been replaced by the motorways and have been left so you have absoulutely no idea what sort of road you'll find once you stray off the Motorways. Since the M1 motorway was opened, for instance, the A5 disappears for one long stretch running out of London, being replaced by the A5183. This can be really confusing seeing as the damn road has been in the same place since 62AD!

Just assume that our roads are five time busier than yours and much narrower and you'll be a little better prepared.

by Member 25348569

"just shown up on a country's doorstep"

We interfered in Afghanistan when the Russians were there and it's gone on since. When we invaded this time, of course the Taliban begged for our help. They didn't? Ooops.

We certainly showed up uninvited in Iraq!

I'm not disagreeing with you about the Islamic threat, by the way, I just really think that we've gone about it in the wrong way and all we're succeeding in doing is to make it worse in every way.

by cactus pete

...has a way of kinda lingering for a while. Sure, the Saudis gave us permission to stage in their country while fighting the "first" Iraq war. But then we didn't leave. Osama felt that we should have gotten out.

And yes, radical people tend to remain radical. That doesn't mean we seek them all out. It's better to isolate them and protect ourselves from the (perhaps) eventual. But if we remain somewhere down on the list (ie not at the top of the list) of grievences, then we won't be a likely target.

And remember, we created the power that Osama wielded. We need to get out of that business.

(And we supported several other nasty guys throughout history, only to have them turn on us, or us turn on them, creating bigger issues than we had to start with)

by old guy

JD's comments: "To stop wasting money on people that are ungrateful and undeserving is a good start.

Get out of the muslim countries. let them go back to killing each other like the curs they are, instead of us."

When could we start wasting our money on people who are ungrateful and undeserving? Also when could we go ahead and get our of the muslim countries so they could go back to killing each other? Isn't that what they want anyway, is for us to leave their countries? Then let's leave them to their own devices.

by jamesrl

....was that they pretty much ignored the west until the west started playing in the Middle east. Anyone recall any muslim terror attacks (other than during wartime or against Jews in Palestine) prior to the formation of the State of Isreal?

As for showing up with Military univited, lets see. Cuba - you showed up with a warship (the Maine) to intimidate, it was blown up, war started. China - boxer rebellion - not invited by China, but the Chinese government was fractured.

Cuba again - Bay of Pigs - not invited.

Afghanistan(helping Osama and co (covertly but not really covertly) throw the Russians out) - not invited.

Grenada - not invited.

Panama - not invited.

Somalia -not invited but no real government (there still isn't)

Does that help?

James

by x-marcap

The whole Mid-East was a large, vast wasteland of nomadic tribesmen. If we had less dependence on Foreign Oil, we'd only need to worry about Israel's security.

England had a hand in those borders, too...

by cactus pete

Never really made sense to me. They do seem so arbitrary. I don't think the winners of the World Wars did a particularly good job of inventing these countries, or even naming them, for that matter.

by jamesrl

And thats the attitude that wins friends and influences people all over the world.

When the US decided that Afghanistan was the target, we supported you. We sent troops. We are still there, we still support the mission. We even changed the Canadians role from peacekeeping and development around Kabul to Taliban hunting at Khandahar.

But we disagreed with your approach on Iraq. You apparently think that makes us weak. It would have been easier to cave in to the tremendous pressure from the US and go join the coalition. It was not a knee jerk or quickly made decision in Canada.

You didn't join us in WWI and WWII until it suited you. The whole world should have been against Hitler. But hindsight is 20/20.

Your buddies signed a pact with you in 1940, before you entered WWII that we would mutually defend each others borders. We participate together in NORAD (North American Air Defence). NORAD is being expanded to include maritime as well as air defence. On September 11, our fighter planes were placed directly under NORAD control and we sent air patrols off the US coast.

Canada is already an Al Qaeda target because of our participation in Afghanistan (we just extended our participation in Afghanistan for another 2 years BTW).

Whether you like it or not, we are a separate sovereign country and we have the right to decide what we will and will not do with our military, beyond the pacts we have already signed. You get upset when people cast aspetions on America's motives, but you don't seem to have a problem insulting your neighbour and calling us cowards.

Would you like to tell that to the widows of the Canadians killed in Afghanistan? Would you like to say that to some of our soldiers?

That was over the line. I thought better of you.

James

by x-marcap

Americans are the kind who don't tend to back down from a fight. Gen. G. S. Patton said, he also said Americans lova to fight, and we love a winner...

I agree that the US should have been in WWII about 1937... Right after the Kenepetai strafed the US PANAY on the Yellow river... Before either Canada or the UK had declared war on Japan or Germany.

If we hadn't had a Democrat socialist FDR as our President, we probaly would have been in WWII much earlier... As we hadn't reacted to a ship being attacked, and the rape of Nanking, and many other Japanese and Italian atrocities around Shanghai, where the Marines had a heavy weapons division... Most of the world thought we'd never get into the war... The US has a tendency to get into wars much later than we should.

Some people think that we jumped in early this time...

by Member 25348569

Sixty years on from the end of WWII and nearly that from the creation of Israel. Since then, the US has been the supporter of Israel and the guarantor of their security with all that implies.

The one little escapade that ourselves and the French tried during the Suez crisis, you f*cked us up royally. Eisenhower threatened to sell the United States reserves of the pound and engineer a collapse of the British currency if we didn't withdraw. Strange, you didn't do anything to Israel who were also on our side.

Anyway, we haven't done anything in the last 50 years so don't go blaming us.

by jdclyde

"WE" did not invade a couple centuries ago.

I will now take it to the next step.

YOU did not invade a couple of centuries ago.

I don't give a ratsass about what people 400, 300, 200, 100, 50, or even 10 years ago did, or didn't do.

We have a parasite festering in the Middle East.

Stop supporting them.
Stop appeasing them.
Stop making excuses for them.
Stop letting people use the blame game to keep anyone from DOING anything about the problem.
Stop condoning them (and I hope you are rational enough to know what should be condoned and what shouldn't.)

Put THAT in your pipe and smoke it, Watson!

by Member 25348569

but I understand, now.

Re-read my post. I said we should have stopped a couple of "countries" ago, not centuries. That is, we shouldn't have invaded Afghanistan or Iraq and should have found a better, sneakier way to deal with Al Qaeda that wouldn't have got us so much bad publicity and got the bad guys so many recruits. That was never on the cards though as Bush had to be seen to be doing something and now we are where we are and I fear it's all going to get worse.

I know that you didn't invade the middle East two centuries ago - you were too busy invading Canada (that was ours!) and trying to work out a way to annexe Texas from the Mexicans.

They're getting Texas back, now - a baby at a time.

by jdclyde

is how you went back and edited your post without it showing that it was edited? :p

Must be an exhaust leak in my car! :D

by dawgit

I do believe that almost every country wiil buy into the Defence of ones land. But, invading another, weaker land, just because you can, No! The Romans did that, The Otomans did that, Napolian did that, Hitler did that, and, and, and....... No, there's a line there somewhere, and the US looks to have crossed it. (again!)

by x-marcap

We have the full rights of any sovereign nation to do what is in our best interest. If you don't like it, that is your opinion. If you are a voter in the US. Vote your conscience.

If we follow the Geneva convention then the world has no bone to pick with us... The terrorists in Iraq and the Mid-East can be executed by any officer as a spy, or saboteur. We aren't playing that rough though.

Conquering a land at one time was the desire of many countries. The US may be called Imperialist, but that is erroneous.

by dawgit

was the desire of many countries." Key word "was". I thought the world had progressed beyond that. oh-well, Back to the "Crusades" than.

by jamesrl

It mentions the challenges of looking at the stats without some further context.

For you chest thumping American patriots out there, just suppose I came up with a figue that said that the US voted against things Canada supported more than 50% of the time - would you think that the US was a false friend of Canada?? I somehow doubt it. But when the tables are turned....

James

by dawgit

It just looks like more 'Neo-Con' B.S. again. (now where did I just hear that ?:| ) Any college student learns who to make statistics lead people to believe almost anything. (at least they used to learn that) Statisitics alone mean nothing, if not accompanied with Documentation.

by jamesrl

Did those countries vote against the US, or the motion put forward?

Last night the new Canadian Conservative government held a vote to propose that Canadian troops stay in Afghanistan for another 2 years.

Seems simple enough?

Except that the previous Liberals government had already committed to stay through Feb 2007. And of course, troop committments are not approved officially by parliament but by cabinet, so the motion was supportive not binding or substantive.

So what did it all mean? Some Liberals voted against it because it didn't mean anything. Some voted against it because they think we should withdraw. Some support staying till 2007 and think we should wait till then to re-evaluate. Some Liberals voted for it, because they think not to do so would undermine the troops. Some voted for it because their favorite candidate for Liberal leader did too.

Anyone want to make this black and white? It isnt.

James

by maxwell edison

....between being a "chest thumping American patriot", and a person defending against the continual onslaught of verbal ridicule. Unfortunately, when you guys insist on continuing the latter, you'll get even more of the former.

by oz_media

You can't ridcule something without a valid argument. If you are being ridiculed it's because people have valid arguments.

In THIS case you aren't even making sense at all. First you make some comment that only 4 year olds make when they don't understand how to look at both sides of something, then you are going on about people ridiculing you. When th earticle was posted by an American and didn't have any comments about Canada ridculing the USA.

Chest pounding American? Well, what else would you call it? It was a completely meaningless stat, designed to fire you up over nothing and what do we see???? Americans getting fired up over a ridculous and irrelevant stat, designed to fire them up over nothing.

by jamesrl

And by the way, I didn't suggest all or any particular Amercians were chest thumping, so take that into context.

But let me ask you - if you feel that Americans feel very free to exercise the right to NOT support Canada, or UK, or your other close allies on their UN initiatives or even in their general foreign policy goals, why do you expect that your allies are disloyal when they do the same. Thats one of the major issues I see in attitude - there isn't reciprocity.

You failed to stand up for Canada, when when of your fellow American posters called us cowards. And you accuse me of ridicule. Think about that Max.

James

by maxwell edison

...Vermont and Massachusetts, and probably Oregon and California. Isolate some cities within the states, and you could include Boulder, Colorado, Austin, Texas, and Madison, Wisconsin, to name a few.

by dawgit

Sorry to dissapoint you on that.
American? Yes.
Hate America? NO.
I just wonder what happened to it.
The people no longer think. That's not good.
The people no longer get acurate infomation. (as in truth, what will it hurt?) That's not good.
Just how did America get that way?

by x-marcap

When sombody tries to kill you, things get much simpler.It becomes Us vs.Them. Don't be stupid and support the people who attacked the USA. That is stupid. Don't have celebrations...

So don't be or support a Them...

I really think that Canada and Australia have stepped up big time... That is to their credit.
They aren't the pissant counties to which I was referring. Nor is Great Britain. I am referring to France along with the Sudanese,etc.

I do think that it is that simple. When I am under attack, those who won't fight with me are against me. Canada has been one of our staunchest allies. No question about it.

In particular, I mean countries that we are feeding that should show some gratitude. Ethiopia, Sudan, Mali, Nigeria, etc. They take the effort to stand against the USA when they can, biting the very hand that feeds them... I have quit sending money for food to Mali. It won't make a whale of a lot of difference, but $500.00 for twenty years buys a lot of rice...

by cactus pete

You're either confused or didn't read what I wrote. Reread it, and if you still don't understand, I'll tryto explain it another way.

by oz_media

First of all, yuo are referring mainly to countries that the US is often looking to impose sanctions or other actions against. They are talking about how THEY vote against your ideas. Most of these proposals would not be in the majority favour of the country it is being appled to. It is obvious that during a vote for such issues they would not vote with the US. The whole poll is pretty ridiculous and nonapplicable to the way it has been presented.

As for cuting off aid, that's your choice. you rely on too many others to keep your country prosperous, I would think twice before cutting that string though.

To top it ALL off though, how can you complain that country's don't vote YOU Rway in the UN when all Americans do is discount the UN and their abilities? You don't want to play with others and that's just fine because you shouldn't have to in your eyes, but when others don't want to play with you you get upset and imply they are the evil empire against the USA?

How typically and hypocritically American. It's always THEM and never you. When are Americans going to start looking at and honestly judging themselves for once in their lives?

by dawgit

That really did damage to the US. And the seceret prisons, They're still looking at that.

by maxwell edison

Before ANY of that was an issue -- make that a contrived issue.

I pointed to a UN vote in 2001, any you're using those ~2004 "contrived" issues as reasoning to justify it.

by dawgit

I saw no reference to a date in the post. and in both links, the year 2003 was referenced. A little help needed here on the dates. I don't really see any reality in the info any, so no real point in arguing about it. I think it just the idea that some people have that it would terible if anyone dissagreed with them on anything. The real problem than would be narow mindedness.

by oz_media

Have you been asleep since 9/11 or something???

Your 'buddies to the North', are currently occupying Afghanistan and the surrounding areas, along with your enemies from Germany and France, while dying to fight the war on terrorism, as they have been at your side all along.

Remember, 'your buddies to the north' were also four years ahead of you in joining WWII an fighting that Hitler terror (WWI started in the late 30's and Hitler was already beaten down after trying to invade England for two years, long before D-Day and America's wakeup call in Pearl Harbour), so don't start pointing the 'unhelpful, passive neighbour' finger without knowing the facts.

Since when did Canada tell you not to defend yourselves? Please post a quote from somewhere in teh last 60 years anyway.

As for Iraq, you were not terrorized by Iraq, you THOUGHT you had a reason for invasion, yet you even ignored you OWN policy behind invading Iraq. You were SUPPOSED to use force to finish inspections (not to invade the country), in the end inspectors WERE completing inspections as promised, they had found NOTHING of any relevance at that time.

Allies requested they wait until the inspections were finished, estimated at 2-6 weeks, and GWB refused to wait, ignored his OWN resoutions that others had agreed to, and invaded prematurely against the wishes of the allied nations.

But hey, THAT's OKAY, now they are expected to support you anyway??!?!? Give your head a shake, son, and get with the 'ucking program for once!

by oz_media

Okay, to rephrase, YOU are not stupied per se but the fact that people are actually seeing something in the stats posted is crazy.

As Julian said, WHAT were the issues they voted on? Judging by the countries opposed, I assume it ws not health care for Iraqi's, better water systems in Kuwait etc. The US is very imposing to most other countries, the US is KNOWN for trying to throw it' sweight around and these countries feel constantly bullied. I am sure you would see similar stats toward Canada and England too. Whomever is trying to impose a nw law or sanction against another country is NOT going to see too many supporting votes.

It would be more relevant and constructive to se ehow many FREINDLY nations, ALLIES were opposed. Not starving third world countires where you have imposed restrictions or other sanctions against then.

If you were always telling us what our government canand cannot do, we wouldn't be voting in your favouir too often either.

And for you to say "they don't like us but I've NEVER liked them because they don't like us" is ridiculous. MAYE they never liked you BEACSUE you don't like them. Who punched first? Again, chicken or the egg?

by dr dij

get the UN to base voting power on how much each member contributes. That would encourage them to contribute. You don't get shareholder voting rights in a corporation based on one person or investor company, you get the rights based on HOW MUCH you invested in the company.

by oz_media

But unfortunately the entire world isn't focused on capitalism. We don't run our companies the wway our government runs the country, thank god.

We have developed a system, that you have made your personal quest to spread globally, calld democracy. Each man is entitled to an equal vote regardless of who he is. or are we now Iraqi allies that are going to support a new dictatorship? Maybe Iraq Inc. and America Corp. would be for new country names? Canada Ltd. could be a new recreational day spa for tired and weary Americans who just can't take it anymore. England & Associates would run an ESL school for Americans perhaps?