Individual Sovereignty ? I am an American
I have tried very hard to understand the perspectives of those of you who are not Americans. What is it that at times puts us at such odds, even when we agree on basic precepts? Thanks to the often frustrating, occasionally angering, and always interesting comments here at TechRepublic and with those I directly communicate with, I have at least come to understand those differences in my mind.
What non-Americans seem to miss is this most American principal that each individual is sovereign onto himself. Government in America, at any level, has no authority except for that granted to it by each of us. I believe that by upbringing or by choice, consciously or unconsciously, this is a value most Americans embrace. I believe this is such a core value that we rarely consider it, but it uniquely impacts how we view the world around us.
This has significant impact on our perceptions. For example, the right to bear arms (individuals have rights, government has powers). May I never need this right, but it is one of the fundamentals of sovereignty. Is this worth the added risk from other sovereign individuals who may choose to abuse their power? For me, yes. I can no more envision surrendering my personal sovereignty than others can envision their country turning all military power over to a higher authority. Perhaps doing so as an American would make me safer, and perhaps nations doing so would make the world safer, but the risk is too high.
This issue of sovereignty applies to our reaction to our government. Every 4 years, we have an opportunity and an obligation to provide power to some group of national leadership. That so many choose to default on their obligation does not change this. As part of this social pact, we support the majority leader and position, knowing that every even year and every four years we can again attempt to sway others to our position and that if successful our personal favorites will enjoy the support of all of us for their terms. So Bush has no power except the power we have granted him, subject to our approval in 2004 to continue or be replaced. An attack on our chosen leader, no matter how slim his mandate, is felt on a personal level because of this.
With this comes responsibility, and every time my country acts in a fashion I feel is counter to my beliefs, my values, I feel deeply and directly the shame of those actions. I personally bear responsibility for every mistake made by any and every elected leader I have helped place in power by my action or inaction. If there is a judgment day I am sure I will be held accountable for my government?s actions. The inverse is the pride I feel for all the good things about my country, because there is no America except for the people and the power we give to our leaders.
This does not correlate to blind following as some believe. Rarely does any US leader have even a simple majority of full supporters. What he has is a majority of those who acknowledge we as individuals have given him 4 years to accomplish objectives and impress us enough for a second 4 years. As an individual I may agree with none, a few, most, or rarely all of his positions. Regardless, his power comes from me and my fellow citizens. To the degree that I can, I support him, knowing that if my preferred representative wins election he will have similar support.
My military oath reflected this each time I took it. I swore to uphold and protect the Constitution of the United States, not some leader. I swore to obey the lawful orders of my superiors, not to blindly follow whatever order was given. I retained my responsibility for my actions. Individual sovereignty, limited by my choice for a set period of time.
I don?t know that anyone who has not had such a perspective can ever fully appreciate or understand the American perception. How can you understand the depth of meaning behind the words ?We the People of the United States? if you can separate yourself from personal responsibility for the actions of your nation? Who is responsible for the US being in Iraq? I am. Me personally. It is my responsibility because of how I voted or didn?t vote in the 2000 election, because of the effort I made or didn?t make to get the current leadership elected. I am an American, I am the source of any power my government has, and I must bear responsibility for US actions.
I hope this helps to enlighten at least a few of you as to why some of us have such a strong sense of patriotism. That we Americans are responsible for whatever good or whatever bad you may feel towards the United States. To understand that we Americans are our country, not simply subjects of some government. When you talk to us, you really are talking to the true power of America, its individual and sovereign citizens.