Discussion Locked

How to distribute Comp time to IT folks?

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have the undaunting task of deciding what to do about Comp Time at our software development company. We want to treat our employees fairly and struggle with how to distribute Comp time without giving away all the profits. (We have quarterly profit sharing and this is where all employees can get cash incentives). As expected in our field, when deadlines are pressed, we work long days and some long weekends. Where do we draw the line on what is a usual amount of expected hours and when do we need to really give comp time??? We've been letting people leave early or take a paid day off here or there but struggle with how much is enough. Some of our people worked tremendous hours in September last year on a huge project, we gave them a party with family as a thank you and gave managers flexibility to okay paid time off as needed by each employee. Some asked for more time than others. However, most still don't think that was enough and has been a sore point we need to address. What would be fair, do we look at # of hours in and come up with some formula to give more days off? If so what is appropriate, 2hrs in to get 1 hr off? We asked them but they are waiting on management to decide what we are willing to give. We are a small company and can't afford to give away billable project time but need to strike a balance to keep are people happy. We have also revised some of our planning so we don't have to work as much overtime, but reality is we will most likely continue to have last minute deadlines that must be met. Any ideas on how to make sure we are being fair, please respond. thanks

17 replies

by jkaras

I wish my job had such perks. The bottom line is people dont want time so much as they want pay compensation. The time sacrifice away from family etc.. desires a payoff for family getaway, new tv, car etc... I wish I could give you some help but times are tuff and no matter how good of a compensation that you will come up with people will still complain. Stick to amount to extra time invested results in higher compensation vs. job title/rate of pay to make it fair. Good luck

by maxwell edison

We expect, of course, everyone to work 40 hours a week. I suppose that's a given. But we also expect folks to work overtime when the project workload and/or deadline requires it.

When people do work over 40 hours a week, our policy is to either pay overtime or give an equal amount of time off, whichever they prefer. People accumulate comp time just like they accumulate vacation time.

So if George works 8 hours on a Saturday, for example, he has the choice to either get paid overtime pay(time and a half) or have 8 hours comp time coming. (Or divided however he wants - 4 and 4, for example.)

by maxwell edison

By the way, people can take that comp time whenever they want, it's all up to them, as long as it doesn't leave the rest of us short-handed or scrambling on a project.

And it's a popular concept because it can allow people to arrange a few extra three-day weekends and/or some time off at Christmas and the like without cutting into their vacation time.

by dbgirl

We also get the choice of overtime pay, or comp time. The difference is that any overtime is compensated at time and a half. In other words, 8 hours of overtime equals 12 hours pay or 12 hours comp time. This works very well here. Of course, preapproval is required for ANY overtime.

by maxwell edison

That's a more equitable way of distributing comp time since overtime is paid at 1.5x. So why not 1.5x comp as well?

That issue has been brought up here on several occasions in the past, and upper management said since comp time was a choice, theydidn't have to do it. At one point someone really started to press the issue, and the comp time option was almost pulled - they would force a person to take the overtime, and no longer allow the comp option. The complaints quickly subsided, and thatperson has long since gone. No one complains too much anymore.

Just the fact the we offer the comp time option has been an attractive benefit to offer potential employees at interview time. Not all companies do it.

In addition, our comp timepolicy is pretty much wrapped into our flex time policy. Office hours are 8 to 5, but if you need a 9-6 or 7-4 or 6-3 or just knock off early and apply a few hours comp time then it's okay.

by cactus pete

My last company let us gather comp days in 2 hour chunks. Any work less than two hours over your normal day was considered just part of your job.

Unfortunately, we never got the opportunity to take the comp time, and you could only carry over 5 days at the end of the year.

We all got screwed every year, and everyone resented it. None of the people who worked there over the past five years [in IT] are still there.

If you come to this level of crunch time this often, perhaps you need to hire more people. Perhaps you need to realign priorities so you don't fall into this trap - at least not so hard.

But be creative and offer other perks - like more opportunities to work remotely, not just from home, but say from a sponsored vacation or something like that. The more creative the solution, the more it pays off in morale.

by server queen

offer people a choice. Presuming these are exempt, offering OT pay or comp time is left to the employer's discretion. If you want to retain quality employees, you're going to have to offer one or the other; yes, times are tough, but the best folks- the ones you really want to keep - can still find work elsewhere.

There's several strategies for this. In a small enterprise, making all employees equal "partners" in the business with profit sharing is sometimes adequate. However, the dot.com crash has left many people feeling burned. Many IT people are no longer willing to postpone living now for the hope of riches in the future.

Some companies, especially large ones, don't allow comp time at all, but they do offer some compensation for OT hours. The Large-Unnamed-Airplane-Manufacturer-In-Seattle for whom I worked for 20 years offered time + $6.50 an hour for exempt employee OT.

Personally, I prefer comp time - given a choice between extra money and a few hours off, I'll always take the extra time off. I believe it should be on a one-to-one basis - an hour of OT equals an hour of comp time. Set policies for how much can be accumulated, how much can be used at once, what kind of prior notification, etc., otherwise, you'll suddenly find yourself without a key employee for three days because they've accumulated 24 hours of overtime. Don't make people wait for a long time after they do their OT before they can use their comp time.

Mandatory overtime is not a good situation. Because of large projects or emergency situations, it's often unavoidable, but if you consistently have excessive OT, you have a staffing issue that needs to be dealt with. People should not have to work more than 40 hours a week for long periods of time. If they are having to do so, you either need more staff, more efficient procedures, or more realistic timeframes to accomplish tasks.

by firstpeter

Being "forced" to work overtime to manage a major crisis or to meet unrealistically-short deadlines takes us away from our families and/or the activities we like to do at our leisure. Although comp time cannot give you the specific time you "lost" back, it can give you "new" time to spend with your family and/or non-work activities by letting you off work (paid, of course).

That's not to say that money can't be a reward. However, for a small business, that becomes difficult, and I think you'll find that many of your employees understand that.

That being said, I'm not sure there's a sure-fire "formula" that you can use to determine how much comp time to distribute. The "hour for an hour" scenario would be ideal, but probably not likely in a small business. We have sixty-hour work weeks sometimes, but it comes with the territory, and folks tend to understand that. In addition, you want to be careful that folks don't get caught up in counting how many hours of overtime they've accumulated. You may lose productivity (and will projects take longer?), and you hit the inevitable conflict when your tallies don't meet theirs.

One of the best ways I've seen it done has been to dish it out as needed, informally (i.e., no tracking of the time). Let your folks manage what time they need. You may find that some people need to take a half-day off to spend with their family the week after a big deadline. Others may not need it as much or need it immediately, but they may need a few hours a month or two down the road when they're starting to burn out. Let it be informal - a good manager will be able to gauge what each of his people needs and deserves. Does that fly legally or from an HR perspective? I have no idea (probably not - there's not enough red tape associated with it). But I have worked under that system in the past and it worked quite well.

by admin

of Labor is illegal. We were trying to figure this out a while ago and then ran it by our lawyers and now we can't officially have it anymore. We didn't believe it at first, and contacted DOL and sure enough, it's illegal, at least in this state.Of course we sometimes do the equivalent unofficially, but it is against our policies to do this. If someone does track it and turn it in, they will simultaneously get paid the appropriate overtime amount and put in the discipline process for not following the policy of prior approval on overtime. According to the Department of Labor in our state overtime must be paid, not comp time.

by cactus pete

My state has exempt and non-exempt employees. Unfortunately, there are several exeptions to this rule, but the general idea is that salaried personnel who earn over $50k each year do not have to be offered or paid overtime. Anyone who is paid hourly, however, must be paid for the work they perform.

by admin

But if you are Exempt you have no need for comp time per se. Only wage earners would have a use for comp time, as salary by definition is not tied to a (hourly) wage.

by oldefar

Exempt and non-exempt salaried workers differ in the the non-exempt are paid a salary regardless of hours plus OT for hours worked beyond their normal schedule. Comp time off is used for the exempt workers.

Comp time for non-exempt and hourly workers varies, but in Texas in 1993 the law required the comp time to be given beforehand. For example, asking someone to come in on Saturday and take another day off instead was okay only if the day off came before the Saturday work.

by cactus pete

Ah.. See, I thought the purpose for comp time was to give something back to the salaried worker who was sacraficing so much 'self' for the company.

I certainly would never think that comp time could be contemplated for hourly paid employees.

by admin

Ok, maybe there are two definitions of comp time? One is an informal way to help salaried people not get their work-life balance too far out and not feel guilty?

To me the reality is that if I work 2 hours or 80 hours a week it doesn't matter. Itdoes matter that I fulfill the tasks in my job description as a salaried worker though and whatever it takes to get done, I work that amount. I average above 40 hrs. a week, but my pay is not based on a 40 hour week, so it's not like I'm getting ripped off or anything. I agreed to fulfill a job description based on clear task analysis and performance. To me, I would think that if I was sacrificing too much I would renegotiate the Job Description and salary because Comp Time, in the event I was already not getting my job done in a reasonable amount of time, would only make things worse as I would have even more to do in less time when I returned.

Anyway, this is quite fascinating and I wonder what benefit one would get from this sort of Comp Time in a different place. I guess this is why in a recent TR poll they called it "unofficial" Comp Time, maybe this is my mistake and I apologize, I was only thinking about the official stuff and the DOL laws here. :)

by firstpeter

I think that definition works in an ideal world (it sounds like admin is in a good situation with regards to it), but I think the reality in most businesses is that job definitions change over time, either in definition or (at the very least) in level of activity. If the job definition has been accurately scoped out up front with all (pertinent) information provided and compensation allocated accordingly, I agree WHOLEHEARTEDLY that if it takes you 2 hours or 80 hours, it's still your responsibility.

What I've seen, however, has been more of a moving target. The job description seems to grow (never shrinks, I've noticed), and if we start talking about adjusting compensation each time that happens nothing new will ever get done (which isn't always a bad thing...).

If what starts out as 50 hours a week becomes a routine 60 hours a week, I think it's time to start talking either a reduction in job responsibilities or more pay to compensate. But if you're covering for two or three weeks while one of your peers is out or you're taking additional work on temporarily, I think the better answer is "unofficial" comp time.

by cactus pete

To many customer service oriented workers, there is no difference between the 2 hour or 80 hour workweek. That's admirable. Whatever it takes to get the job done... But I think most employers would have a fit if you only showed up for 2 hours, whether you got it all done [and more] or not.

On the other hand, my last employer actually thought of doing away with comp time all together since management thought that IT was already financially compensated for the expectation that we would workmore hours than most other employees.

In economics, we say that prices are 'sticky upward'. I'd say that to business, employees' expected work hours are sticky upward, too.

by dbgirl

Where I am, they actually prefer to do the comp time. They consider that they are already paying you your salary, so by not paying overtime they aren't out any additional money. And if all the work is getting done, then what's the harm.

This discussion is closed to new replies.