Different systems of government ...
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by fluxit
Mr Brisbane, I have travelled in the service, on vacation, and as a cruise ship officer. In fact, I sailed into Perth and Sidney, Australia. I met perhaps far more people than you. In fact, while in Dubai, UAE at the Sheraton I was invited to a table where a older man and woman were sitting. They were Australians who owned a shipping company and were quite wealthy. Looking at them one would think they were middle to low income by the way they dressed. Quite nice people. I had a long conversation with them and learned a lot.
National governments do not deal with people they deal with other national governments. These national governments acted up and do things from time-to-time that result is some kind of response from another government. Sometimes its somekind of unfair trade practice, other times it involves the exchange of intelligence, other times it is the selling of weapons or guarded technology. Just because your country may not have a backbone to stand up when wronged does not mean the United States should be the same way.
As for Militant Combatants such as Usama Bin Laden, he is a Radical Islamic that misuses his faith to advance personal gain and personal issues by duping others to do his dirty work. That son-of-a-bitch is alive while others died for his misguided efforts. His entire issue is that during Desert Storm I the Unites States, infidels in his eyes, desecrated holy Islamic grounds. It just happens that those same grounds are where the Judeo/Christian Bible was formed. The supposed early teachings of the Koran.
Unfortunately, there are many people around the world who are fed misinformation and develop uninformed opinions. I can only urge you to continue to seek the truth. The evening news rarely has it.
by hal 9000
Been scared in two places and both times I was in what you in the US call cabs one time was in Rome where every driver should be committed and never let out ever under any circumstances as thay are all homicidal and the other time was in LA where I found myself in a cage in the back of a cab with several hand guns sliding around on the front seat it was something unexpected that one.
Even last time I was in Bruni and had the army shove several M16's or whatever in my face I wasn't all that concerned and I knew that they didn't speak english and that they certianly couldn't read the documents that I had with me that where in english I knew that everything would get sourted.
But I am confused by some of you above statments. Are you suggesting that we should kidnap the US President when he is over here thanking us for helping in Iraq? To me that would not only be extremly bad manners it would be a pointless excersise.
But from your posting I get the idea that you think AU should hold the US President for restrictive trade policies and subsidising the inefficent farming comunity in the US. You can't possible be serrious can you?
However I do have to agree with you about Bin Laden but you are mising the point that I was trying to make he is a problem but a far bigger problem is the sisutation that allowed him to gain the power that the has for this I see him as a symptom rather than a problem that has to be smashed. For everyone of his kind that you kill off there will be more to take his place and until the breeding ground is stopped the problem will continue.
The Brits learnt years ago that Gun Boat Diplomicy doesn't work and right now I think that the US is learning the exact same lesson.
You have got to learn that when someone critises a Government decission they aren't in oppersisition to the country in general but not everyone has to agree with every decission made by a Government, it was somewhere here I think that someone said that there was no perfect Governemnt as they could never hope to please all the people all the time and this is perfectly correct. AS an ex forces person you seem to lack the ability to see beyond the obvious and think for yourself in matters relating to Government Policy, certianly if you where to spend any time here in AU you would see many people complain about their present Government but they will vote for them next time anyway, here we don't have to blindly follow our Government's Policy and most Americians that I have meet think the same way.
Just why is it that you seem to think that when I question something that the US Government does I either hate them or am against them can't you see that I just don't agree with what they are doing?
Oh by the way just how many US servicemen and women are in Timor as I don't believe that there are any active personal there from the US but there are a bloody lot of Aussies there keeping the peace and they aren't being attacked every day as well. So just out of courtisy don't refer to Aussies as lacking the Backbane to do what is required.
There is one very important thing that you will have to learn and that is never under any circumstances piss off an Aussie even the Imperial Japanise Army couldn't believe what happened when they did this. They just couldn't understand how they where beaten when they outnumbered their enemy 20 to 1 and had far better equipment it just isn't a cleaver thing to do. Even the Personal serving in NAM learnt this lesson very quickly.
Actually why do you feel the need to pick a fight with me anyway?
I'm a bit confussed on that one. By the way my name is Col or Colin not Mr Brisbane which anyone could easly look up on the peer listing so you are only making a silly statment that is showing how small minded you actually are by trying these childish stunts.
by onbliss
about freedom. Mind you I am not an atheist. I have some faith and belief. But I don't need to read my religious scriptures or any other thing to know that I need to treat others the same way I expect them to treat me.
I think it is wrong to steal, kill ....yada-yada.
I think we should treat each other civily, be nice, kind...etcetra. It comes from my thinking.
by onbliss
I just know that sometimes it angers me. By placing labels we restrict the individual to certain boundaries.
Human mind is vast. It should be allowed to operate freely :-)
As far as someone calling me a Socialist. Like capitalism we need socialism too in the world.
by jimhm
Native American's including American Indians are eligable to run for the President position. There were only two foriegn born Presidents (If I remember correctly) G. Washington - and T. Jefferson - all the others were native american.
IE - Native American - born in U.S.A.
A naturalized citizen can hold any office except president - or VP ...
As to Native American - I love it when these aholes call with surveys and ask what is your nationality .... Native American.. Oh you're an Indian - no I am a Native American - I was born in this country. Now if you are asking what is my ancentory - then I am American of German/Serbian descent... Or if you are asking my Race - White - they get so - mad it is too funny.
Like telling the bouncer that a person is 21 - when they were born in 1993 - Your birthday celibrates your last day of that year... So you are actually going to be starting your 22nd year. Go figure math - hey it work a number of times on the mussel heads... no brains - all bulk... bouncers
by onbliss
I always leave it blank or check "Other". (Since there is never an "American" selection.
I also leave the Race blank. The only way to eradicate racism is to not see race.
by hal 9000
By the way I was in no way trying to infer that there was a difference between Americians it's just that I've heard the Indians refered to as "Native" so many times that I just whent with the flow but I am in full agreement with you on that one as I do excatly the same thing over here on the very rare occasion that I am rung up now {Seems that I'm on a black list or something} because I don't give them the answers that they want to hear so they no longer bother me.
But don't you just love the way that they respond when you answer their questions literally? They get really confused and don't seem to understand.
I suspose it is all because they constantly want to seperate people into different little boxes rather than treat them as people with the same rights and responsibilities as everyone else.
This is one thing that I hate with a vengence the way people are treated differently just because of their race or whatever I think everyone should be treated equally with special attention directed to needy areas rather than just throwing money at a certian race because it looks good but really does next to nothing to help.
...we need a hole in our hearts.
We don't "need" socialism in the world.
...that you know so much about "freedom". At one time in history, people were not so enlightened.
Before the 18th century, it was pretty common, if not universal, in the world that it was governments, whether they be dictatorships, monarchies, or whatever, that "granted" particular freedoms to "individuals". In other words, the "individual" was not free to do ANYTHING unless it was granted and approved by the "government. The "individual" had no power whatsoever except for what the "government" (the rulers) allowed them to have.
Then, in the mid to late 18th century, T.J. and the boys (and other "enlightened" minds) had this notion that the "status quo" was bass ackwards. They thought that it was the "individual" who should grant power to the government, not the other way around. Their contention was that liberty (freedom) was something inherently granted to every individual by their mere existence - something their "Creator" had intended all along. Wow, the Creator was the one who granted liberty, not the government - what a concept!
Believe it or not, not everyone thought the same way. Many people around the world remained firm in their convictions that the government, not the Creator, had the power to grant limited freedoms to the lowly individual. A war was fought over such an idea. Liberty is endowed by the Creator. Powers are granted TO governments BY the people. America was founded, basically, on that principle alone.
Our liberty is something many take for granted. They don't realize that with liberty (freedom) comes responsibility. And all too many people are too willing to shirk their responsibility, thereby granting to government all power over everything they do - and expecting that government to exert power over others.
So it really has nothing to do with religious scriptures or anything like that at all. (Thomas Jefferson, by the way, was not really a "religious" person at all.) Your Creator - however you may or may not define Him/Her/It/Whomever/Whatever - endowed you with the liberty to make all of those choices for yourself - without me, your neighbor, a government, a king, a church, or anyone or anything else having the right to do anything about it. (Unless, of course, your choices infringe on the liberties of others.)
Thus the comment, ".....We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness....."
So there ya' go. Use your liberty to live your life to pursue any happiness you desire. (But just don't take mine away in the process - i.e. TAXES to pay for other people's bad choices!!!)
by mrbill-
by monkeybutter
by onbliss
>>I also leave the Race blank. The only way to eradicate racism is to not see race
Very well said. True!!!
by onbliss
by onbliss
If you reverse speed further back...people in many cultures believed their Kings/Queens...were incarnations of God, or was from the chosen clan/tribe...whatever. In addition the Kings were revered lot becos of ...(I don't know all the reasons :-) may be becos they protected them from the people in other clan/tribes.....
That could explain the people's view on the rulers.
It took ages for the people to know Kings were not God but mere powerful people.
....that you were born 225+ years after the "enlightenment" resulting in the concept of individual liberty instead of before? I sure am.
Regards
by road-dog
The Constitution prohibits the Presidency to tose not born in the US.
Well, all Presidents born in the colonies before 1787 (the ratification) were not born in the US.
I'm really not inclined to do the research and see how many are in this situation, because I doubt that even Al Gore would dispute those early elections.
by tomsal
...or can be. Since the government applies to a large number of people the addage "Can't please all the people all the time" comes to mind.
Since you can NEVER please *ALL* the people all the time a government will never, nor can it ever hope to be, perfect -- someone will always find something to complain about; no matter how large or small the beef might be.
That all said, an "Improved" government according to me would include:
+ True democratic elections for Presential campaign; no electoral college deciding who is President. However I'd like to actual minimal requirements beyond age for voting. I really think when you register to vote you should have to take some kind of pre-screening test. If you fail the test you can't vote.
+Social programs like Welfare would have STRICT requirements and you'd have to actively prove that you are trying to improve yourself (get a job, increased education, etc.) or you are kicked out of the program. PERIOD.
+Justice system would be completely re-vamped. If sufficient evidence existed that one was guilty of a capital offense - they are tried as an adult, the only exception would be for those younger than 10 years old. No more serial killers on death row for decades either, make that system efficient -- empty those cells, ease the burden on tax payers.
+Immigration control wouldn't be a joke. Like it is today. There would be REAL border controls.
I could go on and on...
by fluxit
No electoral college? Then there would be no representation of states like Idaho or Montana. Only large cities like New York, Chicago, or LA would run the country. Politicians would not even campaign anywhere else but those places. I would not want large cities to run the country! They are already hosed up and most are left wing radicals.
As far social programs, hasn't that happened since 1992?
As for the death penalty, you need to ask yourself does the law influence the lawless? Would the death penalty deter crime if the lawless have no respect for life or the law? Due process is important. After DNA testing they discovered dozens of death row inmates who were innocent. It would be heresy to implement a death penalty without some sort of sound moral doctrine.
Immigration - agreed. This has been politicized by political parties to increase votes. Liberals tend to open the flood gates and let anyone in because they typically vote for liberal causes. Although the Cubans are bitter since the days of Kennedy and vote almost unanimously conservative.
I think the current track the Unites States is on moves us closer to an ideal Government.
by hal 9000
Out any reference to those political items that where discussed but I will offer this coment about the death penelty.
Here in Queensland AUstralia the last person hung for a capatol offence was found to be inconent several years latter and the real guilty person was caught. What could the Governemtn do to rectify this situtation Say sorry and everything was alright?
The only problem with the death penelty is you have to be absoulty sure he/she has done it before you carry out the penelty as once the penelty has been carried out it is far too late to try to correct any misscarrages of Justice and fix the mess that has been made.
by jimhm
No Electoral college - bad idea, then you would have area's like New York and California electing the President - Forget about a majority of the states - And just look how screwed up NY and Ca is - CA just recalled one Bozzo and elected Arnie the Governator...
And forget about any canidate tromping through low populated states ...
The Electoral College was created to ensure that all states were represented and had a vote in the President...
As for reform and Prisions - Yes some major reform needs to be done, from ending most of these programs to ending life long appeals..
And Boarders - there is way to much work needed to even begin to discuss that.
by onbliss
Personally, I'd prefer to see the death penalty abolished.
I don't think it's right to take a life, whether the person or entity taking the life is an individual (a criminal), a doctor, or a state.
Taking a life in self defense, of course, would be my only exception. The military fighting in battle would fall under this category, as would abortion - but ONLY to save the life of the mother.
In any and all other cases, I'd prefer to see more respect for life.
I don't like the alternative to the death penalty either, at least not the current day alternative as it would be in America. A "living death penalty" might me more appropriate - and possibly more of a deterrent to crime. Bring back the penal colony of devil's island, crush boulders into rocks, crush rocks into pebbles, move pebbles back and forth, no hope for escape or parole, etc.
Banishing an evil doer from society doesn't mean we have to kill him.
by oz_media
The Death penalty is acceptable when we look at Cliffor doLsen, Jeffrey Dahmer, etc. These people have without ANY question taken the lives of others and shown little or no remorse for their actions. The world doesn't seem to put a precidence into the psycological problems of these men and simply chooses to lock them up due to lack of ability to do better for them.
If this be the case, I'd rather see them put to the death penalty as oppsed to sucking the taxpayers money for 50 years, look at Clifford Olsen particularly. This man just offers information about another child he's killed each time he needs some cell improvements, no joking, the Canadaian government (and the taxpayers) have paid over one hundred thousand dollars to this man for information about the lives he took!
In this case, end his life, and save our money.
PROBLEM:
The judicial system is so sorrupted and inaccurate that we have placed MANY men/women on death row, only to find out that they are innocent after being locked up for 11 years.
Until the judicial system improves to impecable accuracy I cannot condone the death sentence.
The problem isn't the punishment, the problem is the courts and lawyers who warp the facts to either create doubt in the jury's mind, thus releasing the criminal, or create a misleading trail of evidence that sees an innocent citizen found guilty for a crime he/she didn't commit.
Forget the sentence, fix the laws.
by jimhm
by jimhm
Thats one of the most interesting thing about it here.. The government past a law saying that you'er not to ask it on applications or record it on personnel records but then - the government wants counts by race for when you bid on a government contract. Hum - if I didn't record it do I have two walk around my company and count..
Kind of a catch-22 ... if you don't ask and aren't to record it - but then to bid on government contracts you have to proved it ...
Got to love those government regulations and laws...
by onbliss
I am just happy thats all. With my personality I am sure I must have been happy and sad 1000 years before too.
225+ yrs does not hold any special significance for me.
by oz_media
Why is it that all the street signs depict black people doing stupid things in the middle of the road?
A black man holding a shovel, black children running across the street, even a black kid bouncing a ball across the street (are they saying that black people can't afford a Playstation?)
It's pretty prejudiced to imply that Caucasians and Asians aren't a traffic hazard! How about pets? I've never sen a CAT crossing sign (except in my driveway), I've never actually seen a black man standing in the road shovelling a pile of dirt just for the hell of it. If this sign is supposed to mean that these are city workers, why aren't they holding a cup of coffee while shooting the shit with another city worker?
by fluxit
Why would we want one or two states like New York and California run the country? Should all the states have representation?
Per our Constitution we have such a thing called State Rights. The Federal Government does not deal directly with the people. The feds only deal with the state governments where the majority rules at that level. Then each state cast a number of votes based on how its population votes.
One thing that I have noticed is that so many people really need a CIVICS class. TOO MANY PEOPLE LACK THE MOST BASIC UNDERSTANDING OF OUR GOVERNMENT. If you desire I will tutor you via email.
by john_wills
by jimhm
The problem is the population - if lets say New York votes75% for Billary Clinton ... it would take a number of states to kill that vote - where as with an Electroial college - NY only gets lets say 7 votes...
Also why would politicans do anything for the small states - no votes there - I'll take care of California - New York - Texas - George ... the rest can get bent...
by jimhm
Ah - the American public school system - or is the pubic ses-pool system...
Kids can't read - teachers can't teach - and parents don't care...
We are going to have one great group of people to lead our - Stupid children into the future... And people wonder why Corporations are going to the H1 and H1B's visa...
Duh - Mr how much is 2x2 ... duh I don't have my calculator... But I teach Math in High School..
by fluxit
If you review the history of the National Education Association, NEA, you will note a very definite radical left wing agenda to prepare our youth for a One World Government and destroy national soveignty. Look at their publications in the 40's and 50's. It is real scary and has carried over to today. The outcome of that is stupid people.
It really bothers me. I recall high school Problems of Democracy Class in the 70's where my teacher only taught that liberals were good and Conservatives were bad. Everything was government programs and the need to help defendless people. Conversely from 1976 to 1980 we had the worst economy and one national disgrace after another while under the radical left wing rule of Jimmy Carter and the Liberal Peoples Republic of Congress. I recall double digit inflation, unemployment, and nearly every profession was on strike. Truckers blocked the freeways. Coal miners and steel workers were on strike. Auto workers went on stike. In fact, my teachers wildcat striked in the middle of the school year. They would urge me not to attend school while picketing. I really have a difficult time trusting the public schools system.
by onbliss
by fluxit
Understand. I have had some minor of experience working in the real real world with real real Governments. I am only serving as a US Naval Reserve Officer and have deployed to many places during real world events. I have about 40 combat days on my DD214.
I currently work for a combatant commander, a politican\warrior. Coincidentally, General Peter Pace (current Vice Chairman of JCS) was one of then Combatant Commanders I did work for in the past - although not a direct report I did speak with him occasion. My experience with these Generals has spans C4 systems, Operations (I was on watch on 911 in the Crisis Action Center as the right hand man to the Current Operations Group Commander), and I have served as a Information Operations and Geopolitical Analyst. Currently, I am advancing a vision of mine I call the Adaptive Organization as a technical lead.
I have an idea of what goes on with our the Joint Doctrine, Congressional Affairs, and State Department. I did write an example of some C4 doctrine I thought we should have when I briefed the Under Secretary of Defense at a conference some 4 years ago.
Some of the events I have been involved with span combat operations, humanitarian aide, Nation Building, and a variety of MOOTW ops.
I about 5 years ago I served as a Military Escort for about 7 Ambassadors during a conference. I normally do not hob nob with them but they seemed like nice people. Although one got a little arrogant with me when I did not recall his name.
I am still learning but perhaps I can share some vague understanding that I may have with you.
I know you're trying to be funny, but you're not.
Comments like that contribute to the perpetuation of racism.
by oz_media
of us who have no sense of humor or feel that being politically correct are offended by those who really don't care what you think.
You see, those who do not enjoy to simply laugh at the world and the screwed up ideals that we put upon each other are also those who aren't any fun to be around.
Now I understand that your intellectual thought process is far beyond mine, I also feel that as a result of this that you have become someone who can't enjoy the world for what it really is.
Unfortunately, your inability to smile and enjoy life has caused you to become one of those stuffy, stuck up and miserable old men that stop the world from rotating.
If you don't enjoy life and all it has to offer, that is YOUR perogative. It is sad that those who are around you are subject to your miserable outlook on the world and the people within it, mainly because your analytical skills are atrocious but also because nobody needs a wet blanket to cuddle.
If you aren't amused by those you meet, if you can't laugh at mistakes, if you can't enjoy the day, that is OK just don't expect me to follow your miserable example of how life should be. You're too dry, you're too concerned and too bitchy for anyone's benefit.
Your show exact type of stuffy political mentality that turned the once exciting Vancouver into a no fun zone by removing all the events we had that held the people together.
And I enjoy life to the fullest.
But I contend that the only way to eradicate racism is to not see race - even in humor. And no, I'm not one of those "politically correct" types. (But If you had even the slightest idea as to what type of person I really am, you'd know that.) To the contrary, it's the politically correct types who insist on seeing race; they insist on calling people some hyphenated name based on the color of their skin. No, that's not me.
And no, you're not funny.
In fact, your defense of yourself actually makes you even more disgusting.
by oz_media
by oz_media
You know Max, you may not find my humor amusing. You don't have to and probably wouldn't appreviate dry humor anyhow, judging by American AND CANADIAN TV (with the exception of This Hour has 20 minutes), unless Ernest is falling off a ladder it isn't funny. Now I agree that the USA has had some funny classic comedy's but they were just copies of successful British comedies.
I have actually had a reasonably successful stint at YukYuks, Punchlines and Laughlines here and in Toronto. I just got bored of the industry and got into music touring instead.
I have NEVER looked for you approval here in ANY of my posts, nor will I in the future.
I don't post here for anyone's benefit except my own, it is my right to express my feelings and thoughts, it is my right to converse with others in this forum. Before you go writing more emails to TR trying to get me removed from the site, think twice, your opinion is just that, YOUR opinion as MY opinion is just MINE.
by oz_media
You don't have an IP address either I suppose.
Maxwell,
I didn't mean to imply you had tried to implicate me in the past, by saying 'more', but you seem to like writing to the editors and complaining about others. Perhaps it makes you feel important or more involved, it's not my insecurity.
Like I said before Max, you and I don't now nor ever will have anything in common. The ONLY interest we've shared is music, but everyone shares an interst in music.
The Beatles were a great band that poineered many of todays musical tastes, but I don't give them the musical credit that many still do. There have been many bands with just as much musical influence and talent, if not more, than the Beatles ever had. Especially considering that most of the Beatles music was inspired by Blues musicians and simplified for the general public.
Other than that, nada.
Your constant defamation of my character is second to none, you are the reason that I can't tell people who I work with in the music industry even though some have expressed interest in my contacts and work.
You are the reason that people cannot speak freely, your constant repression of anyone that disagrees with your views, great job Saddam, make you a perfect candidate for Presidency. So to answer your question from before, if I could pick ANY American to run the country, I'd pick you. You'd at least give the rest of the world a good reason to unite and turn America into a dessert. Your distaste towards anything unAmerican and your ignorance towadr human life is the type of singular personality that causes others to see America in the negative way they do.
For someone who considers himself the ultimate citizen, you are actually a terrible example of the people. You are a pathetic, miserable old codger that has seen more than enough days of light. Perhaps it's time for you to rest now and go toward the light.
As they say on Joe Schmo, MAX, you are dead to me. Too bad it's only a TV show.
by john_wills
by oz_media
"The campaigners against the death penalty have not, to my knowledge, brought up a case of a person found after execution to have been innocent - although there have been some near misses"
How many cases are continued AFTER the death of the condemmed? How much time and resources are used AFTER the death penalty is carried out?
It is VERY common to release the condemmed BEFORE the death penalty is carried out. It happens more and more each year as forensic science advances.
Given the fact that the government, the lwayers and the prosecutors are constantly wrong in conviction of the guilty or freedom of the innocent, how can one say that the death penalty should be in place?
I agree that there are some that we don't feel we can rehabilitate and due to our limited knowledge of the human brain, we choose to lock them up or sentence them to death I study forensic pathology quite extensively as well as the criminal mind, as a hobby. There are too many questions and doubts in the fields to accurately sentence someone to death, we have the ability to kill a man but not to know why.
Death penalty -NO
Fixing the judicial system -YES.
Once we can assertain without a doubt (not a reasonable doubt but with NO DOUBT WHATSOEVER) that people have committed a crime, we cannot persecute them in this way.
by john_wills
by hal 9000
Long line of people who said the exact same thing. Since I didn't want to bore people with a complete list I didn't bother but just why would Iraq drill under Kwaita to get the3ir oil when they couldn't sell it anyway? Remember prior to the invasion there where embargos against Iraq which where only hurting the people as the post invasion coverage has shown.
Then there is a very important lesson that is currently being relearned by all parties involved in thsi conflict. It is one thing to invade a country and a totally diffferent thing to hold it once invaded. Germany learnt this lesson in France durring both world wars now we are relearning it all over again but thsi time it is our troops who are bearing the brunt of resistance.
One day and it may not be all that far off there just may be people in Iraq rewarded for resisting the percieved Invaders and susceeding in throwing them out.
We are currently seeing this now in a small way now what do you think will happen if the resistance gets any larger? What is even worse is that these people who are resisting think that Sad Man Who Sucks isn't a despoit but a great leader. Personally I don't which is more frightening!
by john_wills
I understand that in the U.S. there is no known 20th-Century case of an innocent person being put to judicial death: the death penalty is so serious that the innocent, usually after many tribulations, are exonerated.
However, there are myriads of cases of innocent people being convicted for lesser crimes, where there is no concentration of lawyers etc. trying to get them off. In the U.S. at least an important part of the cause of this is prosecutorial corruption; I have personally had a prosecutor conceal the location of an important witness in the hope of convicting me (she dropped the case when her chief witness, a bent cop, turned out to have a record such that no jury would believe him). This would happen less if those who, like me, found out the prosecution had been malicious could sue for it, but in the U.S. they can't. California Government Code Sec. 821.6 protects the traitors. In Canada the equivalent rule is "No Servant of the Queen may allege that the Queen ordered him to commit any tort.", so there is less malicious prosecution. If Sec. 821.6 were changed to read "No Servant of the People of the State of California may allege that the People ordered him to commit any tort." we would see a gradual improvement in prosecutorial behavior, then in police behavior, then in the behavior of the social groups most victimized by police and prosecutorial misbehavior. And we would have far fewer innocent people convicted.
by john_wills
by jimhm
Look at the Muslim countries - where a thief has his hand cut off, or a women is stoned for infedelity, or in India where a man can murder his wife for not obeying his commands.
Hum - the age old question - of Crime and punishment. Is it better to coddle the prisioner in a just and humain way - or make it so nasty that any person in their right mind wouldn't want to be there.
Neither has worked - it has nothing to do with the courts - or lawyers - or laws ...
It all comes back to the persons upbringing - yes there are those 1 in a thousand that are screwed in the head - but you can trace most crimals back to bad parenting - no guidelines or rules at a young age - no displine ...
The death penilty works ... but not to deter crime - but to keep that individual from ever doing it again... Someone kills one of my loved ones - will answer to my death penitly - not the courts... They will never harm another person - again.. That is what the death sentance accomplishes -
by oz_media
The argument at this point in the thread is regarding the ability to correctly convict the right person and not those who have been screwed by a crappy judicial system.
Until we can nail the right guy without doubt, we cannot sentence someone to death. Now to hear this coming from someone with such religious beliefs as yourself is quite surprising.
Yes I agree 150% ! If I caught someone harming any member of my family or friends, I would kill them myself without any remorse and would happily serve any prison time as a result of saving my loved ones.
Clifford Olsen was a neighbour of mine at one time when I lived in Richmond, he had a neice that played with my neice and he wasn't that different than anyone else. If I had killed him, after discovering his other crimes, I would have been put on a pedastal as a hero and not a jury in the country would have convicted me.
As it stands, he gets treated well, has his own cell (complete with satellite TV, a computer "for his studies" and a tonne of money goes to his family every time he releases info about another he killed. This man deserves to die.
Those who are convicted on a shoestring of a case are often found to be not guilty MANY, MANY years after the sentence. This is a strong indication that we have no business in sentencing someone to death until we can resolve the issues that block fair trial and the corruption of the courts, police and prosecutors.
by hal 9000
That the courts don't work because instead of seaking justice which they where originally set up to do they have degenerated into I must will at all costs and a proscituer or lawer who constantly winns is considered as a sucessful person.
When the adversiarl system is removed and we begin to see pure justice where everyone works towards getting the truth that is the only time things will start to improve. Then we will not have people believe sometimes quite rightly that the police are out to get them, the police won't be put under preasure to catch a wrong dooer at any cost and the proscitution will not be under any obligation to winn at all costs. Of course the same has to happen on the other side as well so the privilage must go as anyone who willingly defends a person who they know is guilty is not working for justice but their own ends.
What we need is some humanity back in the court sustem rather than the current winn at all costs. Until this is changed there will be no justice only chaos.
by oz_media
I made similar, yet not eloquently stated, opinions of the American school system some time ago after talking with a friend who taught American History at UCLA. He finally left after seven years due to the one sided and misleading information he was told to teach.
I have made the argument that American kids are taught political bias in school and that they are not really educated to the workings of the rest of the world as much as they are with American politics.
This argument was slammed due to my nationality and diregarded as ignorant because it was coming from a non-American.
Now I see the same argument from an American with yet another American in agreement.
I agree, but it the psychology behind it is very interesting. Thanks for being honest about a flaw in the American school system and agreeing that there needs to be improvement. Now if they would only stop teaching the mating habits of the Canadaian beaver(yes the animal, you pigs) here!
by oz_media
by fluxit
CIRCA 1948 there was a conference in which a 50 year plan was laid out to bring on a New World Order. It heavily involved educating the youth to accept this one world government. The NEA was heavily involved. Fortunately, it has not occurred.
1946: The Teacher, World Government and editor from the NEA publishes, "...In the struggle to establish an adequate world government, the teacher can do much to prepare the hearts and minds of children for global understanding and cooperation. At the very heart of all the agencies which will assure the coming of world government must stand the school, teacher, and and the organized profession."
1946 the American Education Fellowship writes "... establishment of the new world order, an order in which national sovereignty is subordinate to world authority."
Folks this nuts are still here today. New world Order is not being used becasue its taboo. So now they call it Global Governance. Hey Did the Bible not prophetize something about this? Oh well I should not worry about Global Governance since I will be gone at the Rapture. Anyhow it was something about the 'Anti-christ', new Babylon, World Government headquarters... some people think that is about the United States, United Nations, and immoral leaders? But that Bible thing is not real as some of you put it.
by john_wills
by hal 9000
Why can we as man never find the middle ground where things work in a fair and just manner?
The listing you have placed here is at the other extreme of the current US & AU Judical System. Exactly is it that every thime that some form of anything is concerned it has to be taken to the extreme? I can remember here when Lionel Murphy drew up the blueprint for our Family Court which incidently now is a total disater but as at the time I was very well know to this man he tried to get a system where the Legal Whores wern't involved or at least only in a minimual manner and it worked for all of 6 months before the legal whores got their grubby little hands into the system and distorted it to their own ends for profit. Here it isn't even wim at all costs but get as much money as possible out of the suckers when they are at their most vunerable which is surely the best time for these vultures to swoop in and make a killing.
When this court was originally setup there was susposed to be simple rules where the everyday person could get up and get justice so there where no hard and fast rules put in place that you keeded a legal degre to work the system it was all very laid back for any court system and it was this very fact that has been its undoing as the legal whores have got hold of these very lose rules and distorted them into something that now bears no resimbelance to what was originally intended they now get up and say some stupid things like "My Cleint is scared of the way their ex is looking at them" junk like this would be imediatly thrown out of any other court because when you are in a room and the person is giving evidence it is only normal the everyone looks at them but now it is an offence as it intimidates the wittness. This has been so screwed up since its introduction that the Judges who sit over this court are driving Political Correctness to the extreme so that one even tried to have me charged with Contemp of Court after I had ben forced to give evidence and he then approched me in a lift with his body guards and being unhappy with my testominy he asked me a question about what I thought of his actions. Well I'm nor all that subtle at the best of times and particuarly after being forced to waste half my day for some stupidity I told him exactly what I thought of his stupid ideas and the absolute crazy way he ran the court I think I even mentione that he should and would be certified if he didn't preside in that court. Now as I answered a direct question that was asked of me by the Judge out of court he then attempted to have me charged with Contemp of Court to which I replied how can I be in contempt when the court is already in contempt odf the law or something like that. This fool then demanded that one of his bodyguards arrest me to which I replied I was only answering a direct question placed by him to me out of a court and while the court wasn't sitting. He then claimed that I was threating him to which I asked how I'm standing in a corner of a lift I haven't moved and I certianly haven't even raised my voice unlike you. The body guards tended to agree with my position and some even laughed but it does show just how silly things have got when these people do things like this and expect to only hear glowing reports of their actions as if they can do no wrong. ANyway the Lift ended its ride and I insisted to the senior bodyguard to have him removed as I didn't want to move in case he fell over and I got the blame for his inability to walk through a lobby. While this only infurated the Judge even more his body guards tended toagree with me and removed him from the lift and one stayed with me until he had cleared the area. I was then told by that person I wish I could say what you've just said as he diserves it.
Incidently the children who he awarded back to the mother again after she had deserted them several time previously all died within the next 6 months in a house fire while they where unattended and their mother who had custody was out having a good time.
Now maybe it's just me buy I see this as little better than manslaughter by the Judge as the mother had done the exact same thing at least 6 times previously and on one occasion she came into my house and asked my wife could she look after the children while she went to the doctors for about 1 hour six days latter when she returned she seemed oblivious to all the problems that she had caused and even complained that we had gone into her unlocked house to get clothes for her children, the youngest of which was then only a few months old.
by john_wills
by jimhm
We aren't talking about the one more vote - we are talking that the canidate will not worry about the less populated states, during the election and after - I have X dollars to spend on ad's - where is the biggest bang for my ad dollars going to come from - Cal, Ny, Florida and Texas ...as for Az, Wy and the others I will spent almost zero...
My Travel dollars - where is the biggest bang going to be for my spending - Same states - Those that are populated.
Thus you don't have a representation of the country as a whole.. Where even thou the Electroial college may have its problems it is better than the popular vote method.
Once elected why worry about these less populated states - they will not carry any weight during my re-election ... If I carry NY - and CA I can take the election... Thats what it designed to prevent.
by oz_media
This isn't a question of which legal system or judicial system is correct. It doesn't matter WHAT system is in place if it is corrupted and therefore NOT part of the system.
Unfortunately, this is seen worldwide on a massive scale.
by hal 9000
Now the UN is plagiarising the Declaration of Independence what is the world coming to?
Well I don?t suppose anyone will be upset as it is so self evident but I take my hat off to you Maxwell.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending