Discussion Locked

Has libertarianism reached its peak?

0 helpful
141 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The war in Iraq has caused me to divert much of my attention from local issues to international matters.

As I pondered over social mores in various countries ... especially Western democracies ... I realised that we have become to a great extent a dissolute society. Consider things which are now accepted as "normal" such as a high divorce rate, leading to single-parent families; the universal acceptance of homosexuality as "normal," even to the extent of allowing marriage between partners ofthe same sex; the escalating problems of drug abuse and juvenile crime; the "everything's acceptable" attitude expressed in movies and TV series; and so on.

We are seeing fundamentalist religious views gradually replacing the more liberal views to which we have become accustomed.

Is the pendulam starting to swing back to a more conservative overall approach to life?

141 replies

by rickydoo

I agree that we are becoming an "everything's acceptable" society, and worse, it's becoming unacceptable to consider some behaviour unacceptable. Consider the reaction to comments by Canadian member of Parliament Elsie Wayne: "Why do they have to be out here in the public, always debating that they want to call it marriage? Why are they in parades? Why are men dressed up as women on floats? If they are going to live together, go live together and shut up about it." These comments were met bydemands for her resignation, an apology, and outrage for her sheer gall to take a stance on the issue.
Television and Hollywood aren't a symptom of our modified outlook, they seem to be leading the battle when it comes to changing the parameters of"normal lifestyles". Not hard to do when so many of us plop down in front of the TV and soak up the message the second reality isn't demanding our attention.
It's perfectly acceptable to portray suggestive gay sex scenes on broadcast TV, a la "Queer as folk" and "Kink", and it seems all TV shows are required to portray or at least suggest sex somewhere along the line, usually casual, almost always "out of wedlock". The only shows you won't see it in are labelled religious (7th Heaven, Touched by an angel, etc.). When did society switch polarity? One day we have "I love Lucy" and the next we have "I love everybody; You're next".
Disclaimer: I'm agnostic, I'm divorced, I rent the occasional X-rated "comedy". I'm not a prude, I'm just very, very concerned.

Is it really "all good"?

by oldefar

An interesting counter to Julian, who sees a move in the opposite direction.

Now for the $64K question - who is following who? Julian appears to believe liberalism has peeked and a swing to more conservative social values is underway. You reference what appears to be an ever more liberal entertainment industry, in particular TV, and wonder how much further it will go. I have read a number of posts that imply that at least in America, the population is being led by the media.

Seems there is a contradiction some place. Does social change occur first in media, or first in the minds of the people?

by jardinier

As the choice of material presented on commercial television is apparently determined purely by ratings (viewer demands) it is obviously a case of the people leading this particular media.

On the other hand, we must remember that TV Dramas and Soapies are primarily used as escapism, so that while "the people" might want to watch the extreme and the bizarre to escape from the mundaneness; frustration; pain of their actual lives, it does not in any way logically follow that they either wish orintend to live out these fantasies in their own lives.

by rickydoo

I agree that there has been an attempt to swing back to traditional values, but the reaction to this seems to be a concerted effort to shout these "dissenters" down by anyone who has a vested interest in contunued progress of the "new morality". I liken this to a Denial of Service attack. Joe or Josephine Average can attempt to make his/her opinion known, but in the face of an organised attack of hatred and name-calling (bigot, fascist, etc), s/he can only back away in wide-eyed shock. Untilthe silent majority (the soccer mom and the weekend gardener dad) organises as effectively as the special interest groups (I'm not going to name names for fear of reprisal in this thread) and stays strong in the face of reprisal, they don't stand a chance.
The constitutions of Canada and the U.S. protect freedom of expression, but inundating the public with imagery of abberent behaviour was not, in my opinion, the intended purpose. How could the U.S. Founding Fathers have foreseen 500 channels of visual bombardment with seemingly no control over content? I Don't know what is available down south, but in Canada we have a couple of cable channels, Bravo! and Showcase which air standard broadcasts such as Highlander and 3rd Watch, and in the evening show programs such as Kink and Eros, which bypass pornography laws by mixing in commentary, turning S&M and other fetishes, and soft porn in general into "documentaries".

by rickydoo

As for who follows whom (who/who? whom/whom? I dunno), it has been my observation that although television shows are affected to a point by Nielsen ratings et al, the producers and distributors seem to have lots of control over what lives and what dies. There have been many stories (which I can neither confirm nor refute) that tell of programs being cancelled because a network executive didn't like that director or actor. I take these stories and add them into the recipe that is my outlook onlife, and see how the mix tastes. It is getting bitter.
Commercials are getting outrageous. Axe body spray for instance. The gist of the campaign is: spray it on and women will sleep with you at the drop of a hat. Half-naked beauty rolls over the next morning and says "by the way, my names Mandy". Sultry Godess peeks at you under her eyelashes and asks " do you mind if my best friend joins us?" (Heck no!). Good messages for your kids to grow up with?
I believe "to each his own", but if it's illegal to have sex in the park, why is it okay on basic service television?

by jardinier

I have used this ploy to evade the enigma of deciding whether to use the grammatically correct "whom" or the more commonly used "who." [Yes, I actually sweated over that for a while].

Thank you "rickydoo" for elaborating on my over-simplistic statement regarding the degree to which the people control the television media.

In the Bible (1 Timothy 6:10) we read: "For the love of money is the root of all evil." Well of course we are well aware that "the love of a root" is the cause of much evil, whilst "the lust for power" is the cause of really serious evil.

by jardinier

Well of course the Fairfax family and Rupert Murdock are obviously good guys, because they paid my wages when I worked on Sydney dailies.

Now my question is that when these media moguls reach the stage that they already have more money than they could ever spend, what drives them on to control more and more media outlets? Is it actually a lust for power, or do they just enjoy doing the thing that they are best at?

I suspect that Murdoch is actually one of the good guys, in that he startedthe first national newspaper in Oz, "The Australian," which ran at a loss for the first 10 years, and was subsidised by the now defunt "Daily Mirror." However, was Murdoch doing this as a kind of service to the public, or was he looking much furtherinto the future, when owning this now highly regarded newspaper, he could exert more political pressure through his publications?

by jardinier

Now I know first hand that political allegiances and any constant editorial bias come from the top down.

I also know that money rules the amount of content of a publication. First the advertising space is sold, then spaces are left for news itemsand comment according to a fixed ratio in relation to advertising revenue.

And so, as "sex sells," it seems likely that the final publication which reaches the public probably derives from the three types of "evil" I have mentioned earlier: money, sex, and power.

By the way, that naughty Australian who has been found guilty of insider-trading, was a close friend of Kerry Packer (the richest man in Australia) and said that he (Packer) was a very unhappy man.

When Packer's father, Frank Packer controlled the empire, Sydney's "Daly Telegraph" was so biased in favour of the Liberal Party that it was almost a joke. Also, there is no question that Rupert Murdoch, through his publications, helped to get Gough Whitlam elected as Prime Minister, and helped him get out when he realised that Whitlam was going downhill.

by generalist

I suspect that we're assuming that society is monolithic when it isn't.

With that in mind, consider the possibility that a subgroup associated with the media makes a social change because it appears to be the right thing to do. This subgroup, having a higher than average informal influence on the media, moves the 'acceptable behavior' marker a little past what the silent majority accepts.

Over time, the silent majority accepts this as 'normal' making it possible for the original subgroup, or a different one, to move the 'acceptable behavior' marker again.

It doesn't even have to be an overt process. There are lots of people in various subgroups that believe that their viewpoints reflect that of others, even when they are not.As a 'trivial' example, consider the practice of taking office supplies home from work. Some people consider this to be perfectly acceptable behavior, kind of a business 'perk'. Others consider it to be stealing.

Once upon a time you didn't dare 'borrow' office supplies, except by accident. Nowadays it can be a grey zone, condoned by management because it is too expensive to use draconian measures to prevent it.

by qamar

Frankly speaking this topic has enough scope for openning our eyes regarding the moral or otherwise values we as a modern race heading. Human has comparitively talent built for observing, expewrinecing and keep learning from the environment and history. Even then the individulas tend to learn more by their own experience many a times at detructive cost. IRAQ is going through colonization apart from the history of world wars of librations. Sex and other cultural liberalization is also going through the changes well tried earlier before this civilized world. It generally appears the race is destined on a fixed orbits, repeat of path of civilizations.

by ppalij

What you are talking about is progressive cultural and moral decadence. When people stop caring about what others do to themselves and to others then society is fragmenting and it is all about 'me'.
What Hollywood and the media are doing is gradualy breaking down the the framework, rules if you like, that we all live by. Suddenly rules that we take for granted arn't rules any more. I once saw an interview on TV where a man described a TV as having sewer into your living room, then I thought hewas crazy, but now.....?

by thechas

The libertarian philosophy is for MINIMAL government intervention into the lives of the citizens.

This does not mean that anything goes, or that the government should fund a lot of needless programs.

Many libertarians have very conservative ideas and life philosophy. They just want the government to leave everyone alone.

Extreme Liberalism on the other hand can extend that any viewpoint or action should be tolerated by society.
Liberals also call for heavy government intervention in our daily life. Along with a LOT of spending for government programs.

A Libertarian and a Liberal are 2 very different individuals.

Chas

by thechas

As I see it, the swing toward "Traditional Values" by many religious groups is an attempt to hold onto the faithful.

Many western religions tried to be more accommodating and accepting in the late 70's and 80's. The result was a disillusionment of the "core" members of the faith, and a push for even more relaxed rules from the fringes.

Where I live, many 'traditional' congregations are loosing members to the point where they are often forced to merge or dissolve.

At the same time, we have several 'mega-churches' that seam to have no specific rules or faith affiliation.

Many people who left their birth faiths in the 80's and 90's are returning to church since they feel a need for a moral root for their families. Some accept thatthere are differences in what they personally believe and what their church teaches. Others cannot accept the conflict of belief, and search for a church that will NOT preach that what they believe is wrong.

If libertarianism is loosing ground, it is most likely because too many people would rather see rules that increase perceived security rather than preserve personal freedom and liberties.

Chas

by oldefar

First, can we determine if the discussion is about liberalism or libertarianism? The first supports social causes generally sympathetic to the "downtrodden" and "oppressed", typically preferring to do it with government action funded by tax dollars. The second is a political movement that believes the best government is the least government - fewer laws, fewer government workers, less government involvement, and lower taxes. I suspect that the Libertarian Party has lost much of its potentialsupport from disgruntled Republicans in the US due to this confusion in terms.

As for whether the social norm is swinging from liberal to conservative, I think that this comes about more from the aging process than anything else. The baby boomers are now hitting late middle age and early seniority, and their views are becoming more conservative.

Rises in fundamentalist religious beliefs and strict social value groups follow social uncertainty. This occurred during the Great Depression, and to some extent during the current economic slump. Its a search for stability and direction in troubled times. A worrisom trend, since facism also grew out of the hard economic conditions.

by thechas

While the Title says libertarianism, the body of the root post speaks more to liberalism.

I went with the body of the root.

Perhaps Julian will add a post to clear up his intended direction.

Chas

by jardinier

I looked the term up in the dictionary to make sure, and also included in my posting the phrase "a dissolute society" to emphasise my intended meaning.

I find your reference to "Libertarian Party" interesting, in that I once knew a Dutchman who voted "Liberal" in Australia, because he was unaware that our "Liberal Party" is actually our conservative party.

by john_wills

I do not think people usually change churches because the one they are in teaches what they intellectually disbelieve but rather because it teaches what they find uncomfortable. Many Catholics want to practise contraception, or remarry after divorce; they do not think these things right, but a modern Protestant church will not keep on telling them they are wrong. There are also matters like after-service coffee and donuts which attract people, whereas it should be doctrines. We are not such rational animals as we might be. A very odd thing in my experience is a Catholic who became a Zen Buddhist because she wanted a more contemplative life, unaware of the variety of contemplative lifestyles within the Catholic Church. Similarly, John Lennon said of the Maharishi "We've got nothing like it in our culture", unaware of Cassian, Ignatius, Bernard, Elijah... all of whom emphasize the conscious mind rather than wallowing in the subconscious and visceral, which is what many Hindu meditation teachers inculcate.

by oldefar

I wonder how many people change denominations or basic faiths versus those who become agnostic.

I know of very few who moved between Christianity, Muslem, Hindu, Buddist or Jewish faiths. In all cases that I am personally familiar with, the movecame after these individuals had ceased practicing their original faith, and the change came during a point of personal crisis. It appears that each change was made based on a need for faith and an openess with individuals in their new faith to meet their need.

Most individuals I know who move between denominations do so without a formal change. I don't think I know any who "converted" unless it was to meet a marraige requirement. I haven't seen any of these in over twenty years.

by mrafrohead

It's going to get a lot more crazy before it gets better.

I have a funny feeling that we haven't really seen anything yet.

Mrafrohead

BTW - Very good topic!

by richn

It has been said that one can have absolute security or absolute freedom but not at the same time.
The problem is too many people want more of each than they are willing to let the next person have. ie you can do whatever you want as long as it doesn't intrude on my freedom.
I find myself watching the shows on tv that are absolutely terrible for my children. When I realize that they shouldn't be seeing shows with dead bloody bodies lying in the street or shows with talk of sex I turn it off. At that point I loose my freedom to watch what I want to watch. But should I ask government to change the laws or should I simply take more personal responsibility?
by the way I dont even have cable

by oldefar

You are right - freedom and security are opposing positions.

I disagree with your perspective that choosing to turn off a show you do not want your children to see is a loss of freedom. You have a choice, and that is a key element of freedom. Now if those shows were banned because someone else felt no one should see them, that would represent a loss of freedom. This is where some of us have an issue with protective or morality based legislation. Whether I would care to act in a particular way or view particular entertainment or learn particular subjects is less important than having the freedom to choose.

Now where should my freedom end? I believe that my freedom should end when my choice infringes on another persons choice, or puts someone in harms way. I should be able to choose to become intoxicated, but not to put others at risk while intoxicated. I should be able to view pornography, but not to expose others to to it unwillingly. I should be able to follow my religious beliefs, but not impose them others.

by oldefar

The dramas and soap operas tend to reflect what their intended audience wants, and follows their lead. Since they exist primarily from advertising dollars, meeting the demand of the potential audience is natural. A feedback loop exists. Creative and unique expression finds an audience and associated funding difficult and so is an annomally on the air waves.

News programs also receive funding primarily through advertising dollars. Providing the news with a bias towards the beliefs of the intended audience again insures continued existence. Where news is state funded, it is the bias of the sponsor that is most likely reflected.

This supports the views expressed elsewhere that Americans receive a slanted perspective from CNN and the American networks. I suspect the same holds equally true, if with an alternate slant, with the news received by those in other countries. A true unbiased perspective from any news source is unlikely. Or so it seems to me.

by rickydoo

One of the problems with gauging the bias of a news provider is that you can't really guarantee an unbias control group.
Some Americans have written to Canada's CBC news service to thank them for "unbiased coverage of the war in Iraq that they simply cannot get from American news services". This may be true, but considering that it is being reported by a news service in a country which refused to participate in that conflict, how unbiased can it really be? I trust the coverage more than CNN,but I have heard bias in coverage of domestic events in Canada, and can't know for sure if it is not just the opposite end of the pendulum swing.
Media giants which own multiple electronic media outlets have been buying up metropolitan newspapers like a firestorm lately, and many (often unemployed) editors and writers have been complaining of directives from on high steering editorial content towards the viewpoint of their new owners. Are they losing their ability to reports THE FACTS, or just swinging their bias from right to left wing?
Is there such a thing as a "spin-free" news outlet anywhere anymore? I don't know.

by sullyman

Canada?s non-involvement in the Iraq conflict has nothing to do with CBC?s unbiased or biased reporting. CBC has been recognized around the world as a trusted news source for unbiased information regarding international events for decades. Now, that being said reporting on local Canadian events is another story. CBC reporting and editorial usually reflects in the favor of the political powerhouse of the time, and that is the challenge in being a federally funded national broadcaster.

The ?Spin Free? news outlets that you ask about, are the local independent daily, weekly, and monthly papers. If you are looking for ?mostly? unbiased information, turn to your local independent.

by hal 9000

The news is slanted to what the producers think we want to see and is mostly always bad news.

In the UK there was a news service that only broadcast Good News and it was canned in a very short time.

All the comerical stations transmitt contentthat they think we want to see and at the same time will mantain their revenue. But I di understand that we are only getting one mans views from each station {normally the owner as you very rearly see any news that puts their station in a bad light}even when they have lost a case it will not be reported on their channel.

Of course all this changes in a time of war then the stations only transmitt what they consider as correct from their own countries prespective which usually differ vastly depending on which country that you live in.

by oz_media

Colin, I agree 100%! Many people only view local news, and listen to local radio reports. As a result, they are subject to propaganda that is only one step from the Germans dropping flyers from airplanes in WWII. This creates a biased and singlkesided (most often incorrect) view of the world. I have bashed my head against the wall many times reading the one sided and biased (shall we say ignorant) opinions shared in this 'global' forum. I see you have had similar experiences with this site's most notorious leader too. Unfortunately, this same person seems to gether all information and knowledge from the internet, which we all know is jaded and simply one person's point of view. I think if people spent more time exploring other cultures and understanding how they really came about instead of what they are told happened. The world would be a better place. People wouldn't be forced into believing that their country is doing it's best for them, and would be able to form more logfical and accurate opinions based on what really happens in the world.

by thechas

In the US, when you say libertarian, the immediate reference is the libertarian party.

The party is considered to be on the fringe of the political spectrum.

From my CD version of the OED:
Libertarianism: an extreme laissez-faire political philosophy advocating only minimal state intervention in the lives of citizens.
Its adherents believe that private morality is not the state's affair, and that therefore activities such as drug use and prostitution that arguably harm no one but the participants should not be illegal. Libertarianism shares elements with anarchism, although it is generally associated more with the political right (chiefly in the US); it lacks the concern of traditional liberalism with social justice.

So, by the definition, with the current political climate in the world, libertarianism is definitely past it's hay-day.

Far too many people are willing to allow the government to take control of any situation in the name of increased security.

Chas

by jardinier

I visited the site, took the test, and found out that I am a Centrist. This rather pleases me as I like to think that I have a balanced outlook on life.

We have a strange setup in Australia. The Labor Party is actually the party that represents "Liberalism" in that it is the party which introduces legislation to help the disadvantaged, and generally strives to create a more egalitarian society.

The Liberal Party, on the other hands, seems interested only in increasing the gap between the rich and the poor. Most small business people vote Liberal because they believe in the myth that it is the party which supports small business. Actually the Liberal Party appears interested only in supporting the rich, which most definitely does not include small business owners.

Whilst it is popular to say: "The Labor Party is the party that collects tax," in reality it has been shown that the current (Howard) Government has collected more tax than any administration in history.

The Federal Minister for Education, Dr Brendan Nelson, is intent upon introducing legislation that will enable under-qualified students to attend university if they (i.e. their parents) can pay up front. This means that there will be fewer places available for fully qualified high school graduates from poorer families.

by the chalky

Not the love of money. In societies where money never existed, evil still existed. This is proof that Timothy got it wrong in the bible.

The rise of religions throughout the centuries coincided with the demand for expansion. Whilst it is true that despots always call on "their god" in a way that belittles many people?s view of their own religion, if religion did not exist, most of the disputes in the world would never have happened.

Almost all of the religions of the world have claimedto be the foundation for "morality", yet almost all of their leaders/founders have deliberately ignored their own "morality" to a greater or lesser extent.

When society collectively learns that religion is only interested in trying to control them we will have a better society.

What is wrong with single parent families? Marriage was invented by religion to control "morality". My sister has brought her son up wonderfully since she threw out her "religious" husband after he had been beating her up.

Trust is far more important than religion. Because of the diverse religions that exist today and the huge contradictions they have with each other, few people trust the other.

That is the problem with how we live today. Not liberalism. conservatism or any other "ism". Trust people and you will rarely be disappionted. Trust no-one and you will always be right!

by maxwell edison

The first use of "money" can be traced back to around 4000 B.C., long before the writings that later became known as the Old Testament - The Bible - made any appearance.

http://www.mintmark.com/moneyhistory.htm

And before there was, "money", per se, the tool of bartering took different forms.

Moreover, as it (money and/or whatever else) may have been called different things in past civilizations, the translations made in the bible should be taken into account.

by cactus pete

This was my favorite subject in College. Monies have existed in every society, but not necessarily in ways you would recognize from first glance.

Coins, shells, shiny rocks, beads - lots of things can be 'money'.

And on another level, before there were representations of value, there was bartering. It took place in a market, even if there were only two parties at the time.

by john_wills

Jesus said somewhere: You cannot serve God and Mammon. The love of money is a religion, or at least a dedication of the kind we see in religion.

by the chalky

Does that matter today?
You help to illustrate my point by quoting one religious figure of history.
Jesus is reviled by some religions, loved by others, and many other people are completely indifferent to him.
Who really cares what a guy said 2,000 years ago? Only people with their heads in the clouds that do not try and think through today's problems care about the views of someone that may or may not have existed.
Many of today's problems are still caused by religions - of all types.
Some problems are caused by people trying to live up to morals that are imposed on them by others; other problems by people living with the guilt of failing to live up to these morals but trying to hide the fact; even more by people trying to live a life designed by historical organisations that try not to live in the 20th - let alone 21st - century.
Religion has no relevance in modern society. Anyone who disagrees is incapable of providing their own morals.

by john_wills

Webster's Encyclopaedic Unabridged Dictionary of the English Language gives 9 definitions of "religion". Which one are we using here? Catholic Christianity and Zen Buddhism and Vishnaya and Rabbinical Judaism are all religions, so of what category are these all instances? If we take two rather similar religions, like Calvinism and Arminianism, we can find a question the answer to which distinguishes them; what is the question to which the 4 religions in my list above are giving different answers? I rather suspect that the distinction is not in the answers but in the questions: the Christian and the Buddhist do not have different answers to the same question(s) but answers to different questions. If we know what questions are being asked and answered, we can determine Chalky's answers and therefore Chalky's religion.

by john_wills

In the U.S. the word "liberal" is used as an abbreviation for "welfare liberal"; the liberal movement in the U.S. was the same as the liberal movement elsewhere, i.e. free enterprise, etc., but there was a split over the amount of state interventionthere should be for people down on their luck and so forth; the anti-welfare side got renamed "conservatism". Libertarianism, at least in the economic sense, is extreme liberalism, more or less as communism is extreme socialism and fascism is extreme... what?

by maxwell edison

... are similar inasmuch as both are at the extreme socialist end of the political spectrum, but with a couple of distinct differences.

Communism involves state "owned" business, while fascism involves privately owned, but state "controlled" business.

Communism is more global in the desired scope, while fascism is more nationalistic in nature.

It's a very common misconception that communism is on the extreme left and fascism is on the extreme right. This is not true at all, as both are just different forms of the extreme left. The extreme right would be anarchy.

by thechas

Hi Max,

Not to disagree.

In my high school government class, Fascism was described as an extreme Right Wind philosophy.

At the same time, the instructor did point out that rather than a line, the political spectrum should be look at as an incomplete ellipse with a very small gap between the extreme left and extreme right.

His worst fear was that the extremes would someday realize that their goals were the same, and join together.

Chas

by oldefar

Consider the various systems as a circle rather than as a line. Anarchy is one extreme. Dictatorship is the other, 180 degrees away. Left and right leaning approaches are on one or the other arc between 0 and 180. Both communism and facism come close to the dictatorship, but from opposite directions.

by mallardtooxx

You have to remember that Anarchy is in all actuality the first step to a Utopian society. Until there is a total social reversal of personal government there is no way for all people to truly be equal. This is where it gets gray, if the extreme opposite of Fascism/Communism is Anarchy then where is the middle ground. I have never heard of a moderate anarchist. I am just curious because I think that in the future, far far into the future the race as a whole will look back at the last two centuries as a return to the dark ages. Our current social morays are not at all in line with our own desires nor are they conducive to furthering the species for any real practicality. That being said I find my statement contrary to my personal beliefs. How is this possible? Because when it all boils out in the end you are left with one unifying crust, we are all human and that is about it.

I know this seems like drivel but re read it and you will see it. There is really nothing that binds us as a society except the fact that we are on the top. If there were some super predator that came along and took over then everything we are doing now would stop. That is why I say what I say, there is no unifying context, no great cause to concentrate on, just the propagation of a species that rules through superior numbers and a little better intellect or so we think.

I ask this; if Humans are so superior to any other creature, why can?t I speak dolphin?

-duck
I am not as off topic as it may first seem on this one.

by thechas

Another factor to take into account in your walks like a duck test, is who benefits.

Communism as practiced by the USSR (as opposed to Marx' ideal) is not very liberal, and could perhaps be considered right wing, as the people actually worked forthe benefit of the ruling class.

In most all fascist states, the people work for the benefit of the rulers.

Just a thought,

Chas

by oldefar

In my opinion, independent news sources have their own type of bias. In order to differentiate their perspective from that of the media conglomerates they tend to have a consistent anti-establishment slant. If the commercial news stations are reporting a topic in a positive light, they take a negative light. Strangely, is the at large reporting is a bit negative, the independents go further with a negative angle.

Regarding CBC, this must be a change. I grew up watching CBC, ABC, NBC, andCBS since these were the only stations we had. I never noticed a difference in the CBC slant on world news, only sports and local content. I saw a greater difference in the papers - Detroit Free Press versus Detroit News. Of course, that was in the 60's and again in the 80's. The BBC was then considered the paragon of unbiased reporting, but what I saw during the 70's did not strike me as particulary less or more biased than US news sources.

by maxwell edison

...that both theories are correct?

Fascism is considered extreme right wing because of its roots in extreme nationalism.

Fascism is considered left wing because of its socialistic idea that the State, acting on behalf of "the people," is the source of all rights.

If you read all accounts of fascism, you'll see that it is packed with contradictions. Benito Mussolini is considered the father of modern fascism, and he created it out of an originally socialistic state.

If you use "liberty" as the gauge (less individual liberty to the left, more individual liberty to the right), it would belong on the extreme left. That's the benchmark I was using. (Not to suggest that it's correct and anything else is wrong. I guess I don't really know for sure, but I've read accounts for either argument.)

Do an Internet serach of left wing fascism, and it makes for some interesting reading. (Sure, you'll find plenty of sources for right wing fascism as well, so which is right - er, uhI mean, which is correct?)

So what is the correct gauge to use, nationalism or individual freedom - or something else? I guess that's why it's rather confusing. (Now I'm really confused.)

by maxwell edison

Quotes from the article:

"Ask most left-wingers and they'll suggest that fascism is on the extreme right -- 180 degrees from communism. Unh-uh. I've got news for you, friends. Fascism and communism are ideological kissin' cousins. I would place fascism and any other brand of socialism just a few degrees to the right of communism."

"Remember, both fascism and socialism mean -- to one degree or another -- government control of production and distribution. The only thing that distinguishes fascism from socialism in economic theory is how they get that control and how they maintain it."

Here's a link to the whole article:

http://tinyurl.com/blow

So in the context of how we (today in the U.S.) define the differences between left wing and right wing, such as more or less government control, and/or more or less individual liberties, and/or from whom power is granted (granted by the government or granted by the individual), I'll stick to my assertion that fascism is extreme left wing. (Give it the "duck" test. If it walks like a duck, etc.)

by oldefar

When I posted the comment on biased news media, which Colin was agreeing with in his post, I had you in mind. Not from your technical postings, but from your recent discussions on world affairs and your poorly conceived experiment.

"Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but don't consider the beam that is in your own eye?". Matthew Chapter 7

by jardinier

Does anyone think that the people who drafted the First Amendment to the US Constitution could possibly have foreseen the Pandora's Box which they were in effect opening?

by maxwell edison

In 1821, former President James Madison, who is considered the father of the U.S. Constitution, wrote, "A popular Government without popular information or the means of acquiring it, is but a Prologue to a Farce or a Tragedy or perhaps both. Knowledge will forever govern ignorance, and a people who mean to be their own Governors, must arm themselves with the power knowledge gives."

by john_wills

Madison may well have been the father of the second constitution of the U.S., but that constitution did not originally include a bill of rights(although there are rights details embedded in it). Who is the father of the Bill of Rights? It seems a bit of a hodge-podge, and the First Amendment itself covers several subjects. The Bill of Rights in the German Basic Law - http://www.datenschutz-berlin.de/recht/de/gg/ - is much better constructed, partly, of course, because the framers had the U.S. experience to consider.

by maxwell edison

It does seems that over the last few moths there have been quite a number of off topic threads, and the question of appropriateness has come up a few times. Personally, I have mixed feelings about it. I too have thought that it's gone a bit too far,but then I'm not the one to make such a determination. If the folks at TR think so, they could certainly say as much, which they haven't. In addition, I'm sure they could just make these threads magically disappear. They haven't done that either.Are some TR members, as you put it, "sitting on the bench"? I guess you mean that our intended focus is diverted - the focus of being involved in technical discussions and answering questions. Well, maybe yes, maybe no. I'll still answer the occasional question, albeit not nearly as many as I have in the past. And I'll join in on a technical discussion if it catches my interest. (I even started a technical discussion not too long ago - Dell versus build your own.) And I've seen others continue answering questions as well.

Look at the folks who participate in these off-topic threads. Most of them have over 10,000 tech points - a couple are on the top 5 scorers list. These people have contributed sooooo much to TechRepublic, that the ideaof taking a few liberties with the functionality of the site might be an appropriate payback. Moreover, considering the fact that most of these contributors have a billable rate close to or over $100 per hour, TechRepublic has received a gold mine in free technical consultations. They haven't paid me a dime, for example, for the scores of hours I've spent helping others with their technical problems. (If they've paid others, we need to talk.)

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

Moreover, what is it that really drives the profitability of TR? Is it the free contributions made by the members, or is it the number of overall hits and visits the site gets, regardless of the content?

Sure, some folks are playing some games, so to speak, in someone else's yard. But the owner of the yard is watching and hasn't asked anyone (that I know of) to stop. Moreover, the people "playing" in TR's yard are the ones who've planted and continue to plant the seeds that make the yard what it is. TR may not be too thrilled about it, but they sure don't want their free consultants to take their toys and find a new yard to play in.

I think that the worst thing that's come out of these off-topic threads is the viciousness and hate that's resulted. These seem to stir one's passion much more than a failing hard drive, and the slams and insults that result are really sad. I've never heard anyone called an idiot (or worse) because they had a disagreement over partitioning a hard drive. But have a disagreement over politics, and look out, the insults start flying.

I think this will pass, and that's it's just a well needed - and well deserved - diversion.

by oldefar

In the US, there are close to a million IT professionals "on the bench". Some unemployed, more underemployed. Are you recruiting?

The topic is Miscellaneous, and this certainly fits. The invitation for Discussion is to start a discussion aboutany topic, and this fits as well.

For the IT professional, this type of topic offers some valuable insights. Consider the Support Contact Center with an international client base and a focus on friendly, personal service. This type of discussion provided some insight to client perceptions. Perhaps those calls from America should not be routed to Yvette this month. Consider the IT consultant from Australia about meet in Singapore with a client and his client's boss from home office in Toronto. Will that joke about George W go over well? Consider the UK application developers about to seek venture capital from a California investment firm. What are the hot buttons this week? Do you brush up on the new California law regarding security? Do you lead with how your application addresses the requirement?

Sometimes you have to move a lot of clay to find those diamonds.

by the chalky

Your premise that people change "based on a need for faith" is one of the most insulting ideas to people capable of managing their lives without resorting to an external organisation.
When people have personal crises they need support. This support would be far better offered as a friend, neighbour or relative rather than convincing them of the "need for faith".
We don't need faith. All it does is create conflict because of the strange idea that "my faith is better than your faith".
Religion carries on the politics of the school yard.

by oldefar

My statement was made in a particular context - in reference to observations of those I have known to change. In this context, the "need for faith" may also be read as "their need for faith".

I wonder if your particular position might also represent a faith. Those I referred to were seeking strength and solace in the concept of an entity greater than themselves. You seem to propose the same, with that entity being a community of man. Add a set of guidelines, and it could easily become a religion.

by rickydoo

Is this not a faith labelled as "Humanism"? I have heard this before, and I think I may ascribe to it. Quoting from "What is Humanism?" by Frederick Edwords :
"Modern Humanism, also called Naturalistic Humanism, Scien- tific Humanism, Ethical Humanism and Democratic Humanism is defined by one of its leading proponents, Corliss Lamont, as "a naturalistic philosophy that rejects all supernaturalism and relies primarily upon reason and science, democracy and human compassion." Modern Humanismhas a dual origin, both secular and religious, and these constitute its sub-categories."
http://www.jcn.com/humanism.html

You piqued my interest, so I had to look it up... a Google search found 289,000 references.

by thechas

The human mind is pre-wired to have a need to believe in a higher power and purpose to our lives.

Yes, many individuals can function well without any religious belief or faith. But, not everyone.

I also agree that religious intolerance is at the core of many of the worlds problems.

That said, one needs to only look at the surge in church attendance in the US after the World Trade Center attack to see that the average person needs to believe in a higher power and that their life on earth is preparation for a future existence on a higher plane.

Throughout all of recorded history, the population turns to their religious leaders in ANY time of crisis.

In the US, many families are returning to religion to fill the moral void from the liberalized education system.

Chas

by the chalky

The human mind is enormously suggestive. Given the centuries of indoctrination pushed by the religions of the world, it is not surprising that you fall for the view that the human mind is "pre-wired". Fortunately there are enough people in the world that challenge the brainwashing that religion has carried out to prove that the mind is limited by religion and opened by questioning.
You should remember that it is not just the US that exists in this world. There are far more people not of theUS than there are in the US. Many families turn to religion because they suffer from the indoctrination of the centuries and believe that religion can fill this moral void. The void is nothing to do with liberalism or libertarianism, but everything to do with the lack of trust that people show in each other.
Oldefar suggest that my views could be the basis for another religion - he misunderstands that trust needs no rules. Religion does. As long as we keep convincing people that their lives need guidance, the arguments about the isms will go on.
Let's face it; if people actually trusted each other, there would be no need for the number of guns that are in possession in your country - sadly becoming reflected in mine also.
If libertarianism/liberalism means more guns in the world, then I?m against it. If conservatism means more guns in the world, I?m against that too. Teach (preach even?) trust and the isms will disappear.

by maxwell edison

I'm sure no a political scientist, but I disagree with that last comment. I too had the same misconception for a long time, until I really thought about it.

The support for my suggestion is already posted, so I won't repeat it, and no supporting argument has been made to the contrary. (Other than just saying it's so.) Care to support it?

Remember the duck test? Is this (whatever) ideology left or right? Describe the characteristics of a certain ideology (not the name of the ideology) and where does it fall?

It's walking and quacking just like a duck, so how can it be called an eagle?

by oldefar

My post was made before reading yours Max. I read the reference. I don't see the disagreement. We both state communism and facism are very close to each other. Farah focused on the economics of the political systems.

Anarchy, the lack of any government, would either have to operate as free enterprise economically, or it would have to embrace no ownership or full common ownership of any resource. Farah avoids this conundrum by ignoring it.

Perhaps the answer is to look at the spectrumback as a line, based on resource control. At the center are communism (state ownership, state control) and facism (private ownership, state control) and the move left and right is based on control.

by hal 9000

It is not the fault of any religion in particular for the way man carries on but it is the fault of some religious leaders who encourage this behavour. But they are not truelly representing their religions they are simply attempting to strengthen, broaden their own power base which is not what religion is susposed to be about in the first place.

The problem here is not so much the various religions but the people who control them you can take any religion it doesn't matter which one as they all are susposed to promote peace and harmony with all but it is the leaders of these religions who pervert the religion to suit their own ends often at the expence of the personal freedoms of their followers and others who they try to subdergate.All the problems that are atributed to religions are not the direct fault of the rligion but of the people {mostly men} who administer them.

by the chalky

One of the major failings of all religions is that they profess to know "The Truth". I profess to know no such thing, but reserve the right to question everything. Religions - all of them - stop the questioning and indoctrinate. That is their hidden purpose.
A truism of human interaction is that telling someone they are "wrong" will more likely reinforce their own belief they are correct. Whether I am right or wrong is irrelevant. Other than telling me that I am wrong, what you state absolutely reinforces my point about all religions, which is that they are all controlled by humans who have their own agenda. The agenda of all religions is control. They almost always dress it up as ?enlightenment?. But the enlightenment is strictlycontrolled. If you start questioning their interpretation of ?The Truth? you are not fit to be in the religion.
The problem with all religions is that people are involved. End of ?The truth?.

by maxwell edison

...that you are just baiting everyone and leading them on with your messages.

They are full of contradictions and double-standards. If you really believed everything you've said, then you wouldn't have said most of it.

Personally, I'm taking your messages with a grain of salt - in fact, pass the salt shaker - no, come to think of it, where's the nearest salt mine?

by john_wills

If there are ten political questions and two possible answers for each of them we cn construct 1024 political ideologies, so almost any classification we make of ideologies has be an approximation. Concentrating on the economic aspects of politics we have 3 corners: capitalism, embraced by libertarians and liberals (economic sense), in which control is by owners distinct from the people as a whole or the workers; collectivism, embraced by communists and socialists, in which control is by the state (or, in variants, the consumers or the workers); corporatism, embraced by fascists and perhaps integralists, in which control is within each occupational group via guilds, which comprise all levels of control within the individual enterprises. Ananarchist is someone who has fallen off the political table, saying we don't need government at all(all three need some kind of government, with varying theories of its function); in practice we need to know what corner of the table the anarchist fell off. In reality all economies have some kind of mixture: in the U.S. the helium industry is collectivist, the sugar industry is corporatist and the software industry is capitalist.

by john_wills

Every Easter for the past five years I have seen adults make a public profession of faith after some months of instruction in their new faith. Most of these people either were already married or remained single after the conversion. Formal conversions do happen, and not just for social reasons like marriage.

by john_wills

Most people are incapable of providing their own morals; their consciences are unformed; note that "conscience" includes the same root as "science": conscience depends on what we know. And the quotation of Jesus is not because he is an authority figure but because that particular thing he said has relevance to the discussion. As for learning from what someone said 2000 years ago, is it not a little foolish to try to construct ones own weltanschauung without observing what others have constructed? Should I write every program as though none had been written before?

by the chalky

The academia of this world has always lived by the statement "Most people are incapable..." This is intellectual snobbery at it's worst and continues the theme of religions throughout history telling people they are not good enough. If religions were interested in improving people, they would tell people that they are better than they are - after all you don't build someone up by knocking them down.
Being disingenuous comes in your analogy of writing the program. My analogy would be that you don't write code from scratch when you have Development Tools to do the job quicker. Jesus - if he existed - is quoted as having said many interesting things that modern beliefs have been built upon. Like computer tools, much of what has been quoted in the past has been discarded. Human interaction is not built on absolutes like ones and zeros, however many interesting thing sin computers have been discarded as well.
It is time humans discarded religion and trusted themselves.

by john_wills

"It is time humans discarded religion and trusted themselves". In the Mahaparinivanasutra Gotama says "You must be your own gods", and Gn 22, as I understand it - see my book Albatross 0-595-19418-4 - also rejects the gods of the subconsious mind infavour of what can be worked out consciously, which happens, in the case of Abraham, to include a transcendent God. We have various subrational reasons to believe in one or other kind of religion, but on conscious examination we find that some of what we had accepted holds water, and we can put that in a greater context. Please see my thread on comparative religion.

by jimhm

If you mean that liberalism is dieing a hard and fast death - Yes. That the media has awoken to the fact that 80% of the us is Conserative - Yes. That CNN is down to 19% of the viewing public and Fox is upwards of over 40% - Yes ...

If you are defining libertarianism as a person who upholds the principles of absolute and unrestricted "liberty" especially of thought and action... the Yes .

If you mean that we are pulling away from the liberal leftest - Yes. If you mean liberalism is dieing- Yes

But not fast enough...

My question is why should any government care if two women or two men or two different races get married (at one time marrying outside your race was illegal) or that someone pays for sex with cash rather than DMD (dinner, movie and drinks - legal to get it that way still spend a few hundred).

But anything to extreme can be hardful - if not careful this to can be a problem as liberalism is How do you know Liberalism has gone to far - When your biggest problem on college campus is the name of the mascotte (Minutemen is a bad thing??? Redskins??? Cowboys??? Cosacks??? - Get a life)..

by hal 9000

It is not the fault of any religion in particular for the way man carries on but it is the fault of some religious leaders who encourage this behavour. But they are not truelly representing their religions they are simply attempting to strengthen, broaden their own power base which is not what religion is susposed to be about in the first place.

The problem here is not so much the various religions but the people who control them you can take any religion it doesn't matter which one as they all are susposed to promote peace and harmony with all but it is the leaders of these religions who pervert the religion to suit their own ends often at the expence of the personal freedoms of their followers and others who they try to subdergate.All the problems that are atributed to religions are not the direct fault of the religion but of the people {mostly men} who administer them.

by oz_media

"Why do you see the speck that is in your brother's eye, but don't consider the beam that is in your own eye?". Matthew Chapter 7

Now you're going to bring religion into the discussions to? That's bound to get a rise out of people. As for myself, I will not participate in a religious discussion, as long as people have faith of some kind, even if just in themselves, that is commendable but it doesn't belong here.

As for the rest of your post, perhapse you could just get to the point. ifyou think I'm an a-hole, whatever, just tell everybody so you can get it out of your system and we can move on with a smile.

by maxwell edison

...the first 10 amendments to the Constitution.

In theory, the government had (and has) NO power whatsoever except those powers granted to it by the people, and as those same powers were explicitly stated in the Constitution. However, in the course of debate, there were those who insisted that certain "individual" rights be spelled out. Thus, the first 10 amendments - The Bill of Rights - was created.

Unlike other nations of the day, nations where the "government" granted certain rights to the citizens, the U.S, Constitution was reversed. If the citizens didn't grant a particular power to the government, it remained in the hands of the individual (or the state). This is clearly articulated in the 10th amendment, which I consider the most important. (Because if the people have the right to grant power to the government, they also have the power to take it away.)

Tenth:

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, arereserved to the states respectively, or to the people.

George Mason, by the way, is considered the father of the Bill of Rights, as he was the one who primarily drafted those first ten amendments and he led the debate in getting them included.

by cactus pete

When do you do all the work yourself? When you consider it easy, enjoyable, preferred somehow.

When do you allow help from others? When you need it, and think what is offered can aid you.

When do you pay someone to do this for you? When it's REALLY important, and you need assurances that things will be done right...

Take that and apply it to people's need for religious communities.

by the chalky

Are you really suggesting that people are so insecure that they need to pay for religion in this life so that they are guaranteed a place in the next?
Haven't you heard of the old saying, "If you want something done properly, do it yourself."

by cactus pete

I meant exactly what I said.

Here, I'll narrow it down - just for you:

Some people have different priorities, different needs, than others. It is advantageous to allow others to help sometimes. Sometimes you need professional help.

How doreligions exist financially? From donations. The professional religious leaders are paid, not necessarily by you, but they are paid. [And some not necessarily in traditional monetary currencies.]

Now stop trying to bait hooks and just exchangeideas.

I hope you're not such a pessimist that you HAVE to find something wrong with each posting...

by mallardtooxx

"I have bashed my head against the wall many times reading the one sided and biased (shall we say ignorant) opinions shared in this 'global' forum. I see you have had similar experiences with this site's most notorious leader too. Unfortunately, this same person seems to gether all information and knowledge from the internet, which we all know is jaded and simply one person's point of view." -OzMedia

Even in a thread that is totally unrelated to anything discussed in previous threads you try subversive attacks. If you want to post here which you are welcome to do, and you want to garner respect which is what you want (admit it to yourself other wise you would not be here) then you will stop already. Let it go, it has nothingto do with Max, or me or even mrafrohead, not in this thread. No one will attack you for having an opinion, to that you are entitled, they will however take exception to repeated open and not so open quips. Just please bear in mind that there are adults here and even though this is cyberspace, not everyone here is out to get you nor do we want to listen to you attack other members of the forum. Stick to your opinion, that is what you know best.

-duck

by oz_media

"When I posted the comment on biased news media, which Colin was agreeing with in his post, I had you in mind. Not from your technical postings, but from your recent discussions on world affairs and your poorly conceived experiment."

Oldefar

Think again where you point your bill, it's rabbit season anyway

by oldefar

Something with a third dimension seems to be necessary, but I can't seem to make your table work. Is there a representative image of your table available?

I take your 3 sides (capitalism, collectivism, corporatism) as axis in a table, but where is the convergence or intersecting point?

by oldefar

Julian, we have pushed your topic down a couple of interesting paths so far.

I don't know that I accept your premise of a dissolute society. Marriage probably came out of a survival need for two parents to raise a child, and as a method of increasing the likelihood that males were supporting their own genes. Social services reduce the need for the first, availability of DNA testing may soon resolve the second. Homosexuality is no threat to society at large, and the "marriage" is about legal rights of life partners.

The escalating drug problem is in my opinion a result of our existing laws on illegal drugs. If we carry the logic through, look for diets and high risk activities to come under legal bans in the future.

The "degenerate" sexual activities have been around for thousands of years. What consenting adults do in private should not be an issue for society at large.

As for the sewer in the living room, I have a satellite receiver. I have control over content by channel and by show. What comes onto my set says more about me than about society. My TV can also be electronically locked down. Internet access is under my control on my PC. The VCR and DVD are weak links, but I can choose to not have them or keepthem under physical lock to control their use by the grandkids.

Meanwhile, I engage in open dialog with others in Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Denmark, Egypt, Germany, Singapore and the UK on a fairly regular basis. Legitimate concerns over how we treat each other, ethical issues, and concerns for those with less freedom and opportunity are often topics. I think society has advanced significantly over the past 50 years.

by jimhm

OK - Ban the cookie - change the name of a mascott becauses its no PC - Ban this and ban that - lets let the government control all of our life - Oh dam wasn't there a book about that - something about 1984???? or was that 2004???

Ahhh - We need to start back to using Common Sense and wisdom that God (or whatever you believe) in gave us...

And OLDFART is right - You have the power to watch what you want (channel selector)- when you want - read what you want (power button) - live how you want - sleep with who you want (hetro/homo) - support what you want (except when they use your tax dollar) - and believe what you want - no one is holding a gun to your head yet... but give some extreme leftist or rightist the chance and they will .. we must question and watch our government and our elected officals...

by jardinier

I started the discussion by asking a question. I gave a few random examples of behaviour that is now widely accepted, but would not have been in an earlier, more traditional society. There was no judgement on my part implied with regard to these examples.

By using the phrase "dissolute society," I in no way intended to imply that all members of the society were dissolute (lax in morals; licentious). My use of this phrase was to describe a society which accepted dissolute behaviour by a significant proportion of its citizens. Obviously if everyone were dissolute, society would collapse, as there would be no-one to keep the wheels turning, to provide basic necessities of life, and some form of orderly administration.

I think perhaps that "anarchy" and "dissolution" are close cousins in that, if either were practised by everyone, the society would have no structure and would self-destruct.

History tells us (Roman Empire e.g.) that when dissolute behaviour bcomes the norm rather than the exception, the society will collapse.

by oldefar

There are some who would argue that the old Roman Empire simply relocated its capital and then lost certain parts of its territory. Much of the culture survived to become the core of today's Western civilization.

There are also conditions today that did not exist 14 to 16 hundred years ago. One is the globalization of economy and cultural exchange. While there may be a small number of communities that still remain isolated from the rest, I would venture to say 90% of us interact with the world at large. The parameters of earlier societies no longer exist, so perhaps this negates the repeat of history?

Is it possible that future historians will think of this time as an extension of the British Empire, an evolution? The language, and much of the economic and political structures have roots in England. Or perhaps this will be known as the logical growth of the Viking era based on laws and beliefs that arrived in England via Viking invasion?

by thechas

Reading this discussion, I think that there is a great deal of confusion between a Liberal and Libertarianism.
In the US, they are 2 VERY different positions.

These definitions are from a condensed version of the OED that I have on my PC:

liberal adjective
1 willing to respect or accept behaviour or opinions different from one's own; open to new ideas: they have more liberal views towards marriage and divorce than some people.

favourable to or respectful of individual rights and freedoms: liberal citizenship laws.

(in a political context) favouring individual liberty, free trade, and moderate political and social reform: a liberal democratic state.

(Liberal) of or characteristic of Liberals or a Liberal Party.

(Liberal) (in the UK) of or relating to the Liberal Democrat party: the Liberal leader.

Theology regarding many traditional beliefs as dispensable, invalidated by modern thought, or liable to change.

2 [attrib.] (of education) concerned mainly with broadening a person's general knowledge and experience, rather than with technical or professional training.
3 (especially of an interpretation of a law) broadly construed or understood; not strictly literal or exact: they could have given the 1968 Act a more liberal interpretation.
4 given, used, or occurring in generous amounts: liberal amounts of wine had been consumed.n (of a person) giving generously: Sam was too liberal with the wine.

noun a person of liberal views.n (Liberal) a supporter or member of a Liberal Party.
n (Liberal)(in the UK) a Liberal Democrat.

ORIGIN Middle English: via Old French from Latin liberalis, from liber ?free (man)?. The original sense was suitable for a free man, hence suitable for a gentleman (onenot tied to a trade), surviving in liberal arts. Another early sense generous gave rise to an obsolete meaning free from restraint, leading to sense 1 (late 18th cent.).

by thechas

libertarianism noun [mass noun] an extreme laissez-faire political philosophy advocating only minimal state intervention in the lives of citizens.

Its adherents believe that private morality is not the state's affair, and that therefore activities such as drug use and prostitution that arguably harm no one but the participants should not be illegal. Libertarianism shares elements with anarchism, although it is generally associated more with the political right (chiefly in the US); it lacks the concern of traditional liberalism with social justice.

socialism noun [mass noun] a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole. n policy or practice based on this theory.
n (in Marxist theory) a transitional social state between the overthrow of capitalism and the realization of Communism.

The term ?socialism? has been used to describe positions as far apart as anarchism, Soviet state Communism, and social democracy; however, it necessarily implies an opposition to the untrammelled workings of the economic market. The socialist parties that have arisen in most European countries from the late 19th century have generally tended towards social democracy.
DERIVATIVES
socialist noun & adjective
socialistic adjective
socialistically adverb.

ORIGIN early 19th cent.: from French socialisme, from social (see social).

by thechas

fascism noun [mass noun] an authoritarian and nationalistic right-wing system of government and social organization.n (in general use) extreme right-wing, authoritarian, or intolerant views or practice.

The term Fascism was first used of the totalitarian right-wing nationalist regime of Mussolini in Italy (1922?43), and the regimes of the Nazis in Germany and Franco in Spain were also Fascist. Fascism tends to include a belief in the supremacy of one national or ethnic group, a contempt for democracy, an insistence on obedience to a powerful leader, and a strong demagogic approach.
DERIVATIVES
fascist noun & adjective
fascistic adjective
.
ORIGIN from Italian fascismo, from fascio ?bundle, political group?, from Latin fascis (see fasces).

conservative adjective averse to change or innovation and holding to traditional attitudes and values, typically in relation to politics or religion.n (Conservative) of or relating to the Conservative Party of Great Britain or a similar party in another country.
n (of dress or taste) sober and conventional: a conservative suit.
n (of an estimate) purposely low for the sake of caution: police placed the value of the haul at a conservative ?500,000.
n (of surgery or medical treatment) intended to control rather than eliminate a condition, with existing tissue preserved as far as possible.

noun a person who is averse to change and holds to traditional values and attitudes, typically in relation to politics.n (Conservative) a supporter or member of the Conservative Party of Great Britain or a similar party in another country.

DERIVATIVES
conservatism noun
conservatively adverb
conservativeness noun.

ORIGIN late Middle English (in the sense aimingto preserve): from late Latin conservativus, from conservat- ?conserved?, from the verb conservare (see conserve). Current senses date from the mid 19th century onwards.

Chas

by jimhm

Thanks for the dictionary lesson - but I think over time (from the writing of your dictionary) the meanings of those terms have changed.

I think the following applies to the two major views in the USA. Conservative - want smaller government, andless government intrusion and mover freedoms (more to the liberatian).

Liberals - want big government, more taxs, and more government control (Kind of socialist).

I don't think those old meanings are worth the bits they are written on ..

by 1-flash-&-yer-ash

I would surmise you cant speak dolphin due to habitat and early childhood development. As well as different larynx, tongue, medium and method of transmission and reception, spatial awareness etc. Dolphins don,t normally vocalise out of water. Hold your head underwater and speak/vocalise, you'll get my drift. As to superiority, name another species/genus that can change its environment as extensively as ours

by maxwell edison

You said, "Trust needs no rules, but religion does." For the sake of argument, substitute the word faith for religion. After all, religions are no more than organizations of people sharing a common faith. And if you think about it further, trust and faith are somewhat synonymous.

The definition is: Belief without proof.

The word being defined is: ?????????????

You don't "trust" religions, but you espouse a world where trust rules. Become the change you see in the world (Gandhi). Whydon't you practice that which you preach? Why don't you just "trust" people.

Because not all people are trustworthy, that's why. To think that everyone in the world could just "get along" in perfect harmony is not only naive, but also very dangerous.

I do think you're right, however, when you say that, "the human mind is enormously suggestive." You've illustrated that quite well.

by oldefar

Trust requires no rules because it is a condition. The condition is destroyed when trust is betrayed. Religions provide rules for preserving a state of trust, incentive to follow the rules when doing so is uncomfortable or unpleasant, and comfort and support when others fail to follow the rules in dealing with you.

Our political systems try to accomplish some of the same, providing a frameword for individuals to live in a larger community.

Perhaps the need is a reflection of all individual acts being driven by selfish motives? Perhaps a promise of a better afterlife is a greater selfish motivation than immediate gratification?

by thechas

In the US, I believe that the Conservatives (Republicans) do want less government ONLY as it relates to the monitoring and regulation of business and the environment.

They generally want more government imposed restrictions on personal freedoms.

The liberal (Democratic) party wants more personal freedoms along with tighter government monitoring of business and the environment.

As to taxes, the main difference between the 2 parties is who directly pays the bulk of the tax.
The Democrats prefer to tax the wealthy and businesses higher than the general population.
The Republicans prefer large tax breaks for businesses and investment income.

In the US, the libertarians and liberals are miles apart.
1 main difference is that the liberals want government to play a leading role is forcing changes to improve social justice.

If you want labels, a libertarian is liberal on freedoms, and conservative on governmental control.

Chas

by jimhm

I think all the labels need changed - Liberal, Conservative, Liberatarian, Anarchist, Maxist, Socialist, Fasist, ect ... Repblic - Dem - the means have deverged so much over time.

But the one thing I am still trying to figure out is that Dem's want a business entity to pay taxes? Question - How does a non-existing business entity pay a tax?

All I know is if the corporate tax rates go up - all we do is pass it on to the consumer. (Look at your utility bills or gasoline price - 40 some cents is tax - which is past along to the consumer).

I as a business don't really pay the tax - I charge the consumer of my product or service, under cost of doing business - Interesting..

by john_wills

Apart from fees and fee-like taxes, e.g. property tax going to police and fire services, business taxes are actually indirect taxes disguised as direct taxes. If corporate income tax were abolished, dividends and wages would go up and the personal income tax on those would make up for the lost corporate income tax. But corporate income tax is almost invisible to the man in the street so left-wing people who want to disguise the cost of their political policies advocate corporate income tax. Corporate income tax has the same social effects as value-added tax and other indirect taxes: it hits the poor, who can less afford taxes, to the same extent as it hits the rich; it does not attempt to distribute the burden fairly, which personal incometax does.

by thechas

My pre-wired comment has NOTHING to do with the brainwashing of some religions.

Throughout time, man has used religious principles to explain that which we do not understand.

Long before the Greek Gods, man had concluded that there must be some higher power or purpose behind our existence.

All civilizations have their historic beliefs of the origin of the world.

I will continue to believe in a higher power until there is definitive proof that a higher power does not exist.

Science has yet to postulate on where the matter / energy that created the big bang came from.

Chas

by jardinier

go and empty your bowels in the appropriate facility, after which you will be most welcome to rejoin the discussion.

But we do not appreciate you pooping in our sandpit.

by the chalky

One of the problems with religions is that when you question something simple about their religion, you are dismissed. Sometimes this manifests itself as being accused of playing devil's advocate.
The deliberate brainwashing of ALL religions is the problem that holds human development back.
Rather than being a pessimist, I strongly believe in the ability of individuals to control their destiny. It is religion that is pessimistic. When I go to a religious service - out of respect for friends that are religious - I hear the preaching of the "fear factor".
What is more pessimistic than stating "If you can't sort out your life (in my religions way) on earth, you will burn for ever in hell".
Don't confuse questioning with pessimism.
Just because I disagree with you doesn't mean that there is something wrong with every posting. Hitler would have approved of the idea that criticism should be criticised!

by cactus pete

Do not assume who I am but the side of the discussion I may appear to be taking.

I firmly believe the is a need to argue both sides, to debate everything. That prevents blind faith, to an extent. Now that's out of the way...

You're stating that ALL religions are brainwashing their followers. I can see how you might perceive that, and I can even give way on the idea that subconsciously [best fit word] the religion has that as a goal. [In general, not all, mind you.] However, you are not arguing along the lines I set up:

I stated that people need to rely on others at times. Sort of like: Did you build that house in which you live? Did you invent your own car? Do you grow your own penicilin?

by cactus pete

I will break one of my own rules and inform you that I do not partake in religious ceremonies, even as to the extent that you appear to to placate friends. Why? Because I don't believe what they preach. I see no benefit in attending.

However, if someone has made their own rational decision that a particular group of people can support them as they feel would be beneficial, how is this different than you buying a house? You relied on the help of others for something you feel is beyond you, or beyond your conveniences.

Sure, perhaps you can build a house on your own, given enough time. How great would the quality be? How sound can you believe the foundation to be?

I am not weak for having purchased a house built by others. I am not weak for seeking advice from my best friend. And, if I were so inclined, I would not be weak for seeking a reaffirmation of what I do/believe to be 'right' by joining a fellowship, or a church, or a coven, etc.

What is weak then? I believe close minds are weak. I believe that blind faith is weak. I believe that condemning others who see things differently than you is weak. I believe that arrogance is weak.

We will all be weak in our own manner. One can mitigate this with an open mind, discussion, and tolerance if not acceptance.

Extremes, too, will always be needed so we can all see the middle ground.

There is no distinction in my mind between the fact that both the religious zealot and the anti-religious zealot areextremes.