Discussion Locked

Is Jessica Lynch - A Hero - Coward - or Just Stupid

0 helpful
157 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

157 replies

by wordworker

Hey guys & gals, here's what I want to know: Which scurvey dog son-of-a-gun SOLD those pictures of Jessica to Flynt? Is s/he driving around in a hot new sports car after cashing the big check?

If there's any ANTI-HERO in this story it's the low-down p.o.s. who decided to make a fast buck with the candid pics. And yes, I think the media wonks are also low-down p.o.s. for trying to mak Ms. Lynch into a national icon, but for crying out loud - which of her fellow soldiers thought to himself, "Hey you know I bet we can get some big buck$ for these!"

by jimhm

Got to say if I had those photos of her dancing around my room topless and naked I would of sold them also for a Million.

I mean - what the heck, she is selling her sole all over the country. Whats a million between Army buddies...

I think - he did what was best for his future and his family financial future ... spot on bro..

by wordworker

I'm not going to take the bait and say what a p.o.s. scumbag you would be if you really meant this post... If you did, then you probably had a lot of blanket parties when you were in the service, eh Jim?

I'm going to assume hopefully that you're just angling for a fight with your pal OzMedia.

by jimhm

Sorry - but in all honesty I would of sold them for a Million dollars, why not. Not to sound like a pig, but what was she to me - except some very attractive girl running around my room naked that I slept with, and let me take photos of.

She aint my sister, niece, wife, mother or girlfriend - why not make a few bucks. You're going to tell me that if Hussler published those photos - it wouldn't be a record number of sales.

Look at Reality - I be one of the few that will not be PC about it - You drop a certified check for 1,000,000.00 - and my problems are over.

She has already sold her sole for the book deal and for the TV movie, and I am sure for a speaking tour of the US.

And no Blanket parties - no fraging - no shot in the back of the head - matter of fact still have many friends from the fields... if you are going to be who you are - you got to speak your beliefs no matter what others think.

Here are the negatives - give me the million.

by wordworker

To say that the majority of servicepeople joined to avoid jail or because no one else would hire them is pure b.s. I joined, for example, because I thought the big cash bonus would help me pay off some debts (as a stupid divorced 23 y.o. I was in a hole), help me make some contacts (the Honorable Discharge on the res' makes a positive statement), and because I wanted to be like my dad, my grandfather, Elvis, and George Washington - I wanted to serve my country, see some of theworld, and learn a few things. I *enjoyed* firing weapons and playing the cool toys, but I also enjoyed being a part of one of the biggest and best training and operations outfits in the world. It was admittedly in some ways a big testosterone macho trip.

Mission accomplished on all objectives.

So, don't EVEN try to smear all servicepeople with such ludicrous statements as "avoiding jail" and "no place else to go." It ain't so. Many of us were/are there because we are PATRIOTS.

by wordworker

Guru, are you IN the service, or just a hired civilian hack?

I find your blanket explanation of why people join to be, in a word, insulting. See my post below for why *I* joined.

by guruofdos

I am a specialist subcontractor hired by the US Army for three reasons:

1) They cannot get the skills they need 'in-house' and so subcontract a lot of specialist work to 'professional' companies such as mine. As for being a 'hack', spending 17 years in my job and going to college every two or three years or so to keep my skills up to date and to add to my expertise and skills base hardly justifies that term.

2) As a condition of having bases in EU countries, the US Army are required by European law to employ a certain percentage of local labour where the required personnel are not available within the Army. Unfortunately certain skills aren't even available in Germany let alone Kosovo, so there is a clause within Europe that any other EU country can provide specialist employees and they qualify as 'local' within Europe.

3) Fact: The British Army are the best trained and most professional military in the world. They may not be the biggest or the best equipped, but ask any Coalition serviceman or woman who has served in combat alongside the British and they will back up this fact. The US Army have finally cottened onto this fact and are using British trainers and defence training specialists to help develop their training.

I'm not having a dig at US Army personnel....obviously I have only met 2000-3000 or so. BUT....of those 2000-3000, the majority of 'grunts' are in the Army for the reasons I stated. And that's not just my observations, that's from public domain information from the Army and by personal admission from the squaddies themselves!

by oz_media

There's a running joke (for a few years now) in Canada about how the USA doesn't need a welfare system, they have the military.

Which everyone and their dog feels is a right of passage to be a true American.

I have seen it posted where Americans feel the military is a right of passage to becoming a man. Yeah, that's it.

"Son,learn to kill your neighbour and shoot anyone on your property. NOW you're a man." Not.

by wordworker

OM, you don't have to join the Armed Services to learn how to shoot trespassers and thieves. We midwest country boys learned how to do that at a young age.

Seriously, though, the military IS a rite of passage: it teaches discipline, chain of command, responsibility - things that come in handy in the so-called real world.

by oz_media

I do see your point and understand where you're coming from, it's actually quite saddening.

"Seriously, though, the military IS a rite of passage: it teaches discipline, chain of command, responsibility - things that come in handy in the so-called real world."

When living in England I was with the ATC (Air training core) but it was sorta like air cadets.
I had already learned discipline, respect, "chain of command" I respected my elders, aand definitely responsibility from my parents. They didn't rely on a government organization to feed, pay and teach me the basics of beoming a contributing member of society. I found out the so-called "REAL WORLD" actually IS a real world, not the military.

It used to be up to the parents to instill such things in thier children. I've seen others comment on how parents are always looking to blame the government for not teaching their children right from wrong. Perhaps because they are raised with the frame of mind that the military will make you a man, not your parents. VERY weak at the very least.

Thanks for your comments though!

by jimhm

The military teaches a number of things:

1) Discipline
2) Respect
3) Accepting responsibility for your own actions
4) Discipline
5) Respect for leadership
6) Ability to follow commands

They also educate the recruite - in language, technologies, medical, mechinics whatever their field or MOS will be.

You may not like the military or the way it does things - but until you lived it, and found the life values and life experences that are gained from it, you will never understand it. I am not saying - you can't talk about it until you walked it ... you just will never understand it.

You will never understand the meaning of "Code and Honor" - which is a sad thing, but that was your choice to miss out on great times.

by oz_media

I really do feel that I missed out on the whole Vietnam male bonding thing, yet again I never needed it. I grew up in East Vancouver (BC's Bronx or East LA). Many of my friends and thier brothers were either related to or in a well known East Vancouver motorcycle 'club'.

i've been in some life threatening situations where I have relied on my 'brothers' to hold my back as I would have for them. Your Code and Honor isn't just found in the army. The only difference is that in war you have rules and regulations, in street combat you don't.

Vancouver is notorious for it's East Van gangs (long before the Blood and Crypt stuff that followed)that were up against the first strings of the Triads and other Asian gangs, as it still is but the East Van gangs are no more.

I know that being in a battlefield and being in a street fight aer not the same at all, but the fear and reality of death is. Don't be so flattered that you got to find out in a foreign country instead of your own backyard.

Nobody denies that the military offers decent training and that the educational and trade programs are also effective. My father was an engineer in Singapore and Korea, he kept the tanks rolling and the aircraft starting. He then went home to England and finished his other trade apprenticeships, machining, civil AND marine engineering as well as others, you need them to live in England, there are no free rides.

This isn't my point though. Canadians also have a military, remember they are the ones trying to clean up in Afghanistan after you've moved on, but that doesn't count, we aren't involved in wars here, we just smoke dope and whine about the US... just ask anyone.

the difference between Canada's military and the US is that:
1) we are usually liked and accepted into other countries, we have a solid reputation for fixing problems and working with our allies.

2) We don't parade the streets showing off our military, they are too busy putting out fires, helping the Red Cross to deliver supplies into war zones and rasing money for to gas up THE tank.

3) It isn't looked upn as a rite of passage here. Most will say, "You're in the Canadian Army? Sorry to hear that, when do you get out?"

We are proud of what our military has done, a MASSIVE WWII presence alongside the British. Humanitarian efforts worldwide and those neat displays in the mall each year, cool!

When we see American military, they are killing EACH OTHER (often portrayed as a 1:1 ratio with enemy kills), they are getting car bombed and spat on by whoever they are there to 'save', and always thinking they are the worlds best at walking, running, fighting, smiling, farting, drinking, getting laid, and more than anything WAVING THE FLAG as well as anything else a human does in a day. They portray themselves as the best but we are yet to see why.

There's an advantage to being humble sometimes, people can accept it.

But you are right on one thing, I sure did miss the "good ole days" of laying in a wet rice paddy, sharing BS with another guy sitting in the same wet rice paddy, having no idea what I was doing in a wet rice paddy to begin with and coming home to be spit on by my neighbours.
Ah yes, the good times, sigh.

OM

by fluxit

First, I work in an environment where we refer to each other as Mister as a sign of homage and respect. It is a carry over from intelluctual conversations.

Second, I tend to be metaphoric is my conversations from time to time. The weakness of these forums is that it requires one to preface remarks so that others can fully understand and appreciate them but in our rush to post a remark we sometimes assume others are also following along. These forums also require one to use lay language as well.

Third, I was being facetious in my remarks regarding female who could kick a guys ass and males who could dress and sing like Barbara Streisand. The lesibian/homosexual debate. Having the knowledge of eithers behavior contributes nothing positive and the skills of a woman being able to wrestle a guy or a Guy to sing like Barbara Streisand are not skills that really advance society. There are better things they could being doing with thier time.

by jimhm

I am also not trying to gender bash - but it just gets me that some of these women want it both ways. They want the right to server in the frontlines of battle - but at the sametime, have the choice of not going or doing the job.

First - I support women going to the frontlines - all women in the services. I believe that a well trained female is as good or sometimes better than her male counter part. And just like all men in the services have no choice, they have no choice. Your primary job is to carry a weapon and kill the emeney, all your other duties come second.

Second - If they want 1, then they should also register for the draft at the age of 18. Oh its such a great experence watching them pull birth dates and numbers live on TV. (Mine was 18, and they were drafting up to 254 in 1971, mom started crying. Dad said what are you going to do ... I elisted in the Navy - better than being drafted into the Army.)

If women want the Combat Role - they must except all the benefits that go with it ... Draft, Death, Dismemberment, Disability, PTSS, Medals, and the memory of the ememeies faces that you killed. You accept one - you accept them all. No picking and choosing - unless both sides get the same choices. Fair and Balanced -

Thats is my whole point - if they want one they have to take all - All the good and all the bad, and I can't think of many good things about being in a fire fight, or living in the field for a month - but I do have a long list of bad events. Ask any vet - they will remember the good times in the field - they try not to remember the other stuff.

by oz_media

It seems that you as many other here so often do, will refuse to answer a question and simply slam the poster instead.

I answered YOUR points and then asked questions, why don't you try to be a man and do the same?

If you can't support your statements without just slamming the poster you have NO credibility as a voice to be heard.

So open the books and get at it, you have some work to do I think. Before attempting to just defame my post you must first have some credibility, you can't even support your own accusations!

by oz_media

JIM:

You said: "Logic and rational go out the window with women. They run a pure emotion when pissed. (a majority are like that - not all)"

PROVE IT. Don't assume it.

You then said: "(Not all men - but a majority) On the other hand because men don't run on emotions - we use cold logic - think through the problem - develop a solution and alternative - then execute. We just don't sit down and cry and scream that it wasn't fair - "

AGAIN, PROVE IT

Mr.MIAMI:

Your statements about posting formats aer very true, I've been taught over time on how people want to see questions answered. Unfortunately the peron who 'educated' me on this rarely does it himself, but that's niether here, nor there.
You're right, people sould be able to follow a thread, it's not brain surgery. But sometimes posts get mixed up and split up so further clarity is needed.

Your statements abot MEN/Women Barbara and the WWF are so far off kilter it's not funny, I won't even go there because I think I understand your frame of mind regarding the basic roles for each and don't want this to become a religious discussion again.

As for your referring to sdomeone as mister, I THINK I know what you're saying, it's the same as addressing a male friend as sir.

You do realize however that meacuff is NOT a man though, right?
So 'to be curt', addressing her as Maam would be more appropriate.

OM

by oz_media

For answering that question on my behalf. It's always nice to be spoken for, especially by someone with no similar beliefs!

Your POST although gathered from fact is sompletely Maxwell to the Max.

You had a nice little and quite eloquent post about England NOT accepting women in the army, then another post that you OBVIOUSLY disagreed with which is shown by your pronouns used to describe those involved, it's freakin hilarious just how biased your "statement" can be.

You said: "which included feminist, Jane Banfield Haynes, a sociologist at Toronto's York University,"

NOTE, you were VERY careful to attach the political label to these people whom you don't agree with, as always, tiny mind Max.

followed by "Completely ignoring the Canadian Forces' own studies that had results similar to the 2002 British study," Again, listen to the Military, they are the voice to be heard.

And again "it concluded that feminist ideology should hold sway"

Continuing on: "She, of course, did not want the sisterhood descending upon her head by allowing an appeal of this decision."

An ssumption? Who are these 'sisters'? ( I assume you mean the feminist movement They don't hold a political stad in your eyes?

Just more agressive hairy-man pro-Republican crap from Maxwell.

Your entire existence and human values are held based on a persons political beliefs.

In Canada we don't think that way, other than "a Republican is a killer", based on the Republican actions seen coming from the USA lately. If you asked many Canadians what political party BUSH represented I think you'd be amazed at how few actually know and even more amazed at how few actually care, WE DON"T GIVE A CRAP WHO YOUR REPRESENT, IT'S WHAT YOU DO THAT METTERS!!! I know it's hard to fathom, peolpe who DON'T put politics before people, but it's a reality. I've NEVER in my life been asked what party or political stand I take, by a Canadian. We just don't judge each otehr that way. Probably another reason we are at war less often.

The first time I was asked what my political preference was (not asked but told) was by YOU, I still don't know if you're wrong or right and I really dno't care, neither does anyone else.

We just watch what people do, we aren't going accept or reject someone based on their political preference, just the actions of the peolpe themslves.

NOTE: To Canadians that DO care, I am speaking of the general population here not the chosen few.

So Max, it is VERY hard for you to comprehend, if not comletely impossible, but nobody cares if yuo are Republican, Democrat, Socialist, Liberal or whatever. If you're a Republican and F*&% UP, you're an asshole. If You're a Democrat and F*$# UP. yuo're still an asshole. We aren't going to make exceptions just because we believe repubicans or democrats are right or wrong, "it's the ACTIONS not the BELIEFS that count."

Now go a recite that last line until you understand it.

I almost forgot:
You are the the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

Can't actually offer a response without stooping to flame the messenger too.
See, I'm learning from you!

by oz_media

Well done Jim, you actually offered a SOMEWHAT relevant answer. You at least had read and partially understood my opst, well done, I'll counter now.

My point was simply that Americans are slammig Jessica for her actions, I feel that if she were a man, you wold be supporting her actions as others questioned them.

What your Armies policies are on the matter are irrelevant, except that fact that you feel it would've been handled differently if she was a man. I don't know either way how they handle these things but that wasn't my comment. It was regarding people in these discussions, but your point was made. I do also feel that she should suffer the same military repercussions that ANY soldier would. She's not a woman, and you're not a man in he Army, you are soldiers and should be treated as soldiers.

My point was that Peolpe here aer criticizing her for not firing and being captured, by demeaning her as an incapable women doing a mans job. (WOW, 70's flaskback)
I think that is she were a man, and I was comlpaniing that she never fired her weapon and was captured, you'd all be up in arms about how I wouldn't know or understand unless i was there, how people who fight for YOUR freedom should be honored ad not put down, how I'm a Canadian and don't have a say in the matter etc. You would defend your brother but not your sister.

Thus my statement that when the tables are tuurned, the testosterone flows the other way.

by passwordchanged

for once I agree with sometying you've said - the real problem here is that we got into this stupid war in the first place

by onbliss

People might join Defense Services for many reasons. They might have never known if they would be courageous or a coward in the battles.

We have to pay our respects, as civilians, to those people in combat, whether they are courageous or not.

I do not know exactly if Jessica was a Coward, nobody but she will know that. As far as 'Hero', that word has been overused in our day to day life.

Well, looks like she has seized the opportunity (I am not saying opportunistic) to make some name and money. Nothing wrong in it. If others have not done it....well it is their choice.

We as a society, have given her the OPPORTUNITY. We put her on the stage and we should not be complaining about it. Hope she acts well and earns her 15 minutes fame.

by oz_media

Seems to be that as opposed to answering a question with a logical or even statistical answer, once again you've decided to "side-setp" the issue and forget you wre involved im the first place.

Kinda like a kid who covers his eyes, I can't see you so you can't see me.

You once showed some knowledge (or were percieved to show some knowledge), but now you simply blame the poster and refrain from answering the question at hand.

I can assume that even with this post, yuo will simply come up with some more crap to sling instead of answering a question that you were adamantly objecting to.

It's typical, just like the Pres. If you ignore it, it will go away. If it doesn't, just keep ignoring it, it still might go away.

You should know me better than that by now, you've made so many statements regarding my character and beliefs.

Either that or you've simply found out that you didn't have a leg to stand on, never have and probably never will unless you open your mind to the rest of the world around your little existence.

ther's an easy way out, just agree and then add your little tag line about ...

Here, I'll do it for you:
"And you figured out all these things just by being the all-wise, all knowing, always correct expert on anything and everything, especially anything and everything concerning your neighbor to the south, so you must be right and those who disagree must be wrong - and "closed minded".

I really like it, you're so creative for a closed minded little old man.

by wordworker

I guess if you frame it in a way that says, "go into the Military to become something/anything" (like the great Todd Rundgren LP set), it might be saddening. However, I'm not sure why you spin it that way. The armed forces experience isn't a cookie-cutter thing that's the same for everyone.

I learned to respect my elders from my parents and grandfather the old-fashioned way - a whippin' if I misbehaved. I learned chain of command when I went to work for $0.65/hour in '72 at a fast-food restaurant. I became "a man" thanks to a sweet young thing named Jenny. LOL

So no one in my life relied on the government to do anything for me. I signed up to see what it was all about. I worked side-by-side with guys who didn't have any family to speak of, and guys who avoided jail by joining, but all in all, the people I served with were professionals. They didn't see a career in the Army as any different than working 20 years for GM or Ford (like my dad did). It was to them just a job with decent pay, decent benefits, and a pension if you lasted long enough.

Like I said, I got in because at 23 the $3,000 signing bonus sounded like a godsend, I was bored with being a full-time college student and working full-time. The closest I ever got to the "sh**" was when the zealots bombed our Marine compound in Lebanon. Because of my MOS (militaryoccupational specialty) I was put on alert and could have been summoned to go baby go. Fortunately, I guess, I didn't get sent out.

All that said, the military is or ought to be a great learning experience, and lots of immature boys and girls go in and come out stronger, smarter, and better equipped to do a good job in the civilian world. That's all I'm saying. Is it a panacea for what ails our society? Hell no. I mean, we can all see what serving in 'nam did to our boy JimHM's attitude...

by road-dog

but then I wasn't looking for it either. It seems that if you are looking for something, you will find it...whether it exists or not. This applies to racism, sexism, and any number of other "isms".

As for ferocity, many men are not geared for it socially. Men in the US have been "feminized" by cultural pressures in the name of political correctness and "gender equality". My wife says she's glad that my "female side" appears to be a flaming lesbian.

The DOD makes a point of instilling the ability to kill by shooting man shaped targets and realistic training scenarios. The killing instinct has been socially beaten down for generations. The military brings it back up to just below the surface, where it will be available if necessary.

This is essential, because our troops need to be ready as they can be. Needless to say, there are lots of places in the world where the killer instinct has been encouraged from birth. When our troops go into harm's way they must not be paralyzed while the other guy gets in the first shot....

by oz_media

and an accurate one at that.

Off topic but your post made it pop into my head:
I have actually (not in a state of war) had someone pull a gun on me. The only mistake the guy made was not pulling the trigger. I guess he froze while considering consequences.

Bottom line, if you're going to carry a gun, be prepared to use it. If not, don't carry a gun.

If you are prepared to use it, make sure the first shot counts, you may not get a second.

Lastly, if you do carry a gun (again not in war) you're a complete pussy. Men don't need guns to fight, or at lest they never used to. When I grew up, anyone with a weapon was a loser, learn how to fight without a weapon it makes a much stronger statement than a drive by.

by thechas

Guru,

You may be seeing a number of people who could not get a job elsewhere.

The sad reality here in the US is that many entry level jobs now require a college education.

For a large number of individuals, the only option that they have to pay for college is to use the money they can get after 2 years of military service.

If you are not:
From a rich family;
A sports super-star;
VERY smart

There are few options available to pay for college without going into a LOT of debt.

The military sells itself as a way to get money for college.
My own son (who is not Marine material) thought joining the Marines would be a good way to get money for college. Until, his mother and I explained to him what he was committing to.

Don't get me wrong, I was not opposed to the idea of him joining the military. I just know that he would not make it through basic training in the Marines.

Chas

by jardinier

Having successfully failed at most of life's expected norms: university; marriage; kids; material success; I wouldn't swap my life for worlds. I KNOW that I have experienced many things that most people only read about in fiction.

As a pseudo-hippie drop-out in the sixties, I lived a whole lifetime of mental, emotional and spiritual experiences that was like having an additional bonus life.

I've had a variety of jobs; relationships with girls from across the social spectrum; I've expressed most of my experiences in poetry or song; I've been beaten up; I've been thrown in gaol; I've been on the brink of madness; I've loved and laughed; I've exerienced agonising emptiness. But I AM the sum total of my experiences, and I'm more than happy to be me.

I'm still here -- everyday is a new, unexpected adventure.

by guruofdos

Yes, Britain DOES permit women in combat roles, but there are various rules and regulations, and certain criteria must be met!

For several years now, women have been allowed to go to sea with the Royal Navy. The Womens Royal Naval Service (WRNS), or 'Wrens' as they are fondly known, now carry out active combat duties on ships at sea. This has caused two interesting reactions.

1) The biggest protest against Wrens at sea wasn't combat related. It actually came from servicemens wives, complaining that if they went to sea for months at a time then their menfolk would be 'tempted to stray' if there were females on boards ship.

2) From a practical point of view, women's FACES are very different from mens. Not just size and shape, but bone sructure. This causes a problem. One of the most important safety issues on board a modern fighting ship is damage control and firefighting. Hard lessons learned during the Falklands conflict have been implemented following the destruction of ships by missiles. The explosions weren't the problem, but firefighting was. Ships can only carry a limited amount of equipment, and ANY person on board must be able to fight a fire in any compartment. Firefighting masks and oxygen equipment designed to fit a man will NOT fit a woman. The bone structure of the female head is the problem! Ships now have a problem of either carrying two sets of masks in every compartment which means doubling up on equipment and a consequent rediction in storage space. In an emergency situation with loss of power and a fire on board, it is now possible to grab the wrong kit in the heat of the moment (pardon the pun) and as a consequence, valuable time and efficiency is lost.

There is also a psychological issue. Fighting men take their chances. Women have a much lower threshold of pain and shock sets in faster in women, therefore injured women are more of a liability than injured men and need more assistance in battle than their male counterparts.

by wordworker

You're cracking me up! Okay, so I buy into the theory I would sell pix of some chix for the right money. That might be cool if I were selling to an online purveyor of you-know-what kind of pictures. But in this case, if I were the guys who sold THIS girl's pictures, I guess I might worry that somebody from the girl's camp might seek retribution if they found out... And I'll bet she knows exactly who took them, so it's probably a short list of the usual suspects.

by fluxit

My regrets for calling Maecuff a Mister.

Mr Oz, I have given you a humanist viewpoint of social order and you have rejected that. I have not given you a faith based viewpoint. You appear to be begging for one each time you say you don't want a religious viewpoint. At any rate, you will reject that one too. I am not certain you know what you believe. It appears to be an incomplete thought off the top of your head just because it sounds good to you.

by fluxit

I read about Women's emotion strength as a character trait. I read about cold logic as a man's character trait.

Intelligence is broken into down by most psychologist and educators into 7 or 8 distinct areas. This came from a acclaimed book written in the 1960's called 'Frames of Mind'. In short, some of these intelligences target more of an IQ, intelligence quotient, and other intelligences target more of an EQ, emotional quotient. A well balnced individual strives to develop each intelligence but most people have only a notable strength in 1 or 2 intelligences. In terms of gender, men tend to be centered on the IQ and women tend to center on the EQ.

But then we arrive at a situation where the psychological makeup of the genders, as espoused by you already, is different. Thus in the battlespace a differential is formed. We are no longer in a situation where everything can be boiled down to tactic and skill to dominate the enemy.

I suppose we need to make a decision as a society. Do we want the batlespace to be an ultimate WWF match or a cat fight?

by jimhm

So for a Million dollars American - or 1.4 million Canadain - you would destroy them or keep them for private viewing only... Thats cool Max -

But sorry I would Past Go - and Collect $1,000,000.00 - then retire to the islands.

by maxwell edison

Jim,

I'd like to think that I would not sell the pictures - or sell my principles, but not being faced with that decision and potential outcome, I must admit that I'm not sure.

IF is a big word, and IF faced with such a dilemma, do any of us know how we would really act? We know how we would "like" to act, but.......

by fluxit

I am hearing a common theme of people becoming moderate and not having a position based on sound principle. In sorts, having discussed the partisan (male or female) viewpoints many of you have arrived at a 'modicum of outcomes'. Yet many of you began with a principled belief, at least in part, then abandoned it to arrive at this 'modicum of outcomes'. Many of you phrased your principles as 'gender bashing' or 'extremist viewpoints' in the end.

Have any of you thought why you had those principles at first? Do you feel that the negotiated belief is better than the principles? What happened to those principles?

I saw comments to the effect that the endstate was critical to how the force was structured. Did you know that the Combatant Commander, a 4-Star General / Admiral, has three things he states on the outset of any military action and one of them is Endstate. This determines the force type and structure.

In Congress in the early 90's during the congressional caucus debates, the issues were never really the ones you people debated. They debated force composition, structure, who is our would be adversary, does the female cause the battlespace to become kiltered?, and what are the social impacts. Because congress at the time was mostly Democraps a social agenda was espoused and not one truly focused on principles. Yes - it is true the Democraps rarely pursue our founding principles they mostly spin sound good beliefs. In fact, thier party platform states very little about our Constitutional Government. Read it.

Do any of you recall the fierce female Israeli fighter pilots of the 1980's? Where are they today? The Israeli's removed them from the cockpit. They determined them to be ineffective in combat. Their kill ratio was too low.

During World War II the Russians had entire Brigades of female combatants. Where did they go after the war? For the Cold War years, they had hospitatilty ships loaded with women to sex the males on the combatants.

The Amazonian Tribes were warfighting women solely. Where are the Amazonian Tribes today? Did thier leadership make anything of thier future?

The point being if women desired and could perform in these roles just as equally as males why hasn't history shown us this? If you say macho men suppressed them then you are confirming that women do not have the will or capability to assemble the necessary force then rise up and defeat these macho men. As they would have to do today in the battlespace. What has changed in women for that to occur in modern times that was not there in the past? They burnt thier bras and pased laws? Laws work well in war. I am sure our enemy is compelled to be law abiding. Afterall, we saw that with Sadam and these terrorist.

I think many us need to really assess the best roles for the genders then work refocus society. Afterall, if we are to learn from the Amazonians let us have the leadership to build a brighter future for America for our unborn citizens.

by jimhm

I can sell them - it is up to hussler to get the rights to publish them. - its becomes a problem when someone publishes them.

Speaking of which - how do the Provarotic (SP) get away with all those canaded photos of all those movie stars and political figures - topless or nude. Do they get into trouble - nope.

by Member 31238153

Not her, Hollywood!...they're the stoopid ones...Famous for re-writing History (Braveheart, The Enigma File) to name but a few.

In their 'made for TV' docu-crap, they show the young lady firing off an entire M-16 Magazine at the 'Iraqi Dirtbags'.....funny that, cos apparently, they gave up without a fight!

Maybe the Iraqi's captured them for their own safety?...To avoid an F-16 Pilot, from dropping a 1,000lb bomb on them?

by ewgny

Unfortunately the openings in the gas rings don't stay positioned apart, they will rotate
during use. and if the openings line up you're F'd. The M16 is a fair weather gun, it can be temperamental with different rounds, and the forward assist feature is an afterthought joke. The fact is, the M16 does fail, and it always has. Our service men/woman deserve better. War isn't fought on a clean shooting bench at the range, it's fought in the sand, water mud etc.

by oz_media

I originally thought the same way Max.

You would like to THINK you'd do the right thing but it is a big IF whenit's just speculation.

Then I thought about it a bit, I actually THINK I would just cash in, but most likely 'IF' I was in the situation I'd probably end up doing the right thing and not share them.

by road-dog

both with the SS109 rounds and blanks with BFA. Never had a malfunction that would not clear by manual ejection using the charging handle. The next round always went downrange just fine.

As for the gas rings, If you are cleaning your weapon as often as you are supposed to, and performing an inspection before the day's firing, then the gas ring is one of the things you look for.

One could make the case that anything is unreliable, if the user is the problem.....

by jimhm

True - IF is a big word, If she was a friend of mine, or if she was an old girlfriend or if she was someone I still cared about.... Then my answer would be different .. No Sale ... Private Viewing only...

But IF - is like Clinton's what does IS mean ...

by maxwell edison

.
...that dumped you just after you were beginning to think that things were going well, and just after you dropped a couple of C-Notes on that steak and lobster dinner with wine and all the trimmings at the most exclusive place in town?

by mrbill-

Jim,

What IF you were in a combat situation with this guy? Could you trust his integrity if he says, ?Ya, I got your back?. Until he see a bunch of bad guys coming, then it?s every man for himself. Besides it's a lot of money, what does trust mean to a rich guy.

by road-dog

WEAPONS OF THE WORLD: Testing the 6.8mm M-16

http://www.strategypage.com/fyeo/howtomakewar/default.asp?target=htweap.htm

The shortcomings of the 5.56 round are being addresed. Politically, adoption of this round in the US inventory will signal a departure from NATO efforts to adopt common rounds for NATO members to simplify logistics in war.

I wonder if this is such a signal or what the ramifications will be within NATO. Personally, I think that NATO's time has pretty much gone with the fall of the Soviet Union. I suspect that Germany will eventually pay for their recalcitrance on Iraq by the removal of American forces such as has occurred in Saudi Arabia. This is a good thing, as the US foots the bill for billions on advanced deployments and we should definitely reward allies with these lucrative deployments and remove troops from nations that oppose us. Turkey jammed the US on the northern front last March. I think that their foreign and military aid should be reviewed and cut....

NATO membership is not enough reason to spend billions of dollars in maintaining forces unnecessarily.

by jimhm

There's a slight difference there - I think I would have more problems trusting and putting my life in Jessicas hands than the guy that sold the photos. When you are only pulling down $35 or $40K a year - $1,000K is a pretty good pay check.

The question may go to integrity more so than Trust - and that would depend on if she was an x-girl friend, a one nighter, a drunk fling, a quickie, a groupie - in short what did she mean to the guy or girl that sold the pictures.

Now there's a hell of a WiF(What If) - it was another female that took the photos and sold them - maybe the guy was having a little 3 way...

by mrbill-

What was she to whoever sold the photos? She was a fellow solder. Are you saying it?s ok to sell out another trooper if the price is right? I?m glad you were not in MY Air Force. Who knows what you would do for $$$$. Can someone like that be trusted with national security info? Not in my eyes. I am also glad you served your country when you were younger and not as money hungry as you are now or we may have seen your face alongside of Hanoi Jane?s.

by jimhm

Oh - you was one of those - "Baby Killer" - "Hanoi Jane Lover" - "Pussy" - "Couldn't fire a weapon if your life or buddies live dependent on it" ...

Yo dude - you and Oz are in the same class - Attack the person because they don't agree with you .. and I would bet you never served a day in your life ... or maybe you are having a little touch of alzhimers or dementa setting in.

All I can say sir is we agree to disagree - if that isn't good enough for you - then Bless You.

by oz_media

Cmon Jim, you're gettnig a little hot under the collar and as a result are stuggling to grasp for straws.

"Yo dude - you and Oz are in the same class - Attack the person because they don't agree with you .."

Insulting someone by comparing them to me is not nice. What did he do to you?

The statement in itself is an attack on HIS character as opposed to HIS opinion. Not too mention you're pigeon holing him as a person who protested your return from Vietnam. Again very assumtpive attack on HIS character not his opinions.

I can't even begin to imagine the horrors that you may have witnessed in Vietnam. A close friend of mine (recently passed, God bless his soul)was a Mercenary he had seen some pretty horrific things too. I'm sure it is impossible to forget and will stay with you forever. We remember the actions of our Veterans each year as we have since the end of WWII.

To be reminded of your actions on a daily basis as you use it to support your credibility regarding today's presidential actions is getting tiring.

I know you fought for your country, you still do on a daily basis. What you don't seem to understand is people are not attacking your country, just the idiot who is running it for a few years. Get over it, BUSH ain't no hero.

I don't think America is bad and American's aren't bad, it's the ones who follow the presidents every word and take his carefully written press conferences as a religious sermon that get to me.

Let's assume that BUSH IS right in everything he says, let's assume he is the worlds most important and clever commander.

HE'S STILL A POLITICIAN!!! WHO THE HELL CARES WHAT HE SAYS ANYHOW!!!
Did he turn the heat up when you were cold last night? Did he come and pour your coffee today? No. He isn't effecting your life today, let him run the country and kill your families all in good time. Saying that even if you disagree with him you'd still supoprt him just goes to show how you are blindly following the leader. Tag someone else and play a new game.

before yuo go ranting at how I'm crazy and on drugs, try reading and actually trying to understand a point this time, I'm not going to reiterate for you again.

by mrbill-

SIR! Think before you go labeling me one of your ?convenient? hate tags.

I entered the US Air Force on delayed enlistment on 16 Nov 1976, I graduated high school in 1977 and went on active duty on 1 Aug of that year. I retired on 1 Sep 1998 as a Master Sergeant (E-7). That is 21 years of my life given to the service of MY country. I have been deployed to numerous locations in the defense of freedom, many classified. I am a Gulf War Vet. I am disabled due to events that happened while on active duty. I have taken lives I am sorry to say. But I would do it again if I had to. I have also seen friends lose theirs.

I am sorry the Nam vets were treated poorly on their return home. My older brother is a Nam vet, his son will be deploying to Iraq in Jan. Am I happy to see him go over there? NO. Many of my three older sister?s friends served in Nam, some died, some were wounded, all suffered in some way. While I was young I remember them coming home and I said thank you to them. One of my cousins was killed as an ?advisor? early in the conflict, before the draftees got invited to join. I am not saying the draftees are any less soldiers, I know many who were drafted and highly repect them. The got "forced" to serve but served well indeed.

Be careful of who you accuse of not being a patriot! Labels can come back to bite you on the ...!

by mrbill-

I'm sorry you got me on a roll.

From my post:
"... I am also glad you served your country "WHEN" you were younger and not as money hungry as you are "NOW" or we "MAY HAVE" seen your face alongside of Hanoi Jane?s? " (Emphasis added.)

I was not accusing you of any improprieties while you were serving your country in Nam. I was just making a comment that if $$$ was as important to you then than it appears now I do not think I would/could have trusted you. If you have a price someone will pay it.

I am NOT accusing you of being unpatriotic. I am just saying if you will sell nude photos of another GI what else would you sell, if the price was right.

DO NOT class me with Oz! He appears to be a US hating foreigner (who has a right to think however he wishes). I am NOT! I did not "attack" you. I just wanted to know where you stood on integrity.

"Oh - you was one of those - "Baby Killer" - "Hanoi Jane Lover" - "Pussy" - "Couldn't fire a weapon if your life or buddies live dependent on it" ... "

I have no idea how to respond to this drivel. "Baby Killer" was a comment shouted to the returning Nam vets, as I was young then and very set on a military life I would never have used it. "Hanoi Jane Lover" not even close, she still has much to atone for. "P?." don?t think so, unless? "Couldn't fire a weapon if your life or buddies live dependent on it" Can?t and won?t comment more than I already have.

by jimhm

I guess it just comes down to - Do you believe in what Alvin York said - or Audie Murphy did...

York - said he wouldn't sell his story because the Uniform wasn't for sale.

Murphy - highest decorated enlisted in wwII - star'ed in his own story - From Hell and Back - which was one of the highest grossing movies until Jaw's...

I guess Jessica took the Murphy road and made some money ...

This discussion is closed to new replies.