The Taliban is the creation of Pakistan's I.S.I., Inter-Services Intelligence agency, Pakistan's military state-within-a-state. You know how everybody spins ludicrous consipiracy theories about the C.I.A. and Israel's Mossad, the intelligence agencies that live beyond the law and seem to control everything? Out in the Hindu Kush, that's what the I.S.I. tries to be. They can't decide whether they're Pakistani nationalists or Allah-besotted jihadists. They try to be both. The Paki government is scared to hell by the I.S.I. and everything else it can't control, and cheerfully goes about trying to appease any force that seems like it might contest the sovereign government, were it angry enough. Hey, and also, they don't actually govern that quarter of their country adjoining Afghanistan; they just wave a flag over it. Nearsightedness seems to be a medical qualification for Pakistani politicians.
So, what to do about the Afghan war, when our strong right arm is an inveterate screwup? We have to be clear about our aims, and not get distracted by the Pakis. Except the atomic bomb part, which they have. That piece requires extra precautions, but it must not drive all of American policy.
This is a really complex mess, where politics constrain the military side. The military side is where we really have to work hard, like, bombing the Paki side of the border when we have to. But we should not carelessly bomb households along the border simply to save American soldiers' lives; this may seem unnatural to USA patriots, but we owe it to our mission to pretend Pakistani and Afghan civilian lives actually are important to us.
We shouldn't stop bombing and killing, and bribing the survivors, because this is an important thing and losing it would be costly to western civ.
Here are a couple of thoughtful links:
http://www.slate.com/id/2200134/
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3724/is_/ai_n27994317
In case this reads a little incoherently, please note it is Saturday cocktail hour, and I have been working on the Wild Turkey, pate, and cornichons, and going back for more of the bourbon.