Whenever this subject comes up there's a wave of approval for the concept but rarely appreciation for the enormous difficulties of the task. As a Registered Nurse and Certified Professional in Healthcare Quality, I've been dealing with various attempts to create a score card for about 20 years. The lesson from the well-meant projects is this - you must adjust for the severity of illness of the patient population in a statistically valid manner. Systems such as Atlas and the Maryland Hospital Association's Quality Indicator Project have spent decades attempting this, but despite significant progress there is no widely accepted methodology available.
Biological systems are chaotic, and any score card system must recognize, appropriately scale and validly analyze hundreds of millions of unique variables simultaneously in order to produce a comprehensible number the typical consumer can utilize as a "score". Even if we could, as an earlier post noted, there'd still be the financial determinants that ultimately make quality-based choices impractical as the sole criterion for provider selection.