Discussion Locked

Is Jessica Lynch - A Hero - Coward - or Just Stupid

0 helpful
157 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Has anyone read any of her Autobio - by the NYT's reporter. Just finished the first few chapters - and now she is saying she wasn't scared - the doctors took excellent care of her - she wasn't raped ..

Is this women just a typical West Virg Hillbilly - Dumb as a Bag of Rocks - A true Hero, saying what actually happened - a Coward - A Fool -

Anyone else read her BS - line - which is the turth - her live interviews or her story in the book ...

Just another Dumb as a Bag of Rocks - West Virg -

157 replies

by dbertsche

Watched part of the Sawyer interview with her last night and she said she was scared which I think would be very understandable. I see her as a survivor which is what she said on the interview.

She didn't see herself as a hero and stated the same. She also stated her weapon jammed (typical problem with the M16)so she really didn't have any means to fight. I wouldn't describe her as a coward, just a scared young girl.

Having been in a combat zone (Viet Nam) anyone who says they're not scared is either lying or a fool.

I don't think I would categorize her as dumb, the interview implied she had led a somewhat sheltered life before going into the Army so I just don't think she has had a lot of life experiences.

Cut her some slack as she wound up in a situation that was not anticipated and remember her unit was not an actual combat unit so she and her fellow soldiers were not prepared at all for what they went through.

by jimhm

Yes she is - but being used and abused by the Media.

I said stupid / dumb for permitting the Autobio by a NewYork Times (Liberal) author, which she should of known was going to slant it. And now somehow - the Prince of Prono (Penthouse) has nude photo's of her? How many more things is this girl going to step in? In the book she saids they didn't need all those guys to rescue her... Last night she said that the numbers were justified because they didn't know what they were coming into.

Coward, we took care of our weapons and put a rubber over the mussle of it. Also kept the weapon clean. And scared shitless "YES" many times made that talk with God during a good hot fire fight. Anyone that says that aren't scared are fools or liers or nuts. My question, she never fired a round so how did the other 11 members of her team get killed or die?

I am not blaming her for being used by the media (she young, seen money, and lived in Wva) but she needs to answer some questions - The clamed (which is possible) loss of memory from time of initial attack until 3 hours later, so the military needs to investage. Yes, fire fights and protecting each other is scary - but my question is what happened to her brothers and sisters in that company? How was she the only survivor - with a jammed weapon and the Iraqi's killed the others?

by dbertsche

Jim,

According to the interview when the convoy came under attack and our people were shooting back at the Iraqis, the senior NCO realized they were outmanned and outgunned at some point. He ordered the vehicle that 5 of them (including Lynch who was in the middle of the back seat) to run. The driver sped up but wound up crashing into a truck that was apparently stopped in the desert. The impact of the crash crushed the NCO who was in front. The driver (indian lady) was hurt seriously and eventually died in a hospital. One of the remaining two was either hit by a round or injured in the crash and bled out. I don't remember exactly if the other guy was shot or killed by the wreck. Lynch apparently hit her head during the crash and blacked out and only came to in the hospital. She's probably extremely lucky that she wasn't killed. It's likely if an Iraqi had saw movement from the vehicle that she would have been killed.

Regarding the failure of the weapon to fire, It was apparent during the interview that prior to this event happending the maintenance vehicles were attempting to catch up to the regular troops and running virtually non stop. She had been driving another vehicle when it became unoperable. She left this vehicle and got in another one so if it was her specific weapon it was exposed to the elements for at least a few minutes. It was not revealed in the interview if any other weapons had failed. It's quite possible the weapon wasn't hers. Don't get me wrong, I was trained to make sure my weapon was always clean and things to do to protect it but there again I was in the kind of unit that required that. It's likely that since there's was a back element unit they never counted on being put in that situation, bad thinking on their part I suppose but I think the prime reason 11 people in our unit were killed was they were very much outnumbered and outgunned.

by dbertsche

Jim,

According to the interview when the convoy came under attack and our people were shooting back at the Iraqis, the senior NCO realized they were outmanned and outgunned at some point. He ordered the vehicle that 5 of them (including Lynch who was in the middle of the back seat) to run. The driver sped up but wound up crashing into a truck that was apparently stopped in the desert. The impact of the crash crushed the NCO who was in front. The driver (indian lady) was hurt seriously and eventually died in a hospital. One of the remaining two was either hit by a round or injured in the crash and bled out. I don't remember exactly if the other guy was shot or killed by the wreck. Lynch apparently hit her head during the crash and blacked out and only came to in the hospital. She's probably extremely lucky that she wasn't killed. It's likely if an Iraqi had saw movement from the vehicle that she would have been killed.

Regarding the failure of the weapon to fire, It was apparent during the interview that prior to this event happending the maintenance vehicles were attempting to catch up to the regular troops and running virtually non stop. She had been driving another vehicle when it became unoperable. She left this vehicle and got in another one so if it was her specific weapon it was exposed to the elements for at least a few minutes. It was not revealed in the interview if any other weapons had failed. It's quite possible the weapon wasn't hers. Don't get me wrong, I was trained to make sure my weapon was always clean and things to do to protect it but there again I was in the kind of unit that required that. It's likely that since there's was a back element unit they never counted on being put in that situation, bad thinking on their part I suppose but I think the prime reason 11 people in our unit were killed was they were very much outnumbered and outgunned.

by road-dog

I have maintained and fired the m16 in temperatures from minus 20 degrees to 120 degrees F. When properly maintained, this weapon doesn't fail.

Units describing problems with the weapon either are not training their personnel properly or have
incompetent armorers.

Their weapon jams are almost certainly due to known causes, such as a simple alignment of three gas rings which must be placed with openings not together. When placed improperly, they cause excessive bleed of blowback gas that causes the bolt housing group to fail to fully cycle and the fired round to be not ejected.

This is inexcusable in a maintenance unit.

If this were a Marine unit, all weapons in the unit would be inspected and those failing to follow basic maintenance procedures would be fined. To improperly maintain your weapon and cause your own death is a waste of two pieces of government property....

by fluxit

I served in Arabian Gulf and there is problem with airborn granular particulates as much as 50 miles to sea. I never had an M16 to maintain but my aircraft were constantly in repair for damage caused by this particulate dust. Tips of rotors destroyed, AOA indicators clogging, and sandblasting effects on the leading edges and painted surfaces. It was not uncommon to have this dust blowing over the flight deck. In fact, we had an out and out sand storm 50 miles to sea. it was in everything.

So I can see how an M16 or other equipment could jam. As far as the battle tactics when in combat that is part of warfighting. Those soldiers should have been trained and thier leadership should know how to defend his people. Whether they group and defend a point or disperse and become more offensive is a call the on-scene commander should have made. To me they were not properly trained.

The accounts I heard were kind of scary like everyone was just racing around at will. No communication. No leadership. Combat contact should be a well practiced feat. These guys should have been cool and confident. Instead, they appeared to be a bunch of misfits tossed into a chaotic situation with no guidance or training. For that I fault, the Army and thier leadership.

The Profession Of Arms is about people. Failure to realize this is a serious serious fault of our leadeship.

by donnysan

Yes she survived the ordeal - that makes her a survivor. That, however, is as far as I am willing to go. I do believe her rifle would not fire, because if you don't pull the trigger it just doesn't do the job you carry it for. True, she didn't direct her unit to make a wrong turn and yes she did survive. For that you have to give her some credit, but she also did nothing to distinguish herself as a "Hero". This word is being used so much now that it is loosing its value. It sounds to me that everyone that did or did not die on 9/11 is a hero. A dangerous job does not make you a hero. Being in the wrong place at the wrong time does not make you a hero. Being a hero (or not) is determined by what you do (or don't do) when the chips are down. When you throw the term around, like so many people do now, you trivialize it and take away from those FEW that really deserve the title. She was in the wrong place at the wrong time and survived ? let?s just leave it at that. That is the credit she deserves.

by fluxit

Jessica is being used as an icon for numerous agendas. The US Government's desire to recognize soldiers for thier hard earned efforts. The News media for someone to lift up. The local community as thier part in something bigger than life. Hollywood for thier desire to exploit something for profit. In many ways we are seeing the worst of America that may be stemming from the purest intent - Jessica's desire to defend the American Way.

All this probably has the woman dazed and confused. The NYT's book probably has a creative license just as Hollywood used thier creative license in thier movie. When Jessica was interviewed we probably heard from her. This is most likely exposes the media for what they are - HYPE and SPIN. Or didn't someone coined the term shock and awe?

by jkaras

Anyone who actually fought in or participated in combat whom either lived or died for the cause is a hero in my book. This is coming from a person who couldnt go into the service due to the loss of control that I would have to willfully die for an objective knowing full well the tactic. I knew I couldnt follow that kind of order or even make that order. These people that can do this are extremly brave people that have my respect vs. people that joined the service but was never apart of combat or assisted combat. They served but didnt protect so they dont qualify as hero but it doesnt tarnish their service, they were just lucky to be apart when hell didnt break loose.
As for Jessica Lynch she survived an attack that wasnt her fault, she didnt take the wrong turn or make the decision to be far apart from support. I do believe her gun jammed or she couldnt take a life when it came time to kill, I've never experienced that decision so I wont think less of her.
The media and the government used her as a rally cry that got alot of people behind a war that they didnt fully support. She just happened to be the first known female hostage that generated alot of hype. The truth is she was a hostage, she saw people she cared about killed like a soldier and exectuted like a crimminal, as well as a loss of privacy that she definetly wants to put behind her. The media made a lot of money on her misery and she really didnt cash to much in. I saw clips of the soldier thats complaining that why isnt he a hero, where's his payday? HE isnt a hero, he didnt rescue her, he was led to her not knowing anything till they found her. He should be proud that he was apart of rescuing a comrade from the enemy that signifys that his involvement in battle not only took life but saved life, which is what honor is defined. He tarnishs it by complaining. Jessica is the pretty girl vs the other woman who was taken prisioner being not as good looking. Nobody knows her name, see didnt get any payday. I didnt like the rape hype that the tv was lying about when competing for ratings vs the Elizabeth Smart story, truly sad and schameful.

by maxwell edison

I think many things about Jessica Lynch:

I think she's being used by the media to increase their ratings.

I think she's being used by publishers to sell books.

I think she's being used (at least initially was being used) by the government propaganda machine to sell the public on the war. (They really didn't have to.)

I think she's willing to be used, however, to receive the big $$$,$$$.$$ from the aforementioned media sources. (Not to mention the life-long disability payments for her injuries.)

I think what she did and went through pales in comparison to what many other soldiers have gone through.

I think her story is proof that women don't belong in combat roles.

by thechas

Max, I could not have said it better.

I fully agree with all of your above statements.

She is a willing pawn. Doing her best to capitalize on her 15 minutes of fame.

Chas

by wordworker

I think it's pretty bad taste to assail this young lady and call her names. Jim I'm guessing you never were in the military, eh? With all respect, if I were you, I wouldn't go around calling Jessica names in front of past/present military people. It's a far-reaching fraternity/sorority, and I for one feel the need to defend her on based on one thing and one thing only: She swore an oath when she signed up for the services, and from what I can tell, no matter what else has happened, she upheld that oath, and for that she deserves our respect, imho.

by jimhm

First - I did my 4 years (not 2 year draft) and my 365 in country 72 .. so I have been there - seen that - killed that - so speak not sir of what I have and haven't seen or done in my life. And Yes I have walked the talk for 365... how about you ... can you say the same...

Second - I ask the simple question -

A fool - for being used by the Media and government?

A Coward - Never fired her weapon and was the only one of 11 staffer to survive the fire fight. I ask how without fireing a shot?

A Hero - because she survive 90 days in captivity...

You read her story - its very different that what she is speaking during the live interviews... Interesting which one is she ...

Is she permitting herself to be used for the $$$$'s - or is she just dumb as a bag of rocks.

by wordworker

I did my time in the Army '81-87, thank you for asking. I usually agree with you, Jim, but I guess I can't see anything productive coming out of bashing PFC Lynch... She's hopefully doing the very best she can with the resources available to her. I daresay if people with buckets of money lined up outside your door or mine, we'd probably authorize a movie or do a book deal, too.

by mrbill-

I believe JimH is one of our forgotten Vets, Nam? for which he has my deepest respect. I came in right after that era of the armed forces, and there were plenty of those ?older? guys around to get a feeling of what they went through.

If you have never had anyone shooting at you, you have no idea what went on in Jessica?s head. I have not followed this story as close as I should have I guess, but I wasn?t there so I can?t say anything.

I do wish he would stop slamming WV folks, sure they may be a bit back woodsy but don?t call them stupid. My Mom?s family came from that area so please be kind.

by jimhm

Sorry if it came across as disrespecting those from Wva - Pretty Country - Nice down home folks - Kind of meaning to say - it aint big city stuff so I understand how the glamor and dollars could turn her head... all the media hype ... all the attention ...

My appologies - to all the Wva folks - maybe I should of used the word - Naive or inexperienced or green - rather than stupid ... Again my appologies..

by jimhm

April 2 ? Army Pfc. Jessica Lynch's family is on cloud nine over her rescue from Iraqi captors, but they're still praying for the other missing soldiers who were in her unit. (16 other members of her outfit).

In his morning briefing from Central Command in Qatar, Brig. Gen. Vincent Brooks showed video of U.S. troops carrying Jessica Lynch on a stretcher to a waiting helicopter after she was rescued in a daring raid at a hospital in the south-central Iraqi town of Nasiriyah.

She had been held as a prisoner of war since her unit, the 507th Maintenance Company, was attacked by Iraqis on March 23.

Lynch was reported missing when her unit's convoy was ambushed near Nasiriyah. She was not among the five soldiers whose faces were shown on Iraqi television after the capture, and the military had officially listed her status as unknown.

The fate of the other soldiers who were captured in Lynch's unit remains unclear. Five of them, some apparently wounded, were displayed on Iraqi state television, along with the bodies of some dead service members, provoking intense anger from U.S. officials. A total of 16 U.S. service members are still listed as missing.

Acting on an intelligence tip about Lynch's whereabouts, U.S. special operations forces slipped behind enemy lines and seized Lynch from the Saddam Hospital under cover of darkness
Tuesday, military officials said.

The rescue operation included Marines, Navy SEALs, Army Rangers and Air Force pilots and combat controllers. Those involved in the operation also recovered 11 bodies during Lynch's rescue, according to military officials.

by maxwell edison

.
Summer 2001:
Jessica Lynch, an 18 year old who just graduated from High School, joined the Army to "see the world", or so she said. The fact that jobs were extremely scarce in West Virginia at the time may have had some (perhaps a lot of) bearing on her decision to join the Army. But to put things in perspective, many such people join the service as a way to make a break from their parents, so to speak, and to get some training that could, perhaps, give them that "experience" to later find a job. Moreover, I think it's fair to say that in the summer of 2001, the prospects of the United States being involved in a major conflict, where soldiers would really have to fight, was probably perceived by most to be somewhere between slim and none.

September 11, 2001:
The world changed. The mission of the United States military changed. The prospects of being involved in a "real war" went from unlikely to imminent.

October 2001:
The first phase of America's war on terrorism took United States' troops (and others) to Afghanistan.

November 2001:
Jessica Lynch completed basic training at Fort Jackson, South Carolina.

December 2001:
Jessica Lynch was assigned, as her first duty station, to the Army's 507th Maintenance Company at Fort Bliss, Texas. The 507th Maintenance Company is a support unit charged with supplying mechanics who repair the Patriot missile trucks.

January 2003:
The 507th Maintenance Company, along with private Lynch, was shipped to Kuwait to support the pending war in Iraq.

March 20, 2003:
Iraq war started. However, Private Lynch was in a rear-guard unit, one that never expected to be close to the fighting.

March 23, 2003:
Private Lynch was among a dozen soldiers with a U.S. Army supply convoy in Iraq that "took a wrong turn" and inadvertently found themselves in the middle of a war. Some were killed, and some, including Private Lynch, were captured. She was injured, by the way, in a crash of the truck in which she was riding. The truck was fleeing the deep doo-doo in which they stumbled upon. Some of her fellow prisoners were shown (paraded) on Iraqi Television.

April 2, 2003:
Private Lynch was rescued from an Iraqi hospital by U.S. troops. The rescue was filmed, and part of the film was released to the American public. Some though it was a shallow public relations ploy. Some claimed it was filmed for training and documentation purposes. Some suggested that the "danger" aspect of the rescue was somewhat exaggerated. Nonetheless, Private Lynch instantly became the media sensation story of the day.

Subsequently:
Speculation and stories, some true, some false, but all sensationalized, were running amok. Who knew what "really happened"?

Currently:
Television talk-shows, news magazines, and headlines. And, of course, the six-figure book deal and the "made for television" movie deal.

What can be learned:
Women don't belong in combat roles.

by cactus pete

Max-

Not that I'm agreeing or disagreeing, but how does what you posted teach anyone that women in the military is wrong? I'm just not following your details to the conclusion you stated.

by guruofdos

No-one of any importance then! Just another 'dumb' squaddie in the wrong place at the wrong time who happened to grab some media attention.

Having worked (and am still working) on various US Army training 'projects' in Germany, Kosovo, Bosnia and Iraq (from whence I have just returned...hence long time - no Guru debate participation!) I can unfortunately only arrive at one conclusion:

The majority of US service men (and women) in the US Army are there for one of two reasons.

a) Because no-one else will employ them.

b) Because it was the only way they could stay out of jail.

by fluxit

General Krulak spoke about having a variety of principles tattooed to one's soul. What we may be seeing is her tattoo. She does not appreciate being used in books, news media, and other hype channels. Alleged nude pictures of her have been bought. Its amazing Larry Flint actually has moral values by not releasing them? Folks we may be in a new era. Fellow troops are smitting her. Her integrity has been impuned.

She had simple aspirations of being a school teacher who had a sense of duty then desired to return to her humble origins. This is the character our forefathers saw in people. Perhaps what we are seeing is a real patriot that we sort of lost sight of over the years.

Can you imagine a school teacher imparting imparting these kind of values in our youth? Instead of the radical left wing of the NEA Nazi's we have running public schools today.

by maxwell edison

I don't think that she's a hero - except in the sense that ALL G.I.s are heroes for giving some years of their lives to serve their country, some for noble reasons, some for "other" reasons. Did anyone see that TV show on PBS last night (or perhaps some other night) on the Medal of Honor and those who were awarded the medal? All words are (or can be) relative, and using the word "hero" to describe Jessica Lynch is a bit overkill when compared to the "heroes" who were awarded the Medal of Honor.

I don't think she's a coward. I think she's (she was) probably a frightened young girl WAY out of her element, and she found herself in some circumstances that were something other than what she imagined when she joined the Army. She joined the Army in the summer of 2001, before 9-11, and before any indications that the Army would really be fighting in a real war.

I don't think she's stupid. If she is, I should be so stupid for bringing in all those $$$$$$$$$.

I'm not crazy about your "dumb" and "West Virginia" characterization. Just like I'm not crazy about the "arrogant American" characterizations thrown around by others.

by jimhm

As I said before I appologized to those folks from WVa. - my choice of words was wrong.

As for the hero - yes all service personal are hero's -

The Media has labeled her a Hero - and she has continued to say she is not one, and that the Army Rangers, Navy Seals, Air Force were the Hero's that rescued her from her fate. Brovo for that Jessica.

But I am reading her book - which has raised a number of questions in my mind. What she said in interviews is different that what is quoted in the book. Didn't she have editoral rights - didn't she read the book prior to being published.

She is learning a hard lesson in life, and I do feel for her and her family. That is that everything you do in life can come back and get you. Letting others photograph her nude may of been fun at the time, but now look at the cost. That is a painful lesson to learn in life. And suprise Larry Flint is being human about it - Now thats a big suprise - "Doing what is right, not what will make him money."

Also - Other army personal are asking the same questions I have asked - What happened to her brothers and sisters, the media isn't saying anything, she hasn't said very much about it.

It is only right to remember the other 5 MIA's and 11 Bodies they returned with her rescue. Lets not forget the Fallen - who truty gave their all and the families of those fine men and women! Let us not forget - the dead!

by oz_media

May be looking for customer appreciation. He is apparently looking at buying Penthouse from teh piss poor broke Bob Guccione. it would be in Larry's best interests to have the public on his side right now. If he buys a sinking ship, he better have public suport for his efforts.

As always, there is something behind every media move. That's what the media is for, playing and swaying the public. It used to be despised by the rich and famous but I've seen first hand (as an artist development manager) how some bad press can be the start of great things to come.

Look at Madonna, if it weren't for her controversial and often politically incorrect statements and stage antics, she would be unheard of by now. She is a phenominal actresss that can play the media as well as they THINK they are playing her. Except she's the one making money.

I won't go into detail but this is what I see when a politician takes his stand, BS for the media and public to feed on , not Truth, Justice and The American Way.

I'm sure the book was written with the same approach, I haven't and probably will never read the JL story but it goes without saying that it must be somewhat colored to fill an entire book on this woman's life.

Everything else shiny and sparkly is these days, why not her story. Who wants to read about someone who was captured, scared shitless, treated properly and then rescued. It's just not the All American story that would sell.

I say give her credit for what she is and what she was doing. She is a soldier, she was defending her coutry (or so she was told I'm sure), that's it. Not a hero, not a coward, not a liar, a human being.

Funny how it has taken the focus away from all else that has been going awry in Iraq lately though.

by dbertsche

Regarding Larry Flynt, if he was really as decent a guy as he's trying to portray himself he would have just kept his mouth shut. Even though he chose not to publish pictures there is a certain amount of embarassment to Lynch just by him coming out and saying he had such items. Granted she probably shouldn't have engaged in such an activity but Larry is no saint!

by road-dog

The leading edge of helo blades and wing surfaces are a far cry from the inner workings of the M16 rifle.

The aircraft surfaces are exposed to high velocity wind where they get sandblasted. Sensors and intakes that ingest air can be fouled and abraded by the particulates carried at high speed.

Rifles collect grit through dust settling on lubricated surfaces. These surfaces must be kept free of excessive CLP (cleaner, lubricant, protectant), otherwise grit turns into clogging & abrasive paste.

One must resist the temptation to solve grit in the works through application of CLP, or the problem only gets worse.

I blame insufficient training and failure of NCOs to properly prepare these folks for operations in the sand. There are a lot of senior enlisted people who served in the Gulf War that should have passed this important experience on to the newbies. As is, every troop heading into "indian country" should have his gear checked by NCOs checking that their equipment is in good working order....

by oz_media

Jessica was on a radio interview this morning, she was quite upset that she is being portayed as a hero.
She said "It's not like I went down while firing at the enemy". She apparently just cowered and didn't know quite what to do, before she knew it, she was being captured.

She also mentioned another lady (sorry I didn't catch the name) who was caught up in a similar situation but fired on her attackers, escaped and was recovered by American military. This woman has never really been in the press, which Jessica feels is because she is African-American.

She went on to say that the other woman is much more of a hero than she is.

What I don't understand is why Jessica is considered a hero (other than the fact that she is fighting for her country of course)yet those that went in on a covert night op and rescued her were given their medals and pretty much nothing more is said?!

I am not hoing to say she is a coward, she isn't and any accusation of such is very immature.

Her place of residence is also not a reason to defame her. Her intelligence is not at question here, it doesn't matter how smart you are, you can still be killed or captured in the battlefield.

Coward ? Fool?
If you have served in the military (which I believe you have)I am very surprised to hear you call a fellow soldier a coward or a fool.
Is this becuase you WEREN'T in a similar situation and therefore feel you did better?
Do you think you would have acted differently? If so, how and why do you feel you would have acted differently?

When you are with your fellow soldiers, you have a sense of power and moral. This helps retract the fear of being at war or at least make it bearable. When you find all your brothers dead beside you and the enemy is in your face, do you REALLY think you'd have the same sense of power and control?

I doubt it, but as I haven't been in that specific situation, I simply can't say how I'd react.

I see her as a hero, as I would ANYONE who is at war for their country. I don't think she wanted it this way, it wasn't pre-meditated, it is how the media has jumped on the story when there was nothing new to report, and what a job they did.

So why don't we all look at the media and say they are dumb as a bag of hammers instead?

by jimhm

It appears - that she lacked the training to defend herself, and her fellow troops. In combat you rely on your bud to watch your back while you watch theirs.

Also - Your post was the first I have heard of any of her comrades fates, nothing in the media concerning that. And yes, if you are asking - Its a time and place I don't enjoy going back to - but I have been a life taker - its not pleasent memories there were however many good times, life long friends that were made.

The Army's training appears to have failed her.

by oz_media

I understand that you are taight to watch each others backs. Reports I've heard say that her comrades were killed in action. Are you implying that because she lived and didn't fire her weapon, her comrades dies because she wasn't doing her job and watching their backs?

It is possible, I wouldn't know, that her training was inadaquate because of the short time she was enlisted? Is it not possible that she was not properly prepared for combat, either by her officers or a lack of training in fighting terrorists? I don't know, so I'm asking you who anyone else that may know more.

I assume, but again may be quite wrong, that you would be someone who feels women should not be in battlefield conditions?

How about we all just see it as this, instead of the over analyzing of her actions, this is a person who made the decision to fight for what she believed in, her freedom, and in the course of fighting for her freedom she was captured, her comrades were killed, she was alone, she was VERY scared (as any man or woman should be regardless of training)and was captured.

The American military then followed standard proceedure and attempted (successfully) to rescue her from the Iraqi Hospital. I don't see what the big deal is. The MEDIA made a mountain out of a molehill, as ususal, and she was caught up in the big hero's welcome and was bombarded by the MEDIA to share her story, which anyone who has ever made a statement to media reporters knows, will be construed as they feel fit.

In this case I think it is appropriate to blame the messenger not the message.

by fluxit

This movie showed the different kinds of people in combat quite well. Which one do you think Private Lynch was?

This also brings up another point. If you recall the female soldiers being interviewed at GTMO who were guarding the detainees. After several of the detainees insulted her and she was arguing back with then she suddenly realized in an epiphany that she was the guard. Is that a tribute to army training or case of the woman?

Could it be that the role of women is not to be the mother of all wars but mother of our nations future?

by oz_media

Don't know where you live (I assume Miami) but that's a pretty pig headed and chauvinistic statement.

Are you too old to realize that women actually don't have a 'role' anymore but can act just as anyone man does?
Or are you just too young to know better?

by oz_media

Bob's selling Penthouse after practically going broke. Last year he had his mansion for sale, this year he is sellnig $200 million in art (Picasso, Renoir, etc).

There is no confirmed buyer yet but interest has been expressd by Larry Flint as well as others.

Bye Bye, Bobby. Next time, keep up with customer demand.

by oz_media

Oh yes Max, the 20-30 years all over again. What a concept.

I thought many times about that actually. Some times I think I would have done things differently, but on those days when all is perfect, I look back and think 'I wouldn't change a single minute' (except losing my cat).

It is our past that makes us what we are today. Sure in hindsight we'd all be millionaires, actors, sailing the seven seas without a care in the world, but that's not reality.

reality is now and I don't think I'd change my past, as hard as it has seemed to be at times. Hard knocks have given me the strength to be who I am today, learning to fight has brought me my successes, learning from my past mistakes has made me the perfectionist I am today (OK you can ditch that last idea)but, as Popeye says, "I am what I am" today because of what I have been through to get here, this journey's been a rollercoaster but isn't that always the best ride in the park anyway?

by oz_media

I don't think nor ever had thought taht Larry Flint was a nice guy. He uses his power to get whatever he wants, he's flamboyant, he's tied in with who knows what and I'm sure he's exploited more than a few of his models to get what he wants.

the nottom line is he NEEDS to look good right now. He NEEDS the public on his side, and moreover he needs to be in the medias limelight.

He makes a statement, it gets plastered all over the news. He counters that statement, it gets plastered all over the news. Now people have his name in their minds once again, it must work because even WE are talking about him now. When was the last TR discussion regarding Larry Flint?

He is playing the media and the public. It's done daily, and another reason why I don't buy into press conferences and political news reports, they are just another avenue for the poiliticians to play the pubic through the media, except unlike a situation where someone is caught on the spot by a nosey camera, these are carefully planned and scripted reports with voice inflection, body language and even the color of the speakers tie meticulously crafted to achieve a specific result, Reagan wasn't a GREAT actor at all, he was an excellent politician though

by dbertsche

First off I swore I would never respond to one of your idiotic posts again but you apparently think I'm stupid. I never said Larry was a "nice guy" and full well understand why he did what he did. I said he was trying to portray himself as a nice guy, note no where do I say I think he's a nice guy, quite the contrary in my opinion. You state the obvious in talking about his relationship to media, the majority of us already know these things and know all about him and his tactics.

Leave it to you to get to talking about who started the war in Iraq, it always gets back to that with you doesn't it? We know exactly how you feel about the president of the U.S. Too bad you don't live here then you could vote for someone else but you don't live here so you have no say in the matter.

As far as starting the war, there wouldn't have been a war if the Iraqis had come clean as directed by the UN resolution, they had over ten years to do what they were suppose to do and the UN didn't have the balls to do anything about it, what else is new.

Of course you'll disagree with everything in this post and probably respond with your usual but so be it.

by oz_media

You said: "First off I swore I would never respond to one of your idiotic posts again but First off I swore I would never respond to one of your idiotic posts again but you apparently think I'm stupid"

>>I don't even remember talking to you, although I DO recognize the alias from TR. Juding by your hasty post and inaccurate conmments, I'd probably agree with your assumption though, "apparently think I'm stupid"

You then said: "I never said Larry was a "nice guy and full well understand why he did what he did"

>>Ok, so..... I didn't say that you thought he was nice. If so, can your show me where I said that you thought he was a nice guy?

You also said: "Leave it to you to get to talking about who started the war in Iraq, it always gets back to that with you doesn't it?"

>>Are you still reading THIS thread? If so, can you show me where I've said anything about "who started the war in Iraq"?

In fact if you ask me, YOU'RE the one assuming and then going on about the war in Iraq. Perhaps you're becoming too defensive due to all of your doubts and fears these days, LOL!

You stated, not me: "As far as starting the war, there wouldn't have been a war if the Iraqis had come clean as directed by the UN resolution, they had over ten years to do what they were suppose to do and the UN didn't have the balls to do anything about it, what else is new."

>>So your reason for starting war or keeping peace, is one has the balls to do it, the other doesn't? It doesn't take 'balls' to fight, it takes common sense not to though.
So if a country is passive and lives in peace, as we do in Canada, that means we're pussies, right?
Then why would you be striving for peace if that is such a bad thing?

by cactus pete

I'd bet that she was conjoled into the pictures by a boyfriend at the time. I doubt it was anything bad - as private affairs are just that.

I'd blame whoever sold the pics - I doubt it was Ms. Lynch.

by oz_media

If I had nude pics of an old girlfriend and was offered serious dough to sel them, I would.

Now you can spout imorality or how I'm an uncaring human being, but the bottom line is i'm just not afraid to admit to what MOST people would do in the same situation. Unless of course she was still a respected friend.

She F(&^#d up, bottom line. I personally would rather the focus being put on thiose that are still at war rather than someone who ws captured, rescued and now has become porn controversy.

You have to also ask, WHO CARES if she's in Playboy or ANY magazine for that matter. She's not the president, she's not a nun. he's a soldier. I don't see why this has become such a big deal, if it wasn't so publicized,I'm sure she wouldn't care. Perhaps she could take some newer pics and sell them herself? God knows, she could use the cash if relying on, military salary while away at war.

Once again, the onus is taken away from the person who STARTED this war and on to those who fought it to explain their actions. MEDIA

by maxwell edison

.
...has nothing to do with that particular timeline. I just wanted to throw that in.

I think there's a difference between men and women (duh!), and I think that war and the support of such is better suited for men. Call me a sexist, I don't care, but that's what I think.
However, it does illustrate how even a "rear guard" unit can inadvertently get directly involved in a war.

I mentioned earlier a PBS documentary on soldiers who were awarded the Medal of Honor. (Only one of whom, out of 3,000+ was a woman, by the way.) There was this one guy, an Army Sergeant, who was in a rear guard unit taking care of war orphans, of all things. The camp was overrun, he suddenly found himself in "deep doo-doo", and he acted in the most gallant way, saving the lives of fellow soldiers, killing scores of charging enemy soldiers before being captured and sent to the Hanoi Hilton.

The Medal of Honor versus this Jessica Lynch spectacle.

Conclusion: Women don't belong in combat roles.

by maxwell edison

.
I never said that women have no place in the military. I said they should be kept away from combat roles. (Or potential combat roles.)

by cactus pete

And I apologize for drawing the conclusion I did.

Still, I'm not seeing what you arguement for women not being in combat is. Obviously, yes, they're different. But are you saying that they are different at some fundamental level which keeps them from being effective soldiers in combat, or are you saying that the enemy would treat them differently, or something else all together?

by maxwell edison

Men are stronger. Men are better fighters. Men are more fearless - or can face their fears better. (That might get some arguments, but how many men versus women are afraid of mice?) Men can run faster, jump higher, and carry more weight on their backs. There are, of course, exceptions, but this is, for the most part, the rule.

If you had to fight, and I mean really fight, your way out of "deep doo-doo", would you rather have a man or a woman at your side?

When it comes right down to the real nitty-gritty, a soldier doesn't fight for his country or fight for a cause, but he fights to either stay alive or he fights for the guy next to him - for his Army buddy. The last two soldiers to be awarded the Medal of Honor (I think) were the two Army Rangers who went back in to rescue the pilot of "Black Hawk Down". They were both killed, but the pilot was rescued. I don't think the "Jessica Lynchs" of the world would have the strength - or the onions - to do something like that.

What if a Sgt. First Class Randy Shughart or a Master Sgt. Gary Gordon (Black Hawk Down) was in that truck instead of Jessica Lynch? Who would you rather have in that truck with you?

by tomsal

I see no point whatsoever is discrediting her reputation at all. She served in military, was shot at and was captured. Glad it wasn't me.

I never, not once, thought she was deserving the title hero. I thought it was quite humorous yet sad and pathetic at the same time when I heard that. Why? This country is so fast to label anyone a hero -- its really pathetic. If you get hurt, no matter what -- boom you are a hero. That's what is stupid.

From what I heard though she isn't saying what you said. On the local radio station she was quoted as saying she is no hero at all, she was scared out of her wits and she herself says she admits she doesn't know the fuss the media made of her.

Either way, I don't think we should be dragging her name their the mud.

by fluxit

those who fought in vietnam, Bay of Pigs, Korea, Grenada, Iran hostage situation etc...

Many of those people were never labelled heroes. In fact have you ever talked to someone who was at the bay of pigs or Iran Hostage raid? They seem to be aweful quiet.

It seems that many of our service members just serve in quiet grace and dignity.

by tomsal

You are telling me nothing new. I agree.

My grand father for example served in BOTH world wars and the Korean War. My uncles (whom died before my birth) served in Vietnam, my dad was in the Army for a short stint, I have friends in Navy, Marines, Army, Coast Guard....

I think it even more so is "pathetic" (for lack of better term) that the media rolls the dice and picks the hero of the day, when so many have given so much and do so without want or need of anything more than a simple -- "thank you", often they don't get that.

by mrafrohead

Why not just leave it at that and not over analyse the situation.

She went to war, went through a lot. Leave her alone. She's a person.

She went through probably more than most of you have that are judging her behind your monitor in the comfort of your own homes.

Just leave her alone.

Mrafrohead

by jimhm

She is the one calling attention to herself, with the book deal, made for tv movie and the interviews. So if you are going to go and place yourself in front of the media and the world (in this case the USA) then we can debate her actions.

Yes - She Server as many others have before, did you ever see a WWII CMF winner flunting themselfs in front of the Media. Did you see Iran Hostages who spent 444 days (or something) in captivity flunt infront of the TV or books. How about the men, women and children captured in the Philipians and spent years in POW camps. No these folks servered and came home - and continued with their lifes.

And I applaud Jessica - for continuing to tell the media to quit calling her a hero - that label is the medias fault.

And in war when you get down to the bottomline your job is "to Kill or Be Killed." All other jobs come second - you are a ground pounder, you carry a weapon of death and distruction. Whether you want to or not - you have accepted a job to fire that weapon in combat. She failed to perform her job.

by oz_media

I can see your point although I do not agree but what I found most amusing was the post and the responses.

Coming from you, people have been somewhat accepting of your comments no matter how negative they are. What's amusing though, is that if I had posted THE EXACT same comments in the same context, it would have been a flame war to be reconed with. I can't even begin to think what comments would have come up as everyone protected their country's military name.
In actuality, I disagreed with you and posted so.

It just goes to show, it's not whst is said, I don't even think it's WHO said it, it's WHAT COUNTRY the comment came from that matters.

Like I said, amusing.

by jkaras

Everyone has their opinion of what the definition of hero is but every soldier that served whatever country or whatever conflict received a heros welcome regardless of their participation except of course in Vietnam. I never served, but a cook or a supply sargent is a hero in my eyes, that their contribution no matter how big or small did their part to support those in harms way.

Everyone is splitting hairs over the media hype "hero" label. She served, was in harms way, and survived. As for the comment of women in battle grow up. They can serve with distinction just like any man and are willing to fight. Women get shell shock like any other man can and can rise to the occasion. If facing extinction, would you ask or expect a woman to just look pretty or help to save lives? Their finger works just as well as a mans. Women could be raped as the enemy takes over the town anyway, soldiers wanting to do wrong will still do it anyway and wont stop because a woman might be near to the fighting. The horror that these dainty women experienced as nurses would give you or I nightmares for years and they kept a stiff upper lip. I am a man and understand the protect women in our minds that we were taught throughout our lives, but get with the times and treat them as equals.

by oz_media

I'm not sure if you intended to poet this as a reply to MY post or it just ended up beneath.
I agree with you 150%, I hope I haven't implied otherwise.

Maybe, Mr. Maimi could take a few liberation pointers from you.

by fluxit

Of course roles exist. We cannot operate without them. Your life is ridiculously ordered. You assume roles all the time in your relationships and play out life scripts. Your comment is silly.

Have you served in combat? The most basic premise in the battle space is to make everything equal so that the fight boils down to tactic and skill?

Who is the most likely adversary in the battle space, a male or female? How do you account for physiological and psychological differences between male and female if all technology is removed? In short, aside from political agendas females in combat equates to a battle space that is unbalanced and no longer reduced down to tactic and skill.

On another thought; Where does the man plant his fertile seed? Where does that seed take root for offspring grow? Don't we defend and protect such a place for the future of United States? Why would we put it in the battlespace and subject our future generations to the rigors of war? Possibly for the selfish needs of a professional liberated woman? Personally, it even bothers me when a woman focuses only on her need to HAVE a child as well. It seems so selfish to me. Where is her compassion for the child as it is not about her but that child she will bear? What about the innocent life that potentially could be concieved into a POW camp? Would you want that person brought into this world without medical care and unwanted?

I listened to a Jewish man speak once who was a 2 to 6 year old in two Nazi prison camps. He spoke about the smell of death and having to forage for food every day. He spoke about not having a mom and dad since they were sent to another camp and later died. After the war he lived a life of crime, spent time in jail, and finally in his old age he has come to grips with his hard life. He spends his time talking to people and sharing his wisdom. You could learn from him.

I think you need to get off your high horse and give some serious thought to your values.

As for my age - well, I am probably older than you think. Possibly even older than yourself. Certainly, my understanding of roles is well placed. If you want me to give you a Bible lesson I can do that as well.

by oz_media

You assume: "Your life is ridiculously ordered. You assume roles all the time in your relationships and play out life scripts."

>>>Wrong, MANY do, I don't. I NEVER play a relationship role and won't see anyone who does. Life scripts? I've died, there was no script, if I was following a script prior to my accident, I sure as hell don't now because THAT wasn't in the script. Religion dictates that you live by a scripted live, you even have a book of guidelines, not I.

You then said: " Who is the most likely adversary in the battle space, a male or female?"

>>BOTH, if you're takling about Iraqi's seeing a female adversary, let them perhaps it will teach them something about repressing their women.

You said: "How do you account for physiological and psychological differences between male and female if all technology is removed? In short, aside from political agendas females in combat equates to a battle space that is unbalanced and no longer reduced down to tactic and skill."

>>This makes no sense at all. Are you implying that men are more capable in battle than women? I used to have a female wrestler on my security team, I've seen her take down more than her fair share of big agressive men (much more so than a half starved Iraqi), with ease. She was also more mentally capable in a crunch or stadium riot than most of her coworkers.

The rest of your post is so bakcward I won't even get into a response, I looked at it but no I am not even going to entertain the idea because your thoughts and visions of modern woman are so archaic that all would be in vain anyhow. You can't teach an old dog new tricks, once your generation has passed on perhaps women will have a chance in the world.

You closed iwith: "If you want me to give you a Bible lesson I can do that as well."

I know you can, lets just leave it there shall we, thanks for your reply. :-)

by fluxit

Have nothing to do with religion. These are concepts that secular humanist, psychologists and psychiatrist, have developed in order to understand the human mind.

Attorney's exploit them in trials. Gerry Spence wrote a book on 'How To Win Every Argument' by basically identifying people's scripts then ordering prejudicial arguments in which they cannot win no matter how they answer.

This was the Altanta Strangler was caught and convicted. The investigator profiled the stranglers lifescripts to catch him. Then they had a hard time convicting him until the prosecutor learned his scripts and pushed his buttons to take him out of his lifescript. The strangler exploded on the stand demonstrating to the jurors he had the capacity to kill.

There were no women in the Iraqi military. You are way off base on this one.

IRT the battlespace being in equilibrium, I am alluding the the fact that with all technology removed the most likely adversary is a male and one would most likely meet him in hand-to-hand combat. Collectively the female genus has lower upper body strength and lacks the kill instinct.

You are so closed minded and out-of-touch with reality it is humorous to listen to your rant. Hey I got a rant like yours, I know there are meek men out there in the village that can cook a hell of a lot better than most women. They can put on a mean Barbare Streisand too.

Does that mean they contribute to society in a postive way?

by jimhm

As too a number of the posts that women should not serve in Harm's way - front lines of battle, I disagree.

I have no problem with women in battle, as long as they have the training and conditioning to do the job at hand.

It is the old mentality of most Americans males that women are the Weaker sex - that they need protected - from the big nasty monsters.

I servered with a number of very brave women in vietnam - from office clerks to nurses. These brave women - were in harms way and gave 100% of themselfs to their jobs. They cared for the wounded - and cryed daily for those men. And how many women served in MASH units in korea - or in WWII - how many die in the camps in the philipeans?

It is about time the American military woke to the fact that women can perform in battle if trained and conditioned correctly. Keeping women out of the battle lines was like keeping the blacks out during WWII - Just look at the valor and honor that the Tuskagee Airmen had. Those are men of Honor and strenght that should be the model for all service men and women.

God Bless - All Who Servered or Are Serving...Anywhere with Any Country..

by maxwell edison

.
I knew that when I posted those comments they would draw a lot of disagreement. And I further suppose that in these days of political correctness run amok, I'm on the minority side of that issue. But to clarify my opinion, I'm not suggesting that women, in general, are all weak and frail, requiring "protection by the men folk", and/or they can't (and/or shouldn't) perform jobs - any jobs - that men can. But I think the military is different than anything else in life, and the military should be an exception, especially when it comes to combat roles. Discrimination is okay in the military. They discriminate against people with poor eye sight, people in wheelchairs, people with flat feet, and so on. Why? Because they just can't do the job of fighting as well.

The notion that women, in general, can perform in combat roles just as effectively as men falls apart under closer scrutiny. Sure, some women may perform just fine, but most would not. That's just the opposite of men, where most could perform just fine, while some may not. There's no denying that men, in general, are stronger than women and are better fighters than women. A police officer, for example, is called to a domestic dispute situation and finds both the man and woman with a black eye. Who gets arrested?

Moreover, to take the stance that ALL women can - and should - fill combat roles is to suggest that women should also be eligible for the draft. Are you suggesting that as well? If not, why not? But you and I both know that women will never be drafted, and that should speak volumes. Therefore what? Therefore, if women can "decide" when and where they serve, shouldn't men be afforded the same opportunity? "Sorry, I'm not going to register for the draft", will get a man arrested. If women, in general, are just as capable, why do they get a free pass?

The military is not a vehicle for social engineering, political correctness, or implementing some feminist agenda. And to compare the role of women in combat to the Tuskegee Airmen and race issues is comparing apples to eggplant.

If you found yourself in the middle of a war zone, really in some "deep doo-doo", and you had to fight to the death your way out, who would you want with you, Arnold Schwarzenegger or Gloria Steinem?

As a side note: At a local Army base, the Army is considering what action to take, if any, against a woman soldier who refused to report to duty in Iraq. She said that she wanted to stay home with her kids. Her husband, who is also a soldier in the Army, is in Iraq. She didn't want to risk the possibility that BOTH her kids' parents would be killed.

Damn, what's this politically correct world coming to?

by jkaras

As always Max you make valid points. I do believe that politically correctness is wrong. It is the worst invention ever created because it doesnt promote equality and understanding. It merly promotes a soapbox to be heard and put yourself above the other forcing them to acknowledge your difference as superior. It was intended as a good idea that went amoke due to a suppressed ego.

With that said I do like the apples to eggplant by the way quite funny. However people having physical deformaties such as handicapped doesnt equal to muscle mass issues. The women who meet the physical requirements should be allowed the opprotunity to prove that they are capable rather than grouping them in a category of cant. They need to do the same amount of push ups as a man etc... Our outdated view of women should be completely equal including them in the draft, monitary compensation, legally/financial responsible for marriage and children. This will only happen when the lawmakers rewrite the laws accordingly.

As for the woman refusing to report for duty, it goes both ways. The government should have left her behind in the first place leaving a legal guardian in charge of the children in a dual military family like the Sullivan act that protects the family name to carry on. She is just handling the situation wrong. If her husband wasnt in then to bad so sad. If she was a single mother in the military then she should stay behind. You can give me the retoric all you want that you are the property of the government that you swear to when you get in, but this situation isnt in our own back yard. WE are not facing extinction of our kind or country, merly at war abroad. She can still serve locally. I do understand your point due to a friend that is currently in the Air Force doing weather. He has gone TDY more than anyone in his unit due to a few women in the unit that claim femine issues to get out of going to hot spots. All they have to do is get a dr. note to stay safe and that sickens me. The superior needs to punish them by giving them the worst assignments with the worst schedule as repayment for their cowardice or a clear revision of excusable circumstances. If they cant rewrite it punish them unfairly.

by oz_media

No I'm not going to get into a lengthy flame war again, we can't seem to find a common resolution to those.

I will disagree about a womans ability to fight as well or better than a man, regardless of the mental situation. I know of TWO women first hand that would eat you in a second MAX and still have room for pie. I've seen 6'6" bouncers at clubs stand aside when these women have a problem to sort. They are the type of women that make the roughest bikers and so called tough guys shake in thier boots. They were two security managers that I worked with for many years. We had some really big boys on staff, nobody would cross the women though. Not just big fat chicks, but hard ass, well trained fighters that even looked like men sometimes, but in their defense, very sweet when needed.

I agree that the battlefield isn't a place for the secretary to be, but there are women who can fill these roles as good if not much better than most men.

No flame, no personal attack on you, just comments and observations.

OM

by maecuff

First of all, Gloria Steinham is now what? 112 years old? Yes, I'd get my ass kicked by most men if push came to shove, but how much hand to hand combat is there? And have you ever seen a woman react if she feels her child is being threatened? You will see vicious and fearless. Do I believe a woman could be as fearless as a man, you bet. I believe there was a post earlier about women having a harder time with emotions. Have you ever watched a relationship fall apart? I've rarely seen the man come out on the other side quicker than a woman. We are extremely strong emotionally, we have more stamina, we don't have the physical strength, but we're smart, cunning, inventive.. you name it, and sometimes that's what will win a battle. I don't have an answer to the women in combat, but I can't stand to see women portrayed as the weaker sex who's job it is to have babies and nurture the world. My children have TWO parents, and they are nurtured by both.

by jimhm

In Nam the weapon was great just to lite a calabor for the jungle - needed the bigger cal's to do it ... we also had to deal with mud, water, heat and humdity over sand and heat. And cleaning your weapon a couple times a day was SOP. We delt with it with a rubber and cleaning - it didn't jam. A simple Rubber over the mussle worked great.

If her weapon was jammed from dirt that was poor training and NCO fault for failure to inspect his teams weapons prior to a mission..

by cactus pete

A seasoned vet over a 1 month newbie any day.

Yes, generally speaking, men can 'do more' physically than women - and they don't get monthly anxieties like women may...

I agree, that women, in general, aren't as good in combat conditions as men. I just wanted you to actually say what it was you meant so I knew if I really agreed or not (with you - this time).

That said, I believe we should make room for the exceptions. I want the best admin on my systems in each area... I expect there is a similar issue in combat.

Then again, I don't expect that the numbers [odds] put Ms. Lynch in actual combat - so they probably didn't really goof there. I don't recall seeing pictures and video of women in the heat of everything, come to think of it.

The situation that put Ms. Lynch where she was was one of those conditions of war - people die. People get hurt. Things don't go as planned.

Ms. Lynch, I suspect, didn't have much time to even try to fire her weapon, given the details of the situation I've read. There is no proof that she did anything wrong, and the gun jamming is plausible [even if you don't think it's excuseable].

by jkaras

Most join out of tradition. All the men in my family served except me. Some do it for schooling. Some do it for the experience to see the world. But yes there is a prolific amount of people that have no skills or high education that join to make something of themselves. I'm not harping on you, just pointing out since you used the term "majority" there is a significant amount of tradition that weighs on many young males that grew up as "army brats". They see this as a coming of age to gain respect from their parents.

by jimhm

I don't know about the Army but I know the Navy, Marines and Air Force do not accept those that get a choice from the courts to A - go to jail or B - join the Service.

Now the Army may be different ...

I think a majority may not be the brights bulbs on the planet but you have to give these young men and women a lot of credit for trying to make something of thier life and themselfs - and not going on welfare or assitance.

Give them the credit that is due - they are trying and accomplishing something that others thier age just ignore and take from the government.

Kudoo's - to them for trying, and it could be the Army training that really sucks - not the person taking the training.

by road-dog

1) No way to pay for college
2) no direction in life, other than that I didn't want to install carpet for the rest of my life like my dad.
3) The inherent coolness of working on multi-million dollar weapons systems.
4) First rate training and a possible career direction using marketable skills.
5) My older brother was a Marine.
6) The fundamental belief that every young man should serve.

7) because the chicks dig it!

I could have found another job. I was not trying to stay out of jail. I think that you're way off base here.

by oz_media

Tried out for the Joe Schmo show. I don't mean that as a shot at your ability and am definitely not comparing TV to the Marines. He was just a guy with nothing better to do, so he said why not. He's now a TV personality that won $1000,000 and is travelling the world.

As for the chicks, I went with the band manager role. They sure do dig being backstage, I don't know why, it really isn't the big todo that it was in the 70's.

Cheers,
OM

by hazza

Having served my country for 20+ years I would like to make some observations.
1. I am always amazed at the difference in the way your media (and by association our media) treats Jessica Lynch and Shoshonna(?) Johnson. Call me sceptical but could that be because Jessica is what is classically called attractive and Shoshonna is not?
2. As I remember (or not)the first time in a real live firefight is ALWAYS scary and a lot of it goes by in a blur. Also, it being an ambush makes it that much more so, as I presume they ambush with the same objectives and principles as we do SHOCK, SURPRISE, Killing Zones, etc. Having talked to one of my Warrant Officers (he was SAS doing a Regimental posting to my unit) when I was just new, who had survived an ambush, he said it was the scariest few minutes of his life. So the fact there was confusion in the units reaction is somewhat understandable. And if the NCO ic was killed or injured in the opening moments then this only makes the situation worse.
3. From the reports we recieved she was fairly badly injured in the vehicle accident. I don't know about anyone else but if you're badly injured in a vehicle accident, possibly the last thing you are likely to do is get out 'all guns blazing'.
4. From this distance (the other side of the Pacific Ocean) it looks like she is being manipulated by just about everyone. The Pentagon and White House to gather more support for the war in Iraq. The media for their battle against the Pentagon and White House over the reasons for going to war. The Talk Shows for ratings.
4. I think your military is in a lose - lose situation. The have to obey the decisions made in the White House (and it seems the Sec of Def is way too involved!!). They are losing too many lives to 'terror' or guerilla attacks. And, of course, the media is reporting mostly the things that go wrong e.g. the shooting of a reporter and cameraman, the downing of helicopters. But very little that is objective.

My only wish out of all this is that any lessons that need to be learnt are learnt. i.e.
1. Sec of Def should have NO influence in war making decisions. He is a politician not a war fighter. From this distance it looked like he was the one who drove it all (incl the President's direction).
2. Never, ever, ever underestimate your enemy. You can roll his forces up quickly but if you just race by and take the next target you have a liability behind you.
3. The way a war should be fought, even with the territory restrictions placed on him, was how Gen Schwarzkopf did it. With meticulous planning and preparation, unhindered by time constraints and political interferecnce.

There are plenty more.

by jimhm

Well Oz - you hit the problem - Not all women and not all men are cut out to be on the front lines. There were many shy, clumzy men that got sent to the nam, they had no choice.

Man have no choice - then to be a PC'er - women also have no choice! Do what you are ordered to do.

They signed on the dotted line - they raised their right hand and took the oath. They do what has been ordered, without question. They fought for that right to be in combat - they won it - I support it - now do it. They can't have it both ways.

That female that doesn't want to go to Iraqi - because her husband is already there - Tuff it out babe, do your assigned duty and go. That is the risk every military person accepts for the pay they get. She had a choice at one time to accept a medical discharge after having her kid(s) but she decided to stay and accepted the risk. A General Court - and General Discharge for her, she doesnt like that - then Jail time and a dishonorable discharge.

We lost many untrained - scared rabbits over there in nam, you got to get tuff and hard fast, or its a box ride home.

by oz_media

I know that JL had the oppotunity to leave after having her kids, but I don't think she was in the same position at that time and couldn't make that decision. I know it is possible to have your company ambushed and you will have to fight for your life, I'm sure she knew it too. As I'm sure you are aware of first hand, you understand the risks but don't understand how you will react in the situation unless you experience it. You can be physically and mentally prepared but still cower in fear when the time comes, I don't think they allow Marines in training to kill each other to express the feeling, no matter how well mocked up a training battle can be, you know you're not actuially going to die.

I don't think she was weak or unprepared, in fact I think many of her comrades would have felt the sme if his 'brothers' were taken out of the mix and he was left standing alone.

I think she was what she was trained to be, a soldier just like any other.

You said: "We lost many untrained - scared rabbits over there in nam, you got to get tuff and hard fast, or its a box ride home."

This sound too familiar, an great friend of mine was a Merc. in Nam. He was a fourth degree blackbelt that would eat your nose off your face if he had to. After Nam, he was secretary treasurer of the Vancouver chapter of a motorcycle "club", hard assed to his death bed. He even made a Guinness record while in the hospital riddled with cancer, he was the first human to take an extreme dosage (I don't know what it was) of morphine and live. He was also able to sneak out of the hospital and still walk to the bar for a game of darts with us the afternoon before he died.

God bless your sole Boe!

by maxwell edison

I knew I'd be opening myself up to a lot of potential grief, but for the sake of clarity I never said that the female was the "weaker sex". (Men being "stronger" only applied to brute strength - generally speaking, as there are, of course, some exceptions.)

Your reply was right on about everything you said. But you also went on to say that you, "don't have an answer to the women in combat".

You asked, "how much hand to hand combat is there?"

Well, not much, I suppose, but it does happen. And I think that the military, from the top planners all the way down to the single soldier, should always hope for the best, plan for the best, but always be prepared for the worst.

And I never said that women couldn't be effective serving in the military. To the contrary, there are plenty of jobs a woman could fill, and I'm sure they could perform them quite well. I just don't think that a combat role is one of them.

I'm surprised that no one has tried to address the draft issue. If women belong in combat, why not make them regisetr for the draft? Why not draft them along with men? (The answer is that they don't belong in combat, and it wouldn't facilitate the creation of the most effective fighting force.)

by oz_media

Because people like yourself run the country and they as you have shown, have a closed mind toward a womans combat abilities.

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, it seems outlandish that it's always "closed minded" to disagree with you. Of course, you think that you are the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded", of course. Too bad people like you just can't respectfully agree to disagree without attacking people.

Actually, I'm on the outside, I'm on the fringes of this issue. The majority of Americans will either concede (give in) that women can be just as effective as men in combat roles, or they will simply side-step the issue. (Actually, President Bush side-steps this politically charged issue by "leaving it up to the military commanders to decide".) Very few people will speak freely on this for fear of "saying the wrong thing". And the ones "running the country", as you suggest, also disagree with me on this issue, as the U.S. Congress, in 1991, rescinded the law prohibiting women in combat. I would bring it back. (Why do you think they're there?) Yep, I'm on the outside looking in on this one, just like my opposing stance to the death penalty.

I would suggest that an overwhelming majority of Americans would not want to see (do not like seeing) women as a regular soldier in combat units. I would also suggest that an overwhelming majority of Americans would not want their daughters become a future Jessica Lynch, even if she volunteered. But I would further suggest that an overwhelming majority of Americans won't admit to it. It's pandering to feminist groups. It's fear of being criticized. It's an attempt to be politically correct. It's turning a blind eye to both a moral and practical issue.

But you're the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

Okay, I can live with that.

(Gee, which is it, do I "blindly follow" what I'm told, or am I "closed minded" for not conforming to (perceived) present day thought? You've suggested that I'm both. I guess I'm whatever is necessary, at the time, for you to attack me.)

by jimhm

I don't know about Canada or British military - but do those countries permit women in combat and draft them? Not a smart ass question - I don't know the answer.

by jkaras

in the second paragraph refering to that all women need to be included in the draft to be equal. After completing the physical requirements it would be determined the level of involvement in combat situations. If they fail to meet the requirements based on equality and not a womans compromise they then can fill support roles that doesnt rule out combat but not front line combat. Such as engineering roles that get ambushed rather than front line defense/offense. They make great pilots but being shot down and surviving skills must be met inorder to fly combat missions.

by maecuff

I hate that little cliche, but it does fit here. I believe if a woman feels fit for combat, then she can be as effective (or ineffective) as a man. As far as the draft goes, I don't like it in general. People who are forced to do anything aren't going to be as effective who want to be there, however, if there is a draft, I think women should be included. I'd be the first to say that there is inequality between men and women. I work for a company that has been around 100 years and am the first female director in the company. I know what it's like to have to prove myself because I have two breasts instead of one penis. However, I don't think it is fair or right that women aren't drafted the same as men. I don't think that it is right or fair that when a couple divorces, everything is 50/50 (in theory) until it comes to the kids, then all of a sudden, mom is more important. That is bullshit. A parent is a parent, and either could be best, but we are all taught to believe that women are soft and squishy (and afaid of mice) and what we do best is take care of children. BTW, I am not the least afraid of mice or snakes or spiders, but my 6'1", 230 pound 16 year old son screams at the sight of a spider.

by oz_media

Not laughing at all, you have a very valid point and speak your mind well.

If a woman wants to go to war, she should. She should not be criticized of her actions afterwards though just because she is female. If a male had been in Jessica's place and had received the same criticism, I'd fell fine about the criticism that Jessica is getting.
Knowing that if she was a man and that most of those against Jessica would support a man reacting the same way, pisses me off though.

If we (especially me as a Canadian)were here slamming Rick Mankind's actions and calling him a coward, people would be furios and shouting how I'm anti-American and Canada hasn't done anything to support the war and where do I get off slaming a hero.

Turn the table and the testosterone flows the other way. Typical I guess.

by road-dog

I'm inclined to believe that most women don't have the temperament for combat, although from nurture rather than nature. Girls are raised (more often than not) to be geared for concensus rather than competition. I suspect that this is why many of the best Managers I've worked for are women.

Boys are culturally driven to act out aggression as seen from everywhere from bugs bunny to war movies.

As for the physical aspects of combat readiness, I would admit women into combat only if they meet the same stringent requirements that men in that same MOS do. If a woman can pass marksmanship, fieldcraft, and physical fitness evaluations, then she's welcome in my bunker any time.

The standards shouldn't be lowered for anyone. I don't want Howard P. Milquetoast watching my back any more than a female who qualifies under lowered or "gender adjusted" standards.

Men get flushed out of billets all the time. If women don't measure up, then there is not a place for them there either.

As for sociological issues, I think that America needs to be prepared for the horrors of war being visited upon servicewomen. We cannot afford to lose our resolve because a few attractive females get maimed or tortured any more than we would for their male counterparts.

Therein lies the rub.... America's Achilles' heel is unwillingness to accept casualties. We must not increase this weakness on grounds of "fairness".

by maecuff

to agree, but, I have to say, I agree with most of your post. As long as any person, male or female, are capable of doing a job, any job, there should be equal opportunity.

In reading some previous posts, I seem to have done a bit of male bashing, and for that I apologize. It does no good to swing too far in the other direction. People are people, good, bad, capable, incompetent, these things are not gender specific.

by oz_media

T"here were no women in the Iraqi military. You are way off base on this one."
No Im not you didn't understand the post. I didn't say Iraqis had women in the military at all. I meant that Iraqi soldiers would not be much of a match for a marine female OR male, in a one on one fight.

You then said: "You are so closed minded and out-of-touch with reality it is humorous to listen to your rant."

Where was the rant in this post? How am I closed minded, I was the one who considered women equal!?
What part of my reality is out of touch?

I will accept your rediculous and unqualified accusations if you can back them with fact.

Touche

by maecuff

Perhaps it's not so much that women lack the killer instinct as woman are stronger emotionally and are better at staying rational in a flight or fight situation. And meek men who can cook don't contribute to society in a positive way? But meek women who can cook do? I don't understand how one can be positive and another negative.

by oz_media

I don't know if it is intentional, ignorant or just not willing to comprehend, but I often find no sense in Miami's posts. Mind you, NOBODY (or at least very few) sees the sense in mine.

by oz_media

You go off in a lengthy rant at me because YOU stated that although you believe in equality that women are great for OTHER military jobs but don't have a place in the battlefield.

THIS IS A CLOSED MINDED THOUGHT PROCESS, you are unopen to objection because YOU feel that they are inadequate on a battlefield, not just my opinion. So don't go tryng to get me to constatly defend my statements when your's are just as questionable. You expect everyone else to support thier opinions but to simply accept yours as is, wake up and grow up, this doesn't become you at all.

YOU have closed you mind to women in combat becasue SOME would be unfit or unable to fight a man in hand to hand or close combat. You have made this VERY clear as YOUR personal opinion.

I think this is WHY there is no draft for women. You share a VERY common set of beliefs with the politicians that run the country, you back MOST yet not all of their actions with a vengeance. Don't start running off on your own little crusade now, you're a Republican and from what you've shown here, a very proud and loud Republican. OR is it socialist this week ?

I have accepted you for who you WANT to be, OK?

Now, the reason there is no draft for women in the US is due to people , not unlike yourself, who also share the common Republican fantasy that women have thier place in the world and it isn't on a battlefield.

Now, you can be a big boy and accept it or you can go on talking about my life, mentality, drug abuse or whatever you wish. Bottom line is this, you are proud of your political stand. You feel you share a common interest with Republicans, I never said you believe ALL, but most.

You believe that women should not be on a battlefield, are you now saying that A Republican wouldn't feel that way? Are you denying that they run your country?

This isn't an attack it's reality, as you have set me straight in understanding YOUR reality and YOUR mindset too many times. Is it passive-Max week or something or are you standing by your Republican guns!

by maxwell edison

.
If you say I'm closed minded, then there ya' have it. I must be closed minded. After all, you're the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

by oz_media

I decided to go through your post ONE MORE TIME, and found that you feel, as you say, are on the outside looking in. you did mention that MANY military leaders would agree with you however the president wouldn't take a stand out of fear of politically incorrect repercussion, right?

Do these military leaders not believe in George Bush?
Are these military leaders not also thinking as a Republican as they suport Bush?
Do these military leaders speak their mind because they don't fear being accused of being chavinistic pigs, whereas the president would be?

Then I guess they DO support George Bush's actual feelings and speak volumes on his behalf. Your President runs the country, he doesn't want to take the chauvinist rap (bad for reelection) so he lets the military do it for him. People like yourself speak loud enough that Bush can sit back and let his minions do the dirty work?

YOU sidestep the issue like a true politician. you speak for yourself, but then back it with suport by military leaders who would feel the same way. Although George Bush wouldn't openly say so. You're not on the outside looking in, your right in the thivk of it, BUSH is the one looking in, silently. Way to make a stand.

by oz_media

Ya know Max, you used to baffle me with the things you knew. You've simply resorted to just slamming me instead of answering my questions again.

It's better to just slam the poster than to actually find some form of supporting argument now?

I am merely repeating what I read into YOUR post. If you disagree, it is YOUR post that you are disagreeing to. If you disagree with what I read out of your post, then set me straight with some form of tangible ideas that will support yor statements.

you said you didn't feel women should be in a combat role. (I'm sure this isn't just the I'm right you're wrnog syndrome, or perhaps it's just my PC acting up)

I said that is a typical republican attitude.

You then implied that I was attacking BUSH and that he wouldn't say that because it is not in his best interests, right or wrong? You tell me. It's a question, thus the question mark.

You also said you stand alone on this one and are looking in from the outside. Followed by how the military leaders would agree with you.

So....

I read this as, BUSH wouldn't be dumb enough to make such a statement, knowing what kind of political repercussions it would have. Right? Wrong?

So....

You feel that you think just like other GI's would and that women should not hold a combat role but are fine to sew the soldiers socks, pour the general coffee, file the paperwork and other administrative "womens" or "light" duties etc. Right? Wrong?

Your soldiers are mainly Repubicans that support BUSH all the way. Right? Wrong? If Wrong, why do they still fight for the country based on BUSH's recommendations?

So...

If you feel the way the soldiers do, the soldiers feel the way BUSH does (although he can't publicly admit it) and you, the soldiers and BUSH are Repubicans, how is it so off kilter to then conclude that Repubicans are against women fighting on the front line?

You see max, I have learned that you require a clear explanation and some supporting evidence for a statement to hold true with you.

You then go ignoring MY comments by saying that I'm always right, yada yada yada.

So in truth are you simply saying that I have a point and caught you with your pants down while mindlessly ranting? or are you saying you have a relevant point and I've simply failed to understand it? If so, clarify it.

I backed my opinions with how and why I feel this way, now you're up.

See, I haven't called you names, I haven't attempted to discredit your post by saying you're an idiot, but most of all I haven't evaded a question.

by maxwell edison

I say this with all seriousness, but you either try to get your jollies or try to get a rise out of me (or both) by putting words in my mouth , or you really do have trouble reading and comprehending the written word.

I never said, "that MANY military leaders would agree" with me. (And you even added the emphasis by capitalizing the word many.) In fact, I never suggested what I might believe military leaders really think about it.

And I never concluded the President's reasons for side-stepping the issue. Why did you suggest to draw such a conclusion for me (or him)?

As far as your other questions about our military leaders, as the President is their Commander-In-Chief, they follow his orders. The President has military advisors, to be sure, and the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff (he's the top military guy) certainly has the President's ear, but I'm not really privy as to what they talk about. To learn what they really think and why, you'd have to ask them yourself or do some research for whatever public information is available on the subject.

But you drew your own conclusions on your own fabricated assumptions on what they think and why, so I guess that's what it is.

And you figured out all these things just by being the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

by oz_media

Your post had me rethinking and rereading YOUR posts to better understand your meaning. This is what I expect from you or anyone else who is trying to make a point clear.

Then you ended by your usual, flame the messenger again. You've got to get over that, it's an assumption by yourself, I've never said that I know everything.

My calling you closed minded is due to your inablility to support your comments but your ability to slam mine while expecting me to accept your post without supporting evidence.

Closed minded/Narrow minded: lacking in tolerance or breadth of vision

You see one side and one side only, YOUR side to everything ever discussed here. Any contrary opinion is just a know it all, or someone who is sarcastically always correct and never wrong.

So, you said: "(Actually, President Bush side-steps this politically charged issue by "leaving it up to the military commanders to decide".) Very few people will speak freely on this for fear of "saying the wrong thing".

But there wa no implication that was how BUSH felt or MAY feel also? Why follow with "very few people..." in the same paragraph if you're not implying that is where BUSH stands?

You are correct in that I 'assumed' that you said that military leaders felt this way. At least I couldn't find it in this string, (I'm sure I read it somewhere today but I may be wrong). You did say that BUSH leaves it up to the military leaders to decide.

With BUSH being the Commander-in-Chief, would that not also imply that he either agrees with their actions (if he didn't, it would'nt be like George to quietly sit aside)or that the military leaders are adhering to what the President actually wants but we aren't privy to that information.

I don't think there's a middle ground or grey area here, he either wants it so they do it, or they do it and he doesn't disagree so he must approve. He is after all, THEIR commander in chief. I do things I feel my customers would want done with their networks NOT what I want to do with their networks.

I'm sure you also conduct you day as your boss would see fit, not as you would want it. Do you need to ask your bosses opinion on everything? Probably not, you know when you are fullfilling the company's needs and if you don't I'm sure your boss would let you know.

You've also said that the overwhelming majority of Americans would not want to see women as regular soldiers in combat.

George Bush has been on the block ever since the beginning of the war, if he was eager to please the public and gain their acceptance once again, especially after Jessica's story, and if he is against women in military combat situations would he not be holding a press conference right this minute to suport the removal of women from combat?

I find it hard to believe that an OVERWHELMING MAJORITY of Americans feel this way, I think that is a gross exageration on your part.

I think if George Bush said he wanted women out of combat situations it would cause quite a stir and repercussions he's not prepared to face. Therefore, he passes the buck to the military to carry the ball.

This is just my assumption, but at least a somewhat qualified one as I've laid down my reasons for thinking this way.

Now, you've explained to me HOW I'm supposed to answer a post (thanks for clearing me up on that one)so I guess I'll take your next lesson on how to finish a post.

But you're the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

by oz_media

Sorry I must have side-stepped this issue.

You said: "Gee, which is it, do I "blindly follow" what I'm told, or am I "closed minded" for not conforming to (perceived) present day thought? You've suggested that I'm both. I guess I'm whatever is necessary, at the time, for you to attack me.)"

You blindly follow the general feeling of those with who you wish to be associated with. You are closed minded to any contrary opnions. You cleverly took two statements out of context again, well not cleverly but you did it again anyhow.

Your statement: "But I would further suggest that an overwhelming majority of Americans won't admit to it. It's pandering to feminist groups. It's fear of being criticized. It's an attempt to be politically correct"

This solidifies my opinion that people are followers, conformists or sheep, you choose which one. People are scared to speak their minds out of fear of being different or not accepted by a certain group, sect or their chosen political party.

But you asked, so I asnwered.

by jimhm

Oz - You don't know our military very well. I believe that if Jessica was a man - there would of been a board investigation as to why he didn't fire his weapon. And if it were jammed why he didn't take a weapon from his injured comrade and us it. We had a number of those in Nam. (Armchair quarterbacking - looking after the fact.)

Because Jessica - as has two breast and no penis - she is being treated differently. She is being held up as somekind of hero (media word not hers), what about all those males that weren't rescued and survived?

She now clams never being rapped - and that they weren't goig to cut off her legs and that her injuries were from the vehicle reck. But at the same time she said she can't remember anything from the time of the Ambush - to waking in the hospital.

by maxwell edison

British Army - No women in combat roles:

In 2002, the British Ministry of Defence upheld the British military's 1997 decision to exclude women from combat roles. The reason is that women have a far lower capacity to develop muscle strength and aerobic fitness than men. In fact, only 1% of women can equal the performance of the average man. Women have to work between 50% and 80% harder than men to achieve the same results. Thus, women cannot meet the load-marching and other combat duty tasks. Any reduction in standards would pose unacceptable risks to the effectiveness of the forces.
This report confirmed that the British military was on firm legal ground in continuing to exclude women from ground combat risks. Its decision is also in line with a 1999 European Court of Justice ruling that the exclusion of women from certain positions in the military did not violate equality legislation passed by the European Parliament since such exclusion was appropriate to ensure operational effectiveness of the military.

Canada - Yes

In February 1989, a three-member Human Rights Commission, which included feminist, Jane Banfield Haynes, a sociologist at Toronto's York University, conducted a hearing on the question of women serving in combat roles in the Canadian military. Completely ignoring the Canadian Forces' own studies that had results similar to the 2002 British study, it concluded that feminist ideology should hold sway, and, therefore, women should serve in combat roles in the Canadian military. The Associate Minister of Defence at that time was Mary Collins, MP, who also happened to be the Minister Responsible for Women's Issues. She, of course, did not want the sisterhood descending upon her head by allowing an appeal of this decision. So the decision of the Tribunal stayed, and it has, over the years, caused enormous trouble and endless expense for the Canadian military.

In 1997-98, the Canadian forces became subject to the Employment Equity Act.

Interesting story:

http://mensnewsdaily.com/archive/r/reed/02/reed060502.htm

by jimhm

You say - "woman are stronger emotionally and are better at staying rational in a flight or fight situation" - have you been see these women. Logic and rational go out the window with women. They run a pure emotion when pissed. (a majority are like that - not all)

(Not all men - but a majority) On the other hand because men don't run on emotions - we use cold logic - think through the problem - develop a solution and alternative - then execute. We just don't sit down and cry and scream that it wasn't fair -

Look I support women in combat - hell you all want to get shot at - live in dirt - piss and shit in a helment - dig a fox hole - sleep in the rain... Be my guess... and thanks... But if you want that - then you also take the risks of death and injury. And you should register for the draft as well...

I am assuming you are female from your post.

But I found a vast majority of women that run on pure emotion when angry - no logic - that will get you killed faster than a zapper, and women never forget anything - 10 years ago you did this...

Look - You all want the glory - you all take the risks - you can have one without the other. You want combat roles - you get drafted - you take the risk of death and injury - you get the nasty life of a combat grunt... Or stay home ...

by maecuff

I'm sorry, I'm not quite sure I understand the title of your reply. I have to assume you are trying to get my attention? You really don't have to try so hard.

Logic and rational go out the window with women? I assume you meant rational thought, in any case, I don't see very many women beating the shit out of each other over a parking space or if they get beer spilled on them at a bar, or God Forbid, they root for the wrong sports team. I find men very much more irrational, quick to anger, act impulsively, with dire consequences. I don't think cold logic and reasoning with alternate plans come in to play very often. You sound like you've read one too many Tom Clancy books.

Yes, I've seen women yell and rant and scream that life isn't fair, mostly in movies from the 1950's.

As far as sleeping in dirt, or whatever it was, I have no interest in that, I don't want to serve in the military, but women are just as capable as men in 'untidy' situations.

And yes, I am female. I have smelling salts in my desk to help me out whenever I am overcome with the 'vapors'.

by maxwell edison

If you did any "gender bashing", I think most people kept it in its intended and harmless context. At least I did. I, too, hope no one thinks my position is tantamount to gender bashing, because it is not.

I just believe that if the goal of the military is to maintain the most effective and fierce fighting force possible, that men, in general, can make that happen better than a mix of both men and women. This means combat roles only, not the whole military. I could go on and on with individual reasons, but the bottom line is this: the introduction of women into combat roles could, and in some cases absolutely would, cause some adverse issues that might compromise the pre-stated goal of being the absolute best possible force; whereas the elimination of women would not cause any additional problems to deal with. The ONLY reason to do it is for "equality" purposes, not for the purposes of making it better. And considering that it "could" make it worse, why take the chance?

After all, why don't men and women sports teams compete against each other, and/or have co-ed teams? For the same reasons a combat team should not be co-ed.

Can you imagine a football game between two teams, one of which has 100% men on the playing field at all times, and the other uses both men and women? Who would you bet on?

by maecuff

Okay, I concede, to a point. Yes, introducing an element that could adversly affect the ultimate goal makes no sense. I think the adverse affect could me created for the wrong reasons, however, that doesn't really matter when it's the goal that counts.

The sports analogy though... again, it depends on the sport and it depends on the skill of the players. I'd have to make a judgement call after knowing more about each team. Of course, if it is still Gloria Steinam we're talking about, I'd have to bet on the other team.

by fluxit

My remark about meekness was targeted at an individuals remark about chicks with male-like character. Both are capable of doing something like a mean Barbara Streisand or WWF moves. However, I question if there is something more positive they can be contributing to society?

I'll try not to respond to a remark without prefacing the comment first. My regrets.

by maecuff

I'm not sure what the Mr Maecuff means. Perhaps it's because I have an opinion that makes me butch? What I'm trying to understand is why a female with male qualities or a male with female qualitiess cannot make a positive contribution to society? That makes no sense to me.