Discussion Locked

Is the King James Bible the true Word of God?

0 helpful
173 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Now please do not even THINK of posting until you have thoroughly read this article:

http://www.bible.org/page.asp?page_id=665

And a quick note to the resident atheists: this discussion is NOT about whether or not there is a God or whether Christianity is a good religion.

It IS about how a document can become corrupted or altered during almost two millennia of translating, copying, and comparison with more recently discovered manuscripts.

173 replies

by jaqui

The True word of God would have to be what Jesus wrote.

everything else is some human beings interpretation.

and Jesus never wrote anything down, because he didn't know how to write.

* Just for the sake of arguement accepting that Jesus is god, since I'm not christain, he isn't god to me.

by jardinier

I have been associated with various Christian churches all my life but have never really considered myself to be a Christian.

However because I know so much about that religion I can readily pass myself off as a Christian and as a change of pace from TR I have been participating in theological discussions at two Christian websites.

You are quite correct of course in that none of the books of the New Testament were written until 40 years or more after the "death" of Jesus.

How could anyone remember accurately detailed conversations after 40 years?

The same applies to Hinduism and Buddhism. Everything was transmitted orally for centuries before being written down.

However I am sure you have heard of the story tellers of various "primitive" societies, and so perhaps without all the distractions of modern society they could in fact pass on precise records of what was done and said.

by jaqui

the "traditional" means of passing on information was verbal, and most religions actually beleive that any religion that is written down has been killed.
all religous ceremonies become dead rituals when it is hard copy, as the soul of the person performing it can't be expressed. a living religon isn't written and is followed differently by each persaon, as they hear the words and understand them differently than the person beside them does.
that difference is not a cause of friction, it's a reason to celebrate, as by discussing the different understandings you have you can increase your understanding.

by protiusx

Why on earth would you "associated with various Christian churches all my life" if you are so convinced that the very foundation of the Christian Church is not true? How utterly ridiculous.
As for the books of the New Testament - How did Peter die? How did Paul die? How did Thomas die? Could there be anything in life so dramatic and life altering that one would be compelled to remember it for the rest of their lives? How about WWI veterans? I think they remember vivid details of their experiences well beyond the forty year mark.

by computab

The words came from God, eg see Jeremiah, 'Write this for these words are trustworthy and true'. Moses wrote the first 5 books of the Bible, but he was only the emanuensis!

by jacksonian

Jardinier,

If you think you can readily pass yourself off as a christian, I could spot you easily as a wolf in sheeps clothing.

The early biblical teachings, that predate the printing press and other such means of mass media production, didnt need to rely on afformentioned methodologies to ensure that knowledge was passed on. The septuagint (ancient Greek translation of the Jewish scriptures) and contents of the torah was passed on orally from generation to generation. Since the jewish people are the bearers of the law of moses, their ability to memorize, recite and pass on this knowledge is beyond reproach. Its a spritual obligation that non-spiritual people would have a hard time understanding the importance or the relevance of being able to inerrantly speak the words and the laws of God.

The same can be said about the apostles. They knew the early jewish traditions and the importance of ensuring that Gods work was recorded, preserved and passed on.

?Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have.? 1 Peter 3:15

by protiusx

Your first statement is that the "true word of God" would be the writtings of Jesus and yet you say your not a christian. These two statements conflict with one another. If he is not God then he could not have spoken nor written the word of God.

by jaqui

this in specific.

* Just for the sake of arguement accepting that Jesus is god, since I'm not christain, he isn't god to me.

by computab

jesus wrote in the sand at the arrest of the 'woman taken in adultery' He was trained in carpentry which required some measurement & writing.

by jaqui

is the entire christain faith based on other people's writing?
if it's about jesus, use the words he wrote only.

what each of the people who heard him speak is different, as no two people will hear something the same.

by rknrlkid

That makes us assume that anyone in other than our "modern" time is ignorant and illiterate. This is patently untrue. The Roman Empire had written records, and children went to school to learn to read, write, and to learn math and science. In the Jewish culture, children also went to local schools. Jewish males HAD to know how to read and write in Hebrew in order to take their place in their religious society. Just to live in the occupied Palestine, Jesus was probably tri-lingual (Koine Greek, Latin and Hebrew).

I think Jesus didn't write anything because of different reasons. For one, the teacher didn't write things down, the disciple did. Plus, he wasn't stupid. An autograph (i.e., original hand written manuscript) in his own hand would have been worshiped in the later years, which was distinctly forbidden in the 10 commandments. So it makes perfect sense to me.

Most of the arguments against Christian writings assumes (knowingly or unknowingly) that the Judeo/Christian God is pretty ignorant and is unable to be consistent within His own principles. But that isn't reasonable. Context is everything.

by waterstone

The argument regarding his being an aspect of deity aside, the historical Jesus would most certainly know how to write. He was a well-schooled individual in both his Judaic studies and his business studies.

by michael_orton9

Jaqui,
Its almost certain that Jesus would have been able to both read and write.
After all he is mentioned as being called up to read in a Syangogue.
The standard of eduction amongst middle class Jews in Israel was only reached in the UK in the late 1800s.
Apart from Hebrew, he probably had some understanding of Greek and Latin and of course the local dialect of Aramaic, which was written in Hebrew letters.
The only difference between then and a modern Shule would be the paper and the pointing for the vowels, these cam about after the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem.

by jacksonian

Jaqui,

I know I shouldnt even comment on your post, but I cant let you wallow you in your ignorance ...

from John 8:7-8

8:7 So when they continued asking him, he lifted up himself, and said unto them, He that is without sin among you, let him first cast a stone at her.

8:8 And again he stooped down, and wrote on the ground.

by protiusx

My friend this horse has been beaten, pulverized, pur?ed, and spread over toast along time ago.

I think what you?re after is the authenticity of the Christian Scripture and there have been huge tomes written about the subject.

Ultimately for one to believe that a written document is in fact the ?word of God? one needs to first believe that there is a God and then one must believe that he inspired the writing of his Word. The Bible itself is a work of faith. Simply put if you choose not to believe then it can not be rationalized to you.

Pearls before swine.

by Member 25348569

I think that Julian's question is not on the authenticity of the Bible at all. I read it that the article writer feels that King James Version, one of the most popular and most quoted, is full of errors and differences from the "original" works.

Not an act of faith in any way - unless you believe that the translator and typesetters were guided by God also.

But then, you God-botherers can manage that sort of thing with your eyes closed, can't you?

by protiusx

The title of the post is "Is the King James Bible the true Word of God?" It doesn't get much clearer than that. The linked article does talk about different versions of the Bible but the author explicitly states his beliefs at the beginning of the article.

Answer this though; why would someone who as admitted they are not a Christian care about the different versions of their holy book?

by protiusx

So I guess the Jewish Torah which has existed for thousands of years is untraditional. Is this just your belief or did you pick this up some where?

From this we can say that all the Jewish feasts are dead rituals. I think the Jews might have something to say about this.

by jaqui

you are correct, any religion that has written the beleif structure down has taken the soul out of the ceremoonies and turned them into DEAD RITES.

the soul[s] of the person[s] performing the rites are not in them, since there is no deviation from what is written allowed.

by protiusx

Is this your personal belief or did you read this somewhere. I disagree with you of course but I think you already knew that.

by jacksonian

Jaqui,

Your statement that "any religion that has written the beleif structure down has taken the soul out of the ceremonies and turned them into DEAD RITES" may apply to pagan beliefs such as wicca, but not christianity or judaism.

Can I take this a step further and imply that since you believe this way ("the soul[s] of the person[s] performing the rites are not in them, since there is no deviation from what is written allowed") you dont realize the nature of God? Why would there be a deviation if the content is the truth? Since the truth is the claim, there isnt any room, nor was there intended to be, for deviation.

On top of that, "since there is no deviation from what is written allowed", does that mean that our country is a dead country? Since none of the constituational framers are still alive, I guess we are not really living in America anymore ...

(And put in this context, things are beginning to make sense ...)

by protiusx

The title of the article you referenced is ?Why I Do Not Think the King James Bible Is the Best Translation Available Today?

His first sentence states ?First, I want to affirm with all evangelical Christians that the Bible is the Word of God, inerrant, inspired, and our final authority for faith and life.?

So why did you post this question if the article you site indicates that the author believes the bible to be the Word of God?

P.S. Sorry for the confusion ? I was in somewhat of a hurry.

by gildawie

"So you do you post the question if the article you site indicates that the author believes it to be?"

Could you please rephrase that - or is it your intention to be unintelligible?

by jardinier

Protius, the KJV is not "the very foundation of the Christian Church."

In fact as you would know there were many translations of the Bible prior to 1611, as there have been many since. At the websites where I have the discussions, the term "KJVO" is used to refer to Christians who accept the KJV as the only legitimate copy of the Bible.

These websites by the way are dominated by American evangelicals but there are many members who are devout Christians and who are very scholarly and they DO NOT feel that the foundations of their faith depend on one particular translation of the Bible. Quite the contary actually, except for the KJVOs.

Many of the evangelical Christians assert that the closest version to the truth lies in the original manuscripts in Hebrew, Greek and Aramaic.

[b]VERSIONS OF THE BIBLE[/b]

Several Aramaic targums (free translations or paraphrases) of the Old Testament exist; some of them may be older than the Christian Era. The Greek Septuagint, whose canon was not strictly defined, was gradually produced during the last three centuries BC. An Old Latin version of both Testaments was revised by Jerome, producing the Vulgate. Ancient versions exist in Syriac, Coptic, Armenian, and other languages.

During the Middle Ages, parts of the Bible were put into Anglo-Saxon and Middle English. The first English versions of the entire Bible were made (1380-93) by John WYCLIFFE and his associates who used the Latin text. The REFORMATION gave further impulse to translations into modern languages, notably that of Martin LUTHER in German and William TYNDALE in English. Among later versions are the following: Miles COVERDALE's Bible (1535), Matthew's Bible (1537), the Great Bible (1539), Geneva Bible (1560), Rheims-Douai Bible (1582, 1609), King James, or Authorized, Version (1611), English Revised Version (1881-85), American Standard Version (1946-57), New English Bible (1961-70), Jerusalem Bible (1966), New American Bible (1970), Today's English Version (1966-76), and the Revised Standard Version (1946-1971).

by protiusx

I said the Bible. I did not make a reference to any particular version. I happen to enjoy the King James Version but I also study the original text in Hebrew or Aramaic or Greek. Understand that the foundation of Christendom is the Word of God. That is the Bible. You are arguing semantics and that is because you are not a Christian. I look for as close as a literal translation as I can to the original text. Have you faith? No? Then why is this important to you?

by jardinier

No Protius, you did not mention the Bible in that post, you mentioned only the New Testament.

Do I have faith? Yes, I have a very strong faith, but I doubt that you would understand it.

by jardinier

A guy at one of the Christian websites has just posted the following:

Thank you all for doing so much to educate people regarding God's Law. I have learned a great deal from your this website, and try to share that knowledge with as many people as I can. When someone tries to defend the homosexual lifestyle, for example, I simply remind them that Leviticus 18:22 clearly states it to be an abomination. End of debate. I do need some advice from you, however, regarding some of the other specific laws and how to follow them:

When I burn a bull on the altar as a sacrifice, I know it creates a pleasing odor for the Lord - Lev.1:9. The problem is my neighbors. They claim the odor is not pleasing to them. Should I smite them?

I would like to sell my daughter into slavery, as sanctioned in Exodus 21:7. In this day and age, what do you think would be a fair price for her?

I know that I am allowed no contact with a woman while she is in her period of menstrual uncleanliness - Lev.15:19- 24. The problem is, how do I tell? I have tried asking, but most women take offense.

Lev. 25:44 states that I may indeed possess slaves, both male and female, provided they are purchased from neighboring nations. A friend of mine claims that this applies to Mexicans, but not Canadians. Can you clarify? Why can't I own Canadians?

I have a neighbor who insists on working on the Sabbath. Exodus 35:2 clearly states he should be put to death. Am I morally obligated to kill him myself?

A friend of mine feels that even though eating shellfish is an abomination - Lev. 11:10, it is a lesser abomination than homosexuality. I don't agree. Can you settle this?

Lev. 21:20 states that I may not approach the altar of God if I have a defect in my sight. I have to admit that I wear reading glasses. Does my vision have to be 20/20, or is there some wiggle room here?

Most of my male friends get their hair trimmed, including the hair around their temples, even though this is expressly forbidden by Lev. 19:27. How should they die?

I know from Lev. 11:6-8 that touching the skin of a dead pig makes me unclean, but may I still play football if I wear gloves?

My uncle has a farm. He violates Lev. 19:19 by planting two different crops in the same field, as does his wife by wearing garments made of two different kinds of thread (cotton/polyester blend). He also tends to curse and blaspheme a lot. Is it really necessary that we go to all the trouble of getting the whole town together to stone them? - Lev.24:10-16. Couldn't we just burn them to death at a private family affair like we do with people who sleep with their in-laws? (Lev. 20:14)

I know you all have studied these things extensively, so I am confident you all can help. Thank you all again for reminding us that God's word is eternal and unchanging.

by jacksonian

Jardinier,

What you are doing is arguing semantics and legalism.

Regardless of the translation (since many concepts and ideas require different verbage in different languages), the POINT of the matter is the inspired word of god. Unless you believe that the bible is true in the first place, it doesnt really matter what version you read. You are already predisposed to disbelief.

The equation goes something like this:

IF there is a God AND IF the bible is the word of God, THEN the bible is true.

If you are going to participate in the battle of the translations, stand in line. There are tons of books, forums and debates dedicated to such a topic. It is really an exercise in futility. If you believe in the God of the bible, you realize that God took the whole issue of translations into account.

But here is where I stop (before I get into legalism myself and start talking about "predestination")

by gregk

A basic syllogism goes
If a=b and b=c then a=c
You have
If God = true and bible = attribute of God then bible = true
This is equivalent to
if a=b and c=d then c=b. This simply does not wash!

by tony hopkinson

ask him, god not King James.
What do you mean by true anyway, accurate or conformimg to your own or anyones else's belief?
Very iffy word true, bucket loads of semantic freight.

Whether it's true or not depends on belief, anyone who believes it's accurate has a negative IQ. No transaltion from one language to another or from one culture to another or from one historical period to another can ever be 100% accurate. On top of that because written language is interpreted by the reader, it's going to mean something slightly different to every reader even if the words were exactly the same.

by Member 25348569

A quotation from the famous "Buggre Alle This Bible"

"Ezekiel Chapter 5, verse 5: Buggre Alle this for a Larke. I amme sick to mye Hart of typefettinge. Master Biltonn if no Gentelmann, and Master Scagges noe more than a tighte fisted Southwarke Knobbefticke. I telle you, onne a day laike thif Ennywone withe half an oz. of Sense shoulde bee oute in the Sunneshain, ane nott Stucke here alle the liuelong daie inn thif mowldey olde By-Our-Lady Workefhoppe. @ *"?@;!*"

With huge appreciation to Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett.

:D

by Member 25348569

"Good Omens" by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett. Storyline mostly by Gaiman and jokes by Pratchett.

One of the characters is Agnes Nuter, a witch who really [b]can[/b] see into the future. The paragraph of her death had me snorting tea down my nose...

The English, by and large, being a crass and indolent race, were not as keen on burning women as other countries in Europe. In Germany the bonfires were built and burned with regular Teutonic thoroughness. Even the pious Scots, locked throughout history in a long-drawn-out battle with their arch-enemies the Scots, managed a few burnings to while away the long winter evenings. But the English never seemed to have the heart for it.

One reason for this may have to do with the manner of Agnes Nutter's death, which more or less marked the end of the serious witch-hunting craze in England. A howling mob, reduced to utter fury by her habit of going around being intelligent and curing people, arrived at her house one April evening to find her sitting with her coat on, waiting for them.

"Ye're tardie," she said to them. "I shoulde have beene aflame ten minutes since."

Then she got up and hobbled slowly through the suddenly silent crowd, out of the cottage, and to the bonfire that had been hastily thrown together on the village green. Legend says that she climbed awkwardly onto the pyre and thrust her arms around the stake behind her.

"Tye yt well," she said to the astonished witchfinder. And then, as the villagers sidled toward the pyre, she raised her handsome head in the firelight and said, "Gather ye ryte close, goode people. Come close untyl the fire near scorch ye, for I charge ye that alle must see how thee last true wytch in England dies. For Wytch I am, for soe I am judged, yette I knoe not what my true Cryme may be. And therfore let myne deathe be a message to the worlde. Gather ye ryte close, I saye, and marke well the fate of alle who meddle with suche as theye do notte understande."

And after that strange blasphemy she said no more. She let them gag her, and stood imperiously as the torches were put to the dry wood.

The crowd grew nearer, one or two of its members a little uncertain as to whether they'd done the right thing, now that they came to think about it.

Thirty seconds later an explosion took out the village green, scythed the valley clean of every living thing, and was seen as far away as Halifax.

There was much subsequent debate as to whether this had been sent by God or by Satan, but a note later found in Agnes Nutter's cottage indicated that any divine or devilish intervention had beem materially helped by the contents of Agnes's petticoats, wherein she had with some foresight concealed eighty pounds of gunpowder and fourty pounds of roofing nails.

by Member 25348569

while researching for the EL thread. Like all such sites, it tries so very, very hard. The thing that strikes me most of all is the tortuous logic in, for example, "Statements Consistent with...". What, however, puzzles me most is why bother? What are they frightened of?

by protiusx

I did read your post. My point is that you are arguing about something that you don't care about. So what is the point? What are you attempting to accomplish?

by Member 25348569

Your question doesn't actually make sense as written - I assume "why would someone who as admitted they are not a Christian care about the different versions of [their] someone else's holy book?

Why did I post what I did despite the title? Well,
Julian asked us to read the article before we posted and I drew, as I am allowed to, my own inferences. I am at work and excruciatingly bored else I wouldn't have bothered with it at all because, as you say, we've been here before and I, at least, have no wish to do it again.

Signing off.

by computab

The feasts of Israel were instituted by God 3500 years ago, and portray the future. At Passover, they were to kill a perfect lamb, and cook and eat it. Later Jesus told the people that unless they eat his flesh they have no part in him, he fortold his own death and was killed at Passover. Jesus is the lamb of God. At Atonement, they were to take two perfect lambs, one to be killed the other to be released in the desert, away from the people. The one to be killed represented Jesus, the other Satan. The book of Revelation describes how Satan will be put in the 'bottomless pit' for 1000 years.

by jaqui

so someone had nightmares and kept a journal of them and you include them in your religion?

sorry, but if it's been written down the soul is gone from it.
there is no soul in the written word.

and get me the original documents, in the original language to prove that what you say is what was originally written.

by jacksonian

Jaqui,

Can you "get me the original documents, in the original language to prove that what you say is what was originally written" about the soul being gone from it?

I get the feeling though that if you provided me such a document about what your female teacher wrote you, its probably in Microsoft Word format.

I am in no way being condescending about your beliefs, but realize that the statements that you are making are not founded on principles that apply to followers of Judaism or Christianity ...

by mjd420nova

I used to teach a programming class, and one of
the fun things I used to do was take a program
I had written, provide a discription of what
it was supposed to do and ask the students
to either modify or rewrite the program with
out changing the outcome and make it either
easier to use or quicker to run. Few of the
programs I got back resembled the original
and more than a few dumped the whole thing and
rewrote it completely. Most still kept the
outcome or product intention intact, just took
different paths to get there. Some abandoned
everything and decided that this was better
and easier, and the outcome wasn't what was
really wanted but something else was and this
was how to achieve it. Does that sound like
religion??? We all have our own demons so in
respect we all must have our gods and each
an individual way to reach atonement.
Starting to sound familiar??
It's a bit like being at a party, lining
everyone up and starting a joke at one end and
each passes it one to the next. The joke that
comes out seldom even remotely resembles the
original. But it some cases the intent, or
the implied intent, is intact.
Is there a morale to this story??

individual

by jacksonian

Your point may be true for some religions, but not Christianity.

According to the Bible, there is but one way to heaven, not many. If you have a map, there may be many way to get to the same destination. But choice (which is the true moral of the story) is not without consequences.

Again, according to the bible to get to the final destination on the map, one must pass through or over a certain bridge. Depending on the driver, some may be able to cross that bridge (not dependent on having the correct change, but having a pass (signed in red ink)). Without that pass, you cant cross the bridge, but are faced with a detour with not so pleasant scenery.

by jaqui

person that I studied my religion under, it's actually her phrasing. [ gotta love eidetic memory sometimes ]

by ljdavy

When something is translated from one language to another there is always potential for interpretation according to personal persuasion to creep in. However by use of a panel of translators most of this can be minimised. In the case of Scripture there is also the element of inspiration and revelation by the Holy Spirit to bring truth and the intent of the Word of God to the fore. Then of course with out the revelation of the Holy Spirit when reading the Bible it makes a fairly mundane sort of read.

by old guy

First, after reading all the posts up to http://tinyurl.com/89ssz it?s amazing how some of the atheists have to try and throw their barbs and personal opinions into the mix, although Jardinier specifically stated in his initial post: ?And a quick note to the resident atheists: this discussion is NOT about whether or not there is a God or whether Christianity is a good religion.? I agree with ProtiusX since this discussion was started and directed at believing Christians then the others really should have left it to them.

Jardinier?s original question was: Is the King James Bible the true Word of God? The King James is a translation of the Word of God. NIV, New American Standard, New King James, etc are translations of the Word of God. The Word of God is inspired by God through the Holy Spirit. It is a Living Word. Can these translations have some inaccuracies? Yes, they can. Does that mean that we Christians can?t use them? Absolutely not. How does one study a subject or object. Do you take one aspect and call your study a complete study. I certainly hope not. Would it be helpful to take several of these translations and study what they say to learn more about the Word of God? Absolutely. Does that mean that is the only way to discern God?s Word? A resounding, ?No!?

Now here is where the atheists will probably love to devour me but it won?t matter because it doesn?t affect nor concern you since you don?t accept any aspect of Christianity. We are instructed through the Scriptures, that we accept and believe are inspired by God, to study those scriptures. We are also instructed and explained to that when we belong to Christ that the Holy Spirit will instruct you. (John 14:26 "But the Counselor, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in my name, will teach you all things and will remind you of everything I have said to you.")

So, how do we study the Word of God? We believe that God, through the Holy Spirit, inspired the writers to write down what they saw and were taught for other people to study and follow Christ. We must also trust the Holy Spirit to direct us in our studies to learn more and to enlighten us through our spirits.

I do like that Daniel Wallace hit on a very valuable observation. In essence he stated that the translation, be it KJN, NIV, ASB, or whatever, is not what saves us. It is by God?s Grace through the blood of Jesus Christ, who is the Living Word of God, that we are saved.

by jardinier

I don't know how you read this into my post because I did not state, declare or imply such a purpose.

EVERYBODY was invited to comment, with the disclaimer that the discussion was not about whether or not there is a God, or whether Christianity is a good religion.

by old guy

these statements: "Just for the sake of arguement accepting that Jesus is god, since I'm not christain, he isn't god to me"

"But then, you God-botherers can manage that sort of thing with your eyes closed, can't you?" Of course they certainly have a right to believe or feel whatever they wanted to.

In essence, it sounded like Jaqui and Neil, although I do enjoy reading their posts and ideas even when different from mine, still sounded like were taking pot shots, although small ones toward Christianity.

Whether correct or not I assumed since you were asking about the Word of God and placed your statement, ?And a quick note to the resident atheists: this discussion is NOT about whether or not there is a God or whether Christianity is a good religion? that you were asking the opinions of those who believe in and live by the Word of God.

If this was incorrect then I apologize and retract my initial statement. In any instance, it still seems that there was some detraction from the question.

I certainly hope this is not all that you read from my post. Whether I read into some statements or whether I misunderstood some statements then I may have done so. I guess if every post has to be absolutely perfect to get the full meaning then I will probably miss the boat again somewhere down the line?probably more often than not. I am by no means perfect.

by marcato15

What I mean by that is, the core doctrines and beliefs that God inspired the human writers to write down have been perserved through God's Providence through time. As far as versions go though, no English translation, or any translation for that matter can be doubly inspired as its what it says, "a translation". You'll never capture every last thing that was meant when translating between languages.
What matters is, is the fact that the KJV,and the other translations we have today as well, can still can be regarded, and should be, as God's Word and our Highest authority.(Even if its not excatly, word for word what the authors wrote, because all the major doctrines vital to Christianity are still contained therein).

by jardinier

However, as I am not a Biblical scholar, I was amazed to learn how complex was the process of producing the most widely read (I think) version of Scripture.

And of course I fully agree with your statememt:

"Even if its not exactly, word for word what the authors wrote, because all the major doctrines vital to Christianity are still contained therein."

by protiusx

His statement is that the King James Version of the Bible is the ?Word of God? but not exclusively. I would ask you again how you can agree with him when you have stated that you are not a Christian.

by tonythetiger

..."because all the major doctrines vital to Christianity are still contained therein"

The compilers were much like the press of today. They chose what the readers would see ... and not see.

by sleepin'dawg

it again; are we??

If we are talking in the strict sense of linguistic or literary accuracy, then it is ovbviously not the [b]true[/b] word of god. Too many things have been lost in translation on so many different levels, the least of which are historical, cultural and linguistic. What truth there is, in the document, will be found in the mind of the reader and even there you will find differing views of the [b]true[/b] truth as perceived by different readers, whether they be Christians or unbelievers. The reader is placed in the same position as Sisyphus, who upon nearing his goal, is condemned to have the stone roll down to the bottom of his pit. Each day we live and each experience we endure cannot but help in acquiring new interpretations of our perceptions of truth, whether believer or non-believer. Beyond the individual, why should it matter?

This urge or impetus to have others believe as we, as individuals do, has been the cause of more strife in the world than from any other cause. This thread shows all the indications of becoming another EL and to what point? Why should we care [b]exactly[/b] what others believe? Isn't it enough to know their beliefs are similar to your own if not precisely the same. When you observe any congregation do you really think each and every adherent believes identically? If so, then you are sadly in error and are doomed to constant disappointment.

Is the KJV of the bible the [b]true[/b] word of God? Only if the reader wishes it to be because each and every reader will, assuming he is capable of thought, impose his own [b]personal[/b] beliefs on the matter, whether he be unbeliever or not.

I do not think we are in need of another reiteration of EL. We should move on. Nobody's personal beliefs or thoughts will be altered here today, except for the stirring up of a lot of fruitless and useless acrimony. Leave others to believe as they will; why pursue this further??? It won't accomplish or change one iota of anything!!! What's the point, unless you have an undeniable urge for flogging dead horses, in which case flog away. I, for one, am rapidly losing interest.

Note : At no point have I criticized anyone's views or beliefs here. All I have said is that we each have our own personal views on the matter and that [b]I, feel[/b] after EL they've been overstated to a fare-thee-well; my own views included.

Enough!!! Move along!!! There's really nothing here you haven't seen, read and agreed or disagreed with here before.

Jardinier, you addressed the resident atheists but I couldn't help but notice, you left out the agnostics. Are you some kind of bigotted theogonist??? :^O

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jardinier

As I abandoned that one by about post number 500, I would not know if any viewpoints are recurring in this discussion.

Incidentally jd's divorce thread is a close runner-up at somewhat more than 2,000 posts.

So what can we deduce from this? That the top two topics which people like to talk abut are religion and relationships. As these are the two areas of human life that people feel most passionate about, this is not surprising.

So if the people want to talk, let them talk.

by protiusx

I concur. This horse has been thrown into the blender and set to frappe.

Sleepin Dawg! Well met my friend. We meet again.

by sleepin'dawg

Neil we are evil, evil men; except you are probably more evil than me.LOL :^O

That means I get to do fewer laps in the lake of fire than you do but after the first million or so who'll be keeping count. Like you, I can think of a few that might and you know what that will mean??? Don't you??

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jardinier

Your post from a Christian point of view was, in my opinion, nothing short of EXCELLENT.

I included the disclaimer regarding "resident atheists" because I know from long experience that they seem to enjoy trying to disrupt and destroy any serious discussion in the general area of religion.

And now I will give them an opportunity to attack me. Why are atheists so eager to disrupt any discussion about religion? I suggest it is because they have some tiny niggling doubt as to the possibility of the existence of "something" that is innately intelligent in the universe.

You will not see agnostics arguing in these discussions because they keep an open mind to the possibility that there may be a "God" of some kind.

Atheists cannot prove their point of view by logical argument, and so they strike out at anyone who in any way threatens their totally subjective and unprovable stance.

As to your understanding that my post was directed only a Christians, all I can say is that this is not what I had in mind. The essence of the topic is how a document (any document) can be so readily accepted by people without knowing anything about how that document evolved into its present form.

I would hope that people of other faiths as well as agnostics AND atheists would find this an interesting exercise. In fact Neil himself said in an early post (addressed to someone else) that he quite understood the premise of the discussion.

The attitude of KJVO devotees would suggest that God (or the Holy Spirit) personally oversaw that translation and gave it His stamp of approval as the only inerrant and valid version.

by Member 25348569

Nope. You're right of course.

"Religious zealots cannot prove their point of view by logical argument, and so they strike out at anyone who in any way threatens their totally subjective and unprovable stance."

Bugger!

by jardinier

Actually Neil you would have a snowflake's chance in hell of becoming a Christian even if for some obscure reason you decided to.

Your intellectual integrity would immediately disqualify you.

In order to become a Christian of the American evangelical kind, a prerequisite is to lock your mind and throw away the key.

As I have hung around churches all my life, I know a great many Christians who just want to live decent lives and are not at all concerned with doctrines or dogmas.

Speaking generally, Americans take their religion much more seriously than Australians -- and I would assume also Brits -- and so they get very emotional about it.

It is, however, quite possible for a highly intelligent person (like myself for example :))to believe in some form of God -- expressed in my case as an innate intelligence in the universe.

While I draw heavily on the ethical teachings of Jesus, Paul and the other gospel writers, I consider the fundamental doctrines of Christianity to be quite absurd.

It goes something like this. God created humans, but they were imperfect, so he caused a flood to drown all but a handful of them (as well as the unfortunate animals and plants which had not committed any sin).

However humans -- being imperfect creations of God -- did not repent and so he sent his Son to die on the cross to absolve the sins of those who accepted Him (read that as pay out their bad karma from an Eastern perspective).

As the majority of humans remain unrepentant, at Armageddon most of those still alive and all those who have rejected the "gift of salvation" will spend eternity in a very, very hot place.

Now the point of all this is that if God is indeed omniscient, he should have known that the humans He created were bound to sin.

So GOD created us imperfect, but WE cop all the blame and associated "cruel and unusual" punishment.

by gregk

Leaving aside all questions of ""Who is this God person anyway?" as was asked for here...

1. Any translation is just that. Not all concepts will translate correctly or completely. Translators will have off days. The editors will have off days. The printers will have off days. This applies equally to the "Original" Greek MSS. As I recall, Jesus was a Jew, and thus spoke Hebrew, So even the KJV sources were at best translations themselves, and subject to the same problems. The OT has even more problems as the originals are even older than 2000 years

2. Since the KJV was written, the English language itself has evolved. What was written then does not mean the same thing now. The Story of English by Melvyn Bragg gives an excellent layman's account of this process.

3. The originals must be read within the context of the culture of the writers. At at least 2000 years and half a world's remove, I find this an intractable problem. I am NOT a Jew. I was NOT alive 2000 years ago and so on.

For myself, I prefer The New Jerusalem Bible. It at least moves the whole thing into modern, non-colloquial, international English, and therefore reduces mis-understandings based on item 2 above, and by going back to the earliest sources possible, and using multiple editors, helps address the points in 1. I dislike the various colloquial versions I have come across as it "dates" very quickly, both with time and distance.

Of course I do enjoy the KJV for its glowing poetry, but I always go to the modern english I want to understand what was meant.

by oldmicro

The topic is, as I see it, actually two distinct questions:
1. Is the KJV an accurate translation of the original manuscripts?
2. Are the original language manuscripts, the "Word of God"?
And I will add a third:
3: Have all the Inspired manuscripts been included?
The first question is the most easily addressed by scolarship, and the availability of more and more ancient copies of the material copied in the original languages. It is at this point that the accuracy of the translation may be addressed. The selection of one rendering of text from varients in available manuscripts, is a difficult job, and one that provides no definitive answer. Teams of translators attempt to reach a consensus as to the rendering that has the widest acceptance in previous translations, although that is still not a compelling attack for people who require absolute truth.
Second, aside from the above problems of variations in the available manuscripts, lies the fundamental problem. What is meant by "The Word of God" as it applies to anyting that was actually penned on lambskin by human beings? That the work was "Inspired by God" is a position that has been accepted by the whole of Christiandom from the 4th or 5th decade of the Christian era. The properties of "Inerrancy" and "Divine Authorship" have only recently been included, and then only by the small "Protestant" segment of the Christian faith.
Lastly, there is still division, and again by the smaller "Protestant" segment, concerning the number of books that are considered "Cannonical." In its earliest editions the KJV had 73 books, and was later reduced to the current 66.
In my personal opinion, none of these titles, properties, or disagreements amount to a hill of beans. As the Apostle Paul is reported as saying, "I know nothing except Christ, and Him crucified." Until a person can receive that, the rest of the mess is just a mess.

by jardinier

Protius, you are groping. You will never understand my faith, so save yourself the effort of trying to pigeon-hole me.

Anybody who was fully familiar with Christianity and the Bible could agree with the findings of the author of the article.

How many thousands of commercial travellers and drifters do you think there might have been who know the Bible inside out and backwards because they have read the Gideon Bible in hotels?

How many times do I have to repeat myself? This discussion is NOT about the validity of Christianity, but about the amazingly complex history of the King James Bible.

by protiusx

The title of this post is asking if the King James Bible is the ?true word of God?. To believe this one must first believe in God. You stated in the first post that you were not a Christian so how can you believe that a book is the word of something you have no faith in? it doesn?t make sense.

The only thing you have shared about your religious leanings is that I could not understand it. That doesn?t give me a lot to go on.

This is the same as me asking if the Koran is the true word of Allah. I neither believe in Allah nor do I believe that the Koran is a holly book at all.

If this is not about Christianity then change the original post to say something like ?Is the King James Version of the Bible the exclusive word of God according to Christians??

by brokeneagle

Would Republicans trust a Bible translated by the Clinton Administration?
Would Democrats trust a Bible translated by the George W. Bush Administration?
Why trust the version sponsored by King James? The original settlers of New England who were fleeing religious persecution in England did not use it.

by rknrlkid

The crux of the argument in the article is NOT the factualness of Christianity. It is about an internal controvesy within Christian circles called "KJV Only-ism." The context is everything!

In a very broad nutshell, hard-core KJV-Only-ists are insisting that not only are the original documents supernaturally inspired, but so are the words of the 1611 KJV edition.

I think it should be noted, however, that a) no other ancient text in history has as many extant copies or as close to the original time of writing as the documents we call the Bible, and 2) Not one essential doctrine that relates to spiritual matters is affected by these "mistakes." What is referred to as a "mistake" is often just a misspelling of a name, or a variation of something else that does not fundamentally alter the meaning (i.e., "a" instead of "the," or vice versa).

There is more evidence, documentarily, for the factualness of Christianity than for the existence of Plato, Homer, or Julius Caeser. Yet no one challenges THOSE documents.

by Member 25348569

All we know from historical documents is that from around 50 AD there was a religious sect - Christians, if you wish - who seemed to believe that Jesus was a historical person. "Jesus", at least the Jewish equivalent, was a very common first century name. It's also been well recorded that various faith healers, baptisers and miracle workers were attracting followings at that time - as is normal in times of persecution. The basic storyline behind the gospels - an itinerant healer and preacher who ran afoul of the authorities and was executed for his trouble - is, again, perfectly reasonable.

One of the issues that I have with your statement "more evidence, documentarily, for the factualness of Christianity" is that you miss, deliberately or otherwise, the real point. There is very little contemporary documentation that proves the existence of Jesus. Despite this, I have no trouble in accepting, as the simplest explanation for the Gospels and the Christianity, is that it was founded by a person named Jesus. Whether it was [b]your[/b] Jesus, the Son of God, is another matter entirely.

Much, much more contemporary documentary eveidence exists for the other historical figures that you listed. All of them could write and had some of their writings preserved. There are accounts written by people who met them. There are statues.

The only reason why the bible has so many copies and versions is that, for a large part of the post-Roman history of the western world, only the clergy could read or write and therefore only Christian texts were available. I won't go ito the motives, and therefore the morality, of the clergy in keeping the peasants ignorant.

--------

Sorry Jules. I'd rather not participate in this discussion at all but then it would degenerate into a prayer meeting.

by rknrlkid

Big difference, I agree.

My point is this: there are more (quantity) extant manuscripts of the New Testament than there are of any other in antiquity, and with closer ages to the autographs.

The existence of Homer has been argued among scholars for decades. He cannot be proven to be a "real person" even by your own standards, because very few, and incomplete, manuscripts exist, and they are from thousands of years after the writing of the original. Socrates wrote nothing, all the evidence that he existed came from Plato, and very few manuscripts of Plato are in existence, and they, too are close to a thousand years after the original writing. Yet who argues against Plato, Socrates or Homer? No one. Why? Because of personal bias. "Scholarship" believes what it wants to believe.

With thousands of manuscripts in existence, and the earliest within 300 years of original writing, the survival of the New Testament documents is a marvel of history. On top of this, there are contemporaneous accounts of Christianity, and NOT from the Christians too. Remember, the Romans kept records of everything just like we do. There are extant court records of trials of prominent Romans accused of being Christian.

The reason that there are so many copies of the NT in existence has nothing to do with a priesthood. There was no organized priesthood in early Christianity, because it a common man's religion. Manuscripts were copied and recopied because people believed it. The clergy system as we know it was a later invention.

If I was home, I would give you precise numbers on the manuscripts. Most people do not know this about the numbers because its a rather obscure subject.

by jardinier

Not only are your posts totally objective, but I cannot think of anything you have said with which I disagree.

I especially appreciate the above post with which I can find no fault or point of disagreement.

by jellimonsta

Dawg, how could one so lowly as myself, even compare with a person of such malignant stature as yourself? :D

by jacksonian

Jaqui,

When you state a fact, please be sure you use the correct terminology.

If you say that:
(A) "all religous ceremonies become dead rituals when it is hard copy",

and

(B) the jewish and christian religions are not founded on such principles

Then A is considerd a false statement...

by gadgetgirl

want to say now exactly what it is you're after from Dawg?

(ohboy! I bet your knees are hurting from all that crawling!)

GG

by jellimonsta

I am not after anything from Dawg. I am merely illustrating how I am no match his 'His Royal Evilness, Lord Dawg Humptingtonstandiglesworth of The NetherWorld' :)

Heck, I couldn't even bring myself to burn ants with a magnifying glass as a kid! :D

by protiusx

I have been reading a lot of the replies and it dawned on me that this is one of many threads that have been posted with the expressed intent to discredit the Christian faith. I have not in the past two years seen one thread that questioned the writings or validity of any other religion. It appears that in this forum Wicca, Buddhism, Hinduism, Shamanism, Zoral Asterism, (only to name a few) are perfectly legitimate religions and should never be questioned but (insert deity here) forbid that someone actually be a dreaded Christian!

I?ve said it before and I will say it again ? I am not going to convince anyone of the authenticity of the Christian scripture. To do so is to throw pearls before swine. I have said my piece and that is that.

by Member 25348569

This an American-based website and, therefore, the majority of people who access it are English speaking and from nominally Christian countries, such as England and others, more demonstrably Christian, such as the USA.

Under these circumstances you are going to get posts from those Christians who care to post and from atheists from the aforementioned countries who might care to respond. These - and I say this from personal experience - are likely to be more "anti" Christian rather than the other faiths simply because they are exposed more to Christianity.

If any of your listed "other" religions want to get involved then they can. But they don't. We will thus end up in a kind of back-slapping prayer meeting with any thread that mentions Christianity or we will end up with what we do, in fact, get and this is a polarised discussion with atheists versus the Soldiers of the Lord.

I can't see anything else happening for a long time. Live with it or stop posting. Your faith is surely strong enough to do either. I'm not going to stop posting if I see something that I disagree with.

I would also like to point out that neither I nor Absolutely - servants of The Antichrist both - have ever started an anti-religious thread. So, if you guys want to lift up the flat rock, don't get upset if something crawls out.

I also think that you're being unfair to Julian in lumping him in with Abs and me. The article referenced in the thread-opener was an article by a Christian commenting on the King James version. The opening sentence "the Bible is the Word of God, inerrant, inspired, and our final authority for faith and life" doesn't strike me as something that a Christian-basher would point you to "with the expressed intent to discredit the Christian faith".

A. Swine

by protiusx

I am not angry and I hope I have not offended anyone. I love reading your replies because while we do disagree with one another on a great many things you are always magnanimous and very witty.

I do see your point about the persons who post to this web site. I will continue to post as well.

Thanks for keeping me on the straight and narrow so to speak. My oldest son loves to flip over rocks and find the bugs underneath. We went to the beach on holiday and he found thousands of tiny crabs and sea creatures under there. When I read your post I got a good mental picture of your small face under the rock smiling saying ?Hello?

by old guy

the writing, especially a hand written manuscript written by Jesus being worship instead of the One whom He was speaking about.

by jacksonian

Jardinier,

Having faith does not always equate to being faithful (to God)...

2 Timothy 3:16 "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness:"

Which brings me to Matthew 7:3

"And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?"

Lets play fair ...

by jaqui

both the Native american traditions and those of my celtic hertiage.
heavily influenced by my complete lack of mercy.
I only have one penalty for wrong-doing, death.
forgiveness is not part of my life. [ it's not a "natural" thing to forgive, killing those that attack you is natural ]

by protiusx

No forgiveness at all? You must be a very lonely sad person. Forgive lest ye not be forgiven. Forgiveness is about mercy and love. Does love exist in your world?

by jacksonian

Jaqui,

What you speak of is actually one of the strengths of the "testament" of Christ.

To answer your question "is the entire christain faith based on other people's writing".

Basically, yes.

Without Christ present, we are basically in a cave looking for a candle that was blown out over 2000 years ago.

It IS about Jesus. Using his words alone would not help people who didnt believe. They need to see how he impacted those around him (those who believed he was who he said he was and those who did not). How amazing his Paul's testimonty? If you have ever read it, you would know. If you read it like you would read an "Aesops Fable" dont even bother. Read it for the account that it gives and it may suprise you what you find there. Christ chose his disciples for a reason. How can you (a non-christian) tell me "if it's about jesus, use the words he wrote only".

A testament is "a profession of belief" or "strong evidence for something", hence the term NEW testament. How much could we get from a bible with only one author? The fact that many different people contributed, the fact that there were many different accounts of the occurences and the happenings dealing with Christ (to include non christians such as Pontius Pilate and Josephus) helps solidify the case for Jesus Christ.

If one person sees a shooting star and describes it, you have his account. If many people see that same star, you get detail AND corroborating evidence. Food for thought.

by jaqui

if it's Jesus as god, only HIS OWN WRITTEN WORDS are the "WORD OF GOD" everything else is hearsay and should be thrown out of the word of god.

cannot have it both ways, one or the other.

if the bible is the word of god, then it is what god wrote, not what any human wrote.

by gregk

If you take your reasoning to the extreme, then only the words God wrote in G's own hand could be counted as the word of G. Transcriptions would not be permitted. This when applied to the greater world would mean that only Terry Pratchett's original manuscripts are the word of TP. The printed books I read are not his words. Therefore any copyright claimed in his name in invalid. I can copy anything I like anytime. Clearly this reasoning is invalid.

Now let's get back to G.
Anything written by G is the word of G. Agreed. but also any fair transcriptions of those writings may also be regarded as the WOG. This would also include directly inspired god works such as the Koran. Translations are trickier. If we look at, for example, multiple translations of Nietzche, there are often wide discrepancies. This is partly the bias of the translator, partly the incomplete knowledge of the translator, partly simple errors and partly differences in understanding of the original intent.
The same can be said here of translations of WOG. It is interesting to note here that Muslims do not regard as translation of the Koran as the real thing. If you want to read the REAL Koran, learn Arabic and read the genuine article.
Of course it is possible to claim (and it is!) translations - or a particular one - are also guided directly by G, and therefore be regarded as WOG. We then need to look at the internal evidence. Are all the WOG translations consistent? If not then they cannot all be WOG (though one still can) Is the one that is deemed to be WOG consistent with the original language source? If not again it is not WOG.
Of course none of this touches on changes in language and culture which can dramatically alter our perception of the meaning (Should we REALLY make little children suffer? Should we really keep slaves?)
We also need to ascertain whether the original really is the WOG, and if so, was G telling the truth any way?

by jacksonian

Great question.

It seems that non-believers just like to ruffle feathers.

Knowing that someone cares deeply about something (like ones own mother) and commencing to spit or criticize it (aka slapping owns own aforementioned maternal unit) raises a certain degree of satisfaction in some people.

At least thats how I usually take it. You can argue the "facts" or the "fictions" all you want.

It is not a mental pursuit anyway ... Take it or leave it.

Tha answer will be found at the foot of a great white throne.

by Member 25348569

Non believers just wonder [b]why[/b] you believe.

And why so many people believe.

And why so many people believe in something different.

And why so many people believe in nothing.

And why you're all so scared of debate.

Yes. It [b]is[/b] a mental pursuit. That is [b]exactly[/b] what it is and if you cannot see that then I'm sorry for you. Man is a rational animal. Man is the only rational animal. If you choose not to use the mind that you have to the maximum that you are able then I'm sorry for you. No doubt, though, you do not want my pity. continue to wallow in your irrational belief and be happy.

Anyway, I'll leave it, thank you.

Just one thought for you to ponder on. I think you are mistaken in your belief. For that mistake I condemn you to the same fate for eternity as I expect for myself. You believe me to be mistaken in my lack of belief. You reward yourself with eternal happiness and me with eternal damnation. Bit extreme, isn't it? Rather nasty, in fact. (That's British understatement, by the way).

I'm actually quite a nice person - at least as nice as any Christians that I've met and considerably less judgemental. Can you wonder why I sometimes get a little annoyed? Ruffle your feathers? I think you sometimes deserve a little more than that!

by Member 25348569

Amongst the things that you aren't taking into account is that the existence or non-existence of Homer or Socrates as real - rather than composite - figures is, in the great scheme of things, not really very important. The proven existence of Julius Caesar is more significant and, in fact, considerably easier because of his prominence. The proven existence of Jesus in the eyes of Christians - and even in the eyes of an atheist such as myself - would obviously be many orders of magnitude more important than Caesar. I think that it demands a greater burden of proof.

Jesus, during his lifetime, was not a prominent figure so I would have been surprised if any contemporary writings existed even as scraps. The majority - if not all - of the documents whose subject was the life of Jesus were written long after the event. In my original post, I did not discount either the writings concerning early Christianity or even the link between Christianity and someone called Jesus.

I simply question whether documents written with the particular motivation of the early Christians could ever be even slightly impartial and factual.

By the way, the Church hierarchy was very well established by the Third Century. By that time, common man's religion it was not. It was around that time that the selection of what was and was not to be included in the NT was begun.

by tony hopkinson

down without changing over generations, which I doubt, languages change. They pick up new concepts, new forms , words change meaning over time. On top of words written or spoken are symbols, their exact meaning is unique to each and every one of us in individual terms, and in context (sentence or social) ambiguous at best.

Some languages are more stable than others, english is one of the least stable for instance and it's definitely changed since the 1600's.

If I said someone was queer, for instance, what do I mean ?
If you said it, what would you have meant.

If we both had a different interpretation of the word and we both translated into the same foreign language, what would the native speaker of that language think? Which one of us would be right?

A spiritual obligation ? No a necessity, otherwise your current belief structure would have to adapt or crumble.

by jardinier

As I have not described my faith, or the source(s) of it, then obviously you are not in a position to comment on it.

To further baffle you, my faith stems initially from the Bible (as distinct from any particular denomination or interpretation of the Bible) but is greatly enhanced because of a much more profound understanding of the Scripture than would be understood or accepted by most Christians.

by jardinier

Could you have spotted me if I had not stated that I am not a Christian?

Then you must be very insightful my friend because at the Christian websites in which I participate in discussions, not only has no-one queried my religion, but I have in fact become a respected member whose views are taken seriously.

I participate in these discussions for two reasons:

To stimulate people to assess and vindicate their beliefs, and to learn. Although I am fully au fait with all the essential doctrines of Christianity, I have not actually studied the Bible in detail and so I am learning quite a lot.

The Sermon on the Mount is the basis for my ethics and I have attempted to live my life according to the maxims contained therein.

I also like 1 Corinthians Chapter 13, and Galatians 5:22-23

I often feel the need to refer Christians to these passages when they become judgmental, argumentative or rude.

by protiusx

The article posted at http://www.lamblion.com/articles/doctrinal/Bible/Bible-01.php

Written by Dr. David R. Reagan is a good synopsis of why the Bible has been reduced to mere literature. The fundamental question is whether or not the Bible is the ?Inspired word of God? as stated by the Apostle Paul.

Dr. Reagan explains that a good portion of the Church today is apostate, worldly, and apathetic because they have rejected the Bible as God?s revelation to Man and believe, instead, that the Bible is a product of Man?s search for God. This rejection of the Bible as God?s Word is a product of the German School of Higher Criticism.

Dr. Reagan also details several different versions of the Bible that attempt to detract from the reality of the Bible and its message. He goes on to say that the bible itself claims its own origins as stated in over 3000 scriptural references. Now one might think this is using circular reasoning but Dr. Reagan goes onto say that this is not the case. The Bible is a collection of 66 books written by more than 40 authors over a period of 1,600 years. Therefore, if one quotes Jeremiah or Isaiah to substantiate Daniel, one is quoting altogether independent sources that happen to be bound together between the covers of the same book.

So to answer the original question of whether I believe the King James Bible is the word of God ? Yes I do. The translations have been painstakingly copied over the millennia and when referenced against the original documents the lack of error is astounding.

by Member 25348569

:p

Well, of course I'm not offended. I do reserve the right to twist JacksonMN's leg off and beat him with it, though.

Where are you at, these days? Still in the land of the exploding camel? You seem not to be posting on Seattle time!

:D