Discussion Locked

DR pros and cons of OSs

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Tell us what you think about Mike Talon's advice about the DR pros and cons of different OSs, as featured in the Feb. 4 Disaster Recovery e-newsletter. Which OS does your organization use? Does it fulfill your DR needs?

21 replies

by jlmarmier

There is a very good OS with a lot of developpment possibilities : QNX. QNX is free for non-commercial use. You can use it on your PC, PAD etc.. specialized for real time application, this OS is garantee for Nuclear, Spatial, Medical environments. You can find it on http://www.qnx.com

by Member 21032712

Perhaps a bit of irony, but I have been recommending and installing Linux as a fallback DR solution for Windows servers. The scripts I've developed can be used in situations where the more elaborate machinery of tape/san+enterprise solutions are awkward and/or relatively slow to execute. Linux has advantages over Norton, in
better hardware manufacturer support and licensing.

by Member 21032712

Perhaps a bit of irony, but I have been recommending and installing Linux as a fallback DR solution for Windows servers. The scripts I've developed can be used in situations where the more elaborate machinery of tape/san+enterprise solutions are awkward and/or relatively slow to execute. Linux has advantages over Norton, in
better hardware manufacturer support and licensing.

by del

While Solaris is admitedly the most robust of the UNIX variants, SPARC compatabile hardware is (and has) been available from Fujitsu. Fujitsu Primepower Servers offer a reliable, cost effective Solaris platform.

by theseacher

/
In reference to Mike Talon's "THERE'S NO SUCH THING AS A PERFECT OS" he used the term DR frequently. Yet I did not see any definition given for DR.

Anyone?
\

by h.fitch2

Many major data centers operate with OpenVMS with excellent disaster recovery performances (i.e., OpenVMS continues to operate through most disasters without major performance degradation). Perhaps it's time for the "experts" to consider some of the tried and true OS options (MVS anyone?).

by draco vulgaris

VMS (the "Open" is silent), while no longer politically correct, is a superb operating system. It's a shame that Ken Olsen and Robert Palmer killed the goose that laid the golden eggs!

One of the classic stories from the late eighties or early nineties concerned the French bank that lost its Paris data center in a fire without losing a byte of data or a minute of processing time; their VMS Cluster simply failed over to a backup data center 35 miles away. All the disks were shadowed at the backup data center! Does this sound like the Merrill-Lynch trick? Same thing but circa 1988!!!

by fae

iSeries, nee AS/400. Ditto Draco's comments re VMS: an excellent machine, not yet dead but hardly helped by it's keeper (IBM). There are many examples of companies who have successfully recovered operations on systems dedicated to DR/HA for both planned and unplanned outages.

by mbaumli

Novell Netware for instance can be critical to business in order for it to run, but it has been my experiance that Netware is one of the most difficult for DR situations.

OS/400 and other IBM OSs are almost ideal, they work without question, have little troubles, and have proprietary apps that run on them. However, they are equally if not more expensive than UNIX variants.

Also, I feel that BSD, which is one of the strongest variants of UNIX was highly under represented. BSD distros aren't as proprietary as other UNIX distrobutions.

by 1ronman

The article was pointed toward DR so this is a little off topic, but this looks like a good place to get my question answered. We are setting up a new system which uses Oracle. The vendor says we should run it on Unix or linux because Windows isnt able to handle the load. We have ~250 users who will be pounding this DB daily. The problem is we have no linux/unix expertise inhouse, but do have enough depth in our Windows knowledge (just not when it comes to large Oracle DB's). So my question is this. Is the vendor steering us down the path of his best profit margins, or is this true.

by draco vulgaris

I'm puzzled by the omission of IBM Mainframe Operating Systems. They are still much used in large data centers and predate Unix!

by philbarry2002

Well, I think ZOS, OS/390, and even the latest versions of MVS are so different from the original IBM OS that it's safe to say that, strictly speaking, Unix predates IBM's flagship OS. And Unix, which IIRC appeared in 1965 may have actually predatedany release of IBM OS, which was announced April 7, 1964 - but I don't know when it was actually hit the market.

Of course, Unix was a programming tool originally, so it didn't need to achieve even the low reliability of IBM's OS before people started using it.

Unix was not a datacenter OS until well into its teens, while IBM's MVS had achieved a type of 7 X 24 performance by the early '80s.

To write an article on DR and not mention the mainframe strikes me as ludicrous. I really question the knowledge of the writer and the editor.

Without reference to mainframes, the whole article is questionable.

Phil

by jshank1049

Feceral banking regulations required the bank I worked at to demostrate the ability to recover our system at a disaster recovery site. We were able to recover our IBM Mainframe running VM and VSE and our DEC VAXcluster with VMS and have our networkfully restored in less than sixteen hours. You can't even come close to that with a Windows based system that would support the same number of users and applications.

by brian.joe

NetWare can't be overlooked as it has evolved into a superb OS. Total disaster recovery is available and a breeze using products from Veritas for example. Hardware compatibility is extremely strong as well. Looking at the history and current offerings, we see a strong solid foundation for business continuance in the face of adversity.

by miketalonnyc

I figure I should just post once to clear up a whole bunch of issues this article triggered.

First, I said "primary" or "common" datacenter Operating Systems. This rules out a lot of the one-off and older systems. Sorry guys and gals, I have a limited amount of space to work with here.

Next - specific plugs from vendors aside - most of your points are very valid and I won't debate them, as I said in the article EVERY OS has pros and cons.

Finally, I would like to post a small correction. Solaris can be installed on Intel hardware, for development purposes. Since it is generally not considered a wise idea to run such Solaris/Intel machines as part of vitial prodcution processes, I omitted this fact, and apologise.

The topic of operating systems is always prone to heated debate, and I'm glad that this still happens. Please continue to debate, but remember please that each poster is a human being, and everyone has the right to their opinion.

Thanks

Mike Talon

by decon1

Its strange that Novell does not get a mention in this article. Do managing the desktop with ZENworks, printers with NDPS, Web access to the Network including apps (to name a few) not count as a Data Center OS???

by lindsays

There never seems much talk or interest on the BSD O/S 's. I was wondering if anyone had any thoughts on these O/S.

by phelms

FreeBSD has been used as a server for a while. It would be interesting to know of DR solutions for FreeBSD.

This discussion is closed to new replies.