Discussion Locked

How well did our president do: Looking back at the Bush administration

0 helpful
469 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

469 replies

by 87878

It all depends on our obviously different views of the world...

Where I see Bush as the right man for the right time (and am grateful it is him and not GORE)... where I see him as a man that is taking the fight to them rather than waiting like sitting ducks for it to come to back to us, you obviously don?t...

Putin said it this weekend on the heals of the school tragedy in Belsan? Showing weakness will equal defeat. This was a prelude to what is being seen as Russia's policy shift against terrorism... perhaps taking a lesson from W.

We had to take this tough stance and at the same time work on changing the Arab view of the West... It is easy to see why they hate us (and it is not as simple as our ties to Israel). It?s socio-economic tied up with religious rhetoric.

When one has so little it is easy to hate those that do, and their religion already identifies us as the infidels. We can't combat this from the outside... we have to go there, we have to help them develop their countries, we have to give them a better way of life. That is the only way to ultimately stop terrorism ... content and prosperous people do not become terrorists.

This is no longer time where you can chose not to be bothered with the rest of the world ... 9/11 changed that. We can no longer just sit back and just live our lives. But?.The US is not an empire building country... there's a long history that supports this that Europe and the Blame America First gang chose to forget. Look at WWII?. we helped all the losers rebuild.

They came to NY on 9/11; I lost 2 coworkers... but 9/11 was the second WTC attack; we didn't do anything the first time.. They attacked our embassies, they attacked our ships, we didn't do anything, so they attacked again. So we went there (Afghanistan, Iraq) to keep them too distracted to come here. That was the short-term objective... And long-run, to improve their lives and in the process do ourselves some good too. Again, content people do not become terrorists.

I could go on... I think most dems have a fairly naive worldview. One that seems centered on the question of "how is this good for ME/the US" and the heck with everyone else... that may have been good at time where the Atlantic and Pacific gave us some protection and before the communications explosion, but that is not the case today. These days, it?s a bit more complicated.

We went into Kosovo under Clinton.. Where is the outrage regarding that??? Kosovo had never in the slightest been a threat to us... but we did it anyway.

by oz_media

Apparently 25% of Americans still feel that Saddam is responsible for 9/11 or is directly related to the terrorism brought on by Taliban on 9/11.

Your "(Afghanistan/Iraq)" reference implies that you also lump them together as one and the same. Was it skin color or the dusty baren land they occupy that this similarity came from?

by tbragsda

First, thank-you. This is a well thought-out and (mostly) non-insulting post, would be happy to reply to.

"Where I see Bush as the right man for the right time (and am grateful it is him and not GORE)... where I see him as a man that is taking the fight to them rather than waiting like sitting ducks for it to come to back to us, you obviously don?t..."

No, I don?t. I see this as the best way to increase violence, and hatred of the US globally, and specifically in the Muslim world. I don?t want to be a ?sitting duck?, but rather to increase protection at home, while working to resolve our differences abroad.

"Putin said it this weekend on the heals of the school tragedy in Belsan? Showing weakness will equal defeat. This was a prelude to what is being seen as Russia's policy shift against terrorism... perhaps taking a lesson from W."

Russia is a mess with little doubt. To say the tact before these most recent tragedies was weak seems a bit off. I don?t think Putin is taking a lesson from Bush, but using Bushes example as a way to mollify his current tact.

"We had to take this tough stance and at the same time work on changing the Arab view of the West... It is easy to see why they hate us (and it is not as simple as our ties to Israel). It?s socio-economic tied up with religious rhetoric.

When one has so little it is easy to hate those that do, and their religion already identifies us as the infidels. We can't combat this from the outside... we have to go there, we have to help them develop their countries, we have to give them a better way of life. That is the only way to ultimately stop terrorism ... content and prosperous people do not become terrorists."

Finally, I can find something to agree with you on. The reason for the hatred is deep, and complex. It will take time and effort to understand, let alone fix. We have a bad history in this area of the world. Bad policies through Democrat, and Republican administrations. It will be a marathon to repair the damage, not a sprint to war.

We should stop thinking of these countries as our gas station, and start looking at them as unique people. We ARE the most generous, and helpful nation on the earth. We can make life better for everyone. Is the answer to bomb the people till they like us?

"This is no longer time where you can chose not to be bothered with the rest of the world ... 9/11 changed that. We can no longer just sit back and just live our lives. But?.The US is not an empire building country... there's a long history that supports this that Europe and the Blame America First gang chose to forget. Look at WWII?. we helped all the losers rebuild.

They came to NY on 9/11; I lost 2 coworkers... but 9/11 was the second WTC attack; we didn't do anything the first time.. They attacked our embassies, they attacked our ships, we didn't do anything, so they attacked again. So we went there (Afghanistan, Iraq) to keep them too distracted to come here. That was the short-term objective... And long-run, to improve their lives and in the process do ourselves some good too. Again, content people do not become terrorists."

Before 9/11 we cared about the world. We are the country of the Marshall Plan, the Berlin airdrop. We are extraordinary people. Given the chance to show our humanity, we can figurate and literately make rivers run backwards. We are also ugly when provoked. Its something that makes me sick when I know the immense power we have to fix wrongs used backwardly. I don?t blame us first, only when I think we are wrong.

I?m sorry for your loss. My sister lives in Manhattan, and I fear will never recover completely. As for ?did nothing? I just don?t want to go there. We did try to do something, it was just sandbagged at every turn. The Afganistan, Iraq connection is just wrong, and we both know it. These are different discussions.

"I could go on... I think most dems have a fairly naive worldview. One that seems centered on the question of "how is this good for ME/the US" and the heck with everyone else... that may have been good at time where the Atlantic and Pacific gave us some protection and before the communications explosion, but that is not the case today. These days, it?s a bit more complicated."

This is the only place in your post I could find an unprovoked, thoughtless insult. I could say the same for Republicans, but I would be wrong too. Groups of people are never just of one mind.

"We went into Kosovo under Clinton.. Where is the outrage regarding that??? Kosovo had never in the slightest been a threat to us... but we did it anyway."

Where was the outrage? It was on the streets of Chicago where I was protesting against the policies a administration I help to elect. War has done little to help ever.

by dbertsche

Tell us what Kerry is going to do, all I ever hear people saying is vote for Kerry because Bush sucks, give me a break. The Dems have yet to offer any real reason for voting for their guy. What's he stand for?

by oz_media

Nobody REALLY thinks Kery is some political genius that is going to change the world. The issue of people voting for Kerry is simply he is NOT Bush. That's enough for most after watching Bush drag your country and it's people through the mud for four years.

I think if Ronald MacDonald were up for election he would be favoured over Bush just due to the amount of distaste in your OWN country toward Bush. not to mention th other Allied countries citizens that are just as strongly opposed to Bush if not moreso.

So as far as what Kerry could do differently, well he can't b Bush and that's the whole point.

As far as what he stands for, not too much that Bush did, and that's good enough for most.

by aldanatech

This is what he stands for:

1) He has a more solid plan to fight the war on terrorism:

a. The battle ground for terrorism is not in a set country. It is global. So we must restore some of sympathy we lost and get more support from our allies.

b. It will take more than military action to fight the war on terrorism. We must compliment it with intelligence and diplomacy.

c. We must look for ways to reduce our dependency on oil from the Middle East. We can start by supporting the production of Hybrid vehicles.

2) He has plan for the economy:

a. So many jobs are being outsourced from other countries that people in middle class have fewer and fewer opportunities. Kerry wants to cut taxes on business that create jobs inside the US.

b. The wealthiest Americans don't need tax cuts as much as the middle class. Someone with $10 million dollars is not exactly happier than someone with $9.5 or $9.75 million. The middle class is made up of people that work hard and keep our country a productive one. A tax cut for the middle class would truly give that kind of effect that Bush proposed on his tax cut plan.

c. We got to get out of this torturing deficit. Bush's dad had a similar problem, but Clinton fixed it and created a huge surplus by the end of his second term. Kerry wants to be realistic at this point of course, so he wants to at least cut deficit in half by the end of his first term.

3) Education is one of the major issues for this election:

a. The cost of College education is extremely high, and Kerry agrees. His plan for this includes a fully refundable College Opportunity Tax credit on up to $4,000 of tuition for every year of college.

b. Grade schools have issues of their own. For that he offers better training and better pay for teachers in troubled schools, and after-school programs that are open until 6 p.m. for 3.5 million children along with safe transportation.

4) Because of the war on terrorism we seem be slowing down a bit on technological advances and innovation. We need to get back on track and reclaim our top position in the world.

There are other issues that Kerry wants to address that relate to energy and the environment. Kerry's solutions relate to those for the economy and the war on terrorism. So there you go. That is what Kerry plans to do as president in a broad and simplified sense.

by oz_media

Look high and low, every source is bised in some respect, although some more than others.

There IS no middle ground, one has to look at extreme left and right and try to deciher what is so and what is not.

to claim your sources are any more credible than any other is sheer hypocrisy, nobody has the truth yet, it doesn't come out until a president is removed from office, then the following administration starts to air the realities of the former once the truth cannot be hidden from the public anymore.

If you think te White House, or any other source including Bush's own words are any more credible than a Terminator movie, then you need to give your head a shake and wake up to reality.

by dbertsche

The point is the majority of the sources sited are biased to the liberal point of view, yes you are correct in that all sources will be biased one way or another. My point is present an equal number of sources for both points of view and that is not what the initial poster did.

by oz_media

I see your point.

I am just used to the Right complaining that every source is Lefty BS, then they counter with Righty BS?!?

by garion11

Its amazing how you come onto this board and butt your head into everything and try to influence other people into not voting for Bush because of your own selfish gains.

Forget the fact that you know nothing about US politics, but its absolutely ridiculous you word your opinion into "...Bush drag your country and it's people..." all for what?? What are you really afraid of? or jealous of? or envious of?

When I ask why you come onto these boards when this election is none of your business, you spewed out that it is your business (and you proceeded to give your reasons). Thats all fine and dandy, but you are a selfish, self centered guy who doesn't care about American people or citizens, yet has tha gall to accuse US of being arrogant and selfish.

What would you really do if Bush wins? LOL.

by 87878

You are a one issue person who can't see the broader problem.

Arabs are raised to hate the west... how are you going to change that from your comfy couch world?

You'd wish the problem would just go away...

If you can explain why we went into Kosovo in the context of US national interest, then talk to me about Iraq. There was plenty more reason to go into Iraq with respect to national interest then Kosovo, but Dems were all over supporting Kosovo involvement, where the US had absolutely nothing to gain from it... nothing.
What Hypocrisy!!!

by oz_media

What a fool you can be, first of all, you made a slew of incorrect assertions that I corrected you on and provided sources to the reality of what you deem is a day at the fair and you have no reply.

When I respond to someone else's comments, THAT YOU HAVE TAKEN ABOSULTELY NO PART IN WHATSOEVER, your response is that I butt in to conversations? Where did YOU come from ? What a two faced hypocrite you are, man...do you actually think at all before ranting? You accuse somebody of doing exactly what you have just done and expect to be heard out? What a goof!

Please point out [b]exactly WHICH statements[/b] I made in my last response that you say are self-centered or arrogant.

As usual, you will probably just shoot your mouth off and call me a foreigner, nobody will listen to what I want, blah blah blah, yada yada and a whole bunch of other hot air with no substance as always.

What you must begin to realize is that I am not the only one with such opinions, half of your country and th emajority of the free world also sees GWB as the worst rpesidet in US history and he must be removed from power which he has proven completely incapable of holding. Just like he failed as an entrpreneur and every other thing he's done in life that proves him as a constant failure.

by oz_media

I think you have syuggested that the US is not justified in war unless that are gaining from it?

That is the underlying issue you have with democrats suporting Kosovo. The US had nothing to gain from it? What will you gain from killing a few thousand Iraqi's? Freedom? Safety? Do you REALLY still believe you wil stop terrorism, if so let Bush know, even he says terrorism won't be stopped.

So what GAINS are you there for?

by thelastword

If it were Canada, he might have lingered on for 20 years. The only REASON you can distinguish this person as a S**T leader is because you have researched it on the internet. Otherwise you be as butted out of US politics as everyone else was 10 years ago. You have concluded him as a s**t leader, but the democratic system in the US has foolproof on THIS as they can vote him OUT after 4 years if there's not another donkey waiting there. If there's oNe donkey, whose to say there might not be TWO. They are USED to it, you are not, the internet has made this fresh for you.

by 87878

The anti-W lot seems to harp on his reasons for going and that there was no national justification. Well, if that question is raised for Iraq, it has to be for Kosovo... for which there was absolutely no national justifcuiation... it was a noble cause, but there was no national justification...

At least by Iraq, we did a good thing and have some national interest in the cause. I've already covered allot of the latter, the rational for us being Iraq, in my prior postings...

by thelastword

Like that part is a bit sketchy, uhhhh, Arabs have so 'little???' NOT. They are looking at YOU like you have so little. They are rich. Who over there has so little exactly?

by tbragsda

Look at the posts, and who sad "they have little".

Well, I will defend my friend on the right. They DO have little. The distribution of wealth is worse than our own country.

The point he, and I are both makeing is well feed, well clothed, well shelter people, are less likely to become angry homicidal people. Move people up past that, and they may even become happy people.

by thelastword

The distribution of wealth within their country or yours is NO issue unless you feel this is what is fueling their resentment toward the US.

by tbragsda

When people are poor, hungry, or mistreated, they are pron to find someone to blame. We do play a part in their misfortune, or a large part in watching some become wealthy while other remain poor.

As I and others are quick to point out, these are complex problems. They don't have a answer today, as they took a long time become problems. Im not looking back, Im trying to look forward. I don't see even the momentary destruction of terrorist organizations winning. We will have to think about how, and why these problems exist.

So, as to your question "this is what is fueling their resentment toward the US." Yes, its playing its part.

by thelastword

Only the part you directly are responsible for oppressing through previous wars but don't let that fool you. The US IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR TERRORIST Violence in the world. Look around you, do you think the US is the source of terrorism? Arab militia is committing genocide in Sudan as we speak, they blew-up 300 kids in RUssia ONE WEEK ago. If you as an American can sit there and say you have some part in that then your country does have its problems and a WHOLE new WEAKNESS against terrorism. Don't buckle under because of what other countries are saying. Even if people are questioning your presidents last actions it's no call for you to question every aspect of your country because in doing so you are showing weakness to terrorism. ALSO, in your paranoia you incorrectly feel that terrorists are out to get America, thats not even true either. They aren't picky abotu WHo and you are not the onyl target at all. The internet is fuelling these self-analysis discussions and making you show your country as weak when it shoudl be strong.

by oz_media

As many here may remember, I was first disgusted at Bush long before ANY war was waged.

I am a former public speaking and motivational coach as well as a private study of psychology and criminal meantality.

Watching GWB for the first time had me sitting with my jaw open as EVERY one of his eye movements and his body language is TEXTBOOK in the FBI's profiling techniques as ways to determine a liar. He didn't have a single shred of credibility and failed all visual integrity tests, while publically speaking to America.

He was a complete farce of a liar until his 'people' worked to get his mannerisms down to look a little more truthful, anyone from the FBI or RCMP must have been rolling on the floor laughing at him and wondering if anyone had caught on to his falsehoods in his speeches.

Then he just went on and on to prove it.

When I FIRST voiced my distatse for his incredible marreisms ad textbook idications of pure BS, I was foced by many members here to PROVIDE proof. I was adamat that I was only sharig my personal beliefs based on what I had studied, they just don't nuy it unless it is from a website. THAT is when I became focused on exploring the web and comparing thedifferent sides in search of the truth. Funny nough, no truth was found on ANY US site no matter if it was for or against him, both are terribly biased.

Then after searching WORLD news, I realized that te USA is only reportig a TINY party of the realities of what is going on. Our Canadian news was MUCh more graphic and realistic in comparisson, to which I was told the USA does not censor news. After once again provig that the USA has ALWAYS censored and controlled war reports, reporting restrictions are even outlined on the Pentagon's website, they still don't believe the US is only getting the fair weather reports from Iraq and claim the rest of the world is wrong and biased, er okay, whatever you wish to believe.

When Canadian news reports show video footage of the horrors that were taking place, it was called Canadian propaganda and lefty BS. Well in my experience, unless you have a studio and paid Hollywood actors, film doesn't lie. The reportig may be biased but not FILM of events that proved what was being reported in the US and elsewhere around the world were two different things, this also helped explain WHY people actually supported Bush in the USA, they had only seen the rosy side.

So while you would like to think that I have built my knowledge based on the internet, I had formed the opinion myself long before being pushed to use the internet for proof by Republican supporters, time to look at yourselves again.

You guys see one thing and it's understandable that some would feel they get the full story.

I watch your news and other world news, including Middle Eastern news (hard to understand but much is translated), Asian news, British news and Canadian news. Al countries report the same news for the most part, except the US channels and websits where a completely diferent twist, if not an entirely diferent story are the focus.

I understand where/how you guys are so easily lead to believe what you do, but then again, until you've seen the other side of the fence, you have no idea what you are really not beig shown. I am also not the first foreigner to note how different US and world reports are. Just curl up under the blankets and everything will be just fine.

by oz_media

A million volts couldn't get it through to may of you. I may skip around with a Canadian flag, just thankful that I do not live in the USA though, as most Canadians are.

by thelastword

You definitely wont be able to tackle that one unless youve got a handle on it in your own country. Thats irrelevent to the issue

by thelastword

Listen, I am canadian too and I lived in the US for 10 years, lots of cool and fun friends in the US!! Noone is disputing that George Bush is an idiot, every american president has been deemed some kind of idiot at some point. BUT the reality is AMERICANS are not responsible for terrorism. Threats of terrorism exist, that should be the focus as terrorists just blew up 300 kids and 3000 sudanese and they are laughing at you while you sit here on the internet critisizing the US for it. That is exactly the wanted effect. Do you understand my point?
What value do your propose to gain in attempting to sit here and make americans look at all their weaknesses, in effect exploiting George Bush mistake and using it as an excuse to get into americans heads.

by tbragsda

I don't think Oz is "trying to get into Americans heads." are you Oz? Hope not. Im not very strong (weak liberal that I am), and you Canaidan... stay back Canada!!! Im armed to the teeth! (thanks to GWB)

by aldanatech

So what? They're not the ones running for president.

Bush also said he was going to get Osama Bin Laden, but instead he left that mission uncomplete and decided to atack Iraq on March of 2003. And of course this is not a conventional war, and therefore should be not fought in a conventional way. Why couldn't Bush even take his own advice?

by thelastword

I love the US too!! Thats why I spent alot of time. I miss it there. I am very interested in the differences in our cultures, if it weren't my duty to take an opposing viewpoint to you Oz I would say we have a very similar fascination, viewpoint and ability to question the US, I have spent many hours on that too, particularly on how that played out in my personal experioences there so I believe I am in as good a position as you to make that assessment. Sorry!!!

by thelastword

Well then what are you talking about. The whole issie will come down to one of protection if you are discussing WAR and terrorists and the US role in it. If you still feel great and all that and you dont mind people like Oz saying that the US is GOING DOWN as a super power because of GWB than I guess youre pretty good all around

by tbragsda

Im not just blaming America. I didn't know you were Canadian. Now that I do, I will blame your countrymen too.

We, America, has had its hands on this regions since WWII. Government, resources, everything. Im not going to point fingers at any administration, but to say that we didn't play a part (read PART) in how the inequities in these countries developed is to stick my fingers in my ears and say "America can do no wrong".

I have posted several times. America is my country, and I am very proud of all she does right, but I don't let pass when we do wrong. I want to be the America that gives hope to people, not the one that drops bombs.

This is not week. Its much harder to make peace than bomb into submission.

Kudos to anyone for the name of the author of the following quote
"Its easy to hate, it takes strength to be patient and kind"

Its just all this "bomb" talk. (hint)

by oz_media

Better still don't bother, I anm not interested in your comments anyway.

I am not on a MISSION to PROVE anything.

Because I work at home I have a lot of time to kill, the utter ignorace of some Americans to not understand that they just MAY not be getting the whole picture is comical. they then say pople are lying or statig falsehoods because they haven't heard Bush say it, then when proof is rovided, it's lefty BS. good for a chuckle anyway.

I also ha many American friends and parter companies I've worked with, touring companies, record companies, talent scouts etc. I don't blame Americans for being misinformed, I blame the blind ones who simply refuse to accept ay other information other than what GWB has force fed them.

I DON'T BLAME America for 9/11, someone else made that absurd comment earlier. I also don't blame Saddam for 9/11, someone already proudly claimed responsibility for that ad while he was said to be the most imortat target at the time and America would not rest until he was caught, now GWB says he doesn't matter.

Gee, here's a good idea, go vote for him again. Sure.

by oz_media

It is a fact of economics and prove history.

A super power cannot remain a super power, it can't, hasn't and won't be done.

This current administration is the exact reason WHY countries do not retain super power status, they go to war and destroy their economy.

Now if that is Jimmy Carter's fault thn so be it, perhaps Reygun is responsible, no couldn't be him, hmmmm, Kerry? No he's not in charge.

I KNOW !! Geroge Bush waged the war! He offered to spend almost 200 Billion on it!

Well id the economy then taks a beating in th eupcomiong years and aome other coutry, say China for example actually takes oer as the world's leading super power, thee will only be one person to blame. not Nixon, Clinton, Reagan or Kerry, the one that lead them to a pre-emptive, poorly planned, poorly justified invasion of another nation, George Bush.

by tbragsda

I don't need protection from you from Oz "getting into my head" that's all. Really just joking around. I was feeling that the discussion today has been among thoughtful people, lets not loose that because of one joke.

This election is about WAY more than terrorism. I don't feel any more vulnerable then you might up north. It has its part, but 9/11 DID NOT CHANGE EVERYTHING! There were terrorist before, and we knew that, there will be terrorist after this election, or the next. What to do about them, what to do about our economy, our world reputation, our poor, our... the list of domestic and international problems go on.

Its my opnion that Bush was never up to this task. Next.

by tbragsda

I don't need protection from you from Oz "getting into my head" that's all. Really just joking around. I was feeling that the discussion today has been among thoughtful people, lets not loose that because of one joke.

This election is about WAY more than terrorism. I don't feel any more vulnerable then you might up north. It has its part, but 9/11 DID NOT CHANGE EVERYTHING! There were terrorist before, and we knew that, there will be terrorist after this election, or the next. What to do about them, what to do about our economy, our world reputation, our poor, our... the list of domestic and international problems go on.

Its my opnion that Bush was never up to this task. Next.

by aldanatech

In a nutshell, even though these "accomplishments" look kind of nice on the outside, many of they hardly match with reality and are far from addressing many of the true issues in the country.

Examples:

[Made $33 million available for abstinence education programs in 2004]

If Bush thinks its going to be that easy then he better slam his head on the wall. In theory we would wish teens would actually follow this approach, but ever since he implemented this program the rate of teen pregnancies sky rocketed.

[Supports the Defense of Marriage Act ? and a Constitutional amendment saying marriage is between one man and one woman]

Unless to get more conservative votes, there?s not much of point for a president to be dealing with these kinds of issues. Now I don?t expect to see homosexual couples get married in a church. Each religion does have a right to set certain standers and enforce them. As citizens of the US however, we should have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness in our unique way; and if somebody can find happiness at the side of someone of the same sex then so be it. Besides, heterosexual divorce rates today are so high that they hurt the "family foundation" more that gay marriage ever can.

[Signed two income tax cuts, one of which was the largest dollar-value tax cut in world history]

This is the main reason why we jumped from a booming surplus to a record history deficit. Now don?t get me wrong. I do support tax cuts but only when you can afford them. Bush?s tax cuts were so outrageously irresponsible that he probably didn?t even anticipate the consequences.

[Turned around an inherited economy that was in recession, and deeply shocked as a result of the 9/11 attacks]

Wrong. The economy was awesome during the Clinton administration and it was continuing a steady climb. It sharply fell down shortly after Bush?s first tax cuts and the surplus plunged around August, 2001. Then 9/11 and Bush's second tax cut made it even worse.

[Changed the tone in the White House, restoring HONOR and DIGNITY to the presidency]

That was basically "You are either with us, or against us". Thanks for screwing up our alliances with the global community Bush, not.

[Signed the No Child Left Behind Act, delivering the most dramatic education reforms in a generation (challenging the soft bigotry of low expectations). The very liberal California Teachers union is currently running radio ads against the accountability provisions of this Act.]

Several months after the act, I noticed that several schools began to have budget issues that they didn?t use to have in years and several tutoring programs were cut out. Now even some libraries will soon be closed down.

[Increased funding for the Troops-to-Teachers program, which recruits former military personnel to become teachers]

Our local schools didn?t get to see any of that. If fact, we now have a shortage of teachers because some of them were reservist and were deployed to Iraq.

[Killed the Kyoto Global Warming Treaty]

Their reasons to reject the Kyoto treaty were just lame excuses to help environmentally hostile companies save money. The purpose of the treaty was to agree to cut greenhouse gas emissions, which result mainly from burning coal and oil, by an average of 5.2 percent below 1990 levels by 2012. Its development began with concerns presented at the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro about the effects of climate changes; such as the movement of agricultural zones, the melting of polar ice caps and rising sea levels.

The major concern for the US was that fines for violations of the treaty would be around the billions of dollars. Out of the greenhouse gas emissions, the one we must worry about most is Carbon dioxide, which is mostly produced by burning fossil fuels in power stations. It is naturally converted to oxygen by plants, but deforestation is reducing the planet's ability to absorb CO2. If we go on at this rate it is estimated that we will have about twice as much atmospheric carbon dioxide by 2030, and about three times that much by 2100. But of course Bush and his buddies probably won't be around by then, so what do they care.

[Successfully executed two wars in the aftermath of 9/11/01: Afghanistan and Iraq. 50 million people who had lived under tyrannical regimes now live in freedom]

Correction: One half-completed war and another yet uncompleted war. The US left Afghanistan without completing reconstruction and without setting a strong government that would defend it. Now the Taliban is slowly recovering power, and before you know it we will be back were we started. As for Iraq, not even the Bush administration knows when it will end. So far it resulted in over 1000 US soldiers and over 6,400 others wounded, over 20,000 Iraqi civilians, and over $144.4 billion dollars.

[Saddam Hussein is now in prison. His two murderous sons are dead. All but a handful of the regime's senior members were killed or captured]

If the reason to go to Iraq was to free its people from Saddam?s regime then they should of said so from the start, not for WMDs. I find it to be a valid reason. We would have gotten more support from our allies and we now wouldn?t carry so much burned. Maybe even the UN would have supported us. This is how we did it back in Desert Storm and worked just about right.

[Challenged the United Nations to live up to their responsibilities and not become another League of Nations (in other words, showed the UN to be completely irrelevant).]

There is a reason for the existence of the United Nations. Let?s not forget that the US strongly declared the Iraq had Weapons of Mass Destruction. The right move for the UN was to send weapons inspectors to confirm this. They didn?t found any, but they were willing to keep looking if the US insisted on its statement. Well the US pulled the inspectors ahead of time and attacked Iraq only to find that the inspectors, the UN, and all the other countries that opposed this war were right.

[Told the Congress and the world, "America will never seek a permission slip to defend the security of our country."]

Defend the security of our country? From who? From Iraq? Iraq itself was a threat to us, not even Afghanistan. Those countries were only fertile ground for terrorists, but they got lots of other places to choose from.

[Led the most extensive reorganization the Federal bureaucracy in over 50 years: After 9/11, condensed 20+ overlapping agencies and their intelligence sectors into one agency, the Department of Homeland Security.]

Well Bush strongly opposed the creation of the 9/11 commission, and it was only created because many family members of 9/11 victims fought strongly for it.

[Started the USA Freedom Corps, the most comprehensive clearinghouse of volunteer opportunities ever offered. For the first time in history, Americans can enter geographic information about where they want to get involved, such as state or zip code, as well as areas of interest ranging from education to the environment, and they can access volunteer opportunities offered by more than 50,000 organizations across the country and around the world.]

And instead he cut out AmeriCorps, one of the nation's most prominent public service agencies of about 16,000 volunteers. AmeriCorps provided federal funds to more than 2,000 nonprofit groups across the country. Those groups administered a variety of public service programs, in which volunteers (often recent college graduates) tutored students in after-school programs, cleaned parks and streams, or help build affordable housing

by tbragsda

I was going to reply to him, but the fact is, I just don't thing he is reading any of the posts, even his own.

I'm not one to turn down the gauntlet, but if the guy cant even take the time to read replys, its hard to engage.

by tbragsda

I was going to reply to him, but the fact is, I just don't thing he is reading any of the posts, even his own.

I'm not one to turn down the gauntlet, but if the guy cant even take the time to read replys, its hard to engage.

by aldanatech

You sure know your stuff. And let me tell you, I find Wal-Mart to be so Bush like. Bush strongly endorses it, and it is a major contributor to Bush?s campaign.

by thelastword

There's no dispute there from my point of view. It being the demise of the US, I don't think so and I'm not going to contribute to a conversation leading down that path which is where this has gone several times. and B, I don't believe in exploiting the incident to bash american citizens as ignorant and all that other stuff. Thats what I'm 'going on' about. As far as what you do up in Port Fardy. I don't care if your running around wearing the Canadian flag as as your underwear, really. I don't. Have at it, hang it outside your cabin. Wave it at the bears then. LOLOLOL

by aldanatech

Back in February, Bush sat down in the Oval Office for an interview about his service in the National Guard. Bush told us, "I put in my time, proudly so." He said, "And I'm telling you, I did my duty."

But now there are reasons to believe that Bush dishonored the Oval Office by lying to the American people.

This morning, I saw reports about how new investigations from multiple media sources have revealed the truth about Bush's service. New military documents show that he disobeyed a direct order from his commander to take a flight physical and "failed to perform to U.S. Air Force/Texas Air National Guard standards" -- and was grounded as a result.

New evidence supports claims that Bush missed months of service and that he never showed up for service with the Alabama National Guard.

New evidence shows that Bush received special treatment. His supervisor wrote that he felt pressured from above to "sugar coat" Bush's records.

And Ben Barnes, former Lt. Governor and State House Speaker of Texas, has come forward to say that he pulled strings to get Bush a coveted spot in the Guard, which directly contradicts Bush's claim that he received no special treatment.

Bush has a lot to answer for. I guess only he can clear up the questions regarding the discrepancies in his service record, and he owes the American people those answers. Here are just a few of the questions he must answer (and if anyone can provide some answer for these I would appreciate it):

1. Why did Bush say "I did my duty" when he missed months of duty in 1972, 73 and 74?

2. How did Bush avoid getting called into active service for missing months of duty in 1972, 73, and 74?

3. Why did Bush disobey a direct order to take his physical?

4. What standard did Bush fail to meet when he was grounded for failing to perform at US Air Force/Texas Air National Guard Standards?

5. Why did Bush go above his commander's head to ensure a favorable evaluation he had not earned?

6. Why did Bush say he received "no special treatment" when Ben Barnes says he pulled strings to secure a Guard slot for him?

7. Who asked Bush's family friend Sidney Adger to get Bush a slot in the Guard immediately after Bush graduated and at the height of the Vietnam War?

8. When will Bush produce any credible witness who can attest to his service in the Alabama Air National Guard?

I hope anyone (if not Bush himself) can at least answer these question.

by maxwell edison

.
CBS NEWS executives have launched an internal investigation into whether its premiere news program 60 MINUTES aired fabricated documents relating to Bush's National Guard service, the DRUDGE REPORT has learned.

"The reputation and integrity of the entire news division is at stake, if we are in error, it will be corrected," a top CBS source explained late Thursday.

The source, who asked not to be named, described CBSNEWS anchor and 60 MINUTES correspondent Dan Rather as being privately "shell-shocked" by the increasing likelihood that the documents in question were fraudulent.

Rather, who anchored the segment presenting new information on the president's military service, will personally correct the record on-air, if need be, the source explained from New York.

http://www.drudgereport.com/cbsd.htm

by tbragsda

I saw this on Fox this AM. and have to admit, I was not surprised. Not surprised that correct or fabricated, something was going to happen to make this even more diluted. Those that choose not to believe a fairly simple story to begin with, are less likely to buy-in now that its confused with so much complex detail. Bush's team has been working this since he was running for Governor. They can deflect forever. Muddy!

This administration has had enough of a failing record in the last four years, that AWOL makes little difference. Lets all move on to the topics that truly effect our lives.

by tbragsda

http://news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/20040910/ap_on_go_pr_wh/bush_guard_questions_2

---
CBS, which reported on the memos on its "60 Minutes" program, said its experts who examined the documents concluded that they were authentic. They ostensibly were written by Lt. Col. Jerry Killian, one of Bush's commanders in 1972 and 1973.

But Killian's son, one of Killian's fellow officers and an independent document examiner questioned the memos. Gary Killian, who served in the Guard with his father and retired as a captain in 1991, said he doubted his father would have written an unsigned memo which said there was pressure to "sugar coat" Bush's performance review.
---

Two sides to the story. You will believe what you want to hear.

Lets agree on this, Bush got a good deal with the TANG, and Kerry enlisted. These are facts that I think all can agree on.

We all have more important problems faceing us now!

by tbragsda

The IBM Selectric Composer

It had mutliple fonts available. All the way from 12 pt to 3 pt. It typed in proportional type - which could be disabled - and it had a "dead" key which could be programmed to do different characters. It was first introduced in 1966.

See page 3 4Sep68 for example of Superscript "th"
http://www.usatoday.com/news/bushdocs/9-Miscellaneous.pdf

I doubt that its forgery, but will wait and see. Still makes no difference in the face of a failed administraion.

by 87878

The Kerry team seems to be grasping at straws on the military comparisons... and inventing them too, though probably blame it on some 527.

Sad really...

by aldanatech

You mean give up my freedom of speech? I don't think so. Besides, that post was based on what I heard on the news. I am supposed to be responsible for what the media reports? Also, the yahoo report only shows that there is a mix of truth and fiction; and so now this becomes one of those cases where anyone's call is as good as anyone else's.

by 87878

I find we are not so far apart in the major areas. I do hate labels, but alas I am guilty of using them occasionally...

I just have a perspective that comes from being born abroad, in an Iron Curtain country (the Soviet Block countries in the hey day of the USSR; I know the alternatives out there intimately, so I tend get stuck on some dem platforms/approaches... too much of a d?j?' vieux for me.

But as a conservative, we get other labels ? Personally I cherish the day I became an American citizen and have never stopped appreciating both the liberty and humanity it represents.

Both sides tend to stress and exaggerate differences too much, and rather than stressing what we all do agree on, but that?s politics I guess.

In the end, it is the both the beauty and strength of this country that we don't have to agree, but that we would all fight passionately for each other's rights to hold our views, what ever they might be.

I'll look for your future posts and will look forward to our debates.

Regards,
87878

by 87878

"Independent document examiner Sandra Ramsey Lines said the memos looked like they had been produced on a computer using Microsoft Word software. Lines, a document expert and fellow of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences, pointed to a superscript ? a smaller, raised "th" in "111th Fighter Interceptor Squadron" ? as evidence indicating forgery. "

Not sure how old you are, but I can tell you as one who recalls typing on the classic device, the superscript was just not a feature back in the day.

Seems to be some cut and dry evidence of monkey business.

by garion11

"No, I don?t. I see this as the best way to increase violence, and hatred of the US globally, and specifically in the Muslim world. I don?t want to be a ?sitting duck?, but rather to increase protection at home, while working to resolve our differences abroad."

This is what I mean by liberal thought. They already do hate us, you can't talk to these people nor appease them. The differences cannot be resolved because their hatred revolves around the State of Israel and our support for it. What do you do then?

"Russia is a mess with little doubt. To say the tact before these most recent tragedies was weak seems a bit off. I don?t think Putin is taking a lesson from Bush, but using Bushes example as a way to mollify his current tact."

Yeah I agree, Russia is a mess. They are not innocent with Chechenya. Lots of atrocities were committed by Russians and this is simply another escalation by the Chechen side. Although I have to give credit to the Russians for being smart enough to keep this under the radar. Its just the Muslims seem to announce to the world and take that extra stupid step in committing atrocities.

Finally, I can find something to agree with you on. The reason for the hatred is deep, and complex. It will take time and effort to understand, let alone fix. We have a bad history in this area of the world. Bad policies through Democrat, and Republican administrations. It will be a marathon to repair the damage, not a sprint to war.

We should stop thinking of these countries as our gas station, and start looking at them as unique people. We ARE the most generous, and helpful nation on the earth. We can make life better for everyone. Is the answer to bomb the people till they like us?

Instead of hating us, they should hate their governments for opressing them. We haven't done anything to "opress" them, its all their own governments who refuse to provide the aid that we give their leaders.

They are our gas station and we are their customers. If you were to enter a gas station and buy gas from someone, and later on the guy that owns the gas station shoots your family, would you go back and buy some more gas from him?

"Where was the outrage? It was on the streets of Chicago where I was protesting against the policies a administration I help to elect. War has done little to help ever. "

I never heard it. All I hear is everything under the sun protesting "Bush's war" when the liberals themselves have said that they were for this war going back to the Clinton Administration.

War defeated Germany in WWI, WWII. War is a last resort, but good people fight it reluctantly while evil people start it. Please understand the differences between US and THEM.

by 87878

It comes up in 2 ways:

1. Our warring actions have caused the world to hate us more...
2. Our warring actions have caused Arabs to hate us more.

The below are my thoughts on the topic?

A. ?Jihad? was declared against the US by the terrorists who have their tentacles spread all-over globe. In other words we didn?t start this?
a. The terror agenda is simple: destroy the West and all it represents. Paint the West as the root of all evil to all Arabs, most which are not oil moguls and living badly.
b. They already hate us and before we went over there, Afghanistan, Iraq, had exclusive audience with the Arab populous.
c. The Arabs needed to hear and see a different message and lifestyle option. Afghanistan and Iraq will be templates for what can be in that region and though this will take time it will ultimately destroy the terrorist agenda. Echoing my comments above, content people do not become terrorists.
B. Our ?allies? were happy to string us along and sign resolutions in the UN, but when it came down to it were not willing to show their teeth.
a. Why wasn?t the resolution enough justification for the allies going in as a unified group? Do you recall that Clinton like Bush and for the same reason ignored the UN when chose to bomb Iraq?
b. What is the point of a ?UN? if it can?t and doesn?t carry any weight?
c. Could it be that some of our ?allies? had become so politically impotent and besieged by their own ulterior, economic, motives, that they? d forgotten the significance of their commitments to a country that had had their backs and saved their arses over and over again?
d. Can you blame any of us in the US that see the UN as irrelevant and given their recent history, which the liberal press did not give much attention to, also corrupt.
C. Our national interest? this one is simple and Bush is right on?. No nation, not France, not Germany, not the Russians, should presume that our national interest is second to how warm and fuzzy our allies feel toward us?it is not the thermometer we should be basing our decisions on. Sorry, that?s just the way it is. That?s not to say we shouldn?t care, but in the end, the primary goal of any government should be to protect and serve the interests of its own people.

To sum it up,

A. They hate us already? the hatred is deep, it is ugly, and rooted in things many of us outside the Arab world can?t begin to understand; that is why we need to go in there and work to change views.
B. Our allies are not all noble and enlightened countries striving for a better world. They impotent and self motivated, and should not be primary driver in our decisions.

by thelastword

They basically hate everyone. They are just looking for any target. It;s not about the free world either. They just hate anyone. Its a force and they will latch on to whatever looks unpopular whatever is weak to justify their actions and create opportunity to carry out their actiosn which are destructive and self-serving

by tbragsda

They DO hate us. Talks, or bomb, are they our only options? Has the bombing done anything to change that hate?

I see this as a problem that generations from now, we will still be working at. The answer in the short run may look military, but I doubt that will fix it. You asked ?the guy that owns the gas station shoots your family, would you go back and buy some more gas from him?? No I would not! Lets stop using so much so we don?t have to. We must think beyond our current need for oil. It puts us at a disadvantage, where we must react today, less we loose the flow of oil. If our hands were not forced, would the policies be the same?

Just looking at Israel, it?s again, only one of the problems. We in this forum are mostly geared towards problem/resolution. This problem is tangled. Reducing it to this-or-that too small.

by aldanatech

You see, the problem with Bush?s actions as a president is that he has so many negatives that you can hardly cite any positive ones. Keeping this in mind I am still being fair. You will notice that the list includes several articles that would appeal to pro-lifers and those against gay marriage. I even include a couple of sources where I let Bush show his side in the issues of energy consumption and gay marriage.

by maxwell edison

.
...on the 60 minutes story - which was based on FORGED DOCUMENTS!!!

The Democrat Party Dirty Tricks Division screwed up big time. The Democrats are imploding.

The Democrats have lost all credibility. CBS and Dan Rather has lost all credibility.

I might have to adjust my 53% prediction up a few percentage points.

I'll be drinking champaign,
Feeling no pain,
Come Wednesday Morning.......

by aldanatech

Well then in this case it CBS's responsibility. They still stand by for what they reported by the way.

by maxwell edison

.
Please, exercise all the freedom of speech you want. I love it. It actually helps make my case.

However, be advised:

It is better to keep your mouth shut and let people think you are a fool than to open your mouth and remove all doubt.
-- Mark Twain

by thelastword

How does the american need for oil relate to middle eastern terrorists? I don;t get the connection. IF you reduce the need for oil, you don't reduce terrorists.

by maxwell edison

.
1. You said, "The battle ground for terrorism is not in a set country. It is global."

Gee, that's EXACTLY what President Bush and I have been saying, something John Kerry and you have challenged. So you FINALLY agree that the war in Iraq is indeed part of the war on terrorism. It's about time you finally concede that point.

2. You said, "We must look for ways to reduce our dependency on oil from the Middle East."

Again - you FINALLY agree that we need to open up drilling in Alaska and off-shore. Too bad John Kerry has always been against such things.

3. You said, "Kerry wants to cut taxes on business that create jobs inside the US."

WAIT A MINUTE. How many times has President Bush been criticized for doing that very thing? How many times have John Kerry, the Democrats, and you criticized this administration for giving tax breaks to big business? Cutting taxes on business IS EXACTLY what President Bush has been doing - and Kerry wants to REPEAL THEM!

4. You said........oh, nevermind.

You guys are a real piece of work.

by aldanatech

According to Bush's presidential record, here are his top 10 Flip Flops:

10. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON STEEL TARIFFS

Bush Flip: Bush Imposes Steel Tariffs
"President Bush on [March 5, 2002] slapped punishing tariffs of 8% to 30% on several types of imported steel in an effort to help the ailing U.S. industry, drawing criticism from American allies and mixed reviews at home. 'An integral part of our commitment to free trade is our commitment to enforcing trade laws to make sure that America's industries and workers compete on a level playing field,' Bush said in a statement issued by the White House." [USA Today, 3/5/02]

Bush Flop: Bush Rescinds Steel Tariffs
"Facing a potential global trade war, President Bush on [December 4, 2003] lifted tariffs he imposed on foreign steel 21 months ago, declaring the U.S. steel industry healthy and ready to compete despite the industry's claim that it needs more time to recover." [Chicago Tribune, 12/5/03]

9. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON ASSAULT WEAPONS BAN

Bush Flip: Bush Supports Extending Assault Weapons Ban
Ashcroft: "It is my understanding that the president-elect of the United States has indicated his clear support for extending the assault weapons ban, and I will be pleased to move forward with that position." [Confirmation Hearing, Senate Judiciary Committee, 1/17/01]

Bush Flop: Bush Opposes Extension of Assault Weapons Ban
"The White House is opposing addition of gun show and assault weapons restrictions to a bill shielding firearms makers and dealers from lawsuits, prompting angry complaints from Democrats that President Bush is reneging on earlier support for the two proposals...In a statement [on February 24, 2004], the White House urged passage of the lawsuits measure without amendments that might delay its enactment. 'Any amendment that would delay enactment of the bill beyond this year is unacceptable,' the statement said. Democrats interpreted this as an effort to undermine support for the gun-control measures. 'For the president to say he is for the assault weapons ban but then act against it is a flip-flop if there ever was one,' said Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.), one of several sponsors of the assault weapons proposal in the Senate." [Washington Post, 2/26/04]

8. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON HYBRID AUTOMOBILES

Bush Flip: Bush Mocked Gore's Tax Credit for Hybrid Cars
"'How many of you own hybrid electric gasoline engine vehicles? If you look under there, you'll see that's one of the criteria necessary to receive tax relief. So when he talks about targeted tax relief that's pretty darn targeted,' Bush told the Arlington Heights rally, drawing laughs." [Chicago Sun-Times, 10/29/00]

Bush Flop: Bush Supported Investing in Hybrid Cars
In his State of the Union speech, Bush said, "Tonight I am proposing $1.2 billion in research funding so that America can lead the world in developing clean, hydrogen-powered automobiles. ... Join me in this important innovation, to make our air significantly cleaner, and our country much less dependent on foreign sources of energy." [White House, "President Delivers 'State of the Union,'" 1/28/03]

7. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON USING MILITARY FOR NATION BUILDING

Bush Flip: Bush Promised Not to Use Military for Nation Building
In a campaign rally in Tennessee, then-Presidential candidate Bush criticized the Clinton administration for using the military in nation-building missions. Bush said, "I'm worried about an opponent who uses nation-building and the military in the same sentence. See, our view of the military is for our military to be properly prepared to fight and win war and, therefore, prevent war from happening in the first place." [Governor George W. Bush, 11/6/00]

Bush Flop: President Used Military for Nation Building in Afghanistan and Iraq
After the removal of the Taliban in Afghanistan, Bush met with soldiers stationed in Afghanistan at the White House and thanked them for their nation building efforts. A senior administration official said, "The administration, with its international partners, is doing something akin to nation-building." The plans for a post war Iraq also included nation building measures and, according to the Baltimore Sun, "Secretary of State Colin L. Powell confirmed...that Bush was considering, among other options, installing a U.S.-led occupation government if Hussein's regime is removed." [Baltimore Sun, 10/19/02]

6. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON GAY MARRIAGE

Bush Flip: It's Up to the States to Decide
In a 2000 presidential primary debate, candidate George W. Bush said gay marriage was a state's issue, saying, "The state can do what they want to do. Don't try to trap me in this state's issue like you're trying to get me into." [Presidential Primary Debate, 2/15/00]

Bush Flop: Bush Supports Constitutional Amendment That Restricts States' Rights
Bush: "If we are to prevent the meaning of marriage from being changed forever, our nation must enact a constitutional amendment to protect marriage in America. Decisive and democratic action is needed, because attempts to redefine marriage in a single state or city could have serious consequences throughout the country." [Bush, 2/24/04]

5. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY

Bush Flip: Bush Thought Homeland Security Cabinet Position Was "Just Not Necessary"
In October 2001, White House Press Secretary Ari Fleischer said Bush opposed creating Office of Homeland Security position for Ridge. "[T]he president has suggested to members of Congress that they do not need to make this a statutory post, that he [Ridge] does not need Cabinet rank, for example, there does not need to be a Cabinet-level Office of Homeland Security is because there is such overlap among the various agencies, because every agency of the government has security concerns," Fleischer said. [White House Press Briefing, 10/24/01]

Bush Flop: Bush Decides to Support Homeland Security
The New York Times reported, "Bush initially resisted Democratic proposals for a Cabinet-level agency. But once he endorsed it, the president pushed Congress for fast action as it debated such issues as whistle-blower protections, concerns over civil liberties and collective bargaining for department employees."

In remarks to Homeland Security Department employees, Bush claimed credit for supporting the Department: "In just 12 months, under the leadership of your President...you faced the challenges standing up this new Department and you get a -- and a gold star for a job well done." [New York Times, 2/28/03; Bush Remarks at One-Year Anniversary of DHS, 3/2/04]

4. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON CALLING FOR A UNITED NATIONS VOTE ON IRAQ WAR

Bush Flip: U.S. Will Seek U.N. Vote For War With Iraq
Bush: ...yes, we'll call for a vote.
Question: No matter what?
Bush: No matter what the whip count is, we're calling for the vote. We want to see people stand up and say what their opinion is about Saddam Hussein and the utility of the United Nations Security Council. And so, you bet. It's time for people to show their cards, let the world know where they stand when it comes to Saddam. [Bush News Conference, 3/6/03, emphasis added]

Bush Flop: Bush Attacked Iraq Without U.N. Vote
Bush "failed to win explicit [security] council approval for the use of force" in Iraq. Two days before bombs began to fall in Iraq, the Bush administration withdrew its resolution from the UN Security Council that would have authorized military force. Bush abandoned his call for a vote after it became clear that the US could muster only four votes in support of force. [Washington Post, 3/21/03; Los Angeles Times, 3/18/03]

3. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON TIME HE'LL SPEND WITH 9/11 COMMISSION

Bush Flip: Would Meet For Only One Hour With 9/11 Commission
McClellan: Obviously, as part of this, the President will be meeting with the chairman and vice chairman at some point in the near future. We are still working on the exact time of that meeting. We have discussed with the commission what we believe is a reasonable period of time to provide the chairman and vice chairman with answers to all of their questions.
Q: Is that the one-hour time frame?
McClellan: That's what I'm referring to. [WH Press Briefing, 3/9/04]

Bush Flop: White House Says No Time Limit on President's Testimony
"President George W. Bush will privately answer all questions raised by the federal commission investigating the September 11 attacks, the White House said, suggesting that Bush might allow the interview to extend beyond the one-hour limit originally offered to the panel by the White House. 'He's going to answer all the questions they want to raise,' said the White House spokesman, Scott McClellan, whose remarks suggested that the White House was softening its negotiating stance toward the bipartisan commission. 'Nobody's watching the clock.'" [WH Press Briefing, 3/9/04; International Herald Tribune, 3/11/04]

2. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON INDEPENDENT WMD COMMISSION

Bush Flip: Refuses to Call for Independent Bipartisan Commission on Weapons of Mass Destruction
"President Bush said on January 30, 2004, 'I want to know the facts' about any intelligence failures concerning Saddam Hussein's alleged cache of forbidden weapons but he declined to endorse calls for an independent investigation." [AP, 1/30/04]

Bush Flop: Bush Appoints WMD Investigation Commission
President Bush named a nine-member bipartisan commission to investigate U.S. intelligence-gathering capabilities in February 2004. The AP noted, "Bush had initially opposed a commission, but agreed to do so as calls grew from Republican lawmakers as well as Democrats." The Los Angeles Times reported, "The White House opposed that panel initially, then backed down under pressure, and some say administration officials now regret doing so because the administration has become locked in a series of embarrassing battles with the Sept. 11 commission." The New York Times noted Bush "gave the panel until March 2005, well after the November elections, to submit its conclusions." [NY Times, 2/7/04; LA Times, 2/1/04; AP, 2/6/04]

1. BUSH FLIP-FLOPS ON INDEPENDENT 9/11 COMMISSION

Bush opposed an independent inquiry into 9/11, arguing it would duplicate a probe conducted by Congress. In July 2002, his administration issued a "statement of policy" that read "...the Administration would oppose an amendment that would create a new commission to conduct a similar review [to Congress's investigation]." [Statement of Administration Policy, Executive Office of the President, 7/24/02; LA Times, 11/28/02]

Bush Flop: Bush Relented and Appointed Independent Commission
President Bush finally agreed to support an independent investigation into the 9/11 attacks after "the congressional committees unearthed more and more examples of intelligence lapses, the administration reversed its stance." [Los Angeles Times, 11/28/02]

by aldanatech

1. You said, "The battle ground for terrorism is not in a set country. It is global."

Gee, that's EXACTLY what President Bush and I have been saying, something John Kerry and you have challenged. So you FINALLY agree that the war in Iraq is indeed part of the war on terrorism. It's about time you finally concede that point.

Answer: No. The war in Iraq is not part of the war on terrorism. In fact, it hardly has anything to do with it. A global war against terrorism is getting with our allies and ever other possible country in the world to fight terrorism. No alienate them.

2. You said, "We must look for ways to reduce our dependency on oil from the Middle East."

Again - you FINALLY agree that we need to open up drilling in Alaska and off-shore. Too bad John Kerry has always been against such things.

Answer: No. Forget about Alaska and off-shore drilling. I mean more energy conservation.

3. You said, "Kerry wants to cut taxes on business that create jobs inside the US."

WAIT A MINUTE. How many times has President Bush been criticized for doing that very thing? How many times have John Kerry, the Democrats, and you criticized this administration for giving tax breaks to big business? Cutting taxes on business IS EXACTLY what President Bush has been doing - and Kerry wants to REPEAL THEM!

Answer: Bush's tax cuts are for big money making companies and corporation that often outsource jobs. Instead, Kerry wants to change those tax cuts for companies that DO keep jobs in America as an incentive for their patriotism.

4. You said........oh, nevermind.

Answer: Oh C'mon, don't give up now! I'm barely starting to warm up here.

by tbragsda

As much as I have tried to stay away from attacks, Maxwell?s post is what all should regard as ?spin?. He knew what you were saying, knew where democrats stand on these issues, and simply turned the top.

I?m really not into this form, or any form, of gotcha debate. It?s low, and contributes nothing to anyone?s understanding. Ignore him, engage him, just know that it will never go anywhere.

by 87878

Superscript was not an option on any typewriter; that simple truth nails the letter as a fraud....

Lets not get all freedom of speech on this. Freedom to speak is not freedom to change reality and malign.

by 87878

and all the experts I heard over since this story broke agree there was no typewriter that handled it.

Happy to admit the possibility if a type writer was shown to be able to do it.

Also, it seems the line spacing and formatting are in line with the MS word styling too.

by 87878

I am curious... I saw many a selectric in my day and to do a superscript in the way it was done on the memo would have taken some finessing. Not sure why anyone would; most would have just typed it as 110th (normal font).

And then, if you rolled up the roller so that you could actually arrive at the place you'd position the smaller font superscript, getting the bar back down to where original line was never a perfect science. It was never perfect, which is why people didn't bother.

The formatting on that letter was perfect, very MS Word as they explained it... but who knows?
will wait on Dan's explanation.

by tbragsda

http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=109&S...

NEW YORK, Sept. 10 /PRNewswire/ -- Later today, CBS News will address on the air and in detail the issues surrounding the documents broadcast in the 60 MINUTES report on President Bush's service in the Texas Air National Guard. At this time, however, CBS News states with absolute certainty that the ability to produce the "th" superscript mentioned in reports about the documents did exist on typewriters as early as 1968, and in fact is in President Bush's official military records released by the White House. This and other issues surrounding the authenticity of the documents and more on this developing story will be reported on tonight on THE CBS EVENING NEWS WITH DAN RATHER.

by tbragsda

We can address tomorrow.

I have seen lot of typesetting devices, lots of typewriter etc., and special symbols are just not new.

I will admit my ignorance of the devices of this time, and simple wait for the evidence (good or bad).

If its forged, whats your bet? Word, or Staroffice?

by tbragsda

I see about a dozen environmental articles listed in the original post. Anyone interested in the administrations policies regarding this?

It seems we have bigger fish to fry this election, but the predictions of ?green hostile? Bush administration was right on.

I have a hard time believing anyone likes this side of the administration.

by aldanatech

The Bush administration couldn't care less about the environment. In fact, you will notice that the Bush administration actually rolled back some of the hard-won environmental gains to help certain big companies and corporations either make or save money at the expense of our environment. This jeopardizes our right to breathe unpolluted air, drink safe water, eat uncontaminated food, live in clean communities and enjoy our natural treasures; not only for us but for generations to come as well. Kerry is well aware of this and he definitely wants to do something about it.

by aldanatech

Here are some of the questions that the Family Steering Committee submitted to the 9/11 commission:

For President George W. Bush

As Commander-in-Chief on the morning of 9/11, why didn?t you return immediately to Washington, D.C. or the National Military Command Center once you became aware that America was under attack? At specifically what time did you become aware that America was under attack? Who informed you of this fact? (http://www.911independentcommission.org/bush2162004.html)

For Vice President Richard Cheney

Please discuss the advice and plans of the Energy Advisory Council specifically as they relate to pipeline development and gas/oil exploration in Afghanistan, Iraq and other Middle Eastern countries, and the feasibility of such development or exploration specifically in those two countries in 2001.
http://www.dcd.uscourts.gov/Opinions/2002/Bates/02-340.pdf (http://www.911independentcommission.org/cheney3182004.html)

For Condoleezza Rice

Regarding the meeting of Abdullah Abdullah (close aide to Massoud and now the Afghan Foreign Minister) in July , 2001, with ?some top National Security Council (NSC) and State Department officials,? what information about al Qaeda did he convey? (http://www.911independentcommission.org/rice3182004.html)

For George Tenet, Director of the CIA

Why didn't the CIA share vital information about the terrorists with the FBI?
(http://www.911independentcommission.org/cia3182004.html)

For Robert Mueller, FBI Director, 2001-present

Which hijackers have been positively identified by DNA? Is the FBI in possession of DNA samples for all of the hijackers?
(http://www.911independentcommission.org/fbi3182004.html)

Source:
http://www.911independentcommission.org/questions.html

by aldanatech

Let's do a comparison between what Bush's record in job creation reflects and what Kerry plans to do as president.

BUSH'S RECORD:

1. Bush has been a disaster for jobs -- despite having his entire economic plan passed in the last three years. On Bush's watch America has lost 1.6 million private-sector jobs, making him the president to lose jobs since Herbert Hoover.

2. We are now 7 million jobs short of the prediction made by the Bush administration in February 2002 -- after 9/11, the tech bubble, and the recession.

3. Jobs in industries where there are new jobs pay nearly $9,000 less than jobs in industries that are losing jobs.

4. The typical family has seen its income go down more than $1,500 under President Bush.

5. For Bush, making businesses more competitive means more outsourcing. Bush's own Council of Economic Advisors said that "when a good or service is produced more cheaply abroad, it makes more sense to import it than make or provide it domestically."

KERRY'S PLAN:

1. Kerry and Edwards have a plan to help create millions of high-paying jobs. America's dynamic entrepreneurs and talented workers are capable of creating millions of jobs each year. It happened before: in Clinton's first term the economy created more than 11 million new jobs. And with the Kerry-Edwards plan to put the right policies in place we can do it again.

2. For Kerry and Edwards, making America more competitive means investing in more jobs at higher wages.

3. Kerry has a plan to jumpstart job growth right now. This includes a New Jobs Tax Credit, which would provide a payroll tax holiday for new hires in manufacturing, other businesses affected by outsourcing, and small businesses.

4. His plan would end tax breaks for companies that move jobs overseas and use the savings to cut the corporate rate by 5 percent, providing a tax cut for 99 percent of taxpaying corporations.

5. Kerry would make America more competitive by reducing the burden on the middle class. He would cut the deficit in half in the first Kerry term as president, cut health care premiums by up to $1,000 a year, and move America towards energy independence to bring down energy costs.

by oz_media

Was that an actual quote?
An economic advisor to the nations government used the term "more cheaply"? lol. Gotta love it.
:D

by tbragsda

Well.. if not, it seems that the flood gate are open, and US News(hardley "leftie") has more to say.

http://www.usnews.com/usnews/issue/040920/usnews/20guard.htm

----
Some experts say they remain mystified as to how Bush obtained an honorable discharge. Lawrence Korb, a former top Defense Department official in the Reagan administration, says the military records clearly show that Bush "had not fulfilled his obligation" and "should have been called to active duty."
----

Now, move on. I would rather talk about anything else, but this is what we get reduced to.

Lets just leave it, like I said. Bush got a good deal. Its not supprising, lets move on to what he did in the last three years!

by aldanatech

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics and other sources, this is what Bush's record reflect as for the handle of the economy:

JOBS

2,931,000: Number of jobs lost in the private sector since Bush took office.1

135,000: Average number of jobs created monthly under every President since Truman.2

-79,189: Average number of jobs created monthly under Bush.1

2,447,000: Number of people who have become unemployed since Bush took office.1

37%: Increase in the unemployment rate since Bush took office.1

4.1%: Unemployment rate when Bush took office in January 2001.1

5.6%: Unemployment rate in March 2004.1

8,170,000: Total number of unemployed Americans.1

675,000: Number of Americans experiencing long-term unemployment (27 weeks or more) when Bush took office in January 2001.1

1,871,000: Number of Americans suffering long-term unemployment in March 2004.1

177%: Increase in long-term unemployment under Bush.1

11.8%: Percentage of consumers who believe jobs are plentiful.3

760,000: Number of workers who have lost their unemployment insurance since December 2002.4

BALLOONING DEFICTS

$5.6 Trillion: Baseline surplus for the 10-year period for FY 2002-2011, as projected by the Congressional Budget Office when Bush took office in January 2001.5

$5.2 Trillion: Budget deficit over next 10 years if Bush's 2005 budget proposal is enacted.6

$2.4 Trillion: Amount Bush's budget will raid from the Social Security and Medicare trust funds over the next 10 years.6

$478 Billion: Budget deficit for 2004 as predicted by CBO, if Bush' s proposals are enacted.6

$188 Billion: Amount Bush's budget deficit for 2004 exceeds the highest budget deficit in history, which was posted in 1992 by Bush's father.6

BUSH'S 2003 "JOBS AND GROWTH" PLAN

$2.2 Trillion: Ten-year cost of Bush's proposed tax cuts including additional costs for interest on the national debt.7

32.4%: Percent of tax cut for the top 1 percent of wage earners under the Bush "growth" plan.8

8.5%: Percent of tax cuts for the bottom 60 percent of wage earners under the Bush "growth" plan.8

64 Million: Number of taxpayers (48 percent) who receive $100 or less under the Bush "growth" plan.9

$30,127: Average tax cut for the top 1 percent of taxpayers under the Bush "growth" plan.9

$289: Average tax cut for the middle 20 percent of taxpayers under the Bush "growth" plan.9

$4-5 Billion: Amount Bush tax proposal would cost states.10

1 Million: Number of taxpayers the Alternative Minimum Tax affected in 1999.11

36 Million: Number of taxpayers the Alternative Minimum Tax will affect in 2010 because of Bush's tax cuts and his failure to address the AMT.11

LOWER INCOME, RISING COSTS

1.1%: Decrease in real median household income in 2002.12

10%: Increase in bankruptcies since Bush took office.13

1,625,213: Number of consumers who filed for bankruptcy in 2003.13

24%: Drop in consumer confidence since Bush took office.14

50%: Increase in out-of-pocket health care costs for workers since Bush took office.15

14%: Increase in the cost of job-based health insurance in 2003; highest rate in 13 years.15

8.7%: Increase in the cost of the 10 most-used prescription drugs in 2003.16

61%: Percent of employers who cited rising drug costs as a major cause of premium increases in 2003.15

11.5%: Increase in gas prices since 2000.17

49: Number of states that increased tuition at their public colleges and universities in 2003. State budget cuts fueled by the Bush recession have forced colleges to hike tuitions and fees-threatening access to higher education for low-income students.18

35%: Increase in tuition and fees at four-year public institutions since Bush took office, adjusted for inflation.19

Sources: 1 Bureau of Labor Statistics, 3/04; 2 House Appropriations Committee Minority Staff, 3/04; 3 Conference Board, 3/04; 4 Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, 2/25/04; 5 Congressional Budget Office, Budget and Economic Outlook: Fiscal Years 2002-2011, 1/01; 6 Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 2/1/04; CBO, An Analysis of Bush's Budgetary Proposals for Fiscal Year 2005, 3/04; 7 Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 1/30/04, 1/21/04; 8 CTJ Fact Sheet, 1/8/03; 9 CTJ Fact Sheet, 2/3/03; 10 CBPP Fact Sheet, 1/10/03; 11 Brookings Institute, Tax Policy Center, The AMT: Out of Control, 9/18/02; New York Times, 1/10/03; 12 U.S. Census Bureau, "Money Income in the United States: 2002"; 13 American Bankruptcy Institute, 3/04; 14 Conference Board, 3/04; 15 Kaiser Family Foundation, Employer Health Benefits Survey 2000 and 2003; 16 AdvancePCS, 8/25/03; 17 CNN.com, 2/23/04; 18 Associated Press, 8/25/03; 19 College Board, College Costs 2003

by short fuse

It is interesting that despite the overwhelming 'evidence' you present, half or greater of voters (translate that as people who keep tabs on what's going on) still favor Bush. You leftist are so easily swayed by detailed persuave arguments that are the craft of journalists. You have no core. No grasp of reality. Which ever way the media wants to blow its hot air. Many people have learned not to listen to liars no matter how convincing the argument. The liberal media has lost credibility. Yea, you can understand getting angry at being lied to.

by aldanatech

What's wrong is that they readily admit to outsource more jobs from other countries. They don?t care about the massive loss of jobs for Americans in the U.S. and the of kind impact this brings to the economy in general.

by maxwell edison

.
Geesh, aldanatech, didn't you understand his question? He was wondering about the grammatical correctness of "more cheaply". Are you so wrapped up in spewing your partisan rhetoric that you can't even see that? Get a life, man.

And by the way, one can't outsource from something, as said in your context, only to something.

And you're wrong about outsourcing. Here's my proof, where's yours?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=9&threadID=159164&start=0

And you're also wrong in a different message when you suggested that Iraq has nothing to do with defeating world-wide terrorism.

by aldanatech

I didn't point out the grammar because I know that the use of "more cheaply" is common in the US. And I know I am full 100% correct that the war in Iraq doesn't help us in the war on terrorism. That was an early obsession and Bush quickly did whatever it would take to link it to 9/11 when they estimated there was a 10 to 50 percent chance Saddam was involved in the 9/11 attacks, which was an odd conclusion that reflected deep uspicion but no real evidence.

by oz_media

Just like there's nothing wrong with DIVEDED or BETTERER, in the American dialect anyway I suppose. The American dictionary actually has CHEAPLY listed as a word, however the examples of it's use are hilarious. I decided to see if anyone else thought 'cheaply' was a word, one person laughed and said "sure, it's betterer than less costly!"

If I had used the term 'more cheaply' in school (especially in England) I would have be beaten to death. The two words just don't fit nor compliment each other.

Less expensively, at a lower cost, cheaper, more cost efectively, anything but a piss poor borderline slang (adverb, adjective combo)that implies uneducated North Amercian or simply DUH.

I can see it being used on he steet, in a bar, but from the Nations Economic advisor?

No wonder y'all diveded on the Republican campaign.

by maxwell edison

.
And the two words do indeed fit and complment each other.

cheaply (adv.)

more cheaply

most cheaply

More cheaper would not be correct, but more cheaply is. (But cheaper would equal more cheaply, I suppose, in meaning.)

Take a lesson:

http://www.bartleby.com/68/25/1225.html

(Hey, don't feel bad, Oz. We all err once in a while.)

by oz_media

The word cheaply is not a common word, OUTSIDE of America. This is US dialect that actually gets used so often that it has made US dictionaries.

Then again, most people ouside North America don't understand Canadian OR US English.

I just floored me that someone in a position as a national advisor would use a North American term and not a more gobally accepted form of English.

Like I said, if I had used the term 'more cheaply' instead of less expensive, less costly etc., when growing up, I would have been strapped at least. I would have definitely failed English.

by oz_media

And I concur wholly, if you could actually explain your point ad prove that right wig media is correct and left is wrong, which is impossible or it would have been done already. Instantly discountig the left wing as being incorrect is just as ignorant as them saying the right is wrong.

You made assertions that lefties are this and lefty media is that but hae not recognized that righties ae the EXACT same way in regards to what THEY feel are accurate reports.

As someone who see's YOUR news (left AND right) compared to what the rest of the world is reporting (very consistently with each other as well)I can tell you, you are seeing two sides to a story and BOTH are so colored it isn't funny.

Half the news about Iraq is not even making the US news, reports etc. Reportes are standing up around the world and complaining that newws is restricted in the USA and they can't get a story aired unless it paints a positive picturue, either left or right. Thee IS no middle ground.

by tbragsda

Is the media left? I really don't think so.

"half or greater of voters (translate that as people who keep tabs on what's going on) still favor Bush"

Voters really know what's going on? We have people still thinking that Iraq was directly involved in sept 11.

As for 1/2 support Bush...
Gore=50,996,039
Bush=50,456,141

"You have no core"

Beliefs? Way down deep in side, I know killing innocent people, stacking the economic system to favor the rich, raping the environment and detaining people with out trial are all "wrong"

by maxwell edison

.
You never admit you're wrong, and you always insist you're right - and you think you know every F^%$#^& thing there is to know. What a pompous and arrogant ass you are.

But you're wrong. You're wrong with "American English". You're wrong with "Canadian English". You're wrong with "British English".

Moreover, even if it was only proper in "American English", as you suggested, the guy was addressing Americans, you idiot, and it's in extremely poor taste to criticize people for such things.

By the way, Oz, YOU'RE WRONG!

Not only that, but you're a smart-ass little punk who's WRONG!

By the way, where did you get your college degree?

(I didn't think so.)

--------------------

Cambridge International Dictionary of English:

cheaply: (adverb) for a low price:

The shop round the corner does shoe repairs very cheaply.

http://dictionary.cambridge.org/define.asp?key=12760&dict=CALD

by stormyfyre

Whe cant people see just how bad this President has been for this Country. He promised he was a uniter not a divider, 3 years later we are still divided. If you have ever been on the bad side of things, I challange you to see what Bush has done for you. Sure he is great for starting wars and making us feel safe from WMD even if they never show up. Lets face we are going to have to pay taxes no matter what. If we dont take care of the folks who are down on their luck (this includes welfare, social services, elderly, sick and just plain deadbeats ) or society will fail. We will pay one way or another, maybe in crime disease, or hatred for the US. This President has insulted just about every Leader of the Free world, we have lost many allies because of this. We launched a pre-empted strike on another nathion with poor intelligenge to back it up. Now we are finding that this is all untrue. There have been less reasons to Impeach a President, such as his sex habits. We can fight all we want, but in just a few short years history will tell the real truth and we will really know what kind of President George W. Bush really was. There was a time in 1861 when a newly elected President decided to ingnore half a country, this resulted in over 600,000 dead Americans. Hopefully we now have a political system that prevents this. This year when you go to vote, educate yourselves. Dot believe just what you see on television or read in the magazines in the grocery store. Go to the National Archives, the FBI website (Freedom of information act)Read from legimate news sources like the Washington Post, CNN, MSNBC, BBC, and try other sources outside of this country, they tend not to pad the truth. Look to your heart when you go to vote. Are really any better now? Could everthing said about Bush be a lie? Not likely. And for those who complain about the elections and the President that was elected, AND DIDNT VOTE! Get of your BUTTS this time and make a difference, you really can. The last thing to remember is to keep an open mind and look to the past, it has all the answers.

by stormyfyre

You should be scared, its happening already. Check DARPA website sometime and see what their new projects are.

by maxwell edison

.
Your one source said:

http://www.cfr.org/background/trade_jobs.php

?There?s no evidence that outsourcing caused the recession, and there?s no evidence that it?s making it worse,? says Erica L. Groshen, an assistant vice president at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Not all analysts agree with this assessment. Thea Lee, assistant director of public policy at the AFL-CIO, says outsourcing is a major cause of job loss since 2000. And, she says, ?outsourcing is one of the causes for the truly dismal job performance since the recession has ended.?

Why do you believe only the one, and not the other? (Of course, you can't "believe" both.)

That came from YOUR source.

What else came from YOUR source?

What steps are politicians attempting to reverse outsourcing?

There have been a variety of responses. Kerry is sponsoring legislation that would require operators answering help-desk calls for U.S. consumers in other countries to identify their location. He also wants to give tax incentives to American companies to keep jobs in the United States, close tax loopholes that he says encourage U.S. employers to move jobs overseas, and require other countries to meet more stringent environmental and labor standards so that employing people in those countries will cost more. Some states have proposed bills barring the export of some kinds of taxpayer-funded work, such as the processing of welfare checks. In addition, a Senate bill sponsored by George V. Voinovich (R-Ohio) and Craig Thomas (R-Wyoming) would limit the outsourcing of some work done for the federal government.

What is the reaction of economists to these ideas?

Many economists say that these steps are a form of economic protectionism that will only further slow the U.S. economic recovery. As an example, Benn Steil, the acting director of the Maurice R. Greenberg Center for Geoeconomic Studies at the Council on Foreign Relations, points to the overall negative economic effect that subsidies for the struggling U.S. steel industry had on the economy. Protecting the industry from lower-cost imported steel hurt U.S. carmakers and other domestic industries that use steel. ?It?s very clear that the price we paid as an economy per steel worker job was hundreds of thousands of dollars,? he says. On January 26, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan cautioned lawmakers not to increase trade barriers to keep jobs in the United States. While some workers will lose jobs because of outsourcing and other forms of foreign competition, he said the U.S. economy is resilient enough to generate new jobs to compensate. ?We can thus be confident that new jobs will replace old ones as they always have, but not without a high degree of pain for those caught in the job-losing segment of America?s massive job-turnover process,? Greenspan said.

Why do economists say outsourcing is good for the economy?

Many economists argue that outsourcing is just another form of free trade, which increases wealth in the economy. They say that employing workers at lower cost allows U.S. companies to be more efficient and productive, permitting them to create the same amount of goods with fewer resources. In turn, this lowers the price of the goods in the United States, strengthening U.S. companies and freeing workers for other tasks. The savings allows U.S. companies to stay afloat and expand in a highly competitive global market, says Jagdish N. Bhagwati, the Andr? Meyer senior fellow in international economics at the Council on Foreign Relations and the author of the recently published ?In Defense of Globalization.? ?Outsourcing is not destroying American jobs. These jobs are going anyway, because otherwise the goods would be too expensive to produce? and the companies that make them would no longer be competitive, he says.

---------- Conclusion ----------

?Outsourcing is not destroying American jobs. These jobs are going anyway, because otherwise the goods would be too expensive to produce, and the companies that make them would no longer be competitive."

- Jagdish N. Bhagwati, the Andr? Meyer senior fellow in international economics at the Council on Foreign Relations

On January 26, Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan cautioned lawmakers not to increase trade barriers to keep jobs in the United States. While some workers will lose jobs because of outsourcing and other forms of foreign competition, he said the U.S. economy is resilient enough to generate new jobs to compensate. ?We can thus be confident that new jobs will replace old ones as they always have, but not without a high degree of pain for those caught in the job-losing segment of America?s massive job-turnover process,? Greenspan said

-----------------------

Hey, it's YOUR source that concludes that. So will you NOW believe it?

And your other source, the "KirkReport". Who's that guy, Kirk? Just some individual who has a Web site.

Okay, you believe Captain Kirk, I'll believe Allan Greenspan.

Geesh, is that as good as you can do?

And there's no way you formed your opinion from those sites. You got your opinion from John Kerry rhetoric, and when I asked you for your source of information, you searched and listed these.

Sorry, that dog won't hunt.