Discussion Locked

How to Rip Blu-ray Disc to MP4!

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We see a lot of spam on this subject. Speaking as someone who doesn't watch movies, why would one want to do this? What are the advantages? Why does it take special (probably virus-riddled) software to do it?

Inquiring minds want to know.

19 replies

by jaqui

the only advantage is that you can put mp4 onto your iphone or ipod.

and it doesn't take specialized software to do it.
only a media player that will save the audio/video stream into the required format.
[ or one that any of a multitude of apps can convert to the desired format.

Blue Ray is [ apparently ] a very high definition format dvd, so the base image quality of the video component would be much higher to start with, giving you a far better image quality in the ripped video.

by nexs

Why would you need a blu-ray quality mp4 for an iPhone, whose screen is smaller than your palm?
It's over-overkill.

by the 'g-man.'

but fancy having it also available on yer mobile device for those long winter nights on the bus (or whatever).

by charliespencer

I dropped down in the middle of them. I saw a couple, and bored neurons finally sent a strong enough signal to make me wonder what the shills were pushing.

by nwallette

Just saw this in a related link. It's a bit late, but someone casually browsing might find it interesting.

First, why?

MP4 is a container. It has no bearing on the quality of the media within. Same for AVI and MKV for that matter. Though, each container does have constraints as far as what *stream formats* can be stored within, and thereby may impact the quality based on limitations of supported codecs. But that's another matter... The point is, MP4 can store streams that retain all the quality of a Blu-ray disc's program material. It's not inherently "a downgrade", though I suspect most people will pick MP4 to provide support for the iPhone/iPod/iPad, PSP, or some other media player.

And why would someone buy a Blu-ray and then play it back on a measly handheld media player? Well, let's answer this with a question: Would you rather buy multiple copies? (One for your nice home theater, DVD for your car or bedroom, and a digital download for your player, for e.g.) Not me, thanks. I'll buy once and play anywhere. :-)

Or perhaps you'd rather buy only what's necessary for your least-capable device, and have your high-end playback systems used well below their capability? Alright, I'm sure everyone gets the point now.

So then, HOW?

The essential piece is AnyDVD HD. This handles the content protection so the M2TS files are accessible.

What I would do here -- which of course I wouldn't, because it's illegal, and every time you rip a move, God kills a kitten -- but if I were to do it, what I would do is use eac3to to extract the title of interest into its elementary streams. I.e., the chapters to a .TXT file, the video to a .MKV file, the audio to .DTS or .AC3 or .THD or .FLAC file(s), the subtitles to .SUP file(s)... Then use MKVmerge to join these streams into a .MKV file.

There is no quality loss here, unless you specifically request a conversion. You're just encapsulating the streams in a different container.

Then, if I were willing to end a kitten's life, I would use Handbrake to import the .MKV and export a .MP4 with a video track in H.264 at ~640x480, with a 2-channel AAC audio track (with 1.6-to-1 dynamic compression), using the iPhone preset.

I'd put the MKV on my NAS to watch from my capable media players or PCs; and the MP4 I would generate before a long road trip, flight, or weekend away, as it (in theory, of course) takes about half an hour with a fast CPU. The physical disc would go in a box, never to be seen again, but representing the ethical practice of rewarding the content producers for their hard work via the least expensive used copy I could find on Amazon's marketplace.

For example.

by nexs

To press the button.

Why would you do this? You're making the kittens cry.

by santeewelding

The Power That Is comes as though from out of the sky, making you into a Disappeared One.

I can't tell you more than that, except, once on the Other Side, there is no more communication. Those who remain can but clasp their hands and wonder if you are in a better place.

by charliespencer

In the upper right of each post is a link labeled "Mark as Spam", aka "The button". Clicking it sends a message to the site administrators requesting they review the indicated post for offensive content. There's an unofficial competition between some members to see who can be first to flag a spam message, or to flag the most each week. Catching a major spammer is considered laudable in this crowd.

by nwallette

So, my thanks for answering your questions is to have my post marked as spam?

What exactly am I purportedly selling? I intended to write the message for free. If I'm supposedly collecting compensation for it somehow, that's quite news to me.

by charliespencer

I wasn't seeking assistance.

We see dozens of spam each week with titles similar to the one I used. They're unsolicited ads for file conversion software of questionably functionality and legality. Your detailed reply looks a lot like those messages.

by nwallette

Your questions:

> why would one want to do this?

I gave examples. Portability. Play-anywhere.

> What are the advantages?

See above.

> Why does it take special (probably virus-riddled) software to do it?

I provided a list of tools and their purposes. None of them are virus-riddled, the majority are free. The only one that costs anything (which I have ZERO financial interest in, BTW) is simply the best tool for the job, and not terribly expensive anyway.

So, DID I in fact misunderstand, or are you perhaps just a bit jaded?

I know typically in TR-land, it's more fashionable to rag on products and manufacturers, but if I'm regarded as a spammer for speaking kindly of a handful of (mostly free) products and a particular online retailer, then I think I can understand why more people don't offer their endorsements.

I was trying to be helpful. It's a topic I'm interested in. Sorry for intruding, I guess.

by jellimonsta

Even though I have little, to no, interest in performing any of the steps you listed, I did not consider it Spam.
I too saw the direct responses to Palmie's questions, that you gave, in addition to the steps.
I am not sure if Palmie flagged it purely on the grounds of it potentially being used for illegal purposes?

by santeewelding

You did not claim knowledge of his understanding, publicly animadverting only the putative.

Otherwise, Palmetto, you are being raked. Better you than me.

This discussion is closed to new replies.