Hackers, crackers, etc. - treated like heros?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Security
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by stratti79
by avid
by avid
first of all, i have never stolen anything, ever.
we do not have a carpool lane where i live and when i lived in a city that had them i did not use them when driving alone.
yes i have driven over the speed limit, but not in a stolen car.
and littering ? how the hell did you make the leap of breaking into some ones systems or software, a felony by the way, to littering. they can not be compared. if you think they can be compared, then maybe you should lobby for similar fines for hackers. see how far you get. but if you want to continue with the wild analogies, then how about this one. is it okay for a person to break in to your home and take a peek at you and your children while you are asleep ? no. in fact in most states, you have the legal right to shoot them dead. are you going to ask this person if they are just testing your security system or if they are looking for ways to make your home more ergonomic? no. you are going to call the cops or let off a few rounds and ask questions later.
by avid
by apotheon
What do you think open source software is? It's software put together by hackers (in the classic sense of the term, not as misused by popular media) in open collaboration. Something tells me you still aren't quite grasping the fact that the term "hacker" has been most egregiously misused in common parlance.
hacker: http://wombat.doc.ic.ac.uk/foldoc/foldoc.cgi?hacker
cracker: http://wombat.doc.ic.ac.uk/foldoc/foldoc.cgi?cracker
Try to keep them straight.
by 0troy
It's an operating system written by hackers (although most OS's were written by hackers anyways).
You couldn't be any more out of touch if you tried!
by jmgarvin
I'm a self proclaimed hacker. Check out www.greenbranchcommunications.com for an app that I wrote (originally) and it grew into a real app with more than one person coding for it.
Is it bug free? Nope. Is it totally secure? Nope. Does it work as advertised? Yuppers!
by apotheon
Nobody was comparing littering with security cracking, as far as I'm aware. The point is that you can't just make a blanket declaration that all lawbreakers are scum. Littering is in violation of the law, too.
I take even greater exception to your statements, though. Even more than distinguishing between litterers and crackers, I think it's important to recognize that it IS up to us, as citizens of (supposedly) free nations, to determine which laws are good and which are not. That's what voting is supposed to be all about: vetting and determining the disposition of laws. Telling me it's not up to "us" to decide which laws are good and which bad isn't going to make me feel chastised -- just indignant, and dismissive of your ability to make reasonable analyses of your circumstances.
by avid
by apotheon
Here's a gift of a little wisdom for you:
Don't resort to arguments from ridicule. They make you look like an ass.
by 0troy
"look, either you are breaking the law or you aren't. if you are breaking the law you are scum deserving the maximum allowable punishment" - Avid
There is clearly no gray area in your statement. I was merely pointing that out... Scum...
There IS a gray area, and just because you find yourself in it, doesn't mean that everyone else is black and white.
by avid
by apotheon
by avid
by apotheon
by avid
by avid
by apotheon
by avid
by avid
by ron
Maybe you should use the proper terminology then.
If the people you are complaining about are illegal hackers, refer to them as such, not the generic term hacker.
I think most of will agree the 'illegal hacker' that causes damage to other peoples system is wrong, but NOT hackers in general!
by apotheon
Assuming what you say is true, and you truly believe what you say about providing a benefit, why aren't you using your skills through legal methods, such as employment with an AV or security firm? Why check security from the outside for free when you could be doing it from the inside for pay?
Just wondering.
To avoid the use of terms some find confusing, why don't we just start over with one change to the original posting? Mr. Spande, I suspect the wording below is what you originally meant. Please respond if I'm even further out of line than usual.
"IT professionals are fascinated by THOSE WHO WRITE CODE WITH THE INTENT OF BREAKING INTO AND / OR DAMAGING OTHERS' SYSTEMS IN DELIBERATE VIOLATION OF THE LAW. On the one hand, this is interesting coding. On the other hand it makes so many people's work more difficult, takes away from the time people can devote on other aspects of their work. Are we fueling the fire or just getting to understand the enemy? Is this IT's version of the Sopranos?"
Will this help eliminate the linguistic debate?
by 0troy
For those having trouble grasping that there two meanings of the word "hacker".
Doing this could cut the post number in half... =)
by apotheon
You're right: there are two meanings.
1. the correct meaning
2. the incorrect meaning, which usage people to whom the term properly applies often find insulting
by 0troy
Of course hackers work for security firms. I'd wager you know at least one hacker. We don't just sit at home and think of stuff to do. We're productive members of the technology community just as you are.
As for productivity, Linux is an entire operating system that was made entirely by hackers and is free to anyone to contribute.
by techrepublic
I see the whole thing as part of a larger lack of knowledge about property. Cracking or launching virus/trojan/spyware attacks is no different than any other form of attack.
This computer, is owned by me. It is my property, including the wires leading into it, and its hard drive and RAM storage. Crossing over my property line without my permission, or under false pretenses, is the same as trespass, one of the oldest types of law on the books.
It makes me angry that this is view as a "new" crime. But not surprised. The education system raises holywood reporters, not good libertarian thinkers.
by techrepublic
This ability of easily written and modified methods of breaking into someone else's computer, is the fault of the industry itself -- which a long time ago stopped rewarding good code, and instead rewards old-fashioned corporate values like "appearing busy", "meeting deadlines", "formal project management", "coding to hard specs", "resistence to holistic thought", and so on.
We paid people to produce shite code, and they did. Now other people exploit that, new corporate monsters benefit from it, and STILL i don't see fundimental change on the way code-writing is managed.
If I owned a large modern company, we would put a team in place, and build our own from the Kernel up, instead of trying to cut corners, and buy, borrow, and steal the work of others -- including the bad work of others. Then after my company kicked everyone's ass in the market we were in, I'd sell the technology and consulting too. But then, I don't require $5000 to just cover my payments and bills, cause I'm not a corporate automaton. I'm what you call "creative thinker", "Inventor", "Hacker". We always were rare, regularly generate huge wealth for others with our inventions, and usually don't get much recognition till we are dead.
Things are what they are due to billions of stupid decisions being made every day, and re-made the next day. My kind have been almost totally purged from formal IT departments. We say these things and make people "look bad". That is not nice. So I live the punishment of people who are not nice. I live like a monk, think, research, and write every day.
Meanwhile, the biggest moron I went to school with, is spending the oil companies multi-million dollar IT budget on garbage, blaming all the hackers and crackers and spammers for the poor performance of their LAN, WAN, and PC support groups.
by techrepublic
its simple life-cycle. you know nothing, you go to tech school hoping to be taught everything. you either soak it up and make it part of your lifestyle or not. You get your first support job. You mature and life moves on. You go for more technical or more supervisory roles to get more money. You make a lot of money. You decide to consult. You consult for a while. Someone one you consulidates a bunch of consultants into a consulting firm. You join. You make even more money. Company falls apart. You are back in the street. If you are an expert, they want you more than you want them. You pick your projects, charge ridiculous fees, and work to live instead of live to work. Then when you are old and grey, someone makes you an offer you can't refuse, to go and manage a bunch of Microsoft and Linux propagandized kids. Then you die early of poor health.
What is my point? I don't even know. I just know the current system largely sucks, is partly cool, but the end-user-client is still getting crap, and paying more than ever for it, and the IT "professionals" who are in control of most of this, are just as immoral as any frontier profiteer ever was. And all around is horrible code holding it together -- somehow.
by rlutes
there is a saying. You can be right...dead right...stop flogging the cow and realize that on this thread most of us will call hackers/crackers and phreaks the same thing..
I understand what a good programmer is and does. Perhaps you need to go to B- school to learn that Joe executive doesnt give a rats posterior what you call him/her or it.
by ecauthorn
Peter;
You need to grow up and get a life. From the time of Genesis there has been someone attempting to take advantage of another?s weakness, just to cause them misery. It is wining, unprofessional, and na?ve to think otherwise. Our job is to anticipate as much as we can and make sure those holes are blocked, and handle the problems as they are presented. Should you want a hacker proof system, you need to dig a hole in your back yard and bury the computer. Otherwise, anticipate the things you can, and fix the rest of the problems as they arise.
Ed Cauthorn
by avid
look. i am not the one who changed the definition that the general public uses to define hacker. try this link. http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=hacker
it has many definitions from bad golfer to some one who makes furniture with an axe. if you guys are so sensitive about the use of the term, then do something to change it. maybe, in time, there will be a narrower definition of hacker and the bad guys will be named something else. until then i will use the term to describe both groups. perhaps in the future i could add white hat or black hat with my useage to clear up the confusion and try to avoid making anyone feel falsely accused.
by avid
by avid
by ron
The whole concept of 'reverse engineering' being unlawful is so wrong. It should only be unlawful if you are doing it for unlawful reasons.
In Arizona it is legal to carry a gun, as long as you don't use it to break any othe laws. The same should apply to 'reverse engineering' of software!
If the original author can't or won't make the software safer/more usable, then why can't we improve it ourselves for our own use?
If we find a security bug in the process, why can't we advise the author how to fix it?
I have done a lot of 'private patching' in the past, and never done any harm.
Am I a Hacker??
Am I a Bad Person??
by lesko
I think you missed the part about him getting paid to test security from the outside. My company (a government owned corporation) hire firms/individual consultants to hack us from the outside quite frequently. They hack us, they write a report and we pay them.
I think this is what dgenerous1 is in to ... he's a hacker my company needs people like him .. nothing bad with that
by avid
now if you can understand my meaning and don't get too defensive, i will once again restate my point.
did you steal the code or develope it yourself ?
if you developed it yourself, would you be angry if some one hacked it and created a worm for it or used it for something other than intended?
does it have an end user agreement ?
if it does, is it okay if the end user violates it ?
these are my points on all my posts.
if you created this code without copying and pasting someone's copywrited code, then great job.
if all you did was copy someone's code and change a few functions and slap your name on it, then it is wrong.
you do not seem to be the type who would take credit for anyone elses work but your own original work. as for my contributions : i do not now or ever intend to write code. for one i do not have the patience to sit in one spot all day and work on it. i enjoy what i do because of the variety of physical and mental exercise it gives me. also, i enjoy emmence freedom in what i do. one day i am climbing radio towers and install wap's, the next day i am designing a wan for a client. so do not expect to see "avid 2006" any time soon.
by jmgarvin
Thank you. Here is a quick ordered list responding to your points.
1) I developed the code myself (at least the first two iterations, possibly the third, but I honestly don't remeber anymore). The completed product was developed by a number of coders, including me (names are on the website).
2)I'm trying to open source the product (there are issues here beyond my control and I don't own the IP, so I have to wait for those that are the owners of the IP are a little slow to let go, plus there is a whole patent issue that is being resolved)
3) There is no EULA because I am trying to use FLOSS/GPL to get this thing out. The larger problem is that the lawyers want to write the EULA and that would make it draconian and annoy the end user or worse, nobody would contribute once it is open sourced!
4) EULAs are meaningless anyway. They have no teeth no matter what way you slice it. It only angers the legitimite users.
I'm a hacker. I hacked this thing together orginally. IIRC it was a kluge or using Windows Media Player to stream, some open source and generic audio codec, some cheesy network code, and a wrapper to make all the packets come out HTTP.
I hacked this thing together. I've also hacked various other things (like APs) to make them work differently or "better". I've hacked together all kinds of stuff.
I also do security. I do break into things and find holes. I also post these (if found) or write a paper on them. I've written numerous papers and posted a few bugs. My major beef is that crackers (the bad guys) take advantage and use bugs they find rather than report them and move on.
On that note: I noticed this while posting
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5111-6242-26-22893.html?subj=community&part=tr
It is the "Network Administrator's Hacks Pack."
I still believe you can't understand security until you understand how to break security...
by apotheon
A hacker doesn't steal someone else's code and slap his name on it: that's called "plagiarism", not "hacking".
A hacker doesn't destroy others' work: that's called "vandalism", not "hacking".
A hacker doesn't violate contracts (use agreements, et cetera): that's called "fraud", or "breach of contract", not "hacking".
The problem here is that you seem bound and determined to use the term "hacker" to mean "people who do bad things". Those of us who have been called "hacker" (in a good way) tend to take umbrage at that.
by avid
by avid
I did miss that part.
I don't know if I'd hire someone who presents themselves in such an unprofessional fashion. Maybe he comes off better in person, or maybe he's the "talent" and has a partner who handles customer relations.
by avid
1 One who uses programming skills to gain illegal access to a computer network or file
2 a programmer who breaks into computer systems in order to steal or change or destroy information as a form of cyber-terrorism [syn: cyber-terrorist, cyberpunk]
3 (Deprecated) A malicious meddler who tries to discover
sensitive information by poking around. Hence "password
hacker", "network hacker". The correct term is cracker.
not to impune your definitions. i saw them on the same them on the same website that i got these. i only posted these to show how varied the defintions can be. we inthe IT community need to provide more definative terms to the general public so there will be less confusion. after that there will be less ridicule.
i do believe that the original post was referring to the malicious hacker instead of the law abiding hacker.
by bhunsinger
If I buy a copy of a program and then take it apart to see what makes it tick, I don't give a rat's behind about what some lobbiest snuck into a copyright extension bill. Copyrights have exemptions for educational purposes. There is also an exeption for critical reviews. In fact, there is an entire literay culture called deconstructionalism. It's not illegal.It's not even wrong.
Breaking an enduser agreement? That does not make me a criminal or a thief, it puts me in breach of contract in what used to be called a contract of adhesion. That makes me liable for damages in a civil court. Hmm? What damages for taking apart a program on my machine? Can you spell de mimimus? it means-here's a dollar- now go away.
DEconstruting the code to reverse engineer it is, I grant you, a different and more serious matter but that is a copyright infringement only if you distribute or sell the product. That's what software companies sue each other for instead of calling the cops.
If I buy a lock, I need to know how hard it is to break into. Am I supposed to trust the salesman who tells me "it's a good lock, but your not allowed to see how good it is and sign this letter saying we are not responsible for any losses you have because it does work the way I'm telling you it does." ? I want to know how long it takes for someone to bust into it, and that is done by independent testing.
As for unauthorized access, Last week I fired up a customer's laptop in our shop. We do not have a wireless router on our network. Imagine my surprise to see that it was logged into a wireless network. No quetion not so much as mother may I, in. I did not see if I could find a network, but if I had, found thier printer and print a note to them saying just how dumb they are, would I have been wrong? I am not asking about legal here-that is a different thread- but ethics.
If you leave the door to your house ajar, I knock on it, and it opens, do you want to know?
Being able to assess the weak points of any structure, digital or physical with an eye to entering or destroying, is a talent/skill. It is how it is exercised. Some people make a fine living imploding buildings to clear land for new construction.
By the way, I don't do code, its not my bag
by ron
I believe we are talking about 'ethically right or wrong' rather than what some law created by ignorant legislators and interpreted by the old farts on the supreme court says is wrong!
Now, did I do anything ethically wrong?
And what part of the copyright law did I break without redistributing the programs with my changes?
by avid
by avid
by apotheon
[b]jmgarvin:[/b] I've come to the conclusion, having dealt with a lot of hackers and wannabe-hackers, that you can't ever really become a true hacker as long as that's your goal. A hacker isn't someone that wants to "be a hacker". Rather, a hacker, in the purest sense of the term, is just someone that loves to hack. To be a hacker, you do not try: you simply be. People can go from wannabe to true hacker, but it tends to involve a shift from trying to simply doing. That's where the real line of demarcation seems to exist, and it explains the manner in which real hackers tend to look upon wannabe-hackers -- perhaps a little fondly, but with a certain dismissive attitude. This, of course, is because the real hackers have realized that the label is superfluous, and the really important thing is the code.
[b]avid:[/b] The "hackers are crackers" definitions you've provided are corruptions of the terms, and not proper definitinos. Contribute to clarity and accuracy by refraining from using, supporting, propagating, or accepting those definitions as valid, please. I'm sure the original hackers, mainframe jockeys who were also members of a model railroad club together, would thank you for defending their good name.
by apotheon
by apotheon
This definition hasn't changed. There's a vibrant community of hackers ([b]real[/b] hackers), an entire hacker subculture, and a vast sea of hacker-produced software out there. All of us who are at least peripherally a part of that culture are to some extent aggravated, annoyed, or even insulted by your sloppy misuse of the term. How do you think the world's locksmiths would feel if popular media misuse of the term "locksmith" became colloquially synonymous with breaking-and-entering burglars and vandals, many of whom use nothing but a hammer or a shotgun to gain entry?
A hacker is, in short, a skilled enthusiast. Many hackers are professionals, as well. Script kiddies and security crackers are often not hackers at all: they tend to lack either the skill or the enthusiasm, if not both. Stop using terms that describe perfectly ethical, and extremely talented, people to label criminals, vandals, and brainless button-pushers, please.
by spitfed
is like saying that we need vandals to test the structural limits of our Skysrapers / Brigdes / etc...
Unfortunately hackers are here to stay, are needed in the IT sectors that they ironically helped create, and are now therefore a necessary discomfort.
by apotheon
[b]rlutes:[/b] You're beyond help. Perhaps I'll just start referring to all willfully ignorant, peurile sticks in the mud as "rlutes" from now on.
[b]avid:[/b] I [b]am[/b] doing something about it. Specifically, I'm informing you when you're wrong. You're not the only person I've corrected, though you're one of the most obstinate in your refusal to simply start using the term correctly.
There usually isn't much room with my foot already in there.
I didn't say there were two meanings, and I deliberately didn't use the words "hacker" or "cracker". The original poster used both as if they were interchangeable in his mind. I did use the word "confusing" because the working definition (not the dictionary definition) of "hacker" has changed over the years.
For the record, those who intentionally violate the security of others' systems without permission should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, just like any other burglar or thief. Their computers should be confiscated, just like a DUI conviction should result in the confiscation of the automobile. They should not be hired by the industry, anymore than any other criminal should be allowed to profit from book and movie deals.
by apotheon
Further re-reading indicates you are, as usual, correct. I misread your posting as a response to me, not as a response to 0Troy.
I hope the move went well. Still living out of boxes, I presume.
by avid
by jmgarvin
Yes! You are correct. I didn't know quite how to phrase it, but you nailed it.
Too many people think they are hackers when in fact that have very little idea of how to get into the system and uh...break things ;-)
Ok, so *I* mostly break things... ;-)
by jmgarvin
Hacker - Originally, a hacker was someone who made furniture with an axe. In computing slang it is a person who enjoys exploring the details of programmable systems and how to stretch their capabilities, as opposed to most users, who prefer to learn only the minimum necessary. Also, one who programs enthusiastically (even obsessively) or who enjoys programming rather than just theorizing about programming.
www.fas.org/news/reference/probert/PA.HTM
Cracker - A cracker is one who engages in one or more of the following: 1) breaks into a computer system; 2) figures out ways to bypass security or license protection in software; 3) intentionally breaches computer security. Contrary to popular belief, Cracker is not synonymous with Hacker.
practice.findlaw.com/glossary.html
Phreaker - A person who hacks (breaks into) telephone systems to make free long-distance phone calls at someone else's expense.
www.techwriter.co.nz/nerd-ns.html
Script Kiddie - In computing, a script kiddie (occasionally script kitty) is a derogatory term for people who use scripts and programs developed by others for the purpose of compromising computer accounts and files, and for launching attacks on whole computer systems (see DoS). In general, they do not have the ability to write said programs on their own. Such programs have included WinNuke applications and Back Orifice.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Script_kiddie
For real fun check out the jargon file. I know that sometimes words slip out (ok...not so much slip out as I can't control it any more. All my students know the words kluge and borken/borked)
by apotheon
Shall I repeat the old bromide of mothers everywhere?
"If all your friends jumped off a bridge, would you do it too?"
If everyone at all the popular media outlets jumped off bridges (good riddance), would you do it too? Please?
by apotheon
The problem with your answer, avid (that you'll continue to use the term "hacker" because it's what your clients understand) is that they [b]don't[/b] understand it. When you say "hacker", you're obfuscating what's actually happening with a term that doesn't explain anything. You say "hacker", and they think "bad computer person who does things I don't understand". It's a means of getting people to shut up and stop asking questions, not of informing anyone.
If you want them to understand what you're saying, use accurate and precise terms, like "security cracker", or "network intruder", et cetera. This will not only get your point across, even to the technically unfamiliar, but will also be the correct terms. If you're dealing with a [b]real[/b] luddite, you can try dumbing it down even further without obscuring your actual meaning: "computer criminals".
by avid
by ron
Sure, the media started the misuse of the words, but you are an IT Consultant and shuld know better, and not reinforce the derogatory connotation of the term 'hacker'.
I am a system administrator and a hacker and proud of both titles!
The only way to effectivly administrate multiple Windows systems is to hack the available/hidden settings to acomplish what you need to do!
by ron
by tryten
by avid
okay guys. this is my official apology.
to those i may have offended by using insanely generalist definition of "hacker", i am sorry. when i get home tonight, i will write 1000 lines of "hackers are not criminals". of course i will do this in word and probably use cntl-v. or hey maybe i will write a script that will simply write the lines for me. that way i can be on the road to learning to write code, not to say i will ever be as good as hackers are. from now on i will interupt conversations when i hear them use the term hacker incorrectly and correct them. (i wonder how many times i can do that before some one gets mad at me and takes a swing ?) i will inform my clients that hackers are not bad . so please forgive my past generalizations.
sincerely,
avid
by avid
okay guys. this is my official apology.
to those i may have offended by using insanely generalist definition of "hacker", i am sorry. when i get home tonight, i will write 1000 lines of "hackers are not criminals". of course i will do this in word and probably use cntl-v. or hey maybe i will write a script that will simply write the lines for me. that way i can be on the road to learning to write code, not to say i will ever be as good as hackers are. from now on i will interupt conversations when i hear them use the term hacker incorrectly and correct them. (i wonder how many times i can do that before some one gets mad at me and takes a swing ?) i will inform my clients that hackers are not bad . so please forgive my past generalizations.
sincerely,
avid
by ron
Sorry, but I just don't think that these two will ever understand.
Just because you are a hacker doesn't mean you are breaking any laws.
Even though most people think a law is wrong (DMCA for instance) doesn't mean it is that easy to change.
That aside, I feel that if you are breaking a law that is written to improve life for the majority, including speed limits and petty theft, then, yes, you probably are scum, at least to some extent. Fortunatly, the vast majority of "HACKERS" are not doing that!!
BTW: It is not always that easy to get 'definitions' or pronounciations changed to the correct because the people that control these items are about as smart as the RIAA. Their mindset is "We few are perfect and everybody else is wrong!". When I was in school, I was taught that 'zoology' was pronounce 'zo (long o) ology', now all of a sudden it is pronounced 'zoo - ology'. That was the pronounciation that was always taught to be wrong, because it would need to be spelled 'zooology' and letter tripples are not used in the English language!
by ni70
[i]Control your TV and raise your geek factor with TiVo hacks - TechRepublic[/i]
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-22-5842964.html?tag=nl.e124
Legal or illegal?
by jmgarvin
The EULA (while toothless) may say you cannot modify the TiVo. While some EULAs state that if you do modify something, it is all on you and you are no longer supported, some EULAs are draconian and claim they can send you to prision for doing something like this (which is bunk).
Anyway, I suggest MythTV and a Linux box over the TiVo.
by apotheon
No biggie. It was pretty clear that was an unmalicious error of some sort.
Yeah, the move has gone swimmingly so far, and yeah, I'm still "living out of boxes", as 'twere. I'm actually going to have to wait for a paycheck or two before I can get the majority of my stuff shipped up here: move-in costs on the new digs ate up too much of my advance on the relocation reimbursement. I'll just have to sleep on a deluxe air mattress a couple more weeks or so.
by gdoc
OK, first, a hacker is someone that comes up with a different approach, or way of doing something.
The first "Hackers" reprogrammed the MIT PDP to permit faster processing of their batch programs.
A Cracker is someone that is attempting invalid connectivity to your systems.
A Phreaker is someone that is trying to do the same if you are a Telecomm.
There are "white hat" through "black hat" versions of all of the above (with the exemption of the phreaker, though this is concidered "old hat"..yawn).
Folks that overclock their HW are hackers.
There is a whole industry to support these "hackers"
Software "hackers" bypass some of the limitations imposed upon the system through workarounds, and direct mitigation of the OS imposed limitations. Most games use "hacked" code to optimize for different CPU/GPUs.
This leaves the crackers. Can't say that theres a lot of them that are "white hat", but because of the few that are, we can close the holes identified, wherein if they didn't exist we wouldn't even know that the holes were there.
If it weren't for the hackers, the "script kiddies" could be inside your boundry.
I see scans going on constantly against the infrastrucures that I'm responsible for, and having the grey to white sites, allows me to prepare for and mitigate the upcomming challenges.
Hacking has provided the OS vendors with the capability to block most of the scripted attacks (cracks).
If hacking didn't occure at all would we be better off?
I think not, as some of the major advances in high availibility, nor advances in security, would have happened without them.
by el_gazzítò
Crackers are the malicious ones.
Hackers are the ones who are there to "see how it works" and learn from that.
'asta
Gazz.
by beeblevox
Do we all spend that much time on this topic? If so, on which of the undefined facets of the subject. Please note that your hosts are a part of the problem. "Hacking" is a term that was hi-jacked by the techno-illiterate media, many of whom waste your time reporting on the spectacle rather than the useful.
Personally I don't spend anymore time that necessary to ensure that I know what is useful, and I believe that the "community" should encourage the press to employ a more strict set of qualifiers when discussing "hacking" in order that readers might be able to choose the useful over the innuendo. As I recall, the term hack has an interesting reflexive connotation as it relates to the reportering.
Ask the authors to be more specific, so you won't have to waste your time on this supposed cult of personality.
by trading
Let me sum it up for you.
If the world was a perfect place we wouldn't have this discussion.
With this in mind its always going to be a constant struggle between us did you expect anything less in the cyber realm.
Like it or not hackers,crackers and phreaks expose the flaws that we have yet to overcome in our industry not only that but they prevent total control.
Human nature is to abuse power so right or wrong does not exist here just depends on what side of the fence you are on.
A man can be measured by his contribution to the evolution of the human race.
Before you cry foul try understand the curious nature of these people and ask yourself is there anyone out there better to be a tester for your products than someone who can manipulate your hardware/ software like they can.
Take the positives from the negatives and build a stronger industry.
There is a little Hacker Cracker Phreak inside us all this is human nature.
Its how you use or abuse these skills that matter and for those of you who want to waste time arguing the point ask yourself what is echelon's purpose and how is this different from anything mentioned here.
Don't our governments hire hackers for the very reason we are complaining here. There will never be a day without them and i for one applaud it because we all know they bring out the best of us.
Malware geniuses
Couple of years ago, I read a discussion of white hats and black hats, even gray hats. I did not grasp it.
As for computer viruses, it first started with the file viruses. Then came the boot sector viruses, and then macro viruses.
What we have today is mail viruses, sometimes network aware, sometimes not. Not to forget attac vectors like IRC, Instant messaging and malicius web pages.
It seems one author comes up with a brilliant new concept. Then there is a host of followers, who turn out bleak copies of the original. This is to confuse the Anti-virus application.
All this is just a cry of -I am here, Look at me, See me. Just like grafitti. But these doings takes a lot of time for us. And had it not been for these blokes, we would not need bug fixes for the Operating System. Some bots on the other hand are made for stealing.
However I cannot help admiring the author of the MS-DOS file virus 1701 ? Cascade , also called Autumn Leaves. The bad thing of the Payload is you have to reboot. The beautiful thing is, that when it activates, you will see a work of art. The letters will fall one by one to the bottom line and make a heap of characters.
Tribute goes to Dr Alan Solomon, Inventor of the first useful Virus Protection for the IBM PC and compatibles.
Regards
Gunnar Klevedal
Programming education
For educational purposes I suggest a language with strong type control. You should also be forced to declare all your variables explicitly.
The rules for scope of variables, functions and procedures should be clear. It should also be clear what happens when you pass a variable by reference or by value.
Some languages permit you to put a lot of functionality into one line, but I suggest you be a bit more verbose. Type conversions should be out of bounds the first months. The same goes for variant types.
OOP, Object Oriented Programming, is an option only, and I suggest you leave objects and inheritance et cetera out in the beginning
I guess Buffer Overflows are more common in C than in Pascal.
If your code is not self-documenting, do add comments.
Tribute goes to Niklaus Wirth and Borland Corporation.
Regards
Gunnar Klevedal
by jmgarvin
I agree. I think Pascal should be the first language any student learns. Not only is it strongly typed, but it is clear and pretty easy to pick up. C is a little harder (by nature) to pick up and play with. Plus C lets you shoot yourself in the foot without a care in the world. I also have a problem with students following Null Pointers into terror incognito. It seems to be an introductory programmer thing. I explain to them following a null pointer is an exersise in insanity, but it typically falls on deaf ears ;-)
Buffer overflows are VERY common. I don't know what the deal is, but it seems there are either some very messy programmers out there or in some cases they are unavoidable.
What OOP do you like the best? I've been getting more into C# and Java and away from C++ (for the beginner). What do you think?
Many years ago I wished I had a symbolic disassembler. Not today. It is more fun to create your own programmes. There is an abundance of environments for various platforms.
Tribute goes to John Socha, programmer of Norton Commander , ultimate MS-DOS tool
Regards
Gunnar Klevedal
by apotheon
Considering the limited capabilities of VM-based languages like Java and anything .NET, I'm constantly surprised at the popularity of the languages for everything from server applications to beginner programming education. In some ways, they're slick languages that might make learning programming seem "easy", but ultimately I think they do the student a disservice.
For teaching object oriented programming to the beginner, I'd recommend something compiled or interpreted (or some reasonable facsimile thereof), rather than a bytecode/VM language, which combines the worst aspects of both. If your students are already competent procedural programmers, you might think about going with Ruby as an introduction of OOP. It really throws the programmer into the deep end of object oriented methodolgy, but does so without being difficult or obscure. It also allows you to focus on OOP techniques, without having to learn a whole bunch of wacky stuff specific to the language and difficult to grasp.
If you are looking to teach OOP to C programmers, either C++ or Objective C will do. C++ is probably actually not the best language in the world for teaching OOP, but it's prevalent enough that you're at least giving your students something useful in terms of language familiarity, and it was one of the earlier OOP languages. Objective C is a far better language, in and of itself, for teaching OOP, but some might object to it based on its relative lack of popularity. I'd definitely be inclined to push for ObjC over C++, but department heads at universities are highly unlikely to support that decision.
If your students are primarily familiar with Pascal, there's no choice better for teaching OOP to them than migrating to Object Pascal (aka Delphi, the name of the common Borland IDE for Object Pascal). Object Pascal is also available for other platforms than those on which Delphi will run: Kylix and Free Pascal are two tools for working with Object Pascal on Linux, for instance. Kylix comes from the same place as Delphi (Borland), and provides Linux-platform Object Pascal and C++ development that can be Windows cross-platform compatible. Free Pascal is an open source compiler, set of runtime libraries, and pile of extensions for more hackish programmers that prefer the nitty gritty of programming in a text editor and compiling at the command line (or who just don't want to spend money on a "superfluous" bunch of software like an IDE).
Frankly, I'd be inclined to choose Ruby, Objective C, and Object Pascal as the necessary beginning languages for the first two years of schooling in programming, if I was running a CS department somewhere. None of them is anywhere near as popular as C++ or Java, but they're much better suited to education, having fun with programming, and developing good code. They're also all available for free, with no restrictions on use, and provide a simple way to eventually get into the advanced matters of programming since they all have open source compilers/interpreters available and easily accessible.
In terms of further programming instruction, there are also a few other languages to consider:
Perl is a must-have for anyone doing system administration on unix/Linux platforms. If you're teaching unix/Linux, you should be teaching Perl. Period.
C is important for all the obvious reasons. It also provides a lead-in to Objective C in the same way that Pascal does for Object Pascal. C++ isn't as much a natural follow-on from C as you might think, and if you want a clear migration path I'd recommend C to Objective C any day of the week.
Can't forget Lisp. While I haven't really worked with any variant of Lisp much (only touched, very lightly, on Scheme), it seems to be the clear winner for teaching fundamental programming theory by way of practical skill instruction.
by kingbolt
OOPs and object libraries, Ain't got any
I have been programming for school, hobby and leisure. Most often it has been for fun. All code has been different, so I have had no use for reusable objects or DLLs.
When Borland releases DELPHI 1.0 as freeware, I will get it and use it.
Regards
Gunnar Klevedal
by deepsand
The simple fact is that we are all in some manner inately fascinated by the abilities of others when such exceed those of our own desires.
It's called [i]envy[/i].
=================================================
Main Entry: en?vy
Pronunciation: 'en-vE
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural envies
Etymology: Middle English envie, from Old French, from Latin invidia, from invidus envious, from invidEre to look askance at, envy, from in- + vidEre to see -- more at WIT
1 : painful or resentful awareness of an advantage enjoyed by another joined with a desire to possess the same advantage
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending