Discussion Locked

How can IT Dept open CEO's eyes?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been working in my company for 7 years and have seen major changes in all senses.
The company had mainly acquired technology as the business grew. However, two years ago top-management decided to buy an IT project to a consulting company which would cost several million dollars to let the company have a solid IT platform. The decision was made without taking the company's CIO into account, mainly due to a transition in the position.
According to the documentation presented by the consultants to CEO, our company would have four different best of breed systems to cover all business needs integrated via EAI and published in a corporate portal.
At the beginning, the whole company believed this project would change our competitive position; however as time has passed by some of us who work in IT (including our current CIO), who were not taken into account in the top-mgmt decision, have come to the conclusion that the project will not meet its goals and it will even make our IT TCO and operational IT costs higher, without a tangible competitive advantage for the company.
We would like to show our CEO that the project has a minimal earned value and will not bring any of the benefits "sold" to the company. We would like to approach in a way that gives us as much objectivity as possible.
Has anyone been in a similar situation? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
Regards,

4 replies

by oldefar

Alex,

I have lost a couple of these battles in the past. Doing so taught me a couple of lessons.

First and most important, your approach has to deal in the following 5 currencies - time, money, security, knowledge, and prestige. Pointing out an error is going to cost the CEO directly in all of these. At the end of any delivery, he will have to see an aggregate positive exchange in currency by listening to and taking the advice of the CIO. Now there also has to be a positive currency exchange for the company, but here a reduction in an apparent drain can work.

Second, your CEO is not going to care about technology itself. If the project followed an architectural approach that links business objectives to business requirement to technical objectives your discussion so stay here. Don't get into the technical requirements or overall solution details. If the project did not have an architectural approach, I recommend you build one. This will allow you to demonstrate where businessobjectives and business requirements were either missed, changed, or cannot be met with the current project.

Now about survival. Messengers are both killed and eaten. Bringing in an outside consultant to deliver the message may be a good tactic if you would like another 7 years there. A consultant who is totally independent of any decision is the best choice - someone who will not be expected to drive a new solution. There are some of us out there.

by http://stobie.home.sprynet.com/work/

These implement and then integrate solutions almost always fall short of the what is promised and fixing it is a political battle that the fixer loses, either by not getting the fixes done or he is labelled as not easy to get along with (because he supports the organization's best interest versus the political individual's personal agenda - yep, happens all the time.)

Getting an independent consultant to report the overall problems and the probable most effective solutions who will not be responsible to fix it is a good idea.

For best results, integrate by solid upfront strategic design. This is the long term most effective in terms of cost, adaptability, manpower use, and effectiveness. (Note that if the organization has not had solid upfront strategic design, this requires a lead time and solid top executive support.)

by gateso

Hello,

A common challenge to IT management has been demonstrating corporate business performance as impacted by IT. The vast majority of benchmarking is on efficiency (how well is IT managing itself internally) rather than on effectiveness (how well is IT being used by the company in postively impacting its financial performance).

In order to to this you need either the data (comparative to specific market basket of firms) or an EFFECTIVENSS benchmarking firm.

Good luck,
Gates Ouimette
www.interunitygroup.com

by meburke

I've run across this type of situation a lot, and usually it's because the goals are too "fuzzy" to be accomplished. The most powerful questions I ask my customers are, "What do you want, specifically?", and, "What will you see, have, feel if you get it?"

Basicly, an information system ony does three things, based on the assumption that a business delivers goods and/or services to a customer for a payment. Although the time lag between the first contact to receiving the payment may be very short, it is not infinitely short. So the information system either produces the deliverables, tracks the progress of the proceess or provides data for analyzing the process to improve the process in a meaningful way. (I'm indebted to Eli Goldratt's book, "The Haystack Syndrome" for this point of view.) I've never gotten an agument from any CEO or business owner who listened to this description. This leads to shortened discussions of goals and scope-of-work, and clearly defines the outcomes in terms of results rather than hardware or architecture.

IMO, getting agreement on the outcomes in terms of results is paramount in asesessing the value and progress of any IT project.

Mike

This discussion is closed to new replies.