Discussion Locked

Gays Serving in the U.S. Military - Who should decide?

0 helpful
412 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

412 replies

by nicknielsen

I'm still not picking up the thought processes behind your original transition, but I know where you're coming from now.

I think that's part of the problem, Oz. Your thoughts are clear to you, but not always that clear to those that read your posts. I'm not the only one who has had that problem.

My position, if I haven't made it clear elsewhere is that the military should make the call, however, current law bars open homosexuals from military service. Any choices the military makes other than continuing DADT or enacting an outright ban are moot until that law is changed. The military also has existing regulations governing harassment, sexual or otherwise. Other than the usual human persecution of the different, why would you think they wouldn't be applied equitably?

by nicknielsen

At least not in the USAF; in 24 years, I know of no such event at any of my duty stations.

I attended many Dining-Ins and Dining-Outs, though. The Dining-In is a military-only affair, usually limited to the members of a given unit and a guest of honor or two; attendance is mandatory for all unit members currently on-station. The Dining-Out is a less-formal event where personal guests are acceptable and attendance is usually voluntary. In both cases, formal dress is [i]de rigeur[/i]. Never had to dance, though.

The event where a same-sex couple would most likely be seen as such is the Dining-Out.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dining_Out

by herlizness

<< This thread is about who should be in charge of decisions regarding gay men or women into the military, clearly it is the discretion of the military >>

Have you not been following the thread carefully? The authority to decide such matters is explicitly committed to the Congress in the US Constitution.

And just to be clear, the UCMJ is part of federal statutory law enacted by the Congress and signed by the president. It's not something a bunch of generals mull over and create in consultation with the JAG corps.

by ansugisalas

They talk between themselves, flat-earthers. They share cliff's notes on books with good material for presentation, in context or out of it. Obviously, for the use they intend for it, out of context is usually the case.
They all seem to have the same cheat sheets; like, they all have some bogus argument about evolution and the laws of thermodynamics.
Next they'll tell us homosexuality too violates that.

by ansugisalas

You're very good at using incomplete sentence structure to obfuscate your missing points.

Rome was relatively accepting of homosexuality during all of it's rising period. Read Catullus, in italian too.
Christianization marked the beginning of the end, or have you forgotten?

by ansugisalas

Nothing about Adler or any other 30's thinker "needs to be properly interpreted and understood". They have been done to death. It is the scientific method; each generation eats it's forebears, then spit them out, defecate, burp - And then there's nothing left of the classics but quotes and wordings.
But Adler is hardly a classic. Even Sigmund Fraud couldn't tolerate him.

by herlizness

<< As it relates to Palin specifically, there is a very distinct possibilty that her candidates will not end up on the winning side ... again, we shall see >>

and we have seen ... the Palin endorsees who won didn't need her support and all of the true looney-tunes went down in flames

by herlizness

<< Why would a person in all-male relationship care whether or not women get fair pay? >>

oh my ... you don't understand the relationship between gay men and women

regarding fair pay and related issues, there's a common quest for social justice

by nicknielsen

The governor's race here in South Carolina was very close, much closer than it should have been given the Republican sweep of other state offices.

Nikki Haley has some very strong negatives, primarily filing taxes late (including business withholding) to the point that liens were issued, but also some conflict-of-interest issues over an undisclosed business contract (she was hired for her "access"). Given that she was running a campaign highlighting her business abilities and pushing legislative transparency, there were some questions. The underwhelming support she received from the SC Republican party and from prominent SC Republicans also spoke loudly to those paying attention. In this case, the Palin endorsement may have actually made a difference. Without it, I think Nikki Haley is sitting at home, wondering where she will get her next job.

by ansugisalas

But I was talking about what would happen if there was no oppression of gay men.
They're still men, after all.
There's lots and lots of right-wing homosexuals, and I wager, almost exclusively male. Just look at the "outing scandals" on the right wing, those people weren't moles trying to infiltrate the enemy, they were pursuing their own ideals despite having to hide their personal preferences while doing it.

A bit like gay people wanting to serve in the US military despite the ban.

Without a "common cause" there'd be even more of them.
Like all-male boards of directors, there are tendencies for things to go too far in certain directions when there are too many too similar perspectives.
And without a history of being marginalized, there's just not a big difference between a gay man's and a straight man's perspectives.

by herlizness

<< In this case, the Palin endorsement may have actually made a difference. Without it, I think Nikki Haley is sitting at home, wondering where she will get her next job >>

fair enough, I guess; I was reacting in large measure to people giving Palin credit for [Gov] Rick Perry's win in Texas, and some others ... which is ridiculous; Palin just didn't matter one way or the other

anyway, time to get beyond the elections; that's all a done deal. tough policy decisions lie ahead

I hope everyone has been following the recent commnentary provided by David Stockman, Reagan's budget director

The short story is that he's been saying in no uncertain terms that cutting ANY taxes at this point in time is pure lunacy and might have disastrous consequences downwind. We've heard that before but when Stockman says it, it should make people take notice. Of course a lot of people don't realize that he told Reagan much of the same but was shouted down. Then again, most people don't realize that Reagan also did a lot of tax-hiking in his first couple of years.

If this tea party movement wants any real credibility they better start asking the really hard questions about budgets and fiscal policy.

by nicknielsen

That endorsement came just before the primary and moved her from last place in the polls to first in the primary. She won the runoff handily. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikki_Haley#2010_campaign_for_Governor

I'm not sure any of the alternatives would have been better choices. All of them jumped out onto the right wing and started spouting "No new taxes" and "Cut government". The problem here in SC is that a few years ago, the legislature passed Act 388 (and Mark Sanford signed it :0 ), which exempted owner-occupied homes from property tax that funds school operations and substituted sales tax. At the same time, they started phasing out sales tax on groceries. (Yes, I know. That's beyond crazy.) The consequences are growing. http://www.postandcourier.com/news/2009/jan/14/s_c_paying_piper_act_tax_cuts68293/

I'm sure most legislators are reasonably intelligent individuals (the ones I've met are), but when they gather in groups at statehouses, they seem to check their intelligence at the door. South Carolina is probably the most egregious example of this; the legislature here is living proof that a committee is the only known form of life with two or more stomachs and no brain.

They don't allocate budget cuts based on need, they just cut everything by a fixed percentage to bring the budget in under receipts. The next round of cuts (I can almost guarantee taxes won't get raised) will cut the backbone out of most state agencies and most likely put public safety at greater risk. http://www.thestate.com/2010/10/31/1537808/fraud-danger-and-dirt-state-letting.html

I don't want it to happen, but I think the only thing that is going to get their heads back on their shoulders is a major public safety incident that causes multiple deaths, but could have been prevented if the agency responsible hadn't been cut to the bone.

edit: corrected Act 388 actions.

This discussion is closed to new replies.