Discussion Locked

high school geography teacher goes nuts

0 helpful
206 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

206 replies

by absolutely

I think I have slightly more posts on this thread than you, but you obviously have an opinion that you have judged worthy of publishing, so why shouldn't we, who live in the United States, state our opinions, you Canadian you?

by absolutely

"I believe that the government has its place, [b]it allows us to not be ripped off by private doctors[/b], it allows us to regulate development of drugs and ensure such research is controlled and regulated, as are our doctors, patient care etc."

What government regulation put an end to private doctors ripping off their patients?

by absolutely

"Exremism to me isn't having a strong belief it's being unable to contemplate examining it to see if it still holds true."

I think the phrase "wearing blinders" fits that description better. Mohandas Gandhi was extremely peaceful. Stephen Hawking is extremely smart. Come on, dpetrak, what's wrong with extremism, really?

by tony hopkinson

Taking an extreme position generous, pacifist, mathematical, whatever. As in one not held by the majority.

Does this make you extremist, or does the desire to impose your belief system on others, as opposed to proselytising or not giving one.

Would you say your position on objectivism was extreme, or mine on socialism?

If Bennish had been instilling the virtues of objectivism, which is definitley a minority mindset, would you have considered him an extremist, or a sensible chap?

So are we talking extremist as in the dictionary definition or the pejorative label used by politicians.

by absolutely

"So are we talking extremist as in the dictionary definition or the pejorative label used by politicians."

Words have literal meanings (dictionary definitions). If politicians (or anybody) uses one or more words differently than their dictionary definitions, it may be interesting to define the difference between the real meaning(s) of the word(s) and the meaning in their deviant usage.

"If Bennish had been instilling the virtues of objectivism, which is definitley a minority mindset, would you have considered him an extremist, or a sensible chap?"

Ayn Rand once wrote, and I agree absolutely, that reality gives man just one "commandment": think. Whatever name you give to a philosophy that demands active exercise of the intellect as its first step, it is incompatible with the tone and carelessness with fact that Bennish exhibited on tape. So the premise of your question, Bennish instilling the virtues of objectivism, contains a crucial logical contradiction.

"Taking an extreme position generous, pacifist, mathematical, whatever. As in one not held by the majority.

Does this make you extremist, or does the desire to impose your belief system on others, as opposed to proselytising or not giving one."

The imposition of a belief system, however popular or unpopular, is tyranny, not extremism, although more extreme points of view tend to be ignored by populaces or imposed on them, never adopted voluntarily by many people. The difference between popularity and morality is the reason that charters of successful democratic governments include guarantees of individual freedom that serve as prohibitions of tyranny by the majority.

"Would you say your position on objectivism was extreme, or mine on socialism?"

I'd say my position on Objectivism is inconsistent: I have a tendency to be excessively emotional.

I have no idea how I would characterize your position on socialism in general. I'll agree or disagree with individual statements, but I don't remember enough of your posts to characterize you.

by cactus pete

What's your definition of extremism?

Now, what's your definition of extremism in a casual, but politically connected, discussion?

by absolutely

a code word used to dismiss, without consideration, any point of view substantially different than the one held by the speaker. The accused "extremist" is as often more moral than the accuser as less moral. Being called "extremist" could mean that I'm principled or that I'm a terrorist. In politically connected discussions, the word is so badly defined that it is irrelevant & meaningless.

by absolutely

Why does the United States poison other countries lethal drug crops [b]but[/b] not permit any foreign nations to poison our own crops that are [b]even more[/b] lethal?

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Why DOES the United States drop poison on the crops of farmers who are growing coca to supply a demand FROM THE UNITED STATES?"[/i]

Because it's illegal in the United States, and it finds its way into the country anyway; and it's also illegal in the country upon which the authorities are dropping poison to kill the plants, but it still finds its way out nonetheless; and because the United States is doing it with both the blessings and the support of the legitimate government of the countries in question.

To compare it to tobacco, and to put it in the same classification of tobacco is ludicrous. Tobacco is legal in both countries, and the U.S. government has given no other country permission to spray poison over North Carolina.

Find a substance that's illegal in both the United States and the country into which massive amounts of that substance is illegally smuggled into, and then make your argument.

[i]You said, "It's the farm lobby, the fattest of all the swine at the mother pig's teat."[/i]

No, it's the reason I stated.

Besides, the largest and most influential lobby in Washington is the NEA (the teachers union), not the farmers. The trial-lawyers probably are bigger than the farmers as well. I would even throw in the government employees lobby being bigger and wielding more influence than the farmers. Why not do some research and list the ten thousand plus lobby groups in the order of money and favorable legislation gained, or at least the top ten? (No, I won't do it because I didn't make the claim that the farmers are the biggest, you did.)

Disclaimer: I am in favor of legalizing most recreational drugs in the United States. But I try not to let my emotions run away with my sense of being reasonable, realistic, and accurate.

by absolutely

There was one student voice on the recording that was more audible than all the other students' voices. I assume that was the student who owned the recorder, and will continue with that assumption until told otherwise.

That student [b]did[/b] confront the teacher, repeatedly, and was answered with lame excuses and no admission of being undeniably wrong, although the Bennish definitely was, repeatedly. I think the student did his diligence and correctly identified a corrupt ideologue who didn't submit to reason and fact, but stuck to a false premise, even in spite of the student's corrections.

Fire the whacko, and give him none of the normal severance benefits. Let him look for work at a tabloid or Crossfire.

by jdclyde

I have heard the interviews with the kid, and it WAS him on the tape.

This was not the first time this "teacher" went off like this, and past students have stepped up saying he has been like this few YEARS and allowed to use his position of authority over kids to distort reality.

by jdclyde

If YOU are paid by an employer to do a job, but you decide you want to spend your time doing something else, you deserve to be fired.

This person is a waste of tax payers money and air.

There is NOTHING good or productive that comes from his ranting and raving at a bunch of kids, as he was not even attempting to engage them.

Again, also a complete violation of stated school policys, making every favorable argument FOR him invalid.

Oh yeah, not the only country, just the best! B-) Enjoy limbo.

by x-marcap

Idiots who are willing to resort to violence without a clue or without understanding the consequences are the problem. Not just the extremist.

I am an extremist, but you can wave you hand in front of my face and call me names. Your right to wave your hand ends at my nose. If you hit me you'll be sorry... The Islamic extremists never understood that they can burn my flag and call my country names, but when they touch me or my property or my contrymen's property, they are getting the accumulated anger right back at them...

by cactus pete

When you say "Not just the extremist" you are wholely encompassing and including my statement, but saying you disagree?

You continue to saying something else which seems fascinating on a different level:

"Your right to wave your hand ends at my nose."

So, I can wind up, and throw the punch - if I miss that's OK. If I hit, that's not OK, but you intend to do nothing to prevent me from actually hitting your nose?

Perhaps I meant to FAKE hitting you in the nose and stop JUST short of it - where you say I'm perfectly still within my rights. Do you honestly believe you would allow that to happen?

If you didn't allow it to happen, would I then be right to challenge your right to "pre-emptive" defense if it involved you hitting me before I could hit you?

I'm not taking either side, mind you, just trying to drag your true definition out of you...

by x-marcap

I have been led from the PC darkness by listening to him on Rush Limbaugh.

I was much more PC until I learned that I, too an the idol of women. I don't smoke, drink, married one time and have the adulation of many. I am happy to say he helped me return to my masculine roots.

Alan Alda

by cactus pete

Well, the teacher says in the audio recording that he hoped he gace them something to think about.

It seemed to me that he was trying to get the students to see that their viewpoint wasn't the same as others. That's an important lesson, and one that you must grasp fully to understand geopolitical situations.

Before I listened to the recording, I was mostly against this teacher. Now, I'm not so sure.

Additionally, we don't hear the entire class discussion.

Perhaps this teacher puts on the face he does and takes those stances so that he challenges the thoughts of the status quo. In which case, he forces the children to think contrarily to what HAS been indoctrinated, and he is then not trying to DO the indoctrinating.

Please feel free to discuss it from that perspective.

by cactus pete

Clarifying the above post, if that's what the teacher was trying to do, he wasn't particulary GOOD at it, but I can see that as his defense.

by cactus pete

Since you all have access to it, I'll start by using http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=extremist

This is a base as to what has been commonly used in US discussions recently. But that definition isn't exactly the same as what is typically meant. It's not as extreme.

So let's move one to http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=extremism

"n : any political theory favoring immoderate uncompromising policies"

Since extremists practice extremism, this seems to get close to the general understanding of the word in current discussions.

Immoderate and uncompromising are very good words for what was intended when I stated the root post above.

Now, let's consider someone who is extremely generous. Is that person an extremist? Well, that's not the common understanding of the word, is it? In fact, I submit that the typical use of the word extreme is bastardized from it's true definition, too. It is overused and applied, well, too generously.

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=extreme

In general, the word extreme has a negative connotation in social contexts.

So, I think those above understood my point, but chose to be contrarians. C'est la vie, no?

by montgomery gator

If it was real, the Ferengi, with their much stronger economic base and knowledge of free market capitalism, would have been able to take over the Federation (and the Klingons and Romulans and the Cardassians) bit by bit over time, developed their markets, and made the whole Alpha Sector prosperous.

Kind of like how the Free Market NATO countries triumphed over the economically bankrupt Warsaw Pact. And now Ukraine (former member of the USSR) wants to join NATO.

by cactus pete

You're really just trolling, aren't you?

Are you saying you couldn't understand my point of view above?

I gave some links to definitions below, perhaps you could see if your understanding of them is the same.

by x-marcap

The 5th Amendment to the US Constitution protects against self-incriminations. It was never intended to prevent anyone testifying about anyone else?s illegal activity.

That is why Omerta was successful keeping the Mafia from being prosecuted...

The media and Hollywood prevented the truth from coming out by focussing on the demonization of Joe McCarthy. They destroyed the messenger rather than examine things that they didn?t want to be known.
Charles Lindbergh was destroyed by FDR and refused to allow him to return to active duty because they disagreed on some political issues. Lindbergh was a singular talent of that time.

The Truman administration illegally had surveillance on many of these pro - communist groups. Funny thing, When there is a Democratic President and Congress, criminal acts are not a big deal. Together the Democrats and the media made Joe McCarthy into a political scapegoat. Even today as the paperwork is processed from government vaults, there are more repeats of history than are normally recognized.

by x-marcap

There aren't the waiting lines in the USA like there are in either Canada or the UK. I am not saying that there may not be a place for Socialized medicine, but everywhere it has been tried it is more expensive to the government per capita.

I think that the people who need help should get the help they need. Oh wait there are laws that guarantee that. The problem is not health care but competency. I am a General Surgeon that hasn't held a scalpal since the 1970's. I think that the problems are Medical Schools allowing less qualified foreign people in, and not following up on sending them home, as they have agreed to when they came into this country on their student Visa.

Then we need to open up those who qualify. Not make it so that even quality people can't get in. By limiting the people who can get in, the high price of health care is assured by the cost of Medical School and the scarcity of quality coverage.

When someone with power gets sick, if they can get there they come to the Cleveland Clinic or the Mayo... There is a bigger difference in the quality of care if the patient is educated and not educated... Even in when they will persue care...

by tony hopkinson

There's always a nugget somewhere.
That's where the label extremist comes from the assumption that anyone who holds such apposite views one subject must of course hold equally contentious views about everything else.

Tony is a socaialist, therefore he wants you to give up all your income, your religion your independance and grow food badly.

Must admit that's close though.
LOL

by jdclyde

to do anything but complain.

If he were to express his opinion that religion is the key to our existince you would not be supporting him.

If he went on about how there isn't a sucessful socialist or comunist country in the world and railed about the evils of that, were would we be now?

This man knows nothing about politics and world events or his facts would be straight before he presents them as facts to his students. Any person that doesn't know or care enough to get his facts straight before presenting them to his class AS facts has NO place in modern society as an instructor.

Anyone that breaks the schools policies of presenting ideas objectively and from alternate views is ALSO not a teacher any of us should tolerate.

It is amusing that people that are also Bush Haters (you/OZ) would make excuses for him and give him a free pass to say whatever he wants and distort facts as much as he wants. He does NOT have freedom of speech while on the clock. He is paid to do a job. If he doesn't like what that job is, he should be in another profession. He clearly is NOT a good educator.

by x-marcap

Bush has freed more than 50 million Arabs from oppressive regimes. That is even against the international will. When The UN members question if the Mid-East is ready for Democracy, they are supporting despotism, and looking toward one world government to solve these problems.

What I don't see is what The USA has gotten out of the UN since Truman helped to institute it.

The UN is anti-American and it is not helping the world toward Democracy. The French, Germans, and the Russians who support true imperialism only resent that we see things from a right and wrong, Black and white type of viewpoint. The gray of international politics shouldn?t be considered. The absolute of right and wrong should be balanced with our country's interest.

The current resident of 1600 Pensylvania Avenue and I are not in lock step. But, I believe he will be revered with Reagan, and Washington. I disagree with his current positions on spending and many other things...

I think that the US has freed millons from tyrany. Bush may have gone with his feelings rather than evidence, but nobody thinks Saddam was benevolent. Tony, the people who appease tyrants enable the true Adolph Hitlers and the Saddam Husseins of this world.

All Evil men need to succeed is for good men to do

NOTHING!!!

by tony hopkinson

Saddam's biggest backers for years were the US and europe, first against the red menace and then against Khomeini. He was always a nasty b'stard, we kept him in power, we effectively enslaved the iraqi people by turning a blind eye to his actions for years because he was the enemy of our enemy.
You may be right maybe histoy will mark GWB as Lincoln, but if it does it will be afghan and Iraqi historians who make that call, they are the only ones with the right.

by Member 25348569

that, in this case, the judgement of the Iraqi and Afghan people is the one that counts in judging Bush's actions.

I'd like to add a couple of points. Firstly, neither Afghanistan nor Iraq are yet free by any criteria, yours or theirs - which I suspect are also quite different.

It's also worth noting that Afghanistan and Iraq were exactly the same countries with exactly the same undemocratic governments in August 2001 as they were October 2001 yet there was no indication of any pending invasion of Afghanistan nor much of interest in the US's attitude towards Iraq other than your usual disinterested impatience with the UN weapons inspectors. I don't remember any evidence of George W Bush's Unselfish Desire to Free the Opressed People of the World in the Inaugural Address at the start of his presidency. I don't actually remember Bush saying anything about anywhere outside the US in his first six months in office.

Other than dumping Kyoto, of course...

by x-marcap

The side on the short end of the stick of a war has their own history, but they don't usually have it considered by mainstream...

To the Victor goes the spoils...

Problem is Tony, Neil, there is dung on the other half of the stick...

by Member 25348569

Tony's point - and my agreement with it - is that only the Afghani and Iraqi people have the [b]right[/b] to define the success or failure or GWB's efforts.

You have invaded both countries - without the sanction of International Law in the case of Iraq - and are attempting to replace the governmental and political structures of both countries with ones defined by the US in your own image.

Good luck.

by x-marcap

I suggest that you fake from farther away than you can hit...

I am a Nidan and understand that the attempt of intimidation means that you will escalate until you "get your way". I refuse to play that game.

The threat indicates your willingness to use force.

I will stop aggression, occasionally by stopping the threatened action before actual violence. (My smile used to scare people when I was on active duty...) I am not a pushover, but I have no desire to take damage.

Just say that you pay your money, and you take your chances... My pre-empive kick to your balls might get people mad at me, but your high voice will indicate that there is only so far that you can go.

by cactus pete

Whenever you feel like actually discussing the actual point of the thread, you jsut let us all know.

by x-marcap

The problem is that liberals thaink that you can say anything, but they don't realize that they will be held responsible to the words they say...

by x-marcap

They believe they have the freedom to say what they want.

They believe that you as a conservative do not have the same right. If you identify a problem it may be hate speech...

The problem Hate speech should be just as protected as the anti war protester... I may disagree with what you say but I have already fought for your right to say it...

by jdclyde

with the ones that stepped up trying to make this as no big deal or say he was within his RIGHTS.

To make the claim that his RANT and then slamming of anyone that tries to make counter points is in ANYWAY productive show just how dishonest liberals are more than willing to be if it fits with what they believe.

They completely forget that you don't have ANY "free speach" rights when your on the clock. This nut was on the clock and HAS to abide by the rules and regulations of his employer.

by Member 25348569

"Socialized medicine, but everywhere it has been tried it is more expensive to the government per capita". That's not at all true. I'm not pushing the NHS here, either, (despite working in the "trade" for 15 years), as we just don't spend enough. And I also think you'll find that everywhere is cheaper per capita in true spending terms than the US. Unfortunately, the model that seems to be the most efficient and cost-effective is the French - check 'em out. The one thing about their health service is that, by paying some of the cost of treatment up front, the consumers know what the cost of healthcare is. The lack of that direct involvement is, I believe what skews both of our health provision schemes away from common sense in opposite directions.

Should you disagree then please let me know and I'll try and reproduce the figures. I've done the comparison before but I can't remember where I put the stuff.

Neil

by jamesrl

Lindbergh was flirting with Hitler. At one point in 1938 he was looking to buy a house in Berlin. Hitler had given him a medal, Goring had taken him out to dinner.

He did accept a position as Colonel in the air force in 1939.

When the war began in 1939, Lindbergh had urged the US to stay out of the war. He joined America First and was their most active speaker. He argued in Congress against Lend Lease. Roosevelt called him a "Copperhead" and Lindbergh resigned.

In a speech in 1941 Lindbergh said ; Their greatest danger lies in [the Jews?] large ownership and influence in our motion pictures, our press, our radio, and our Government. We cannot blame them for looking out for what they believe to be their interests, but we also must look out for ours.

Even after the war, after he had toured Nazi death camps, he refused to return or destroy the medal Hitler gave him. Point here - I am not accusing him of being a Nazi, but he was certainly poltically naive.

Its not McCarthy's view that there were communists in the government that is in question - there were. Its the method, the slimy insinuations, and in some cases outright lies that he (and Nixon btw) used to try and uncover communists. Its a case of the cure being worse than the disease.

Television, the telivised hearings which McCarthy lead is what demonized him. Murrow and others had tried, but McCarthy killed himself as a political force when he and his tactics were broadcast to the nation.

James

by jamesrl

From Wikipedia:

Cost of health care
Health care is one of the most expensive items of both nations? budgets. In 2001, in Canada, about 16.2% of government money was spent on health care, while in the United States this number was 17.6%. When exchange rates are included it can be seen that government in the United States spends more per capita on health care than the government does in Canada. In 2001, the government of Canada spent $1533 (in US dollars) per person on health care, while the United States government spent $2168.

Despite the American government paying more per capita, private sources also pay far more for health care in the United States. In Canada an average of $630 dollars is spent annually by individuals or private insurance companies for health care, including dental, eye care, and drugs. In the United States this number is $2719. In 2001 the United States spent in total 13.6% of its annual GDP on health care. In Canada only 9.5% of the GDP was spent on health care. This difference is a relatively recent development. In 1971 the nations were much closer with Canada spending 7.1% of GDP on health while the U.S. spent 7.6%. Most observers take these numbers to mean that the Canadian health care system is substantially more cost effective than the American.

Some analysts do not feel the straight GDP numbers give a wholly accurate picture. The difference in cost might have more to do with societal differences than approaches to health care. Drug abuse, obesity, and violence are all more common in the United States than in Canada, and all place a burden on the health care system. Recent history has meant that the United States has far more veterans and war wounded, also somewhat increasing cost. Accounting practices also differ and in Canada fewer capital investments are included in health care costs. Another important caveat is that research and development spending in Canada is lower, but Canada still benefits from the research done in the United States. This leads some scholars, such as David Gratzer, to argue the actual cost difference, while still real, is much smaller than the straight GDP numbers would indicate.

In some areas the private system in the United States allows for greater reduction in costs. In recent decades managed care has become common in the United States, with some 70% of privately insured Americans belonging to managed care plans. Managed care is when the insurance company controls patients' health care to reduce costs, for instance by demanding a second opinion prior to any expensive treatment. Proponents assert that managed care reduces health care costs by up to 30% with no appreciable decrease in the quality of this care.

by oz_media

I obviously care? Yes, I obviously care about how much time and energy Americans waste on chastizing fellow Americans. Again just another example of ho wyou are trained (I am wondering genetic now) to look and point fingers but never loko inward. I don't know if CARE is the right word, I am definitely amused or puzzled over it though.

Your entire existence seems to be based on judging those around you, other countries, other companies, other countries people and when you run out of people to condemn you start in on each other, democrats suck, republicans suck, when you run out of political sterotypes, you then turn to anything YOU feel would be immoral even though many of you would do the same thing.

It just blows my mind how much time and effort you put into condemning everyone for the most miniscule things, does it really make you feel any better though?

by jamesrl

http://www.amsa.org/studytours/WaitingTimes_primer.pdf

The study by the way was written by an American medical student.

Summary:
There are waiting lists in Canada for certain elective procdures. Whats isn't clear is the magnitude of the problem. Wait times vary from province to province, hospital to hosspital and procedure to procedure. The US doesn't have wait time issues to the extent Canada has. The idea that hordes of Canadians cross the border to avoid waiting lists is a myth. A small minority of Canadians specifically cross the border to receive care.

I will add, in recent times, my province has paid for certain patients to go south rather than face long waits. The most common - drug and alcohol addicts - there are too few beds here for that and many free ones in the states.

James

by jdclyde

your one funny dude.

They think that their "freedom" allows them the RIGHT to say ANYTHING they want, ANYWHERE they want with no accountability to accuracy.

They also feel that you are infringing on their rights if you TRY to hold them accountable.

ITLobo, anyone?

You CAN say what you want. But others have that SAME right to say what they want and they WILL tell you exactly what they think of your speech.

The double edged sword bites them more than not, but they are too dishonest to see or accept it. Must be someone elses fault, huh?

by oz_media

Thanks, those are my feelings exactly. This COULD have actually been a very good excersise. I am just disappointed that only one student seemed to have a voice, and others sat and grazed like sheep.

by oz_media

Please show how you can say he didnt inspire anyone. Have you interviewed teh children? Nope.

But I assume that since only one kid actually decided to complain, that nobody was inspired? You don't have to stand and scream in order to be inspired.

As for the referece to defending th eteacher, I am nto defending him, and EVEN HE DOESN'T STATE IT IS FACT! Get over it, he said it was HIS opinion. But as these forums prove all too often, no matter how eloquently you explain that your comments are personal opinion, some Republican will always quote last nights news and say you are wrong.

I think a good brain wash is due for most Americans these days, you are all living in tunnels.

by tony hopkinson

I can even live with the idea that he at least in some cases was justified. But if his goal was so laudable, why did he have to lie his ass off about it. Locking up, outing and persecuting dangers to your country/society, no problem. Abuse the system of justice that 'they are the enemy of', to do so, is just f'ing dumb. Truth and justice don't need enemies with friends like that.

by maxwell edison

And although I disagree with what he did, I agree with the decision of the school district. This has been an overall learning experience for students, for teachers, and especially this very young teacher, and for the public at large. I hope it leads to providing more balance in presentations, and illustrates the problems with such things in our schools. But I won't hold my breath.

by bbaltas

I also agree with you. As a side note, the student who made this recording also feels that Jay Bennish should not be fired but allowed to continue his teaching career.

by av .

I agree with everything you said. I think it is a learning experience for everyone. I hope that the event has brought emphasis to the challenges of our world today and how they are conveyed to young students in the education system. Maybe it will lead to an improvement in the quality of our education, something we need badly.

by jdclyde

it has been a wake-up call for parents to watch out for teachers in our public education. They are there for their own political agenda, not to educate kids.

Teach your kids what is right and wrong.
Teach them to stand up for themselves and not let nutcases like this push crap on you as if it were a fact.
Talk to your kids about WHAT they are being "taught".
Talk to the school to find out where they stand on cases like this and avoid wingnut teachers if the system is too corrupt to remove them.

by maxwell edison

....then to be fair, they'd have to fire every teacher in the district (or the state) who's done the same kind of thing.

Like that teacher who recently had her elementary school kids write letters of protest to President Bush about a proposed sale of public lands. Like another school teacher who took the kids to a protest rally. Like another teacher who gives lower grades to kids who argue against the man-made global warming myth in a paper. Like another teacher.......

I could go on and on. But they'd have to fire a large percentage of teachers! And then we have "tenure" entering into the equation. According to the rules negotiated by the teachers union, most school districts couldn't fire an incompetent teacher if they wanted to.

The government run school systems in America are pitiful. Jay Bennish isn't the problem, per se, but rather a symptom of a much larger one.

by maxwell edison

.
http://denverpostbloghouse.com/csap/index.php?action=FindSchool&school=&district=130&optSenior=1

CHERRY CREEK HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: Excellent

CHEROKEE TRAIL HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: High

SMOKY HILL HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: High

GRANDVIEW HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: High

EAGLECREST HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: Average

OVERLAND HIGH SCHOOL - Performance This Year: Average

Overland High School, Jay Bennish's school, ranked at the bottom of all schools in that district. I wonder why? And I wonder why you, and others, consider him a good teacher?

by oz_media

Canada's medical system and teh doctors in it are tightly regulated. They are only ALLOWED to charge $X for their time. Private doctors? That would be south of where I live, in fact it's anothre country altogether.

by jdclyde

I see you in the posts about American politics and day to day life being VERY judgmental when you don't even have a direct stake in many of the discussions. (like this one)

Yet anyone else that is judgmental, (which you just got done being) is wrong for doing such.

No one should agree with what the Americans think because they don't know anything anyways because of their edited newscasts (accept the liberals of coures. THEY get it, huh?)

There are plenty of ways to engage kids, but this clown had no intention of doing it and obviously didn't have the skills nor temperment to do so either.

He was there for one reason, to indoctrinate kids that don't know better than to accept what this authority figure would tell them, and would face retrobution if they were to say something.

The kid that did the recording is looking for a new school because of threats of violence against him for standing up. He and his father DID give the school system a chance to handle this, but when they decided to do nothing, he took it to the next step.

Right now the teacher should NOT be on paid leave, but UNPAID leave until there is a review of the tape which is the only evidence that is needed to show that he clearly violated school policies.

Of course, none of that matters to you because you would have beat the teacher up if he hurt your feelings.

You call this being sheep, we call it respecting authority figures. We also call this individual case "abuse of power and trust".

by oz_media

I was waiting fo rsomeone to bring up the age old and ridiculous comment about patients going to the states for treatment.

This is WAY over reported and blown WAY out of proportion. Americans come here for drugs, but that doesn't mean our medical system is better or worse, or more or less effective. It doesnt mean you can't buy drugs in the states, God only knows its like an expensive 7-11 there for anythign you can think of.

Why do people go to the US for surgery? Well it isn't because there is a waiting list here, you can forget that right away. I have had some pretty intense surgery in a VERY short time, you can get MRI's and CAT's the same day, but peopl ecomplain about 6 month waits. Why?

In Canada, our government wont cover unneccessary surgery, or non immergent surgery if someone else is about to die. When 80 year old Bob Wakersfield complains about not getting his new hip within two weeks, it''s because someone else is in dire need of a new hip and his was just a suggestion from a doctor, not really needed, or is not needed at all or a doctor has deemed it wouldn't help in any way. So while Timmy get's a new hip, as his existing one is shattered in a car accoident at 14 years of age, old Bob has to wait, and rightly so.

If this was privatized, little Timmy may be laid up in bed for a year while he sends his family to teh poor house, or may have to wait until his INsurance is paid up, while old fart Bob get's some fancy new robotic hip that he really didn't need.

People don't wait endlessly for help here, that's complete BS that the lefty papers just feed on with isolated issues that are rarely as claimed.

by jdclyde

as you wish, but it does not change the FACT that he is not ENTITLED to express his opinion in this fashion and in this setting. His OPINION has no place in a classroom where he is suppose to be teaching facts.

Sounds like you have already HAD your brainwashing.

Yes I listened to the news, and yes, you are wrong.

by oz_media

No wwe all have proof of just how narrow your thought process is. Unfortunately you are also lumping yourself in with those 'unmentionables' you contest with so often.

Lets assume they havea class of 22 students. Out of 22 student, ONE, 1, UNO, actually stood up and questioned a teacher on a rant.

That would be less than 5% of America able to actually speak for themselves. that's just too typical. BAAAAAA.

And while I also agre ethat the teacher was over the top in his comments, he DID liste tp the kid and he did rebut, with little or no reply form teh student. Let's at least credit teh teacher with a nobel try, even if YOU feel he was wrong. It does show that no matter how hard you try, sheep will always follow each other without contest.

by absolutely

You have more regulations, except in one crucial area of medicine: tort law. Punitive damages can be 100s of times the "victim's" lifetime earning potential because this crazy country [b]pays[/b] people to endure "pain & suffering". That is insane. Nobody's pain & suffering ever translated to a bit of value rendered to me, or to anybody else. Malpractice suits should stop at damages for loss of income, but they don't.

I think the regulations that you do have in Canada are more intelligent, and may even be more numerous. But we have the one big, stupid government intrusion into the free market that jacks up everybody's price.

by tony hopkinson

is as much to do with your own position as theirs.

Marxism -----------Socialist -----------Capitalist

Anyone is extremely far away from the other.

Labels /categorisations can be an excuse not to think.
Which is why the media and politicians encourage their use.

by absolutely

Tony Hopkinson: "Labels /categorisations can be an excuse not to think.
Which is why the media and politicians encourage their use."

It's terribly unfair to say that labels are "an excuse not to think". And some labels are very helpful. "Hand me that pint of beer" is much more convenient than the gestural languages probably employed by pre-historic man! Overuse of labels doesn't enable modern men "not to think" altogether, just not to think anything that might disrupt their faith in whatever premise(s) they stupidly refuse to ever check.

by oz_media

Since when was questioning a tirade in a learning environment to be considered disrespecting authority? The teacher was clearly stating personal opinion and was ready to debate his views AND listen to why the kid was interjectinng with.

The fact that he is in danger for speaking out just reiterates my point, people are taught/expected to just follow like sheep, whether they deem it right or wrong. "Lemmings", is a term a gentleman used yesterday when this came up in discussion during a meeting break.

As for not allowing people to be judgmental, that's exactly what I expect the kids to do in the first place and it feel it shouldn't be dragged beyond that point.

To even say that you EXPECT and actually understand why an entire class would sit like morons and idly listen to such a rant from someone they are SUPPOSED to respect and be able to relate to is hideous. It's truly laughavle that such a thing is taken so seriously there, yet nobody bats an eye when given admittedly false information that leads to war. In fact, they even go along and support it, despite the realization.

I don't think anybody in the world actually 'get's' America(ns), it's just a completly different/uncomprehensible train of thought than anywhere else. I don't know why, is it school, is it media, is it genetic? Who knows, but it's like vistign the zoo sometimes, you just gaze in the window in astonishment, except we feed you too.

by jdclyde

if they are all wrong.

Besides sharing the rabid Bush hate that is very popular in liberal circles, what he was saying should have made even the most loonie of you step back.

by tony hopkinson

could have been a lager, or a stout.
You could be sat at the bar with your brain turned off and someone gives you a glass of budweiser !

After the first sip, you'd be cursing yourself fo not paying attention. A little less alert and they could have stuck you with a glass of Miller Lite, and wouldn't you be sorry then.

by jdclyde

that has even a little bit of intellectual honesty.

Tony, I said EVEN, to show how EXTREME and completely out of touch with reality you would HAVE to be to NOT think this man is a nutcase and should not be around children.

Has anyone seen pictures lately? I heard he cut his hair and suited up to TRY to look less loonie while he fights this.

by absolutely

"Has anyone seen pictures lately? I heard he cut his hair and suited up to TRY to look less loonie while he fights this."

The best way to prevent distortion of what's presented as fact is to cite your sources, and demand the same from others.

by jdclyde

from a person I have known and trusted for over 25 years that follows current events and politics.

This was NOT watercooler talk.

I have just been too preoccupied with my house to turn on the news or anything. Not even out in TR land as much...... :(

Can't wait for this house to sell......

by x-marcap

Just a sad thought you live too far from here to get this kind of health care. Actually I find that a good thing...

by oz_media

One big issue Canadians are actively fighting against now is a split medical system, one where private medical is an option to provincial medical.

The fact that one clinic in the US is filled with who you deem are Canadians gone awol, not to be confused with Canadians injured while in the US, Canadians living in the US while still holding Canadian citizenshio, does NOT by any stretch f the imagination represent a problem with Canadian medicine at all. To take such a miniature sample and reach such conclusions is exactly why most Americans are said to be clueless, polls and samples do not count.

Just as all similar reports from the US falsely show, they are generally based on inaccurate figures anyway.

Was it you who interviewd all tehse Canadians? And more importantly, WHY woul dthey choose to go all the way to Chicago for treatment and not some other over priced US medical facility that will feed them any drugs the doctor makes th emost money on? Comission for doctors, now THERE's something to run screaming from! It's not very comforting to know that the pills you have been given haven't really been tested beyond pigs and cows, that the side effects are usually worse than the symptoms they claim to resolve, and that the only reason you are taking them for the rest of your life is because some doctor wanted another free entry for a trip to Vegas that the pharmacuetical company was offering.
Yeah, sign me up.

I have NEVER waited for ANY medical attention, and I have been admitted in more than my fair share of hospitals.

We don't make elective surgery a priority over some poor sick kid who actually needs help, now THAT'S something I would be embarrassed to admit as an American.

As has already been pointed out by James RL, the FACTS and REAL numbers prove otherwise. Try reading the other posts too.

by absolutely

I don't care if you were standing next to a water cooler, a beer keg, or a pot field. I don't know your source, therefore I don't trust your information. Jay Bennish did not cite his sources, therefore the students had good reason not to trust his. See the link?

by cgoeckel

First the teacher is SUPPOSED to be teaching Geography and not lecturing on politics as he sees it. If he wants to do that then I would say he should have formed a club or something along those lines outside of the classroom.

Second I hate to say it but it sounds like he is pushing his thoughts on the kids and not giving them the chance to respond. But that is just one of his "lectures" that was aired.

Third...no wonder kids nowadays can't find a country outside of the US...or another state!

I am all for your 1st amendment rights but he was way outside of them.

If that was his first offense, then you slap his wrist hard and you tell him do not do it ever again and you do unannounced monitoring of his class to make sure for a certain period of time he understands the ramifications. If he does it again....you either fire him/her or suspend them without pay (depends on the policy).

Those are just my thoughts on the matter.

by x-marcap

No reason to go to Chicago. Cleveland Clinic is in OHIO. OZ you idiot. At the outpatient center, where I take my wife for vascular surgery, there are ~500 car slots. There are by count 17 cars in one row of 50 that are from Canada. My wife assures me that there are no Canadians in her department.

If 17/50 = ~1/3 with 500 cars in the lot there should be 150 Canadians getting vascular surgery or examinations...

I know there are several foreign leaders here when the SS closes the entrances and my wife has to walk in from the street...

by oz_media

While BFC was mainly ripe, so is mnost of what the right clams is true. Th etruth is, in most cases neither side is 100% correct and only airing what they deem suitable for their point.

To claim even for one split second that th eright is truthful and correct all the time is a pure heap of shite. If you were really aware of TRUTH and not just that which you choose to believe, you would find that both sides are full of it and either side can easily discount the other.

That's why there is no end to political debates here, think about it for once instead of simply defending what you choose to believe and discounting what you don't. You can contradict just about asny point or comment raised by either party, just because you choose to believe one set of contradictions, does not make it correct.

by absolutely

"When was the last time that affected my quality of life?" when they hear or read the words of a career politician, how different do you suppose the world would be?

by jdclyde

If no one worried about anything that doesn't directly affect them, the world would be in a sad place.

The charities I work with, while cancer has affected my family so they would still be on the list, helping kids that are going without would fall right off my list. The Katrina donations? didn't affect me one bit directly, so I shouldn't care?

I think more people should look how their actions affect OTHERS. civil liberties and rights STOP as soon as someone else has the same rights to do the opposite. "You" can say what you want because of free speech, but I can say what I want about you FOR what you have said with your free speech and hold "you" accountable for anything "you" say.

NOTE: replace "you" with any person at any time that does anything, not aimed at anyone here directly.

by jdclyde

to hear this from you?

[i]"That's why there is no end to political debates here, think about it for once instead of simply defending what you choose to believe and discounting what you don't. You can contradict just about asny point or comment raised by either party, just because you choose to believe one set of contradictions, does not make it correct."[/i]

I agree completely, even if it does counter YOUR approach to every post you make against American companies/governement? You are not the holder of the keys to truth, because you also hear what other people have chosen for you to hear.

by oz_media

A simple slip but its not that I didn't actually know where Cleveland is, unlike yourself who thinks French Canadians come from BC and that all of your resources come from south of from the middle east.

Yoru speculative numbers also don't prove anything either. So out of 50 cars, 17 are Canadians who you have decided fled to teh US for help because of Canada's poor health care system. I suppose they were also French Canadians from BC too.

If you had any credibility or even a remote clue of what you were talking about, I would give you SOME credit, as you have already proven you don't, then I won't.

by jdclyde

of comparing my request if anyone can confirm something I had heard, with a loon passing off his crap as facts.

Kind of like comparing Bush to Hitler? :)

by rob mekel

Your "Kind of like comparing Bush to Hitler? :)" is a tricky one.
[i]Hitler was elected in a democracy, as Bush is
Hitler started a war, as Bush did
Hitler checked on citizens, as Bush does[/i]
Won't like the conclusion that can be drawn from here. [b]I sure won't like that! [/b] (although I don't like the Bush administration very much)

I know you didn't mean so but you left the door open to do so. Be careful with what you can imply.

And yes I know I'm stepping on your toes, on purpose but not to hurt you. It is just to make you aware of what can be done with the words you typed.

To the comparison that Absolutely made regarding to your friend and you versus Jay Bennish not reveling his sources to the class, I think that; it is more that he doesn't trust you or your ability to know whether or not to trust your friend is the issue, then that he dis-agrees with you. Though I do find it strange that he scrambles up your figure of speech on the ?This is NOT watercooler talk?, as if he doesn't understand it as being the equivalent of a ?Not a ?chit-chat? talk?. Special as he agrees upon you that the students were right too not to trust their teacher. (As I make up out of your critics about this teacher and he does state about the students)

Rob

by jdclyde

they are both male.
they both have/had a dog.
they both had a mother and a father.

sure, any simpleton can make basic "comparisons" that mean nothing.

Look at how Hitler got into power. He had a gang of thugs that beat anybody up that apposed him.
Bush was elected and re-elected by following the existing rules in place for elections. The first time he won by the electoral collage which the simplitons of the nations can't seem to understand. The second time he won by both the electoral AND majority vote, and was STILL not accepted by the simpletons. He recieved more votes than any president has ever recieved in our history.

When Hitler went into a country, it was HIS. He was not above killing any and everyone in the way.
When Bush went into a country, it was given to the people of that country. Bush does what can be done to avoid civilian casualties and respect the people that are there. He even allowed the stupidity of allowing Iraqie soldiers to defile shrines by fighting from them, and not leveling the shrines or in many cases even firing back.

yeah, I can see the similarities already.

Hitler tried to wipe out an entire race.
Bush tried to give an race self rule.

Yeah, more and more I can see your point.

Hitler gave firey speaches, screaming at the top of his lungs, inciting people with hate.
Bush gives quiet speechs that to not advocate hate for other people. He has gone out of his way to make it clear this in not an assult on Islam or Muslims.

pretty dishonest comparison if you are trying to say they are similar.

by jdclyde

http://michellemalkin.com/archives/004715.htm

As I had said before, (Absolutely) that I had heard about this but hadn't taken the time to confirm.

I HAD asked if anyone else could confirm or deny but it seems no one else was privy to this information, so it is with great pride that I step forward and enlighten the lot of your! :D

by absolutely

I just said it above, but it bears repeating: I didn't mean to dispute your claim, but to emphasize the importance of citing sources [b]because[/b] of the context & origin of this discussion. Then, I got distracted and forgot to make my point for several days, maybe a week or more.

About Jay's "makeover": he looked better with long hair atop his head than that bristly mess all over his face. A full beard can look dignified, especially on 50+ men, but a half inch of stubble just makes Jay look foolish.

by Member 25348569

Judging by the comments on this site, I would reckon that he's running scared that one of you gun-toting neo-cons is gonna blow his Democrat brains out for forcing your young folk into Communism and Satanism.

Hell. Some of you frighten me and I've got an ocean betwen us.

:p

by absolutely

It's impossible for "gun-toting neo-cons" to blow out what doesn't exist - "Democrat brains" do not exist!

by Member 25348569

Maybe he's seen the errors of his ways and wants to become a clean-cut ex-marine all-American right-wing boy and this is his first step along the road to redemption...

Though I still think that he's just running scared.

by x-marcap

He still looks too wild eyed! Grab the 12 guage pump Martha, I'm gonna get me some squirrel!!!

Neil, the greatest danger you have from the legal gun toters is that the legal ones would still protect you while a skin head tries to mug you on the tube while carrying some kind of 9MM fully auto machine pistol...

by absolutely

You can hold me accountable for my actions. You may agree or disagree with my words, not 'hold "you" accountable for anything "you" say.

NOTE: replace "you" with any person at any time that does anything, not aimed at anyone here directly.'

Unless my words are incitement to violence, defamatory, fraudulent, maybe a few other sorts governed by law (?), you have no right to in any way [b]hold[/b] me accountable.

You may repeat my words to me, if you wish, and I may require you to cite the place, time and circumstance in which I said them, in order to establish context. As you can already see, this gets much more complicated, very quickly, than if we each live and let live, and consider nothing criminal that does not interfere with our own pursuit of our own happiness.

You have provided a convenient example for me to illustrate the point I just made.

jdclyde: "If no one worried about anything that doesn't directly affect them, the world would be in a sad place."

Those were not my words, and your conclusion is not consistent with my view. I have never promoted turning a blind eye to others' suffering. In fact, I expect that if people asked themselves "How does this affect me?" more often, they would give [b]more[/b] to relieve suffering because they would vote for [b]fewer[/b] regulations on activities that are harmful to nobody, but are currently illegal.

For example, drug peddlers [b]offer[/b] dope, they [b]never[/b] (to my knowledge) accost people and blow smoke in their faces or inject them with needles in order to create more addiction. They [b]peddle[/b], leaving each person free to accept or refuse their offer. Granted, the effects of addiction are ugly, but addicts basically choose their fates, and if the members of society sober enough to vote would ask themselves, "Does this 'drug epidemic' really [b]affect[/b] me?" I believe they would conclude, "No, it just frightens me when I hear or read about it."

I slightly regret being such a stereotype of a "legalize it" libertarian, but honestly, it is obviously the right thing. One of [b]many[/b] worthwhile benefits of eliminating the extra laws that protect none, but give police too many statutes to ever enforce half of them effectively, is that more of the money that is still produced by efficacious people would be available for emergencies like Katrina.

by absolutely

I didn't have a major disagreement with jdclyde's statement, this time, I just found it ironic, and chose to use the "teachable moment" to emphasize that if citation of source had been emphasized in Bennish's class, or [b]in any before his[/b], the students would have been much better able to take his arguments apart.

One or more of Bennish's students made admirable efforts to point out the "teacher's" illogic and deviation from fact, but in the world of my ideals, more of them would have been able to say with absolute certainty that a particular statement was absolutely false, because of something they read recently, citing the publication by name. Accountability is much more easilty achieved with well-organized, quality data.

by rob mekel

And you are right it is a pretty dishonest comparison, even one I don't want to make (as I did state) merely pointing out that it can be done IF YOU ASK FOR IT.

And, by the way, Hitler didn't win the presidential elections (in fact he did lose them to Von Hindenburg) in 1932 but the parliamental* elections. He became president (f?hrer - leader) after the death of President Von Hindenburg in 1934 (self declared president, that is) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hitler

How "clean" were those elections in the USA in 2000? Wasn't there a problem with Florida, was there an inquiry how it did happen, were there measures taken to prevent this in future, did they work (the measures) with the 2004 elections? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bush_43 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_election_recount

I know it is easy to question afterwards and I do think that there are faire elections in the USA but if we don't stay critical to those who govern us y'll never know what can happen.

Rob

* the real power lies with parliament in Germany

by x-marcap

OZ, I said Canadians. Not Quebecois, as I didn't specify which ones. What I can tell you is that many people from Ontario come to the clinic. This is especially true for heart care and for vascular surgery.

What I didn't know was that you have different health care from Province to Province.

If you watch Drew Carey to make your decisions about Cleveland, you think we are all retail shop clerks, janitors and bumbling idiots. The only place in the show that is even slightly similar to any place I know is that the Warsaw tavern may be somewhat like Sokolowski's, but they have eliminated the best buffet of ethnic food in the world... Their Kielbasa, pierogi etc. is to die for...

What I don't understand is that why would Ontario have so different a socialized medicine plan, or Quebec from BC. If there was a good one, (I am not ceeding the point) why didn't it get rolled out across the country? If you understand my surprise at the weaker Canadian federal government.

by absolutely

If you want to be first to deliver the punch line, you need to be prompt. Don't blame me, it isn't my fault that you're slow!

;)

by jdclyde

that it is indeed the "gun-toting neo-cons" (whatever that means) that ARE the legal gun owners.

If you want violent criminals, look for a democrat...... A fair bet that 90% of violent crime is commited by them!

(that is why the Dems want to allow fellons to vote!)

by tonythetiger

"(that is why the Dems want to allow fellons to vote!)"

It's a counter to the fact that Republicans want the dead to be allowed to vote :)

by x-marcap

There were enough dead people voting in 1960 to give Kennedy the state of Illinois. Otherwise we would have had a President Nixon in 1960...

That is the real why that he was paranoid about the Democrats and their plans. If not for Daly and his crew, Kennedy might be alive and Nixon might have been in Dallas, any takers if that would have made Democrats happier?

by x-marcap

97% of the prison vote is Democratic of those waiting on Felony charges...

That info was taken from Florida 2000 exit polls. The whining that all felons should be allowed to vote is coming from Democrats.

Isn't it amazing that the democrats who have stuffed the ballot boxes for years complained about voter fraud... Having worked for Diebold, I believe the problem with voting machines, for Democrats is that there won't be voter fraud...

by jdclyde

when your cause in more nobel, you are justified to do whatever it takes to push your political agenda?

Then quick accuse the other "side" of doing it because the masses are so stupid and lazy, they will believe anything that they hear in a sound bite.

by jdclyde

I didn't want to get picky with him because he DID have his :) showing that he didn't really believe it either!

Smokes for votes anyone? Crack for registrations anyone?

We don't need to bring up Democrats trying repeatedly to block the military vote either.....