Discussion Locked

Even drunk stoners pass in Pittsburgh schools!

0 helpful
44 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So you skip out, you turn up drunk,m you smoke a few joints in class, you turn up and leave as you choose, you listen to your iPod all day and draw pictures of naked women on your textbooks and guess what? You get a 50% passing grade!

Yes, it seems some schools feel it is wrong to fail a child and while some schools have long implemented a 50% 'E' rule to replace the horrible failing F, this school has decided there will be no failing grades. uhhhhh, now when I went to school.....oh whatever.

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08266/914029-298.stm

Yeah, I think this whole positive reinforcement things has gone too far, we coddle our children, don' tlet them play outside in teh evening (don't FORCE them to get otuside in the evening), we drive them all over the planet instead of telling them to walk, ride abike or take a bus, we encourage 'everyone wins' rules for junior sporting events (no score is kept, just a friendly game of soccer or baseball and 'everyone wins')and now we won't let them fail in school.

I can just see the grads of tomorrow, being dropped off at school, wrapped in bubble wrap and packed into the passenger seat with pillows so we don't break our fragile children.

These are the people who we will trust to live in a competitive world, a hard world, a world of wars, religious zealots and terrorism?

I suppose we should let them know what the world is really like one day though.

But I suppose its not too new, Bush was given a C in school too. ZINGER! badum-dum.! :D

44 replies

by jdclyde

how you described your highschool experience, huh? B-)

That is all part of the problem of lowered standards being placed on people for generations.

This is just getting them ready for a shining future as tomorrows blossoming liberals who will tell us it isn't "fair" that no one will GIVE them a job. :0

by oz_media

I excelled in academics, so I got bored easily and just wrote/passed teh tests. But nobody gave me a C handout, I was not the best student but held a high C+ to B average in academics. In shops, which dominated most of my HS curriculum, I aced everything, A's and A+'s all through. Career auto (3hr periods), career drafting(1-2 hours periods depending on projects), Career machining and welding (2-3 hour periods)and then Math and English, dropped French as soon as it wa an elective, dropped science and social studies as soon as they were elective also, just focused on English (never an elective) and shops, my career focus. I went to two high schools, one that was huge for sports and
trades training and one that was a former technical/trade school converted to highschool.

Yuo seem to be reflecting on my senior years in elementary, where we harassed teachers for 3 years. In grade 5 I was in a 5/6 split, so we were seniors a little early and go to join in all the reindeer games.

High school I showed up for the classes that I felt I got something out of, trades. I was working as an apprentice machinist and only had interest in working for a living, not studying for another 4 years.

I didn't care about anything but my trades classes and was thoroughly bored by whay they called academic education, so I just turned up and wrote tests when I had to, and attended a few classes just so my attendance didn't slip too far and make me fail, that got me a decent passing grade for what mattered to THEM, my actual working skills is what mattered to ME though.

I think I did pretty good for a drop out though.

by jaqui

the radio ads for "jobshop.ca"?
and monster?

the "new hire" bursts into tears when the "boss" say hello. acuses him of yelling at her.

by oz_media

The government conspiracy angle, always did like that one. I like to stop before it comes to thinking I am living with computer chips inserted in my head by aliens that work for the CIA though. :D

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I'd lay this conspiracy at the foot of government. I'd lay it at the foot of money interests. Keep the masses one or two steps from losing their @sses, and control wages, bennies - or lack thereof - retirement packages, all those things that contribute to the cost of doing business. Further, uneducated masses won't be able to see it happening.

Bizarrely - or not - I'm reminded of John Carptenter's "They Live". Keep 'em in the dark to control them.

etu

by shasca

I watched a documentary this weekend about Airborne enrollee's. 17-19 year old kids busting their humps to qualify to be able to jump out of a perfectly good airplane.
These volunteer recruits did everything humanly possible to get to the next level "Scared to death" the whole time.
The pride and exuberation shown when they completed each stage was heartening. They became giddy at completing a bungy jump from a 30+ foot tower in early training, and all the way up to nearly wetting themselve when it was time to jump from an actual plane.

After completing 5 jumps they qualified for their wings. The ceremony showing Veterans coming in and pinning a simple little emblem on ther lapels was like a dream come true to these "kids". They were as close to tears as a "man" can get surrounded by other "men".

There is some hope!!!

by oz_media

Some people in fact MANY people actually do work hard in high school, no need to look at the military all the time just to find driven people. Poeple who overcome learning disabilities and graduate are on cloud nine, people who work hard and get good grades/scholarships are also near tears when graduating.

My point is that there are so many people who just slip through the cracks and get by that it demeans the achievements fo those who actually do work hard and learn to be better contributors to society. If I know twice as much about a subject than someone else, because I have studied hard and learned teh material, why should I receive an A and yet they pass too just because 'it's fair'.

Life aint fair, that'll teach you to slack off when you repeat the class next year!

As for your example, well it was true but it just saddens me to see how many times military enlistment is shown as the only righteous way to become a contributing member of society.

by netman1958

When I read this part of your post:

"My point is that there are so many people who just slip through the cracks and get by that it demeans the achievements fo those who actually do work hard and learn to be better contributors to society. If I know twice as much about a subject than someone else, because I have studied hard and learned teh material, why should I receive an A and yet they pass too just because 'it's fair'."

it sounded like something I have heard before but at first I couldn't place what it was. I finally figured it out.

First, a disclaimer: I don't particularly like Donald Trump and don't know for sure that this really came from him, but I've always liked the analogy. Here goes.

Donald Trump's daughter, Ivanka, was about to finish her first year of college. Like so many others her age, she considered herself to be very liberal, and among other liberal ideals she was very much in favor of higher taxes to support more government programs -- what her dad dismissed as "redistribution of wealth."

She was deeply ashamed that her father was a rather staunch conservative, and a rich one at that -- a feeling she openly expressed. Based on the lectures that she had participated in, and the occasional chat with a professor, she felt that her father had for years harbored an evil, selfish desire to keep what he thought should be his, rather than benefit society.

One day she was challenging her father on his opposition to higher taxes on the rich and the need for more government programs. "You don't need to spend money on these expensive furnishings in this huge house when there are people who need to earn more than minimum wage and better food!" she lectured.

To her shock and amazement, all The Donald said in reply was "Welcome to socialism."

That's it? she thought to herself -- no argument? But before she could even think of a follow-up, he actually changed the subject! "How are you doing with your studies?" Trump asked her.

Taken aback, she answered rather haughtily that she had a 4.0 GPA, and let him know that it was tough to maintain, insisting that she was taking a very difficult course load and was constantly studying, which left her no time to go out and party like other people she knew. She didn't even have time for a boyfriend, and didn't really have many college friends because she spent all her time studying.

Her father listened and then asked, "How is your friend Audrey doing?"

She replied, "Audrey is barely getting by. All she takes are easy classes, she never studies, and she barely has a 2.0 GPA. She is so popular on campus; college for her is a blast. She's always invited to all the parties, and lots of times she doesn't even show up for classes because she's too hung over."

The Donald was closing in now. He asked Ivanka, "Why don't you go to the Dean's office and ask him to deduct a 1.0 off your GPA and give it to your friend who only has a 2.0. That way you will both have a 3.0 GPA and certainly that would be a fair and equal distribution of GPA."

Ivanka, visibly shocked by her father's suggestion, angrily fired back, "That's a crazy idea, how would that be fair!? I've worked really hard for my grades! I've invested a lot of time, and a lot of hard work! Audrey has done next to nothing toward her degree. She played while I worked my tail off!"

The Donald slowly smiled, winked and said gently, "Welcome to capitalism."

by shasca

You can only force your self to acheive/over acheive. You can try many ways to motivate, but if it isn't received accordingly. It is a lost cause.

I have seen a few news stories on the topic you posted. It seems too many goals are put upon local shool districts to meet graduate numbers. In order to meet those goals people are "promoted" as opposed to graduating. These are the individuals that are not receptive to these failed motivation tactics instilled by the same school districts.

It is indeed sad........

by delbertpgh

Flunking in Pittsburgh schools has now been set to a grade of 50% or lower. (Most of the schools I've been to set that at 60%, or they curve it.) So, a grade of 50% is still flunking. You can't (as you stated) pass with a 50% grade... it has to be just a little higher.

However, the new rule also says that if you flunk any exam, your grade for that exam shall be recorded as 50%. 'Cause that's flunking, right? So, here's what can happen:
** First test of the year, you get 55%.
** Next four tests, you turn in a blank sheet, and get 50% for each.
** End of year, they average all five grades, and you pass with 51%.

Even though $4000 from my city property tax goes to Pittsburgh Public Schools, and another $400 from my county property tax goes there, and an additional 1% from my and my wife's income taxes is earmarked for them, I do not send my boy to Pittsburgh Public Schools. It costs me $20,000 a year for an alternative. I wish the schools were not wasting the cash. I wish the schools were not wasting the lives of the students whose parents can't sweat out $20k to send them someplace good. I wish I could keep my $20k for myself. Damn, do I wish that.

The reason they do this, by the way, is so they can promote every kid out. Many of them drop out, anyway, but by inevitable promotion of the ones who stay, they avoid the problem of having a 19-year-old uneducable doofus sitting in a freshman class, screwing up every other student's school experience while he pretends to try for a fourth time to pass the course.

by oz_media

You pass and you pass, you fail and you pass.

the issue has been floating around for years now, initially it was a problem with the grade letters being in increaments of 10 points, but from 60% down to 50% it was a drop from D to F, and where was E?

That was pretty stupid, as if a letter change would help.

But in this case, you can get a failing grade and pass the year, PATHETIC.

in contrast to what you said "19-year-old uneducable doofus sitting in a freshman class, screwing up every other student's school experience while he pretends to try for a fourth time to pass the course."

Now the hard working and mroe educated people have to sit in a class that is dummed down because of the number of flunkies that screw up a progressive education for them.

When younger kids get a flunkie in class, he is not teh leader of teh pack by any means and nobody loses out. He will ultimately encourage the others to do better as they look at him as an example fo what COULD happen if you screw around for the year. On the other hand, letting him pass just means that the next years class will be filled with uncomitted, idiots who are not there to learn but to screw around for another year because they will still pass. Meanwhile the hard working students lose out due to someone else holding it all back.

But they won't hae a negeative effect on a younger class if they are held back, it just puts a fire under their butts to not wind up like teh idiot repeating grade 9 for the third time, an example of what COULD be if you don't work hard.

by delbertpgh

You said that 50% was what you got if you failed, and 50% was passing. I said, nope, it isn't passing; just a hair above 50% is passing.

In your response, you said that having an overaged failure sitting around a classroom would be no problem; he would be no leader, and everybody else would feel motivated by looking at him to do better academically. What I've heard many times from teachers is that kids who are much older than everybody else and who lack the wits or discipline to pass the course are a disruptive force. They draw attention to themselves, or misbehave, or look fantastically bored, and take an inordinate amount of the teacher's time. And, they're harder to teach, because they tend to be embarassed by being in with little kids, and being more stupid than any of them.

Some folks don't belong in school, but as long as they don't drop out, we're legally obliged to pretend they have a chance of learning something. That's an honest picutre of the situation, and a tough truth.

by notsochiguy

...when I was in 8th grade (before they started mandatory passing in Chicago), there was a 16 year old student named Kenny in the class (fortunately, he was actually a very friendly guy...as he was about 6'1" and 225 at the time).

One day, the teacher looks up, and notices that Kenny decided to 'take the afternoon off'. She asks the class does anyone know what happened to him.

Without skipping a beat, a friend of mine (I wish I could claim this as my own) pipes up: "Kenny had to leave early to pickup the car from the shop and go get his mom from work".

If someone ever asks me about the public school experience in Chicago, that is the anecdote I'll share.

by oz_media

The word on the street is that the US has one of the slackest and pooerest education systems around. However, Americans all over will show yuo how MORE Americans graduate and more Americans go to college than in most other counrties.

Gee, no kidding?

Colleges make immense amounts of money of of students, culling the herd in high school loses college money. However, while so many people attend college, what percentage actually PASS college and go on to a career in that field of study?

It seems that while some people do do very well and gain great benefit from college, many just go as a rite of passage. The parents have saved for over a decade, why not spend it and kill 4 more years while pretending to educate yourself?

the student loses, loses valuable life skills by not entering the workforce and gettign to it, and the parents lose out on their saved money. The college makes out like a bandit, the polls look great for the government and immigration, America still appears to be the land of opportunity for foreigners.

It's all smoke and mirrors really.

by tig2

But this time I am just gonna have to suck it up.

We have been out of the business of honestly educating
children for years now. We have NOT however, gotten out
of the business of shilling eduction for paper's sake. I
know a number of people on this very site who are in
their field today because they took the time and effort to
EDUCATE themselves in a variety of ways. The fact that
we cannot seem to allow for OTJ and individual
determination makes me ill. I would much rather hire the
man who is passionate about what he does than someone
who is merely trading time for money.

This is a paradigm that needs to shift. Don't forget to use
the clutch!

by ganyssa

I have a college degree - in French and World History.

And that's why I'm a network administrator :)

I did have a purpose originally, I was going to be a college professor. But then I realized I'd have to hang out with college professors. After the debate about how I wasn't allowed to call a traditional group of people living on the plains of Africa a 'tribe' because it was demeaning, I realized I didn't want to hang out with them, but I couldn't afford to change my major to something more useful.

by the scummy one

American Education System. between 'political correctness' and not punishing bad behavior, all they are doing is coddling the WATB's amongst the young, and encouraging a lower standard of education.
What a shame, our education system has lowered the standards a lot, all the while we are encouraging more globalization. With many other countries already ahead of the US in education, it seems that there will be a big hole in educated people in the US, forcing more offshoring of just about everything.

by oz_media

The anology is completely different.

as a tradesman, I have spent years in school and many thousands of dollars on tools and tuition. As a result, I get paid more than a backyard mechanic who knows 50% of what he's doing, how to replace parts but not diagnostic, no idea WHY it broke or failed, no idea what else to look for etc.
So I put in the time, I get paid more....fair.

But I am also happy to help someone learn in order to make it, just as I am also happy to have a portion of my tax money go to support Canada's less fortunate. I've been on the bottom and I've played at the top, and now I sit somewhere in between, either way, I helped, have been helped and see value in the system, even though it is horribly abused. The way i see it, we either nix such support (medical, welfare etc.) and people in need will perish or we continue it, hope to weed out the bad apples and live with the fact that ANY system will be abused as there are people out there with nothing else to do.

While that is hard for some to take, I find that it is no different than any other criminal. We pay more for goods because of theft by SOME people. In essence we are paying more because someone else decided NOT to pay. You can find a similar flaw in ANY system on the planet, its human nature for some poeple to seek out ways to abuse a program at the expense of others.

The same for vehicle insurance, I have been accident free for 13 years, and yet they take money out of MY pocket to pay fo rthose who DID abuse the system.

I support the welfare system, I know it takes my hard earned money from me but I accept that. You just never know when YOU will be forced into a position where you must take that money also, and its a good thing it is there because those who are right minded WILL get ahead again and CAN do somethign positive.

anyway, dragged that just a wee tad off topic, sorry.

by jaqui

I see far to many of the abusers of that system.

with the high demand locally for employees there is no reason anyone capable of working isn't.

yet I see a lot who won't get a job, because they don't think they need to work, welfare will support them.

by oz_media

And you know very well that I have seen then too. I had friends when I was MUCH younger who would collect a UI check, a welfare check AND a paycheck. UI was for smokes (and smoke) while teh welfare check covered the monthly keg party.

They have tightened the system up a lot since then but there are still the lazy pricks who simply won't work and don't mind living on less than $600.00/mo.

But seriously, I know many people who teh system HAS helped and they legitimately NEEDED it to work for them and they have since moved on and rebuilt their lives.

There are two sides, unfortunately, like most other things, we only see the bad side of it and wonder why we do it. In this case, I know teh system has holes and it gets scammed, but we have to have SOMETHING in place and until a flawless system is cerated, which has never happened ANYWHERE, we just have to suck it up and put up with the losers in order to help those who deserve it.

by oz_media

We actually have schools for such kids. Enriched programs that work in smaller groups with drop outs and other encourageables.

Passing them through a system with a free pass just doesn't help anyoen though. Lok at the 2 grads or 2009 which both apply for teh same job. They both have teh grade 12 prerequisite for teh position, specific grades are not in question. Why should the motivated, hard working scholar not get that job because a flunkie applied too? noting that in this case little sets them apart on paper, its just the luck of the draw.

As for teh older kids influencing younger kids, I remember a few classes where a grade 10 was in our grade 9 class. It was always somethign we laughed at, quietly to be polite of course, and simply made you strive to be better and make him appear to be even mroe of an idiot than he already is. It certainly wasn't influence for any of us and teh teachers don't take crap from people like that, they just kick them out and let them land in an enriched school with like minded losers.

The only reaosn I dropped out was I was only interested in trades, could ace my academic work and was working full time in an apprenticeship, which was exactly WHY I was in school to begin with, to learn skills that pay bills on the outside.

When I studied automotive in BCIT, you had to have grade 12 to start teh course, I was allowed to pass an entrance exam (grade 12 math formulas, english etc.) which I a;so aced so I got into the course. You'd be surprised just how much math and engineering goes into automotive work, even a basic journeyman mechanic learns to do some pretty high end calculations to get the answers he needs.

I got what I wanted because I worked at it, not because it was easy for me.

by ontheropes

Recently there's been a commercial floating around on the national networks that talks about how low the US ranks in education compared to the rest of the world. I wish everyone in the US could see that commercial. Maybe it would be a wake-up call.

Nah! :0

The majority of people will just go back to business as usual. Foist the kid on the public school system then blame them when the kid is a freaking useless dumbass.

Whatever happened to parenting? The parents need to be educated on the proper way to raise their children, in my opinion. Instead they get all bent out of shape when their precious snowflake doesn't get higher marks. It's the school's fault, don't you know?

If I try really hard I could probably find a third way to say essentially the same thing all over again. Not going to try.

by ontheropes

Years ago there was a parent teacher meeting to decide the curriculum of the upcoming elementary school year, grades K thru 6. My wife and I were the only parents to show up for the meeting. They rescheduled it and had 700 students take home flyers announcing the meeting again and the next time my wife was the only parent to show up as I had to work.

That's pitiful.

After that my step-daughter went to a private (expensive) Catholic Montessori school. I was Catholic for a few years there, if anyone asked. The way we got around the church attendance requirement was to buy the school a new Apple computer every year, Catholic computers. :^0

Oh well, you do what you've got to do. :)

by ontheropes

That's got to be a rough job. I don't think that we pay teachers enough money. In some case the public librarian makes more. That's what I should've gone for years ago, being a public librarian. "Sssshhhhh!" I've got it down pat. Dewey who?

by notsochiguy

...but student-teaching in an urban school forced me to reconsider that choice.

During the holiday season, the kids were asked to write down wishes for a Menorah display. One of the kids wrote: " I wish for just one day, mommy and daddy wouldn't hit each other or me".

And that was one of the better behaved/performing students in the class, bear in mind.

To teach nowadays, it seems as though you have to be equal parts instructor, nanny, psychotherapist, FBI profiler (to determine which kids are doing what illegal activity), and referee. Couple that with the handcuffs put in place by various policies (unions, No Kids Get Ahead, etc, etc), and it is little wonder why the public school system is in total disarray save for the well-to-do districts.

Dewey postulated that the main roles of public education were to enrich the community and further/strengthen democracy. I don't find it coincidental that our governmental environment (corrupt and chaotic would seem overly euphemistic at this point) and our school systems (abject failure or FUBAR come to mind as appropriate descriptors) have followed similar trends over the past several decades.

by ontheropes

I think that I've had more than my fair share of intense. There is excitement though. That's usually anticipation of some event and not the actual event itself. I'll stick with boring, had my share of excitement too.

I can enjoy such boring things as watching the hummingbirds duke it out for the feeder or watching a bumblebee make it's way back to it's nest. I'm telling you, boring can be good.

Ever jump out of an airplane? That's something that you want to be as boring as possible. If it's terribly exciting you might not want to or be able to jump again. Me? I could get hooked on such a boring activity but unfortunately it costs too much and insurance won't pay for diddly if you splatter. Bummer.

by the scummy one

But none of the examples are truly boring!

I have wanted to jump outta a plane, but never have. I also have wanted to hang glide, but never have.
but intense can be very fun, and not really boring.

If you are studying the behavior of the hummingbirds and bees, or trying to learn something from them, then it really isnt boring either. However, if just looking at them, yes, it can be I suppose

by ontheropes

I jumped solo with a static line and really the most dangerous part was going up in the airplane. Until you reach sufficient altitude for jumping you're in danger of the plane going down. After jumping you're just hanging in a harness that you can steer. Boring in that respect. You try to keep it that way by aiming for the big open space on the ground, away from the trees, houses and water.

My risers were twisted when I jumped so it was a little exciting until I kicked and pulled my way out of it but after I was squared away I couldn't help but think of how boring it was. I think that's why experienced skydivers are always trying to do something new like skydiving naked. :0

Skydivers are all a little crazy so I fit right in. Fun sport. I want to do a HAHO (High Altitude High Opening) jump. Take me up to 20.000+ feet and let me jump. Better have a real good idea of where to land jumping from that height. You could end up at the wrong airport. :^0 "Oops, Excuse me. Pardon me. Look out. Coming thru." :^0

by the scummy one

That would be an experience :D

I have heard tale of hang gliders travelling 30+ miles due to updrift (or something like that). That would be cool. Until it was time to find my truck :0

by ontheropes

When I jumped the University had told me that there was a good possibility that I had leukemia. It tainted my perspective. I asked myself what would I like to do before I die? Skydiving was one of my things so I did it. I can go ahead and die anytime now. :^0

by nicknielsen

There's no such thing as a perfectly good airplane. :)

Gives a whole new attitude on commercial flights. :0

by oz_media

How wrong am I though?

I sorta see it here too, but fewer Canadians have college funds, well perhaps more these days, and it just isn't a focus of most people UNLESS they are seekgin a career in which it is imperative, ie. doctor, lawyer, etc.

In my case I spent 6 years of my life training for my basic and extended mechanical certs. It was my career focus and has given me very useful and important skills. OTJ training does not work as it is a field requiring licenced technicians.

It just seems, again as I 've said before, like it is a rite of passage in the US, as if 17-18 is too young to go and hit the workforce, you can fight for your country though and get a free college education though. Not a lot of sense there, no attack on the US military academy, just that it is OKAY for you to join the army in order to get an education, as if it is THAT imperative.

by oz_media

Funny though, I couldn't tell you what they were advertising, I just remember hearing some broad break down and sob over and over again while waiting for more music to be played.

I automatically filter out anything but decent music it seems.

by ganyssa

who once received assistance - not cash, but I got health insurance and food for several months. I had a job, but it didn't pay much, and I was recently divorced with a new baby.

I was lucky in that I was able to find a job with my current employer that was higher paid, and had insurance about 6 months later. I did meet a few people in the office that had been coming in for years, though.

This discussion is closed to new replies.