Discussion Locked

Gays Serving in the U.S. Military - Who should decide?

0 helpful
412 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

412 replies

by oz_media

I can appreciate that the guy was somewhat passive and left without altercation when asked. Perhaps its less of a matter of him than the polling station security. Apparently he was there for an hour. He should have been addressed much sooner and dealt with right away, especially if he left quietly. They fact that news crews were there and managed to report on the guy just illustrates a lack or ineffectiveness of security taken at the polling station.

How quickly would this same situation be addressed if it had been a group of Muslims (not terrorists) trying to intimidate people outside?

by maxwell edison

Heck, I thought it was a prerequisite to bring a soap box. Everybody else stands on theirs, why shouldn't I?

by oz_media

To most young men going to the military, it's a job, a route to get some post secondary training and something all their friends do to.

Don't want to or can't get into college, don't want to take some menial job in a fast food restaurant etc. join the Marines. It's employment, training and, in the USA, bragging rights for standing up and being a man.

by oz_media

I'm shorter so I get a bigger box and shout a bit...a lot louder. Don't make me start using upper case too!

by oz_media

Just when you think you've got it all sorted out with ad hominem attacks, straw man arguments, fallacy, knee jerk opinions and the like, along comes a bloody THINKER!

Gawd, back to the drawing board, we have another patient for a frontal lobotomy, or make it a bottle-in-front-of-me and we'll call it even.

by delbertpgh

Of course there's a lack of polling station security. There are maybe 50,000 polling locations in the United States, and most of them have no cops at all. They are nearly 100% staffed by volunteers, usually equally divided between Republicans and Democrats, who check each other's work and cross-tabulate everybody who comes in to vote.

If there were police hanging around, staring at everybody, some people might be discouraged from voting. (If my car failed inspection and was illegal to drive, I might not want to drive to a place where I knew a cop would be loitering around the parking lot all day.) However, generally no police are necessary. It's not like Iraq here; polling stations don't attract trouble. So, to point out there was inadequate security is to observe an irrelevancy.

I said it didn't seem like anybody had been intimidated out of voting, or even from entering the building; nobody testified that they had. There's a lack of habeas corpus on that one. Prosecution for intimidating action has slightly more to go on, given that the one guy was slapping his billy club in his hand and yelling stuff like, "We're gonna elect a black president today! Nobody needs to vote here if they don't vote for Obama!" However, I didn't hear in that any direct threat, like "I'm gonna stop you if you try to enter." I can see where there would be difficulties in prosecution on this; apart from standing around with a weapon with 100 yards of a polling station, there's no unambiguous illegal thing that he did. (A side note: the other Panther guy, who had no stick and did less talking, actually lived upstairs in the building where the polling was taking place.) You can work up a case based on the implied threat they presented, in the absence of explicitly threatening language or behavior, but it would be a case against two dipsh*t guys, because nothing else like this happened in the city of Philadelphia that day, and there was no evidence connecting the Black Panther organization to this activity, except that the two were both members and both wore little funny Panther berets and military-style tunics.

Now, you may say it's not the point; it isn't the point that nobody was hurt, nobody was kept out of the building, no legally-defined threats were made, and no criminal conspiracy was established beyond two stupid guys acting together. You'd say it wasn't the point either that arresting them would make for ill will, an expensive and dubious prosecution, and nationwide free publicity in print and TV for a racist, radical organization. It's the principle! Just because there's no actual party who was harmed by them, and deserves justice, there's an imaginary party! There's a principle!

I think principles have their limits, and if standing on principle gets you nothing but trouble and no compensatory benefit, you might want to stand slightly to one side. It happens all the time. Cops tell a belligerent drunk to go home; unless he resists or breaks something, they don't bother to arrrest him for the half dozen ordinances he has violated. Cops don't give you a speeding ticket unless you're at least ten miles over the limit; they consider less a waste of time (caution: this rule does not apply in Alabama.) Voting is an important principle, but two guys acting dumb for one hour does not necessarily degrade its importance.

Smells like a big nothing to me. Ho, hum. I'll wait for the Civil Rights Commission report to see if there's more behind this.

Incidentally, if you drive through Alabama with Yankee license plates, there are some communities that cheerfully round your observed speed up, until you're ten miles over. Even if you thought you were one mile under. Seen it happen.

by ansugisalas

"Of course, people around here also like it a lot more if you actually post useful thoughts and analysis rather than perpetually diverging off topic and posting obtuse nonsense. Take that as a recommendation." :O

That's a tall order for most of us non-lurkers :p
I hope you don't mind it, but I'd like some sources to back it up! ;)

Here's a caveat there too; like, Habermas is one of the most quoted present day philosophers (I guess, seems to come up a lot anyway), but whenever I am subjected to his production, I can't help but think "This is just so much obtuse nonsense!".
So, there's a distinct possibility that I am unable to see something highly worthwhile - Of course I don't think it is so, but I allow for the possibility. ;)

etu + smilies + There>Here

by ansugisalas

You have two boxes... tie one under each foot and presto - soap-boxing with foot-work. ;)
Having one's tongue in one's cheek helps with balance :p

by john.a.wills

sometimes attempt sexual intercourse with members of their own sex. But humans are intelligent enough to distinguish even if handicapped, so do not have the excuse of the animals.

I know that sexual inversion occurs among animals, who sometimes when so affected do weird things (apparently whales do some odd things with their snorkels) but, again, we are the rational animal and know what things are for, so even sexual inversion is not an excuse.

by ansugisalas

Know horses? Even mares go dry-humping other mares from time to time...
I guess they don't teach that in convert school :p

by oz_media

My Buddy's pit used to try to bang my pit all the time. As soon as it came in the yard, my dog would sit and look at it with those, 'please, no' eyes.

But hey, we are "evolved" and are supposed to restrain ourselves from such sins as we should know better, don't you read the bible?
Well I guess that throws 'evolved' out of the window, maybe we are just going against God's design then, yeah that makes a lot more sense, don't do it because God says so. :D

by jamesrl

Try dogs - if you haven't seen this, you've been blind - and last time I checked dogs had better smell capabilities than we do.

The most scientifically studied animal groups that have same sex behaviour are chimpanzes.

If I follow your logic, gay people are less intelligent that straight ones. Is that what you mean? Really?

by ansugisalas

this exact and entire message of his was available between the lines of what immediately preceded the "pervert" line.

Too warped to be able to hide.

by ansugisalas

wondering if "thought this out" is meant in this instance as specifically, pertinently different from something like "thought this through"...

Keeps me young ;)

by oz_media

You'd almost have a point about Canada's Liberal government, if we didn't have a Conservative government of course.

Sexual Orientation refers to the direction (orientation) someone seeks sexually.

Based on the remainder of your lunacy, I take it that you feel homosexuality is a warped mind, or perhaps warped orientation.

What a numpty!

by oz_media

So police = security. That's new to me.

IN Canada, we have commissioners at places like welfare offices, banks, UI offices etc. They are just normal security dudes, usually very old security dudes, that are there to be eyes and ears, open doors for people that need help, speak to problematic people and escalate it to a greater authority (police) if needed.

Pretty sure that in this case, someone just there to watch over things would have had his request heeded and they would have left peacefully in a timely manner.

These people could also be volunteers as well, just ask them to make sure that everything is going as planned and report any difficulties they have if people refuse to cooperate. It works here nationwide, don't see how it wouldn't work there too.

So far you are barely hanging on by a thread, you have no logical or reasonable support for your comments.

To suggest a volunteer or part time, low income worker, assigned to keeping things orderly, would be either a financial or resource burden on the worlds greatest and most mighty nation, who can spend trillions on a foreign war but not manage it's own polling stations is purely laughable.

You are not Afghanistan....yet.

by jamesrl

While I haven't done it in a few years, I've participated in the whole organization of voting at all three levels of government in Canada.

In Canada, there are people hired to be Returning Officers who manage the voting process. They are considering government officials. They in turn hire people to run polling stations (Deputy Returning Officers, and Poll Clerks).

Candidates may also assign scrutineers to watch over the process. They (scrutineers)are allowed to see the voters list to determine who voted. They are allowed to challenge the credentials of a voter (DRO has final say though). In the days of paper ballots they were allowed to view the counting process.

Candidates may also appoint a legal agent who may officially represent the candidate when talking to election officials. I've done that role too, though usually its a lawyer.

If any intimidation took place at a polling station, the paid staff have a procedure to handle it, by calling the Returning officer, and/or police.

In Canada we have rules about what can and cannot happen near a polling station, and there would be grounds for anyone seen to be campaigning withing XX feet of the polling station. Scrutineers are not allowed to talk to voters, wear pins or buttons.

I know if there was an incident, the scutineers would pitch in and help the paid staff. Because the last thing they want is the voting to stop because of a legal issue.

by oz_media

I was thinking mulled it over, tossed it around, held under scrutiny; you had already used 'through' so I left it there.

by oz_media

Use three boxes, garners more attention. Plus you usually get a date by the end of the day.

by ansugisalas

was referring to santee's wording, and how always expecting a trick can start to play tricks with one's semantic projections.
Like expecting a feint in a fist-fight, then realizing "what if the pattern of feinting was a feint...", it's certainly something to ensure a few extra revs of the gray cells...

by oz_media

I know what you meant, I was just farting around as always.

As for Santee, not worth racking the brain over, I don't think he understands himself half the time.

by oz_media

Just because one gay man changes or showers near a straight man, it doesn't mean he is automatically attracted to him and will try to rape him.

How many gay men are in the military now? You'll never know and probably wouldn't know if you shared soap with him.

Have you ever showered in a public pool or gym? Did the gay men rape you? Do you even know who is or who isn't gay?

Being straight myself, I have been around nude women and wasn't attracted to them just because I was straight.

To these ignorant, homophobic soldiers, what makes them think they are so desirable to a gay man to begin with, personal flattery ?

What makes them feel that Big Bubba is not a gay man that likes effeminate men?

Half of these idiots wouldn't know it when they faced a gay man anyway, the other half probably wouldn't be attractive to a gay man either.

It is just 100% pure ignorance that belongs in the dark ages.

by ansugisalas

talk about "cruel and unusual"...
But I guess these prison yard bodybuilders with their "bitches" are actually gay, and only kidding themselves when they're out of prison ;)

by maxwell edison

Your argument is nothing but a straw man run amok.

I'd guess that I probably agree with you regarding the underlying question, but your presentation of such a straw-man is beneath even you.

Rape? Please, spare us.

by drowningnotwaving

Only 70 years ago, left handedness was considered (in many parts of the english-speaking world) against the [i]natural order of things[/i]. People had it beaten out of them, with no consideration of short or long-term issues.

People with cleft paletes, sciatica, cerebral palsey or myriad other conditions were considered by many to be 'against tthe natural order of things' and treated as such. Hidden, forgotten and ashamed.

You may well find "sexual orientation" a strange phrase.

Your "natural order of things" is as flimsy a foundation as yesterday's fashion magazine.

Not entirely sure what your last sentence meant, but I am 100% confident you need not concern yourself with the risks or afflictions of genius.

edit shpellink

by santeewelding

You may be more right than you realize.

Understanding the understander, before I go telling what others are about, is a trick I have yet to master.

by maxwell edison

Often times (but not always), when I read one of Santee's messages, I take pause; I read again; I then read yet again.

Just like poetry.

Sometimes I get it. Sometimes I don't get it.

Oh well. Poetry in motion.

P.S. My guess is that Santee might appreciate the link.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IUb9jTdLUu0

P.P.S. Don't get any ideas because of the subject matter of this discussion!

P.P.P.S. Don't even think about it!

by maxwell edison

1950s (and early 1960s) music is something else. There's nothing like it.

My transister radio - AM only. The one I made myself from the kit I bought with the silver dollars I saved from my allowance. Soldered connections and all! The one I listened to late at night ..... under my blankets ..... when my parents thought I was asleep .......

And there was that tall radio tower, far off in the distance, but clearly visible from my second floor bedroom window. The one with white lights that ran all the way from the bottom to the top. Red lights blinking at the top. The white lights shut-off at exactly midnight. Sometimes I saw them go off. Other times, I had already drifted off - only to find dead batteries in the morning.

Oh my! What a segue!

by santeewelding

Of transistor radios, about the size of a deck of playing cards, I learned on a summer beach in New England as an-up-and-coming youngster that Ernest Hemingway had blown his brains out.

Devastated me. I had been studying his technique.

by oz_media

I was directly replying to the ignorant comment posted before me.

The guy actually thinks that if gays are not openly allowed in the military that there won't be/isn't gay men or women in the military? WTF??!!

He thinks that if a gay man is let into the military that he should be weary about showering around him? Don't flatter yourself!

It's pure BS, the stuff that homophobes just don't get. Because a man is gay is he automatically attracted to all other men? No.

Guys like this seem to think they are and that he is in danger of being 'taken' in the shower. What a farce!

It's only utter ignorance, no idea what he's talking about, no interaction with gay men.

It's fear due to ignorance, nothing more. Freakin' 1950's redkneck shite.

by tonythetiger

make some logical comparisons. Just as hetero men are capable of non-sexual interactions with members of the opposite gender, I can be reasonably sure that homosexual men are capable of non-sexual interactions with members of the same gender.

Personally, I think society should be far more afraid of the people who doubt the above.

by jamesrl

Do you honestly believe that the minds of gay people are that much different than those of straight people?

I would have thought my libertarian friend would understand that being gay isn't the singular defining charecteristic of an individual. None of us should be defined by a singular charecteristic, wether thats the colour of our skin, our religious beliefs, our weight, whatever. We are as individuals so much more than anything that simplistic.

So how one acts around those that one is attracted to is much more than a factor of one's sexual orientation.

by oz_media

You don't have to get into the mind of a gay person. Gay people are just like anyone else, they aren't like some kind of different species. They are just attracted to same sex mentally, physically, physically or for whatever reason, just as heterosexual people are. I see plenty of women I'd jump in the sack with in a heartbeat, it doesn't mean I am going to run up and grab them from what they are doing so I can have my way with them. (Unfortunately, I am told you aren't allowed to do that?!)

I don't want all women, I don't like all women. Having known, worked for/with and hung out with my fair share of gay men and women, I know that their desire for a relationship or partner is no different than my own. They just choose same sex people to share the more intimate moments in their life with.

I really don't understand how it is so difficult for people to grasp or even why they feel they must get it in order to accept it.

by carlo.di.giorgio

old argument used by gay lobbyists. What you allude to could only be observed among domesticated animals which have lost most of their natural instincts by leaving so closely to single humans and being dressed to behave as if they were sort of humans. I suggest you consult the famous work of Alfred Adler if there is an English translation, in case you are not familiar with difficult German
DAS PROBLEM DER HOMOSEXUALIT?T - Fischer Verlag. Adler, Founder of the Individual Psychology, dismisses categorically any genetic links to this phenomenon defined as neurotic sexual perversion originated by distorted upbringing, social trends, especially promoted by modern media and above all inculcated into themselves by repetitive auto training ??somatization??. All known homosexuals can fit in perfectly well in Adler's discourse. Basically, they have their own history behind and that is understandable, since by sound and balanced upbringing and education men should only be spontaneously attracted to women and women to men. All arguments of those who tolerate this neurotic phenomenon as acceptable life style can be easily dismantled on all fronts. The vast majority of world population and serious religions consider homosexuality a dishonorable vice like many others affecting humans. It is only in liberal West where it is nowadays not only tolerated but even promoted and this explains why the West is elsewhere considered decadent. All previous societies affected by such perversion have fallen apart and decayed?

by jamesrl

First of all, I'm far from a gay lobbyist. I'm a businessperson, I'm a father, I've been a conservative political activist.

As to your assertion that only domesticated animals exhibit same sex behaviour, you obviously didn't read my writing about chimpanzes. Those were wild chimpanzes.

As for Adler's theories, I've met many homosexuals who had fine upbringings and are decent human beings. If there is anyone who is perverse, its those who chose to obsess about the sex lives of others and charectise a human being solely on their sexual orientation.

by john.a.wills

between on the one hand sexual inversion of the erotic instincts, a condition sometimes called "homosexuality", and pseudosexual activity (a.k.a. gross indecency a.k.a. sexual perversion a.k.a. mutual masturbation) such as cunnilingus, tribadism, buggary or fellatio; when such activity occurs between members of the same sex it is sometimes called "homosexuality". If we condemn gross indecency by people who experience sexual inversion, a fortiori we should condemn it by two-sex couples, who have the option of sexual intercourse.

Having a sexually inverted eroticism does not compel one to engage in gross indecency, i.e. it does not compel one to become gay. There are indeed societies of sexual inverts determined not to become gay, e.g. Courage (www.couragrc.net).

I am afraid that the Pentagon mixes the two meanings of "homosexuality", although the "don't ask, don't tell" policy as currently applied seems to apply more to gross indecency than to sexual inversion. It is unfair that soldiers practising this kind of behavior are not expelled if they practise it with members of the opposite sex, for their guilt is greater.

by carlo.di.giorgio

not jump into conclusions. Adler still is The Authority in Individual Psychology by observing as a medical doctor 1000's of patients for long years. I have been a passionate reader of Anthropology and Psychology in all major European languages, I master as first, since my adolescence and intensively during my Oxford years. In the 80's I also observed as consequence of limitless perversions since the liberal 60's how many homosexuals had become victims of the pest many believe they themselves were responsible for infecting humanity in first place. In the early 80's they were falling in the 1000's like flies and despite 'plastic' precautions they still represent nowadays the most vulnerable section of humanity. The tragedy, however, is since then the catastrophic widespread of the terrible disease among many innocent victims (women and children) mainly in Africa, whereby the real and permanent cure cannot be the palliative usage of condoms but abstinence and strict observance of high moral standards, which are always in accordance with the laws of nature.
To conclude this discourse I would say that the US and all other nations are well advised to ban homosexuals as unfit to serve under their banners.
Cheers!

by oz_media

If there was any sense, reason or fact behind your theory that it is a decision people make one day, you'd have a point.

Do you REALLY think people CHOOSE to be a minority? Have sex with someone they are not naturally attracted to?

And why is homosexuality ALWAYS related to the physical act of having sex?

Is it not possible that someone would seek comfort, friendship and alliance that develops into love for the same sex but is unable to feel such emotion toward the opposite sex?

It's not all about men lusting after men or women lusting after women, it's about relationships, companionship, partnership, who you want to spend your life with, who you like to share special moments with.

by maxwell edison

..... I might imagine myself in a group shower with a dozen women - those very same women - of different shapes, sizes, and varieties. At what point could [i]non-sexual interactions with members of the opposite gender[/i] turn into .........

??????

Working together is one thing. Living together is another.

Note: Just playing devil's advocate, here.

by jamesrl

There are most certainly thousands of homosexual men and women in the US Armed Forces today, and there have certainly been homosexuals there throughout history. Has it been a problem?

Has it been a problem for the other armies around the world, like most NATO countries?

I ran for my high school cross country team in the late 70s. We knew one of the team was gay. None of us refused to shower with him. I'm sure other scenarios like this happen every single day.

Gay people do serve today, the issue is whether or not the don't ask don't tell policy should be thrown out, and if so, who should do it.

by oz_media

That's like saying you couldn't have a female roommate without having sex with her. Even worse, these people are merely at work together, they are trained to work together professionally.

I lived with three girls when my ex and I first split, even on the rebound I respected boundaries. They'd walk around the house in not much at all but they were roommates, not partners. Even if I did find them attractive, it doesn't mean I am going to try to have sex with them.

Just because people share a space it doesn't mean they have to take it beyond that.

by carlo.di.giorgio

...old and misleading argument misused by gay lobbyists. What you allude to could only be observed among domesticated animals, which have lost most of their natural instincts by leaving so closely to single humans and being dressed to behave as if they were sort of humans. I suggest you consult the famous work of Alfred Adler, if there is an English translation available, in case you are not familiar with difficult German:
DAS PROBLEM DER HOMOSEXUALITAET
- Fischer Verlag -.
Adler, Founder of the Individual Psychology, dismisses categorically any genetic links to this phenomenon defined as neurotic sexual perversion originated by distorted upbringing, social trends, nowadays since early 80's especially promoted by modern media and above all inculcated into themselves by repetitive auto training ''somatization''. All known homosexuals can fit in perfectly well in Adler's discourse. Basically, each of them have their own history behind and that is understandable, since by sound and balanced upbringing and education men should only be spontaneously attracted to women and women to men. All arguments of those who tolerate this neurotic phenomenon as acceptable life style can be easily dismantled on all fronts. The vast majority of world population and serious religions consider homosexuality a dishonorable vice like many others affecting humans. It is only in liberal West where it is nowadays not only tolerated but even promoted and this explains why the West is elsewhere considered decadent. All previous societies affected by such perversion have fallen apart and decayed.

by carlo.di.giorgio

How can one possibly assert that there is no order in nature? Unbelievable statement, to put it very politely.
It can only come from countries originated by Brits who sent to their Austral colony, officially declared ''non-populated by humans''. North American Pueblo Indians used to consider homosexuals unfit as warriors as weak and coward, hence relegated to domestic tasks only. You might also care to research what the cultures of Austral Aborigines, brutally devastated, at the hands of exported British criminals, were considering the status of homosexuals.
I am glad to read that only English speaking societies were professing such totally uncivilized hence ''un-Christian'' perverted beliefs. If you care to travel to Italy and look around you will find that all health and social centres were originally founded and established by religious orders, who cared for sick, invalid, handicapped and poor humans. I read Dickens and am still astonished by the cruelty of English societies of earlier days.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It appears you interpret rather liberally.

[i]How can one possibly assert that there is no order in nature?[/i]

by herlizness

<< What is needed is social change. But if your Religious Right is gaining ascendancy - as it looks from over here >>

they're making a lot of noise and *claiming* ascendancy, which is not the same thing as gaining it

we're making progress; we're always in the process of making progress

by jamesrl

On one hand you espose that you don't care about what gay people do. On the other, you seem to see them as a group apart from yourself, having a different mind.

I know gay people as friends, neighbours and coworkers, as diverse as any others.

Max, you started this discussion. I don't honestly know if you care about the issue itself, or whether you are just using the issue to bash Obama. I know this kind of subject as wedge politics- finding an issue to try and get the opposition to fight each other. Get the democrats who support abolishing don't ask, don't tell to get mad at Obama, and maybe stay home in November.

I'm not suggestng this is only a tactic used by only one side.

I could be wrong Max, I could misunderstand what you are saying, explain it to me.

by maxwell edison

James, you said, [i]On one hand you espouse that you don't care about what gay people do. On the other, you seem to see them as a group apart from yourself, having a different mind.[/i]

You also asked, [i] Do you honestly believe that the minds of gay people are that much different than those of straight people?[/i]

Well, James, you're right. I don't care what people do in the privacy of their own lives, gay or otherwise.

As far as seeing them [i]as a group apart from myself, having a different mind[/i], you apparently missed the sarcasm. Moreover, you shamelessly - emphasis on shamelessly - put words in my mouth that were never there in the first place. I said, [i] Well, since I've never had, or been into, the mind of a gay person, I wouldn't know.[/i] That's all I said, James. No more, no less. You tell me, James, where did I say that anyone, gay or otherwise, had a [i]different mind[/i]? (Ignoring the obvious observation that each and every one of us, gay or otherwise, has a [i]different mind[/i] from others. We're ALL unique individuals, with unique - and different - minds.)

I've never been in your mind either, James. I might know what you say, but I have no way of knowing, with absolute certainty, what you think, how you reason, or what deep thoughts you might choose to keep to yourself. If you want to call me on what I say, that's fine and dandy. But why don't you actually call me on what I PRECISELY say, not on what you've extrapolated - or made up - from what I said?

In that same vein, so many people in this discussion have presumed to do two things: they first seem to group everyone of the gay persuasion as having a like-mind; they then seem to presume to know, with absolute certainty, what goes on in the minds of all those like-minded people. Both of those suggestions, if you really think about it, are utterly preposterous!

[i]I (you) know gay people as friends, neighbours and coworkers, as diverse as any others.[/i]

Well good for you. I suppose that makes you an expert on the millions of people - all of those like-minded people (note the sarcasm) - whose thoughts you seem to be privy to (note more sarcasm). That means absolutely nothing, except you know a few people who tell you things about themselves.

[i] Max, you started this discussion. I don't honestly know if you care about the issue itself, or whether you are just using the issue to bash Obama.[/i]

When did I bash Obama? That's another shameless extrapolation. All I said was that when it comes to establishing and/or changing military policy, the president - in his role as Commander in Chief - should be the one who makes the final call. Not the courts; not congress; and not by popular consensus of the people. You might disagree with that opinion, and a couple of people have challenged it with some pretty good arguments. But the president has ALWAYS made such calls, not unlike President Truman in 1948. The reason I asked the question in the first place is that, in my opinion, the courts are assuming too much power in this country, assuming a role that was not intended by our founders.

I will admit, however, with the exception of reining in activist judges, I don't care about the issue. Whether or not gays are allowed to openly serve in the U.S. military is an issue about which I couldn't care any less. I'm neither for it nor against it. And regardless of what any president may or may not do, it's just fine by me.

Under Clinton, it was [i]don't ask, don't tell[/i]. Well, that was fine by me. Under Bush, nothing was changed. Again, fine by me. Under Obama, apparently nothing is changing. Again, fine by me. But if Obama did lift the ban on gays serving openly, I would neither praise him nor criticize him for making the decision. It's the president's call. It's his job - as Commander in Chief. I'll give him (or her) the courtesy of allowing him (or her) to do it.

You said, [i] I would have thought my libertarian friend would understand that being gay isn't the singular defining characteristic of an individual. None of us should be defined by a singular characteristic, whether that's the colour of our skin, our religious beliefs, our weight, whatever. We are as individuals so much more than anything that simplistic.[/i]

I never said, or even suggested, that [i] being gay is the singular defining characteristic of an individual.[/i] Other people in this discussion, however, have come closer to making such a preposterous suggestion - those who, like I said, presume to do two things: they first seem to group everyone of the gay persuasion as having a like-mind; they then seem to presume to know, with absolute certainty, what goes on in the minds of all those like-minded people.

I hope I answered your questions, James. If not, feel free to quote me - but quote me exactly - and ask for clarification. I'll be happy to answer.

Let me ask you this, James. In your opinion, and considering your expertise, as defined by your knowing certain people, is adopting a gay lifestyle, either in totality or in part, always a matter of nature, or is it sometimes a matter of choice? And how does being gay versus being bisexual fit into that question? And what about people who go from practicing homosexuality to practicing heterosexuality, or vice versa?

Having said all that, James, what's your opinion on my specific question? In regards to allowing those of the gay persuasion to openly serve in the U.S. military, who should ultimately make the call? I say it's the president (not the courts). What do you say?

Edit for my P.S.

P.S. I hope you know, James, I wouldn't spend that kind of time answering a question (or questions) for just anybody.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

That people blithely continue to interpret one so obviously unlike them as though that one is like them, has a great deal to do with 'understanding' santee.

I may have to work at understanding him, but I take that as excellent mental exercise in a day and age that is woefully lacking in imagination and direct relation with necessity.

edit the usual

by boxfiddler Hot topic

over substance. Utterly lacking in metaphor and imagination, as well. It passes.

by jazzyjeff2u

the way i see it, anyone that is physically and mentally fit for the job and willing to die for my freedom should be allowed to serve.

I understand that interpersonal dynamics can become issues of safety in that setting - but that risk exists with or without sex. and there are plenty of women in the military so i don't see the difference.

but really - the most important part is - anyone that is willing to work hard and risk their life to protect me, my civil liberties, and my dreams should be allowed to serve.

by santeewelding

That you speak so fluently about others "protecting" you. You -- you -- are incapable of doing so yourself? You would pay and authorize for others to do for what you have no stomach to do for yourself?

Puke.

by delbertpgh

Sometimes I do. We have an army that thinks they are a breed apart. It doesn't reflect the citizenry any more.

by oz_media

"You -- you -- are incapable of doing so yourself? "

Are you suggesting everyone take up arms, forget the soldiers, pay for tickets to the Middle East and take up the fight themselves?

I think he's merely saying that, if someone is willing to put their live on the line in the name of US security, their sexual preference becomes quite irrelevant. Thank and respect all those who volunteer for such noble duties.

by nicknielsen

[i]...anyone that is physically and mentally fit for the job and willing to die for my freedom should be allowed to serve.[/i]

Your comment makes me think I wasted 24 years. Do you not think that maybe those who are physically and mentally fit for the job aren't willing to die for your freedom, but for theirs?

by delbertpgh

have developed a political outlook that separates them from the people they serve? Even worse, does it seem that soldiers have come to think of their role as the most true expression of what the country is, or ought to be, about? And that civilian ineptitude in the politicians and the electorate is letting them down?

I know of police who feel this way. You might think it's even natural that somebody who serves the state directly, is both the armed fist and the international janitor who is sent out to clean up the politicians' messes, and puts his life on the line in the process, would think of himself as a super-citizen.

When I was in the Air Force the career soldiers would grumble about civlians' outlook, and I would think, "Hey, they're talking about me. I'm just here as a temp." (I enlisted to beat the draft.) I was sure they complained a lot more about civilians and their stupid unappreciation when I wasn't around; I knew they didn't talk this way when actual civilians could hear. Now, if you stand in line in the airport with them, you can hear that talk, and they don't even care. Something has changed.

by oz_media

Isn't it for America's freedom? Anyone else could just as easily get up and move to a free, more democratic nation and gain such personal security with far less effort or personal risk.

Aren't soldiers out for the greater good of the nation, not themselves.

by Member 25348569

then I expect that we just might revisit this subject. We might even re-open the subject after Tuesday's vote.

:)

by maxwell edison

The economist of the most liberal stripes. Would you really expect him to predict anything but doom and gloom about Republicans?

by herlizness

I suppose it could happen but I don't think so; with a little bit of luck the US populace will acquire a better vocabulary with which to express its frustrations, discontent and anger ... one that does not include "Sarah now!" ... but we'll see

As for Tuesday, it would seem the handwriting is pretty much on the wall, no? As it relates to Palin specifically, there is a very distinct possibilty that her candidates will not end up on the winning side ... again, we shall see

by Member 25348569

we wonder what on earth is going on. Your country seems to be running scared.

Islamophobia seems to be gaining ground again. Anti-China sentiments abound. Iran, terrorists, socialism...

welcome to the ex-imperialists club.

:)

by nicknielsen

I knew several not-so-open gays who openly participated in "the testosterone-fuelled macho barracks atmosphere which would feel threatened by open gays".

Brought a sardonic tear to my eye...

by delbertpgh

Newt, Sarah, the whole tea party nonsense... how the hell can I ever take Republicans seriously? The only wackadoodle who clearly will be rejected is Christine O'Donnell.

I'm gloomed.

by maxwell edison

I wish people could engage in honest discussion without CONSTANTLY resorting to various phobia charges. It's the second time you've done it in this discussion, Neil - first homophobia, and now Islamophobia.

It's just not being honest, and is merely a ploy to be dismissive of those who happened to disagree on an issue.

by maxwell edison

..... I wouldn't be a bit surprised if Hillary Clinton resigns from her top spot at the State Department near the end of 2010, and actually challenges Obama for the Democratic Party nomination in 2012. She could run on the [i]I told you so[/i] platform, and she'd be right!

by Member 25348569

The US Military is homophobic. A phobia is an irrational fear of something and if you can give me ANY rational reason why the US Military should treat gays any differently than straights then I will withdraw the charge.

ANY fear of homosexuality is phobic.

Islamophobia? I merely mentioned that it is growing in the US - and here. I didn't describe the country as in any way universally islamophobic. Any studies that canvass the general population over time as to their positive and negative views towards the Islamic religion will show that growth in antipathy. As to how much of the antipathy is deserved and how much is phobic reaction born out of ignorance, feel free to decide yourself.

Neil

by maxwell edison

You apply the word in cases where it doesn't apply. It might apply in isolated instances, but not always - and I would guess, not mostly. Thus, you paint with too wide a brush.

by Member 25348569

and from a different culture. I call it as I see it and I can't see the fine detail. All you're ever going to get is a broad brush unless we hit on something specific that has caught my interest.

I still reckon that the reason why gays are not wanted in the military is because this would require a real cultural change away from the testosterone-fuelled macho barracks atmosphere which would feel threatened by open gays.

by nicknielsen

Why should that change?

The flap is over whether they can do it openly. I don't see why not, but Congress passed DADT, so Congress needs to repeal it.

by delbertpgh

They passed a law (as part of the military budget of 1994) saying homosexuality was incompatible with military service. This was a setback to Bill Clinton, who wanted to open the service up to gays, so he imposed Don't Ask/Don't Tell as a restriction on the enforcement of this law. The restrictive DADT policy was done by executive order, not by legislation, so Congress can't actually repeal it; but they could make another law making DADT illegal. That still just affects DADT, and not the underlying prohibition on homosexuality in the service.

At least, that's the way I understand this mess. I could be wrong. Ask Liz.

by maecuff

In very simple terms..we just don't like the brown people here.

I really wish that were a harsh and unjustified statement, but it's not. I hear it all the time. You hear it voiced by politicians and politician hopefuls.

Fear and intolerance. Or maybe that is redundant. Either way..it all makes me sad.

by Member 25348569

It vaguely passed across my conciousness that there was an NFL game on. I didn't notice it on the TV but I do believe that there was a sell-out Wembley crowd - 80,000 - to watch the game.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/other_sports/american_football/9126726.stm

A few years ago we used to have the action from one or more games on Channel 4. I got quite into the game because most of the breaks were stripped out. I found that I couldn't watch live games when in the US - too many stoppages and I don't have the necessary mindset to know what to do.

We don't have any televised games, now.

Interest is fairly limited as most watch proper football.

Edited to add: The match highlights were shown on BBC1, the main channel, at around midnight. Past my bedtime but I recorded them and may watch them later. The first half was, it seems, "dire". But that is why we have fast-forward.

by delbertpgh

I haven't seen any other economist who has seen the issues on this mortgage/banking crisis as well or as early as Krugman.

by jamesrl

Its easy to miss sarcasm in print. I don't think I'm the only one.

I exatrplolated a "different mind" simply because you say you'd ever been inside a gay mind. Like there is a gay mind or a hetero mind or white mind or black mind.

And I didn't say you bashed Obama, I said I couldn't honestly (NO SARCASM) tell your motive, one motive was you brought it up because you care one way or another about the issue, or another because you feel that Obama isn't handling it well. And despite your paragraphs of explanation I still don't know.

Again the singular defining charecteristic was a reaction to "Gay mind" which I found offensive. I understand now that you've enlightened me that you meant that sarcastically.

And I'm not suggesting I'm an expert, but I have had some exposure to gay people in many facets of life.

As for your questions, I don't think anyone choses to be gay, to have an attraction to one sex or another, or both, is something that is born. Wether you chose to act on that attraction is another issue. I've met men who had seemingly normal heterosexual lives, fathers etc., who came out after a divorce or death of their opposite sex partner - I think they had been repressing for years, not changing their basic nature.

As for the gay lifestyle, I presume you are talking about activists who go to gay pride parades etc. That too is a choice. I've met many gay conservatives who abhore that kind of thing.

If you have forgotten, I weighed in early on the subject of the original question. As the commander in chief I presumed he had the power to dictate the policy. If consitutionally I'm wrong, which I could be, then at least Obama should lead on the issue.

by jamesrl

My father in law served over 30 years, at first in the British Army and then in the Canadian Army.

He certainly had lots of political opinions, and they ran contrary to many, but while he didn't regard many politicians highly, he didn't think himself as smarter, just more experienced.

He was against peacekeeping, against any war that wasn't declared by others on his country. He thought inserting soldiers into political issues was wrong headed and wasteful.

by oz_media

Perhaps you aren't aware that even volunteer solders are known to not shoot at the enemy when it comes down to it.

It was actually found that during WWII that only a small percentage of men would shoot to kill the enemy. When a single enemy solder was exposed a said 80% would not shoot at him.

Those statistics have been proven changed somewhat over the years due to mental training. But if you revert to a bunch of people who don't want to go to war, don't believe in war, don't want to fight a specific enemy, you are back to square one, paying for bullets that just don't matter and don't help your cause.