Question Locked

Fun config question for hardware gurus, see the picture

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Which configuration will yield optimal performance?
http://i303.photobucket.com/albums/nn142/cerfer457/pc.jpg
(500 meg of RAM, which is max for this mobo)

19 replies

by dumphrey

what level of performance are you getting with a pci sata card on that bus? Is it faster then the native ata? plus he forgot to include the Parallel Infinityband Engine and Monitor Infinityband Link Kinetics...
how can you build a computer with no MILK or PIE?

by bobstone888

The SATA is slower than the native ATA. That makes me thing it may be best to put the OS/apps on the SATA channel (since high throughput is desirable when playing DVD files off of hard disk, and it's *definitely best to have the swap file be fast as possible)...but is it even possible to boot from a PCI-based controller? Not sure how that would work, since it seems like the SATA PCI driver would require Windows to be alive before the SATA drive would be visible.

by bobstone888

dang, tough crowd! ;)

OS is XPsp2

This isn't a school assignment, I did that illustration myself using pbrush.exe

Yes, a P3 *is* pretty pathetic these days, but it is what is is. I've got the hardware so I figure I may as well rig it for max (or "least sucky") performance.

The reason I called this a "fun" question is, I thought we might get some strong opinions, e.g., whether to share the DVD with the OS/apps channel or with the data channel.

by dumphrey

floor beside me as we speak. its currently running Debian and has nagios installed, but not correctly configured yet. You can do tons with an processor like this. Router/home web proxy/gateway, Web browsing/email box. Kitchen computer (who cares if you spill on it and it fries), kids first box... lots of solutions.

by older mycroft

Is that the minimum spec for XP is a 1.2GHz processor.

Now, as I said in the title, Uncle Bill is world-renowned for uttering false-promises in terms of what a system is capable of - but your 0.9GHz processor is way off base.

Your system would fly with Win95/98/98SE.

I should know - MY Win98 ran on a Cyrix P133 overclocked to 166MHz and at the time (1996) I though that was 'fast'. ;)

by dumphrey

for example, if you want the system to load quick, put the OS on the sata, but if you are going to run a database on this machine, put the data on the sata. No matter what you do, the swap file should be on a seperate disk from the OS, and preferable a separate controller/ide chain, and a dvd should have its own chain.... Ideally with IDE, the two devices on the same ribbon should not both working at the same time.
so...
sata1 OS/apps
ide0/0 Data/Swap
ide0/1 Data
Ide1/0 DvD
This only really works (maximum performance)if the two hard drives on the prmary ide chain are not being used at the same time.

by bobstone888

Thanks for your thoughts, I should have been more specific about what I'm doing.

Mainly I want to be able to watch video (DVD files streaming from the data drive thanks to DVD Decrypter) without any jerkiness. So I don't think I need the DVD drive to be on its own channel (since I won't be "watching DVDs" in the sense of actually using the DVD drive to stream video).

For sure I don't want the swap file on the same channel as the OS/apps.

by dumphrey

media from one drive to the OS, then having the movie on a separate drive/ide chain from the OS is the way to go.

So maybe...

Ide chain1

ide1 os/apps
DVD

Idecahin2
ide2 movie files

sata swap files data

by older mycroft

Go to sleep.

My old tower media centre has this annoying habit. All my mp3 and mpg/avi files reside on a separate ide drive from the os.

But when I choose to stop running Showshifter (digital TV), the delay waiting for the other drive to wake up is painful, because it slows down the shutdown for Showshifter too.

That's with an old Celeron 2.4GHz.

by dumphrey

I have a similar problem, but the drive that sleeps is the "storage" drive. I have 2 working drives and an OS drive. The OS and 2 working drives are sata, the back up drive and dvd are pata. If my processor and video card were not so bobo I would be a happy camper with by 1700 GBs of storage...

by dumphrey

And it is possible in most cases to boot off of a pci controller (depending on the controller).

As for the DVD, a movie will play more then fine over a 33Mbps bus, a full 100Mbps is not needed, ram and processor make a bigger difference, since they decode the data from the disk.

So, based on your info, I would put the OS and Apps on one IDE disk, data on the other IDE disk, the DVD on its own IDE chain, and the swap I would move to the sata after its set up and verified.

by jamesrl

Fragmentation.

Just ensure that the files that the movies are on is not the same drive as the OS and the apps. The OS drive tends to get fragmented as Windows creates temp files, restore points etc. Having the movies on a clean unfragmented drive will help the data rates.

James

by bobstone888

Thanks everyone for your thoughts.

I ended up using configuration #1
http://i303.photobucket.com/albums/nn142/cerfer457/pc.jpg

i.e., IDE1 sharing the OS/apps (drive C) and the DVD writer, IDE2 dedicated to the data drive, and the PCI SATA controller card for the SATA drive which is where I put the XP swap file (aka virtual memory). Per various web sources, I also left a small (5-to-50 meg) swap file on drive C.

The lowly 930 megahertz P3 with its maximum RAM of 500 megabytes is running XP pretty well, since the swap and data files' traffic are not competing with the OS/apps.

DVD movies played directly from the DVD drive (Nero Showtime or Windows Media Player) and DVD files playing from the dedicated data drive (thanks again, DVD Decrypter!) are fine, thank you. No jerkiness as long as I don't do anything else while watching the video. Multitasking less-demanding apps is no problem of course.

The only thing I would've had my druthers on would be to be able to run the OS/apps off the SATA drive, since it (see the sidebar in the illustration linked above) is a bit slower than the ATA drives; it would have been ideal to have the swap file on the fastest-possible channel (I didn't want to use the SATA drive for data because it has much less capacity than the ATA drive I did use for data). Actually I slipstreamed SP2 and the PCI SATA driver (was a bit tedious to configure/burn a custom XP install CD, but it actually worked on the first attempt, whew!) to allow XP to install on the SATA drive, but after the first (during-installation) reboot, the XP install routine couldn't see the SATA drive (which was my fear about putting the OS on the PCI-based controller in the first place). I suppose a more modern mobo (mine [manufactured in 2001] has the last available BIOS update) would have been a different matter.

Bottom line, this P3 runs XP passably with OS/apps, swap, and data on separate channels and using fast drives (all three of my hard drives are 7200 rpm). The main remaining limitation is just lack of ability to do heavy multitasking.

This discussion is closed to new replies.