Discussion Locked

Is the King James Bible the true Word of God?

0 helpful
173 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

173 replies

by protiusx

That there were 60 different books written by over 40 different writters over 2000 years.

by protiusx

You've said that your faith comes from a deep understanding of the scripture but in a previous post you said you haven't studied the scripture all that much. Which is it?

by protiusx

You are correct my British friend. I am still in Iraq. I will be returning to my beloved drizzle very very soon. Not soon enough however. I have had the great fortune to meet some very nice British friends here and while I can barely believe it myself I have switched to tea rather than coffee. Now coming from a Seattleite that is saying something. I will probably be disowned when I get home but I am sure the Starbuck shamans will cast some spell and make me return to the brown nectar.

by gregk

There are well over 60 book and 40 writers that support Darwinian evolution, so by this "logic" it must be true.

by tonythetiger

The point I was making was that, at best, the Bible is not a complete book because of what the editors left out!

It just goes to show that liberals ran the media even back then :)

by jardinier

It is not necessary to make a detailed study of the Bible in order to learn the more pertinent parts on which my faith is based.

I have a fair knowledge of the Gospels and Epistles, but have not found any need or reason to explore the Old Testament in detail.

You should also take into account that "faith" is not an attribute exclusive to Christianity. For all you know I may have faith in Krishna or Buddha.

I may have faith in the same God as you do, but have an entirely different concept of what that God is like.

by jardinier

If you knew some of the rubbish posted at the Christian websites at which I participate,
then you would perhaps say that the term: "intelligent Christian" is an oxymoron.

I am currently participating in a discussion (started by myself) "How old and how large is the universe?" Some of these people are insisting that the universe is 6,000 years old, and that science is a "false religion" and ....

American evangelicals seem to be in a class of their own, and thankfully Australia has not yet been infected by this fanatical, close-minded version of Christianity.

However my personal friends (mainly through association with one church or another) include a number of retired professors in various disciplines, as well as persons who hold a PhD.

Ad nauseam in these threads, I refer to my cousin Professor Sir Gustav Nossal, who is chairman of the committee which oversees the Bill and Melinda Gates program to immunise several million children in poor countries.

Gus is Professor Emeritus of Pathology at Melbourne University.

He is, and always had been, a practising Catholic.

by jardinier

More like gobbledegook and waffle.

Now if I was on trial for murder, this is one lawyer I would NOT like to depend on for my defence.

Although the judge might choose to dismiss the charges rather than listen to more like this.

by jardinier

nor ever was intended to be about my personal beliefs.

Protius will never understand where I am coming from.

While Neil would not agree with my beliefs, I feel sure that he WOULD understand where I am coming from.

by tony hopkinson

On one side non-believers who can use the thread to point out that some of the arguments for are a tad illogical. The other, those who view you raising doubt that this bible is the verbatim word of god and therefore challenging their faith.

Like all such threads, an excuse for people to state their view, logical debate hardly.

by Member 25348569

and quite a long time ago, too. That would probably be a plus if he was defending you.

I dipped into the page but I couldn't get more than a paragraph in before my brain siezed up. The guy might have had a wonderful revelation to make but I was never going to read it.

Haven't these people heard of "Executive Summary"?

by jardinier

I have just been accused by some smart-ass former pastor in a discussion at the Christian website of the horrendous heresy of dialectical thinking.

I replied in part:

Thank you for the compliment.

Above all else I value my intellectual integrity. Yes, I question everything without any preconceived ideas.

My mind will ALWAYS remain open to new knowledge and insights.

by Member 25348569

Taking his intended insult as a compliment.

They tend to be a little more direct with me, "Servant of the Antichrist", "Bastard smartarse" - either of which causes me a small glow of "mission accomplished".

Neil

by jellimonsta

I do not view you as 'Bastard Son Of The AntiChrist'. Even though we obviously disagree, I always appreciate your wit, intellect, and discourse.

I view you as an extremely intellegent peer with whom I very much appreciate conversation.

Of course, I realize I am MORE intellegent than you, due to the fact that I KNOW I do NOT KNOW anything! :p

by jacksonian

Neil,

You could care less WHY I believe (you have made up your mind already about God).

You wonder why so MANY people believe. Since you are on the other side of the why fence, I guess you think all Christians are delusional?

Why so many people believe in nothing? That I cant answer when there is so much to believe in.

I am in no way scared of debate. God wants me to give an account as to why I believe the way I do. I have debated this issue (and many like it) plenty of times. But why debate an issue someone already has a preconceived notion about?

Once again, it is NOT a mental pursuit. Since you cant see it otherwise, I am the one sorry for you. I am extremely rational, and logic based (hence the career path I have chosen). And in regards to your other comments about my "mind", your pity and my irrational beliefs, thank you for the persecution and the condescention.

Here is a thought for you to ponder. I KNOW that you are mistaken in your belief. And its not me that will condemn you. I dont reward you with anything but the hope that one day you realize the truth.

Neil, I posted to this topic because of my beliefs. I am a "nice" person myslef, and I cant help the fact that many Christians have been judgemental towards you. It may annoy you, but we are not perfect.

So you think I deserve more than feather ruffling? Can you justify? You feel I should be persecuted because of my faith? Thats exactly what Christ said would happen, so persecute away.

On a side note, fot those that read this post and are open to explore the possibility of God and the truth contained in the bible, check out a book titled "I Dont Have Enough Faith to be an Atheist". Its a good book for Christians and non-Christians alike. It touches on alot of things spoken about here in the past few days ...

by jacksonian

Yes I could have spotted you ...

As soon as you decided to turn this topic into a forum where you could tout your super-spiruality and your ultra-insight in regards to Chrisitianity (despite the fact that you pride yourself on your "non-christian" denomination and participate in Christian discussions).

And as far as referring Christians to Chrisitian principles if they are "judgmental, argumentative or rude", I see what your strategy is ...

Expecting other to live by their rules, while you are bound by none. I state that I am a Christian, not perfect. When topics like these come up, the gloves come off ...

by jardinier

Nor am I perfect.

I don't lay claim to "super-spiruality." You would be pushing uphill to read that in my posts.

What I am STATING (absolute) not CLAIMING is that through studying other sources I can see simple and clear meanings in certain parts of the Bible which Christians will be debating about until they are called up to heaven. If the literal meaning were clear, there would be no need for debate.

But doctine is NOT clearly set out in the Bible. It has been extrapolated (by men -- with more than a little help from the Holy Spirit if you like) and there will always be controversy about the meanings of various passages because the meaning is NOT CLEAR on a literal reading.

Ecclesiastes 12:6 Or ever the silver cord be loosed, or the golden bowl be broken, or the pitcher be broken at the fountain, or the wheel broken at the cistern.

Can you interpret the meaning of this verse?

by Member 25348569

"And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?"

I thought that I'd quote the KJV as it was the original theme of this discussion and, of the Bible versions that I've read, has the most turgid, least comprehensible and least relevant language. The point still stands, though. I don't believe in [b]any[/b] gods, yours included and it's not a "preconceived notion" but a decision arrived at rationally. Nobody "taught" me to be an atheist and I was not brought up as one. Given that, I find your comment a tad patronising but, alas, not uncommon when coming from the righteous. I think that you should examine your own "preconceived notions". At least mine are my own.

You did not address my point that your religion of "Love" practises blackmail of the first rank in the fate that it allots for unbelievers. Jesus wasn't [b]that[/b] nice, either: "But those mine enemies, which would not that I should reign over them, bring hither, and slay them before me."
? Luke 19.27

You do not [b]know[/b] that I am wrong. You [b]believe[/b] to the point of accepting no alternative. You also believe contrary to the beliefs of the 4,000 million of the Earth's population who are not even nominally Christian.

In no way am I persecuting you - "persecution: punishment or harassment usually of a severe nature on the basis of race, religion, or political opinion in one's country of origin". I am debating with you if you wish it or I am winding you up if you do not take it in the manner that I intended. Perhaps your grip on the reality of what is going on in this thread is indicative of the grip that you have on the reality of your existence and your religion.

This is an Internet forum. No-one is going to get stoned or burned at the stake.

Oh, I forgot. That's what [b]your[/b] lot did to [b]my[/b] lot.

Standard treatment for a heretic - the Holy Trinity: an Iron mask is heated in a fire until red hot, then put upon the heretics head. A red-hot scourge (that's a rake, by the way) is then applied to his back. After the mask had cooled, it is removed from the sinner, taking skin (and usually eyeballs) with it. Finally, red hot pincers are used to remove the prisoner's tongue.

It is interesting to note that the Holy Trinity was designed not to cause death, so that the maimed, blinded and mute prisoner could live out his days as a burden to his family and as a testimony to what happens when one lets his tongue wag too freely.

Nobody's doing that here.

by tony hopkinson

Kettle is busy right now he'll get back to you.

On a side note for those that read this post and are open to learning the fundamentals I suggest reading

Calculus of Logic By George Boole.

Preconcieved notion

ROTFLMAO

by tony hopkinson

Christianity does not profess to convince the perverse and headstrong, to bring irresistible evidence to the daring and profane, to vanquish the proud scorner, and afford evidences from which the careless and perverse cannot possibly escape. This might go to destroy man's responsibility. All that Christianity professes, is to propose such evidences as may satisfy the meek, the tractable, the candid, the serious inquirer."

meek, tractable, candid, serious enquirer
vs
perverse, headstrong, daring, profane, proud, scornful and careless.

It's always nice to see an unbiased investigation into important issues

Oh my ribs

by sleepin'dawg

Or are you just a plain old master baiter??? :^O
Sorry Neil, I just couldn't resist but you did post it.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

That's posh-speak from around the time of the KJV Bible for "bugger off"!

I'm going home now. You've upset me. I'll probably have to go and pig-out on a curry to make myself feel better.

by jellimonsta

My wife actually prefers not to question anything, in her faith and is happy following the herd.

I personally, have always questioned everything. I was not actually raised Christian, and in fact came to Christ myself at around the age of 22.

Some of the brightest people I know are Christian (a number of friends who have PhD's are Christian). I imagine I can also go the other end of the spectrum too though. :)

by Member 25348569

but it was just an excuse for a lamb jalfrezi. I don't do "upset" - except when I want to. I'm supposed to be on a diet...

by jacksonian

You posted some of the following (which I couldnt respond to in the original thread titled "Replying to JacksonMN@.. (19 of 128)" (The max message depth was exceeded))

You said that you "have not described your faith or the source(s) of it" and that I was "not in a position to comment on it".

I have not described my faith to you either, so how can you be in a position to comment on mine or any other Christians for that matter? Your faith comes from a myriad of sources, and I guess you feel that (like being bilingual) that makes you "hyper-spiritual".

I can read a few books and talk to a few people about avionics, but that doesnt make me a pilot ..

You also noted something about baffling me in regards to the source of your faith. Believe me, you are not baffling me in any way. I wasnt always a believer in Christ, and I know plenty about what the world has to offer.

I also find it rather amusing that you feel that you have the secret "profound understanding" about God in terms of having a greater understanding of scripture.

From "Christian meditation" to "osmosis", its all useless, and so profoundly not Christian. Christ didnt hide the truth, nor did he leave cheat codes to warp straight to level 99. As layed out in the Bible, without the guidance of the Holy Spirit it is not from God but worldy nonsense ... (see 1 Cor 2:12-14 & 1 John 2:20, 27).

With this alchemical approach you have towards "religion", you are not turning lead into gold.

Since you stated you based your faith on Christian principles, you started with gold.
B
y diluting the truth with different worldy concepts (see the book of Revelation for detail), you are turning gold into dirt ...

You also mention your faith is distinct (from any particular denomination or interpretation). I do not claim a particular denomination, does that make me uber-spiritual?

Every Christians faith is distinct, that is why encouragement and fellowship is important. To lift up others in areas we are strong in and to be lifted up in areas that others are strong in.

by jardinier

no-one comes to the Father but by me."

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have everlasting life.

Well there ya go. That says it all, doesn't it.

I have no intention of describing my "profound understanding" because it would fall on deaf ears.

Re: "The max message depth was exceeded" the answer to that is to post to an earlier thread linked to, but above the one you are answering.

by jardinier

Someone has come up with an appropriately reverent and profound comment on the subject matter of this discussion. ;)

by gregk

That wasn't clear to me.
The post before yours seemed to be saying that using the bible to prove what the bible says is valid because it actually was a compendium. You seemed to be agreeing with that post, only disagreeing with his figures.
I simply pointed out that evolution which many christian fundamentalists disagree with, or any other topic where many people agree in print can be "proved" by the same method if it is agreed this is a valid proof.
What I now understand you were really saying was that they agree because the editors only chose the texts that agreed with their stance and that is why they are consistent. I agree with you on this point.

by sleepin'dawg

Look at Neil he gives me stuff I can work with. Definitely not up to your standards.

Neil, what's with the diet business??? Hope it's only a weight loss thing, I wouldn't like it to be for medical reasons.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by Member 25348569

what we in this country would call a "lardy git". More than 220lb in American money and a good lump of it put on over Christmas and not lost over the last couple of weeks while we were reorganising all of our storage.

Pizza? Pizza! Damn. I've ordered too much again...

by computab

You don't believe it because you've told yourself you will not believe. But no man could have fortold what the bible fortold, The Roman Empire, the destruction of Tyre - it is still as the Bible said; Sidon is also as the Bible said, a small busy market town; and wars in the middle east, and the one that has not happened yet, nuclear war over Jerusalem. It is all because man cannot live at peace with his neighbours. The best thing you could do is go to a private room, get on your knees and pray for God to reveal these things to you, and ask his forgiveness.

by tony hopkinson

I don't believe because I can find no convincing reason to do so. Your reasons will never suffice, because they are built on your faith. With me there is nothing for them to sit on, no foundation.
One of the main reasons man can't live with his neighbours is religion all those foolish heathen infidels who cast doubt threatening your own belief system.

You need god, I don't.
You need me to need to god to bolster your own belief, I don't care whether you hold the same opinion as me or not.

You don't challenge my belief system, you validate it.

P.S.
A tip don't bet anything you value on seeing me on my knees begging. If you really really want to see that bring friends, guns, dogs and sneak up behind me while I'm asleep.

by jardinier

to a large extent is a ploy used by organised religion to induce people to accept the teachings regardless of glaring contradictions, omissions or absurdities.

I accept that there is "real" faith based on an individual's personal experience.

But in the context in which it is normally used, it is just a con to get people to accept illogical, irrational and unprovable doctrines.

You may pause for a moment and think about when do you get your reward or punishment for good or bad deeds.

Universally -- across all religions -- it is after you die. Be it eternal heaven or hell, or reincarnation, you simply are promised NO proof in this lifetime.

As I have never met anyone who has returned from the afterlife to inform me of what I may expect, then I stake no faith in promises of reward or punishment AFTER I shed this mortal shell.

Many years ago a Professor Emeritus of Biology who was also a committed Christian made the following observation:

"Life after birth is more important than life after death."

Well I have no argument with that. If there IS an afterlife, the only way to prepare for it is to live the most honest and ethical life that I can in this corporeal realm.

by gadgetgirl

you're extra cuddly?

(just spent 10 mins converting your weight back to real money.......!)

Not that I would know, of course, because....

[b]YOU STOOD ME UP!!![/b]

:D

GG

Jules - profuse apologies for hijacking this post in your thread, but the opportunity was way too good to miss....sowwy! :x GG

by gregk

Faith is belief without proof. No christian needs to "prove" anything about the KJV or anything else about their faith. One needs only believe: "Jesus saith unto him, Thomas because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, yet have believed" John 20:29

by jardinier

there is quite a lot of archaeological evidence that supports the HISTORY of the Hebrew peoples.

And yes, some of this evidence supports events that were in fact prophesied in the Bible.

The Old Testament contains history, law, prophesy and poetry as well as specific theological teachings.

I regard it as simply all that was recorded by these people in every facet of life. It is a library. You can read the history, enjoy the poetry, (and laugh at the prophecy if you wish).

However the various parts cannot be separated from the religious theme that is woven through it.

If you don't believe in God, you can at least acknowledge that it is a fairly trustworthy history book.

by tony hopkinson

It's as trustworthy as any 'history' book, the older the history the more suspect.
Archaelogical evidence does not account for motive.

Tell me why was David lauded for cowardly shooting an honourable opponent from a distance ?

Because Goliath was a bit dead.

How come Soddom and Gommorah, got such bad press, because everyone except the git who ran out on them was a bit dead.

History is written by the victors. Book are paid for by the victors. Writing bad things about them was very very bad for your health. It's a historical document but if it's history it's a poorly written, overly subjective, disjointed and massively biased.

So no I don't acknowledge it as a history book, I've read a lot of proper ones.

by dr_zinj

1. I come from a raised as a Roman Catholic background.
2. The writers were certainly inspired OF God. But I sincerely doubt they were inspired BY God. There are too many differences in translation to convey accurate, original meaning. If God is so great and he inspired the Bible, then he'd have made sure that there was one version, completely accurately translated into any language, that would be accurately and identically understood be everyone that read it. Instead, we have a myriad of "christian" religions that have resorted to bloodshed and pursecution over the millenia; not exactly what I think God intended.
3. I think the Bible should be a starting point for people to find God. Unfortunately, various organizations and the passage of time have done a terrific job of eliminating conflicting viewpoints or viewpoints that do not reinforce the positions of those already in power.
4. Jesus of Nazareth was a son of God. One of the best; but we are all sons and daughters of God, at least according to the Bible.
5. The Popes aren't and weren't infallable. Some of them, including the 'legitimate' ones, were downright wrong. Neither is the Dali Lama. Buddah made mistakes. Jesus is on record for having his temper get the best of him and trashing a market.
6. There are many roads to "Heaven". Christianity can take you there. So can Islam. So can Buddism. So can Hinduism. So can the path of Taoists, animists, etc.
7. Most of us are totally ignorant of what God really wants us to do. Unfortunately, too many of us don't know it and are proud of it.
8. I have yet to find someone who can really tell me who or what God really is. Not saying they don't know; just that they are incapable of communicating that information.
9. The 10 Commandments are one of the major bases for our legal system in the United States. No reason to tear copies out of government buildings; but I'd like to see copies of the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution (with ammendments) equally prominently posted.
10. I'm just a voice of a man in the wilderness. I may sound like a howling coyote. If you listen to dogs barking, you'll go deaf early, and not learn very much.

by tony hopkinson

In fact that's basically my argument against faith.
Tell me for you it's rewarding, satisfying, comforting ... fine, don't tell me it's logical though, the latter is taking me for an idiot and I don't tolerate that.

by jck

I've been saying for years...after you see history filled with idiot rulers who manipulated things to their advantage...including the church...how can you not say any Bible is impure?

Plus the fact, the men who have transcribed it and interpreted it over the centuries probably have not conveyed all the original writings perfectly.

Humans are imperfect. The Bible has gone through thousands of modifications and transcriptions by humans.

Therefore, it's content (or that of any other modern religious tome) should not be considered perfect and should not in any way be considered the "true word of God".

by jellimonsta

I actually had my first taste of Indian Food since I have been in the States (eight years). Went to an Indian Buffet with some friends. It was actually very good and I will have to visit there again. I just wish they had some Chicken Korma on hand when I was there. :(

by gregk

The reason religion is not science is that it CANNOT be disproved.

It is perfectly valid to say that God created the fossils 6000 years ago. In fact it is perfectly valid to say that God created me yesterday, and all my memories are part of God's marvellous creation. Statements like these can be neither proved nor disproved. That does not alter the fact that they may be true, or for that matter false.

My reason for not believing (or at least not worshipping) the Christian God is the problem of Suffering.

If we define God as all powerful, all knowing, all loving and interventionist as I was brought up to believe*, then I simply cannot believe in a God that can allow such things as the Boxing Day Tsunami. To stand by and do nothing when you know about such an event, and are capable of doing something about it, even want to do something about it, but do nothing is not consonant with that definition.
It is, I suppose, valid to argue that we cannot understand His ineffable purpose, but I choose NOT to worship a being that would allow that event to happen.

The problem of evil itself just barely squeaks under the wire on the free will argument.

* The first three were explicitly stated. The fourth is implicit in the very concept of miracles and the Messiah.

by tony hopkinson

It is necessary that we suffer, without suffering we would not grow. If there is a god and we are operating on a half way intelligent plan, of course we suffer.
As far as evil goes, that's necessary too after all evil is not good, if god is a personification of all that's good then the devil is a necessity.
Evil must be as powerful as good or at least powerful enough to be a factor otherwise how can good(god) continue to be defined ?

Eternal life, eternal love, relief from suffering. I'm sure this was a significant goal and worth a bit of begging for the ignorant. I don't consider that a heaven though, no growth, no progress, an eternity of now, I'd rather just cease than face that.

So I didn't decide on faithlessness because I suffer, but because I believe that without suffering I would be in hell. The fact that the church would have be kneel and beg for entry to such an estate just proves how f'ing stupid they think I am.

by gregk

Why do pigeons have to suffer to make cats content?
The way we ARE made we need suffering/sadness/misery as a juxtaposition to happiness/joy/wellbeing in order to appreciate them. An all powerful all knowing god (refer my definition) would not have to make us that way. A loving god would not choose to do so. That fact that he did indicates that one or more of the necessary attributes of god is missing. There whatever created us is either not God as defined or not something I want to worship.
Even if we allow your pigeon/cat argument which I don't, where is the "cat" in the brutal death of a baby by tidal wave?
I do not buy the "Adze blows" of CS Lewis either.
This is now well and truly off topic.

by jardinier

Of course it is biased. It was not written by a third party.

But do you know of any other document written in the BC era that gives such a detailed account of a particular race of people and their culture?

Estimated years of authorship of the various books of the OT are from 1445 BC (Genesis) through to 450 BC (Chronicles 1 and 2, and various others).

I'm no historian so I am asking you the question.

by jardinier

Who cares? I am enjoying hearing the different points of view.

Besides TR needs a religious discussion every few months or certain people start to suffer withdrawal symptoms.

The discussions are usually started by Protius -- a fair dinkum American fundamentalist evangelical, or myself -- a hybrid who no-one has yet been able to "pigeon" hole.

by tony hopkinson

Evil to know good was one argument.
Suffering a requirement for progress, one argument.
The complete an utter stupidity of the idea that anyone who loved you would choose to make your existance an unrewarding blur of non-events another.
Sorry I was so unclear you managed to mix them up.

by tony hopkinson

Makes me think about it. Explaining my position, without insulting people is challenging, occasionally descending into name calling when someone insists on pressing my buttons even more so.
Just off to go into a dark room, get on my knees ....

and harvest some mushrooms now.

by tony hopkinson

I'm afraid 14 - 17th century english history is my favourite. Particularly Good Queen Bess' reign.

However from what I do know, the BC stuff were translations censored by a political process by vested interests at the time. Subsequently the bible has gone through more translations, again by people with a particular bias. On top of that, it's been revised to be more current in terms of society. So I think if you built a time machine and zipped back to BC days, the people around at the time would not know what you were talking about.
There again if I was to don my tights and ruffle , and trundle back to see the greatest british monarch of all time, how much would my books help me, certainly not as much as their various authors would claim.
Historians can't even agree on how WWI was conducted. The only difference now is the ones who conform to the view of the state and or church don't get to set their detractors on fire.

by tony hopkinson

If there IS an afterlife, the only way to prepare for it is to live the most honest and ethical life that I can in this corporeal realm.

Practice what you preach, should be the first principle. Break that one you're a liar. Where there's one lie, there is always another. The church has done more to damage itself than any number of people like me has done to it.

by montgomery gator

Thanks for the link. The KJV is one of many translations of the true Word of God. As the article points out, it does have its flaws. Those of us who do not know Hebrew and Greek must depend on those who do to translate from the original language. And as the article points out, there is disagreements as to which texts are closest to the original. But as far as differences I have seen and know about, none of them are major enough to make for a difference in orthodox Christian theology.

I prefer the New King James Version myself. The translators used the general grammar and text of the KJV, updated to modern English, but retranslated from the original Greek and Hebrew, with footnotes pointing out where the various Hebrew and Greek manuscripts now in existence vary, as the article points out.

by montgomery gator

The gospels report that Jesus read from the book of Isaiah in the synagogue, and that he wrote in the dust of the ground when the woman who committed adultery was brought before Him. But, you are right, as far as we know, that He did not leave any writings behind, but we do have records left by His closest followers.

by montgomery gator

Free Will started in the Garden of Eden, when Adam and Eve ate of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil, bringing sin and death into the world. We also have Free Will to accept or reject the gift of salvation from our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.

Just had to get that in since you mentioned "predestination". :-)

by montgomery gator

How dare you call the greatest prophet of the Old Testament, who talked to God face to face, and author of its first 5 books of the Bible, an amanuensis, whatever that is!! Remember that Moses is the guy that did take dictation from God!!

Then there was Baruch, who wrote down what Jeremiah told him, and Jeremiah got the words from God.

by gregk

I hope you were:
Amanuensis \A*man`u*en"sis\, n.; pl. Amanuenses. [L., fr. a,
ab + manus hand.]
A person whose employment is to write what another dictates,
or to copy what another has written.
That makes both both Moses and Baruch Amanuenses!

Of course it also makes Jeremiah guilty of hearsay (literally) :P

by montgomery gator

Have you ever been called a Homo sapiens?
I bet you have been known to masticate in public!!

(see the apocryphal story of the Senate campaign in Florida between Smathers and Pepper over 50 years ago) :-)

by montgomery gator

Much of the Bible was written down as it happened, or within a few years. The events in Genesis was passed down from generation to generation until Moses wrote them down for the first time, but Moses wrote down the events he was involved with in Exodus through Deuteronomy pretty much as they happened (except for the first part of Exodus recording his birth and early part of his life up to his return to Egypt to liberate his people). The Torah (or Law, the first 5 books written by Moses) were placed next to the Ark of the Covenant as Moses instructed (Deuteronomy 31:26). Only the last chapter of Deuteronomy, recording his death, was written by someone else (probably Joshua).

The writings of the prophets, from Isaiah through Malachi, were written down by each individual prophet that each book is named after.

The scribes of ancient Israel and Judah were dedicated to faithfully transcribing each letter perfectly and accurately of Holy Scripture to preserve it over the generations.

by montgomery gator

The Bible is noteworthy for presenting its "heroes" as having flaws, not as perfect heroes and supermen. Most ancient history and legends sugarcoated events and made their heroes look perfect, but not the Bible.

Moses (who wrote the first 5 books) wrote about himself that he was timid and a bad speaker, and that he disobeyed God on occasion. His brother Aaron, the High Priest, was shown to be complicit in the construction and worship of the golden calf.

David, the great king and hero of Israel, was portrayed as a murderer and adulterer, not as a perfect role model. David did not have his history sanitized, he admitted he was wrong to sleep with Bathsheba and have her husband Uriah killed, and repented, and he and his kingdom suffered for his transgression. All the kings and queens of Israel and Judah were shown to be imperfect and flawed. This makes the Bible unique as a history book from ancient times. The writers were more than willing to write down bad things about their rulers.

Other kings and societies in ancient times left out the bad, ignoble parts of their history, but the history of Israel and Judah as recorded in the Bible did not whitewash anything. The good, bad, and ugly were recorded for all time in the Bible. This makes the Bible more trustworthy as a historical document than the writings of the Egyptians, Babylonians, and other ancient people from the same time.

PS. Yes, David did knock down Goliath from a distance using a sling, but at least he had the guts to face Goliath in battle, when no one else was willing to answer his challenge. And, if you were in David's situation, I would think you would do the same thing rather than fight Goliath up close. David showed intelligence in that matter in that he knew the only way he could defeat Goliath was to trust in God and knock Goliath down from a distance, then rush up and behead the sucker before he could regain consciousness. David was lauded for trusting in God, being the only one in Israel willing to face Goliath, and having the wisdom and intelligence to knock down his enemy at a distance.

by tony hopkinson

He couldn't lose, his opponent was completely blindsided.
I pity Goliath, it never occurred to him, that this coward was going to do him in such a fashion.
When you hear the 'uplifting' stories about David it's always, him vs Goliath, and why because he won. The historians at the time were hardly going to start
Then King David who has the honour of a starving rat and the courage of a paedophile ...
were they. I'd have a lot more faith in humans as a group, if his own side had tore him to pieces and ceded victory, that would have been courage.
Gut's, I've wiped my arse on harder material.

Question, how many times do you think this sort of behaviour would have to be lauded, until wars decided by combat of champions were replaced by the mechanised mass murder that warfare became.

This discussion is closed to new replies.