Fair Competition?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by mrsgarbers
"Commit" is a bit of an insult to those of us who have commitments to our families and such.
Shift-work in itself is a commitment. I chose that word because that is how it has been decribed to me so many times before.
Thank you for the wake up pinch...next time someone mentions the "c" word to me, I will remember your footnote.
would have us believe in the enormous amount of effort it requires to get a degree.
They might be right, however one can expend an enormous amount of effort and be fully committed when having a s**t as well.
So it's not a stand out part of the proposition as far as I'm concerned.
by mnoldsea
I agree, only I would call it Academic Elitism.
"The first act in any leaning is an act of humility"
Mark Twain said it best, "I managed to lean a few things in spite of my education."
Pure knowledge, here's Bill Gates a Harvard drop out, and here's these schools now that owe their very existence to him. Must be a tough pill for them to swallow.
If you read my other posts in this thread you will see that I acknowledge that the theory is useful for some work and not others. I even recommended that people work on a degree whilst in the industry. The important and overiding things is - Can you do the job properly? and that should always be the main criteria, regardless of where you got your knowledge and skills.
The either or exclusion that you refer to relates to the new graduates because the uni (read college for the USA) courses are NOT practically based and do not include what is really needed at the coal face for the majority of the work in the industry. Yet the newly hatched grads frequently complain that they should get higher than basic entry level jobs in areas of the industry where they have no immediately usable skills or knowledge - they think they are better because they have a degree. When these course do update to the modern reality you will see a change of view on this.
The problem really seems to be that most of the uni courss prepare people to be computer system designers not technicians and repairers, yet the majority of the work is for technicians and repairers. For this work experience is usually better than theory, but much of this experience can be taught in the classroom, sadly the unis do not teach much of this. But the TAFE technical courses do thus the preference for tech trained over uni trained.
I have been working with computers since the early 1970's and then went and got some recognised qualifications in the late 1990s - two diplomas and several certificates. The material I learnt in the courses did expand slightly on the practical and theoretical info I already had.
Given the need for a PC repairer and faced with a kid with 3 years field experience or a 4 year uni grad I would set up a test for them to fix some of the expected types of client problems. I would bet that most uni grads would take much longer to fix them or not fix them all. Simply because he did not get taught the knowledge and skills needed for that work. Conversely if the same two people applied for a job to dsign a new computer or network I would expect the uni grad to win hands down as that is the sort of theory he had been taught. Similarly if the work requires a lot of research the uni grad should have an advantage as that is a skill he should already have from being at uni.
by r. neil
Alexander Graham Bell "invented" the telephone, but Tom Watson built them -- Guess who had more fun!
One of the hardest lessons for Engineering (BS-whatever) graduates to learn has been to allow the technical staff to DO their job. Computing is just now maturing to the same level.
Moral: If you want to play with the toys, go the techie route; if you want to design the toys, go the BS__ route -- YES, you can do BOTH!
by rob.perkins
"Piece of paper", as in how others WITHOUT degrees see some degrees. A degree IS worth a lot to yourself, not necessarily everybody else, as it SHOULD. That's not something you can control. I know exactly what you are saying, I'm getting a degree myself...not just going the "Cert" route. I think by getting the degree I am not only bettering myself in my eyes, but the "piece of paper" SHOULD make me more valuable to an employer. I don't think a degree justifies what you SHOULD know, or as you put it, "validate my knowledge". It simply shows that you put forth the time and effort to accomplish a huge task.
Does getting a degree increase your knowledge of what is studied? Of course. Does NOT getting a degree DECREASE the amount of knowledge you have? Of course not. As we both know, a degree doesn't "make" you who you are. But, I totally agree with you that some professions require a degree in that particular field, doctors, especially, but in that case I think it's all about laws and liability, blah, blah, blah. In our field, which is relatively new to most others, I think we're still developing and haven't reached the point where degrees are required to work on say a Cisco switch. Maybe one day we will get there.
And don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to lessen the significance of having a degree, but I don't think it is an absolute necessity to be successful in our industry.
I always thought the reason I didn't get a degree was because my da was as poor as a church mouse, then I became a dad myself and became poorer than a church mouse with kids.
Wrong again, Working my ass off to support my family was just an excuse for my laziness.
Bit of a surprise that, perhaps I should have left my family to support itself, got an education and then I'd know stuff like that.
There's me think I was a standup hard working guy.
You learn something everyday...
Well I do anyway.
Poor choice of words indicating your massive academic bias there matey.
by cheerstork
...open a car repair shop in you part of the world, without being a ***LICENSED*** mechanic?!!!
Well...
...it's very convenient to say that IT should be open to all--especially, if you never earned the accreditation. Many like to call it "elitism" and other rhetorical nonsensical names, just to avoid facing the fact!
As if only those guys--and gals--are the ones who "worked" and "toiled" hard! Well, still; not a justification for you to define what it takes to call yourself a "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer" / titles dime a dozen...
I don't intend to hurt anyone's feelings, but will my feelings be hurt if a Doctor says to me that, despite my "toiling", "hard work" and tremendous "knowledge" of medicine, that despite all that, I can't work as or be called a Doc?!
Systems are failing and applications are dragging and crwaling and security is an oxymoron because average joe and jane are "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer"
Hey, by da way, can I open a car repair shop?
Nuff said, eh!
:)
globally recognised non vendor specific test to assess skill levels in varied IT disciplines, I'm in.
None of this four years in school crap, or spending $ks on swatting adverts rubbish.
Just test me, I've already passed a harder more demanding curriculum than they would dare set for a bit of paper.
On a less funny note. I've paid qualified mechanics who it turned out didn't know one end of a spanner from the other.
by cheerstork
...and I understand what you are saying,
BUT
That is not how it works!
Or is it?!
If it is, then IT seems to be the sole exception!
You know something; you might very well be more hands-on and more experienced than I am--for various reasons! For instance, say, I earned my degree 7 years ago and for certain reasons I did not get to focus my efforts on one IT track. It just doesn't mean that a degree is irrelevant!
The only thing that it means is that *I* am not up-to-date, and *I* need to do some brush up. Once on the job, *I* will pick up in months what you picked up in decades!
By saying that, I, in NO way disparaging you or belittling your vast knowledge. It is just a fact that the sort of education that you receive in a 4-year college arms you with the basic and fundamental tools and knowledge that is needed to become a versatile and adaptable IT professional. Whether you are good at utilizing this knowledge or not, is not the fault of the university!
The really important thing that I keep trying to get through is that other professions exclude non-licensed wannabes from practicing, so why are we any different?! I bet I have much more knowledge and enthusiasm than many dietitians; by your token, why shouldn't I call myself one?!I should also have the freedom and liberty to open a dietitian consultancy office or a car repair shop. However, they won't let me!! Conversely, a dietitian or a mechanic, can freeeeeely roam my field and be a "system Architect"!!!!
Many like to call it "elitism" and other rhetorical nonsensical names, just to avoid facing the fact!
As if only those guys--and gals--are the ones who "worked" and "toiled" hard! Well, still; not a justification for you to define what it takes to call yourself a "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer" / titles dime a dozen...
I don't intend to hurt anyone's feelings, but will my feelings be hurt if a Doctor says to me that, despite my "toiling", "hard work" and tremendous "knowledge" of medicine, that despite all that, I can't work as or be called a Doc?!
Systems are failing and applications are dragging and crawling and security is an oxymoron because average Joe and Jane are "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer"
Hey, you need that proclaimed knowledge and expertise validated and fortified with formalized, comprehensive and well-rounded education, before you can object!
The fact is, you can write a porous, ineffective, sloppy, buggy, non-modular program, and it might work. In the eyes of a non-savvy person, you are a programmer; and you will also call yourself a programmer!
Another fact is that we made the commitment and large investment, yet you guys because you never made that investment, you come in and undercut us. The market offers meagerly $12 and $15 an hour, which I in no way will take?not even $20. I would and certainly would open a car repair shop or even sell hotdog?they make much more MUCH more! But, ?
Hey, by da way, can I open a car repair shop?
by cheerstork
In commenting on:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11181-0.html?forumID=6&threadID=190118&messageID=1965643
I understand what you are saying, Tony,
BUT
That is not how it works!
Or is it?!
If it is, then IT seems to be the sole exception!
You know something; you might very well be more hands-on and more experienced than I am--for various reasons! For instance, say, I earned my degree 7 years ago and for certain reasons I did not get to focus my efforts on one IT track. It just doesn't mean that a degree is irrelevant!
The only thing that it means is that *I* am not up-to-date, and *I* need to do some brush up. Once on the job, *I* will pick up in months what you picked up in decades!
By saying that, I, in NO way disparaging you or belittling your vast knowledge. It is just a fact that the sort of education that you receive in a 4-year college arms you with the basic and fundamental tools and knowledge that is needed to become a versatile and adaptable IT professional. Whether you are good at utilizing this knowledge or not, is not the fault of the university!
The really important thing that I keep trying to get through is that other professions exclude non-licensed wannabes from practicing, so why are we any different?! I bet I have much more knowledge and enthusiasm than many dietitians; by your token, why shouldn't I call myself one?!I should also have the freedom and liberty to open a dietitian consultancy office or a car repair shop. However, they won't let me!! Conversely, a dietitian or a mechanic, can freeeeeely roam my field and be a "system Architect"!!!!
Many like to call it "elitism" and other rhetorical nonsensical names, just to avoid facing the fact!
As if only those guys--and gals--are the ones who "worked" and "toiled" hard! Well, still; not a justification for you to define what it takes to call yourself a "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer" / titles dime a dozen...
I don't intend to hurt anyone's feelings, but will my feelings be hurt if a Doctor says to me that, despite my "toiling", "hard work" and tremendous "knowledge" of medicine, that despite all that, I can't work as or be called a Doc?!
Systems are failing and applications are dragging and crawling and security is an oxymoron because average Joe and Jane are "system/software developer" / "Systems Architect" /Software Engineeeeeer"
Hey, you need that proclaimed knowledge and expertise validated and fortified with formalized, comprehensive and well-rounded education, before you can object!
The fact is, you can write a porous, ineffective, sloppy, buggy, non-modular program, and it might work. In the eyes of a non-savvy person, you are a programmer; and you will also call yourself a programmer!
Another fact is that we made the commitment and large investment, yet you guys because you never made that investment, you come in and undercut us. The market offers meagerly $12 and $15 an hour, which I in no way will take?not even $20. I would and certainly would open a car repair shop or even sell hotdog?they make much more MUCH more! But, ?
Hey, by da way, can I open a car repair shop?
by hal 9000
by cheerstork
And, isn't that what the "edit" button for; what happens when you post something and realize that you missed a point, or that more clarification was needed?!
Now, it's becoming a bit childish, Docta :)
by cheerstork
I just noticed a very unintelligent (for the lack of a better description) comment made by a fellow who stated something to the effect that Bill Gates invented the IT field, and he is a college drop-out. Consequently, we should be appreciative of the non-academia fellas because they are the source of our career! This is just to paraphrase what was said!
Well, Bill Gates and many others are entrepreneures. That's what made them the fortune!
Go and emulate him, and kudos to you, if you make it!
Your comparison is totally irrelevant.
Oh, and computers and computer existed well pre-gates!
and it's certainly a very convenient thing to say
and you ain't Bill Gates!
by mnoldsea
Thank you, but some people just confuse their opinions with the facts..........
http://www.microsoft.com/billgates/bio.asp
by cheerstork
I was just searching Microsoft's website for available positions, and noticed that all of the ones that I looked at had a "BA/BS Computer Science/Engineering" in the requirement area!
I'm just wondering, why did "microsoft" do that?
Is Bill Gates aware of this discriminatory practice!?
Face it:)
by hal 9000
Firstly I don't have any CS qualifications mainly because when I was studying there was no Computer Sciences so like a lot of others I did Electronic Engineering.
Oh by the way there where no PC's at the time either just dirty great mainframes that we had to fight like hell to get a 15 minute user slot generally at 2.00 AM in the morning.
When I started working commercial IT as it's called now I worked for a large US Based company making Mainframes and I was at first employed as a senior tech for that side of the business and eventually rose to State Service Manager so I effectively controlled the Service Department of the day and all the staff working under me had Electronic Engineering Degrees where as I had a PHD in Electronic Engineering, which to this day I insist only gave me the rights to go out into the big bad world and start learning my trade it didn't give me any actual right to work in what is now know as IT.
My very first run in with one of the New Computer Science Graduates was a bitter pill to sallow as I was at that time moved into a punishment detail for not following company policy to the letter and putting my customers first. So I was sent to a small subsidiary who sold engine management systems to the racing car industry and in those days we all where working with 64K EPROMS that held the entire program and High End Z 80 CPU's again if you can actually call a Z 80 a CPU.
Well the company that I worked for grabbed a couple of the top CS students fresh out of Uni here and Honestly didn't know what to do with them as they at the time where just starting a PC line most went there but one ended up with me for "Training."
The very first job that I gave him involved writing a subroutine to drive a very small part of the entire program and it needed rewriting and I got on with the more important stuff that was required. 2 Days latter he returned with this what should have been very small Sub Routine written in what was then called Basic and took all of 356K he totally ignored my instructions and did it his own way and was highly opinionated about the way things should be done even if it wouldn't actually work on the hardware available. I then told him to rewrite it in Boolean and do it properly to which he refused and called me several names referring to my complete lack of education.
So I just gave him the entire specs required and told him to write the program in whatever he wanted to the way he wanted to write it and how he preferred to write it. His result took over 2 MEGS which at that time was impossible to actually fit into the hardware so I gave him a PROM burner and told him to make me several EPROMS to fit into the engine management systems that we sold. I then rang head office and insisted that he be transfered back to the area that I had come from and arranged the transfer.
But it didn't end there when he couldn't get it to fit on the available hardware he insisted on a complete redesign and because he wasn't a hardware engineer he wanted someone else to redesign the existing hardware. Then the absolute worst thing happened he realized that he had to attend Race Meetings it was great during Work Hours but Weekend Work was out of the question so he requested an Immediate Transfer back to the Head Office where he was put to work on the PC side of things.
He was completely hopeless at what was required, Highly Opinionated and demanding on the proper way of doing things. Needless to say he went far with the PC's and I'm glad that he never worked for me ever again! What's worse he didn't even offer an apology when he found out who I actually was and I'm extremely glad that I didn't go back to the Mainframe side of the business as I would have taken every opportunity to kill the little SOB available to me and that would have been on numerous occasions.
[b]What you have to start off with is a piece of paper that only gives you the right to start learning, some of what you where taught might be useful and a lot of it will be useless but that Piece Of Paper in no way entitles you to any job or in any way implies that you are somehow better than others working in the same industry. If you want to setup your Own Business you can act as you please but honestly you will not last long if you carry on the way that you are in your original post where you seem to think that somehow you are owed a living in your preferred field and people should bow down and kiss your feet for agreeing to work in a certain place.[/b]
If you want respect you have to earn it by hard work and waving a piece of paper around which can be easily shredded isn't the way to go about earning respect all it does is earn contempt from your co workers when you eventually get a job but with your attitude I don't think that will be much of a problem as no decent IT corporation would employ you.
Everything IT related is a [b]Service[/b] so you need to work with people and treat them as equals so get that Bug out of your A R S E and get on with beginning to learn your trade. Remember MS isn't the only player in town and with their current practices they are unlikely to remain Top Dog forever so you'll need to start diversifying your knowledge base.
Incidentally you can apply for any job that you like but while you are unlikely to get it you are always welcome to try. I've found no Nero Surgeons working IT or Lawyers for that matter but the people currently there have got there by working hard and establishing a reputation for themselves and that is something that you fresh out of College can not hope to have.
I should add here that there was no attack upon your character intended I'm just making statements of [b]FACT[/b] in the above so start off by having an attitude adjustment and see what it is you are doing wrong at interviews. That will be of far more use to you than any other single thing.
Col
by cheerstork
"When I started working commercial IT as it's called now I worked for a large US Based company making Mainframes and I was at first employed as a senior tech for that side of the business and eventually rose to State Service Manager so I effectively controlled the Service Department of the day and all the staff working under me had Electronic Engineering Degrees where as I had a PHD in Electronic Engineering, which to this day I insist only gave me the rights to go out into the big bad world and start learning my trade it didn't give me any actual right to work in what is now know as IT.
"
Puzzle of the day:
__________________
Hey, there is actually a comma somewhere in the midst of this 7-line long sentence, quoted above!
Can you spot it?
After all, maybe yours WAS a piece of paper, Doc!
Hey, may I borrow one of your faces for a sec?
Thanks! Here you go ]:)
by hal 9000
Being able to write was not a requirement when I started I had a secretary for that. :p
The fact that I had to correct most of her work was immaterial though and here I'm defiantly not expected to bother with minor things like grammar.
But more importantly did you get the message at the end?
You need to adjust your ideals and find out what it is you are doing wrong at interviews or you'll never get to see someone like me who is likely to employ you. :p
Col ]:)
by crawk
To Cheerstork -
It might be better for you not to criticize others' grammer, my dear, when you still have much to learn about it yourself. If you were to study the matter, I think you'd see that one of your more prominent problems has to do with syntax and agreement.
But, perhaps this is what one learns from degree programs these days: to launch a personal attack when unable to debate on merit. That's not to say an idea is unassailable; only that one is insufficiently skilled or knowledgeable to assail it.
Sadly, from your other postings, we know that your demeanor cannot be blamed on or excused by extreme youth or inexperience. Such a disappointment.
by absolutely
"Oh by the way there where no PC's at the time either just dirty great mainframes that we had to fight like hell to get a 15 minute user slot generally at 2.00 [b]AM[/b] in the [b]morning[/b]."
HIV virus
PCV valve
You know what I mean, HAL!
LOL
by hal 9000
:D
The HIV [b]Heavily Into Valves[/b] bit I know about but where the Virus fits in is way beyond me. :p
What's a PCV Valve though some thing for the Nitrogen Cooling or Halon Fire Suppression? :)
Col ]:)
by absolutely
by hal 9000
They have very low skill sets and a low requirement to pass their courses. Even my now dead Dog got her Psychologists degree from a correspondence school. Well it was in her name anyway. :p
The only pieces of paper I've ever kept and always know where they are, are the Degree for the Dog and Her Birth Certificate from the Canine Control Council, they drive Psychologists nuts. :D
Physicist no that's a different ball game. :)
Col ]:)
by absolutely
"I bet I have much more knowledge and enthusiasm than many dietitians; by your token, why shouldn't I call myself one?!I should also have the freedom and liberty to open a dietitian consultancy office ...!! ...!!!!"
Since you're using so much punktuation, I've decided to ease some of your angst: anybody [b]can[/b] call themselves "dietitian" in the United States. All you have to do is convince your clients that you know enough to keep them coming back and recommending their acquaintances. The title that has to be earned according to legally mandated guidelines is "nutritionist". Any fool with a mouth can call itself "dietitian".
by absolutely
by hal 9000
And you would most likely know far more than the qualified Mechanics as well.
Do you know what a Kettering Ignition System is? Most of the mechanics over here don't as they are not taught the very basics.
It appalled me when I asked a 4th year apprentice just after he had returned from his college course what he had covered which was ignition systems so I said something about knowing all about Kettering Ignition Systems to which he replied no I didn't learn anything about those high end rare stuff that you are here about I only learned about points coil type ignition systems. What made it even worse was that it was only the old guys there that knew what the hell I was talking about.
So the mechanics don't have a great deal of technical training and they are allowed to set up shop if they have enough money. :p
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
With 30 + years in piratical work you have by then forgotten everything that you ever where taught in College as it is now all out of date.
For example 30 + years ago we where all using Valves in huge monster machines with punch cards. How often do you see a punch card today or a valve for that matter? Or even a 10 inch floppy? Well they where somewhere around the 10 inch mark maybe 10.5 inches but that was so long ago that it no longer matters does it?
Lets look at something much newer just how many 5.25 Floppies are in use today? When they came out they could hold all of 360 K and where considered as marvelous and cheap at a little over a $1.00 a piece or CDR's at $25.00 each when they first came out you could bung all of 600 + MEG on a single disc and it was so cheap now you can buy the same thing for several cents and that is only in a 7 year time frame.
So if you walked away from IT for 7 years you would have an awful lot of catching up to do as everything that you learned back then is now obsolete unless of course you wanted to work with Vintage Computers in a Museum. :D
And then of course with 30 + years experience plus whatever other qualifications you either started out with or have picked up along the way you'll find yourself unemployable to most companies as you are over qualified for their needs which actually means that they'll need to pay you more than they can get some pimply faced kid to do for virtually nothing in comparison to what they would have to pay you. :p
It used to be the harder you worked and the more you studied the better you where when it came to jobs but that no longer works as all it means to the different companies who employ you is how much money you will cost them. Most would prefer to have 3 or 4 people working for them doing substandard work rather than employing one person who could do the job properly as it makes them vulnerable to your whims and that is something that accountants [b]DO NOT LIKE![/b] :)
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
I have 3 PHD's in various subjects all engineering related and 4 if you count the one I was awarded by Neil on the Erogenous Zones of Sheep. :D
But I refuse to allow anyone to call me Doctor I'm more likely to beat the living daylight out of them if they do. I don't even now know what initials I'm supposed to put after my name and unless it's been for legal purposes I've never actually ever used them. Over all I have 6 [b]Pieces of Paper 3 Bachelors and 3 Post Grad[/b] and I don't even know where they are nor do I care!
In the overall scheme of things they mean absolutely nothing at all and have never landed me a single job of any sort. What has got me every job that I've ever had is my reputation in the field that I don't even have a CV prepared and I honestly don't really know if I could even prepare one if my life depended upon it, mostly because I can no longer remember all the places or times that I've worked at different places all of which I've been Head Hunted from over the years until I finally got feed up with Corporate Politics and walked away from it all, and I'm still getting offers of jobs although finally I think that the message is getting through that [b]I'm Not Interested![/b]
The last time I actually used any initials after my name was for a court case which hasn't come to life yet.
But this is something that I firmly believe that people who insist on using any titles or putting letters after their names are all up themselves as they do not cause anyone important to see you in a different light and those that are impressed are not worth impressing in the first place anyway.
So why bother?
Save the ink and get on with your life.
Col ]:)
by cheerstork
So, all the self-proclaimed "Software Developers" "Network Design Architecutre Specialists" and etc, all of them say that a degree is not necessary.
I am fine with that.
Now, I just wish if that were applicable to all other professions. I wish if we could hop around professions, as long as we have the passion and the enthusiasm. There should be no "license" "certification" or whatever barriers, then!
Only IT is such!
by cheerstork
while(you still did not get the point and keep morphing your same feeble argument) {
Read my posts again, for they contain the ultimate answers to your hopeless arguments;
// This code instructs faulty processors to
//do the right thing.
//For instance, one processor liked to
//point out that it was ?nutritionist?
//NOT ?Dietitian? that required a license!
//Well, that processor really keeps
//missing the point: It?s not the
//title! It?s the fact that there are many,
//if not all, professions that require
//a license to practice. OK, so be
// it a ?Nutritionist!? I mean, come oooon dude!
// :)
};
return(?I?m done with this thread, since I have said it all and see nothing but hopelessly morphing replies?later gator!?)
by rknrlkid
by hal 9000
It's exactly what the edit button is for I reposted the entire thing where it was supposed to go not where it ended up.
Buy the way do you want me to get Gino and Luigi to pay you a visit? :D
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Likes to grab kids fresh out of Uni, College or whatever and teach them M$ way of doing things.
They work long hours are poorly paid for their work and after about 5 years are thrown out with the trash when they are burnt out.
The Person in charge of Product Development at M$ sets unrealistic time frames and then keeps changing the content so M$ never ever meet the announced releases and it's always blamed on the coders.
I'll let you have two guesses who's in charge of Product Development at M$. :D
He didn't finish any formal schooling and still has unrealistic ideals of what it's possible to do with his [b]BASTARD CHILD WINDOWS.[/b] Do the initials BG mean anything to you? :)
Col ]:)
by cheerstork
gotta give ya credit for that, eh:)
Well, listen! You are focusing on the wrong thing. It certainly is not my "ideals" or what I am "doing wrong at interviews "...
you don't know me nor do you know my personality. Just because I objected to something that I believed was a wrong and unfair practice doesn't make me arrogant nor snotty! And just to save you the time, I don't even care the slightest, if all you got out of my discussion was the perception that I was an arrogant person! :D
As I mentioned on many posts, I have the degree, and TONS of prestigious certifications that takes the average person many years to earn. Is it wrong to ask that IT should be treated like other professions are, so we could ensure some standards and also to protect our market?
IT field is a very challenging and intense. Why would you wanna offer your services to a company that will pay you peanuts, while they will earn millions--if not billions! Nowadays, all businesses are highly dependant on IT. Well, if it is so important to their business, why would we accept less than what WE demand!? They make millions and billions, and pay you, the guy who toils and exerts himself, pennies? Our field is not easy stuff--requires plenty of knowledge, hardwork, and YES, INTELLIGENCE! Why should they get that for $20 or even $40 an hour?! Yes, you might say, you have to like the field, in order to work in it! And YES, I will say! I LOVE the field, but will do for myself and as a hobby in a lab or at home but not give it to the employer for free because, well "I LOVE IT!"
And what drove our market value so dirt-cheap, you might ask! The answer goes back to the start of this thread!
We have been FLOODED by the average Joe and Jane who call themselves "SYSTME PROGRAMMER" etc. and are willing to work for $12 or $20 an hour!
Hey, and what's up with that "Luigi Gino" Dude? :p
by hal 9000
In the field. And this isn't just the tech side it starts at the sales side where various companies will sell rubbish for far more than it is actually worth to unsuspecting buyers and then sell them a [b]Service Contract[/b] that isn't worth the paper that it's printed on.
At this stage the customer gets the impression that everyone in IT is [b]Out to Rip Them OFF![/b] So things get very hard to work through particularly when the existing so called [b]Service Contract[/b] is still in place but the companies can not get anyone out to fix their problems. This is [b]Small to Medium Business that has these problems![/b]
The big end of town is driven by purely bottom lines so why should they pay you what they consider an exorbitant amount of money when they can get someone else for peanuts? That's how Accountants think it doesn't matter if the work gets done but that they appear to be doing the work and complying with any revel ant Statutory Requirements. It's for that very reason that an entire section of the User Market has just disappeared literally overnight with the advent of 95.
Before that time the users had to know how to use a program and where quite good at it but then M$ came out with Windows 95 and everything went to [b]Hell in a Hand basket![/b] what where once considered as mandatory requirements disappeared and what was once one of the most basic things is now relegated to the realms of the [b]Power User.[/b]
What makes it even better is that none of the higher functions of application usage is taught any longer and some little Macro Writer is considered as a [b]Programmer![/b]
I didn't do it but you can certainly thank M$ for the current state of affairs in the IT community they push out MSCE certs by the bucket load making out that this is something important when really it doesn't even qualify as toilet paper and because there are so many of these M$ Certified people around they are a [b]Dime a Dozen.[/b]
If you don't like it [b]JOIN THE CLUB[/b] but stop complaining about the way that things are and either do something about it or shut up. You are not going to change the mind's of Small Business who have been robbed as much as possible to pay $100.00 per hour or more to fix the problems that they shouldn't have on the second rate junk that they have been sold by so called [b]EXPERTS[/b] and you sure as Hell are not going to alter one single accountants idea of perfection by insisting that his or her 200 low paid monkeys are actually costing them money by doing second rate work. It just ain't going to happen in your lifetime anyway. After all they already have a junk OS that is the B A S T A R D default which falls over at the drop of a hat called Windows which everyone believes that they just have to have to get any work done with their PC's.
As for Luigi & Gino you did refer to me in one of the above posts as "Doc." :p
Col ]:)
[i]You asked, "Is it fair for a person who has no degrees in computer science to compete with one who has it for the same job?"[/i]
Of course it's fair.
[i]You asked, "Is it fair, when there are those who persevered and toiled to earn a degree in CS, only to find that many of the CS positions are held by individuals who just ventured into the market because they couldn't find jobs in their own professions or just because they were seeking better income?"[/i]
Same question, same answer.
[i]You said, "I would think it's fair, if it worked both ways."[/i]
It does work both ways.
[i]You asked, "Can you, as a holder of BSCS, apply for a psychology-related position?"[/i]
Well, you could apply, but you may not get the job.
[i]You asked, "If not, then why was it OK for a person who majored in psychology to compete with you for a computer job--if not become your boss?"[/i]
Because treating a person for psychological afflictions is very different that treating a computer for its afflictions. I've never heard of a brain being reformatted and reloaded with software. (Although I'd like to do it with some people!)
[i]You said, "Please, exclude exceptions, i.e. don't just focus in your reply on the cases in which the guy with no BSCS is doing a better job than you. I'm talking about the situation where you are just as good (if not much better, which is often the case.)"[/i]
If what you provide at one cost is less valuable to an employer than what your competitor can provide at his cost, then it doesn't matter if you are "as good or better". A Corvette might be a "better" vehicle in your mind, but if an Impala can adequately provide a service, but at a much lower price, then on balance, most people (employers) try to measure the overall value.
[i]You asked, "Shouldn't there be a criterion for computer positions--just as there are ones for most other professions?"[/i]
Not necessarily.
[i]You asked, "Can I, with no degree in Engineering, go and compete for a job against an engineer with a bachelor's degree in Civil Engineering?"[/i]
Absolutely you can. And you might be surprised at how many such people are in that particular field. Granted, they may not advance as far and/or qualify for certifications and licenses, but they are indeed there, in big numbers, I might add, contributing a great deal. Moreover, some civil "designers" make a great deal more than civil "engineers". It depends on the quality of their work and the profit they can generate for the firm.
[i]You asked, "Well, why does it seem that anyone on earth with just 3 or 4 months of study of some certification can come and compete for the same job with someone who has spent at least 4 years of academic education for a Bachelor's degree and experience in computer science?[/i]
The same answer - value and profitability.
[i]You said, "In some instances, they might be working in the cubicle next yours and making MORE money than you do--let alone having your boss as someone who holds a degree in some arts or physical education; or no 4-year degree at all!!![/i]
Same answer as the civil engineer making less than a civil designer. If the designer is better and more profitable, he SHOULD make more money. Degrees do not automatically equal more value to a company.
[i]You said, "This renders a Bachelor's in Computer Science truly worthless!!![/i]
Well, you can define "worthless" however you want. But there are a lot of non-degreed professions that pay more than degreed professions.
[i]You said and asked, "Often times, it's not really that the guy--or gal--in the cubicle next to you is doing a better job than you are that earns them the extra money or authority. How about favoritism, attraction, other preferences that are irrelevant to the job?!"[/i]
I'll just consider that an emotional rant. We're beginning to repeat ourselves. Same questions, same answers.
[i]You said, "If a degree in CS were a benchmark, then at least, you would be competing against peers in the profession."[/i]
But it's obviously NOT a benchmark. Play the IF game all you want. A look at reality, however, will get you further.
[i]You said, "Or maybe we should do away with degrees altogether, and one could go and apply for any sort of job as long as you demonstrate the willingness to do it and the enthusiasm to learn![/i]
Now you are beginning to understand.
[i]You said, "But then again, I should be allowed to open a car repair shop, without having to become a licensed mechanic; I should be able to be an electrician without needing a license to practice,... how about a doc?![/i]
Not all professions are created equally. I wouldn't want a non-degreed person who learned medicine in his garage to perform brain surgery on me, but if he can fix my computer cheaper than you, he'll get the job.
Provide more of a service, more value, and help the company reap more of a profit to the company than the guy competing for the job, and you'll get it every time (well, most times), regardless of whether or not you have a degree.
Where do you get the time to post such lengthy dissertations as yours? Man, I really hope you aren't on my Project plans. If you are that committed to our profession to the point that you are writing these things on your own time I'm dog-gone pround of you and would love to hire you.
If you are busily tapping away on your keyboard faking like you are being productive you should thank whomever you feel is the Almighty Creator for the protection of not working for me or on any of my projects...
by absolutely
by oknightowl
You said, "...certifications are not worth the paper they are written on."
Neither are degrees.
In either case, it's what you do with it that provides the "worth".
by absolutely
by hal 9000
Allow that Brain to get Malpractice Insurance and without that piece of Paper the Brain can not get any Malpractice Insurance so they effectively can not work in that field. Well I suppose you could until your first mess up and then you would be broke.
That's why one of my Bitches got a Psychologists Degree just to prove a point. :D
Lets face it no matter how bad things get in IT no one is likely to die are they? Unfortunately the same thing can not be said in other fields like most of the Medical Professions. :(
Col ]:)
by absolutely
by cubeslave
I do not discount the worth of an IT degree, or college degrees in general. Until I had to drop out of college I got a lot out of my time there.
A circuitous chain of events led me to becoming a consultant specializing in adapting systems for blind and low vision users.
At no time did I not appreciate how much better a job I could do with a degree. On the other hand I was also getting job referrals from people with Masters degrees and PHDs in CS who said I was one of the best in the state.
When the state decided to phase out using consultants and hire people to do the job, all of the job descriptions that didn?t paid enough to keep a roof over my head all required a degree, any degree.
A Degree in Rehab engineering, CS or a related area was preferred, but not required. There was no "or equivelent job experience" phrase in the requirements.
So now I do something else.
by cubeslave
I would be making half again or double my current income if I had a degree.
I've gotten sick of people why say "well why don't you just get a degree..." since they are normally people who don't grasp the work involved. Getting a 4 year degree when your are still living with your parents, or can get by on a part time job. Having tried to do it, someone who can work a full time job and get their degree has my respect.
I once considered buying a degree from one of those diploma mills, but I have moral issues with them. Besides, I?m not the sort of person who can even ?fluff up? their resume.
I'm just saying what others actually perceive about you, me, and others.
I've been in both positions. I worked from 1986 to 1998 without a degree in an engineering, manufacturing, and IT role.
I earned my first degree in 1998 (Associates), second degree in 2002 (Bachelors), and third degree (MBA) in 2005.
By the way, nothing is guaranteed! However, the percentage of probability for those attributes does increase with degreed individuals. That's something that can be shown by many different studies.
They are not just my opinion - it's simply how the business world views candidates. I've seen the difference (they way businesses and hiring managers react)first hand too. It (the treatment)is different and you can laugh all you wish to about that but I don't think you can reasonably deny that it isn't true.
There are exceptions to everything such as Bill Gates (only 2 years at Harvard) but you see it over and over again where people with a certain level of education earn considerably more over their lifetimes than those with less education.
It's because well educated people have an advantage over those with lesser or no education. You're not denying that, are you?
by psykoticandy
Did you happen to notice the last sentence that said I'd love to hire the person if they had this much interest in IT to be so expressive on their own time.
I was asking, not accusing.
by mnoldsea
Hey Night owl, I think your reply was great. I'm up all hours of the night on the computer myself. It's the best time to develop my program solutions. Quiet, peaceful, undisturbed etc. It is nice to know that there are people like you that will make the effort to formulate a synopsis, and put a complex issue in some perspective.
Thanks again, and warm regards.
by jesc
Many of the posts bring out that a BS is obsolete or less valuable than work experience. The issue that comes up with strictly learning on the job is that the person's tool box of tricks is limited. Sure they can write another system like the ones they have worked on. But ask them to develop something that requires complex data structures or statistics. Unless they do alot of reading and studying beyond the latest C++ book they will be handicaped.
At some point a developer needs to learn hard core computer science.
by cheerstork
Why? I mean, I can't have a degree in english studies and buy a C++ for dummies and learn how to write a few loops and a couple of functions along with some cin cout and then visit the print shop and order cards with "Systems/Applications/Software Developer/Engineer/Architect"??
I mean, English studies and c++...all are languages...
by jkowolf
If your degree plus your ability doesn't separate you in the minds of those hiring, then why did you get one? I've seen plenty of jobs on Monster that require a degree. I doubt they ignore that criteria when hiring time comes.
The IT industry is an infant compared to the other fields you mentioned. When CS is as old as the engineering profession, degree plus certification will be required.
I work in the Investment industry where licensing is required. Guess what? Many licensed investment advisors suck.
by kreeseis
One thing that a degree does is verify that a person has the ability to learn information, process it and apply it in some form. Also, it verifies that a person can accomplish a goal...actually finish something.
This doesn't mean that the grad is smarter or even a better candidate than the non-grad. It simply covers the basics.
In theory, you would think that a person with a degree was trained correctly, is well versed in the "basics" and is well rounded. This isn't always the case, but what measuring stick do you have for a person without the education?
HR is always a crap shot, so employers always try to hedge their bets.
by kreeseis
I dropped out of college years ago because I ran out of money.
Recently, I went back. I'm married, with children and a full time management position (it was HARD to get that job.) I made it work because I understand the reality of the world. I didn't want to piss and moan about it...I wanted to fix it. Thats just what I did.
I wish you all the best of luck.
by jerim79
You must understand the difference between Computer Science and IT/MIS.
Computer Science is about understanding how to use computers to solve problems. In this way, it is very much like mathematics. Most colleges aren't going to teach you some really cool things in a particular language. Instead they are going to teach you concepts such loops, arrays, data structures, etc. All things common to most programming languages. They will also add in some networking courses, mostly in terms of how to program applications that work across the network. Add in some mathematic courses, and some electives, and you have the basic Computer Science program. It is expected that you will fill in the details later, using the knowledge that you gained while earning your degree.
IT/MIS on the other hand, usually concentrates on very specific things, such as programs and programming languages. You might learn to do a loop in VB.net but you won't ever be taught that loops are pretty much the same across all programming languages. You will be taught "vo-tech" skills. True, when you graduate, you might impress a few people because you know exactly how to extract data out of MS-SQL, because you took the "Extracting Data from MS-SQL" course. But what happens when they want to switch to Oracle or MySQL? You and the Computer Science degree person will have to both go look it up, but the Computer Science will probably figure it out faster.
And for the people without a degree, sure you can probably struggle along for a while and claw your way up to a respectable position. But I personally have always found people without degrees to have a tendency to over-inflate their accomplishments. You will never hear a non-degree holder say "I don't know that." Non-degree holders tend not to have done half as much as degree holders, yet they will say that they have.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending