Go to work during bad weather?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by protiusx
by oz_media
Vancouver is a place of rain, rain and more rain. As soon as it even begins to sprinkle, the ruch hour accidents start all over the place. YOu would THINK that people there would LEARN to drive in the rain, but they don't.
As forsnow and ice, how can OTHER people be a problem? I lived in Richmond, where while racially incorrect, the rules of driving are just avoid the Asians and you'll never have an accident.
People LEARN ho wto avoid OTHER people,don't drive close behind or let people drive close to you, you keep immense disctance between drivers and all is okay. In fact Richmond (The richest part of the mainland excluding the British Properties) is FULL of $80,000 cars, and I mean FULL of them EVERYWHERE and REALLY bad drivers in them. High performance and tight turning radius coupled with an insecure and unsure driver. I know it is very racist to pin it on Asians but in all reality, they have less money and a population that has grown up riding bicycles, NOW they have fast cars.
They say the most popular car in Richmond is the courtesy car :) .
YOu just learn to drive and avoid people.
Now whether or not OTHERS can drive in snow, not brain surgery just common sense, you should be able to rely on public transit or your good old feet for a refreshing winter walk (within reason, maybe an hour or so) to get to work.
by oz_media
I live in a MUCH bigger country than you do and I would walk to work anytime.
Mind you, I would NEVER even consider a 40 mile commute (although it has been FAR greater recently). I would A) Move, B) Find a new job (jobs are jobs), C) take transit!
by ginkga7
In most cases, if you do not show up for work you are in violations of the rules.
That means it is grounds for dismissal or you will be written up and it placed on your record. I can speak from experience that if you take your life in hand, and go to work in order to keep your record clean it doesn?t mean a thing when they decide to lay you off.
Also you are never rewarded for taking that chance when you do go to work. SO?. IT DOES NOT MATTER ..you just don?t count?it is what the big man wants.
by oz_media
I had a job that was a 1hr commute, by public transit (but acceptable due to expensive and limited parking). The skytrain would be down due to track issues but the busses would still take you in, full to the doors and hot as hell. A slow painful drudge into the office, a complete hassel as buss schedules wer off and they would just get there when they could. There would be people left behind to wait indefinitely for the next bus etc. But you STILL made it to work.
When there was a a mere few feet of snow, I would get to the office and greet my secretary (she also took public transit) only to find ALL the people WITH cars were not at work. They would slowly start phoning in one after the other to say the roads were too bad to drive.
In many cases, I lived farther from the office than they did. ONE guy had JUST bought a brand new 4-wheel drive, and called in because it was too snowy!
The world is full on complacent pussies who simply can't make the simplest of changes in thier day to accomodate their employer.
Whimps!
by nd_it
by apotheon
The sky looks a little overcast here (just north of Tampa).
Question: Why does your profile say you're in Georgia? This is the second time I've seen you mention Florida.
by apotheon
by apotheon
If a boss is a slavedriver, employees will usually just do enough to get by and will spend all day watching the clock. If a boss treats his employees with respect and treats them well (while still ensuring they know what he expects of them, performance-wise, in no uncertain terms) they'll probably follow him into Hell if need be. Loyalty from employees comes as a response to loyalty from the employer.
It's not something you can reasonably expect to happen just because you're the one signing the checks.
by protiusx
by apotheon
by apotheon
If your boss decides to open on bad weather days then that Is on them not you.
As far as going In In bad weather It would depend on the condtions and how dangerous It would be for you to get their.
If conditons were so that by drving you wuold be putting you or your family In danger but at the same time your boss told you that If you did not get their or you would be fired after telling him/her I would quit that line of work and go somwhere else.
by protiusx
by protiusx
by kaceyr
I was born and raised in Southern California, I've lived in Virginia and Yokota Japan, and now I live in western Washington (State, not DC).
It's been my experience that drivers in and around Virginia and Washington DC come from all over, and tend to be wary of other drivers when the weather gets bad. This leads to more cautious driving.
In southern California it's more like the drivers are hanging out the window trying to figure out what happened to the sky.
But worse still is western Washington! People here get rain from a drizzle to a flood-creating downpour for 8-10 months of the year. We get icy roads, snow, sleet, random hailstorms, thunder & lightning, torrential downpours,... you name it, we get it. Unfortunately there seems to be this idea that "if I drive fast enough, I'll get there before any of the idiots get on the road".
The only time I don't go into work is when the building is closed. Regardless of the weather. If I have some work that I can perform off-site, great. If I can VPN in, great. Usually neither is available for various reasons, but that's just the way it goes.
My advice is to use your own judgement as to going in or not, and if you don't go in and have no other options, accept that you'll take some kind of hit (a vacation day, sick leave, or even lost pay). That's life.
by protiusx
You should see drivers up here in Seattle. I think all the whacko murderous pinko commie Californians (Myself included although I?m not pink) moved here during the exodus of the 1980?s and now I-5 is a parking lot on most days. People tail-gate which DRIVES ME CRAZY! I keep thinking that it?s my huge Ford F-250 Quad cab extended bed gas guzzling triton V10 that enrages them so they cram there little Coop cars right up on my rear fender. I want to just smash on my brakes but they would probably zoom underneath my truck and smash into the car in front of me and then I would have two insane liberal whackos screaming that they were going to sue me for violating their human rights and over consuming natural resources by driving my truck.
And for those of you who are reading this for the first time. That?s called HUMOR. I do own the truck though. ;o)
by protiusx
by mrafrohead
If it's so bad that you actually aren't able to get anywhere, then don't try to kill yourself just to get to work. After all, it's just a job and there are millions of them out there...
On the other hand, if you just don't want to go in because it's snowed and you wanna play... Don't be upset if your job is handed to someone that wants it more than you do.
If it is really bad, then it's really bad. If not then you're going to have to buck up and deal with it.
by willcomp
Regretfully, I haven't had time to read through all the posts, so may be repeating someone else's comments.
The company I used to work for (not in IT) was a large electric utility and had a similar policy to your employer. They did, however, provide transportation for critical employees that could not get to work in their own vehicles. Non critical employees were allowed to take vacation or personal time. Anyone that tried to come in but couldn't due to blocked or impassable roads was considered to have reported for work.
Conditions here in Mississippi are not much different. We don't have as much ice in the southwest corner where I live as does the nothern part which is similar to conditions in north Texas. But when roads are icy, it is pure hell to get around at all. Even a 4 wheel drive vehicle is not failsafe. Chains are about the only way to get around on our glare ice. For folks not familiar with this stuff, glare ice is rain that freezes after hitting the ground (or trees or anything else) and is slicker than greased owl s**t.
To compound the problem, truckers who "can drive in any weather" jackknife across the major roads, blocking all traffic. Several trucks across the road per mile is not uncommon.
My advice:
Give it a go in rain and snow.
Stay home in icy conditions unless you have a 4 wheel drive or chains or both and roads are not blocked.
Dalton
by oz_media
by jgmclees
by knudsenmj
by joey indolos
There's something wrong with your co-workers, not your company, if they think you should be going in during ANY icy weather. At least your company gives you the option "it is up to you...". However, you didn't state what effect exercising that option would have on your pay or benefits. If any absence, no matter what the weather, is docked from your pay or charged to your available leaves, then that option isn't really much of an option after all.
Here in the Philippines we don't get ice or snow since it's a tropical country, but our main problem is typhoons (hurricanes to you westerners) and their attendant effects -- floods, roads blocked my fallen trees, posts, or debris, and landslides. Companies here rely on official government pronouncements as advised by the weather bureau. If work is officially suspended then, legally speaking, you cannot be considered as absent or on leave.
by whizbang3000
I live in the Atlanta metro area. We have similar weather and driver conditions here as what you describe in Texas, so I understand where you're coming from regarding our fellow travellers on the roads.
However, inclement weather is one of the easiest ways for an employer to differentiate between those who are willing to work vs. those who are looking for excuses not to work.
From your description, it sounds like your employer has left it up to the individual's descretion. If you get out there and discover that the roads are really bad on a particular day, then stay at home. (Or go in a couple of hours late.) But, if every time that you hear on the clock radio that there is a storm, you simply turn off the alarm and sleep in until noon just in case it's bad out there, don't be surprised if you're one of the first to be "downsized" during the lean times.
Since you asked what we do: I drive an hour to work in good weather, and I just modify my route (avoid the side roads where most Atlanta drivers try to make it up icy hills at 5MPH from a complete stop - yes, it's as funny to watch as it sounds) and leave earlier on the icy days. If it's really bad, I'll just be a little late to work, but that's better than a no-show.
by websunny
Your boss has a business to run and has to answer to his clients. Apparently you cannot work from home and your job would be at stake should you stay home. Therefore, the next best thing would be for you to hop on the bus, they are reliable, very safe on ice as they normally run slow, are driven by experienced pros and these days they have their own dedicated lanes which will be a bonus on ice storm days as normally there is a lot of traffic congestion.
Should the bus system not be available because of the severity of the storm would be sufficient reason to justify your absence from work and it would be difficult for your boss to call you up on it.
by apotheon
For long commutes, the bus is often not really much of an option. The bus trip is certainly a "good" idea for shorter commutes, but if you have to go thirty miles or so one way, taking the bus would make your commute take something like two hours. Four hours out of the day just getting to and from work is sort of unacceptable in my book.
Then again, if the job is that important, you should be able to find a place to live that's closer to work.
by oz_media
What was normally a 40 minute commute could be more than 2 hours on a bad snow day, again in a PACKED bus, usually standing room only and all stuffy due to the heater and closed windows. Mch like front row at a concert really.
But I got paid well for the fact that I was reliable and capable. You do what needs to be done to get the job done, not because it is easy of comfortable. What about when you wer younger, haven't you ever worked at some BS position doing grunt work or physical labour, maybe as a teen while all the experienced workers who'd put in their time watched with a coffee in hand? Geez, hopping a bus on a bad day seems like nothing in comparisson to real work.
by willcomp
Your response requires access to a public transit system. Quite appropriate for metropolitan areas but not so for most of the US (and Canada).
To my knowledge, omly one city in my state has public transportation (buses) and they run only within the city limits. That leaves 99% of the state without public transit so it's not an option.
Questioner didn't state whether he was located in an urban area; but if in a smaller city or rural area, public transit is likely not an option.
Dalton
by oz_media
If you live in the boonies and can't get to work, you are not a prime candidate for your employer.
IMO, it is just as much the employees responsibility to get to work as it's the employers responsibility to pay you.
If your employer said you will be paid next week because he can't get to the bank in bad weather, you'd be pretty damn pissed off wouldn't you?
by apotheon
Yeah, I've worked in BS positions doing grunt work, et cetera. I've been in the Army.
I'd rather dig holes for the Army than take a two-hour bus ride to work every day.
by oz_media
I know I'd rather had labour to buses,my point is that you learn to do what you have to do, like it or not. You are hired to do a job, that's why they call it work and not fun time. As a trusted employee of that company you are expected to do whatever possible to get there. Of couse there are days when travel is warned against, but in such a situation even the employer in question here would accept your absence.
It has to be within reason. Taking public transport must be consiedrered within reason.
OM
by apotheon
by vltiii
by michael.r
What you have here is a company policy that?s ambiguous. You now have a pile of killer suggestions from this discussion thread (like "Look for the win-win" from maxwell edison), so why don't you take-up the offer from your CEO and talk to "your immediate supervisor"? Your co-workers can give you their opinion. So What! Management (if they?re capable) will give the company direction.
All the best!
by _nobby_
It's by a guy called Tony Capstick
It's called Capstick comes home
It was released as a kind of Christmas record in the UK when I were a lad, somewhere arround the late 70s - early 80s I guess.
by saphil9
I pay attention to my own driving and don't worry about the other drivers. In my piece of Georgia, there is a tiny bit of ice or snow some years. Sometimes the company is closed, but I used to have to go in anyway as network administrator. These days, Wet or dry, I make it to work. I really have no excuse not to....
I can shell into the server from home. lol Cannot beat the commute time.
by vltiii
One company I worked for was in North Carolina. There they don't often get snow, but sometimes when they do it's heavy, and they don't have the infrastructure to deal with it.
They had a "call list" for each departmental manager. The CEO would make the decision as to whether the weather was too bad to travel in. Then she would call the department heads, and they called their reports, who called their reports. On snowy days, everyone knew to wait until at least 7:30 to see if they had to go in or not, and no one complained if you got in late on a snowy day, because everyone knew that (1) travel was difficult and (2) you waited to be sure you were supposed to come in.
As far as time goes, the standard policy was this: If it was the first day it had happened, nobody got docked; the company absorbed it.
If it was past that, it was a "no pay" day, meaning you either could take no pay, or you could take a vacation day. And, of course, some people had work they could do from home, but in this particular instance that was only about 25% of the company.
by paymeister
I commute 25 miles over back mountain roads. A half-ton of gravel in the bed of a 4x4 pickup helps in snow, but I don't like the momentum on ice!
My wife and I concluded that under ice conditions I could probably limp into work late going the long way over State roads after they salt, and take a room at a nearby motel and get to work the next day as well (their whole place is empty in bad weather, and they'll give $32 rooms for anyone in our company). Seems reasonable for "insurance" - auto, life, and employment.
by oz_media
by apotheon
Generally, I try to go to work. I also live in the Dallas area. I concur that people are CRAZY here in the snow/ice. With me, there is no question about getting paid. I'm a contractor, so if I don't work, I don't get paid.
There are times that I can't get out of my neighborhood. I live at the bottom of a hill, so if there's much ide, I can't get up the hill in any direction.
BUT, it seems like the way you worded it, your policy has some flexibility. And as always, you should discuss things with your supervisor.
Back in '76 or so, I lived in Ohio and we had a blizzard. I worked from 3-11. Waited all day to hear from my supervisor what was up. Tried calling the office and no one answered. Finally called him at home (had to look him up in the book) and asked what was up. Turend out that NO ONE called anyone, so we all assumed that the office was closed. This was a Thursday. Same deal on Friday. Finally thawed out enough on Monday, that we could actually make it in to work.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by apotheon
It was more a generic statement: "All cats are black in the dark".
Of course, there are plenty of people who are a) from here and b) know how to drive in snow (and stay home in ice storms). But I suggest that people who meet either criterion are in the minority.
by sam
by vltiii
In all fairness the employer has to have a way of documenting the employees absence from the work place. The employees employment status (salaried or hourly) also has to be considered. For an hourly employee the option should be simple-time off without pay. For salaried employees it's not quite that simple. I don't know if all salaried positions are equal in the eyes of the law, but in my case as a salaried employee and exempt from the fair labor standards act my pay doesn't change (aside from my annual raise) whether I work 32 hours a week or 60. It wouldn't really be fair for me to not come to work because of weather and still be paid. In this case the only two options are to be charged a vacation day by the employer or the employee can pre-empt this by calling in sick.
With all that being said, I live in Southern California where missing work due to inclement weather is never a good excuse.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by jdclyde
How could you give up that glamorous, fast paced lifestyle for sitting in front of a computer all day?
Don't you miss the constant sex?
I have seen the ski movies, I know what goes on up there!!!!!
(I kill myself sometimes)
by vltiii
by vltiii
.
I'd rather go to work in bad weather, than have to weather bad work.
by vltiii
by vltiii
But, you didn't address the real issue. The CEO of this company stated basically that each employee had to decide for themselves (my interpretation) if it was safe to come to work or not. When an employee decides that it's not safe and you fire them because you think it is, I think you have a legal issue on your hands.
That aside, I'm confident that just firing someone without so much as a warning, counseling, note in personnel file, etc, presents a potential legal issue in itself.
The original poster mentioned that employees were to discuss with management if they had questions, etc. I don't recall reading that he has done so. This discussion would (or should) clarify the policy that the CEO put out.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by apotheon
If you're not willing to live near work, you'll have to contend with the consequences of that, including the problem of having to figure out what to do when inclement weather means you go without pay. Employers should not, of course, be required to build housing, but there may come a time when some employers will have to in order to attract employees, or will have to pay more so that people can afford to live in an already overcrowded area where housing goes for a premium (as is already happening in New York, and has been for years).
No solution is perfect, of course, but I for one won't maintain a long commute through heavy traffic for long. I'll either get a different job or move closer to my place of work. I've done the long-commute thing, and it sucks. Not only that, but long commutes in heavy traffic will (probably) eventually get anyone fired anyway.
by vltiii
by oz_media
I was actually referring directly to a walk to an industrial park what I consider walking distance most would consider a commute.
I USED to work in Vancouver but lived about 60kms round trip from work, enter public transit. It costs nearly $15/day to park in town and takes quite a while to find a spot, even if your own building has parking. That, plus who wants to sit in traffic after a long day when you can read or listen to music and let someone else drive?
As for walking, I HAVE walked from downtown Vancouver to my former home on MANY occasions and in many types of weather, it doesn't kill you.
When I worked in an industrial park, ever longer commute than downtown, I NEVER drove to work, unless the snow was REALLY bad and I knew the buses would be crawling and late.
SO I chose to only drive in REALLY bad weather. If it was TOO extreme,I would take the bus, but even then it was usually quicker to walk than wait for a crowded bus so I'd go partway in by bus(to skip the hills)and walk the last hour an a bit.
The City buses were on strike here for over two months a few years back, I walked to work (IN an industrial park every day).
I was an employee, not only was it MY responsibility to get to work, I took an interest in the company and wanted to be there, so I was.
Yes it is an effory, yes it can be a royal pain in th earse, yes it can take hours and a lot of work, no it isn't fun, but work isn't fun ut is work or else we wouldn't get paid for it.
If someone working for me made an effort and simply couldn't get in, that's fine and dandy.
If my employee started a thread about whether or not they should try going to work in bad weather, they wouldn't need to bother for long.
If you mention walking for even ond hour to most people and they curl up in the fetal position and cry. I am sure some of our vets here can understand that you PUSH to get the job done.
People can't even walk to the damn store these days, we live in a lazy society, who's mentality really doesn't fit nor compliment the workplace anymore.
WHen it comes to military everyone so tough and mighty and normal people could not understand what theu have endured. When it come to walking to work, evreyone starts to cry about it being too far, it's raining, snowing or whatever. What a facade.
by apotheon
I'm a vet. I've had to do a marathon distance in one shot, fully equipped (carrying a substantial percentage of my own body weight on my back). Now that I'm a civilian, I don't have any interest in walking for an hour each way to and from work. Heh.
I like my car.
by vltiii
OK, but none of this changes the fact that your opinion is based on what you do and does not allow for the will/desire of each individual and their own preferences. Because one doesn't want to walk an hour or more to get to work doesn't make them bad, lazy, or whatever other adjective may apply. As stated, we all have differnt motivators. Some like to spend their free time with their families, etc. Walking an hour or more each way to and from work cuts into the amount of free time left in the day after factoring in required sleep time, and time actually spent on the job.
As to the military aspect, I recently retired from the military after 24 years of service and fully understand the work until the job is complete mentality. But the military is also a unique organization with unique demands that don't necessarily transfer to the civilian community. I don't even think it's fair to compare the two.
by oz_media
I think such experiences are exactly what gives you the ability to laugh at such a miniature predicament and get it done. I have been in some very testing situations when I was lerning to climb and be a wilderness junkie. You know you can't just stay where you are until you finally starve, dehydrate and die, so you make it somehow.
Now when I get stranded, stuck, lost or face such issues I always make it from just knowing I am in the city and it is like being a Holiday Inn compared to some situations I've been in.
You can ALWAYS MAKE IT, when you don't it wont matter any more will it?
by apotheon
Yeah, you've got a point there. As an Army vet acquaintance of mine used to say, "After you've been shot at, everything else is just small stuff."
Still . . . I'm almost morally opposed to walking an hour to work, unless work is a life-and-death thing.
by oz_media
Seriously, when you take a LOOOONG walk your mind wanders too. THis can result in the same effect a dream has by airing out the laundry, taking sometime to really analyze issue etc. I would get to work feeling revived, fresh and ready to take on the day.
I find that I still like to take a long walk at some point in the day, just to listen to some music (of my own choice), think a bit and sort things out. It's a good, uninterrupted 'ME' time.
by jrisner
by vltiii
by vltiii
Your colorful description of the navy "Canoe Club" is indicative of your bias against the navy and by extention your inaccurate slant or ignorance of what the policies are. There are certain expectations in the military. It's all part of maintaining good order and discipline which comes in handy when you're on the battlefield and need a cohesive unit to complete a mission. However, none of the navy's policies are intended to be so restrictive that they can't be adjusted for certain circumstances. If you were so dizzy that you could hardly stand up it would be unreasonable to expect you to drive in to work just for an SIQ chit. If you were so dizzy that you could hardly stand up, I doubt that you would be able to drive. The fact that you were able to drive to and from the shipyard tells me that you've exagerated the situation to support your point.
I also did a year at Bath Ironworks (Maine) and I know for a fact that they are tenacious in keeping the roads clear (getting back on topic). I've never seen anything like it, so road hazards are rarely an excuse to not get to work.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by willcomp
Depends on where your place of employment is. I used to work at a nuclear power plant (not in IT) accessible only by narrow rural roads. Nuclear plants are not located in the center of metropolitan areas but rather the exact opposite.
In icy weather, it was not unusual for roads to be blocked by the brave souls who tried and didn't succeed or broken trees. So the rest of us couldn't get there period. Granted, in our mild climate such was an every few years occurrence. But Texas isn't much different (climate wise) and the fools there don't know how to drive in poor conditions either.
Dalton
by gonzonorth60
It's simple. If state authorities declare driving hazardous or advise motorists to stay off the roads, then do so. If you feel justified in not putting yourself (read your life) at risk by venturing out in inclement weather, then that is your call, not the company's. If they decide to dock you a day's pay, you have two options: 1) Grieve it with the your union, State Worker's Comp Board or, 2) chalk it up to taking a day's pay and possibly saving your life by not venturing out in bad weather.
Merry Christmas!
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
Some years back I set out by car in eight inches of overnight
snow at 05:30 for a half-hour drive to the train station. Then a
two-and-a-half hour train journey (with one change) and a mile
walk through what was only a thin dusting of snow at my
destination. I arrived at 09:00 and was virtually the only one
there. By mid-day the dusting of snow had melted but there
were still very few staff in. One guy who lived only a few miles
away stayed off for three days claiming that he was frightened
that the weather would trap him at work.
He and the others were employees who got paid whatever: I was
on a contract being paid by results.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by sexiboi
What the fcuk??? is this discussion for real?
Totally agree with HarryBarracuda: any tolerance of this sort of soft shite attitude is ludicrous.
They are *YOUR* staff after all, you decide the terms and conditions, if this arsehole accepted a job with you, he signed up to come in to work whatever the weather... and deserves to see his P45 dropping through his letterbox with a blunt note telling him not to bother coming in again!!
I can't believe UStatians are so fcuking soft!
Declan Delamere
by sexiboi
Come off it mate!!! are you winding me up??
1.
It is perfectly valid to argue that if others can make it into work, then it is reasonable to come into work.... so this skiving bastard must come in OR HE IS FIRED!
2.
Robin Hood was a criminal.
Declan Delamere
by mdpetrel
Ok, then, according to you, Joe Stalin was the greatest business man in human history...
Come back from hell and be a part of humanity, won't you...
by mdpetrel
... King John was the criminal ....
An unjust law / rule should not be a rule ...
Maybe I need a labotomy so things that are unreasonable won't seem so...????
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending