Global Warming - Fact or Fiction?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by maecuff
take a few aspirin, drink plenty of fluids and read a few chapters of Ann Coulter's latest book and you'll be fine in the morning.
edited to correctly spell aspirin..
Can the fluids be in the form of scotch? (I loved that too!)
Edited to add the following comment:
I've probably posted some of my best "flames" after consuming that particular fluid!
by maecuff
It's more fun that water! I plan on making a pitcher of Mojitos tonight. And when I say 'I' I mean my husband is making it. I'll help drink with the drinking part.
Edited to add: I've made some posts on Friday evenings that I thought were very funny. Saturday morning though, I realized they were just gibberish..
by maecuff
by protiusx
This is exactly the kind of misinformation that I am talking about. You have an idea that to produce power by use of a nuclear power plant takes plutonium (wrong) and produces vast amounts of radioactive waste that is not contained.
If you were to actually take an objective look at the various ways to viably produce mass power you will find that of all the various energy producing systems nuclear power has the lowest waste to unit ratio. This means that there are far more pollutants generated with oil or coal than there are with nuclear power.
Nuclear waste can be dealt with effectively and efficiently due to a new process called vitrification. The problem is that while nuclear power is cleaner and more efficient the oil and coal and gas industries have done a very good job of labeling nuclear as bad and dangerous.
Go back and read my post, just coz I hug trees does mean I'm f'ing stupid
You put your house hold rubbish in a bin, is it dealt with, no it's contained, that what's vitrification is. Its contains the material though not the radiation.
Until we've got some way of disposing of it safely, which is not vitrification and burying it in a third world country or the dropping it on the ocean bed, fission is just damn stupid.
Cheaper my ass any way you seen how much it cost's to decomission a plant ? Course our kids can pay for that so gives one eh ?
As for quantities simple choice 1000 tones of c02 in you atmosphere or 1 kilo of radioactive waste.
Course you could go tree-hugger and pick neither, that would be misinformed though wouldn't it ?
by protiusx
I didn't say your were stupid. I said you are uninformed and are spewing the same leftist propaganda over and over again. Have you ever worked at a nuclear facility? I would guess not. Have I? Why yes! I have and so has my wife who as I have stated before in many different posts worked in nuclear physics until we had children. In anycase your argument makes no sense. You ask if I have ever seen the cost of decomisioning a plant? Yes I have. It is drastically less expensive to run a nuclear power plant than it is to decomission one and I bet if you stop and think about it you will agree with me. The very process of vitrification encapsulates the radioactive material in a thick tube of glass and does contain both alpha and beta forms of radiation.
I choose not to hug trees as they tend to give splinters. Splinters notwithstanding, I do love the glow as they burn in my fire place. Oh my! I guess that is releasing more CO2 into the air too!
by tonythetiger
"What is unnatural? Oil does not expell itself from eth ground"
It's not natural for Antelope steaks to fly off the bone and into the mouths of lions either. The lions used their skills to provide for themselves. Some animals tear foilage from trees for bedding and nesting materials. Are we hunting them down and killing them so they won't damage those precious trees?
Why are those things natural and the things man uses his skills for to provide himeself not?
The point is: There is a group of largely powerless, impotent people use guilt-rendering terms and techniques to try to control those who have some real or imagined advantage over them because they don't have the balls to achieve on their own.
by oz_media
Antelopes being eaten by lions is a pretty natural occurance. I think it is chalked up as natural survival. Nobody gave the lion a gun to kill with and he doesn't hunt for sport.
We can live with teh world's NATURAL occurances such as food for survival, trees for shelter and warmth and yes of course unnatural things like paper etc. even though there is no denial that this practice DOES irreplacable remove our resources because we farm more than we allow the natural reproduction.
this has NOTHING to do with achieving your own advantage. It has everything to do with waste and gluttony.
We can afford to drive cars, we can afford to cut trees, we can afford to fish for our food. We can't afford to ABUSE these resources, as we do on a daily basis.
If eberyone simply reduced or at least paid some attention to reducing their daily waste of resources, we probably wouldnt be in such drie situations. What does it take? personal responsibility that's all.
A cat left with a bowl of food will usually have some food left when you return. they know it is a depletign supply that may not be replenished.
A dog left with a bowl of food will eat until it gets sick and be found starving when you return.
Why act like dogs when we can use a little intelligence and be more resourceful?
by tonythetiger
by maecuff
call me last night and beg me to be her friend. I told her I would, but I just didn't think I could stomach it.
I'll see what I can do. Although, I don't know if I want to, I don't want you to stop posting, I like reading your posts.
by protiusx
From what I have read I believe that the planet is going through a climatic cycle which is as normal as the change of the seasons. The thing that makes it unusual for us is that it takes a very long time for the changes to occur and we live such short lives. Does man have an affect on the environment? It would be ignorant to say that he didn?t. The question is to what degree is this effect and what will the natural systems do to compensate for these effects.
Now I am going to astonish a great many of you and say that I think alternative fuel is a wonderful idea. From an American perspective if we could harness some other fuel source other than oil we will eliminate our dependency on foreign oil. From a conservationist perspective the reduced emitions will allow the air to rid itself of pollutants which in turn will clean up the water supply and so on.
Exxon has just released that for the second quarter in a row the have had record increases in profits (38%) while consumption remains flat over last year. What does that mean? It means that not only did Exxon pass on the greater cost for producing oil but tacked on an additional little something for its share holders. As an avowed capitalist this disturbs me as I believe in Exxon?s right to sell a product and make a profit but when does profit become to much? I am ranting now so I better stop.
by jerome.koch
The event that really got the Athropegenic Global Warming(AGW) Craze going was a series of studies published by paleoclimatologists dubbed MBH98, and MBH99 (after Drs Mann, Bradely, and Hughes).The UNs IPPCC - the group that peer reviews climate studies endorsed MBH98,99 almost overnight. What Mann showed the world was a stable temperature plot for 950 years (the long handle of the Hockey stick. But the last 50 years was a dramatic spike in global temps - the spike on the Hockey Stick). This went completly against setteled science which showed a 500 year warm period (800-1300AD), and a 500 year cold period (1300-1850). Since 1850, we have been warming to the median of the 1000 year average. Mann completely wrote out the Little Ice Age and Medevil Warm Period.
MBH98 was a statistical study of surface temperatures taken from temperature proxies that spanned the last 1000 years. Since we have no way of knowing what temperatures were in the distant past, climate scientists use "proxies". Proxies can be anything that scientists can measure which infer a certain temperature. Tree rings, Ice core samples, certain maritime flora, and human events have all been used to approximate temperatures and temperature trends.
The problem with using proxies is that certain proxies are better than others for a specific region. . Some proxies can only be used in certain areas (ie ice coress or conifers). Climatologists goals are to construct a global trend of surface temperatures regardless of region. Of course, large areas of the globe are covered in oceans, or have had no carbon based life for the last several million years. It is very difficult to construct a proxie history when there are no proxies.
Climate scientists have known early on that they would need to build multiple proxie studies in order to get a decent handle of our climate's history. In order to do this they would need some algorithim or method in which to do multivariate calculations. Soon it became apparent that there were just too many variables in which to do this. No matter how hard they tried, they couldn't reduce thier field equations; there would always be some variables that couldn't be reduced.
This is where statistical analysis came in- or more explicitly, the method of Principle Component Analysis (PCAs). This is the method that MBH9x used to build thier famous Hockey Stick temp chart. MBH98 or the Hoeckey Stick Study wasn't a scientific analysis of our atmosphere in time, but a statistical analysis of data sets (in this case proxy data covering they years 1000-1997). It has nothing to say about CO2 concentrations, global weather circulations, etc... However, he advertised it as such. The world fell for it hook line and sinker.
It took 2 Candadian math gurus to catch this con job. Steve McIntyre, a statistician requested from Dr Mann in 2003 his data sets, algorithims and programming code. Mann refused citing that his info was private. Luckily, he left a FTP site at MIT open and McIntyre was able to recreate Mann's PCAs. Immediatly he found holes in Mann's methodology. No matter what data McIntyre put into his programs, the famous Hockey Stick was recreated. That is, Mann built an algorithim that guarenteed the same results every time reardless of the data. McIntyre published his results in Nature Magazine and all hell broke loose. Finally, late last year Congress ordered the National Academy of Sciences to study MBH98 and McIntyre's critique of it. This National Assessment blew MBH98 out of the water.
Since the National Assessment publication in June, more and more scientists have now openly said what they couldn't say for the last 8 years: There is no Hockey Stick.
by x-marcap
by jamesrl
I'm sorry to break up the love in....
Sure, in terms of consumption of oil per capita, we are worse than the US. In much of America, if you can't afford to heat your home in the winter, you can put on a sweater. In much of Canada, we have a harsher climate. Unheated homes can cause death.
In the summer, I would bet we use less AC than the US, but the gap would be less (factopinguess there).
We tend to drive the same kinds of cars that they do in the US, far different than the UK.
We do have some environmental controls that at one time were much more strict than the US, but suprise suprise, the US has now implemented many controls more strict than ours. Wonders never cease.
We are trying to clean up, with or without Kyoto. The premier of Ontario committed to shutting down al the coal fired generators by 2007. Twice he has had to revise that, and now, who knows when the last one will go. There was one shut down recelty and demolished (Lakeview).
James
by maecuff
by jamesrl
And I have single malt.
Ann Coulter, I'm afraid, doesn't do it for me.
I don't find her manner/attitude pleasant or appealing.
Maybe, in the spirit of the occasion, I could suggest Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks?
James
by maecuff
However, the Ozone depletion mechanism and measurements are a lot simpler than anything in the GW debate and it's a lot less contentious that it is a man-caused issue.
I'm having a bad week with other people screwing up and I decided to growl at you - you can take it and you can't fire me.
We'll never know what the truth is, though, because climate change (which isn't happening, of course) is shortening the year's depletion period (winter) and so the holes aren't as big as they might have been but they're still getting bigger. CFC's continue their activity for decades so it will be the middle of the century before things get better.
The replacements for CFCs are, unfortunately, thousands of time more effective as greenhouse gases that CO2 but you probably won't worry about that!
The holes do sometimes overlap some of New Zealand and Australia and Tierra del Fuego. I don't have any figures about the incidence of skin cancer down there and I don't think it would be relevant anyway since sunbathing habits have changed enormously (slip, slap, slop) in the last thirty years.
Suffice to say that UVB exposure enhances the risk of skin cancer by damaging cells and affecting the immune system and when the ozone layer is thinner, more gets to the surface. You can make up your own mind if you want to strut your stuff on Bondi Beach without a shirt. I don't.
Neil
p.s I have cheered up since I started typing this at work. Harrods, the UK's biggest and most expensive store, have a sale on and I've just done an evening's shop, bough some cheap (relatively) shoes, a print and had a nice free taste of lobster cream pate at about USD75 per pound.
by protiusx
"existing only in imagination," from O.Fr. fantastique, from L.L. phantasticus "imaginary," from Gk. phantastikos "able to imagine,"
Climate change - as I have always understood it and as it is referenced in this country - refers to the period from 1900 to the present and, obviously, extrapolation into the future.
The "hockey stick" graph is pretty irrelevant in this. It's a nice pretty picture to push at the general population I suppose and the IPCC has overdone that in the past but it is rarely or never referenced in any but the most trivial texts.
Wow. You've slain the dragon. Not.
Neil
By the way, only the uninformed and obvious antis call it Global Warming. The terminology now is Climate Change to indicate that some places will get warmer, others get colder and some won't notice. :p
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
This site is very informative and also explains how the hole has increased in size, when it was first recorded, noticed, what are the effects etc.
It also has a link to many other Ozone Hole related websites.
http://www.theozonehole.com/ozoneholehistory.htm
Hope this helps shed a little light on the issue or perhaps provide some answers for you.
Enjoy your weekend, OM
by oz_media
We often agree on similar issues for different reasons that usually don't surface.
We both speak alomst in code so as to invoke thoughts or objections, it keeps TR fun sometimes.
We don't agree on political issues at all, ut every now and then I dig and drive to find SOME common understandin gin what you say. In this case, I concur. As i have ALWAYS stated, I am nto saying Canads government is better than any other. I don't know anyone in ANY country that feels their government is great or even halfway doing 'the right thing'. The reason I blast the US government is because the peopl eof America think the president and the government is the cat's meow. The answer to all things wrong, the world's BEST government and one that only works to see the people of America do better.
This if of course pure crap and it gets me very irritated as it is not at all logicall.
All governments act in their own best interests and for their own monetary and political gain. Not to make life better for anyone but themselves and they are ALL crooked liars, one step worse than a lawyer.
EXCEPT in America, the government is always right, tels the truth while all other governments lie, they are the only one that is democratic or correct in their dealings, and so on. This is again of course, pure and utter crap, and again gets me very irritated because it is not logical.
With that I bid you adieu, and wish you a nice weekend.
by oz_media
"I've probably posted some of my best "flames" after consuming that particular fluid!"
Think abotu that next time you accuse me of smoking too much before posting. I don't smoke these days, haven't for some time now. I also dont bother with TR while at home drinking Scotch, at least I know where the truth sits now.
by oz_media
Max, on teh Scotch scale, that's piss.
I drink it when out and about because it's under $10.00 a double (usually between $7.50 and $8.50 gotta love the cheap house Scotch in BC)
Now if you said you would sip a Glenmorrangie Sherry Wood Finish, I'd blast off a few shots and reply. :)
.....tomorrow, who knows? Whatever it takes to continue the attempt to dupe the population. Perhaps Hot Air is more appropriate.
http://www.floridatoday.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20060728/NEWS01/607280336/1006
One of the problems in this debate is the fringe elements on both sides.
This post's URLs exactly parallels the Intelligent Design debate when ID supporters sieze upon one piece of disputed evidence and then use it to discredit the entire biological science profession. See! See! Evolution isn't true!
So somebody has improved on the data set and a single paper on Atlantic hurricanes is questioned? OK, you've won the debate.
As for "Climate Change", that's what it's been over here because that's what is expected - some bits cooler, some hotter, some wetter and some drier.
You're probably correct, Neil, in pointing out the fringe element on your side of the argument, blaming anything and everything on man-caused global warming, or man-caused climate change, or whatever it's called these days. Some of the fringe element was even blaming the Christmas tsunami on it. However, since I blame nothing on it, does that put me at the fringe on the other side?
I don't doubt that the climate's changing. Why shouldn't it change? It not only changes daily, but the general patterns change dramatically over the years and decades. It's only been doing it for millions of years. Is it hotter in parts of England now-a-days? Well, if you say it is, I suppose you'd know better than I. (But you said it's "expected". I don't understand exactly what point you're making, unless it's mine.) I also hear that it's cooler than usual in Florida. And I also remember reading that the parts of North Africa that are now arid and dry, used to be wet and lush. So what? Things change, and the climate's no exception.
Look at intentional attempts to change the climate, such as cloud seeding. Even though the people actually seeding the clouds might claim it helps with precipitation, it's not documented to be true, nor could it be documented to be true. In fact, in many ski areas in our Rocky Mountains, the ski towns, even today, have played around with such methods, and no conclusions have been drawn. It snows more some winters when they don't do it, and less when they do. My point being is that if we can't conclusively change the climate when we actually try to do it, how on earth are we doing it if we're not trying? (I know, I know, this is when you'll go into your CO2 spiel and the greenhouse affect and all that.) But in my estimation, and from what I've seen, we can no more affect the climate of the earth than we can change the orbit of the moon. If that belief puts me on the fringe, I'm happy to be here.
I'm actually astonished at all the time, money, and efforts that have gone into trying to prove the claim or convince people that such a thing is happening. It's nothing we can realistically wrap our hands around, so to speak, all the while some REAL problems take a back seat. It seems to me, Neil, that people like you consider man-caused global warming, or man-caused climate change, or whatever it's called these days, more of a threat than the proliferation of and the threat of world-wide terrorism. One alleged threat is tantamount to the preverbal pie in the sky. The other is real and measurable and something we see every day. If the efforts that have gone into YOUR cause had been diverted instead to mine, perhaps we really could do something about a REAL threat. How about a world-wide [i]"Kyoto Treaty"[/i] to fight terrorism? Where in the hell is that?
Even if -- and that's a huge if -- we are affecting the climate in an adverse way, it's nothing that can't be tolerated and adapted to today. And all the doom-and-gloom predictions for tomorrow (after we are dead and gone) are so far fetched, that any reasonable person just can't take them seriously. The people of tomorrow will either fix it or adapt, just like we're fixing things or adapting to what's been left to us by the people who fixed things or adapted to what was left for them, and on it goes, back to the beginning of man, whether that beginning was by means of evolution or creation. People will adapt to their environment, just like we've been doing for thousands of years.
The bigger question that's begging to be asked, as it relates to climate change and hurricanes and such, is this. Instead of discussing whether or not Hurricane Kartina, for example, was either caused by or made more severe by human activity, we should be wondering how we got ourselves into a social position in which tens of thousands of people remained sitting on the fat asses, both before and after the storm, waiting for and expecting other people to save them and rebuild their lives. That sort of thing never happened a mere 50, 60 or 70 years ago; and that IS something we CAN measure and we CAN document with 100 percent certainty.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4859980.stm
Seems high enough for me. That's around ?4 billion each. You see, we're stuck on a little island that you can walk across the widest point in a couple of days. Nowhere are we more than a couple of miles from someone's house and nowhere are we more than 20 miles or so from a town or city. Anywhere we bury this stuff there's somebody's ground water. Can we bury it in the Arizona desert, please?
Vitrification is the best idea so far but doesn't contain gamma and the fact that the waste is shoving out alpha and beta indicates that over the hoped-for 20,000 year life of the waste slug the energy absorbed by the glass is almost certainly going to break it down and the whole lot will start to leach out and we've nowhere to run to.
I don't really have a problem with nuclear - especially with the new pebble-bed reactors - but we have to solve the waste problem and we [b]haven't[/b].
Strangely, the UK has six of the world's best 20 sites for tidal barriers. Low-tech, non-polluting and BIG. How many do we have? None? Are we building any? No because it would upset wildfowl and migrating birds.
The English Channel has a twice-daily tide of nearly 20 feet. All that free energy and do we use it? No.
That's why we are planning to bury it 50, 100m down on stable sea beds and why we a pleased that this safe material will sterilise the surrounding area.
Oh seem to have missed out that we have to store this crap above ground in vessels for about 40 years before it can be vitrified. Also skipped off the list 100m3 of only slightly dangerous waste per reactor per year, that we are just going to bury in someones backyard, because we are well aware of the long term non-consequences of such an action.
Each of the individual solutions For dealing with the various types of waste looks almost sane in a certain light, but looked at as a whole and then taking into account potential future volume out kids are going to be living and eating in a toxic dump if the industry gets it's way. Our planet is getting smaller by the day, every one will be next to it if we go down this road and nuclear plants proliferate.
Oh and cease with the leftist crap, green is not anti-capitalism, it's ethical capitalism, if that's not an oxymoron in today's world.
The communist campaign against the nuclear industry was engendered by the USSR in the cold war to slow down efforts in a hi tech industry they didn't have a hope in hell of competing against.
We could have had fusion by now in my opinion, if the oil indutsry had devoted 1% of it's advertising budget to research into it.
Joy's of unethical commerce eh.
is the only answer to fission waste. Some sort of reusable scramjet? spaceplane that won't explode *ever, repeat, ever* on the way up. Whatever the cost, it would be worth it to be able strap rocket boosters onto the waste canisters and head them towards the Sun.
You don't have that sort of technolgy because the US space program was so entirely an expensive political Cold War stunt that there was no money left for research. And no space program once they'd finished.
Until then...Dam the Severn, Dee, Solway and Humber and we have electricity to burn. So what if Weston-Super-Mare get's covered in Bristol's sewage, it's already crap. Stick turbines with 20m blades [b]underwater[/b] in the English Channel - the same technology as wind farms but they don't ruin the view, you get far more energy from moving water compared with air and the tide is guarenteed. Tidal lagoons a few miles across all along the coast with turbines in the walls. The sodding Spaniards can't trawl the crap out of them so we get fish AND electricity.
Ooops, couple of rants there but you get my tidal drift...
I've been saying that sort of thing for years. Figure out a way to send the stuff on a one-way trip to the sun. Hell, I'd even send Oz or Julian as the pilot! (Just kidding, guys.)
And I also agree with your water power solutions. Can water flow produce large amounts of power? I was at Hoover Dam just a couple of months ago, and all those lights in Nevada......? The English Channel? Why don't you guys do it?
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Exothermic reations give off energy in the form of heat. endothermic reactions absorb reactions.
Neil et al. let's start endothermic reations.
by x-marcap
Why bother when you are already making money. Now you already have a fledgling nuclear industry why look at something else.
Now the wind farm is in someone elses backyard, sound.
It's very simple Max, it would make a mess of the next account statement from various vested commercial interests.
Oil prices raise much more and I guarantee every pit that was closed by Thatcher to put those nasty commie miners in the UK out of work will start getting re-opened as they'll be commercially viable again.
Have to pay them a lot more tho as it'll be f'ng dangerous, course you can get round that economics migrants are cheap in europeand and eastern european ones don't like commies. Doulbe win
At least that what this guy is claiming:
http://news.independent.co.uk/environment/article1205975.ece
I'll bet he sends the bill to the USA.
by oz_media
He's Dutch.
But like I said, he'll probably send the U.S. the bill.
Actually, I think in this case, when it comes to saving the planet from imminent destruction, we ought to go dutch. Oh, the irony! Go dutch! Get it?
Let's be clear on this. The Americans can be held responsible for destroying the planet, but the Dutch will get credit for saving it. Thank goodness! (I would say, thank God, but I don't want Neil to have a hissy fit.)
At least I humor myself!
by x-marcap
by tryskadec
by tryskadec
by protiusx
by tonythetiger
by protiusx
by protiusx
by oz_media
You said he's Dutch, like I said; The USA will still take credit for saving the world, for the third time, was to jest at how Americans take credit for saving the world in WWI and WWII, now with Iraq (WWIII ?)why not the ozone layer.
The laff was that if he was to bill the USA, that would be fine, the USA would take credit for it anyway.
So yes, I understand he's Dutch, that doesn't mean the USA won't take credit for saving the world though, that was the humour bit (for others) I guess.
If Canada sent a spaceman up with a giant plug for the ozone hole, it would still be America's doing, somehow, I am sure.
by oz_media
It's common knowledge around the world that America thinks it's saving the world.
What is the kid isn't really drowning and is just happily slashing about in the pool though? Do you still need to send in a lifeguard to pull him out and give him mouth to mouth if he doesn't want/need it? Sure you performed a heroic action, but only you will see it that way.
by oz_media
And I think thats one of teh rare places where most people, even Max and I agree. Th eproblem is, we all have a different measure of what is considered personal responsibility.
Ex. Max feels give nobody anything and if they perish, they perish.
I feel we need to give SOME to people in need and that means we in turn need to give to those who abuse the system.
The same thing goes for personal responsibility with resources though, some people such as myself, feel that each indivudual needs to make a personal (minor) sacrifice and that equates to a lot oin the grand scale.
Others feel that there should be NO use of of said resources at all, while others feel it's up to teh government to stop their misuse and abuse. "If THEY can waste, then so can I" syndrome.
We have no benchmark, we have no common ground. Thats why these issues drag on endlessly with no resolve. Until a common basis for judgement can be decided upon, we will never resolve the issue until too late.
by em dubyah
Well if Al Gore is running around the country saying it's true - IT MUST BE!!!
(NOT)
by geekchic
what we are experiencing is just the earth doing what comes naturally. I think that the earth goes though natural cycles and that these cycles are necessary to help the environment cleanse itself. I know that sounds dumb but like you say, what caused the drastic weather changes in past history if no one was driving cars around, spouting polution into the air from factories or destroying the rain forests.
Yes, I do believe that we need to protect the environment when we can but the earth is going to do what it wants to protect itself! It has in the past and it will continue to so so in the future.
by x-marcap
The cost became 2.00/gal the margin at 8% became $.16 if the rise in cost was from $1.00 to $2.00 the profit margin was 8% but the gross profit increased 100%.
Profit margin is one of the ways stocks are rated.
at 8% they had record profits due to record costs (which always get passed along to the consumer.)
...that I'm obviously being (or attempting to be) funny and sarcastic, and that you are conversing with me, who doesn't fit your description as presented, but you still continue to spew your rhetoric. Get over it, man. Get over it.
Just like the guy who automatically discredits an entire political party because of who they are, instead of challenging the issues they advance, it only goes to show his own bias, not the ones he's targeting.
by tonythetiger
"we should be wondering how we got ourselves into a social position in which tens of thousands of people remained sitting on the fat asses, both before and after the storm, waiting for and expecting other people to save them and rebuild their lives."
It's a logical extension of the "me" generation called the "Me want, you give, or feel guilty that you don't" generation.
.
You global warming advocates often claim that it's a forgone conclusion that there is general consensus within the scientific community that human activity is indeed causing global warming.
1. Define "scientific community" by describing those "scientists" who are both educated and experienced in whatever fields which would qualify them as being a person who can offer an expert opinion -- make that an expert conclusion based on their own findings or the review of other's findings. And, of course, define the field in which those particular scientists work. A nuclear scientist, for example, who works for the Atomic Energy Commission wouldn't qualify.
2. Show me the results of reliable poll conducted by a reliable polling organization which showed that the "scientists" you described above -- and ONLY the scientists you described above -- agreed that human activity was causing global warming, and that concluded there was a "general consensus" among those people that human activity is causing global warming.
3. Define "general consensus". Would that be at least 50 percent of those scientists polled? 60 percent? 76.8 percent? 100 percent? The poll results are necessary to reach this conclusion.
4. And as a matter of full disclosure, who do these "scientists" work for, and who pays their salary and/or provides their means of income?
You continually cite these people and presume to speak for them. How about defining and identifying who they really are?
by davembeer
You are taking 2 unrelated causes mother nature and man to a potential effect of destruction of the planet.
Obviously there is some things that mother nature can do suddenly that bring on catastrophy.
A current mother nature cause example scenario would be the Yellowstone caldora (valcano) going up, that would potentially kill the planet. Of course this has nothing to do with Global Warming. This example is a similar scinario (albeit a larger scale) that what occured in the 19th century.
So what would be man caused ways to destroy the planet.. well
1. nuclear war
2. global warming
well 1. would require an sustained exchange between a 2 superpowers this is now somewhat diminished to a local event now that we won the cold war.
So lets talk about 2. Your statement only stated that Gore misrepersented the science. Well when you try to proove a point you gather information the supports your point and then also recongnize the alternative view. Which is what Gore's movie did.
Meanwhile you just say his misrepresented but did not provide any specifics on what was misrepresented and how it was incorrect.
Then here is why you are an idiot you bring up a totally unrelated thing to quickly conclude that global warming is a bunk.
Dumbass
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending