Discussion Locked

Countries in the UN against the U.S.

0 helpful
178 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

178 replies

by jaqui

england was the only country that voted with the us in the un on that particualr issue, even the us protectorates like singapore voted against the us.

the move into iraq was only supported by the us government and british governments, every other country gave the exact same response as france.

by x-marcap

I did my share of bleeding for this country, I hate seeing it get nibbled to death by the Ducks in Congress and their sycopants...

by dawgit

'nuf said
(& who said we aren't on the same side, just looking at things from different angles)

by x-marcap

But we get oil from them and they get tolerance, support, military equipment from us.

Britain set up the borders long ago.

I really think that the Sauds run a repressive regime that keeps women as chatel, treats outsiders in a manner best described as unclean, and hates the existance of Israel, and keeps anger at Israel at a high level in the Mid-East... It is easier to remove troops from being in harms way than to provide a safe haven in hostile territory.

The religious leaders in Saudi are anti-Israel. Saudi men tried to kill a US Air Force Sergeant because she was driving a vehicle. Get it SHE was driving... They think that women having freedom is the best example of what they call Western decadence, and weakness. If there were a viable alternative to the Sauds, I'd support it, unless we suspect that any other voice in the region is more anti-American.

by x-marcap

edited --- > emoticons not working..

Don't tell me you got your history from Robin Hood Men in tights ;-)

We aren't trying to kill them all, or posess the land. You spew that garbage and some moron believes it. We are still in Bosnia and Haiti. Why isn't the left angry at that "6 month" engagement started by Bill Clinton... Are you as upset we have troops in harms way there?

by x-marcap

We will not let even our buddies to the North tell us we cannot defend ourselves.

I agree you are our buddies... Canadian, you are too quick on the trigger with this one...

I said even... Canada, I consider our closest ally.

The point is, as Bush has said, "No foreign country will dictate American security and foreign policy... I respect the Canadian presence, and I think you need to read what I said. No country has the right to tell the US what we can or can't defend ourselves... The UN is in the same boat. I suspect if the UN was abolished there would be no more or less conflict in the world. I think they were dynamic in the Ruwandan genocide. The UN ran from Iraq, and they real point is without the WWII allies the UN is a joke...

by oz_media

But if Iraq wants to develop the technology to defend itself, YOU have the right to stop them?(after initially providing them the munitions for such defense)

Nobody has said you can't defend yourselves, except your elected presidential liar, whom you all seem to buy into like he's a religion.

The whole point is, YOU ARE NOT DEFENDING YOURSELVES BY INVADING IRAQ.

Perhaps one could POSSIBLY hang onto the teeny thread of a hope that he COULD have developed the ability to attack, but he didn't.

Remember the inspectors that you removed from completing inspections just weeks before a qualified decision could have been made?

THAT'S wher eyour president lost the suport of your allies, THAT is why ore Americans have died than would have if there was a broader coalition, THAT is why your country has invested hundreds of bilions of YOUR tax dollars to rebuild the damage they inflicted on Iraq. THAT is why America is on her own and has the world saying, FU, we TOLD you to wait and you ignored us.

It has NOTHING to do with not being able to defend yourseld, that's just pathetic media hype created to build loyalty from Americans and show everyone else as the bad guy, as always.

by jamesrl

The Saudis may run a totalitarian regime, and while the Royal family are very western friendly and even cozy with the Bush clan, they have to walk a fine line with their citizens. No doubt if the Royal family is threatened, its by extremists like Bin Laden who would ahppily replace the Royal family with something more like the Taliban.

So what choices do the US face? Abandon the Royal Family and there will be a radical regime there.

James

by x-marcap

Let's look back just one previous incumbancy to the Oval Office.

He started conflict in Bosnia, We are still there. He started conflict in Haiti, We are still there.
He tried to join conflict in Argentina, ostensibly to cool things down between Great Britain and Argentina.

Thank God the Argentinians refused to cooperate with a US presence after the Faulklans conflict... That was the last gasp of the Pro-German leftovers such as the Peronistas left over from WWII that were Argentinian Army VS what was Pro-British Navy... There is a country always devided against themselves...

Argentina was a Nazi refuge after WWII, and the Pro-German sentiment ran deep. Many Army officers from Argentina were educated at the German Kreigschool or War college. Sort of like Levenworth with Schnitzel... Understand how deep the Argentine dislike for the USA is, and you'll find socialists at every turn.

Our socialists are trying to enact the same kind of policies that has kept Argentina from becoming a great world power.

by oz_media

Ridisculously wide of the topic at hand and the comments you made, even the reply I offered but still a nice rant all the same. Bit of a waste but whatever.

by x-marcap

Governments and the people in them rarely tell the truth... Would the OFF program have gotten to a previous President named Clinton, or Bush... We may never know...

How about the name of the person who told the shooter at Ruby Ridge to "Shoot the next person who walks out that door." That was a criminal act. but it is sealed for another 65+ years...

I believe it was either Janet Reno, or President Clinton. If it was either, they should have been tried alonside the shooter, even while in office... The records are sealed, and I will never know if the President gave a direct order to murder a woman and her baby, over a challenge to the legality of the IRS's existance.

by onbliss

Quite true. But there have been other countries fighting terrorism before, and so when a country implies that others are not doing their part, no doubt some countries get upset.

by x-marcap

He really hates to read what I write. He reads into what I write, something to rant about...

by onbliss

...chooses its friends or foes correctly, at least in long terms. It chose a "rogue state" as a (temporary)friend, and ignored one of the biggest democracies. I accept the "biggest democracy" was spear heading the NAM (Non Alignment Movement) and did side with U.S.S.R many times.

But let me tell people were pretty much frusturated when they saw USA helping out the "rogue state" even when they were supporting cross-border terrorism for years.

Oh well, past is past. Tides are changing :-) Hopefully the Democracies march forward.

Edited: Grammar.

by jdclyde

A chicken and an egg are laying in bed.

The chicken sits up and lights a smoke.

The egg says "Well, I guess we answered that one..."

by x-marcap

1. The failed assasination attempt on Bush 41 after he was out of office.

2. The failed attempt to take over the US Embassy in 1979. Iran had just fallen, and The US Ambassador got locked in the basement and kept away from communications until the attackers quit trying to take over the Embassy. Were many Iraqis killed trying to take over the Embassy? No, but 5 instigators were removed by precision rifle fire... 3 of them were Mullahs.

3. They supported the Iranian hostage takeover of the US Embassy, and tried one themselves...

4. They declared war on the US in 1974 for our support of Israel.

5. They supplied arms to terrorists for the Mayaguez incident 1975.

Do you really want a full list?

by oz_media

I replied to
"Jaqui, are you suggesting that the U.S. is the terrorist now although we are the ones who were attacked first?"

this was shortly after another post that directly mentioned it was retaliation for 9/11. It wasn't, and if you're SO educated on teh happenings of the past century of war, you would have recognized that too. Iraqi's didn't fly planes into US buildings on 9/11 to wage war on behalf on Saddam.

by x-marcap

Did the UN come storming out of the building and shoot? No.

Do UN members enrichen themselves on US Dollars. Yes.
Did UN members enrichen themselves of OFF? Yes.

Does the UN support Thugs and dictators? Yes.
Does the UN allow genocide? Yes.
Does the UN stand against oppressive regimes? No.
Does the UN do any good. That is questionable...

by oz_media

You stray so easily, if you have so much to say on a different topic, start a new thread.

My comment again was : "Neither the UN or Iraq attacked you."

Perhaps you can dig through some of your fact finding websites and post a link that proves such a statement incorrect instead of running of on a tangent.

by oz_media

You stray so easily, if you have so much to say on a different topic, start a new thread.

My comment again was : "Neither the UN or Iraq attacked you."

Perhaps you can dig through some of your fact finding websites and post a link that proves such a statement incorrect instead of running off on a tangent.

by x-marcap

France rounded up their Jews before Germany did.They have a poor history of being right in the 20th Century.

by x-marcap

Bravery is a personal trait. I am a coward about finding out what my daughter is up to now that she lives with her Grandmother... I could handle incoming fire more easily than that. Just like I did in the past.

I was not Impugning the bravery of Canadians, if you are referring to me. You spell appeasement France. From WWI through today. Their leadership specializes in appeasement. They really like the thought of dictatorships, and kings. That is why they support despotism all over the world...

The worst part is I think we have elected many of our cowards to Congress. Either that or they are using the conflict for strictly political gain...

Nah! They wouldn't do that...

Sandy is the guy I just don't get. All the current and past officers I personnaly know support the situation in Iraq. Sandy and a few others are in the vast minority.

by maxwell edison

Last thing first. You said, [i]"You (I) failed to stand up for Canada, when (one) of your fellow American posters called us cowards. And you accuse me of ridicule. Think about that Max.[/i]"

Well, James, whether or not I even saw the post to which you are referring is anything but a given, and I'm not sure you can make such a presumption. Even with a discussion in which I actively participate, I might not read all of the messages, sub-threads and tangents, much less feel compelled to comment on all of them. Feel free to point out the particular case, however, and perhaps I'll comment further.

Even if I did see it, I'm not sure one's silence equals one's ridicule. That's a bit of a stretch, if you ask me. How many times, for example, have YOU remained silent (regardless of whether or not you even saw it) when your fellow Canadians called me any number of things? Were you, too, "ridiculing" me with your silence? I would never suggest such a silly thing, and I'm rather surprised you just did. Think about that, James.

You said, [i]"And by the way, I didn't suggest all or any particular Americans were chest thumping, so take that into context.[/i]

Okay, the context is my reply to your previous comment, [i]"For you chest thumping American patriots out there, just suppose ....[/i]"

You know, it's rather disingenuous (oops, there's "that word" again) to group a bunch of people into a description such as that, not name anyone in particular, and when an objection is raised you backpedal a bit. Stand by what you said, clarify if necessary, or even retract something if you feel uncomfortable justifying it. I notice, however, that while you didn't necessarily include me in the description, you still didn't exclude me when I raised an objection. Say what you mean, and mean what you say. If you can't qualify it, or justify it, or defend it, perhaps you should consider not saying it at all.

Personally, I don't think there's anything wrong or objectionable about "chest thumping" Americans (and "chest thumping" can be defined in a variety of ways), whether you think I'm one of them or not. (And in some ways, I probably am.) Just like I don't think there's anything wrong or objectionable about "chest thumping" Canadians (and "chest thumping" can still be defined in a variety of ways) -- and there are plenty of you guys who post messages about how great Canada is. You'll notice, however, that no, or at least very few, Americans (and never has this American), "ridiculed" you for it, and/or continually blast away at you, your policies, your country, or anything else about you. How many times have I read the most blatant, dishonest, misleading, and mean-spirited attacks from the likes of jaqui and Oz, and how many times have you joined the ridicule with "your silence"? If one isolated person, in one isolated case, called you or a fellow Canadian a coward, or calls Canada a nation of cowards, and you take objection to that, perhaps you should deal with that person and, as you advised me, take that into context ( and perhaps even thump your chest a little bit ).

On the real area of disagreement, here's my take (for about the umpteenth time). I've said it before, and I'll say it again. For the past forty or so years (prior to 9-11), every freedom-loving country in the world, including the United States (and including the United Nations), with the possible exception of Israel, has, at best, paid mere lip-service to the growing threat of Islamo-Fascist generated terrorism. The threat -- and I mean the "big picture" threat -- transcends the isolated 9-11 incident. The events of 9-11 are not the only problem, per se, but only a part of a bigger problem -- a "bigger picture" problem. From that point forward, however, the policy of the United States towards Islamo-Fascist generated terrorism drastically changed. Part of the policy was, of course, a direct retaliation for those, and on those, who executed that particular attack on 9-11. The other part of the policy was intended to address the "bigger picture", something, as I said, has been paid mere lip-service for so long. You may disagree with how we're doing it, and that's fine. But I (and others) disagree with YOUR way of dealing with it, which is just more of the same lip-service. Moreover, anyone who really sees the actions in Iraq as more related to the isolated 9-11 incident, and less related to the "big picture" is, in my opinion, a total and complete moron (or a total and complete uninformed moron ..... or a total and complete disingenuous moron ..... or a total and complete dishonest moron).

In a previous message you criticized the United States for its late entry into W.W.II. Well, James, the same sentiment right back to ya' -- but just 60 years later against a different enemy. Maybe the USA learned a lesson from 1936. Maybe Canada didn't. And the United Nations especially, the initial subject of this discussion, has not only failed to learn that lesson of 1936 and act accordingly, but in the opinion of many people, including yours truly, not only is the United Nations failing dismally to address this growing threat to the world, but in many ways, they are actually facilitating it. And that is why, James, I absolutely despise the United Nations, and consider it an inept, incompetent, impotent, and even corrupt organization.

By the way, did I answer your question?

by jamesrl

I don't see the chest thumping remark as disingenous at all. I did not call all Americans chest thumpers (or patriots) and I was addressing my remarks to those who have the my country right or wrong attitude. When I used that remark I wasn't replying to you I don't believe - why would you think I was tarring with such a broad brush. You've accused me in the past of being too sensitive to see insult, perhaps we share that trait.

As for me defending Americans against Oz, I have on occasion, as you well remember.

I will admit that the post about "our buddies to the North" and cowardice in the same post and within 3 paragraphs lead me to a leap. Perhaps its because a Canadian soldier with my wife's somewhat unique first name was killed in Afghanistan on Wednesday. I never claimed to be anything but human and flawed.

My point about the US and WWII was not directed as a criticism, though I have in the past mentioned it in a different context. My point is that there is a double standard - the US expects its allies to toe the line, vote with it(as in the Original posts' point) but doesn't feel the same obligation to support the objectives of its allies. It is natural that even the closest of allies will disagree. As is our right as sovereign nations. I might be so bold as to suggest that Canada was punished by the US for our stand on Iraq.

I've not been the one going on and on about the UN. To me the body is a collection of states/countries. If the majority of them are "evil" or "corrupt", its hard to expect the UN to be anything but, as the UN would have to be more than the sum of the collective worth. I support the ideals of the UN, the ideals that principally America imposed on the body when they founded it. But I agree that its ability to actually take relevant action to uphold those ideals is lacking.

And no you didnt address the question - if you expect us to support your UN votes, should we expect you to support our UN votes? Thats as simple as I can break it down. And the question isn't just relevant to the UN but to each of our respective foreign policies.

James

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"If you expect us to support your UN votes, should we expect you to support our UN votes?[/i]

My simple answer is, no. Both countries should vote their conscience and/or their best interest.

And yes, I would also concede that this will clarify my opinion that the voting record described in the initial discussion message should be taken and viewed in the context of nations "voting" their conscience and/or best interest. And by extension, it becomes clear that many nations are operating from a different premise of conscience, or best interest, or both.

Does this necessarily make THEM wrong? Does this necessarily make the UNITED STATES wrong? The answer to both of those questions might be the same.

by x-marcap

The UN allows Sudan, and China on the Human rights commission, One practices de-facto slavery, and the other practices slavery...

Islamo-fascism has been growing since Carter didn't stomp it out when it was mewling about in Iran.

by dawgit

It was after Pres.Carter that a Marine LtCol named North was activly working with Iran (as in Helping the enemy) The damage he caused has never been publicly released (for good reasons)

by onbliss

USA is ridiculed unfairly, sometimes. So, when Americans protest and point out the invalidity, one ought to accept the invalidity of the points.

Like Max and other correctly point out, if citizens of other countries have the right to defend criticisms, is it not fair that Americans have the equal right? (constant)Chiding them is simply wrong!!!

As far as to valid arguments, is it SMART to keep constantly ridiculing USA or for that matter any country? In my opinion it is not smart and neither being nice.

It is not smart because, it only means the ridiculers fail to see the American's point of view. There is always a disconnect between the people and the Government, in any country. Sometimes the Government has to do what it has to do. So when a common man sees ridicules from certain quarters consistently, they wonder why nobody is looking at the positive aspects of them and their country. The feel that their point of view and ideas are being dismissed summarily without due considerations. Hence they are pushed more to the corner and they (appear)take sides with the "chest thumpers".

Also it is not smart because, the Americans will simply not trust the World, if it keeps crying Wolf all the time when there is really no wolf. So when we cry wolf, they will not give heed to our words.

It is not nice, because, well it is simply not appropriate :-) I don't think I have words to articulate what is nice or what is not :-)

My 2 cents

by oz_media

"Also it is not smart because, the Americans will simply not trust the World, if it keeps crying Wolf all the time when there is really no wolf. So when we cry wolf, they will not give heed to our words."

GWB approaches allies and teh UN at an international meetng to determine the validy of the claims against Saddam.

If he WAS in possession of stockpiles of WMD and refused to allow inspectors in, the idea was to use force in order to complete inspections, not to INVADE IRAQ or RID THEM OF SADDAM, simply to force inspections.

Allies voice their objection to a rushed invasion as at that tme, inspectors were neaaring completion of their task and had found NOTHING they were predicted to find. GWB provided evidence of Saddams intentions, which was at that time questioned because the source, the informant known as "curveball", was not reliable and had ulterior motives.

GWB decided to pull out inspectors and proceed with the invasion basedon the FACT that Saddam was still in possession of WMD and was plannign to use them against the USA.

In other words, he cried wolf, the sky was falling and America needed to defend herself.

What was missed here? Saddams WMD were NOT capable of intercontinental attack, they were just low end antiquated weapons for reasonably close combat. The said WMD were NOT a threat to the USA at all.

While they did find some unused delivery systems, they found no WMD, not even those not capable of attackign teh USA.

Allies were told to heed GWB's warning and said there was not enough evidence to justify premature invasion.

So WHO cried wolf???? America, thank you, well done.

As for the rest, it is just completely typical that you only see peopl epointing at America and refuse to acknowledge the way most Americans and TR peers spend day and night chastizing EVERY other country on Earth for not supporting their rash and unjustified invasion.

Get over yourselves.

by onbliss

By saying "completely typical" if you meant that I am an American, I want point out that I am not an American.

You are talking about Bush and Iraq. That is one of the issues in this world. Quite important one though.

Let us take one of those countries mentioned in the list - Sudan. The present genocide is caused by the Sudanese themselves. Bush or America did not create that. [b]***[/b]

But, are ALL THE PROBLEMS of the WORLD caused just by America? Nope. Do I think America is the good-goody country that never creates a trouble. Nope.

I have elsewhere indicated the problems of the present world because of Imperialism and Cold War, but do not think that ALL the problems of the WORLD are just because of America, Imperialism or Cold War.

The domestic problems of any country SHOULD be attributed to DOMESTIC REASONS first, and then the FOREIGN REASONS.

My point is constant criticisms should not prevent us from giving the fair and due credit to USA or any country.

[b]***[/b]I do think that NO COUNTRY should sell ARMS and WEAPONS to such countries involved in genocide and brokering terrorism.

by x-marcap

The said WMD were NOT a threat to the USA at all.
He stated he would use the WMDs on our troops in Saudi Arabia and on Israel. That was a legitimate threat, bunky.

Any WMD is a threat. Saddam had used Gas on Kurds. He could have been ready to cook off a scud toward the Independence, or an Aegis cruiser in International waters.

You said
"Allies were told to heed GWB's warning and said there was not enough evidence to justify premature invasion."

OZ, is every single intelligence organization wrong that Saddam had WMDs and projects in action, or did they get hidden in the Mid-East. Also the Nuke program in Lybia was paid for by Saddam.

by old guy

thanks for posting that. I'm sure some people will look at that as dripping with sugary sentiment but I think it was a great document and said in sincerety. I wish that more people could read and look at the more positive statements such as this. Thanks, again.

by maxwell edison

I can't count the number of times the United States (and other nations as well) has been faced with deciding which "bad choice" to make.

- Aligning with the Russians in 1941 or not.

- Going against the Russians (General Patton's suggestion) in 1945 or not.

- The events in ~1980 Afghanistan are another such case. The people who mention this, while failing to mention the real alternative, in the context of that time, are being _________ fill in the blank.

- The Iran-Iraq war of the 1980s.

- Courting the Saudis or not.

- Going along with the United Nations (in 2003) or not.

When faced with deciding which one of two bad choices to make, the outcome will be certain criticism from someone or somewhere.

I suppose there is a third option, but personally I like to stand with my head held high, not stuck in the sand.

by x-marcap

They still think it is OK to not support our troops...

That and they really seem to hate the military.

by jamesrl

But thats the point regarding the original post. The US votes the ways it needs to or wants to, and should expect that others do the same. Of course that doesn't mean that every vote contrary to the US is by extension bad, devoid of conscience.

About 15 years ago, we had a major set of amendments to the Canadian constition, and a national vote was held. You only had a choice of voting for the entire package or rejecting it. There were some points that everyone agreed with, some that were very hotly debated. Predictably the package was rejected by the voters - the vast majority didn't agree on what they didn't like about it, but the majority found at least one thing they didn't approve of.

I think similar things happen with UN votes.

I don't think the US is wrong to hope for support and even lobby its friends for support on major issues at the UN. But the mathematical approach from the original post doesn't tell the whole story.

James

by jamesrl

But thats the point regarding the original post. The US votes the ways it needs to or wants to, and should expect that others do the same. Of course that doesn't mean that every vote contrary to the US is by extension bad, devoid of conscience.

About 15 years ago, we had a major set of amendments to the Canadian constition, and a national vote was held. You only had a choice of voting for the entire package or rejecting it. There were some points that everyone agreed with, some that were very hotly debated. Predictably the package was rejected by the voters - the vast majority didn't agree on what they didn't like about it, but the majority found at least one thing they didn't approve of.

I think similar things happen with UN votes.

I don't think the US is wrong to hope for support and even lobby its friends for support on major issues at the UN. But the mathematical approach from the original post doesn't tell the whole story.

James

by maxwell edison

I sure understand your sentiment, and an easy "emotional" answer might be, "right-on". It's not very practical or realistic, however. (But I'm not sure you really intended it to be.)

But I will say this. In the very least, I believe the permanent members of the UN Security Council should all be nations that not only buy-into, but also promote the common ideals of freedom and basic human-rights. Canada or Australia, for example, are much more deserving and appropriate nations than either China or Russia; and either Canada and/or Australia would be a better permanent members of the UN Security Council to help promote, what should be, the real goals of the United Nations. If it doesn't stand for something, as the song lyrics might suggest, it'll fall for anything. In the case of the UN in general, and the Security Council in particular, it's crumbled.

I don't want to be a member of united "nations" just for the sake of it. Nor do I want to be a member of united "rogue nations", or united "socialist nations". I want to be a member of nations united to promote and advance the ideals of freedom and liberty and basic human rights for all. Anything short of that, and I'm not ashamed, in any way whatsoever, to say, I want nothing to do with it.

by oz_media

well a valid comment anyway. Yes it woul dbe nice to see everyone on th esame page and focusedon making teh world a better place, but as always, and in American politics also, there are people in it for a personal agenda. So really, the way YOU see the UN as being failed due to poor choices in leadership, so do peopl esee America today as being failed due to poor leadership. REALLY, you don't have a bad country, just the worlds nost insane leaders, well maybe not the MOST insane but definitely on a goal of personal agenda and all eh while convincing their entire nation to support them.

I agree, the UN has failed at many of it's initial tasks due to poor leaderhship, had it been properly conducted we may not be having such a converstation. The same goes for the USA though, if you had leadership that was on teh same page as the rest of your allies, we too wouldn't be verbally attacking your every, self servient move.

by oz_media

You keep going on and on about defending yourself and how you are justified in defending yourself.

Even after it has been explained that you are NOT defending yourselves and are instead takign an initiative to invade and declare war on what is now a growing enemy across the middle east.

Yet your reply is the same as those who were posting here several years ago, before anyone knew what was really going on.

"You have different ideas about what we should do."

Americans are the kind who don't tend to back down from a fight. Gen. G. S. Patton said, he also said Americans lova to fight, and we love a winner..."

Now you are quoting a general's comments made several years after war had been declared in Europe, thousands were dead and countries had been brutally invaded.

How do you then equate such a comment as justification for the premature and questionable invasion of another country?

the only TRUE part is "Americans lova to fight".

The only reason you LOVE to fight is because you are all lied to until you believe that it is justified and you must defend yourselves. This plus the fact that you refuse to let other countries develop similar weaponry so that you are always on top.

It's like the pansy who takes a gun to a fight and tells his opponents thay can only use knives. Of COURSE he wants to fight.

by onbliss

50 years is not even 2 generations and is not sufficient time enough for the countries to raise and shine. I hate to say it but, erstwhile Imperialism and Cold war did cause additional damage to many countries.

Some countries have raisen, usually they are the smaller nations, city-nations, or where population has a semblance of homogeneous nature.

by oz_media

To be absolutely clear on this, you KNOW that those opposed to the war are NOT necessarily opposed to the hard and sometimes seemingly impossible tasks of your military.

I can completely object to the REASON for war and object to those who start the wars, but in NO way whatsoever have I EVER opposed the work that the brave men and women of your (and most other military forces) do.

It is not the troops that start wars, it' sthe troops that fight wars, mainly without question and without hesitation as they are completely set on just doing their job.

I don't know how deeply you meant your comment to hit, but rest assured we don't oppose your military, we oppose your leaders decisions.

If you were referring to other nations, your enemies for example, fine, but that's not how most people see it at all.

by old guy

terrorism. So, yes, he is on topic. I don't remember the exact title or phrase used but President Bush started with the terroristic acts from 9/11 and widened it to include this is a war on all terrorism. Some of the ways and acts that have been put in place may not have been the best way. However, since most of the terrorists originate in these countries, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Pakistan, etc then yes, we are defending ourselves from their terroristic acts.

by old guy

of the problems with a lot of things. There are some people who have tunnel vision and can only see one thing at a time. Again, in this discussion, there are very broad views and very broad conflicts that come into play. To tell someone they must speak only of one sentence or question you may pose is extremely narrow mindedness.

Does President Bush have a sinister, hidden political agenda in taking the war to Iraq? Maybe he does or maybe he is sincere in trying to stop all terrorism. Your opinion of what a person intends or my opinion of what a person intends may be far off the mark.

by oz_media

If you follow the segue that I replied to and he further commented on, the theme is insinuating once again that Iraq was responsible for 9/11.

Iraq did NOT attak the USA.

As for your own summary, it's FAR to broad a brush, just broad enough make it seem so fine and simple. It's NOT fine and simple though.

"since most of the terrorists originate in these countries, Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Pakistan, etc then yes"

Actually it is said that the largst part of AlQaeda resides OUTSIDE of the middle east, but this is okay because terrorists are far from the Afghan pipeline and it's incredible revenue stream. They are out of the way and unable to extort and control oil revenues.

Anyhow, if we are to target ALL terrorists, in blanket invasion style, then we will be invading over 60 countries one by one, including the good ole USA. YEs, AlQaeda terrorist sects are known to reside in the US, Canada, UL, and literally dozens of other countries, in stronger numbers than before, perhaps not quite as organized yet but getting there.

This will not end by turning the MIddle East into glass, someitmes there needs to be a different solution found, beyond brute force.

No I don't have that solution, it's pretty bloody clear that THIS isn't working though, it hasn't even worked in Afghanistan with far less resistance.As the old saying goes, know thy enemy, and in this case you don't.

by oz_media

You were going on about crying wolf and how it's always said to be America's fault. I replied by showing that in this case, specifically described in my post, was completely America's crying wolf and THAT's why they are being attacked so. There is a war, a seemingly endless war that threatens the world as we knows it.

Was it started justly and fairly based on an allied agreement, as originally agreed to by Bush? Nope.

It was a result of deceit, misinformation and an extremely rude leader who decided to ignore the best wishes of his allies and his own assurances to go at it alone.

Wel now it's a huge bloody mess, and we are all paying the price in one way or another. In Canada's case, for example, we have deployed mroe and mroe troops, and more and mroe Canadians are dying in Afghanistan, because the US removed the bulk of it's forces and left it to allies to police. Ths was nto the original goal at all.

Why was the force thinned so? So you could wage a resented war on another country.

Why are people so pissed and pointing the finger at you for this? .

Do people have a right to be pointing teh finger at Bush and discrediting his pathetic attempts at leadng a nation?

Well if it hasn't sunk in by now, it obviously never will. How can you possibly pretend to be so naiive in wondering why everyone is against teh US?

by oz_media

A thread was started, posts flow in tiered fashion. We were talking about something and he replied to my comment with something irrelevant an dnot even on topic, and it was intended to be in response to what I said. So YES, it is off topic and was somewhat mindless as it had no point or protest to begin with.

As for GWB's intents being good or bad, his INTENTIONS I am sre are good, though may not be completely pure in that he most likely has an ulterior motive. Much heavier evidence of his scheming than there ever was about Saddam having stockpiles of WMD on hand to atack America (complete BS because his weapons would not be ABLE to attack America if he had them anyway. So the Republican smokescreen was wafer thin.

But as you say, we won't know, at least until the next administration uncovers the proof on it.

You seem to be missing a very important and VERY relavant point though. As a leader, your primary task at hand is to make the right decision and when you don't you will be harshly criticized. That is called politics in a democratic nation. If this was Kerry at the helm you would all be having a field day on his EVERY move regardless of intent.

Bush may have had god intentions, though I think a personal motive too, but teh bottom line is HE FAILED, regardless of his intent, it was/is a large mistake.

by x-marcap

Understand that there are many ex-military guys who appreciate the support. Most of the ex-Mil guys I know that were officers and moist of us do support our President.

I support the Mission and the troops and our President in the situation in Iraq... Sandy and I are at polar opposites in that...

by oz_media

lumping it all togetherIt seems to me that whenever you express distaste in the US government's actions, that everyone gets overly defensive, as have you.

GWB was NOT justified in starting this war, Blair has admitted as much, GWB was smug and continues his charade.

Now whether you agree with this fact or not, that is entirely up to you. Blair apologized, Bush pretended he was right. Even though he HAS publicly stated that he hasn't found the stockpiles of WMD he expected, he still feels it was right. IF it was right is irrelevant, he was set on finding WMD, he told the UN andallies so and then ignored their wishes and screwed up anyway. This is undeniable, he did it and we all watched as it happened.

But why does MY expressing my distrust for GWB have any effect on your troops and especially veterans? So what? Are you suggesting that just because someone serves then they must then heed every word of the rpesident for life? After you serve you no longer have freedom of choice in who you support?

So what, I oppose him and I have a lengthy list of valid reasons. This doesn't mean I hate America, I am Anti-American, I am a terrorist or anything else, just that I don't believe Bush and feel that the way so many blindly follow without question is absolutely laughable.

He failed miserably in business, he failed as president. He's a cheat, or a fool if he's so easily egged on, why would ANY country vote for him twice just because it is thier duty?

This is a democracy, we are allowed to view our opinions either way; unless of course, it is AGAINST the US president. Hypocrisy as always.

by heml0ck

Just because Canada and the US don't always see eye to eye doesn't mean a lack of support, just different priorities.

by heml0ck

but the disagreement comes in how to do it.
As a side note, it is often overlooked that citizens of something like 16 countries were killed in 9/11.
I find it curious that the US and countries involved in the '91 Gulf war did not choose the legal avenue available to them. The end of the Gulf War was a ceasefire, not an armistice. This means that technically a state of war still existed between Iraq and the coalition countries. I think it would have generated a different response to have invoked the terms of the ceasefire as the rationale for invading Iraq. Hussein's government was in violation of those terms, and as such it ( the cesefire)was no longer in force. As far as I can see there was no need to go back to the UN to resume hostilities.

by x-marcap

I always thought you were an anti-religion person. You don't seem to support faith in God, now you lambaste faith in a system or a person...

OZ, that is where you live. The name fits you to a "T". You live in a fantasy where the rest of the world agrees with you. Most of the countries who should have been on our side were tainted by OFF money. Even Russia was tainted. So too, is China.

You think the Sudanese who still practice slavery are more riteous than those who call for an end to slavery?

You think the Chinese, who kill people for finding out the truth and disagreeing with the government over their treatment of other disidents, or those of a religious faith?

These are the people you siode with OZ. Righteousness would be a problem for any menber of the above groups... Your positional allies.

France may change positions depending on which way the wind blows. So you can't count them on your side more than 50% of the time...

by x-marcap

Before you tell me that he is so bad, Is Algore better? Is John "I make my name by slandering Vietnam Veterans" Kerry any better. As a Vet, I'd never vote for him as dogcatcher.

Before we invaded Iraq he was talking as Gung Ho as Bush. The real issue is if Bush says it, He does it. With some disappointing exceptions, he has been truer to his word than any President since Reagan.

Your anti-US sentimate is directed at me, and at our President. I didn't vote for GB either time he ran. I am not all that thrilled on tactics, but I agree with the strategy. Fight them over there, not here.

by maxwell edison

....blasted people for being "self-righteous" (and I mean he's done it a LOT), and always in his usual self-righteous manner. There's no point in trying to reason with him in that regard. He's right, you're wrong, end of story.

Consider this. The stereo-typical "self-righteous" people want, in some way, to control other people. Speaking for myself, as long as another person doesn't infringe on me (or on others), I don't presume to control anyone and/or suggest how that person should live. Oz can't say that. And he gets on his "self-righteous" soapbox in an attempt to qualify and/or justify it. (But he's not alone. A lot of people do it.)

It's okay, at least in my opinion, to be self-righteous in a self-control and/or self-responsible kind of way. "This is how I want to live my life." This is how I choose to believe." And as long as that doesn't interfere with another, being "self-righteous", in that regard, is no more than being "self-responsible". But as soon as a person starts to say, "This is how YOU should live and/or believe......", then it is THEY who are the "self-righteous" who disgust me, and who should be dismissed as people who only want to control others.

by dawgit

"...is every single intelligence organization wrong that Saddam had WMDs and projects in action, or did they get hidden in the Mid-East. Also the Nuke program in Lybia was paid for by Saddam."
You should know better than to make that statement. (simply not true, anybody in that comunity would know that)

by x-marcap

That was after non-payment...

It is also after having the Chinese ship boarded and the restricted machines found...

The High speed Centrifuges and 4 axis CNC MILLING machines are pretty much a dead giveaway when going with mercury switches.

by x-marcap

He was appointed by Carter. I can tell you that in December 2009, you will be able to read the book "Guatemala Gut Check" from Penguin books.

It was supposed to originally be titled "Iran-Contra from the inside"...

You'll then know more about things that were happening in Carter's administration with Iran.

by x-marcap

He hates the fact that not everybody hates Bush.

He really hates the fact that Max is so eoquent and makes him appear to be semi-literate... He hates my blunt: "These are the facts." He won't address the facts if they don't fit his worldview.

Well, I'll address the last bit in this manner. I was dead on topic, but not what OZ wants to read...

by maxwell edison

And I suppose you're privy to such "information"? If yes, you just violated your confidentiality obligations (and people in such a position just don't do that, especially on an Internet discussion site, so I strongly doubt it). If no, then you're just blowing smoke.

Geesh! I get SO TIRED of people spouting things as "fact" that are no more than a guess, at best, or made-up fabrications, at worst.

I think I'll make up a new word, f a c t o p i n i o n g u e s s.

Let's condense it a little bit so it flows off the tongue easier, and we now get, [i]factopinguess[/i].

factopinguess: \fakt-o-pin-ges\ n : 1. To falsely present as fact something that is derived from opinion or pure conjecture.

by oz_media

in a nutshell, perhaps you should begin your career in psychiatry.

As for your rash and way off base judgement, I'll just chuckle and let you feel clever.

by oz_media

First off, tsjanko, you state "I always thought you were an anti-religion person. You don't seem to support faith in God, now you lambaste faith in a system or a person..." You thought WRONG, VERY wrong. If you had paid any attention whil ecreating your clever MO, you would know otherwise. Now in your defense, you did say "I THOUGHT" which is okay, but you thought wrong. I have never, ever discounted somone's choice of religion or faith in any way whatsoever. As a person who has had a near death experience (actually I was declard dead) I don't find faith in a specific religion, but do see some relevance in most religious morals. I also respect anyone's choice of religion, whatever that rekigion may be. Other people have not experienced what i have, I have not experienced what they have, we have found different faith.

I have also NEVER told anyone on TR how to live or think, I simply put my comments forward, as do you, and use what I consider to be fact in order to support my claims, not any different than anyone else here. NOBODY has the full truth and nothing but the truth, including yourself or Maxweell.

I have chastized many for(what I deem)ridiculous reasons for supporting the world's most questionable leader, but I have absolutely no power whatsoever to change people's minds of beliefs, that doesn't happen here.
Max, your snobbish little aside just doesn't hold water.
And that's with the third party crap? Only newbs try that here, trying to rally the troops again are we?

So lets be quite clear here,tsjanko, you been implying everyone is the enemy as they all took advantage off OFF. One thing missing is the acceptance (of even aknowledgement) that the US was ALSO taking advantage of OFF AND the country's the US says ignored the programs restrictions. In fact, the US FED a lot of the breaches with it's demands and made Saddam play eye for an eye by continually stopping inspections.

Max, you were here when the document was first posted, we discussed it and it was quite clear who had played what role. The bottom line is that the US was no more innocent/guilty than any other offender of the program. I am not saying it was all your fault, just that you were not the innocent party there.

When I post facts that people don't like, even with supporting evidence from your own sources, it is considered being self righteous.

Self righteous is when you both trumpet your support for your government and reduce any other country in any way you possibly can, simply to justify your government's highly questionable actions. Whenever someone brings up somthing not in favour of your government, you instantly mention every other country that has ever donen anhthing wrong. France did this, England did that (often in the middle ages), Canada doesn't do this, Chili does that...ANYTHING but address the facts posted against your governments actions. Now it has resorted in Max's most amusing game, flaming the poster.

What's amusing is this is all I expect from either of you, I could almost write the whole thread by myself it's so predictable.

WHat's not amusing is that you actually believe what you are saying and simply haven't learned to look within, without first discounting the issues by looking outward.

Edited to add comments.

by oz_media

Talk about a template, your fresh from the mold, but with last years comments. But I'lll make this fair and show the same BS from both sides not just against Republicans.

Kerry, while he is said to have flip flopped on his vote to invade Iraq, he has not. What people see as him once accepting the the choice to invade Iraq was not so at all. As Bush himself had originally stated, IF (and that's the big error) the inspectors were NOT allowed to inspect th esites as selected, in a timely fashion, then the USA (and her allies) would use force TO SEE THE COMPLETION OF INSPECTIONS.

Kerry supported this and so did most of the allied nations also, just as all of your allies came to your aid when you were terrorized by the Taliban (In Afghanistan, not Iraq).

Bush then pulled inspectors who were completing inspections as planned and were nearing completion. He went ahead and invaded Iraq and arrested Saddam Hussein.

Now, I am not opposed to helping Iraqi's, removing repression, aiding in creating a democratic nation etc. But that was NOT the reason you went to war, as even YOU are echoing here.

Now while the right wing wrongly accuses Kerry of this flip flop, the left wing has done no better.

They quote Bush as at one time stating the he had found the labs and chemical warehouses he had sought. Then another quote that stated 'we have not found the stockpiles of weapons we expected'.

THIS I saw him say, but in that case he was admitting he had been mistaken about the stockpiles of weapons. In his first comment he was reporting on the existance of buildings. These are not the same thing, but when in favour of your side, the facts are easily forgotten.

This is seen all the time coming from both sides (sometimes it's better to remove yourself emotionally and look at the big picture instead of a chosen party), again from both sides, but fact of the matter is...Bush flip flpped on his decision to invade Iraq, allies didn't support it and you went to war, without justification.

The end result must ultimately be positive, although Afghanistan is not looking as positive as it was at first. The justification is not enough though and THAT'S why you weren't supported.

Edited to clean up a few misdirecting sentences.

by oz_media

"Saddam had used Gas on Kurds."
Yes, during a war that you supported. The mass graves were left over from the war, not from Saddam huddling them up like Nazi concentration camps, as many have often insinuated here.

"OZ, is every single intelligence organization wrong that Saddam had WMDs and projects in action, or did they get hidden in the Mid-East. Also the Nuke program in Lybia was paid for by Saddam."

No, talk about not seeing the forest through the trees. The US right wing has grasped at every thread of an angle they can to justify an invasion.

Yes, the entire world KNEW he had WMD, I am sure the White House kept the receipts. That is the entire reason inspectors were sent in to Iraq. The plan WAS, 'if they are kicked out, the US (and allies) would use force to complete inspections.' Is this what happened? NOPE.

Inspectors were NEARING completion and had found very little, this (you may be right) was reason to believe they had been moved (not destroyed as promised). Instead of completing inspections and then deciding how to go about sarching elswhere for these' stockpiles of WMD (ready to attack the USA), you invaded Iraq. WHY? You KNEW there were no WMD there. But WMD were used to justify a rash invasion, no wonder nobody with half a brain joined in for such reasons. Now Blair, on the other hand, admitted as much on public television wile addressing his nation. Bush just smugly said you were doing the right thong, not acknowledging his error until on a Barbara Walters special(of all places). Once again, Bush is too smug and proud to admit the error.

Blair had a VERY compelling reason to continue, several thousand exiled Iraqi's living in England had pleaded for him to liberate and create a democracy in Iraq. Bush started tu murmer similar comments shortly after, just to try and win back a little lost support.

These are all events that happened, not what if's.

Your defense is a what if? ANY country could attack you or I at any time, it doesn't mean we invade them at random.

First you are going on about being attacked, then you are on about the OFF scandal being everyone's fault but your own, then you were under threat of WMD, then you were under threat of nukes, then the WMD must have been hidden and though they weren't able to attack America they MAY have been used against naval ships in the middle east....your story just gets weaker and weaker.

Bottom line, your president did NOT do what he had arranged to do and what allies had agreed to support, THAT is why you don' thave support. When there is a JUSTIFIED reason for war, your allies are at your side.

by onbliss

I just thought I will play little with the words..

[i]
factopinguess: \fakt-o-pin-ges\ n : 1. To falsely present as fact something that is derived from opinion or pure conjecture.
[/i]

I silently pronounced the first part \fakt\ and it brought smiles. So here is my attempt to offer an alternate pronounciation to the standard :-)

A "d" instead of "t" would sound even better :-). And how about splitting it as /fakd-op-inges/. The /op/ is pronounced as /up/ :-) /inges/ could convey how false statements, opinions and guesses are actually "ingested" as the truth. Nice, eh?

Disclaimer: This post of mine, directly or indirectly, is [b]NOT[/b] aimed at any TR member. It is just my silliness to amuse...

by maxwell edison

...post a message in my factopinguess thread (just to remind me), and you will indeed get credit and SHARE IN THE BOOTY.

by heml0ck

"When are Americans going to start looking at and honestly judging themselves for once in their lives?"

I know many americans who have made it their life's work to do just that.
It seems to me that one of the problems with the UN, the countries that belong to it, and our view of it, is that we only ever deal with generalizations. As we all know, generalizations may be accurate frrom a distance, but close up they just don't hold water.

by oz_media

The inistial post is a really broad generalization to begin with. It's simply unsupportable BS simply printed to create stir, somewhat successfully if you ask me.

by old guy

it was not posted just to create a stir. I'm the one who posted it because a friend sent it to me in an email and I think, for the most part, this discussion has not gotten as totally out of hand as some have. Actually, I have been glad to read almost everyone's post. During this I have been able to question and re-evaluate some things as well as better understand a few things. Since the majority of the "rants" in here have actually been a little subdued I have even been glad to read those.

What you think of as "unsupportable .." is as supported as most of what anyone else has had to say. Most of it, from all sides including you, is subjective anyway.

Keep in mind that any of this type of discussion really won't effect changes in any government. It is our opinions and feelings and, though it may help us to voice those, I'm quite sure it won't get anything changed in goverment but who knows...if they're "spying on our phone calls" then maybe they are watching our posts here and maybe some of it will seep through. :) We may actually get some laws changed. Ya reckon?

by heml0ck

Getting people talking about stuff like this, whether they agree or not, can only help in the long run.

by oz_media

I said it was PRINTED to create a stir. You're the messenger, the media that writes such tripe is to blame, not you. Sorry if you felt it was directed at your comments, I don't object to your posting it, I just think that the results are pretty meaningless as they are just not specific as to what has been disagreed with. And I wonder if Canada disagreed or agreed on those same votes? Or England, or France even.

This discussion is closed to new replies.