Discussion Locked

How is it that four year college educated people are better technicians?

0 helpful
127 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

127 replies

by adel.mattar

Employers will hire educated people over uneducated ones. Even though experience is a PLUS, employers want to see that you have gone through the pain of earning a degree.

Unfortunately, in some cases, they do not care what degree you have just as long as you have one.

by ksoniat

At least a GED. I've know people with extenuating(circumstances that actually got a GED early because family life was untenable.

Without that - no.

by snuffy09

People that want to make the most of them and learn all they can in the IT field go to college or school of some kind and if they are really serious about it they will take home what the learned... literally. I know I did. a lot of things I learned in my labs I also played with at home Installing operating systems, configuring RAIDS, creating Active Directory accounts and OUs, networking home computers, making home NAS server, you know... the fun stuff!

I DO understand about the clueless "tech" guys you are talking about. There was one in my classes all he would do is play games online. I think people automatically think working in IT is going to be a piece of cake easy way to make lots of money! Once they start the training they get hit with the reality. So they just start slacking off rather than admit they were wrong. If you don?t have a passion for it the starting wage(s) won?t keep you interested in the first place.

So there are different types of people that go to these schools, people that really have a desire to be in IT, and others that are looking for the easy way and think that the IT world is just LAN parties (not knocking lan parties).

by codekraft1982

great post as I am one of these people too....and the fact that some IT vets have this burning desire to with hold valuable info to all the noobs on the job or if they do have to work with you explain things half-assed lol its makes you wonder.....

by matthew.balthrop

I can agree with that to some degree, but i think that the "jumping through the hoops" is probably only what someone in IT would see. If your dealing with a Business Professional, i could see them looking at the certs/schooling as the "will to further skill/knowledge". Like it was said earlier, i think it is all about who is reading your resume.

-alias

by drayhill

This is a great article(title does not express what you're thinking). There are plenty of people out there with degree's/Cert's that do have a clue about real world experience but that's how the system of hiring was created(unfortunatly).

by lazlohollyfeld

that i don't feel the need to act as though i am attending a comprehensive writing course and earning a grade.

I could very easily write using the shift key, but I choose not to do so. It's my choice, and I am very well capable of writing just as well as you can.

if i wanted to be a butt, i could go off on you spelling 'departement'. nice job there, mr. professional, judgemental i.t. manager. lmbo

thanks for your input though, g-man. however unnecessary and unrelated as it was.

by matthew.balthrop

I think from all the posts we can gather the real differences between experience and schooling. If you want to be good at your job, and be able to prove it the second you walk in the door, you require experience. If you want to make yourself marketable in today's economy, and create a well rounded education for yourself, you require and schooling. So it only makes sense to have both, while i would personally put more emphasis on the experience. The major point i believe is that it won't hurt you to have both.

-alias

by keith

Oddly enough I've struggled with this for some time as well. I was often asked off the way questions, questions that you would expect a computer systems or network administrator would know. I've often viewed the whole college vs experience issue and I've always been on the side that experience wins every time. Though this is likely due to me dropping out of 2 colleges and going with vendor neutral certificates and building a rich IT background.

Experience > Degree for Techies, Degress > Experience for management / hiring process :(

by matthew.balthrop

Seems to be the general agreement here, So might as well have a little of both. I personally think experience is much more valuable to have, but that's me. The guy hiring you might think differently. If it comes down to getting that job i would love to have, i don't want to be turned away because i was lacking the certification/education. It's becoming one of things you just have to deal with. Now they just need to make college more affordable and we can all be set :)

-alias

by tony hopkinson

Is the claim of having a degree or cert proof of learning?

Even if you take the claim as honest, what did they learn?

Even if they learnt the right stuff, can they apply it?

Of course I could write a load of BS about what I've done and call it my experience, no reason you should take that claim at face value either.

I certainly wouldn't and don't.

Can you say a degree in computer science = programmer? A cert in Programming with VS and C#?

So proof of what? Academia and vendor certs are self proving, they don't prove that you are capable of a role in general, never mind a specific one.

As an an estimation of potential, given the claim is honest, yes. There again gainfully employed for two years doing a similar role, could say as much.

Now if you are just starting out, there is no substitute. Opportunities to learn from 'nothing' on the job, are not exactly common nowadays.

by snuffy09

People that want to make the most of them and learn all they can in the IT field go to college or school of some kind and if they are really serious about it they will take home what the learned... literally. I know I did. a lot of things I learned in my labs I also played with at home Installing operating systems, configuring RAIDS, creating Active Directory accounts and OUs, networking home computers, making home NAS server, you know... the fun stuff!

I DO understand about the clueless "tech" guys you are talking about. There was one in my classes all he would do is play games online. I think people automatically think working in IT is going to be a piece of cake easy way to make lots of money! Once they start the training they get hit with the reality. So they just start slacking off rather than admit they were wrong. If you don?t have a passion for it the starting wage(s) won?t keep you interested in the first place.

So there are different types of people that go to these schools, people that really have a desire to be in IT, and others that are looking for the easy way and think that the IT world is just LAN parties (not knocking lan parties).

by gsg

I have a degree, but not in anything tech related. I wish that I'd had the opportunity to have some of those classes at the time. I feel that I'd be better able to do some things that I've struggled with. I'm completely self taught, but was lucky to work with someone who loves to teach people how to do things. He helped me out with the concepts that I was having trouble with. It was a personal triumph when I got my MCP. Did it help me? Yes, I did learn quite a few things that helped me at the time. Is it worth anything now? Yes, for the experience.

I've moved away from the technical to being a project manager, but I still use that knowledge every day. So, like JD said, I've used a combo of things to get where I am.

This discussion is closed to new replies.