Discussion Locked

Hack and Tell student quits school, awaits trial.

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.securityfocus.com/brief/829

"
Hack-and-tell student quits school, awaits trial
Published: 2008-09-29

The 20-year-old student that allegedly hacked Carleton University's e-mail system refused last week to agree to penalties and, instead, quit school and now awaits his trial on computer-intrusion charges, according to a local news report.
"

So, I can't support running a security audit without authorization even in a place claiming to be "for higher education" and probably with the normal abismal security practices common among Universities. (mine anyhow)

What caught my interest in this specific report was the following:

"
the university required last week that Moufid admit that he did not alert the school to the problems before distributing the report. Moufid told the Citizen that such an admission would be a lie
"

This seems to be a common knee jerk reaction among companies responding to security researchers even when they do go about the practice ethically. I think the school's demand is unacceptable myself but I admit that I haven't enough of the information to determin what basis they make that demand on. Thoughts?

2 replies

by oh smeg

I would say that the student did it wrong and when the flaw was discovered instead of sending it to the Universities IT Section alone he continued on and sent the Hack to other Students.

This isn't the way that a Professional or one intending to be a Professional behaves. It's obvious by the Kids actions that he was attempting to Big Note Himself and make him look better in the eyes of other students & authorities when all he actually achieved in doing was exposing a possible Security Breach and then informing what effectively was the world to it and how to break in.

He was offered a way out that wouldn't have led to a Felony Conviction that he has to live with for the rest of his life and he refused to accept the terms of that Settlement so he is getting exactly what he deserves.

Of course if he had of discovered this Possible Breach and then sent it onto the University and only acted after the university refused to act to rectify it that would be a different story. But what was done to the guy who developed the Infinite Improbability Drive in HHGTTG is exactly what is happening here as [b]No One Likes a Smart A$$[/b]

Col

by neon samurai

I disagreed with the public posting of the report when I read the first article along with the unathorized tests. In the linked article, the disagreement that caught my eye was the schools demand that he admit to not informing them first. He may have continued to inform other's which was not acceptable but he does apear to have informed them first.

I actually have a friend who lived the myth and had a job offer after University security came to his door and asked him to come over the the campus computer manager's office. He hadn't breach any systems but there was a complain when he found BO on a students machine and tried to notify them and give details on how to remove it.

The Administrator realized that he was detecting and recommending removal not detecting and making use of the already present exploit. This was back in the days before every IT insodent worth reacting to was worth overreacting too.

I guess it also left me more critical of these events when they come up. And I thought the Hack & Tell an interesting topic that no one else seemed to have started yet.

This discussion is closed to new replies.