Question Locked

external hard drive no longer works after plugging into vista laptop

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a western digital 160gb usb external hard drive(gets power from usb) that I've been using for a while on my xp tower computer. I just got a new laptop with vista, plugged the external hd into the laptop, and it started clicking, and now it won't work on the xp tower either.
is there any way to get it working again? i'd seen similar topics which made me think it just couldn't get enough power from the laptop usb, but that wouldn't completely screw up the hd, would it?
other topics mentioned taking an external out of the case and using it internally, but does this work for ones designed as external, or only internal harddrives in an external shell?

I hadn't seen a topic where someone couldn't get it to work on a computer it had before, so any help would be greatly appreciated.

3 replies

by older mycroft

It would give us an indication of what specification of HDD is inside this casing.

Does this external drive have a USB cable that terminates in TWO USB plugs? If so, were you using both when you connected it to the laptop?

When you attached the HDD was it recognised by Vista?

After it started clicking how did you remove it from the laptop?

Did you use the 'safe removal' process?

by robo_dev

so if the failure is with the enclosure, then the drive itself could be mounted in a PC.

Does the enclosure have a 'double ended' usb cable or a separate power jack?

If the drive has both a DC power jack and a USB port, then the thing to try would be to supply power via a separate power source to see if power can get to the drive that way.

it sounds like either the USB power-supply electronics of the enclosure were damaged, or the drive itself suffered damage. If the drive were trying to start and there were not enough current, something may have fried.

I would take it apart and look for burnt components on the circuit board of the enclosure as well as on the drive itself.

Obviously by doing some substitution you could quickly determine if the drive itself has failed, or just the interface board within the USB enclosure.

This discussion is closed to new replies.