Has libertarianism reached its peak?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by hal 9000
Humans can't speek dolphin because we are designed differently for a different enviroment now you may like to call this evelution, God;'s Grand Design or what ever but the fact that we can change our enviroment isn't necessarly a good thing as on most occasions when we do change the enviroment it is us who pays the price for destroying the enviroment in the first place.
Sure we manage to exterminate quite a few species along the way but is thia necessarly a good thing?
Does it make us superior to those so called animalls who live in harmony with their envirmonent?
I think hat you are under the misapherision that because we can we should and to hell with the conquences, well sorry but I don't think that way and as I live in Australia I have seen many instances of introduces species causing the destruction to the existing enviroment from simple flora to the introduced Fauna. Something as simple as cattle are causing irreversable damage to the land but we continue with their production just so we can have our Big Mac's and the like and don't worry about what will happen. Here we are beginning to see the results of only a few hundred years of altering the enviroment and it isn't a preety sight. Salinity getting out of control, introduced ants killing off everything in their path. The Fire Ants that where accidently introduced had so far been contained to a fairly small area only a few thousand square Kilometers and it is costing us millions to eradacate these. How would you like to attempt to eredacate the wild dog population completely over here?
Just because we can change our enviroment doesn't make us in any way superior but mostly makes us inferrior to all other species on the planet.
by hal 9000
Would you trust the person who enters you place of living at 2.00 am armed with a base ball bat to rob you? Guns are not the problem and from guns I do mean all firearms from the humble revolver through to weapons like the M16 or any other high powered rifle which onl has one purpose. And lets face it without any ammo these are little better than a base ball bat. But that being said it isn't firearms that are a problem it's the nut who's using it. If you where to remove all firearms from this planet tomorrow do you honestly think for a single nanosecond that things would improve? No people would just find other ways of maiming/killing each other.
I do like the idea of trust but trust has to be earned not something freely given as it then looses its value. The reality of our society {I'm speaking generally here and not about any particular country either} is that we will always have the haves and haves nots and it is some of the have nots who will continue to try to obtain others propery at any cost for their own gratifaction.
But then again Bill Gates just might start trusting everyone and make the sorce code of Windows freely available for the benifit of the entire world mightn't he?
by hal 9000
First you say get rid of religions and trust every one and then you say don't trust the religious leaders. How do you reconcile this? You must either trust or not you can't have your cake and eat it to.
I'm beginning to think that you are only trying to throw a spanner in the works to take this dissucission where you want it to go and in no way actually contribute to what the original question actually was.
Sorry but I'm with Max here as you seem to me to be condricting yourself when everit suits you own ends.
You can't say trust everyone but those that I tell you not to because then you are no better than those who you are critising now.
Or is it you just want the power and prestige that comes with the job and none of the responsibilities?
by hal 9000
I once thought about forming a religion and even went as far as contacting an accountant and legal specalist about my idea. Being the subtle person that I am I though to call my religion something like "The Church of the Latter Day Tax Avoiders". The concept was simple just get a group of people together {I already had enough to start this going and it was legal} and get them to doniate all their income to my church, now being a registered religion all donations would be tax deductable so thesepeople would have no taxable income. My Church being the tolerant and helping organisation that it is would then give these destitute people charity which is not taxable something like 90% of their donations. But why stop there? I could also set up a charity shop and sell to all my followers products that where bought by the church and as it is a religion I would not have to pay any tax on my purchases so I could pass the savings on to my followers. I could sell everything from a packet of cornflakes to a 747 and everything in between natuarlly I would have to take a slight profit but my followers would still be far better off than if they had just gone out and bought the items themselves.
If I had of actually set up this church the only group that would be paying for it's existance would have been the Government as they would have been loosing all the taxation from all my followers.
My followers would have been better off than if they had never joined as they would be saving large amounts of money if this had ever happened.
by hal 9000
So How can you claim that people pay for religion if they chose to donate money or goods to any religion that's their right and to date I've never seen any religion actually hold some one down and force them to hand over any money. Sure these peopleare encouraged to donate but how is this different from donating to any other thing that a person is interested in? Every Charity and quite a few other groups encourages donations from the public no matter who or what they are. If some people want to follow a certain religion and there very many people all over the world then it must offer them something that you can't see.
And who are you to tell all these people that they don't know what they are doing and that you know better? If you where to do this how are you any better than the people that you are currently deriding? Wouldn't you just be another form of religion {by this I do mean a belief system} than all the others? Every one believes in something even if it's nothing more thanthe Sun will rise tomorrow.
When I ws far younger than I'm now I was constantly told that there are only 2 certinaties in Life and they are Death and Taxes everyone will be in some way controlled by these 2 things. It is certian that we will all die at some point and most of us hope it is latter rather than sooner {again another belief} and to date I haven't found a way of not paying taxes of any kind.
by hal 9000
If I want to purchase a house to live in I will borrow the money I will get professionalls to build it or inspect a preexisting house that may take my interest these are things that I'm not qualified to do and not only lack the resources {like most people} but I also lack the knowledge to perform these tasks as well as someone that does this type of thing for a living. I do trust these people to do their jobs but not because I believe them to be trustworthy I trust their opinions because I'm paying for these opinions. Does than make me a lesser person because I don't know everything?
Anyone that believes that they know it all are only deluding themselves as there will always be specalisists who know far more than I could ever hope to learn in my lifetime in their specalised area. This fact is true for every person on this planet and it doesn't require any belief as it is nothing more than a simple fact.
I work with computers so obviously I wouldn't be expected to know how to culture biological agents that could destroy masses of people or for the same reason cure masses of people from some illness, nobody would expect me to know more about my own health than a professional. How many people have you ever heard complaining thatthey arn't well the first suggestion is for them to go see a doctor, so by your defination does this mean that they are lesser people because they seek inderpendant advice? Instead of treating themselves whit medications that they can't legally obtain.
by hal 9000
Pass a rulling that it was improper to make students of schools in America repeat the Oath of Allegence?
If you where to extend normal manners that I was taught all those years ago to a female you could end up on a charge of sexual harasment. Asby opening a door giving a seat to a woman is an admission that the female is incapable of doing either of these things.
However I don't see these things as any form of harassment they are nothing more than showing respect for our fellow humans. It is more a statment of the legal structure than a statment on society that you can be charged with an offence by just offering some form of respect to a fellow human being. So maybe we should be discussing how the legal societies are taking this society down hill fast rather than judge the current society by the actions of the fringe minority who resort to legal means at every perceived slight to themselves. Mostly these actions are not bought about to achieve an appology but to gain some formof compensation for the so called slighted indivudal. So how can we display trust to everyone while at teh same time being unable to show them the respect that they desirve?
by hal 9000
In the first listing that you put up didn't it say something about willing to listen to others views? Or at least something like that. So in the truest sence we all here are liberal no matter what our political leanings might be as we are willing totolerate others opinions and willing to listen even if we don't agree. If this wasn't correct those people wouldn't be here now or at any time.
Right?
Now for the politics all political parties want one thing in particualy they just vary on how to get it and that is to be in control rather than in oppersisition.
The main sticking point here is the inability of seperating political ideas from the words and the way that society acts and what is currently acceptable to our current society.
Perhaps we should have 2 different discussions on this topic one only on the political side and the other on how society behaves and what it will tolerate before a certain type of behaviour becomes unaceptable. When invitro-fertilasition was first introduced there where all types of gloom being put out but the moral minority who wanted to keep things the way that they where and not change with the times. Well all those susposedly horendious outcomes haven't eventuated.
I believe the differences that we should be thinking about here is the differences between those who want to change with new developments and those who resist change at all costs.
The one certinaty is that change is inevitable but where all parties are concerned is in the rate and direction that this change leads rather than any political beliefs.
by john_wills
by the chalky
maxwell & colin have found contradictions in my postings. Having been through them, perhaps they will point out what they are.
Nowhere have I said distrust anyone (including religious leaders). What I have said is that many of the people that have caused wrs in the past have used the religions to get their own way by misquoting these religions.
I will repeat the statement. Trust everyone and occasionally be disappointed. It is a better outlook on life than believing in a "higher authority" that states in the bible "Though shalt have no other god than I."
The preferred interpretation at this end is that of "I" meaning all of us as individuals, ergo I am my god, you are your god.
It doesn't take a genius to work that one out, but it's taken centuries of misinterpretation to brainwash humanity into believing that religion - not faith - is necessary.
PS I only went back to my level of the post because we had run out - and I've also enoyed a few days holiday. Trust me.
by the chalky
There is nowhere in any of my posts questioning or complaining about people paying for religion. I asked if people are so insecure that they need to pay for security in the afterlife - a question you have chosen not to answer.
In addition, where do I say everything has to be done by one person (let alone me)? The tongue in cheek statement of "doing something properly" is a saying that I had repeated to me when growing up ? a bit like yours death and taxes. Once you grow up you realise you can't do it on your own.
My viewpoint is that trust is more important than religion.
Generally speaking, workmen that I employ to do something have qualifications or accreditations that are trustworthy - because of the awarding body.
Finally regarding all those donations being tax deductible, I'm glad I live in a country where that doesn't happen.
I wasn’t planning to post any more messages to this thread, but since you asked me to clarify my previous comments, I’ll give you that courtesy. However, I will reveal my bias here by reiterating that I think you’re just yanking everyone’s chain – trying to get a reaction. I’ve concluded that you’re either extremely mean-spirited (I’ll explain later), or extremely confused, or you’re just trying to get people riled up enough to post a reply.
When I made the comment that you’re contradicting yourself, I didn’t mean it as literal as you interpreted – inasmuch as you specifically stated one thing, and later something contrary. (Even though I could probably find something if I took the time to find and read ALL your messages, which I won’t.) I came to that conclusion by reading into the style, the attitude, and the impression your words instilled in me. The sound and style of one’s writings, just as much as the words, certainly does leave the reader with an impression of the writer.
For example, take your message titled, “How to win Friends”. What exactly is that supposed to mean when, in the text of the message, you go on to insult the basic beliefs of others? You further make assertions about “religions” – and you don’t differentiate between any of them, by the way; you just group them all together – but you make those assertions in the most simplistic way. You say, for example, that religions “profess to “know the truth”. Do they? Do they all? Support your argument with specifics. Don’t generalize.
(continued...)
You go on to dismiss “religions because they, “are all controlled by humans who have their own agenda”. Yet all humans – whether organized or not – have an agenda. Your agenda, one can certainly presume, is to discredit all religions. “The problem with all religions”, you say, “is that people are involved”. The opposite could also be said – the problem with agnostics or atheists is that people are involved. So what’s your point?
Trust is more than a just word to describe the validity of some accreditation (that is trustworthy) because of some awarding body. And trust and faith are very synonymous. You might “trust” someone to not steal from you, for example. You thereby place your faith in that person to behave accordingly. Furthermore, whether you admit it or not, the belief in a higher power or the belief that there is no higher power both have a foundation in faith – since neither viewpoint can be proven.
To return to my “mean-spirited” accusation, for someone to disagree with one’s political views is one thing, since implementing one’s political views can certainly affect others. But to attack one’s religious views – to attack what’s in one’s heart – something that has no bearing on others, is indeed mean-spirited. (And no, I’m not talking about the extremists who kill in the name of God, but rather those who just use their faith as a moral compass with which they try to live a good life.) To insult one’s basic beliefs in life and their beliefs for after-life is just downright mean-spirited. And that, my friend, is certainly no way to “win friends”.
by jimhm
by john_wills
by the chalky
Thank you for proving (some of) my points Maxwell. Simply by stating that I should not generalise but give specifics but also stating that you will not go into specifics about my contradictions, but "the style, the attitude..." was enough to show where contradictions exist. Generalisations are a necessary part of argument. As are specifics. Wouldn?t it be better to concentrate on your own statements than telling me how to behave?
The whole point of discussion is to get a reaction ? agreeable or otherwise. For some reason that is what I thought we were all doing. Again, perhaps I question more than most ? especially when I don?t like the answers. Whilst openly admitting that I do not have personal experience of every religion in theworld, the ones that I have experience of are interested in control of their flock.
I don't see the need to be controlled.
If you had read the greatest (IMHO) book ever written you would have clearly understood the meaning of "How to win Friends". Dale Carnegie's bestseller explains that the best way of reinforcing someone's beliefs are telling them that they are wrong. To change them you never tell them that. Look at the title of previous posts for that explanation.
Regarding your beliefthat my agenda is to discredit religions, again we have to agree to disagree. My agenda is to question, not accept or discredit. If by questioning something is discredited, then that is because the something was discreditable to begin with and thequestioning only highlighted that. Anyone who follows a religion accepts the teachings of that religion. These teachings are never based on facts, but a belief in some esoteric statements from the past ? sometimes the recent past, but more often the distant past. This obviously helps these statements to go unchallenged.
by the chalky
My point on ?people are involved? is control. Incidentally you chose to quote only the summary rather than the specific on that, making my meaning significantly different when taken out of context. The original quote (before summarising a few words later is ?they are all controlled by humans who have their own agenda.? It is the control that is hugely different. Agnostics and atheists are ? as far as I am aware ? not interested in controlling other people by having them believe statements in an unquestioning manner. There are doubtless some agnostics or atheists who are interested in that agenda, but they will find a different way to do it. It may be more honest than religious leaders showing ?the truth?. Then again, it may not be.
Again, you chose to misinterpret the ?trust? issue. Trust and faith are synonymous, it is faith and religion that are not. This is the crux of the misinterpretation. My belief is that trust (or faith) is necessary for human interaction. Religion is not necessary. The belief or non-belief in a higher power is irrelevant to trust. It is only relevant to religion ? an institution which I clearly believe has held back human development.
Your point about attacking what is in one?s heart is facile. Religions have brainwashed people into this ?heart? thing. If human?s thought more with their brains and less with their hearts they would realise that they do not need the control (or guidance as you and numerous despots throughout history have called it) of a religion and can actually survive with the human support that exists around them today. Mean spirited doesn?t come into it. Winning friends is entirely about trust.
by the chalky
I admit to being confused. I am confused at the level of gullibility that exists in people to the extent that they still rely on religion. I am also confused that people still criticise non-religious people for questioning things. I am confused that people believe they need religion to show them how to live. Perhaps most of all, I am confused that anyone really believes that any religious institution can have the lives of the individual as a greater priority than the lives of the people that control the religion.
And yes, I do believe in what I have posted.
by jimhm
Got to toss the Biggest Red BS Flag I have ever read in Techrepublic - on this one. It's strange you say the agnostics and atheists don't have an agenda - BS FLAG - who has forced the schools to remove all prayer including a moment of silence? Who is it in California that wants the phrase "Under God" removed from the pledge - Who is it that wants the phrase "In God we Trust" removed from our currency? - Who is it that wants the 10 commandments removed from public walls - who is it that want religions programs removed from television - who is it that wants no mention of religion on anyones lips in public places...
If I recall - they are Agnostic / Atheists - Hum - No Agenda ha - BS FLAG - Big Time ...
The Majority believes in some higher power - so deal with it... you believe in nothing but what you see - thats fine ... we will all find out when we die - who was right or if we were both right.
by jimhm
Dam - If it wasn't for it being electronic - we would all be drowned in the BS that you just wrote and posted ... Where's the Payloader... and tri-axels to haul it away...
We believe what we choose to believe - you believe what you choose to believe - I don't understand your beliefs and I don't care - nor do I care that you don't believe what I believe... In the same breath you have no right to question why I believe is something, for I have not attempt to place beliefs on you ...
Are you in search of an answer to a question - is that why your confused - Are you looking for something to believe in - is that why your confused - Why do you care what I believe - Why do you care what others believe in - WHat is it your business anyway -
You're an idiot who's full of crap, and what you write is not worthy of my time trying to sift through the b.s. that you spew.
You're a waste of time and bandwidth.
by oz_media
Yup you're right MAX, biggest waste of time, yet for some reason I was drawn to see why this post is so popular. Someone earlier mentioned that it was like passing an car accident, you can't help but rubberkneck to see the dead people, (I think their analogy was a little prettier though).
One statement from JimM kinda bothers me though,
"If I recall - they are Agnostic / Atheists "
Being agnostic and being an athiest are quite different although there is a fine line.
I choose not to pick a specific religion to hold faith in but feel that almost all religions have something that I choose to believe in. Nuff said, I am not going to try and change anyone's religious beliefs here.
Whereas an Athiest is a strong disbeliever that downs religion of ANY sort, this I am not.
Does this then make me Athiest/Agnostic?
by hal 9000
Us all at TR that in the United Kingdom that the Church actually pays Taxes?
Sorry but that's not the way it happens all registered churches are tax exempt and have been from the time that the Christian Church first started. They have durring theyears also held formitable power as they have on many occasions warned the Kings that they can be removed if they displease the church admittedly this was the Roman Church but the sediment still continues amoungst all churches even 30 years ago these churches where still telling their flock how to vote at any upcomming elections.
Any church weilds enormous power and they arn't afraid of using it if and when it suits their aims.
As far as trust goes I do trust most people to a point and unless they prove themselves untrust worthy I will continue to trust these people but I still wouldn't hand over my cheque book to anyone with signed cheques in it. There are dergees of trust and it is in the dergees that you have to decide where to draw the line.
by the chalky
As always with religious people - who can never explain why they believe in their religion - it gets personal - then again, existentialism is all about the personal, which is the closest to ?religion? that I have ever got! It is too isolationist though ? even for me.
Jim says that Agnostics/Atheists have an agenda. Some of them do - read my post, I stated it!
I'm glad I live in a country where choice is more important than schools having to start with prayer. In addition my country is not insecure enough to have a ?pledge of allegiance?. Nor does our currency mention god. Although that IS a contradiction... Doesn't the bible talk about money being the root of all evil, yet your currency says "In God we Trust".
Regarding believing what you choose to believe (as Jim says). If you think that my posts have been designed to stop people believing in whatever, that's up to you. I will continue to question religions. So far all of the ones that I have come into contact with do notappear to have the best interests of the individuals at heart. They have the best interests of the religion at heart.
I remain confused at the lack of questioning that goes on within religions. Otherwise intelligent people seem to throw all rational thought out of the window when confronted by someone who says ?I believe?. Continue to believe what you do, but please stop being arrogant enough to tell people that questioning is wrong. If it?s wrong for you fine, but it certainly ain?t wrongfor me.
by hal 9000
The answer to the ulitment question of Life The Universe and Everything is 42.
Don Addams told us all that many years ago but still some people haven't come to terms with this simple answer.
Perhaps this will help lesson your confusion but I personally don't thik it will.
...that I was a "religious" person? I sure didn't.
In fact, I've made efforts to avoid revealing whether or not I am. I didn't even give the slightest hint.
As usual, your misguided assumptions reinforce what I did say - You're an idiot.
The quote that you misquoted - another example to reinforce your misguided idiot status - discusses the LOVE of money being the root of all evil, not money itself.
You continue to prove that you belong at the top of the idiot list, and that youdon't know your ass from your elbow.
by hal 9000
What ever you profess to question you are expressing a belief in something in this case the church which you claim to constantly question. One could question your fixation on this matter but as I'm not really interested I won't bother.
Unfortantly there are some among the church leaders who do place more effort on maintaing their power base and increasing it where possible but equially there are more people involved in the church who do this work because they believe that they are helping people and honestly what's wrong with this? It does not matter if someone who wants to help come from a church or from a University/Colledge with a degree the end result is always the same so as an instution I really don't have too much of a problem with the church as a whole.Even the most radical religious people are only trying to help others and the fact that they gain some form of power/prestige/finical reward is only of secondary importance.
You have to look at the entire picture to form an opinion and not only rely on personal experience as this is too limiting a perfect example here is I've never personally seen a Fission weapon deploy but I do believe that they do as we are told and I don't want to see one in action either I will believe that they are capable of performing what is claimed by the Governments who own/use these weapons. Religion is much the same only instead of a promise of death and destruction there is a promise of some sought of an after life {in most anyway}and I personally find this a more rewarding experience than only believing in what I have actually seen because I bring my owm biases and beliefs to whatever I see and these may not be correct but it is the way that I interpurate the event.
by hal 9000
Well here goes you have menaged to place me in a position of having to defend something that I don't necessarly believe in but as you have raised the question yet again people belive in a lot of things sometimes they also include faith in a religion.
All religions do have a basis in fact and do not only rely upon somethng that was alledgely said/done thousands of years ag. A Buddist monk that I once knew told me that different cultures perceive the same facts in different ways hence the different religions all around the world.
Humans have a need to believe in something and that can range from when you flip a switch your computer will start to a surpreme being called anything from God, Allah, Buddia and countless incantantions of the same being who is either enlightment or a soul who has atained enlightment even to the Creator of the World/universe or whatever one choses to believe in.
I have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow and this is based on previous observations but in actual fact it is impossible to prove as there are numerious things that could prevent this from happening all of these I won't go into because unless you are well versed in Kaos Theroy and some of the other more advanced Phyiscs theroies will just be a waste of both my time and more importantly my bandwidth.
by hal 9000
Another person could see the same thing and see something completely different it all boils down to our own personial biases and there is no way of changing these nor would I wish for this to be possible.If everyone believed the same thing this world would be a very booring place to live and personally I like the different views put forward by others as I find them a mind expanding experience I don't have to believe them but I do learn from them.
This is something that you will have to do oryou will stay in the rut that you have dug for yourself.
And Max is right you are constantly changing your arguments to suit your own ends but I can't percieve your purpose.
But here is a perfect example how did the second part get in place before the first posting? I believe that this could not happen but I've been proven wrong again.
by hal 9000
All political parties start out with the idea of helping the indivual in the country that they are attempting to Goven. But unfortantly as time goes by and the original leaders bow out or die another group comes in with a silghtly different agenda. This process continues until the stage is reached where being in Governemnt is the main objective {Hence the Power Angle} as obviously you can not achieve anything by not being in Government or a position of power. Eventually it is the office that becomes the overriding thing and the good of the people is only a secondary thought if it even comes into the equasion.
With our current political system unelected people can buy their way into the halls of power just by donating large amounts of cash to a reelection fund of either a person or party and by doing this gain an unfair advantage over the rest of the people in the country. The cigeratte industry is a perfect example here as they have constantly poored large amounts of cash into reelection funds and they don't do this for the good of the electorite or the person who is running for office they do it for what they perceive they will get in return if/when that person/party is elected.
Someone once said "That there's no such thing as a free lunch" and that is perfectly correct as no company would give away money if they did not expect something in return.
by john_wills
Colin Luck is right about firms bribing politicians, but there is a deeper issue. If a public company gives money to a political party or candidate the managers of the company are, by giving the money, stealing from the owners of the company. This is true even if the majority of the owners approve of the donation: they should take slightly higher dividends and themselves give to the party. Similarly, a labor union's management is stealing from the union members if the union donates to a party or candidate: reduce the dues and let the members themselves donate.
I can extend this. A few years ago someone in China was accused of giving money to the U.S. Democrat party. If the someone was the Chinese government, it was stealing from all Chinese citizens and taxpayers. If it was the Communist party, any donation to a non-communist party was stealing from the members of the Chinese Communist Party.
I am not a libertarian, but I point out that the solutions to social problems often come byconsidering commutative rather than social justice.
by jimhm
Power is the one thing all parties want - it all depends on the way in which they will us that power. Some will return control to the people, others will control the people with it.
Our forefathers knew that 100% power corrupts 100% - and thats why they put so many checks and balances in.
A new senator maybe clean his/her first term - but after that (s)he's got to play in the mud with all the others to get what they want done.
The power must be a real turn on ... I can't understand why you would sell your soul and integraty for a new highway so you can get re-elected ... Look at Byrd of WVa - he should of retired 20 years ago - so the job is easy - and the power must keep you going..
by jardinier
I think we are dealing with someone who neglected to read the newspapers for the past half century. In the relatively recently dismantled Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, the practise of tradional religions (predominantly Christianity) was banned. The official State "Religion" was atheism. Persons who were dedicated to pursuing their preferred relious beliefs had to do so secretly, and under threat of dire consequence if detected.
Under the Maoist Communist rule, the practise of traditional religions was also totally banned. However in recent years the practise of religions is becoming increasingly tolerated by the Government.
As I meet a lot of Chinese people -- many of whom are IT Pros -- it puzzled me for a long time that none of these people were aware of their religious heritage, which included Buddhism, Confucionism and Taoism. One friend told me he believed in God, but knew nothing of the religions which had been practised in China for roughly 2,500 years.
Recently I engaged in conversation with a retired, and very well-informed Chinese gentleman, Soo. He explained that because of the total ban on religion imposed by the Communist Government, a whole generation of people had grown up to adulthood with absolutely no awareness of even the existence of these religions, especially Taoism with its Yin/Yang philosophy.
I now see it as an astonishing accomplishment of the atheistic Communist Government to virtually erase from the memory banks of the most highly populated country in the world, all knowledge of this fundamental aspect of their culture.
I think it can be readily seen from these two examples that atheism can most definitely have an agenda: in this case stripping the people of their inherited faiths, and replacing their belief system with atheism, so that they would be much less resistant to the socialist and communist philosophies respectively.
by hal 9000
A major fight over what goes on in politics I was only trying to show how the aims of a political party changes over the years and I certianly wasn't having a go at any particular political party or for that matter any particular country.
It was only a throw away line so please don't get carried away with the comment as in all honesty it isn't all that important.
It was only an attempt to show just how Big Business exerts some form of control over elected people and this is something thatI think should be addressed so that this type of control can be stopped. There's nothing like telling a polition that you will do as we want or we'll not contribute to your reelection fund again.
The bit about companies not giving donations to political parties/canditates is just unrealistic as the reality of the situation is that to the company it is a form of advertising or an attempt to prevent subsquent Governments from doing anything that adversly impacts on their industry so they keep being profitable for the long term there is very little profit in making millions this year and then have your product outlawed or taxed out of existance.
In cases like this I'm sure that it is in the share holders best interests for these contributions to be made and in most cases these companies hedge their betts and support both sides of politics so they are in a no lose position whatever happens. And honestly whats a few million every few years for election funding they would pay far morethan this paultry amount for their normal advertising in a 6 month period to increase their market share/sales which is in the shareholders best interests.
by jardinier
Anyone who cares to consult a thesaurus to find synonyms for "religion" will have to admit that atheism clearly qualifies to be described as a religion.
The fundamental assertion of atheism that "there is definitely no god," can neither be proven nor disproven.
In the same manner, the fundamental assertion of recognised religions that "there definitely is a god" can neither be proven nor disproven.
I have found that, upon even a superficial questioning, the vast majority of people who describe themselves as "atheists" are merely rejecting the "old man in the sky" image which they were taught as children. Almost invariably they are in accord with the concept that there exists in the universe an innate intelligence which caused it to come into being.
Whilst there are some people who refuse to accept even this concept, they are in a minority among atheists in general.
[A small aside: A former elderly computer student of mine declared that he was an atheist. "Why are you an atheist?" I asked. "Because I don't believe in God." "Why don't you believe in God?" "Because I am an atheist."] Well, you can't refute that logic now, can you?
by john_wills
1. After the collapse of the Kremlin Empire the Polish communist party wanted to regain power so it changed its theories to something between liberalism and socialism, and so gets enough votes to stay important. Similarly, the Russian communist party has obtained votes and power by shifting its ideology. But... in the DDR the communist party has stayed true-red and now has only 2 members of parlliament: it has preferred ideological purity to power without purpose.
2. Quite often a "paycheck protection" bill gets laid before the U.S. Congress to prevent corporation and union management stealing shareholder or member moeny for political donations. The last time in the Senate it almost won. So excluding this kind of corruption is not an impossible dream.
by the chalky
I apologise for making an assumption. Your postings sounded like every religious bigot that I had encountered in the past, therefore I asumed you were. For that I apologise.
It amazes me that you have reacehed a conclusion about my intelligence -or lack of it according to you - without knowing anything about me.
Like everyone else who disagreed with my questioning, you have not been prepared to back up any of your statements with facts. I happily admit it is easier to question than it is to provide answers, but very few of the psotings here have even attempted to provide answers.
Bigotry is based upon ignorance. Ignorance is based upon a lack of questioning - among other things.
Religions - mostly - encourage people not to question.
I question - argument ended.
Idiocy is not questioning.
by the chalky
It is clear that very few people are actually interested in answering questions now - which is the basis for debate/discussion.
Personal abuse is more important to a few, therefore there is no point in trying to continue a debate when it has becomepersonal. I'll continue to have interesting and robust debate with friends that are members of religions. Unlike some posters here, they respect questions and accept that they cannot answer some. They choose to ignore these - as is their right. I continue to ask - as is my right. We agree to disagree. That's why they are still friends.
Those posting here that enjoy acting like an Ostrich will doubtless continue to do so. That's what religion has turned most people into.
Doubtless it will please some that this will be my last post into what has become a sterile and personal series of postings.
by jimhm
Before I contunie a discussion on that topic which has nothing to do with Techrepublic - you need to answer one simple question that many have asked you ...
If you don't believe in God or a superior entity why do you question what others believe?Why does it borther you that people believe in an hereafter and a God (no matter what he/she is called)? Why do you concern yourself about things you don't believe in - Unless you have an Agenda for something? - Hum those some interesting question Iwill wait for an honest answer and not that I am a questioning type of person. I don't need to justify my beliefs to you - nor you justify yours to me ... My question is why do you care what I believe unless you are unsure of your own beliefs ..
Answer those question first - Otherwise your BS is just what it is BS and aint worth the time and effort.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending