Discussion Locked

Is IT degenerating into a field where idiots rule?

0 helpful
329 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

329 replies

by blieffring9

a D was 2 JKs in series with 2 sets of data gates and an inverter. the first jk would load when clock was in load state. when the clock went to set, data would be blocked to the first JK and the gates would be enabled to the second JK. a SR had connections to override clocked data to the second stage. returning inverted output data to the input would divide the clock frequency in half with an even duty cycle.

by tony hopkinson

Building your own logic circuits, bit rusty myself, but I got started on programming by literally building my algorithms. Adress decoding, adders, driving segment leds those were the days. EPROMs and PLCs took some of the fun out of it, though those too were interesting in their own way.
Todays professionals are so remote from the real nuts and bolts of how things work they don't even think of this sort of thing as computing.

PS. I got into digital circuitry because I found the mathematical requirements of analogue way too difficult. Fourier transforms , arrgh.

by blieffring9

DEC died becase they had a simple architecture, and someone put uVAX on a chip. It was faster and cost 1/40 of their 8800 8900 frames. Third party resellers dropped DEC when they would not release their new 8xxx bus structure, and had to use DEC's interface chipset. They choked the speed of uVAX 1, but everyone found out. VAX 3 was faster than anything. SPARC and MIPS were ruling speed tests with RISC, so DEC developed alpha and ported it to UNIX. Microsoft announced it would develop to alpha and had compiled NT on alpha. The head of VAX read that DEC was dropping VAX and VMS for Alpha UNIX and went to Microsoft and integrated the registry from VMS to WNT. VAX/VMS died about 1988.

by tony hopkinson

Early in my career , I knew a great deal about technology, but much less about business and how to apply it effectively. My boss was not as gifted as I but he did know how to get the best out of what he did know and showed me how to do the same.

I've never had a manager who was as good a programmer as I, in fact I think the attributes are mutually exclusive. All I require from a manager is recognition where my strengths and weaknesses are, can't ever get that if I don't recognise where their's are though.
To say my manager is a failure because he's not as good a programmer as I, is as daft as him saying he's a better programmer because I'm not as good a a manager.
I have met the latter attitude, I've also been a tad tactless on occasion in correcting it as well.
LOL

by tony hopkinson

The original idea behind certification was that by being awarded one you'd achieved an industry recognised standard. This was simply to cope with the multiplicity of qualifications of varying degree that were out ther before. A subtle but extremely lucrative change of emphasis, turned recognition into achievement. The verification itself became more important than what it was meant to be for. Hence , boot camps , on line CDs, the merry-go-round, massive costs for little reward and a generalised contempt for what they are.
If a certification or a degree for that matter is an indicator of excellence then awarding them to everyone who can see lightning and hear thunder makes them an indicator of mediocrity.

I've worked with many people who had either or both who were far from mediocre, equally I've worked with far too many just as 'qualified' who weren't even that good.

by johnofstony

I'm very fortunate in that the Managing Director of the company I now work for is a competent electronics engineer and very knowledgeable about IT (and my immediate boss). My experience of many other companies' IT departments is not good. Very simple programming tasks seem to be beyond them. Security is lax in reality yet they seem paranoid about security in other areas. Only today I received an attachment which contained personal credit card details which were irrelevant as far as the information I needed was concerned. I assume that the employers pay them peanuts and end up with monkeys because they haven't a clue about what IT involves. Another problem is IT personnel get fired without any thought as to the experience and knowledge of the business that is being lost. My main complaint in every IT job I've ever done is unrealistic deadlines. I was once asked at a job interview whether I had ever finished writing a program and my reply was, "Yes, once!".

by basie.venter

I rather use an MCSE with 2 - 5 years practical experience than one of those Gods gift to mainkind college or university graduates. (meaning u Mr KnowITall)

by mr_dobby

Well said basie.venter......

The original posting is one of those usual offerings which states people with certs have no idea. A very negative posting i must admit!

Everybody has a learning curve, just because someone has a BSc/mcse/cne or whatever does not mean they know it all, these qualifications are generally only used to get a foot in the door. This is where the real learning starts, on the job. Experience is the most important thing. I agree, many mcse's are c##p, but some use an mcse (or whatever cert) to get a start in user support so that they can get there IT career moving. What is so bad about this? The same goes for the BSc great to have but only to get started in the IT field where the real learning starts.

If there is something you are unhappy with, change it! Complaining about all the IT people you politely refer to as "idiots" will get you nowhere fast.

by barry 441

This could be another whole topic and I believe it has been covered here before? certs.
I have a co-worker with MCSE certification. Doesn't mean a darn thing.
He has no real comprehension of even the most basic workings of an OS and can never answer the simplest of questions from our end users.
Calls to him are forwarded to someone else on the helpdesk quite often because he can?t help them.
He studied for the test and passed. Big deal...
The frustrating part is that on paper he looks more "qualified" than the rest of us, when in fact he should be flipping burgers.

by olero

My CEO knows more about IT than IT-staff.
Why is that. Well he bought a computer from a coupon magazine.
He managed to plug all cables in the right places, and it seems to work.
So he managed to do what IT-staff cant - he made it work in less than a day!
So why can't we get Novell, MS, *nix and what ever is in demand work as well...
Well, complexity might be a factor - but what do I know.

by loki201183

With the Shoe String Budgets and A$$ on fire work people expect the IT dept (read Techies) to answer the questions like Why do we use this Antivirus and not THAT ...
Well we could answer ... The reason is that this is cheaper that that one !!!

IT depts generally have to deal with multiple deployments at the same time ... eg .. just last week we had to implement Antivirus, Domain .. Internet Domains ... etc ...

Well all this costs money ... (For upgrading as the company needs grow)... which has committies to decide ... but a new water cooler would arrive in a day or two once someone says it is needed :(

People do not think of all this and expect techies to explain in detail the reason WHY DID WE USE THIS PARTICULAR ANTIVIRUS ????

by andrew.moore

I remember a saying which went something like "a consultant is someone who borrows your watch, charges you to tell you the time and then keeps the watch".

We outsource very little IT contracts in my company mainly because anyone who has tried to sell us these services have always been found wanting. i.e. They cannot provide reasonable turnaround, have a very narrow range of skills (in one highly amusing case one company would only support Cisco kit and they were hoping to get our network maintenance contract) and were slow to adopt new technologies which meant our growth would have been stunted as we tend to be very leading edge with new technology.

Outsourcing IT can never hope to compete with having trained people onsite readily available. These people are up to speed on all the companies equipment and configuration, are aware of quirks within the system and don't have to spend an entire morning doing "familiarisation" before tackling a problem.

by airmid

The problem we have in South Africa is that companies employ A+ techs as field engineers, and expect one or two so called experts to support them, and because of our past most of these techs grew up without basic knowledge of electricity and general DIY skills so they end up as board swappers and can not repair anything. People think that IT is the only place where you can make a reasonable living without having to study to hard, and that cause youngsters to enter IT with no skills or aptitude. Gone are the days when techs read every piece of info regarding IT to try and better themselves, these days they read music, car and bike mags instead, no passion for IT anymore

by mgtucker

Whoever "you" are, you may have replaced someone who was "more qualified" than yourself but, after "downsizing" and "right-sizing", you got the job. Many are made to believe "our company could not get along without a super candidate" at hiring. If YOU are the one hired you tend to think everyone else was an "idiot".

I've known plenty of "experts" who are "the smartest technicians in the world" who spend weeks researching a $25 product with NO consideration of the total cost of ownership or correlation to the CIO perspective. Their only concern is if Product A (for $95) is "better" than Product B (from a big company) or Product C that runs on Linux so It MUST be better than Product D that only costs $25.

by lederhoden

I agree that so much software is bought because it is cheap in terms of acquisition and the TCO is...not understood by the "idiot" signing the cheques. One of the main reasons why IT departments spend their lives chasing their tails is because of this short-sighted attitude. If the IT dept. were allowed the resources to perform a proper PoC, before any purchase was made, they would spend far less time, in the long run, plugging leaks to the keep the whole setup afloat and far more time on proactive management and performance enhancement - for far less outlay to the company, certainly over the entire life-cycle of the application.
The problem with that attitude is that PoC costs are visible as are acquisition costs. The cost of maintaining one application within the framework of the company's overall IT landscape is far easier to hide.

by dave

Management decide what to spend, and what to spend it on.

If this company has outsourced to the cheapest quote then guess what, they're not training their staff on the best solutions for each situation.

They use windows because you can pretty much jump into a windows server, read a book, and have it running in a few days. Unix would be much harder, you'd need to know what your are doing for a start!

I'm not saying this windows server is running well - its probably full of security holes and as you said the design of the network - well it wasn't designed was it? But it works, they paid nothing on training and don't need experienced staff - and guess what - they still get paid!

Same goes for AV - yes the professional approach would be to design a testing methodology and compare several popular AV suites on these common factors then pick the best one a cost / performance base.

BUT...

Do you have a few weeks to do this properly? I doubt it. My choice of AV comes from the fact that 1) it works and 2) I've used the personal edition myself at home.

by graham

Finally someone that might be more in touch with IT than others realise. I have been in IT for 28 years, working in a management role in later years, and have seen the cycles of IT come and go; from before the days of PCs, from the glass house, to distributed systems, from the demise of great companies that deserverd to survive (CDC, DG, DEC), from SNA, RS232 to IP, to the manical ramblings of so called university qualified "professionals" that have proved themselves worthy of reading text books and passing exams, to the over paid, and over rated consultants that are in truth, only IT hobbyists in between proper jobs.

Yes the IT world is ruled by idiots and consultants, and now I am paying for IT by relying on inexperienced staff that have no idea of what they are doing, but are good at quoting the sales manuals, and incapable of looking outside the 9 dots. In the 3rd world country which I now call home, appropriate technolgy is not applied to appropriate skills, but is a reflection of the selling skills of the engaged consulting specialists from a well developed nation that has the specialist's contact cell numbers at their beck and call.

What am I doing about IT? Just sit back guys, have fun, enjoy life, dont get stressed out about IT, and pay off the mortgage. Your hourly rate is better than Doctors, so just take it easy.

g

by tonyg324

Please let us know when you plan to move on to your next employer... and please provide the name of your current and future employers. That will give us a chance to polish up our resumes and begin our search for the new job we will eventually need to have...

:)

by jck

Can't agree more, adunlap.

The IT workforce tends to know their job inside and out...and tend to have bigger BS detectors when it comes to decisions made involving their occupation.

by ediaz

I think that after the buble a lot of wanna be tech entrepeneurs wanted to make a living on tech. There are a lot of people with no technical skills giving support, or are presented like tech experts.

Also we, IT professional are guilty, because we don't protect our profession. People don't understand technology, and we talk in technolang, so when some one explain in simple terms something probably him could sell better. We IT Pros must learn more about how to sell, explain how we add value to our costumers bussines.

Today is not enough to be certified and technically skilled, we also have to learn some marketing skills.

Users don't want to do investigation, they want solutions, in a well done brochure solutions looks like silver bullets. We can do good brochures too, but telling the truth, explaining why things have the cost they have, and always add an analisys of how your solution could add value to the user's business.

We can fight idiots, just we must change our speech, listen to the users, and show them our value, and the value we add.

by gprinsloo

But the problem is worse where I am, in that IT has become a control tool. I have encountered that companies hire their friends/family/political buddies in order to control

1. The gains derived from contracting IT consultants/workers.
2. The information availability/restriction control.

Technical abilities, qualifications or expertise is of no worth against this evil.

by gdeckler

What is a true sign of idiots is that you all are just realizing that this is a problem in IT. The real pros have been advocating professionalism and how stupid vendor certifications like MCSE's are for over a decade. Welcome to the party. If you guys would have had a clue 10 years ago, we wouldn't all be in the mess we are in now. Thanks for nothing.

by markarse

...by 'outsiders'

IT is still perceived by many as an easy way to make a lot of money.

In the UK we are bombarded by TV advertising that offers self-paced IT training - 'train for IT qualifications that employers really want' the theory being that anyone can come along and be taught to pass IT certification exams.

Now this may be true. To be honest, when I took my MCP and MCSE exams, it was perfectly possible to pass without ever having worked in IT if you had the type of mind that can relentlessly hoover up and regurgitate information the MS way.

This makes the quality of the certification hugely questionable.

I've been in IT nearly 10 years. I started off doing it on a part-time basis along with other duties because I was the person in the office who 'knew about PCs'. As the company grew it became a full-time job and eventually I managed to persuade my employer to put me through my MCSE - although largely for my own benefit. So I am largely self-taught, and pretty proud of it.

I work with a guy who has a burning desire to get into IT. He has tried to get posted into my department on numerous occasions, but I have blocked this on the grounds that he does not have the necessary temperament or mindset to work in this environment.

If you give him a numbered list of steps in order to complete a necessary task then he will follow it to the letter. However, as soon as there is some out-of-the-box thinking required - for instance to solve a never-before-seen issue, he does not have the ability to do the analysis to at least have a starting point for problem solving.

Some of that comes with experience, I will not deny, but it is the thought processes and analysis that are at least as important to doing the job. Now he wants to get his MCSE, which I am sure he can get, but it doesn't make him suitable to support even a small network.

There will always be a problem with 'bad' IT people. IT is more about approach and experience than certification in my opinion, but while IT is perceived as being an 'easy' option and certification is still easy to achieve there is nothing to stop them.

by dg_atl

Boy did Too old for IT hit the nail on the head for me. Latest SEC filings declared our new CEO earned 1 mil in wages but the board felt sorry for him and ok'd a 3.5 mil bonus. All the while declaring the IT staff (tech's) was earning too much and proceeded to reduce salaries 5% across the board. Business strategy seems too be shrink this sob till nothing remains. Wall Mart here I come.

by fremer

If all said is true, it isn't even the tip of the iceberg.
No only are techies highly ignorant of the solutions they recommend, but foremost, usually those "solutions" are based on personal likeness and a corrupt culture of gifts and bribes, at least out here in South America.
I wouldn't agree that technology certificates are a waste, but they certainly don't hold water unless accompanied by a proper background based on experience and even better, formal academic degrees.
Nonetheless, we are in the midst of being overrun by idiots whose lip technique surpasses their real knowledge of the stuff they push.

by holdupmaster

Whilst I understand the sentiments of some of the posters on this thread.

I get annoyed when people constantly bash management. By definition they cant do your job. Lets not carry on this shameless "my manager is crap" approach. I know the feeling, my manager isnt great, but then neither is his ... etc
I work in a quite large manged service environment, and often have to deal with techies from other companies (Hospitals in our case). Some of them arnt very well qualified and just muddle along. Does this mean they are bad? Does it mean that there manager shouldnt have hired them. Or is someone somewhere saying, A) we dont need the best b) we couldnt pay them anyway. So the cloth gets cut accordingly. Even in a utopian environment where nothing is failing. They do exist. There are other things an IT department needs to concern itself with. Change management is one, Testing of new software / hardware to provide better service to the business. Changes will be constantly requested by higher powers, understanding how to do them and manage them so that there is no impact on production systems is a key part of the job.
If you are sat around doing genuinly doing nothing then expect to be downsized, as the business will have seen not value from you. Always keep in the back of your mind, how can I show business benefit , either to the bottom line (always a winner) or to productivity (good one, although subjective and difficult to demonstrate often).

There are a lot of people posting, that are obviously not happy with there employer. Please dont just rant though, it gives a very unprofessional appearance to our profession. There are cowboys, and they exist in every industry. Just make sure you can show you arent one of them.
Certifications are good, they show the candidate could demonstrate knowledge. The CCIE that was mentioned earlier is considered equivalent to a Masters degree in the UK as its content is difficult, wide ranging and requires good demonstratable experience in the field.
Degrees are good, they show a good academic ability and often give a good rounded skill set.
If you have a combination you are laughing (I know I am ) As you can not only show that you are able academically but that you can fit roles defined by certifications.

Plenty of people bash certs out of envy, they wish their employer would pay for them, or they wish they had them so that they could move to another job etc etc. Those people stand out a mile off.

Certs are also getting harder, particularly Ciscos, Microsoft are committed to preventing braindump passers, and now many employers are looking for the experience to backup the certs, and are happy to quiz a candidate at interview. I know I have been grilled at interview serveral times. It also helps to rule out the blaggers.

Lets not constantly put a downer on our industry, we work hard, and there is the potential to earn good money if you put the time and effort in. It could be worse, you could be shovelling dirt in some other job.
IT has been infested with Politics, there is an answer.. ignore them, or deal with them. Either way, just get on with your job to the best of your ability.

my 2p

by hendre

Idiot firms will buy services from Idiots and in turn deliver Idiot quality products for Idiots.

by dilipj

Hey, All fingers are not of the same size but definitely your comment represents a major group of IT Managers. Some funny facts about these 'I' community.

- Many times they dont know what they are saying.
- If they found experienced person in interview, they will protect their future by saying that u r more experienced.
- If they are getting old then they will say that they want more young candidates to work with them..
- They will always say that 'Don't make a fool by saying that it is not possible. Every thing is possible'
- They will try to explain some 'Great logic' for software programming or future planning in IT dept.

And many other but still I feel that it will be injustice to comment like this, based upon your experience with 'Single' instance.

by silver fox

I have been in IT since the late 1950's and I honestly don't see anything new about your comments or complaints. People have been saying for years, if only we could educate "Management" on how IT complexity, skills, difficulty etc. then our jobs would be a lot easier.

Give it up. That is part of the territory of IT and the management is not about to get into all those details of IT Technology. If you want to manage IT and have probably more support than you desire, then work in Engineering or Research IT. However, these folks think they understand all technologies, so be prepared for all types of advise, most of which will be wrong.

Enjoy yourself, you are in a unique field and people do respect you more than you can realize.

Life is short, smell the roses. This is coming from a guy who has done many all nighters working on networks, servers etc. As recently as this August.

Like I say, enjoy yourself and quit complaining before you give the IT Profession a worse reputation than it has all ready.

Midnite.....

by mark

NZ,
This post is actually posed as a question but is actually a self serving question. You ask a question and then attempt to answer it anecdotally, but in truth your answer speaks more volumes than you know...lets take a look at several of your statements...

You said, "People dont recognise the skill and training that goes into a degree in IT and would rather trust MCSE which is not even NZQA accredited so in truth is not a qualification."

Ummm - Sure they do. Employers ALWAYS respect a degree. Certification however, indicates proficiency with a particular product. You then go on to say that MCSE is not even a qualification because it is not "NZQA" (New Zealand Quality Assurance?)Rated. Guess what? An employer sets the qualifications for the position! If the Company says an MCSE is a req, then thats just the way it is...tough luck! It sounds like you have a degree in IT but dont have a cert...sour grapes? passed over for promotion?

Why do sales people sell a product? Simple, because they work for the company/distributor that handles the product...If I worked for Ford, would I be selling Chevys?? Your complaint there is simply ridiculous.

Finally, I have a difficult time considering the syntax and spelling of your post, that you even possess a higher degree. When you get right down to it your complaint is nothing but a Microsoft bashing session disguised as a valid complaint. Nice try, but you would be better advised to get off your duff and get the MCSE - that after all, seems to be the crux of the issue here....

by gprinsloo

I am an MCSE and have the same gripe regarding non MS products. Take the latest craze, freeware.

Wake up people you dont even get trouble for free.

I find that IT staff both with degrees and product certifications alike face the same problem.

It is middle and top management who have to cover their butts. They need to perform from a financial point of view and will do so short term. Once they take the next rung on the ladder the buck is passed to the new individual to fight the fires.

We in IT need to, perhaps spend more time getting sales and management training in order to better manage our bosses than we do our systems, pc's, mainframes or pda's.

NO other job/work/career in the world is less defined, structured or established than IT.

I still believe, when door to door sales went out of fashion, most of those salespeople turned to IT.

by banyangod

Good point,

All too often I find myself as a,

jack of all trades
master of none.

Anything even remotely electronic(not even IT) and I am being put to task to take care of it. I have even done work on the Air Condition system at work.

so I find myself being put to task on things that I have little experience in just because I am IT.

I notice that people see IT in one of two ways;

Either

a: It is relatively easy and anyone can do it
b: as an IT person you are a genious and can do anything at all in the IT field.

just because I can build out a well running efficient network does not mean I know anything more than basic SQL language, or reprogram our websites and applications to Flash and ColdFusion.

by lrbassoc

ONe of the problems we all face is the constant lack of understanding about how to accomplish business goals. As a consultant I have to face this almost daily. Helping the entrenched big iron face the reality that the business needs superceed what they expect. Because of budget constraints and the lack of understanding on both parts I sometimes feel like a referee.

I also object to the statement that they would rather hear from an MCSE. I started with a degree in Business and moved into IT. I obtained my MCSE and MCT and enjoy teaching others. I even recommend Linux and the retention of mainframes if it is cost effective and the staff is able to support it.

by reccaa

IT in Germany started out with punch cards.
The people in the organisition who were considered to be the least valuable were relegated to this job.
This attitude has not changed even today. 95 % of the IT Managers in Germany are not IT Educated, but are people who are qualified in other walks of life( such as finance or law. I have not met a single IT Manager in my 30 Years of IT experience who is can write a program or who can give a qualified opinion on Hardware. They all have their 'specialists' who do their technical thinking for them.
Therefore it is no wonder that they are ready to accept shoddy practice from Vendors.
Firms such as SAP, IBM and Microsoft don't have a problem in siphoning large amounts of revenue from Firms who are their customers, since such managers who are basically insecure look for security in numbers and buy from large vendors.( Lemmings do the same, plunging in the sea.)

by markarse

I work for the UK arm of a German company and this is soooo true.

All too often the decision is in favour of 'big' names without any real thought being given to the fact that often the solution presented is too complex and either:
a)doesn't really address the issue in the 1st place, or
b)requires consultancy support for the rest of the lifetime of the software

The general perception in the UK is that it is safer to make the 'easy' decision in favour of a well-known product as there is perceived to be a smaller chance of the outright failure of the project.

It has been asserted that this is due to an inherent sense of CYA-syndrome, and coming from a company where rank and power is measured in 1/2mm increments on the org chart, I have some sympathy with that.

by bbeckett2000

That's because IT is a cost center. It is what it is and that's how management views it. They have no clue how much it costs to keep things running, not to mention moving things forward.

They see it as an expense only, a necessary evil.

by codebubba

That is exactly correct. What's weird about it is the cost center is what produces the product so they can have a profit center in the first place. Still - I.T. is the last one to get consideration in the operation. Weird but fact-of-life.

-CB

by bobby.ricardo

I am agree with you, I am leaving my job because my managers believe that everything could be done running the software wizards. ????? and we have got 28 servers and 1500 workstations spread on 3 sites.

by drkhorse19

It's a fact that like techs, most doctors fall prey to the same kind of marketing and reaction to questions of what to "prescribe" for given conditions. It's up to dedicated IT service professionals to be informed and make choices. And let's not kid ourselves. In any field providing services, there's going to be someone who does the same thing, whether medical, IT, auto service, etc.

Instead of being frustrated by it, which solves nothing, inform yourself. Have at the ready not just what product you'd use in a given situation, but why you'd use it too. You might score points at an interview or with a customer by giving a lucid reason why brand A is better than brand b in a given situation, instead of "because they're the best".

As it was once said by Mark Twain, "Let us be thankful for fools; but for them, the rest of us could not succeed."

by danetter

I am not an IT professional, just a retired mathematician never employed in academia. Three out of four companies I worked at were sick in the sense that a disturbing proportion of managers was interested primarily in expanding their own empires. Competency becomes a secondary matter and the result is idiotic professional behavior. My worst experience was with my last employer. A project manager wanted an improvement to a standard statistical test for acceptance of a classified system, because the customer didn't like the one proposed. He wouldn't tell me what it was that the customer didn't like nor let me talk to any customer's representative who did know what the objection was. I eventualy found out, long after the fact, that it was a simple matter of customer dissatisfaction with the balance between the probabilities of a good system failing and a bad system being accepted. It should have been maybe a week's work writing a report with a simple explanation and some simple examples. It dragged on for a couple of months with me trying to guess what the customer might conceivably be objecting to about a standard hypothesis test. I am convinced that the project manager didn't have even the remotest idea of what the customer actually wanted. The company - Norden Systems - no longer exists. Another of the sick companies disappeared years ago. The third still exists, but no longer receives contracts of much importance.

There is also, of course, the instance of the top U. S executive office.

by ke_xtian

This is the most insightful summary of the problem I have ever read. You said everything I have been thinking for the last 20 years in just a few sentences. It is right on the money.

While I am not the writer you are, I would add a few thoughts. Management increasingly buys what Microsoft claims to sell, which is easy, integrated, cheap solutions. While I do not have the expertise to critique all of MS's solutions, I can tell you that for mission-critical, web-based database applications, SQL Server is neither mission-critical, easy, or cheap. MS's solution is to scale out. That is expensive and needlessly complex.

MS is proof that the free market is not always right, especially in the short term.

by hushpup9

I wouldn't take advise from some of the village idiots,It seems that it is easy to put anything on your resume (but can you do the work, BIG IF!!!). My boss who doesn't know anything about computers.(Token.) She doesn't have a clue and keeps hiring idiots. the last one stole $1200 worth of stuff, said he was a college grad, (bull hockey)and she wouldn't do anything(she is doing the same thing) The next one says he is a Network Engineer, (bull again) he doesn't even know where to go to change network settings. They both expect me to train them, but I am the one going to school not them.They go home and put PJ's on. I have documented the network and everything for them, but my boss thinks I should tell her how I fix things how I troubleshoot. What do you think? I don't feel I should be doing all the work in figuring out the problem then tell my boss how to do it. There has to be a law? I could go on. I think it is time to move on..

by dshaw1

As IT consultants we have become increasingly frustrated with an apparent increase in the lack of knowledge in customer IT departments. Without giving chapter and verse, if it's not rows in a database table they don't understand it. It seems they get certified in a tool, e.g., Microsoft, Oracle or whatever, and then all they know is the care and feeding of that beastie. We work mostly with business units, and it is the kiss of death if the IT department gets stuck in.

by aasmith

Actually it seems to be a bit of both. As you note budgets remember the largest expense in most companies is payroll. As such it is likely that the senior IT professional may not be hired as quickly as the newbie just out of college.

Second of course is the infrastructure, and there is a lot to deal with there that upper management does not understand, but can be educated on. In the end it all depends on the understanding and level of commitment of the company.

Isn't firefighting what we all signed up for?

by ctrimbath

I think there are two big problems in IT (not the only two, but two that pertain to this discussion)
First: There are people in IT that have gotten there by dumb luck. They happened to do something or be involved with something that happened and some Manager/Director said "you should be in IT" so they went into IT. And through knowing the politics of the company have remained there for years without really knowing IT. This also applies to people who got their IT positions through attrition.

Second: People who got into IT because they thought they could make a lot of money in IT. And since they could keep their computer running they figured they could do that with everyone elses. Most of these people don't last long but you do find those that catch that niche market of people that believe they are the best thing since sliced bread. Until they happen accross a "real" techie and are blown away by what can be done.

by kelenpc

We could teach them all very fast by organizing a walkout...LOL.
Let's see who gets the 3.5mil bonus and a new house.

by codebubba

Yeah ... describes us to a "T". Incidentally - people wonder why I no longer have hair on the top of my head!

-CB :-)

by mguglielmi

In the scheme of things IT has not been around for that long. It will take many years for the professionals in our field to know everything that is going on all of the time. The constantly changing tools that are used in the field also make it difficult to stay current with accurate information. 50 years down the road, there will be lot more good IT professionals in the field and training will be more accurate and efficient. Patients everyone, Rome wasn't built in a day.

by ediaz

I think that after the buble a lot of wanna be tech entrepeneurs wanted to make a living on tech. There are a lot of people with no technical skills giving support, or are presented like tech experts.

Also we, IT professional are guilty, because we don't protect our profession. People don't understand technology, and we talk in technolang, so when some one explain in simple terms something probably him could sell better. We IT Pros must learn more about how to sell, explain how we add value to our costumers bussines.

Today is not enough to be certified and technically skilled, we also have to learn some marketing skills.

Users don't want to do investigation, they want solutions, in a well done brochure solutions looks like silver bullets. We can do good brochures too, but telling the truth, explaining why things have the cost they have, and always add an analisys of how your solution could add value to the user's business.

We can fight idiots, just we must change our speech, listen to the users, and show them our value, and the value we add.

by it mgr/packer fan

I have been fortunate in my past, to have very talented and dedicated IT people working in administrator roles-- but every once in a bit, you get an employee who thinks that all management is inept, and uses that as an excuse for his own lack of results, or productivity. The first thing I think, when I hear someone blame management for the organization's problems is, "This person has a MAJOR blame complex- he or she will never own their responsibilities"- and that would be the LAST person I would trust with a new implementation, or a better position!

by muralidhar_chaturvedi

It seems that common sense has lost its significance and The word creativity has disappeared from the face of the earth leading to Believe The IT men are gods resulting in degenerating of life itself.

Muralidhar

by tantor

People who were truck drivers five years ago and never owned a computer bought into the whole "Certify and make a fortune" pitch. Fortunately hard times have shook some of them out of the tree, but enough got into management to make it hard to survive for someone who knows what they are doing. The business users listen to managers, because they don't understand those of us that understand the technology. They feel more comfortable with others that don't understand.

Case in point, my old boss. Was a real estate agent (The last easy money boom) before getting into IT. Didn't have a lick of technical ability. Once unplugged a switch to give to another location before bothering to check if anyone was connected to it. His response to the 132 users he put offline? "Figure it out, I already promised so and so they could have this."

This was two weeks after he decided to assign our gateway address a network printer he was installing for an executive. Then he told us to just change the Gateway, because he didn't want this exec to lose his printer for even a second.

Never mind that the exec lost his email, database access, financial reports access, etc. At least he had his printer. Which, oh yeah, DIDN'T WORK EITHER.

by ardeur478

Budget is never an issue where I work. If I need to buy something to get a project rolling, I'm given the money to do so.

Much like you, James, I was hired on with little experience, and have learned 90% of my skills on the job. I'm very grateful to this company for hiring me.

But at the same time, I can't deny the fact that management is full of people who don't have a clue.

For example, my NETWORK ADMIN, that is, my direct supervisor, the head of the IT department, had a mouse that died. I told her to go ahead and shut the computer down and I'd connect the new PS/2 mouse. She responded with a question, "well how do I bring up the Start menu without a mouse?"

This is not an isolated example, but its one of the funniest that I have seen.

by bill.affeldt

It is the job of the manager to make sure that what is happening is good for the business. That is what it is ALL about.

Installing technology for technology's sake is NOT good business.

IT is about doing things cheaper, faster, more reliably, safer and generally better.

As manager (former technologist) it is my job to make sure I am moving the company in the right direction.

Please do not assume that means cutting salaries or over working people till they are ready to quit. It means keeping a competent workforce happy, productive and focused on the goal.

It bothers me that so many IT technologists see the world in black and white (binary?) when the world operates very much in the grays.

And yes I might engage a firm because they took me out to lunch and at that lunch explained that
'If you have any problems --- you can call me and I will make sure it gets resolved'. That is called networking and just like T1 lines it is the way important information gets to where it needs to go.

P.S. In a 'for profit' business the goal they should be focused on is making money.

by ajit.kapoor

The idiots do not but on the contrary very savvy marketers rule it. They by pass the IT and its CIO and approach the CEO with promises to save millions and backed by Ivy league studies. Now we only want to please-survival of the fittest. Who will tell the emperor that he has no clothes?

by tbg58

Of course idiots rule. People who have technical skills can't be promoted into management -- they're needed where they are.
As for the professional manager class, the pointy-haired technical and ethical moron of the Dilbert comic strip is based on a stereotype that has roots in reality.
Yes, there are some competent managers out there, but sadly a significant plurality (if not a majority) are utterly clueless, flying by the seat of their pants because they have no actual connection with reality. All they have is a completely arbitrary GANTT chart, and equally arbitrary budget based on articles in trade rags and unrealistic assumptions.

Sorry, but a significant number of "managers" are just people who have learned how to game the system to advance their own position whose only real skills are self-promotion, butt kissing, squelching the voice of conscience and office intrigue.

Sorry to be so cynical, but down here in the trenches we have to live in the real world, unlike so many who are in management.

TBG

by ojeda

From the outside, at this institution, a medium size hospital in a city, it appears that we have a bunch of Netasaurius Dictasauriases. It's our system, and we'll help when we're darn ready. Being the pharmacy computer contact, it has been very frustrating to watch projects remain unresolved for up to 6 months, even with 2 month lead time. I have taken the view that my IS department is made up of pompous jerks. I believe that the knowledge level here intimidates them, so they fight back by stonewalling. I checked with the fellow who had my position before, and he said this has been going on for 10 years.

On the bright side, it means I don't have to work as hard. My excuse: I'm waiting on IS. Since they don't function any better for my boss, I can get away with slacking, and they carry the blame. Haha. Then, I only have to assuage my own desire for excellence, with the fact that I'm living slower.

by robertcleiper2003

...by checking out how pretty the average IT geeks's girlfriend is. If she belongs on the cover of vogue you know its too trendy to be a geek. Time now to find another virgin industry where knowledge wins over LA Law type suits and a copy of Loaded under one arm.

by cjannink

I know that in my field, if I didn't research a product that I recommended to a client, I would not be in business very long.
You have to give every client 100% or you are out!!
Research is a must, but competition drives the need for research.

by activated

IT uses the lowest skilled of tech workers, those working in the HelpDesk are even lower skilled than those in the back room. Are you surprised IT is viewed as a pain in the rear?

by old guy

I guess the "Me" syndrome crosses generations. I was also placed in IT because when the office installed our network about 10 years ago I was about the only one who knew how turn a computer on. However,I have progressed into the IT guy. I have worked with folks who have the credentials who I wound up having to go behind them to fix the problem they were supposed to know how to fix. I've also worked with a lot of other crendentialled folks who taught me most of what I know.
I'm sure there are others, like me, who have learned OTJ who bluff their way through to look good to the bosses. I'm sure there are also a lot of OJT folks who have a tremendous amount of knowledge, and ability, to keep their networks perking.
Whatever the situation I agree that the chronic complainers usually spend more time griping than working. I just try to do the best job I can. Sometimes that means calling in someone more qualified, who may or may not have the "credentials".

by johngaz

It all those 30something year olds who run IT shops and do not have a clue about management or what technology can do for an organization. They just know technology but they do not have the experience to manage technology. They have no idea how to make a business case for technology. Sad but true.

by nickwojo

Sometime around the late 1980's or early 1900's, in an obcure MBA class, an idea was floated that "Why can't an SBA do the job of a System Administrator?". One large IT support company caught on to this idea (name left out intentionally). They sold the idea to their customers to save money. The idea caught on Globally.

Now read about all the problems in IT, all over the world, and you will understand how this field came to rely on none Technical Personnel to run their IT Departments.

You will also understand why there is a perceived shortage of good IT Tech's coming into this field.

by isapp

There have been several discussions on the topic of non-IT managers in IT departments. Managers seem to think that there's nothing technical about managing technical staff. My response as an IT staff person has always been, "Would you hire an English major to head the accounting department?"

by rgreen619

My local school district recently underwent a major IT upgrade. As a volunteer member of the district Technology Infrastructure Committee, my advice was sought for proper hardware, software, etc., to meet current (and future) network demands. Not only did the superintendent completely ignore my recommendations, but also ignored expert in-house talent during the upgrade planning process. The superintendent instead chose to use the services of a non-responsive company (Tek Connect) to install equipment (at a much higher cost) that not only did not meet the need of current demands, but had no room for future expansion. The superintendent quit (before the project was complete) to work for a much larger district (more $$$$$). The district now is looking at having to purchase another server to safeguard administrative information, because the (new) current equipment is not capable of any additional tasking. My small rural town is forgiving, but asking to forgive blatant arrogance is a pretty tall order.

All boils down to "pay me now or pay me later". In this case, both exist in the time tick.

by sethao

Sadly, the majority of these posts could have been taken straight from the pages of any ONE of Scott Adam's infamous 'Dilbert' cartoons! The bottom line is that IT projects/support are predominately driven by middle management possessing little - if any - actual 'real world' technical expertise. Until this situation is changed you will always have a world where mission critical IT decisions are driven by faulty budgets and slick marketing - NOT by solid, tested technical research.

by andeanderson

It has always been this way, not just in the IT field.

I have watched companies who had no staff or equipment place a bid to provide services and after winning the contract they went into a hiring frenzy following the advice of the new hires for what was needed to comply with the contract.

These new hires didn't have a clue about their fellow workers or customers and pushed for what they wanted, not what would work best for the customers. And, these ad-hoc Service Companies were bragged about by their customers, who had no idea of what was really going on, for the fantastic job thay were doing.

It didn't matter what they were actually capable of other than making the customers believe they were receiving outstanding services for the price.

Welcome to the World of Capitalism.

by itjunkie

Are you retarted? Capitalism caused this? Keep on sucking down that genius juice and explain to me which *ism would have stopped this from happening.

...Here's your sign...

by jbartlett

Its true that business and IT need to work from the same strategy and playbook. This has to apply to all departments, not just IT and "them". However there is a additional element that makes working together difficult in most operations I have worked in.

For some reason people feel they know a lot more about computers and IT than they do and are therefore assume they should have a say in how things are done. They make erroneous assumptions about what is involved in implementing strategic goals through technology. I've spent far more time trying to talk people out pie-in-the-sky ideas and concepts than actually making them happen. Any project where the stakeholders cannot agree on the nature of the problem and the solution is bound for failure. The arrogance of non-IT people thinking they already know the answers just makes it worse.

No one would every dream of telling a chef how to prepare a lunch for 500 people, a pilot how to fly a plane or mechanic how to remove a tranmission. But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?

Does this happen in other professions?

by averagejoe

Hey NZBN,

I come across with these "idiots" often and when they mess up, they come back crying to me for help.
Think about it this way, if those guys are really smart, they would not need us to fix their issues.
Just check and hope that they have money left to pay you after they blew the funds on the previous vendors and strip clubs!!! :P

- AJ

by dblaylock

Like you, I have been in this game a long time. My job as IS/IT Supervisor of an 85 user 5 server AD network came as a direct result of my making myself indispenable and necessary. Having a degree in IT does not make you the expert and not having one doesn't make you a fraud. It is only through the trial by fire that we endure daily that we grow and perfect our skills. The more we encounter, the sharper we become.

Management and IT will always be at odds because business doesn't like spending money on something they really don't understand. At the same time, "He who has the gold makes the rules." I for one am more than grateful just a have a job doing something I love. Not everyone is this fortunate.

by randdcomputers

My biggest problem isn't the argument that "anyone' can do it - it's getting people in small biz networks, (3-15 computers with a server) where your are NOT onsite everyday, to stop thinking their office computers are their OWN. The IT guy or gal is just there to fix their breaktime escapades...after all, how dare you put security/road blocks in place??

by nip2655

I get so tired of reading these posts that bash this IT cert or that degree or this experience level.

The simple truth is this: Some people can have no degree and no cert but have the opportunity with the right job (and the natural ability) to allow them to learn and experience a tremendous amount in a year or two. Some folks, on the other hand, could have 3 degrees, multiple IT certifications and be clueless (though it is, of course, unlikely). Degrees are earned through hard-work and dedication to following through on a goal and certs are not that different. Neither teaches that much about practical on-the-job IT skills or how the IT world relates to an organization's larger business goals (and how to get the two to cooperate). Anyone who can't understand this last point or work towards figuring out the reality that in today's business world those two things are mutually inclusive, is doomed to be at the help-desk or in their unhappy positions forever.

The best IT people in the world, in my experience, (12 years in IT, MCSA, MCSE, A+, N+, S+, CCNA, BSc, IT Manager experience and now working in another field), are the ones who don't waste time complaining about who has what qualifications and how unfair this or that situation is. The best people work hard to gain experience, understand that certifications are often very helpful (even if not a true indicator of ability) and sometimes even go after the degree to further their career opportunities. You won't find that many people complaining about all of the pros and cons of one approach over another because they either pursue all of them or understand that it is pointless to bitch about something that you are too lazy or otherwise unable to work toward.

Those that have VALID complaints about management or co-workers and have half a brain usually know that the little IT guy isn't going to change their big company. These professionals either take the steps to affect change (i.e., get a degree to get into management) or go somewhere else. After all, there are plenty of people in IT (as well as in management) who LIKE their jobs (though you wouldn't know it from a lot of these posts). The best all-around people usually find themselves in these positions or are working towards getting there.

My point? If you are concerned about your career, your managers, your qualifications, etc., quit wasting time jealously sniping at the different types of IT qualifications. Start working towards what will help you and try hard to gain every shred of experience possible. All of it helps!! If you don't like your company or your managers, make yourself attractive and get another job!

by ordinarysoul

I'm just curious. Does anybody wonder what happened to the smart people that were once in IT? What happened to them? Where did they all go?

by too old for it

... pounded them into a new patch of ground they could call thier own, and formed their own business.

Might be computer repair, might be consulting, might be selling old books or a coffee shop tho.

by sgawron

Does the term "burned out" ring a bell?

Does the concept of too many nights spent in the office trying to get the latest directive implemented mean something to you?

If you want to attract top talent, you only get what you pay for. I know plenty of highly skilled IT workers who are frustrated by the compartmentalization of our industry. To demonstrate competence you must have 12 of 12 requirements. This is pathetic. The bright stars in IT were always the ones willing to learn more about their field, not the ones who accumulated certifications and degrees. If you want 12 of 12 requirements, you had better open yourself to a bidding war.

Anyone who has spent time in IT knows that a certification is obsolete within a year of its issue. How about a "certified IT Learner", that would be a valuable certificate!!!

Steve

by htos1

Well,@ my location it's more like the bench guys are maybe 19-21 years old,and us network guys are 40+,a really good balance and we get along great.The bench like it when I discuss techniques with a deep electronics background,something they haven't had time to develop-especially importatnt when we live in Florida with its' lightning dangers.Everyone here is allowed to stand or fall on their merits and idiots would have a hyper-short tenure.

by bodhione

I experience the idiocy of some IT people daily. I am currently a laid off Probation Officer in Illinois and attend Net Admin classes at a local college. I frequently have contact with IT people who can't tell me what the acronym SMTP means, etc. These guys have 45-50K/year jobs and I can't get anyone to hire me when I admit I know little and would flourish with some on the job training and real world scenarios. I have a college education in another disipline and am willing to pay my dues to learn, but mgmt. would rather have someone who claims they can do the stuff while they cram over the info every night before going to work. I'm not willing to lie about my competencies so it leaves me in the dust even though I have a very strong interest.

by john

This seems to me to be merely a rant, and unworthy of this forum as I have come to know it.

There are good eggs and bad eggs everywhere you go. I think the members have taken this in a good direction by pointing out the underlying flaw in coorporate IT strategy, that flaw being the lack of funding that is so often found.

Another good point is the problems with the NZQA, which according to research seems to be doing a pretty good job of running off qualified professionals by failing to recognize (pay for) credentials that individuals obtained elsewhere other than NZ. However, I don't live there so I am not directly effected.

However, you can't just say "IT in such-and-such a place (country) are idiots!" Generalizations such as this serve to discredit the IT industry as a whole.

-John

by acsmith

Sorry to interupt the rants but since NZQA accreditation appears to be New Zealand specific does someone want to enlighten the rest of the world with the details?

by Member 25348569

And discovered that the New Zealand Qualifications Authority doesn't appear to recognise an MA from Oxford University. I gave up reading about them after that - life's too short.

Still, NZ's got nice scenerey. Shame there's no more Lord of the Rings films to make so we'll probably forget all about NZ again.

by bweber

My experience leads me to conclude that one must have either a degree or be very talented to succeed. Even with talent, a degree will definitely help. But, it is possible to succeed without the degree if you have the talent. I am a senior system architect and doing very nicely with out a degree. I also have over 15 years C++ experience. At my current level, a degree would not help me. I can demonstrate my work ethic and experience without one. That being said, I would have dearly loved a degree when trying to move up to my first lead programmer role. Instead, I had to donate many 100 hours weeks to overcome my lack of formal education.

by sgawron

Some previous replies have implied that it is who you know not what you know that gives you access to management.

For years, we in IT have been accused of talking 'geek-speak' which upper management needs translators. Fred Luthan's published a white paper indicating that 80% of managers are considered successful by networking their way to the top. Only 30% of all managers were considered effective. (i.e. making time and budget considerations for projects) The 'idiots', indicated here, are persons who excel in translating 'geek' into 'manager-speak'.

Luthan's implies that only 10% of successful managers are both networked and effective.

This implication applies to all management and not just IT. If IT is going to get a 'place at the table' with upper management, we need to be better at conveying why what we do in IT and how we benefit the organization on the whole. Not just at the management level, but at every opportunity to explain it to senior management and the people outside of IT.

I'm glad I got that off my chest.

Steve Gawron

by glenvdb

H.R are the biggest idiots when it comes to hiring good IT personnel. Most H.R people are looking for certain "Keywords" on the resume and could not care less about hiring a "good" IT person.
I recently was in negotiations with a MAJOR computer manufacture (I wont say the name, but it has 4 letters and the last 2 are LL) for both a help desk , and an IT position. The HR person had no Idea what i was talking about when I mentioned their products that I had worked on. I have over 10 years as a consultant in the IT field and have worked on all major networks, built and serviced machines and such, but because I have not "worked" at a company, that they can call the HR department, I have no verifiable experience and am not hirable as a long term employee. They don't consider the 100 of man hours I do researching the latest hardware and software or the thousands of machines I have built and service for the last 10 years. It just comes down to my papers.

by richards_unsubcribe

Sadly, it's not what you know it's who you know that gets the big account... this is the same as why we techies seem to get all the idiot managers... they might not know much but they do know that to get anywhere they hafta get their noses brown.

We have to market out ideas and ourselves... and be proactive in the workplace. If something isn't working say so and document it. Be firm... if X antivirus isn't working, document it and ask for a different brand... if everything is limping along ... suggest a better way.. and do it in writing.

Talk is cheap... action commands attention.

Unfortunatly that brown nosing manager will be quick to blame everyone but himself when the proverbial shi*t hits the fan after a major failure or security breach.

So you have to protect yourself... if your having trouble be professional... mention it in a memo... then letter... then by letter with copies to "higher ups" and so on... If your working in a poisoned work environment.. time to get the heck out.. start sending out those resume's (or CV's) while your still working.

Richard in Canada

by tb_tempest

I am almost finished with my degree attending college part time and I have to say that I see alot of people everyday that are working tword a Computer Science degree demonstrate barely any work ethic beyond showing up for class. Alot of the people in my classes are happy to see a B or C by the end of the semester. I have listened to students complain that they have no need to know hex and watched professors time and again attempt to get the students involved in the learning experience. About the only thing these people want is a piece of paper so they can collect a paycheck and I cant help but think that these are the last people in the world I would ever want to have working for or with me.

by sgawron

Outsourcing has severly depleted entry-level persons with an IT-knowledge. It is cheaper to hire an IT guy in Mumbai than to find a qualified candidate in the country where you are.
The problem is that outsourcing has been oversold to upper management. What good is a PhD in IT, when you do not have the infrastructure to apply a company's technology and enough knowledgable personnel to staff the project.

Our next great crisis will be that persons like you are no longer in IT. Entry-level requirements will be at a minimum an MCSE or B.S. in Information Technology. Anyone who has gone through the academic route knows that most college IT departments are 10 or more years behind the technology curve. The best way to learn a company's technology is to wade into the IT pond and role up your sleeves. How will this happen when the pond has moved half way around the world?

I will get off my soap box for now.

Steve

by banyangod

Well here in the states, about 7 to 8 years ago if you knew how to turn on your computer you could get an position in IT.

The market exploded and there was a vast need to fill positions. There definetly seemed to be an incredible demand and a small supply. Which is why I am sure that so many people went into IT.

I remember interviews for jobs, and being asked the most rudimentry of questions such as "How would you search for a file if you only knew the name of it?". After I answered the question the interviewer tells me I would be surprised at how many applicants did not know the answer.

I guess what I am getting at is that it seems to be just a phase the market is going through. Once cut backs start happening in IT, hopefully the incompetent people, will find themselves needing to look for something else to do. Unfortuneatly politics also plays a role.

by too old for it

"No one would every dream of telling a chef how to prepare a lunch for 500 people, a pilot how to fly a plane or mechanic how to remove a tranmission. But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?"

I'm posting this up in my cube ...

by coldeye

...Isn't money directly, or laziness, but one or both often are deeply involved. Many people in charge or making buying decisions don't know enough to make a good judgement, and they don't want to learn. So they start with the assumption that all solutions are probably equal, or the assumption that the Big Names got to be where they are because of their quality.

If all solutions are equal, then there's no reason to buy any but the cheapest.

If the Big Names got to where they are becauswe their quality exceeds all others, then as long as their price is tolerable, they are the best solution.

Either approach requires exceptionally little thought or learning, making the 'zecutive's rough life a little less complex.

by churdoo

I'm gonna try to stay on point of the initial subject, but let me apologize right now as I'm sure my post will be wordy.

"IS IT DEGENERATING INTO A FIELD WHERE IDIOTS RULE?"

In a word "YES!" or actually I think it's been a steady decline over the past 5 years, but for several reasons.

IT STAFF:
In any profession, there are good and bad; there are good cops and bad cops, good doctors and bad doctors, good mechanics and bad, etc. OF COURSE the same holds true for IT staff!

For some reason however, in my experience there are waaaaay too many people holding IT positions that have absolutely NO BUSINESS accepting money for touching a computer or network in any way! Whether it is as a consultant or as an employee, the percentage of incompetent IT people is higher than in any other industry, or maybe at least tied with auto mechanics.

Primadonnas to boot --
In addition to being incompetent, there is a huge subset of them that are primadonnas! They are not nearly as good as they think they are, but you can't convince them of that. They have bad attitudes, i.e. they don't understand that IT is a SERVICE organization whose responsibility is to HELP the business produce its product whatever product that is (yes sometimes in SPITE of the business)! Not only do they not help their customer/employer/etc. adequately, but they don't share information with each other, as if they are so insecure of their own ability that if they help their colleague, they will become threatened.

Poor Business Sense --
True also; a lot of IT staffers have poor business sense, and therefore make decisions that are based on other things and not necessarily in the best overall interest of sound business practices.

Communication --
Many but not all IT staffers are poor communicators.

Those are the main reasons that I believe that IT staff has contributed to the decline.

NON IT STAFF ...
"No one would every dream of telling a chef how to prepare a lunch for 500 people, a pilot how to fly a plane or mechanic how to remove a tranmission. But why does everyone who has read the "Chip Chat" section of the sunday paper think they have the answers and are more than willing to try and trump the IT guy at the next meeting?"

Hurray! jbartlett for your post above! Indeed for some reason, the rest of the world thinks that they have an insight into good IT practices and feels that they can second guess our recommendations, or even worse, ignore them completely!

"... Good with Computers ..."
If I had a dollar for each time I've heard someone tell me "my friend (so-and-so) is 'good with computers,' and he says ...," I would be island-hopping for the rest of my life because I wouldn't need to work.

Unfortunately, just like joe-consumer trying to find the right auto mechanic (no I'm not purposely trying to slam the auto mechanic industry, it's just that I think there are many similarities), anyway, the person making the hiring decisions oftentimes lacks the insight to know which candidate is the tech-wannabe and which is the real deal. Whether it's the non-qualified person hiring the IT manager, the non-qualified person hiring a tech employee, or the person hiring the outside consultant, if you can't separate the IT Men from the boyz, then there's a good chance the wrong selection will be made. After all, based on the law of percentages, if 2/3 of the candidates suck (I think this is a close estimate, and there are subsets of the industry that are worse, approaching 3/4 or even 4/5 incompetent) and the person making the decision is not qualified to make the decision, then there's a good chance that the wrong candidate will be selected.

It's simply too easy for the wannabe that's "good with computers" to talk a good game and BS his way into convincing the poor unsuspecting unqualified decision maker into making the wrong decision.

We good ones, the IT Men as it were, have plenty of work to do with the clients or employers that have the sense (or the luck) to select us; we leave those who make the wrong decisions for the bottom feeder wannabes because there simply aren't enough of us to go around!

by sgawron

Having been in IT management for a while, I have found that experience trumps education in IT.

A person with a degree often feels they deserve to be treated better than someone without one. Persons without degrees have an incentive to prove themselves and tend to be self-motivated.

I have spent 25+ years in IT and have recently completed a Master's in Management and Organizational Behavior at one of the top schools in the US for that field. I have done several studies in my degree work and have discovered research that supports my supposition.

A degree is no guarantee of success. Only dedication and persistence overcome the obstacles that a career in IT presents.

I would be glad to share my views with you off-line, if you are so inclined.

Steve Gawron
sgawron@bigfoot.com

by amcol

I don't do anything offline. Anything worth doing is worth doing in the light of day.

Plus, I agree with most of what you say. My differences with your position are minor...I've known just as many people with degrees as without who suffer from diva complex and think, for whatever reason, they're something special. I also know just as many degreed professionals as self-taught ones who are highly motivated.

While I'm sure there's statistical evidence correlating degrees with PITA (Pain In The Ass) Syndrome, a condition that often manifests itself in low motivation (I have a degree, therefore I'm great, and since my greatness is self evident even to the casual observer I need not work hard to prove it), I also believe there are other causal correlations that have nothing to do with degrees.

This is a fascinating topic. Why don't you start a thread about it? We can all learn something.

by sgawron

Glen,

I agree. I have found that many HR departments are staffed by HR types rather than a technology person with a talent for hiring IT people.

They (HR) are also at the disadvantage of cutting their most senior HR people when G&A cuts are dictated by upper management. Thus removing people who might understand the company's technology needs in favor of someone who is cheaper. In many cases, 're-engineering' results in 'de-engineering' putting that company at a disadvantage.

A friend of mine once told me: "People work, systems don't". He explain that even the best systems will fail without the personnel who understand how to use it.

Steve

by sgawron

Hi Tink,

I would rather hire someone with your qualifications than a half-dozen newly minted B.S. Info. Services degrees.

Steve

by maldain

The problem isn't the head of IT it's managment listening and nodding at what's being said and then ignoring it because effective IT services cost money. And the board, CEO and COO are only concerned with costs when looking at budgets. The only way around this is to make IT services pay for play. In other words, the departments that consume IT resources have to pay the costs of those resources. For instance marketing here has a tendancy to ship big files around they would get charged for managment of those files as well as per incident fees. While it's something of a shell game it does make the point to the end user departments that IT needs to be adequately funded.

A similar point can be made by tracking and costing out resources for the various departments represented on the commitee then presented to them in the form of a bill (we used that a year ago and the results were very good). It is a sales and marketing issue and we need to sell our services to our customers who happen to be internal but they are still customers. We on the other hand need a customer service attitude which is helping people rather than clearing problems.