Discussion Locked

Individual Sovereignty ? I am an American

0 helpful
119 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

119 replies

by john_wills

was that two intelligent people can admire the supposed roots of the U.S. for entirely different and even contradictory reasons. We all have a tendency to see in things what we would like to see, whether to admire or to bewail it; in the case of the U.S., both Ayn Rand and Mr Miami find something to admire, but surely they cannot both have found something really there?

by john_wills

that Mr Miami and Ayn Rand may both have believed something and then "found" it in the origins of the U.S. There is a truth about the origin of the U.S., but Mr Miami and Ayn Rand are unlikely to find it because they think they already know it.

by hal 9000

The troops always should get the support from us the civilians that they desirve.

I'm old enough to remember what happened to the guys when they got back from Nam, and thought that it was terrible as they where made the scape goats for the Governments decissions.

But I guess that it is easier to blame a bunch of troops who where only doing as ordered rather than accept that you carry some of the blame by allowing the Government that is/was in power to have got away with their actions for so long.

Anyway Cheers for now

Colin

by john_wills

Here is a problem I sometimes put to U.S. high-schoolers, especially if they're discussing history on the bus. In 1776 Great Britain had 27 American colonies; of those, 13 seceded and formed the U.S.; why those 13? Here is a question definitive of the republic, yet no-one seems to know the answer. Just what do Massachussetts and Georgia have in common that they do not have in common with Nova Scotia or Bahama? Bermuda and Nova Scotia did send delegates to the Continental Congress, but why didn't Jamaica? And why did those two not continue with the secession?

by deadly ernest

Now this is my personal opinion base don what I have read about the times, I have yet to see a professional historian try to fully analyse this particular question, most do even see this question at all.

You have to remember that there were major differences in the way some of the colonies operated and how people lived their. Also the British governement treated some colonies different to others. The main point of commonality was the grievances that they had.

The Continental American Colonies (CAC) were fairly well developed (for their day) by free citizens and virtually no local nobility above the slave holders worth talking about. Most owned their land and had a living standard much higher than the average citizen in England. The CAC citizens were basically self dependent as far as essentials were concerned, but they were importing a great deal of luxuries. Not many people would see tea as a luxury but the average free citizen in England made their own tea from inferior local plants. The imported Indian tea was a luxury good for the aristocracy and rich traders; yet in CAC the average citizen was buying and drinking the imported tea. This difference in affluence and attitudes between the colonial citizens is the core aspect that you seek.

When you examin the average lifestyle in Novia Scotia and Bermuda, etc at that time it was very different. In Bermuda and there abouts there was a larger level of British aristocrats on the ground and in control with the majority of locals NOT drinking imported tea. In Novia Scotia the majority of colonists were employees of the Hudson Bay Company and had enough trouble just staying alive in the harsher environment, again most used local plant variants for their tea.

Then you add in the fact that most of the CACs have some sort of representational legislator with some say in the local government, most of the other colonies did not have such a high level of local involvement in the government.

Add into this mix the fact that the majority of the taxes being levied at that time were to enable the British government to conduct war efforts elsewhere in the world in places that the CAC citizens were not interested in. They saw the money as being syphoned off for luxurious living in England by the King.

Thus you come down to a group of affluent independent thinking and acting yeomanry used to managing their own affairs getting upset with what they see as a basic staple being excessively taxed- have grievances against the British aristocracy who are levying the taxes on what they see as a luxury good. The yeomanry have always been the core of the British fighting forces. Whereas the other colonials were not affluent enough or free enough to have the same grievances or be so upset by them.

Personally I think the conflict between the CAC citizens and the British govt were inevitable deu to the differences in local social organisations. The 'What if questions' concern how the conflict would have been handled if it happened 10 years earlier or 10 years later. depending upon who was in charge of Parliament in England it could have been much blooier or no blood at all.

by john_wills

eebywater has done some thinking, and I suspect an investigation of tea imports in the 27 colonies would be of interest. However, a lot of NS people were yeoman farmers, and practically all the White folk in Canada (i.e. Quebec + Ontario) were. There was in Barbados a slave-owning aristocracy similar to that in SC, quite different from the yeomanry up north. So I don't think eebywater has found the commonality of the 13. An interesting point is that 2 colonies which did not join the revolt, Ohio and Florida, are now states of the Union. These were both being administered with the interests of the Indians in mind. During the revolutionary war Florida was lost to Spain (the U.S. got it later) and at the end of the war the U.S. got Ohio despite the wishes of the inhabitants, GB being too tired politically to resist. If we look at the detailed grievances in the Declaration of Independence we find a complaint about an arbitrary form of government in a neighboring province, which means that in Quebec Catholics were going to get the vote; this explains very neatly why Quebec did not join the revolt. But most of the grievances would apply as well outside the 13 as in them.

by oz_media

the Nazis were spread WAY too thin to launch a successful incasion of England.

I've seen a few what if's regarding Hitlers actions in WWII, they clearly documented how with his Nazi troops spread across Western Europe and then the French completely evacuating France his troops were needed against Hitlers will to occupy the country instead of simply governing the country.

The RAF was wiping out the luftwaffe very successfully, if he had been able to conquer the channel islands, IOWight, IOMan etc he MAY have been successful as he would have had a close range base. His three attempts to bomb the forces off of these islands were unsuccessful and he was at his wits end as to how to gain control of Southern England. During this yime, the US, British, Canadian and other Allied forces launched the full scale D-Day invasion, which would have been much more difficult without the efforts of Canadian troops who were the first to start clearing the surrounding areas as the Allies were due to arrive.

Hitler didn't take England, he was bombarded when the troops hit the beach and once again turned the tides of WWII. the sheer volume of fresh soldiers and experienced leaders was enough to take down the already tired and thinned Nazi troops who had been at war for nearly five continuous years already.

All of Europes western countries are very happy to have defeated Hitler, the USA, Canada, Britain, Australia and other aliied forces combined to an undefeatable force.

The USA didn't save Western Europe, England owes nothing to the USA for joining the force other than a thank you for your support as all other countries did too.

I haven't heard too many Australians claiming to have WON WWII and saved England, nor Canadians, and they were at war LONG before the US involvement. Thier assistance and support will never be forgotten but then again, we aren't going to bow to you for your help. You now what you did, you know where your pride stands and rightly so. Don't wear it on your sleeve and make us hate you too, is all I ask.

OM

by mrbill-

?Hitler didn't take England, he was bombarded when the troops hit the beach and once again turned the tides of WWII. the sheer volume of fresh soldiers and experienced leaders was enough to take down the already tired and thinned Nazi troops who had been at war for nearly five continuous years already.?

I have no idea of what you are talking. If Hitler had been inclined to invade England and ignore Russia he would have been able to take it. He would have had a very tough go of holding it without the widespread slaughter of Brits. His troops were not tired of ?nearly five continuous years? of war. They had been at it for less than one, all victoriously, they were more than a match for the beleaguered Brits. The Luftwaffe could have defeated the RAF if Goering had not kept switching targets. He was two days away from destroying the RAF, twice.

One troop of Canadians reached their objective on D-Day, no other Allied unit did. However the Brits and Canadians were unable to clear Caen on schedule, or anywhere near it. The great Monty could not solve that problem.

by oz_media

It's always nice to see the differences in how history is reported.
You have rewritten anything I've read but that's OK, I usually only dig up the old war stories and not the actual historical events as they are recorded.

DDay was in 1944, supposedly.
The war began in the late 1930's, again from what's reported. That would be approx. 1939 to 1944. You're right, it WAS only a year. The USA wasn't late to the draw and the two thwarted attempts you mention at taking the RAF must have been successful after all. From what I'd heard, damn British school propaganda, the RAF wasn't defeated by the Germans, now I know they were and thank you for sharing your wisdom.

by oz_media

The following is a section of The Complete Idiots Guide to WWII.

http://tinyurl.com/wjry

German Luftwaffe was being DEVASTATED by the RAF and ground forces.

German campaign was spread too thin.

Hitler could not logistically invade England.

If he were to succeed in his objectives, he would have a two sided war between Russia AND England (apparently the same mistake made in WWI).

You mat want to get a copy of this "War for Dummies" book and have a little review.

by garion11

Heh, we are flattered that you already think we failed in getting those terrorists. I guess you had a timline, we should have gotten them by tea time perhaps? WE are that good, yeehaw!. Thank you for your flattering phrases.

SOOO, maybe you should ask the French on whether they got their butt saved or even the English or how about the WHOLE European continent?? Did we go at it alone, NOOO, and I never said we did. But you sure as hell in no way would have won that war if it wasn't for the US help. Even when we weren't in it, we still supported you logisticaly (some secret and some open).

Yes wars are won, lost, and are tied, its a game like anything else with an inevitable outcome.

Its ok, you already hate us, its plain old jealousy of the US wealth and power. No one simply gives a damn about what you think post 9/11. So piss off! :).

Its interesting that you think our education system is backward considering US is the largest economy in the world. Thats right we have trees that grow money, and wait, wait, it rains gold here did you know that? But the definition of education is so relative, you would think that, since we don't preach enough Marxist "ideals".

And which quotes would those be, "From each according to his ability to each according to his need"?? or some variation of it?.

No, love of money is not evil, its UNEARNED money which is the root of all evil.

Have fun organizing.

So please sit in a corner and let the adults speak.

by oz_media

When you are able tto formulate an accurate response based on fact and back it with supoprting information, I may take a little notice of your efforts.

it is OBVIOUS you have absolutely NO idea regarding WWII or the state of current affairs either so I ask you to kindly do some study before taking up my headspace.

There is another thread titled: U.S. Dollar vs. the Euro: Another Reason for the Invasion of Iraq

I think this coupled with: US Corporations have a Chokehold on the US Media:
http://tinyurl.com/wkc7

and "The Complete Idiots Guide to World War II" may help you understand what REALLY happened.http://tinyurl.com/wkoi

You can look at a few free pages but you could get your mom to buy you the book if you claim it is educational, she'll probaby be impressed with you interest in study.

Your Republican government owns ALL of the media in the US. how do you actually expact to hear and see the truth unless you look outside.

By the way, the USA is VERY unpopular worldwide these days, I don't think ANYONE wishes they were American. Believe me, I am in Canada, I could move to, work and live in the USA in a heart beat, if I chose. Jealousy isn't part of it, however if I WAS American, I'd probably be lead to think everyone was jealous of the dump too.

Do some reading and actually think about your position in the world for once instead of just churning over the same BS we've all heard for years from your delusional citizens.

by garion11

OMG, LMAO. Republican Media???, muhahahahahahaha. Shut the hell up. UP to this point I was willing to listen to what you had to say, I believed that you had valid information. Your idiotic statement in the last post more than proves it. Stop listening to your Left wing media, sheesh. YOu have NOO IDEA about what media is like in this country, NONE whatsoever. YOur right wing media is soo far left, you guys don't have a right anymore. Its all one big happy Left wing family. Thats why you are getting these distorted images of why you think we view our president and our country the way we do. Just shut up, discussion over, I can't believe I wasted my valuble time responding to your posts, gah!. When you decide to grow up maybe I will give you the honor of talking to me. Buh bye.

by oz_media

That's it? You sure fold fast! Man you didn't even offer a single supporting argument for your little rant!!

Your last post offered not a single ounce of evidence to back your point.

You resorted to simply slamming a political view as well as my intellingence and completely side stepped the issue of discussion in a single post.

This is actually very common here, they come and go like pets in the pet store. You try not to become attached by not using names and keeping a sort of professional attitude. One minute they are all YADA, YADA, YADA, BLAH, BLAH, BLAH, the next minute it's forget the issue at hand, blame the messenger, make some ranting statements without any supporting fact to be found and Bye,Bye, They're gone again.

Just like they never existed.

Good thing your Leader had enough money for his smoke and mirrors campaign! If they all fold under the opposition as easy as you did, there'd BE no campaign, debate or election.

by deadly ernest

Not even the worst holocaust predictions predict the total destruction of all the people without the total destruction of all life on earth. We just dont have enough bombs to get everyone. An even distribution of all the devices around the globe may cause a bad enough nuclear winter to ensure the destruction of all life, but that is unlikely. Most major targets will have multiple bombs aimed at them and thus many areas will be devestated and others largely untouched.

People will survive and rebuild, but to what extent is another issue. All I can say is

WATCH THIS SPACE

by john_wills

Perhaps the U.S. is the oldest SURVIVING republic. Apparently older republics have been something else inbetween. Palestinian and Armenian Christians both claim their nations as "the first Christian nation". The Palestinians seem to be right, because Palestine was majority-Xn from about 200 AD, whereas Armenia became Xn at its king's command in 301 AD. But over 80% of the Palestinians are now non-Xn, so although Palestine is the FIRST Xn nation Armenia is the OLDEST Xn nation. Similarly, the U.S. is - so far as I know - the OLDEST republic, but not the first.

by deadly ernest

The major thing to look at is the difference in general affluence, those pushing the succession had stronger economies and more people with time to think and get upset. Some of the other colonies that secceeded did so more in support of their friends next door than in real desire to fight. Look at the differences in time between the first actions and when some of the colonies made formal declarations.

But you still come down to essentially free people used to looking after themselves with the affluence to have time to think beyond getting tomorrows dinner gettin upset with laws that are not relevant or too expensive.

A similar type problem is occuring in some societies today, and people are getting angry with their govts about excess or excessive laws. Today they talk a lot more, in those days they were more used to taking action.

by rwilson4

I was proud of Oldefar's eloquence and I also understood the statement to which you to exception. Then I read your pronouncements regarding that statement and was more than slightly amused when you made the following "point":

"Whatever, you'll never understand the rest of the world anyway."

This strikes me as "the pot calling the kettle black" . . . you claim that the American was arrogant when he said that, if he had to explain it, you wouldn't understand it and then you declare that he;ll never understand the rest of the world . . . is that not a bit arrogant as well?

Perhaps, had the statement been "I can't explain it if you don't already understand it.", you _might_ not have objected quite so strongly.

Can your accurately translate the German term "gemutlich" into English? Would it be arrogant of a German to say, "If you don't understand it, I can't explain it."

This discussion is closed to new replies.