Discussion Locked

HELP! University of Phoenix Degree.

0 helpful
203 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

203 replies

by jerseydave

I was actually talking about this and other 'online' schools with a professor tonight, and was told that he knows people at MAJOR employers said no, they absolutely would not. He said they don't mnd online classes, but from a REAL university.... Real meaning they have a campus, you just happen to be taking online classes.

by anniemae46

Sometimes I think this country is insane and how fast some people will put down innovation just to defend the establishment in terms of learning.
UOP is accredited by The Higher Learning Commission of the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools. They also have campuses all over the place. It's just that when UOP offered a solid online program, not many others did--UOP had the process figured out early. I think that's why enrolling with other, more established universities was not an option for many working adults. I've had class mates in the military working online from all around the world; something they could not do otherwise. Or, people who live in rural areas, or who were disabled, etc.
I think anyone involved in screening prospective candidates should know more about accredited online-only learning and how it actually works. No slacking off partying some place.. In fact, it involves much discipline, collaboration and work. Perhaps many people get into these programs when they should not have if they are not fully committed. It would be a slap in the face of the faculty if the faculty would be seen as mediocre. I mean if there is a problem then it should be fixed and the process improved, but not abandon the entire idea.

by gralfus

The whole reason I went to UOP was that HP made us get BS degrees just to keep our positions (and paid for the classes). This is a major employer (or used to be, now they are a major unemployer).

UOP does have a real campus, they just offer complete degrees online for those who are unable to physically go to the campus.

by nuskool

I didn't have a crappy job but more of a crappy boss who hired someone without a degree and expected the results of someone with a degree certs and 4 years experience.

This lead to two things:
1. I hated my job.
2. It made me work harder to acquire the skills I needed for a better job.

It turned out pretty good though because I was way ahead of everyone in my class knowledge wise when I graduated, I am now comfortable with my skill set and I learned how to tell my boss I don't know how to do that, (sometimes I multiple times if I have to).

ITT Tech was a good school in my opinion but it wasn't well rounded enough for me. Not enough humanities, social science, etc. And like other people have said. You get what you put into it. If you're doing it for a piece of paper you can frame, I don't think you will succeed in this field (or any field for that matter).

by nuskool

Well sort of,

I started working for this small company when I had about 9 moths left for my A.S. I've done everything from google maps, to installing anti-virus, anti-spyware, setting up policies, putting the server in a rack whole bunch of other IT "stuff" that makes my job easier and of course helps the company. I couldn't agree more that a small company is a good place to start for the maximum exposure to IT.

by anniemae46

Sperling was also featured in FastCompany Magazine in March of 2003 -- a magazine I regard highly (hope I remember the date correctly, but just look it up). The article also went behind the scene and explained the concept, such as the types of materials used, etc. UOP has been quite revolutionary with the idea of online teaching -- now most are doing it.

by scat10

I am just finishing up my UOP degree (BS/Business Magmt & Marketing) and I just scoured my student website for any information about a PhD in Web Development. I was extremely skeptical about such a degree, just as you were. Well, guess what? UOP doesn't offer it.

I find it highly annoying that you passed judgement on the school without doing your homework. Clearly, the idiot applicant was lying; had you done proper research, you would have discovered as much.

By the way, UOP offers plently of brick and mortar programs and classes. Nearly all my courses were in classrooms with professors and other students present.

In my case, I have 10 years of IT front line tech experience and wanted to take it to the next level. UOP fit perfectly within these goals. If not for what I learned at UOP, I would not have doubled my salray in the last year and a half. That's right, DOUBLED.

Additionally, the weekly group work (which seemed frustrating at the time), perfectly prepared me for my current position. I managed to make my mistakes in a school setting, not real life. Now I am very well equipped to work with group dynamics and varied personality types.

The required weekly presentations have also proven to be hugely beneficial. Now, when called upon to speak in front of a group of my peers OR senior management, I feel perfectly comfortable. Thank you UOP.

My career is making leaps and bounds because of my efforts at UOP. For that I will be forever grateful.

****

Here is a list of UOP PhD programs, direct from the student website:

Doctor of Business Administration v.001
Doctor of Education v.001
Doctor of Education in Educational Leadership with a Specialization in Curriculum and Instruction v.001
Doctor of Management v.001
Doctor of Management v.002
Doctor of Management in Organizational Leadership with a Specialization in Information Systems and Technology v.001
Doctor of Health Administration v.001

by madtechgirl

I did do my research as I stated in my post. At that time UoP did offer a PhD in Web Development. I also took it further and looked at the coursework.

by falconeer

Let?s hope that people like that live in a SPECIAL place from now on.

Let me know how you are doing in search of IT positions. The 'best' place, in my opinion is Atlanta.

Know what I miss? Good old programs like, for instance, old GW Basic with all the go to?s, and the little routine that someone wrote that allowed one to renumber lines of code. 'When you ran out of goto's'

Around here we have people from all walks of programming experience and all are blow away by the fact I can bring a beginning program to life using Foxpro 2.6 within a few hours. Woops, showing my age again.

The problem is that the newer languages rapidly promote ?bloat?. They don?t really care that the routine isn?t being used they just put it in the compilation. ?just in case?.

Take care...

by apotheon

Compilers do that, not languages. What languages are you thinking of that allegedly compile unused routines rather than optimizing them out? I'm curious.

by suzitech

I've been at the same company as an IT Specialist for 5 years now, with virtually no room for moving up. Hopefully this degree will either push certain useless people aside (or just get rid of them completely) so I can climb above "tech monkey", though my plans are to bounce out of here, ASAP. I'd like to go back to NYC and get a little more experience in something like project management. My family is pressuring me to move to Georgia since we have some family members down there, but the humidity would kill me!

As for BASIC, nothing like a million lines of spaghetti code to ensure job insurance!

by xicxi

Honeslty;

In this world you will run into just about eveything. The most important thing is to Get your foot in. Once you are in, it doesn;t really matter the school you graduated from. I manager graduated from the UOP..and i believed he is an excellent manager. He is not engineer, however, he leads a whole grp of engineers including me.

I believed one is in you, it doesn;t matter the school you gradute from. Unfortunately we live in a world that does looks at that. It is your job to prove them wrong. If you are good at what you do, it doesnt matter you show that pride very up high, and fight for your degree.

I manager has my respect, not because he is my manager but because he knows how to lead. There are many techs in my area who know their job very well. Do i cared where they graduated from? not one bit..because they have proven to me that they know their stuff very well.

Concentrate on getting the first step into the door.

by ljkinder

Sorry, Karen. But, some of the most prestigious companies pay TUITION REIMBURSEMENT for UOP, so I don't think it's because of UOP. Willingness to START AT THE BOTTOM, pay dues, work hard, work smarter, and provide solutions is how to get advancement: appreciating that advice, will tell you whether or not you are promotion material.

by amoore

I understand your dilemma. I am not in the IT field but I do expect my team members to be well established in their fields of skill. To answer your question, I would hire a person from UOP because it still takes someone with dedication to push through the hard work to graduation. However if they are applying with only the degree in their hopper and no experience, I would most likely hire the other applicant which has years of experience and no degree. My advise to you, if you really want the company to take you seriously, start taking on projects in your own time. Books you think your "boss" would want to see you reading to help you improve your chances for the promotion to IT, leave them out on your desk where he can see them. Not so much he would think you are making it obvious but enough where he might ask you about it. Then, you are smooth sailing for explaining how much you do know. Or read them at your desk at lunch time where everyone can see you. Employers want someone who is self-starting and takes initiative. Little tricks like this can make them think they made a wrong choice in your job position. They will add you to their metal list and start noticing what you do know. This is when you can start shining with your knowledge.

by suzitech

A masters of IS degree is not a technical degree, though, but more like a business-related degree. It gives you rounded-out knowledge in things like managerial communication and the like. You're expected to already have somewhat of a technical background before you attempt an MIS at any school. Frankly, most of the MS-certified people I know only know the things when a book is placed in front of their nose. None of them are capable of working in a real-world environment.

by wingedadmin

I have taken lots of formal education classes. Including top Liberal Arts, Military Training, highly ranked CS schools, online, and ITT tech (not in that order), and I have a few certs and 5 years of experience.

Anyone, within reason, can pass any class if they have the desire. When is the last time you actually had a discriminating professor that had the guts to say "I just don't think you are smart enough to get by in the real world. Sure you finished all the assignments and got a 70 on the final, but rather than pass you with a C, I think I will fail you to prevent future hiring managers from giving you a shot"?

Maybe this goes on at Stanford, MIT and others, but in all of my experience a below average learner will pass.

by wingedadmin

The military is not for everyone, but if you want experience this is the place to go. Just make sure you know what job you are getting.

by asydoriak

I have over 10 years experience in the IT field and for that entire time I have had no degree.

I am about to complete my BSIT degree from UoP.

What you are telling me is you would "winnow" me right into the trash because I have the degree, but if I left it off you would give me a chance?

Sorry, but eliminating someone based on any school but keeping them if they have none is... odd.

by jhogue1

Even when transfering from an accredited school, credit is not automatic. We sometimes go so far as to request a course syllabus from the original school to see what was actually covered rather than what was in the course catalogue.

by jmgarvin

Many "traditonal" colleges offer online degrees, how do you know if they physically went to the school?

Online degrees have this strange love/hate relationship and people don't seem to understand that "real" schools offer them.

by jmgarvin

No wonder IT is a mess, HR is killing us.

By killing off UoP grads and probably other, you are limiting your canidate pool to those with the experience that might not be the best fit.

What if you had a UoP canidate that had the EXACT experience that you needed, but a degree from UoP, would you still throw it out?

What about the non-name brand schools that put out excellent quality (eg New Mexico Tech is the first place Sandia Labs and LANL look for scientist)? Would they get tossed in the trash too, just because you'd never heard of the school?

by apotheon

It doesn't matter how good the UoP candidate is: the resume gets thrown out. The reason is that the previous poster never notices anything on the resume on the first pass other than the school, and a UoP grad's resume would end up in the trash before anyone really looked at it.

Great plan. Yeah?

Could you imagine throwing out a resume belonging to the next Turing, Kernighan, or Wozniak without ever realizing it? I guess the upside is that you don't know what you're missing.

. . . unless you remember the name at the top of the resume years later, when the next Alonzo Church is making headlines. At that point, you just hope nobody else in the company remembers that you threw away his resume because he went to UoP, else you'll end up flipping burgers.

by madtechgirl

So where have you been in terms of job searching lately? Now HR uses tools that throw out resumes that don't fit their criteria exactly before a human ever reads them. I don't like it either but that's what is happening unless you apply to a small company that doesn't use an automated HR tool yet. It certainly is possible that hiring managers are missing out on some real talent.

If a UoP graduate had EXACTLY everything I needed I would interview them but it has been my experience that none of them have. When I see a school I haven't heard of I research it. As I said in my first post - I looked up UoP and realized it was a bullshit school.

by gerald80

But in the end many of the comments are part wrong in the sense that the degree no matter where it is from just gets you into the door. I live in San Diego and I have had neumerous interviews for high paying jobs. currently i am in the BSISS program and i currently work for NOKIA Mobile phones and mke well over $60k base salary. To those who care stick to your guns and understand the theory behind it and the rest will work out. In the end many will complain about the college attended but people opinions are like assess every one got's one. P.S. my manager has a degree from MIT and I am not impressed at all just something to pump your chest and be in debt over your head.

BR
Gerald

by jmgarvin

The problem with transfer credits is that it boils down to: if the Registrar wants to take them, they will, if they don't, they won't.

by too old for it

A lot of employers have torupble hiring ex-military people.

Seems they are too honest, tend to do the "right thing" rather than screw over the customer.

That and they don't play the office/corporate politics game very well.

(USMC 1974-1978)

by apotheon

You just described the basis for every conflict of personality I've ever had with corporate management.

US Army, 1994-1998

by jmgarvin

No wonder the corporate world and I don't get along so well...

US Army 1993-1997 (US Army NG 1997-2000)

(I was a 31C Single Channel Commo (also reclased to a 31M and 31K "by the needs of the gov't))

by sarge62436

Not only are veterans "too honest" and prone to "doing the right thing", we also have a bad habit (according to corporate clone manager types) of GETTING THINGS DONE.......in spite of all the "roadblock" policies, procedures, and processes....

US Army 1989-1994

by ljackson

You can say that again.

US Navy 1963-1985

Other negative stuff ... I'm over 50. That doesn't help at all.

by navy moose

I thought it was just me not dealing with office politics very well.

IT3 US Navy Reserve 2001-2003
SrA US Air Force Reserve 2003 - Present

by laconvis

The mitilary is full of "corporate politics". I feel that to make it through you hitch you have to play the game, ie corporate politics.

The problem that I see with some of the military experienced people is an issue of "best fit". Because of the strigent rules and ideals it makes it difficult for them to interact with the general office staff. Tone down the "right thing" rhetoric and work on fitting in with the non-veterans lax view.

by michael.w.mcdougal

This is absolutely the wrong attitude to have. Being at the executive level in the military you need to focus on the mission and bring processes that will indeed enhance the ability to complete each task at hand. Empower your employees to search and bring solutions to the table and do not be afraid to state why a certain course of action will not work. Be sure to offer an alternative solution as well. If you perceive something is not right then make your stand. Never settle for the norm and remember there is no "I" in Team.

by vcox

I disagree wiht the statement "The students with 4-year university degree have gone through much tougher fundamental CS and science courses, and have had countless sleepless nights for the most basic computer programming, assembly, OS, network programming, etc." That's a misnomer. I obtained my BSIS from an accredited college attending both online and traditional courses, and the online courses were by far much tougher than the traditional ones. The value of either is determined by things like class criteria; the professor teaching the course; the school offering the course; the system used to deliver the course; and, of course, the student's ability to learn.

In my area (Massachusetts) the best schools all offer online courses in the IS degree programs. As far as I can tell, comanies around here do not favor traditional degrees over online degrees as there is no basis for determining one from the other.

by gralfus

I am a graduate of UOP, and the most frustrating part (outside of a couple of incompetent instructors) was the group grade. Just like back in high-school, there were people who work hard and others who coast in on the work of others. I only had a few such experiences, but they were frustrating. And the person who graduates with such behavior still has the same degree I have.

So the degree is a starting point, but in any interview you should ask pertinent questions to see if the candidate knows his/her stuff, as opposed to just seeing UOP and deciding against the candidate.

by nuskool

You are right about UOP being structured for people already working looking for a better position. I am glad you are not the coattail type because that means that there is hope for you yet.

Many people find it hard getting into their field and alot of people end up getting into a career not even related to what they study for. Not only in IT.

I would keep applying, have you tried career development centers? Out here in Los Angeles, CA we have Worksource. They tell you to go to school, teach you math skills and how to create a resume (I'm positive you already know how to do this), but one other thing they do is help people with career changes. Staffing agencies such as AppleOne should also be able to get you a job that will get your foot in the door.

Just some additional suggestions.

by jmgarvin

I wonder how many other HR folks do this. I mean if it isn't name brand or a school they "approve" of, then what does that mean for the canidate pool? Honestly, have you ever passed up someone that looked like a good fit with experience and skill set just because they graduate from [insert university here]

It also drives me batty that I now have to put a keywords section on the resume just to make it past the filters. Insane. It seems like HR isn't looking for the right canidate, but the easiest.

by the admiral

I think that is a weak arguement since you are telling me that you are more than likely to respond to a Manpower survey rather than answer three questions about a potential candidate.

Since you are a hiring manager, and you have failed to provide that information, you are lacking in what your job duties are. It is your duty to let them know that you did not feel the skills/experience were a match.

Unless you are a form feed hiring manager, then that would explain that attitude. The company is looking for A and you have A and you did not hire A, so not you have to tell A why you chose B. Plain and simple.

It is OK. When I was doing the job search, unless it was a thick envelope, it went right into the trash.

by apotheon

That's exactly what they're looking for: the easiest. HR departments are about efficient narrowing of the field to acceptable-on-paper candidates, and if they're allowed to do interviews, those are geared toward covering the HR department's collective ass.

by apotheon

"[i]It certainly is possible that hiring managers are missing out on some real talent.[/i]"

I can damned well [b]guarantee[/b] that hiring managers are missing out on some real talent because of HR procedures and tools. I've seen it happen with my own two eyes. I've been on both ends of HR departments (though, thankfully, never [b]in[/b] them), and their ability to sort for something meaningful has (if it ever existed) long ago atrophied.

By the way, I'm absolutely stunned by your incredible diligence in "looking up" UoP and using that to judge graduates.

The real world isn't effectively represented by the crap you have spelled out on paper. Of all the corporate-employed professional fields, in fact, IT may well be the the profession least susceptible to accurate measurement by resume bullet points.

Frankly, I could probably replace your average HR department with one webpage, one data entry operator, and two Perl scripts, for purposes of finding the next IT employment candidate -- if I wanted the same results, that is. If I just wanted the same effectiveness without the exact same results, I'd just burn two out of every three resumes.

This sort of broken-ass logic is the same sort of thing that sees Java chosen for jobs to which it is entirely unsuited, deadline deathmarches, and technical decisions made on the strength of vendor advertising copy.

by techmngr

I'm sorry to say that UOP has never offered a PhD in Web Development. You must have UOP confused with another school.

by lorddragondan

Sounds like your from Springfield.
Yes we have many Colleges here. People go online for other reasons though. Time, travel, convience, disabilities, family. I have young kids and a wife that works. Evening daycare is not an option. Problem is some online schools are a rip-off. This taints things for all the others since some employers don't differentiate between good schools and bad. There are differences between brick and mortor campuses and some aren't very good. But what is a good online school? I'm thinking of going back online but finding a good school is difficult. Be sure to check out the accreditation.

by techmngr

If anyone would not hire you just because you went to UOP then you probably wouldn't want to work for them anyway. The whole point of a completing a college degree is to get your foot in the door. You are now 'qualified' to enter the interview process for a given position. I am a hiring manager in a Fortune 500 company and to be honest I could care less where a person went to school. I only look to see if they have completed the prerequisites for the position. IMHO, where you went to school has zero impact on how you will perform on the job. I actually admire those who complete a degree online/part-time while working full time. It shows dedication and perseverance. I would definitely hire a UOP grad without hesitation if they met the requirements for the position.

by jmgarvin

I just take the key words from the job posting and I'll get an interview. As long as I match the key words and stupid filtering, I'm fine.

Little hint, if you see a posting for a sys admin just put in these key words:
Windows, Windows 2000, Windows 2003, Microsoft, Unix, Linux, Oracle, and Cisco

by aldanatech

Pascal in College?! These days?! That's pretty darn outdated all right. I actually took a Pascal course in High School back in the early 90s. Even back then it was considered outdated, but still it did help me better understand how programming in general works. It seems that some Colleges today are really starting to slack off. My recommendation to everyone is to do your homework and study the schools you plan to attend in detail, no matter how popular or prestigious the institution might be. This would include examining their degree plans, course descriptions, and if possible, some feedback from current and former students. Don't get me wrong, I know there are many really good universities out there, but since you're going to spend all that time and money on a degree, you should at least know what you're getting yourself in to.

by vpomar

A UOP degree is acceptable, but what you have to understand is that UOP IS NOT a technical school. I don't know what your level of experience was before you enroll at UOP, but if you expected to go there and become an expert in IT...you went to the wrong place.
Now, if you did have plenty of experience and got a degree at UOP, I would hire you in a second.

by pigpen702

Two things....

I received a BSBIS degree (BS Business Info Systems) degree from UOP 7 years ago. I did the majority of my degree in the classroom in San Jose, Phoenix, and Detroit. I was a trave3ling consultant from the Silicon Valley world and their program was fine by me. YOU get out what you put in. I was on a corporate plan so the cost was not MY issue. I did appreciate the one night / week classroom with the group study format. I worked very hard and graduated with a 3.98 GPA. I could have easily slid by with a 2.8 but that is not my nature.

The second thing is that I already had 15 years of technical experience and was transitioning from Mechanical Engineering to IT. I became an analyst and then moved into Project Management. I will tell all of the doubting types on this post that the UOP IS instructors in San Jose were QUITE well qualified. They are facilitators, not professors. They come from industry, not full time teachers. Some could teach; some could not. They did all have knowledge, just had to adjust the method of extraction from one to the next.

UOP is ONLY designed for working adults and for continuing education. It was not created for the first time student, but for the corporate worker attending night school for another degree. The only two online courses (Directed study) I attended were accounting and finance. They are difficult courses no matter where they are taught! Same is true off statistics. I would go on to relate that calculus us the same at the U of Tennessee and Georgia Tech the schools I attended for my BS Mechanical Engineering degree! A few of the courses were quite challenging, but I busted my rear and I learned plenty.

UOP or not UOP? First time student - NOT; Professional trying to transition of move up - Maybe. It is completely up to the student what you get out of the school!

by jhogue1

"Professional trying to transition of move up - Maybe. It is completely up to the student what you get out of the school!"

The original question here was about the employability of UofP grads not about how much was or was not learned.

Since statistically most folks change employers several times, the fact that a particular employer will accept UofP is not a valid point. A great many hiring pros think that UofP is a diploma mill. If your degree is going to enhance your chances of getting the job you really want, you need a degree that is accepted by ALL the HR people not just some of them.

Part of the problem is UofP's agressive marketing but a great deal of the problem is students not doing their "homework" on schools before starting an expensive and time consuming program.

There are a lot of "brick and mortar" universities that have online degree programs. It only costs some time and maybe a few phone calls to check them all out.

by anniemae46

...right! Prospective students should carefully review the curriculum. I considered UOP's BSIT curriculum diverse and a good fit for me because it also focuses on IT business requirements and management. It has a broad focus on design and development of systems in various business situations, following concepts such as systems development cycle, OSI model, contrast studies along with basic programming, networking, and much more. BUT, it does not at all make you, e.g., a systems administrator (unless you already are one..).

by asydoriak

So why don't you post the job with something like "Four year degree required from a school I approve of. Experience level not applicable"?

It's nice that, in your capacity as an HR person, you know not only the quality of education from all colleges, but how that education has been used by each potential applicant.

by gyuris

Simple question with a simple answer about employability:
Take two canddates for the same job, both equally experienced with the same certs, same age, same personality, and same geeky looks.
One has an IT degree, say, from MIT. The other has an IT degree from UoP. Which one would you hire?
Case closed

by anniemae46

I see your point but that's not a realistic case example--other than suggesting that alumni is a heavy weight to take on. In that case, I could have a degree from all kinds of U's and still face the same challenge. And anyway, I assume that many MIT guys go very different routes (alumni connections, self-employment, hired right out of MIT, etc.). In the end a lot is up to a person's own desire and timing. One problem at UOP is that many don't really get to network or establish close ties like some of the fellow alumns at other institutions.

by jhogue1

I think we have a couple of issues here:

1. Unfortunately many times the ability to do a job does not directly relate to getting hired for that job. Looking good on the resume is critical to getting interviewed. If you don't get a chance to sell yourself and your abilities nothing else matters.

2. The quality of UofP instruction is questionable. The actual quality of UofP is not really the issue. The perception of that quality by HR people is the issue. As long as that perception remains UofP grads will sometimes have difficulty - especailly in a very highly competative job market.

by gyuris

IMHO, An UofP degree is fine if you already have an IT job and are looking to enhance your stature or maybe qualify for a promotion within the company.
However, if you are trying to use the UoP degree to get that very first job, you will be at a disadvantage vs other candidates from traditional universities with accredited IT programs.
Even though your studied hard and poured your heart and soul (and money) into that UoP degree, the perception outside is that the UoP degree is not as valuable. This perception maybe completely erroneous, but it is there. This is unfortunate, but most often "perception is reality" for the folks hiring.
Even though UoP has been around for many years and there are many fine graduates from there, that general perception still has not changed.
The UoP degree is controversial and this thread proves my point. You won't find this kind of thread questioning the value of an IT degree from, say, MIT or Caltech or even USC.

by jhogue1

You may be right that with your UofP degree, you could win in an interivew situation but first you have to get past the HR director. Every HR person I have ever met, thinks they are overworked and too busy. They need to very quickly go thru 100 applications to pick a few to interview. On paper a traditional degree looks better than UofP to a lot of HR folks.

by laconvis

As has been mentioned several times, it is important to check out the college or university you plan to attend. Find out about the ability to transfer credits, reputation of school, experience level of teachers, acceptance in career field. These are the same things that my friends children are being told as they are on their way to selecting schools. It is an investment of time and money and you want to make sure you get the dividends from this investment.

There is no easy way through school. Take it from me I am working on my first degree after being gainfully employed in the IT field for 28 years. For my studies in my area I quickly ruled out both University of Phoenix and ITT Tech. One of the first clues that they were less than normal schools, when I asked for information all they did was hound me to enroll. If they were quality schools wouldn't they have more than enough people waiting to attend their schools. After 30+ phone calls from each school I informed them they were to put me on their do-no-call list. These telemarketing tactics led me to believe they were less than credible.

Many reputable schools offer online degrees. Personally I don't think that you receive the broad knowledge base you would have received in a classroom lecture.

Of course this is just my opinion.

by jhogue1

Online education is the wave of the future but some things are more some suited to distance learning that others.

Would you like to have heart surgery from a doctor who took the course online?

Would you rather have a tech repairing your critical network who took network troubleshooting on line or a tech who walked in to class several times a week to find the lab network broken in a new and creative way?

Of course, you would rather have someone who had spent 20+ years in the networking trenches but you are needing to fill a vacant position.

by jmgarvin

All schools have reps that are bad. You have to realize that schools hire recruiters (salesmen) and the tech folks aren't on the front end. This goes for any school. I think you might have gotten a bad recruiter for ITT as they are supposed to help you and see if the school fits your needs.

I can tell you that ITT in Albuquerque has a very good reputation.

When we gratuate people with their AA, they are ready to go out and be entry level admins and they really know their stuff. They know Cisco, Windows, and Linux backwards and forwards. They know how to subnet (something I can say I didn't know how to do out of college), setup DNS, DHCP, and a little bit of security knowledge (basic stuff).

If they continue on to get their BS they'll pick up stuff like snort, iptables, risk analysis, forensics, vlans, vwans, large network security, policy writing, etc.

I'm not ITT is a good fit for all, but I know in Albuqueruque my fresh graduates will own any other fresh graduates in IT knowledge.

by jeffp

I thought maybe I could help with this topic a little on several points.

First off, I'm a 10-year Navy veteran (92-02) who worked in electronic intelligence, I have a Master's Certificate in Music Production and Technology from Berklee (online) and I've got a BS in Computer Science from a state university.

I obviously had to work really hard to finish all that; I had knocked out most prerequisites for my degree by the time I got out so it was just a matter of doing all the Calculus and CS classes. I finished with my BS and my Berklee degree at the same time and had almost no problem finding a job in IT since I had worked part time on campus doing IT support.

So now one of my many responsibilities is all the hiring and firing(oh joy!). We've had a few ITT grads come through as well as a UoP grad and we didn't hire any of them. They couldn't answer a simple question about data structures (i.e. "what is a linked list?") and had no relevant experience with working as a team on a large software engineering project - something most CS graduates are intimately familiar with due to capstones.

There is a feeling that potential hires with traditional degrees have common experiences with the rest of the staff. It was mentioned elsewhere that most CS students are familiar with all-nighters spent coding or debugging some insignificant program. It's something we all have in common in our background. Like it or not, it gives them a leg-up on the competition.

About the online degree...

I once had a dream of working in a recording studio, hence I got my degree online from Berklee, a very respected school. On its own, it is worth almost nothing. But combined with another degree, it enabled me to get the job I have working in R&D for audio-processing applications.

My military background was pretty much worthless and we do not really even take a person's military experience into account when considering them for employment. They are usually too specialized in a field that has little in common with our own.

by nuskool

"They couldn't answer a simple question about data structures (i.e. "what is a linked list?") and had no relevant experience with working as a team on a large software engineering project"

There are good teachers and there are good students at ITT but many students are lazy and they are allowed to get away with it which affects there employability and the schools reputation.

I had to look up what a linked list was, probably because I received my associates in Computer Networks not Software Development but still I am disapointed I did not know what it was.

Putting that aside I did take a VB course and I did spend sleepless nights debugging code but, most students just downloaded the answers from the books website and couldn't understand why I would "waste" my time trying to figure out how to do something when I could just download it, turn it in, and get the full credit for the assignment.

Like others have said you get what you put in and it'll show in the interview.

by jmgarvin

If they don't know the material it will show on my quizzes, homework, and in class questions. It's amazing how fast students learn the material when you ask them the tough question in front of all the others and wait for them to answer.

by mdhealy

> They couldn't answer a simple question about
> data structures (i.e. "what is a linked list?")

Now *that* is rather shocking: at places with which I am familiar, the SECOND programming course will include linked lists (when I was an undegraduate they taught FORTRAN, C, and PASCAL, now at most places it will be Java (except MIT where they emphasize LISP), the concepts are still the same but reference-based data structures are WAY easier in Java than in those older languages).

by apotheon

The very name "linked lists" makes their nature obvious to anyone that knows what a "list" is, and has the ability to think through the implication of the term.

by jmgarvin

LISP and Scheme are both friggin' messes of languages that should only be used to torture the odd student that forgets to turn in their homework.

You know what LISP stands for? Lost in Stupid Parentheses. ;-)

by nuskool

Teachers like you were rare at the campus I went to. I could think of a handful of teachers that did actually challenge the students and they were thought of as @$$h0le$ among the student body.

by kjell_andorsen

I've been looking into some online colleges as they seem to be the most viable solution for me. I'm currently employed in IT and have a nice little collection of Certs. I have my resume up on Monster and get calls from recruiters on a fairly regular basis, but I lack a degree.

I've been looking at Western Governor's University, they're quite a bit cheaper than UoP and include 9 different certifications as a part of their BSIT program which I found to be a big plus. It's also a not for profit college and regionally accredited.

Has anyone had any experience with this school and it's competyency based model? I'd be curious to see how it could help me

by gyuris

Unfortunately most recruiters are going to say Western Govern...WHAT?
If their perception is that it is little known school, or a cake walk school (even though it may not be), then they won't think much the diploma mainly because the admmission requirements to it are not at all competitive.
However if you already have a job and are looking to get a promotion within the company then it might be worth it.

by vpomar

Is WGU a certified school? Ask to see their certification, without it, any degree from them is worth zip. UoP is certified

by jhogue1

The whole theme of this thread is that even though UofP is certified their reputation in many HR departments is still questionable.

I would never attend an uncertified school but a wise person would also seek out a school with a reputation that is at the very least neutral and idealy positive.

by kjell_andorsen

It is an acreddited school. Regional accredidation through the Northwest Commission on Colleges and Universities and nationally accredited by Distance Education and Training Council. It was the brainchild of former Utah Governor Mike Leavitt in conjunction with 18 other Governors of the Western United states as a low-cost online alternative to for-profit schools such as UoP. They also have some pretty large tech companies comprising their National advisory board such as Microsoft, Sun, Dell and google.

It's kind of a new school, but their program seems interesting and very competency driven, I really like their focus on also obtaining certifications during the course of getting the degree.

by jhogue1

There are a lot of traditional brick and mortar Universities with online degree programs. You are not limited to a strictly online school with a shaky or unknown reputation. You are going to spend a lot of time and money on a degree. It might be wise to spend a little more of both at a more known and respected school.

Are the engrance requirements tougher? Probably.
Is the degree worth more in the market place? That is a question you will have to answer for yourself.

by delmonte

I'm a graduate of WGU. Credits are earned through testing and projects. In order to pass the competency you must perform at a level
comparable to "B" level work in a B & M school.

If you enroll, you will be assigned a mentor who will work closely with you to keep you on track. WGU is very affordable. You pay about $2700 every 6 mos. and can attempt as many competencies as you are able in that time frame.

If you have any specific questions, I'll be happy to try to answer them.

by prichusa

I attend WGU and I have been enrolled at UOP. WGU, is far a better school, however it is much more difficult as far as work. With your certs you have a good chance to waive a good portion of your classes.
You will be assinged a Mentor that wil help you, very much.
The great thing is you pay a flat rate for tuition and you can do as many credits you can handle for the same price.
I hope this helps.

by vpomar

I am really sorry you had that experience with those graduates from UoP, but the fact is that you take out of any school, what you put into it. Are all UoP grads geniuses? NO, are all of them unqualified? No.
As I posted in a previous note, I would hire any UoP grad who shows me he/she had plenty of experience within IT. UoP enhances your knowledge, but if you go to UoP expecting to learn about IT and had no previous experience in the field, then you are not going to benefit from it. I wish UoP would make that distinction very clear before they enroll students in their classes.
Have experience in IT? have a degree from UoP? yes, I would hire you (if I had any openings that is :) ), but I certainly would.

by pigpen702

So I graduated from UT with a BS in Aerospace Engineering. I guess that would be a big plus for your Austin based company!

OOPS, this resume says "UT" but they are lying... they are from Tennessee. I guess the University of Tennessee would not suit your automated system while it does in fact have one of the best Aerospace Engineering programs in the world.

So much for your bogus attitude, may you hire the candidates you disirve.

Oh yea by the way, I did also graduate from UoP San Jose, CA. I guess that would count me out!

by pigpen702

Your HR filtering system might be a database type thing, probably like PeopleSoft...

In San Jose I attended UoP. My database courses we3re facilitated by a guy with a little background in database design... Briefly: He began with IBM, rose to the leadership within the DB2 creation team, and received a call to join a small start-up in California. This guy was employee number 16 of the little company to soon become "PeopleSoft". So I guess my poorly qualified UoP instructor was the original database designer / developer of the very system that would kick out my resume! HUMMMMM... It must really STINK to be an HR type!

by markisaaca

A degree from UOP or MCSE from Microsoft does not determine the worth or knowledge of the student. Many have stated a truth that is commonly overlooked, "Knowledge is gained when an effort is given". The greatest minds, past and present, can make knowledge available to you. You the student are task with absorbing that knowledge.

I am a manager who has worked in the Information System field for more than 11 years. I believe most managers, including myself, believe that a degree demonstrates motivation and paints a picture of a person that seeks to improve and reinvent. A degree will usually get you through the door to an interview. Your actions during the interview will determine success or failure.

Please continue to seek knowledge in the classroom (Brick and Mortar or Online) by way of certification (CCIE, MSCE, Network+?..) or self study. Knowledge is a vital tool. Good luck to all and have learning. Have a good evening.

by falconeer

? it also helps to spell . I see you?re the same type of speller that I am.

My spelling, in places, is ?appalling? (although I instantly recognize my, and others, mistakes) so I keep Word loaded and use it to keep mistakes to a minimum. (might be a little ?anal? but it definitely is a quirk of mine).

Punctuation is a whole different matter though.

?Mathmatics? ≈ mathematics and ?feild? ≈ field, ??I? before ?e? except after ?c?? I never miss.

See
http://www.jimloy.com/language/ibeforee.htm
for the 'strangeness'.

Isn?t English a ?strange? language?

I?m sure there?s no need to emphasize to the originator of our ?ire? that, during more ?formal? written communications they need to make sure their spelling is im-peckable.

by pigpen702

We are an Open Source house... We do have some Cisco equipment, but NOTHING Microsofty. Supercomputers and .NET don't seem to be compatible. As successful as I am, I guess UoP was good to me.

My years at GA Tech are still a blur, but UoP is quite clear. Adult education is not the same as K-16-18 but the student is not the same either.

Brick and mortar vs. online: my UoP was in the classroom in San Jose with some very talented "facilitators". I cannot express an opinion of the value of an online degree. I didn't see any reference to "on-line" in the original post? UoP has some 60 brick and mortar campuses... The classroom is set up more like a conference room... Yup it sounds too much like business reality for the ?cert? carryin? folks.

Business skills = significant advancement PERIOD.

by jmaldonado5

I too went to UOP for a while, until I realized they are thieves! I got smart and changed universities early enough to finally earn my degree from the American Intercontinental University Online.

First thing you should do is get in some kind of entry level IT job if you can, after you gain some experience in the field, your degree will be a solid selling asset to getting a job more commesurate with your abilities. I started that way after graduation, now I am on my way to becoming the IT Project Manager for a major city.

Be patient and concentrate on building yuor career to complement your degree, show hiring companies that, while UOP is perceived as a degree mill (nicely put by you), you really earned yours by working hard and they will be lucky to have you.

Good Luck!

JAM

by mtolab

have been working for this company for 7 years, I got my MBA from Keller about 2 years ago. I am still in the same position for the last 5 years and didn't move up. our main office is in Denver which where I applied for about 32 postings for last 1 1/2. no call back from any hiring managers. What do you guys think the problem is? is it where got my MBA from? Because it is not a well known school?

by crockejw

A foot in the door is always a chance to prove yourself. Of course, I worked for a large defense contractor for about 8 years, and I saw a lot of more-than-qualified people passed over for promotions, and many total suck-ups promoted when they honestly were barely functionally literate. At that job, it wasn't what you knew, it was who you knew, and how well you knew them! So, as with all things, it is a matter of finding the right job at the right time.

by markisaaca

What does a person?s human flaws have to do with UOP? Her character would have been the same whether she attended a high or low rated college. Please state the relevant fact.

by 38droy

Hi Karen,
Like you, I wonder about the degrees from UOP. I just started my first course a couple weeks ago and plan on quitting. I've been reading a lot of info on the web about this school and all of the lawsuits going on against them.
Now, I'm also wondering about their degrees. Are they worth anything ??
I'm gonna find out somehow but in the meantime, I'm just gonna quit this so-called flexnet course.
Thanks for speaking your mind because it caught my eye and hope many other people will also agree.
Dave

by dspeacock

I have been in the industry for 16 years now, after returning to college and getting an Associates degree. Since then, I have advanced up the ladder in various facets of the IT world to a management position responsible for a large non-profit's support organization. Along the way, I have kept up my continuing education (gaining another associate's degree) as well as a couple of certifications pertinent to my career at the time.

I've had prospective employers look at my AS degrees (even though they've specified a 4 year degree), experience and certs, and they've determined thatI meet or exceed the educational requirements for the position. A couple of them even considered my CISSP to be the equivalent of a Master's.

Nowadays, when I'm going through resumes looking for a candidate for a position, a BA/BS/AA/AS doesn't really get your foot in the door. Neither do certs. Attitude, experience and a willingness to do what's necessary will get you in my door.

What gets you right OUT of the door is the failure to spell correctly or write a coherent sentence or paragraph. The number of resumes and cover letters I've read that contained egregious grammatical and spelling errors is mind boggling. If you can't spell or write, I don't care if you have a PhD, I won't hire you.

The order of things I look at are:
1. Communications Skills
2. Attitude
3. Experience/Skills
4. Certifications
5. Degree or lack of one

Just one man's opinion.

by redleg_155

Karen,
The IT field is a different animal a degree does help but it needs backed by certifications. I feel your same pain. I have a Masters in IT but no certs. I suggest looking over and evaluated what part of IT do you want to specialize. Database, network, security are a few options then determine which cert supports that path. I have attended many online universities and 90% of my education is online. As long as the school is accreditted then the degree is valid. UoP has a valid credential and is not on probation like AIU.

George in FL

by jhogue1

You are missing the original point of this thread. UoP is acredited so the degree is valid.

But how marketable and valuable is a UoP degree to those making the hiring and salary decisions? If the reputation of the school is as a diploma mill with HR people, your chances of getting hired are less than another applicant with a degree from another school.

The critical question is not online vs face 2 face but the perceived reputation of the school to those making the hiring decisions. I sit on the hiring committee for all openings in our division. It will be interesting to hear the discussions the first time we get an applicant from UoP.

by apotheon

Oh, come on. That family of languages known as LISP (including Common Lisp, Scheme, and even Logo) is actually quite clean, elegant, powerful, and flexible. The fact you don't like ubiquitous parentheses and are more familiar with imperative programming in the C idiom doesn't change that.

LISP was, in fact, originally conceived of as using a syntax without all the parentheses. That syntax was known as an M-expression syntax. This syntax would be compiled to a parse tree, which would then be interpreted (executed) or further compiled to binary code before execution (depending on your platform). The M-expression syntax doesn't use ubiquitous parentheses, but rather a simply functional, list processing oriented syntax.

Initial implementations of the LISP platonic ideal used an S-expression syntax, essentially just parse trees in human-readable form -- similarly to the manner in which assembly language was created as a human-readable form of programming in hexadecimal, but with a much higher-level syntax and a far more interesting semantic form. The S-expression syntax incorporated parentheses to provide functional grouping to ease the process of implementation.

The idea was that the "fingernail clippings in oatmeal" S-expression syntax would be an intermediary step on the way to a usable M-expression syntax, but people found the S-expression syntax much easier to use effectively than was originally assumed. As a result, LISP caught on in popularity faster and more widely than expected. The S-expression syntax was incredibly easy to implement in an interpreter or compiler, and was quite easy enough for LISP programmers to use to produce excellent code.

Because the S-expression syntax was "good enough", further development of the syntactic representation kind of stopped in that respect. There were easier, and more interesting, problems to solve than an M-expression implementation of LISP. After a while, the further translation of LISP to an M-expression language might have occurred, except that there was already a strong code base and community using S-expression syntax, and it became "the standard" for LISP. In other words, "good enough" became the enemy of "perfect", or of "just right". M-expression syntax was never implemented for mainstream LISP (in the form of Common Lisp and Scheme, primarily).

Eventually, however, someone actually did create an M-expression LISP. It's called Logo. The reasons this did not sweep aside S-expression LISPs are mostly three-fold:

1. A great many people are heavily invested in their S-expression LISPs. They don't [i]want[/i] an M-expression LISP to take over.

2. Logo's early implementations were far more limited than LISP in terms of functionality. For instance, the infamous macros associated with Common Lisp are absent in most implementations of Logo, and in fact there's nothing in the standard Logo specifications that suggests macros are a part of the language. Eventually, UCBLogo was created at UC Berkeley, complete with macro support, but by then it was much too late (for reasons outlined in point 3 of this list). Much of the reason for the decreased power of Logo in most implementations is tied up in the fact that when Logo was created, it was created and billed as an "educational" language, and not as a "real" programming language. Because of the educational intent, it was determined that (like BASIC) it did not need the more powerful characteristics of other general purpose languages. This leads nicely into the third point.

3. Logo is a victim of its own success. Because Logo was so successful as the educational programming language of choice for many educators, and was so widely evangelized as the tool to use for teaching children to program, it has become widely regarded as a child's programming language. People don't think of it as a serious language, despite the fact that with a little more library and tool support UCBLogo could run circles around most of the "serious" programming languages in use today. It may, in fact, essentially be the most faithful implementation of the original LISP idea yet created -- because it's LISP with an M-expression syntax -- and one of the most powerful languages available, in and of itself. The fact that it was billed as an educational language, however, and that nobody has made any serious attempt to use it for more "serious" purposes and to actually get the point across that it is a "serious" programming language rather than just a child's toy (and that damnable "turtle" didn't help in this regard) is the major problem with Logo's lack of viability in "real world" programming.

If you want a LISP implementation that won't get you "lost in stupid parentheses", perhaps you should give UCBLogo a look. There's a trilogy of programming and computer science textbooks available online that use UCBLogo as the example language, too, so you can learn the language sufficiently for real-world use quite easily. These books are designed for college students, not children, so don't worry that they won't be up to snuff for adults trying to learn something useful.

by michael_yau_canada

I am currently working on my MIS/M at UoP and I think the online school is good for the people who have experience in the industry.
To be honest with you, I did not do good in school when I was working on my Bachelor at University of Torornto. However, a person attended a brand name university does not reflect on his or her ability to work. In order to be a good worker, the worker might not need to be a smart guy but he or she must be accountable and responsible toward his or her job...

by arthy_0686

Hai

I'm planning to do my masters in UOP(MBA)
i'm an international student and will that help me get H1.
USCIS Accepts University of Phoenix for filing H1.

by jasonkernan

I have many years in the traditional colleges that we speak of. I had a scholarship to play baseball at a division 1 school. And I went there for a time . The scholarship was an academic one first and then sports... So I excelled at the college level in academics, I did not graduate from the school at the time.. Then I went on to pursue my degree at U of P. I can tell you this, I learned far more from my experience at U of P than any college or university I had been to. The curriulum that I had was right on with the curriculum that I had at the other universities. It was far more a better learning experience... Period. That may be age related, or not. But the education I got at U of P was far better than I got at state sponsored schools. I learned far more from them than I even did before. That may be from growing older but I did learn more. And I credit them to this day for my promotion in my field. I would have not got their if it was not for U of P..... Excellent education... you learn from what you put in. If you are not willing to put in much, well you might be dissapointed.

by jmaldonado5

Start by getting a job as a tech. Unfortunately in the world of IT, many people have to start at the bottom, because experience counts more than a piece of paper, regardless of what University you attended.

My 2 cents

by bdist

Dear Mr Zhong. I am glad to hear from someone in a position such as yourself. I am currently enrolled through the famous online university. no names for bias reasons. The question i have is when you went to a real university were your programm courses all lectures in a room of dozens of people? Did you have to learn all the material yourself? or was there plenty of help around all the time to help you? The online courses feel like you are being rushed through a meat market and not fullfilling. Plus there is no hands on. Main point of question. 2 poeople interviewed. 1 interviewed not so good with a real degree. The other interviewed great form an online school but lacks any hands on exp. who would you choose for the position?

Brian

by bdist

Does all course work from LA tech trensfer to USC? Anywho i am enrolled at the BSIT/SE at UOP. i feel like i am not learning anything. I turned in a paper that a second grader would have laughed at and still got an A on it. DO you feel the same way about your courses?

by jerry8888

I guess I shouldn?t be surprised at this narrow minded view of UOP, and it seems that downplaying the value of this school has been a popular past time for many in the IT field. Regardless, short of name calling (degree mill), and vague comparisons (not as good as others), I have yet to hear any real valid arguments against attending an online university.

Will some people graduate with poor skill? Sure, but this can be said of every university in the country; especially if this student happens to be good at sports.

On the contrary, I have heard many valid points concerning the value of an online degree, such as flexible hours, instructors with ?real world experience?, and a much more demanding work ethic.

Understandably, there are those of us who feel that online universities are a poor substitute for a more traditional university, but please try to at least prove some fact to back up your assumptions. Hint: Finger pointing and name calling just shows a lack of understands on the subject.

by uopchump

I don't think the degree is bogus, but it's not going to prepare somebody for an entry-level IT job. It's only good for somebody who is already in IT and their employer wants them to have a "degree in IT" for a guaranteed promotion, to teach a class of kindergarten kids how to play math games (after getting a teaching certification), or to say that you have a college degree so you may beat out the high school kid for that last job opening at McDonald's.

I have one of these typically useless BSIT degrees from the UofP -- do yourself a favor and either find a real school (ask IT companies) or spend the money on the sports car of your choice. I now have student loans to pay off and I curse writing the check every month. The "degree" is buried in the closet somewhere but I wouldn't hang it up to even cover a hole in the wall.