Discussion Locked

Is the United States on the road to bankruptcy?

0 helpful
140 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For the past twenty years (ten, here at TR), I've been warning about the possibility - no, make that the inevitability - that the United States government will face the ultimate financial disgrace - financial bankruptcy.

I've been extremely critical of the Democratic Party for advancing policy positions - especially social policy positions - that will ultimately lead to such an outcome; and I've been even more critical of the Republican Party for capitulating to said Democrats and for failing to advance a more fiscally responsible and libertarian principled philosophy for the sake of [i]bipartisanship and/or compromise[/i].

Political party preference aside (if that's even possible), what's on the horizon for the financial stability of, what was once the most financially stable nation on the planet, the United States of America?

P.S. I expect most replies to be nothing but typical political rhetoric. Please prove me wrong.

140 replies

by santeewelding

Sir: the full faith and credit of the United States of America is, at this point, a fiction. It is upheld by us all only because not a one of us can conceive of the alternative -- an ugly thing, indeed.

by santeewelding

Where Scott Paley was interviewing the "99s", those people whose extended unemployment benefits will expire this month.

(I paraphrase):

"What will happen when they run out?" he asked the woman.

"The abyss," she said.

"And, then what?"

"Over the edge," she said.

The "abyss" is the lowest, darkest, coldest point on earth under the seas, where only Beebe (I think) and an associate visited once, tethered and insulated in an iron sphere with a wall about a foot thick.

You got wall?

by maxwell edison

I've been technically, unemployed, in the sense that I went from ~20 years with the same "employer", to being laid-off, to having no "employer" at all for the past 18 months.

Over that 18 months, I've neither applied for, nor collected one dime of "unemployment" payments.

Where there's the will, there's a way. Unfortunately, all too many people lack the will. But government will, for them, ride in and save the day! (Yea, right!)

P.S. Unemployment payments - especially extended unemployment payments = one more brick laid on the road to national bankruptcy!

by santeewelding

Too scattered for me to bear in with some kind of singular, ball-busting reply.

The lack of cohesion, however, does serve both the first tactic and the strategy of self-defense, which is, to say nothing identifiable or locatable about it.

So, I will not ask after how you have achieved what you have achieved. Nor, I suggest, do you relent and describe how for any who ask.

Keep your mouth shut.

by unhappyuser

Done that.

Too many people believe it's the government's job to pull them out of the quagmire. The problem is the government IS the quagmire!

EMD

by nicknielsen

And anybody who can see past political beliefs to actual facts (granted, an increasingly small part of the population) knows it will take a combination of tax increases and spending cuts. But it ain't gonna be easy. And it won't happen as long as the noisemakers in Washington keep talking through their...selves.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/11/07/AR2010110704541.html?nav=rss_opinions

What's on the horizon? More of the same, at least for the next two years. Then, in 2012, when the swing voters repudiate the Republicans the same way they just repudiated the Democrats, it might start sinking in. If not, wait two years, lather, rinse, repeat. Maybe the party leadership will get the message by 2020.

by santeewelding

I don't think we have until 2020. Business as usual is headed straight for a brick wall -- not a yellow-brick road.

by maxwell edison

Speaking for yourself, if you add up (estimated, of course) all the taxes you currently pay per year: federal, social security, medicare, state, local, sales, gasoline, property, various fees, various surcharges, etc., and estimate those to be a certain percentage of your total income, how much are you willing to have your taxes increased? Would you be willing to pay ten percent more? Twenty? Twenty-five?

by nicknielsen

I could live with not more than a 10% increase in that, but only if rational budget cuts also take place.

Now, Max, a question for you: South Carolina is living the nightmare right now.
- An electorate that virulently hates taxes,
- a Republican legislature that refuses to raise taxes, and
- an increasing budget deficit due both to irresponsible tax policies and the current economy.

How much do you cut before you raise taxes? http://www.thestate.com/2010/10/31/1537808/fraud-danger-and-dirt-state-letting.html

by oz_media

You mean, what's that word...HOPE?

LOL, the way I look at ANY situation is;

Q)
Will I actually die from this and not wake up tomorrow morning?

A)
If NO, I'm not going to die tonight, no problem then, tomorrow's another day.
If YES, may as well make the most of it and not worry about it then there's nothing I can do about it.

In most cases I realize that, no matter what happens, I will still wake up tomorrow and live another day, when I don't I wouldn't know it anyway.

by hal 9000

Being so much of the US's GDP that is coming very quickly and has been building for quite a few years now.

It's taken at least 20 years to get to this stage so it's going to take a lot longer and a lot of [b]Pain[/b] on the part of the Citizens to get over it, if that ever happens.

From past Political Experience if it takes 1 year to get into a mess it takes 3 or more to get out of it. Being that it's now at least 20 years of successive Poor Economic Administration on the behalf of successive US Governments I really don't think that there is any [b]Political Will[/b] to do anything about the way that the US Government works.

Also I remember the US Authorities deriding Japan for what they called [i]Quantitative Easing[/i] and it now appears that while it was Bad for Japan and going to cause much trouble for Japan it's acceptable for the US.

Probably because it's [b]EASY[/b] and the people who do it now will not be around when it's time to clean up the mess. The longer that the current situation continues the worse it's going to be for all US Citizens but Unfortunately with the Political System being the way that it is I think you'll find that the Brick Wall has to be Hit and then who ever comes after that mess will blame the previous Government and say that they are going to fix the mess. Of course it's not going to happen quickly and with the current need from the US for [b]Quick Fixes[/b] I very much doubt that there will be enough Political Will to see it out as things should be done and that the Governments who ever they may be will resort to the [b]Easy[/b] Fix.

Max see why I consider all Politician's the same? ;)

Col

by charliespencer

Pain that none of our 'leaders' are willing to ask us to accept. You're dead on about the political will. The opportunities of Sept. 11th are gone, squandered on luggage inspections and wiretaps. The population was in a mood to accept sacrifice; no one in power was willing to ask it.

by delbertpgh

I should qualify my answer to "Yes, virtually," because we can't technically go bankrupt, so long as we can print more money. If we can't pay our bills, i.e. become bankrupt, we can always inflate.

I think the country has big-scale problems that go beyond politics. The biggest is that we buy vastly more from overseas than we export. The only reason we keep getting away with it is that we are the world's largest economy and the international reserve currency. Central banks are willing to hold our paper. You need to value something to run a banking system, and for now, the USD is it.

A problem that goes hand in hand with the first one is that we don't make stuff here like we used to. Capability, performance for price, and exclusivity of technology marked our world-leading manufacturing base up to 1970. Now we put as much business energy into finding ways to outsource our manufacture as we used to invest in making things we could sell and use. The new economy is based primarily on loaning each other money, serving each other lunch, wiping each others' rear ends, and shopping.

We have a particular failing in our leading service industry, the rear end-wiping business, health care. We spend one dollar in six (2008 statistic) on health. We don't manage it in any competitive way; our means of paying for it is irrational and suppresses efficiency; we don't have, as a population, better outcomes than countries that spend less; and it promises only to grow in cost. I saw today an article on a new vaccine procedure that will fight already in progress prostate cancer: it promises to extend life by four months at a cost of $93,000 per treatment. You're going to hear a lot about this. Is it properly priced? Can we afford to add this to an overburdened insurance system? Can we even get around to discussing whether an extra four months at the end of life is a worthwhile investment, given that the party that has risen to power has run against "death panel" discussions like that?

As a rising country in the 50s and 60s, bearing the burdens of defending the free world and building our own prosperity, we were able to invest huge sums in building interstate highways, sea ports, and airports, and all the other infrastructure that goes with being a first-rank economy looking to grow. Today we can't find the political will to invest money to keep it all in repair. In part that's because everything we do costs more money than it did 50 years ago. Some portion of that is government regulation that requires expensive features, and some due to fears of lawsuits that requires every niggling event in life be insured. I remember in 1960 driving in Iowa and Kansas and seeing the new interstate highways, with signs proudly announcing that it cost $50,000 per mile and was 90% paid for by Federal funds. Who can imagine public works projects for so little these days? Who can imagine a jet fighter aircraft for $220,000, the F-86?

We can't educate people to support the economy we wish we had. In the 50s and 60s we produced all of our own engineers, and they led the world; now we import them from Delhi and Taiwan, while our own kids major in communications and criminal justice. My wife teaches at a state college, and she gets the B students who come out of our high schools. And at the rural area college where she teaches, they pretty much get only the white ones, in case you were wondering. And they're stoooooooopid. They come out unprepared to write or reason, and don't see the importance of picking up facts, and have checked out of difficult nerd subject material like math or chemistry.

We have lost the will to regulate our banks, as the populace has lost its will to save and invest. The financial disaster that we experience now is nothing compared to the nightmare we narrowly avoided, but nobody has caught on to what occurred. It will happen again. We've also lost the will to pay for the government services we demand. Tax cuts have become a cure-all and a religious chant that displaces financial reason in our national accounts, and recipients of entitlement spending rail against any talk of rationalization at the expense of their comfort.

So, I'll agree with you, on a lot of issues. Maybe there are some here you haven't thought much about. All these issues are critically important. Government is dysfunctional and wasteful, and so are the people, in their politics and social imagination.

by nicknielsen

[i]...as the populace has lost its will to save and invest. [/i]

The biggest problem I see here, Delbert, is a tax code that rewards consumption and penalizes saving and investing. It's not as bad as it used to be, when credit card interest was deductible, but it's still bad. What to do?

1. As a home-owner, I'm all in favor the the mortgage interest deduction. If government wants to encourage home ownership, this is a good way to do it. But if you can afford a "home" that covers tens of thousands of square feet and costs millions of dollars, you sure as hell don't need the government's encouragement to buy it. Reduce the limit on mortgage value from $1,000,000 to $500,000, or, better yet, give the deduction to the people who need it the most. Limit it to a certain threshold, say 125% of the median home price in the area at the time of purchase, as provided by the NAR and certified in the mortgage.

2. Most of us have all we can do to make payments on one home; limit the mortgage interest deduction to the primary dwelling. No second homes, vacation homes, etc.

3. If you want people to save, they need some encouragement. Exempt the first $1000 of interest or dividend income. This includes savings accounts, certificates of deposit, mutual funds/money market accounts, and stock dividends. Leave IRAs alone.

The other part of the issue is much more problematic. The stock market has changed over the past several decades from a way to capitalize corporations to a way to speculate on society. Don't know how to fix that.

by delbertpgh

1. The home mortgage tax deduction is so holy, you're not going to cut it, so forget it. We don't need to pump more money than we already have into housing, so no need to make the deduction even sweeter.

2. Tax deductions won't make people save.

3. Pay people more. With more money on hand, they won't take out second mortgages, and will have the cash to invest. And by people, I mean the bottom 98%. The years since Reagan have seen all the country's growth captured by the wealthiest few, while median (not average) income has scarcely budged.

We've had 30 years of trickle-up economics, in case you haven't noticed. And I haven't seen where the top crust have gotten so much better at their jobs, or have provided so well for the rest of the country, that one could say they deserve so much better from the economy.

by charliespencer

I've owned four homes. Not once has it been worth itemizing my return to take the mortgage interest deduction. Even in the first full year of each mortgage, when the interest paid is at its highest, I always came out ahead taking the standard deduction instead of itemizing.

Just one goober's opinion, but I wouldn't miss it. I wonder what percentage of home owners can deduct it, or itemize without comparing against the standard deduction.

by the 'g-man.'

Iraq has Oil

Cut a few corners here and there - major oil spill 2010

Add those up for starters...

Same Applies to the UK as well!

by tony hopkinson

if you believed in the incline.

They aren't real numbers, they had, have and will continue to have no basis in reality.

Somebody says something and your 'value' doubles or halves in minutes?

It's bollocks, let the market place find it's real value, if a few of the parasites who make zeros out the imaginary relationship between value and money top themselves, no great loss...

by oz_media

People out here, for the most part, NEED more money to live a happy life. (I am speaking of Canada specifically now, but I see the same issues in the US).

However, when I am in the UK, and for those friends and family that I have there, THEY are just as happy with far less, though they all talk about how nice it would be to live in Canada and make so much money.

The difference I see is that people spend more time in social situations in the UK and Europe in general than out here.

Financially they don't have as much, but they still enjoy the money they have, moreso than most out here do. People here generally stop going to the bar in order to save money, in the UK I find people with less will STILL socialize at the local with all their friends and neighbours.

People in the UK seem to DO more with less, if they are broke they don't care. People out here seem to be insecure doing that as they are used to having more, when they think that they will have less as a result of doing something, they stop doing it.

Maybe that's what it all comes down to, the HAVE'S are scared of not HAVING so they stop DOING. The HAVE NOTS, are used to not HAVING so they are less worried about it and enjoy what little they DO HAVE and don't fear NOT HAVING! :D

Say that 5 X fast! I THINK you'll get what I mean though.

Perhaps its a matter of being content, while everyone WANTS more, I find people that are used to not having more are comfortable with it and don't fear it as those who always have more. They are able to enjoy life even though they have less. There is actually some sense in there somewhere.

I just know that people in the UK and Germany seem to do more with less, and enjoy it a lot more than people out here and south of our border do. In fact I think the fears of being broke in the US are running rampant now, people are really getting freaked out that they just might not have as much money as they are used to having.

If I were you, I wouldn't trade what you have for anything out west (well we have gorgeous mountains and scenery but that's where it ends), it's all just shiny and pretty on the surface but it's really the same dire, grungy economic dump out here too.

Nobody has money, fewer have jobs and those that do fear losing them any day whether they like the job or not. AND ITS BLOODY EXPENSIVE HERE TOO (specifically in Vancouver)!

by jamesrl

But I also know from experience that it can be turned around.

Canada faces many of the same issues the US does. Plus the US is our number customer, so if the US suffers, so do we.

But Canada was, in the early 90s, in worse shape than the US, in terms of government deficit/debt per capita. The books hadn't been balanced since the 60s and the interest cost of the debt was starting to eclipse spending on social programs. So the government (Liberal, to give them their due) took drastic action. About 10% of the federal government workforce was eliminated, some program areas were pushed to the provinces (downloading), and virtually every program was reduced in some way. In a few years, the government broke even, and then started to pay down the debt with surpluses, reducing the interest costs. This leadership lead the provinces to follow suit.

Now this latest crisis has meant that our governments have had to borrow heavily again and projections say it wll be many years before we are paying down the debt again.

But in theory, Governments should be paying down their debt in the good times, and have room to borrow and spend in the bad times.

I think some level of long term government debt is inevitable. If you build a bridge to last 50 years, you shouldn't ask the taxpayers to pay for it all at once, when it will be of benefit to generations yet unborn.

But to continually add to your debt, and get to the point where you lose your triple A creditor rating (which means you pay higher interest rates on your debt), is reckless.

I don't think that bankruptcy is predestined, I think the US can and I hope will take action to turn things around. But I don't see any indication this will happen any time soon. It may mean an INCREASE in taxes, and that doesn't seem very palatable.

by jamesrl

The amount of the debt that the US government owes the world is a real number.

The ratio of that debt to the Gross Domestic Product is a very real number. That ratio determines whether or not the US government gets low interest rates or high. That can mean the difference between a managable debt and one that is spirally out of control.

The stock market is the real of unreal numbers, as the price of stock reflects expectations not reality. Dividends reflect past performance, stock prices are all about future anticipation. But the stock market isn't directly about government debt.

by ansugisalas

that debt is in US$... so just devalue your US$s to turkish lira levels, then sell some stuff to Europe or Canada or India or China or anybody else with harder money...
I'd recommend selling Alaska to Canada, for instance. Get rid of Palin and make things easier on the map-makers too.
With the hard money from the sales you can pay off your devalued debts in no time.

Sure, it would destabilize the world and might cause some wars. But you'd get out of your debts.

by tony hopkinson

The stock market
The futures market
Currency Speculation
Quantitive Investment...

It's all bollocks, the values are only real within the system.

by jamesrl

Government debt is calculated in real numbers. The only intangible is what the government owes at any given moment, cause it keeps growing.

Stocks have a tangible value when you buy one or sell one.

Governements sell bonds, the value of which is constant. Its fixed at a specific rate and for a specific time. Or they get loans, for a specific time at a specific rate. If their credit rating changes, it effects new loans, not existing ones.

If you buying another countries bonds, then you could argue that the relative value of your currency or the curency from the other country vary.

by cg it

which results in ever increasing wages, which results in ever increasing prices.

Social programs like medical care, retirement, are the same as insurance and the same as a pyramid.

one needs an ever increasing base to support and ever decreasing top, and most of all, less and less people taking out than putting in.

Greece had about their entire population not putting into the retirement system and just about everyone pulling out of it.

Unions keep lowering the retirement age as a perk for being union, yet pensions rely upon an increasing population of young people paying into the system while the retired hopefully die off.

Here in the US, you've got government employees, retiring after 20 or 30 years in their 50s getting 100% of their salary and living for another 30 years.... when social security bet that those retiring at 65 might live to 72 or 73, only pulling out 6 to 8 years not 20 to 30 years....

Personally what I think will happen is the US will go back to pre 1929 era social programs, that is there wasn't any, and that it's up to the people to plan and prepare for retirement, and the wealthy will still their money just like they did in 1929...

that's what this most recent recession is all about. The wealthy stealing the middle class and poor's money in the stock market, because the middle class and poor will always believe they will win the next hand like a gambler at the card table, and lose everything.

by ansugisalas

After all... there are bigger pies being handed out, left and right.
War-pie, Tax-pie, Bank-pie, Pork-pie, W-pie.

As for your question... it depends on a lot of things. Will the US kiss and make up with China? Will the war spending be curtailed? Will the political system be cleaned up to reduce the pork-pie ratios? Will the US continue to think that wastefulness is a prerequisite for growth?

You have a lot of avenues available, that can all save your asses, but you have to stop and think about which ones to use.

Social spending is investing in the nation's #1 resource - the people. You wouldn't like it if the government started investing in (i.e. developing ownership of) US corporations... nor would you like it if they started buying mineral commodities. That would be market manipulation, and not the business of a government.
Making the population more productive and less wasteful (sick days are waste) is one of the few non-manipulative ways for a government to spend money on improving it's own future economy.
Infrastructure is another, but that's very porky.

by maxwell edison

[i]After all... there are bigger pies being handed out, left and right.[/i]

That's not quite true.

Two thirds - or more - of U.S. spending is for various social programs. One third for everything else. And in 25 years, or so, it's projected that social spending will account for ALL projected federal revenue.

Social Security and Medicare alone have projected spending of upwards of 70 trillion dollars that's not accounted for anywhere in budget projections.

P.S. Spending is not [i]investing[/i].

by ansugisalas

if it pays dividends.
Social spending, when done right, does pay off.
So call it what you will.

But you're probably the right person to ask for a run-down of US federal and state spending, so you can probably give sources on the two-thirds thing.
I'll say it's hard to believe. Not that I don't believe you, per se, I just would need some assistance in the endeavour.

by tony hopkinson

Govmints of either stripe spend our money like it's not theirs, on somethimg or other. When was the last time either of our two regimes managed by whoever, gave us less government?

First rule of government, first you decide what you want to spend, then you change the rules so it looks like the previous mob wasted all the money on something else, so you have to borrow it.

Generational ponzi scheme....

by tbostwick1

I've been heartily disappointed that the conservative movement would allow, if not practically promote the idea of living and spending beyond one's means. It's so easy to look at, for example, credit cards. This is one area which our entire economy was floated on "credit" (mostly bad) and a notion that I could sell you a $500k house with only a name
and nothing else. We entered into yet another realm that took "buyer beware" to another level within housing, real estate, mortgages and the list goes on. While folks were shaking hands on the outside, they were laughing on the inside and all the way to the bank for 10+ years. We need to develop a new term for this form of "free-market" and "free-trade" - call it something simple, like greed or gluttony. Socially -we've even worse and "society" really doesn't exist anymore, nor does community. It's also apparent that history is absent from your article - and is biased heavily in favor of blind ignorance and letting the corporate world rule society - as if no other possibility existed. What this country needs is a good, honest dose of socialism - and perhaps it'll wake up - otherwise it'll wake up one day, still plugged in and when the headphones come off - your world has disappeared beneath your feet.

by tbostwick1

And of course - your ignorance is more than apparent when it comes to infrastructure. When 1/3 of the nations counties can't provide adequate water supplies to their citizens, and we still (some 10+ years later) properly fund or staff hospitals to meet the crisis of another 9/11 or Katrina - we argue, spit and claw around in the sewer known as politics. republicans - make a lot of money for themselves, and hope that it "trickles down" - for their own projects.
Dems - spend the money instead of hording it because no one else will, esp. Republicans

This system is failing us all and only puts our country further and further out of touch with the top countries. Soon, the USA will be nothing but a bunch of over-zealous demagogues who can't think, talk or act for themselves.

by maxwell edison

Paying unemployment benefits, for example, is not [i]investing[/i] in anything. It provides absolutely no return.

Giving people money they did not earn is not [i]investing[/i] in anything except creating a larger dependency class, providing absolutely no return.

But, like I said, we'll have to just agree to disagree.

by ansugisalas

In some cases it's keeping people in a working order for the limited duration of unemployment. After which they will repay, in taxes.
Someone who's in the middle of foreclosure is not a very reliable worker.
Nor is someone who is now living in his/her car.
Bankrupcty is wasteful. Foreclosures are wasteful. Suicides are wasteful. People turning to crime is wasteful.
A government should optimize its social management to minimize waste. It's not about spending more or spending less... it's about deciding the level of spending that gives the greatest returns.
If you think that a dollar given to a starving man is pure loss, then you've got a few things to learn about synergy. And about starving men, too.

by maxwell edison

You assume that the role of government is [i]social management[/i]. No it's not - at least it's not supposed to be in the USA.

You also assume that without a nanny government, people would be unable to find alternatives to cure their own life's challenges. They would.

I could have applied for unemployment myself, but I chose not to - which FORCED me to find alternatives. I'm no smarter or better than anyone else. I simply adapted to a period of change. Others can too.

I also know that many people - maybe most people - abuse the unemployment system. So many of them earn money [i]on the side[/i] and don't report it to the unemployment office. And I know some of them personally.

by jamesrl

Money spent on transportation infrastructure is investing, because it opens up markets. Money well spent on education(note not just throwing money at it) can mean a smarter workforce which keeps high value jobs in America.

But much of government spending goes beyond that kind of investment and into non productive wealth transfer.

by j-mart

That is their choice. You would probably class Finland or New Zealand, a nanny state, you are entitled to your opinion. I myself would prefer to live in Finland rather than the US. A less uptight and less desperate population makes for a much less violent society to live in. Life is for living.

Your constitution, like any legal document can often be turned into shades of gray depending on what interpretation you hire your lawyers to find in it. It is the same with our founding document, the Treaty of Waitangi, whenever a sharp lawyer finds a loophole, there will always be another lawyer who will bend it into something else. Even the 10 commandments, seemingly black and white have been bent by all religions to be interpreted in their own way.

by rayezilla

...Twenty or thirty years down the line, a military coup will put a strong personality in capitol hill. He'll reorganize things so that they work again, with the only catch being that he will put his kids as the next generation of leadership. (effectively making US an empire by a ruling family).

As long as the leaders are 'ok,' things will go on like that until we finally get a leader who is so inept that one of two things will happen: 1) assassination by the military 2) public dissent will result in a revolution.
If it's the first, the USA probably will cease to exist as we know it. If it's the second, we may have hope.

Sound impossible? This is ancient (Roman) history... and as the sages say, history repeats itself.

by tony hopkinson

predict the US
Will go super socialist
Become a theocracy
or break up into corporate fuedalist states, some would say that has already happened...

Can't see the dictator bit working, you've all got guns....

by rayezilla

All of those options (theocracy, socialist, corporate feudal system) require a cult of personality around a single person (maybe a few different people in the case of corporate feudalism) and most of them would support hereditary leadership.

I'm think that however the guy fixes it, he's going to say that the country 'owes him' enough to turn his family line in the leaders... which will work out ok at first, but eventually we may have a Roman scenario.

by ansugisalas

If counting together social security, unemployment/welfare+other_mandatory_spending, medicare, medicaid+child_health.
But this doesn't take into account the taxes paid on these benefits, nor does it take into account the part of this spending which is a de facto subsidy for medical businesses, which in itself generates a sizeable tax revenue.
And it doesn't take into account the amount of this that goes to payroll, which again is not all spending as part of it comes back as taxes.

by j-mart

The whole point of any government is to manage society the alternative is anarchy.

by tony hopkinson

It's a piece of paper, a fiction, a way of keeping score.

Dear america you owe us forty billion dollars
Here you go

IOU $40,000,000,000
Signed Uncle Sam

Now they don't?

by maxwell edison

We apparently have different visions of what our friend from Finland meant with his use of the term [i]social management[/i].

Government role, among other things, is, of course, to structure itself as to prevent societal breakdown. But [i]social management[/i] is so vague and open to myriad interpretations. And in the case of the particular subject at hand - unemployment payments - government failing to provide such a thing is hardly tantamount to anarchy.

Less government nannyism does not equal anarchy.

by j-mart

what does a government need to do to manage society?. How best to spend finite funds. Is it better to spend taxes on people, militarism, infrastructure, taking into consideration a major factor in the ending of the cold war and the USSR was the financial drain. The direction the US goes in is not up to me and if a solution to any of the western worlds financial woes is found it won't be simple and based on any black and white ideology.

by jamesrl

so are all the pounds in your bank account.

If they are all fiction, I'm sure you can be persauded to give them to me.

Somehow I doubt thats going to happen.

by maxwell edison

You and I (and/or others) might disagree, so we refer to the rules - the United States Constitution - which has been absolutely butchered and/or ignored for decades (at least in my opinion).

For example, show me exactly where in the U.S. Constitution it allows government to provide funds for those folks who are unemployed. (And if you cite the [i]General Welfare[/i] clause, please tell us what James Madison said about that particular clause.)

by ozmidnight

I found this and thought it may be interesting this is the web address

http://www.ustreas.gov/tic/mfh.txt

MAJOR FOREIGN HOLDERS OF TREASURY SECURITIES
(in billions of dollars)
HOLDINGS 1/ AT END OF PERIOD

Aug
Country 2010
------

China, Mainland 868.4
Japan 836.6
United Kingdom 2/ 448.4
Oil Exporters 3/ 226.6
Brazil 165.0
Carib Bnkng Ctrs 4/ 159.1
Hong Kong 137.8
Taiwan 130.2
Russia 129.0
Switzerland 106.6
Canada 103.4
Luxembourg 79.1
Thailand 60.9
Germany 58.7
Singapore 52.7
Ireland 42.0
Korea, South 41.6
India 39.0
Mexico 36.0
France 35.5
Belgium 34.3
Egypt 33.6
Turkey 29.5
Poland 24.1
Italy 20.9
Norway 18.2
Netherlands 17.7
Colombia 17.0
Israel 16.4
Sweden 15.7
Philippines 13.7
Chile 13.2
Denmark 12.9
Malaysia 11.7
Australia 11.7
All Other 165.7
Grand Total 4212.9

Of which:
For. Official 2771.8
Treasury Bills 495.6
T-Bonds & Notes 2276.1

Department of the Treasury/Federal Reserve Board
October 18, 2010

1/ Estimated foreign holdings of U.S. Treasury marketable and non-marketable bills, bonds, and notes
reported under the Treasury International Capital (TIC) reporting system are based on annual
Surveys of Foreign Holdings of U.S. Securities and on monthly data.
2/ United Kingdom includes Channel Islands and Isle of Man.
3/ Oil exporters include Ecuador, Venezuela, Indonesia, Bahrain, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Oman, Qatar,
Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Algeria, Gabon, Libya, and Nigeria.
4/ Caribbean Banking Centers include Bahamas, Bermuda, Cayman Islands, Netherlands Antilles and Panama.
Beginning with new series for June 2006, also includes British Virgin Islands.

by nicknielsen

[i]For example, show me exactly where in the U.S. Constitution it allows government to provide funds for those folks who are unemployed. (And if you cite the General Welfare clause, please tell us what James Madison said about that particular clause.) [/i]

What is the role of government?

Until that is settled to everybody's satisfaction (or at least a consensus reached), all else is moot.

Unfortunately, given the increasing animosity from both fringes, I don't see consensus in the near future.

by maxwell edison

It's spelled out - specifically - in the U.S. Constitution. No more, no less.

Hint: If you have to go searching for the clause that might justify your desired end result, it's probably not something that was intended.

by santeewelding

I was about to post the same.

Thought better of it, though. Got nowhere when I tried it in the past.

by nicknielsen

Why is there so much discussion and argument? It's not as cut-and-dried as you (or I) would like, Max.

Give me a few days, and I can probably raise a reasonable justification for health care reform under the commerce clause. (I said reasonable, not convincing, eh?)

by maxwell edison

Legal documents should have a basis upon which decisions should be made. That basis is the United States Constitution.

by maxwell edison

What it's been made to be, versus what it should be, that is what disagreements - and revolutions - are made of.

Dont tread on me - I won't tread on you - Don't tread on others. A pretty good rule of thumb.

by santeewelding

For any two or more sovereigns who understand that "government" means self-government. Anything else here is a farce.

by maxwell edison

...... to be sent to a work camp for 5 months, each and every year, to toil and work - without pay - for the benefit of others? The only difference between that and what you said is the location and possibly the type of work.

P.S. Don't forget the required reading from your little red book. (I actually have a copy on my book shelf.)

by maxwell edison

..... without accepting self responsibility. (Who's gonna' pay for my health care?)

We live in a nation of cowards - afraid to accept self-responsibility and the outcome that follows. And they are dragging those who are willing to accept it down with them.

by santeewelding

This goes to my point in another place, viz., there is no constitutional answer to the Constitution.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It might be worth teaching people the pitfalls of covetousness, and the value of being content with less.

You can't save what you don't have.

edit
points for using covetousness in a sentence

by santeewelding

Points subtracted from [b]delbert[/b] for his hellashish contention that someone is in charge of this thing we call the, "econonmy".

by j-mart

Those legal documents are still based on the interpretation of the founding document, and as the original document was written in a different world, there is always opportunity to look at it in a light that suits your particular preconceived view.

The US Constitution will not make the slightest difference to saving the US economy.

by maxwell edison

[i]The US Constitution will not make the slightest difference to saving the US economy[/i]

Maybe, maybe not.

However, decades of ignoring its true intent is what caused the problem in the first place.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It's about mentality. We'll go down the tubes if we don't change our mentality.

My two cents.

by paladin2

The fact that you differentiate between the two parties shows a certain naive knowledge of the system because there is but the One Party and the circus of an 'opposition' keeps em coming to the show. The U.S. is already bankrupt and has been for a while, it's just gotten to the point where either they can't hide it or maybe they just don't care what the people 'think' because they'll just squash any real attempt to make them honest. Once a right has been given up or a power unconstitutionally taken it won't ever come back and they will never give anything they've taken up. When other countries, and it's happening now, stop buying worthless bonds, the real reality will no longer be deniable. I've lived outside the states now for 16 years and the U.S. isn't just in trouble, it's finished. WW3 is what will probably happen before the 1/10 of a percent that own and run the country give up any power and that ball is already rolling but the so called 'press' in the U.S. has become nothing but a press release system for them. You'd be quite shocked at the news that is not mentioned in any of your media. Shocked and really pissed. The foreign policy of the U.S. has nothing to do with 'national security' and certainly isn't in the interests of We The People. You can call it ignorance by choice or a more correct term like cognitive dissonance but the fact is that most gringos don't want to hear the truth and even with the documented facts staring them in the face they will still deny it. And drop another bomb on someones mud hut.

by tony hopkinson

my bank spent them all..

All money is, is a promise, bearing in mind it's backed by bankers and politicians, relying on it, is an iffy proposition.

by delbertpgh

You have to be able to claim lots of stuff to beat the standard deduction. My wife has a ton of unreimbursed professional expenses, and we have a thoroughly unwanted condominium that we try to rent out, and the money we lose on that is also deductible. All this stuff, with the home mortgage interest, makes it possible to save a little on taxes.

Of course, along comes the Alternative Minimum Tax, and takes a lot of that away anyhow.

by charliespencer

I'm not going to spend more just to save a little. I was mostly wondering how many homeowners are able to take advantage of this deduction. I'm with Nick - cap the deduction and apply it to primary residences only.

by maxwell edison

..... have to do with American government out-of-control spending, deficit spending, accumulation of massive debt, etc.?

Our trade deficit is related to oil, to be sure, but federal spending?

by charliespencer

Why did we go to war defending Kuwait in 1990 if it wasn't over oil? Why are we there now? There may be other excuse, but oil is a prime factor.

It isn't cheap to maintain a military presence there for eight years. Unlike previous military excursions, we funded this one with ... tax CUTS.

by maxwell edison

The amount of money spent on military presence in the middle east pales in comparison to federal spending on social programs. Moreover, you want to see our economy really tank? Then stop the flow of imported oil!

Re: Tax cuts - more accurately, tax rate cuts. Why is it that over those years of tax rate cuts, the total revenue collected by the federal government increases (almost) every year after year, and is always on a general upward climb? I certainly acknowledge that if tax rates were cut to zero percent, or some other ridiculously low number, that total revenues would drop, but that hasn't been the case.

The answer is obvious: They've taken in MORE money - regardless of tax rate cuts - but their spending has outpaced even those increases in revenue!

http://www.usgovernmentrevenue.com/downchart_gr.php?year=1902_2014&view=1&expand=&units=b&fy=fy11&chart=F0-fed&bar=0&stack=1&size=m&title=&state=US&color=c&local=s

If federal spending could be frozen at a particular level - and tax rates, for that matter - the growth in GDP would result in higher revenue year after year, thereby eliminating the annual budget deficit in a very short time, and eventually allow the national debt to be paid down. In the very least, STOP INCREASING FEDERAL SPENDING!

by Member 25348569

The only thing that will do THAT is the bankrupting of your economy. There is never going to be the widespread adoption of a more energy-conserving lifestyle when there are other alternatives.

by oz_media

and I again revert to oil, sigh, sorry.

You know how I have often commented about how Middle Eastern investors have socked away trillions into the US for huge chunks of Florida etc. You know how I have often commented on the dire straits if more Middle Eastern Nations start trading in "Eurodollars" instead of the American "petrodollar".

The US government, sorry to say this and I hope you are sitting down, is probably just as aware of the economic situation as you are. Perhaps they have even seen it since you began posting to TR too?

So is there not some bizarre coincidence, IS it a coincidence, that the US is VERY infatuated with the countries that control oil trade?

The whole Afghan pipeline thing, where it is in America's best interests to make sure control is not turned over to the wrong hands, must play a role too.

If they make peace and allies with these Middle Eastern nations, prove to the Middle East that US relations are imperative to their security and safety against terrorist, Russia etc., are they not in turn securign the petrodollar and therefore the Middle Eastern investments in the US?

We aren't talking about money that can simply be produced when requested. What if the investors of those trillions decide THEY would rather invest in the European economy and Eurodollar? Can America even handle that kind of "refund"? Will they start selling hotels, then houses, then their get out of jail free cards in order to make the bill?

I think people who say it's not all about oil are either in denial or simply don' tget it. Then again, those who say it is ALL about oil may be the same, but there IS undeniably some VERY strong relation between the US economy, Middle Eastern oil, terrorism and support.

This isn't new either, as you very well know. This goes way back through many presidencies where Middle Eastern support has been for the good guy, then the bad guy, then the good guy etc., because one day they are an enemy, the next an ally.

I think they have the US government over a barrel, it's funny how Tony Blair had such interest in it too, being a representative of a major European power that ALSO relies heavily on the Middle East for oil.

Was the cold war ALL about nukes? Why not oil too? Were we duped into hating Russia just so governments had an opening if they needed to go to war in Eastern Europe? Was it not Russia's OIL that Hitler's commanders initially sought out in WWII to try and turn the tide when he had failed at dominating England?

Obviously there's a lot more to it than most care to put together or admit to when they do.

Just thoughts, not bait, not seeking argument just thoughts. In fact, I'd welcome some healthy dialogue on the issue as I am sure you have a lot of insight in it too.

by jamesrl

To a certain extent its the old "What is Bill Gates worth" question.

Because If he decides to sell a certain amount of his stock, the price will plummet.

Similarly Japan (bought lots of US Real Estate), China (US gov't bonds) and the oil barons of the Middle East may not like the policies of one US admin or another, but they all have very large holdings in the US economy, and If they tried to liquidate even 10% of their holdings at once, the value of the rest would drop like a stone.

As for Hitler, if you read Mein Kampf and listen to his early speeches, Britain was never the target. Russia was, and Poland was a stepping stone to get there. Hitler constantly referred to the need for more land for the German people. Many accounts suggest that he was gambling in 1939 in attacking Poland, betting that France and Britain would fold again. After all it worked in Czecheslovakia. He never had a workable plan to conquer Britain, but the Battle of France knocked France and Britain out long enough to concentrate on the longer term objective of defeating Russia. He knew Stalin was weak, after killing off many of his officers. He knew Stalin was thinking the truce between them would hold for another year or more.

Hitler coveted the Russian/Romanian oil fields for his war machine. It wasn't as easy to get as Middle eastern oil from an economic exploitation standpoint, but Hitler knew he wasn't going to take over the Middle East.

As for modern middle east, I've watch OPEC work their pricing magic. When the price gets too high and people start buynig smaller cars or looking harder at alternatives, OPEC allows more oil to be produced and the price lowers, and people start buying big trucks again. They need customers.

by oz_media

I have read Mein Kampf, more than once over the years.

Hi focus was to get Russian oil, to ease his campaign to take over the world completely. His temporary truce with Stalin was in place so he relaxed and decided to conquer Western Europe. Having taken Britain, he would have ruled the Atlantic, as it was Americans were having many transports destroyed by U-Boats off the US coast in the Altlantc.

With Japan working to hold the Pacific and eventually cut off Australia (a massive point of potential attacks by British Navy vessels) and the axis foothold in Africa, the Axis Armies would have wiped out the British commonwealth and been all but unstoppable. With US resources, UK navy, Australiacut off and Western Europe conquered, Russia would have no choice but to lay down and give up its resources to the Axis powers.

Really it was a feasible master plan. By the time his syphilis got to the point of causing mental issues, he had started recalling his armies who were moving toward the Southern Russian borders, where oil was stored and produced. Despite their protests, he sent the few remaining officers, who would still follow him, on a frontal attack toward Stalingrad, which was where he met his end.

His megalomania that began as his strength became his weakness and ultimately his end, which was further fueled by madness set in by his advanced syphilis.

by maxwell edison

I don't want to debate or discuss oil - unless you (or anyone) can tie the US's financial woes to its consumption of oil. Otherwise, I'd rather not go there. If it is a factor, it's very small.

Our government spends more than it takes in, and it's been doing it at alarming rates for several decades. And the future, as it seems to be unfolding, will be more of the same, but only more of it.

I really can't see how anything oil-related has anything to do with that.

by charliespencer

You asked what was the connection between oil consumption and federal spending - military defense of the source. There it is. I'm not making claims as to the size in comparison to other expenditures, or in terms of value for the money spent, just that the expenditures are there.

by ansugisalas

like that of any corporate direction, is to manage the resources bestowed upon it for optimum returns. If a corporation allows its employees to lapse into unproductiveness for preventable reasons, then it's not doing its job well. If it doesn't have a policy for dealing with employees in danger of falling into alcoholism, that's poor leadership. If it doesn't care to deal with poor indoor air quality causing excess sick days, that's poor leadership.
And no, if enough people are out of work at the same time, not everyone can find new work, the tricks you have used won't work for everybody, in fact, each "emergency niche" can sustain only so many people.
So, if government does nothing, that's piss-poor government.
Maybe if you'd have taken the benefits you've already paid for in advance you'd have had the time to find a job that lets you pay more taxes and thus assist your nation in averting bankruptcy?
Not that I'm pointing a finger at you, but I remember you pointing fingers at others in the past. The government would prefer its subjects to be productive, and it pays social benefits for those same reasons.
It's simply a tried-and-true way to improve the economy.
But if you could, I'd be very interested in seeing what the US government spending is made of.

by maxwell edison

[i]You asked what was the connection between oil consumption and federal spending - military defense of the source. There it is. I'm not making claims as to the size in comparison to other expenditures, or in terms of value for the money spent, just that the expenditures are there.[/i]

And what would happen if the U.S. military didn't defend the free flow of oil - the life blood of not only the U.S. economy, but the world's economy? Maybe the French would do it. Or the Brits. Or maybe the Russians?

Why do people treat [i]oil[/i] as a four-letter word? All the people who speak out against it as something evil, depend on it themselves!

Besides, I doubt very much the G-Man was referring to the military use and/or defense of the flow of oil. He just saw an opportunity to paint Americans as [i]greedy[/i].

by maxwell edison

It's so silly debating the issue, what's the [i]job[/i] of government - or the role of government - especially between people from different countries. The [i]job[/i] of government - the role of government - is different in different countries.

Moreover, I don't presume to tell people of Finland what the role of the Finnish government is. Why is it, then, that a person from Finland presumes to tell an American what the role of the American government is? (Fill in any other country as a substitute.)

Besides, it shouldn't be debated as much as it is, even among Americans, because.....

The [i]job[/i] of the U.S. government - its role regarding the lives of United States citizens - is not a matter of opinion. It's spelled out quite clearly in our constitution. That's its role; no more, no less. Why is that so hard for people to either understand or accept?

by maxwell edison

That was funny. I laughed. Touche'

P.S. But I really do see a lot of people as afraid to face life's challanges without the guarantee of a government bail-out! And politicians prey upon that fear.

by charliespencer

"And what would happen if the U.S. military didn't defend the free flow of oil ... Why do people treat oil as a four-letter word?"

As I already said and as you already quoted, "I'm not making claims ... in terms of value for the money spent..." Again, I'm just pointing out where the connection is, in response to your original query, "Our trade deficit is related to oil, to be sure, but federal spending?" Federal money is used to pay for military operations in the Middle East that are primarily conducted to sustain the flow of oil. (It's also used to subsidize arms deals to questionably friendly countries for the same reason, now that I think about it. One could make a case it is a factor in our support of Israel.)

I assume you're addressing your 'What' and 'Why' questions to someone else, despite their being in your reply to me. Seek value judgments on this topic elsewhere; I'm not making any today. As to G-Man, I won't speculate on his motivations.